Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E216 Machinima News Omnibus (Mar 2026)
Transcript
- Damien Valentine 01:12 hello, and now for something completely machinima. I'm Damian Valentine, and this week we're going to be discussing the news, and I'm joined by my co hosts, Tracy Harwood and Phil rice. Hey, there. Ricky has gone. He is building himself a robot. And don't know what inspired him to make that, but we look forward, or maybe dread, seeing the results of what he comes up with Phil Rice 01:38 out of broken doll parts from one, Tracy Harwood 01:40 yeah, that looks horrific, I have to say, yeah. Damien Valentine 01:43 And we are not joking. That's what he showed us. Yeah, right. So we are here to discuss some news about machinima and the world of machinery and animation and technology. So I do not have a whole lot of stuff. So I'll start with mine, because I have one item to talk about, and I get over with very quickly. The day we're recording this, it's off. Who were famous for Doom and Quake and so many other games are celebrating their 35th anniversary, and obviously that had a huge influence on the world of machinery with Doom and Quake, and I thought it's worth mentioning, because, you know, they're a big part of the machinery community, and why we're all here. Tracy Harwood 02:27 Yeah, happy birthday. Yeah. Damien Valentine 02:30 I feel like I should have got some cake, but I only found out about it just before we started recording. Yes, I'll see why I find something chocolaty after we've done to celebrate with All right, so Tracy, how would you like to go first? Sure? Tracy Harwood 02:47 Well, I've only really got one thing that I wanted to touch on, and I'm guessing you're going to jump in with some comments as I talk about this, really, and that's to do with the recent Disney and open AI partnership whereby Disney has licensed its content of characters to open AI. I think it's kind of a really interesting development. They claim the partnership is structured to protect creators and avoid unauthorized training on IP. But it would be fair to say that the deal has drawn a lot of apprehension across creative sectors because it highlights broader anxieties about how AI might reshape creative work, rights, compensation and also control in entertainment. I think one of the biggest copyright controversies in AI today is whether large AI models may lawfully use copyrighted works without permission to train their systems. I think critics are arguing that many models were trained on copyrighted data scraped from the internet without licenses, and the companies themselves are often claiming fair use as a defense. Legal scholars, of course, and the courts haven't yet resolved the key questions about what constitutes infringement versus permissible training, which is, as I said, it's kind of a major unresolved area of copyright law, which is pretty much a global phenomenon at the moment, instead of fighting in a court or hoping for a favorable judicial ruling about fair use, however, Disney has chosen to license its intellectual property. These are some 200 odd characters, which includes things like Mickey Mouse, Yoda and whatnot, directly to open AI for its use in the Sora AI platform. And it's significant legally because it sidesteps some of the thornier questions about whether AI companies can use copyrighted. Works without permission for training or generation. It also creates a commercially negotiated licensing model where a rights holder is paid and consents up front, rather than trademarks and characters being generated without authorization. And some of the commentators see this as a model that could encourage other rights holders to seek licensing deals with AI platforms rather rather than fight lawsuits. In other words, Disney's approach moves that debate on, because Disney, the Disney deal, only licenses content with clear legal rights. So it reflects skepticism among rights holders that Fair Use alone can or should resolve these conflicts. So that's that's a big deal. I think timing matters here, and that's because creators and unions want clearer compensation mechanisms for the use of the the their works in AI beyond just fair use defense, if you like, the Disney nil highlights a path where creators and rights holders can negotiate value rather than relying on these kind of ambiguous kind of legal doctrines. The deal, I think, will serve to shape industry norms on how these AI systems should respect and pay for IP, and I think this has important ramifications for machinima and game based fan creators as well. One could argue, for example, that it doesn't directly target machinima creators, but what it does do is signal how big IP owners are thinking about control licensing and derivative creativity in an AI era, and that's the bit that has ripple potential. Fan works, it's fair to say, are mostly still legal, but only by tolerance, not by right. Most machinima and fan fiction exists in this kind of gray zone. They are technically derivative works under copyright law. They survive because publishers tolerate them or even encourage them, and very few are explicitly licensed, unless you're in some kind of creator program. And what this Disney deal does is reinforces a key idea rights holders believe their IP has licensing value, even when used creatively or transformatively. That doesn't automatically make fan works illegal, but it strengthens owners confidence that permission matters so human made Machinima is still a better proposition than AI generated content. I think courts and copyright law tend to treat human creative of creativity far more favorably than machine generated works. And for machinima creators, you know, you got to remember you're choosing the shots, you're writing the dialog you're editing the scenes. That bit about human authorship matters legally and culturally. It makes a strong case for transformative use, certainly stronger than AI generated outputs. So I think ironically, as AI faces more scrutiny, handcrafted machinima may look look actually more defensible, ironically, not less defensible, but it's the commercialization of it where I think the risk increases. Non commercial, fan films, YouTube, machinima, I think is likely to have quite low, well, low to moderate risk, say, but anything that's monetized, we're going to sneeze anything that's monetized, anything that's anyone that's sort of standing selling a standalone work, using game IP or using game characters to train AI models for their own purposes. I think that's where you're going to be at high risk from being pursued. I think the Disney open AI ideals suggests IP holders are going to be especially sensitive when their assets are used as tools, not just for inspiration. So if your machinima competes with official content, uses any kind of premium characters heavily, or is branded in any kind of confusing way, that's when you're going to start to draw more attention. On top of that, the platform rules will begin to matter much more than they have in the past. As we've said many times, now there is a quiet but important shift towards platform enforcement, where, for example, YouTube, Tiktok, Steam Workshop are all all basically tightening their policies. Some of that will come from Game Studios pressuring platforms without suing. Creators and others are likely to be panicked by AI, which is clearly accelerating the Better safe than sorry moderation strategies that we're going to be seeing take even greater. Effect that means machinima creators might feel constraints before laws actually change. It could mean that studios will push license fan creativity models through official creator programs even more than they have in the past. It could make things like, for example, revenue sharing more explicit by saying, for example, you can do this, but you can't do that. So those kind of rules are going to be more evident, I suspect, and more tools could be provided by the IP owners, which you know that all might be a plus, but for example, I suspect the bad news will be that there's going to be less freedom for creators outside of those kind of boxes. I think what machina majors should realistically do now is basically emphasize originality, and that's in their story, in their commentary, that kind of thing, they should certainly be adding very clear disclaimers not official fan work. For example, unofficial fan work, rather than, you know, making claims about this is using content from X game. I think they've got to diversify away from IP, or certainly one IP, and keep backups and mirrors of the work as well, to avoid training AI models on copyrighted game assets. Definitely try and do not not do that. They certainly should think about how they're selling standalone works built entirely on somebody else's IP. Using characters in ways that damage brand reputation is definitely going to trigger takes down take downs the fastest. But obviously this, this Disney open, a ideal, isn't it about fan creators. I think, though it does signal a world where IP owners are going to want more control as the technologies begin to scale creativity. Yeah, so I think, you know, it'd be fair to say Disney, and it's in its approach, has always been more alert, more strategic. It's always been less tolerant of edge case rights, which is going to mean that, you know, ambiguity and content created where there is a recognizable asset, similar to a Disney one, is much less safe than it was, say, 1015, years ago. I think safer inspiration is going to be things like emotional tone, broad fairy tale structure, archetypes and whatnot, moral worldviews, those are things that you can kind of draw inspiration from Disney assets. Tracy Harwood 12:49 You know, draw the inspiration from, but riskier ones are definitely going to be anything that looks or sounds or feels like a Disney character or parallels some kind of known arc in the story. I mean, you know, we all know that Disney characters are really highly distinctive. I think framing that work is also going to become ever more important. Using phrases like Disney style is going to become tricky. Anything with a hashtag on it is going to become quite tricky. I think, you know, all of that's going to be much more difficult to do in the future with this, with the, you know, with the ripple effect from this kind of deal. I think the more your project looks like a product, the less inspiration you can say could be taken from Disney as an argument that basically will protect you from the, you know, the the sense of it being laundered in some way. But basically, the advice from, from my analysis, is you need more distance, more originality and more intentional framing than than ever you have in the in the past. Yeah, so that's my my thoughts on that. I dare say you both got comments. I think this is a particularly important one to have a look at. Damien Valentine 14:03 Though, yeah, I've been since this was announced, I've spent some time thinking about it, this, this. So basically, the idea of this deal is Disney are going to be allowing fans to create AI generated videos with the Sora, and those videos will go on to Disney plus the Disney streaming channels. So we need to explain how that actually works, like that's that's where the these videos are going to go, is onto Disney plus. So it's controlled distribution, right? It will last a year, and that's the main reason for that is, I Disney obviously owns Star Wars and they own Marvel both are franchises that have really struggled recently with the official productions, and this year for both of them is really big for them, because they're trying to relaunch both franchises to try and. Really get that hype and interest that has wavered in the last few years because fans haven't been satisfied with the official releases. So we've got the Mandalorian grogu movie coming in May, and even though that's meant to be a big thing, there's not really been much to advertise it, which as we call this. This is four months away, and we've had a teaser trailer that shows a random selection of footage and not much else. You'd think there'd be more to that by now. And then with Marvel, you've got a Spider Man film. I don't know the exact date, but sometime in the summer with Tom Holland. And then the big one in December is the Avengers Doomsday, and they're bringing back so many of the old Avengers cast who we thought had moved on, because the actors contract has expired and they were interested. So obviously they spent a fortune on this movie, and they've even brought back characters like Professor X and Magneto, played by Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen. So they're really trying to make this movie The big thing to revive Marvel. And the reason this AI thing isn't going to work, because all it will take is a fan to create something that is better received than these big budget productions. And that is probably going to happen. Some fans is going to create a maybe they'll take a moment from on the comic, famous Marvel comic, where we create that using the actors who played the characters in the AI, because the AI will have those images, so they'll be able to do that. And when the Avengers film comes out, and I don't know if it's going to be a good film or not, I haven't seen it. I don't know anything about it. It may be fantastic, or maybe it will be a mess, because they've, one of the things that people have criticized it so far is they've got 27 major superheroes in it. That's a lot of characters to give a lot to in a two hour movie, or two and a half hour movie. So it's, I don't know if it's going to be or not, but I feel like that's too much. So it's going to be weak, because you're trying to get through so much, and it's not going to flow too well. That's my personal opinion of it. I hope I'm wrong. If it's a really good film, but some fan is going to create some kind of Marvel video, and it will be better received than the official one, and that's when Disney will pull the plug on this, because, yes, they won't want to be spending millions. And then some fans to come along and make something, oh, we want that. And the fan did it for freeze and the Disney plus thing. And it'd be the same with Star Wars. Someone's going to make a Star Wars AI video, because they'll have all the characters available to them. They can make a better someone's going to make a video released on Disney, plus that's, again, probably going to be better received than the Mandarin Greg or any of the other Star Wars productions that get released this year. And it's kind of inevitable that will happen. So how good those two films I talked about, the official ones, some fan is going to make something that's going to be better received than both of them, and that's when Disney's saying, Tracy Harwood 18:11 No. So you think this deal's not going to last too long, then Damien Valentine 18:15 I think Disney will. The deal will have been placed. But what happened is Disney will just say, well, we're not going to let fans have access to this anymore, so they'll just pull the plug, and then they'll probably have to pay up to open AI, some kind of penalty for pulling the contract. But Disney's eyes are probably think that is worth paying, because it's fans are making something to their own AI platform that's better received than they spent millions on that's bad for Disney's image. So they will. My understanding is Disney's image is actually more important to them than profit, which profit is obviously very important to them, but their image is even more important to them. So anything that damages that, they will immediately shut it down. Like some of the films that have been released. They're not hugely successful. You'll never hear from them again. They're not available to watch. You can't buy them. You can't stream them that you won't find any official merchandise. It'll all just be taken off the shelves, even if it's just thrown in a landfill somewhere. They will make that disappear, and that's the same thing will happen with this. Phil Rice 19:23 So they're, they're, they're moved to, it's, it's almost like they're trying to productize the output of the AI that uses their material. By, I assume that when you say it's going to be on Disney, plus, it'll be that that's the only place it's legally shown, right? Damien Valentine 19:40 Yeah, so I imagine someone could download it off Disney plus and OH, they Phil Rice 19:45 will, yeah, but, but they have ways of. They have ways, yeah, yeah, yeah, Damien Valentine 19:54 but, yeah, whatever content is created, I think this, they'll have some kind of software, or Apple, what? Ever, and it will automatically put that onto Disney. Plus they'll play via an AI channel that you can click on, and it'll Yeah, so you start. Phil Rice 20:08 It's a strange move, because, like, I don't know, it feels more like just a meaningless flourish to do that than an actual I say the word productize, but like, what monetary value does that really have for them? Nobody's gonna know. I can't foresee that somebody's gonna subscribe to Disney plus, just so they can watch an AI creation on there, right? No existing subscribers, but Tracy Harwood 20:37 licensing the characters, isn't it? It's not, it's not what the content creators do with it. It's how they are making money out of the licensing process. Damien Valentine 20:47 Well, yeah, there's a big thing about all the streaming, all the streaming TV shows, all the streams, shows and movies cost a fortune to make, and that bubbles kind of burst a bit, because it launched when covid started, like Netflix and Disney plus re took off then because people were at home and they had nothing to do. So streaming became a huge thing. And obviously when that passed and people went back to work and to school and cost of living hit cancelation. Subscriptions were canceled because people had other things to spend their money on, and belts had to be tightened and stuff like that. So streaming has gone down, which means they were throwing a fortune at creating all these big budget things that people aren't watching, so the return on investment just isn't there. So I think, well, they were somewhere at Disney was thinking, Well, if we let fans make stuff that's instant content, it doesn't cost us anything. Phil Rice 21:39 But I don't think the deal is vulnerable from another direction, too, and that is, you figure on the Sora side of things, they're going to be looking at. How can we justify this expense? Are we getting additional subscribers to chat GPT slash Sora because of this deal? And if they can't quantify that and see that people are signing up for Sora so they can make Disney AI stuff, then it's not worth it for them either, you know? So I yeah, I think the deal is pretty fragile. It's quite a gamble, you know? I guess we'll, we'll have to wait and see how it it turns out, a lot of the other ramifications, you know, taking caution with, you know, kind of banking your creative direction on someone else's IP it feels kind of like that. That's, it's old news, kind of, you know, I mean, I guess if there's a sense that they're going to crack down more now than they already have then, yeah, but yeah, it's, it's, it's an interesting experiment that they're doing. I don't, I don't, I don't quite see the math to it, how it can possibly a billion dollar deal. I mean, good grief, that's a lot of, that's a lot of hooch to shell out or for an industry that really the No, the only people making money on AI are the AI companies. And I guess that's really what this is, is that Disney says you're going to give us a slice and as and as a result, we're not going to make your life more difficult. You know, by suing you, that's really what this is. It's a settlement, yeah, to not go after them for what they've already done, because they've already gone and scooped all this stuff up and so Sora looks at it as well to to try and purge all that from our training, or to retrain, God forbid, and set ourselves back. That's worth a billion dollars. Well, nobody, but I don't see how anybody's going to be actually making money from this deal. This is really a legal settlement just packaged as as some kind of agreement. Damien Valentine 23:58 But well, even if they did say, I don't know how these the data sets work, but even if they could go and say, delete all the Disney stuff, the box to go out, scrape it, just going to do it again. They're just going to find the material and they'll do it again. Phil Rice 24:13 So yeah, because their method of acquiring training food is consume everything, right? It's the Internet. The Internet is open by default and yeah, so Damien Valentine 24:27 even if they say don't go to don't scrape anything off Disney plus, well, there's pirate sites that's gonna the bots are gonna download stuff from that. There's the official stuff from there as well. So you can't really avoid Phil Rice 24:41 it, and it's not as easy to I don't think that presently, it's as easy to detect use of visual information in the same way that it is to detect audio audio. They can now detect stuff down to like the level of a sample. You have even just a small sample. Of commercial audio in your audio, and they'll they'll find it. But I think visual is harder. Damien Valentine 25:09 I had that with a one of my videos, I used a sound effect. I think it's wind or something like that. I can't remember. It was just the sound effect. Some musician used the same sound effect in his song, and YouTube picked that up and issued me a thing saying, using the copyrighted material from this song, but it wasn't, it's just the same sound effects Phil Rice 25:31 because, yeah, it's even more sophisticated than that now too. Is because I did, I did a video a year or two ago, a little over a year ago, I guess, and in it I sang a cover tune of King of King of Pain by the police. It's completely fresh recording. There's no audio from their song in it at all. I basically performed it and then sang it with different lyrics, kind of like a weird owl type of approach, right? And YouTube didn't have a problem with it for some reason. But when I tried to upload that to Tiktok, it caught it right away and dinged me for the copyright, it detected a cover tune because it was similar enough. So it's way more sophisticated than just listening for or digitally comparing it's it can actually detect song structure. So audio has come a long way in that regard. Video, I would think, is much more challenging to know whether or not Woody from Toy Story is, is in a video. That's, that's a nuance, that's, that's tough, but I think they'll get there eventually. So do I then, then that's when enforcement can really clamp down. Right now, they don't have any additional enforcement mechanisms. They can. They can declare, hey, this is no longer but they're in the same boat that they are right now, which is, it's just, it's, there's no, there's no way to police it yet. But I don't think that that should lull anyone into a sense of safety with dabbling with this commercial IP, because, believe me, they're working on that. They're working on being able to detect it, and as soon as they can, they will, if it just come, if it's something friendly, like YouTube's revenue sharing option that most music has, if you use commercial audio, then if the if the record company has made the appropriate deal as part of that deal with YouTube's system, then they'll allow you to use it without a copyright strike. But you share, you share revenue, you know, well, the thing that's, that's what happened on YouTube with that cover song I was talking about. It's a revenue share thing, but they allowed me to use it. Damien Valentine 27:54 So with, yeah, with my thing, with the sound effects, I disputed it. Say, well, it's just because the I found the song and listened to it, I see what this happened here. I just beat it, and then YouTube said, Oh, it's fine. We'll just delete that and don't worry about it. Phil Rice 28:07 Oh, that's cool, yeah, because there are false positives for sure. Damien Valentine 28:11 Yeah, yeah. And it's just because the same sound effect it was, I hadn't lifted it off their song or anything. I never even heard of them before. But yeah, so anyway, go back to this Disney thing, yeah, as a service, it won't be available for more than about a year. I think once they see the impact of someone making a film that's better received, Phil Rice 28:34 yeah, I think both sides will have reason to to object to it. Yeah, it's a costly deal. Damien Valentine 28:42 Personally, I would not like when the AI menu comes up on the Disney plus when they launch it, I'm not going to click on it, because I don't want to watch that. I want to watch the official stuff. And I've noticed a lot of fan reactions to things now is a massive rejection of AI content Phil Rice 29:01 we talked about this months ago on the show we discussed it that this, this wave of revulsion was going to come. And some of it is because, I think that the instance that we discussed was there's going to be instances where you see something and you think it's real, and then you find out it's not. People don't like that. People do not like that. And and that will create this pushback, and it's happening, particularly among people a lot younger than us. The sentiment is very strong. There was a video game that swept one of the Game Awards in the past few months. Yeah. Claire Claire obscura expedition, 33 I think, is the full title of the game. It's a beautiful game. It's an amazing story. Like, it's, it's, it sounds really impressive. And word got out that in their. Pre production, they used some generative AI to research and kind of idea eight, if that's the word, word of that got out, and the guy didn't deny it, the CEO didn't deny it, and they ended up pulling awards from the game. One of the images, backlash, Damien Valentine 30:20 yeah, one of the images made it through release by mistake, like a background image or a loading screen or something like that, something Phil Rice 30:26 very inert, yes, yeah. And the reaction in the amongst indie game developers in particular, it is like it. There's hostility toward it. There's another interesting development there, too. Sorry, Damien. Go ahead, Damien Valentine 30:43 well, I was gonna say there's a Star Trek game coming out in a few weeks that's based on Voyager, and the idea is you're the captain and you have to get the ship home, and you're managing the crew and basically reliving the series, but making your own choices about how it events. So you can go in completely different directions. So people ask, Are you going to get the original cast from the show to voice the characters? And they said that no, because we've got so much text in the game that it would cost an absolute fortune, because we're a small indie studio, they can't afford to bring all those people back. And so they said, Would you like us to use AI for that? And the massive reaction was, No, we'd rather read than listen to synthetic voices, and which the Earth said, we're really glad you said that, because we didn't actually want to use AI, but we thought we better ask, because we know that the fans of the show is expected, Phil Rice 31:41 good that there's, that's good because there's a conversation, you know, yeah, it is good. That's, that's what this is ultimately going to be. I think for developers, is a negotiation with with the fan base, and if they're open about it like that, I think that will yield a better outcome than than trying to hide it, or, in Claire obscures case. It what? It's a small team of indie developers, and they were very open about it, and still they got dinged. Now the game's going to do fine, because it's, the reviews are just ridiculously Damien Valentine 32:12 good. It's that's been out for about a year now. Phil Rice 32:15 So yeah, it's, it's, and it's a beautiful, beautiful game, and a amazing story, really unconventional story for a video game, Tracy, you'd be interested to read up on it. Maybe you'll find a will, yeah, find a video that just talks about what the game is actually about. It's extraordinary. I need to play extraordinary. Yeah, I It's on my wish list. Yeah, another interesting development related to AI and legality and and fan reaction is Darren Aronofsky, who's a well known director, is getting ready to release, I can't remember which, if it's on one of the streaming platforms or maybe One of the television networks, but it's a limited series on the events of the American Revolution. 17 has 1776 in the title, but I remember what the actual title is, and it is. It's it uses screen actors, guild voice actors, like legitimate, real voice actors. But all of the video is generative, AI, and it's an official production. And I mean, Twitter is not Twitter slash x is not really the best representation of the world's view, but amongst the maybe more technically savvy or plugged into that world, it is. A lot of artists are on there, and the reaction is just savage. Just, you know, the first post that I saw mentioning it, the person who was reposting it says, I hope this destroys his career. Oh, just wishing all kinds of of evil on him. Now, people have varied opinions on Aronofsky, and whether, you know, there's people who think he's a hack, and there's people who think he's a genius, but these are people who apparently liked him and are saying, This is disgusting. I can't believe you would do this. And so, yeah, it's, it's a, it's a, really, there's a lot of turmoil, Tracy Harwood 34:26 very supportive of the development of the tool for runway. And he's been on the, you know, he's been one of their judges on there. So it shouldn't have surprised people. But apparently, not at all. It shouldn't have been a surprise that he'd been experimenting. Phil Rice 34:42 I saw the trailer for the the show it, it looks like generative AI, you know it's Yeah, talking, shot of person talking. Wide Shot, Shot of person talking it. There's nothing groundbreaking about it at all. It's. Up that he, he did a Sims two edit on it. You know, he cut out the goopy stuff. But it's, it's just, it's not anything more impressive than what we've seen regular old schlubs like us do with generative AI. It's, it's still just what it is. So I don't know how well it will do. Damien Valentine 35:20 I can tell from the way you described that you're so excited to watch it, you're not really selling it. Phil Rice 35:26 Phil, I'm not. I've kind of decided that for myself, because I've used some generative AI and stuff here and there. I'm sure there's people out there right now saying, I hope it ruins your career. Good luck. Good luck with that. Because what career, right? But I've kind of decided that that as I kind of ride the fence on this thing and try to see both sides of it, that for me, the only useful purpose of generative AI is is deeply is satire on the topic like that's where I just feel at home with it. So I like it when it's weird. I like it when it's broken. I'm not interested in it being something to be mistaken for realism. I want it when it's just stupid. I think it's hilarious, so, and not to the point of where it's, you know, there's slop where it's like, you know, making some overweight girl fall off a cliff when she's bungee jumping or something. There's all kinds of just horrific uses to it, you know, fake skateboarding accidents that are just like something out of GTA just horrible. I'm not interested in that, but it just in the silly side of it, I guess. And once it's not silly anymore, I'm I will lose interest, because, to me, it's just, it's, it's, it's got comic value, maybe in certain, certain cases. So, but Damien Valentine 36:54 when you want to see something with a good story, you want it to be handcrafted by real Of Phil Rice 36:58 course, yeah, no. I want, yeah. I want something with a good story. That's really all you have to say. And generative, AI, is not really part of the picture, you know, in terms of generating the story, yeah, you know, there's obviously people who are great storytellers who happen to use that as a presentation method, and that's great, you know, what's, what's the name neural this, yeah, and again, it's weird, but he's leaning into the weird. It's his stories are weird, so it's perfect. His dialog is weird, yeah, yeah. All right, well, let's, let's talk about a few other things here. There is a tool that I stumbled upon. It's currently in, in its beta, I believe so. Like it's it's not fully released yet, but this company has has released some other tools in the same vein. It's called portrait studio pro. The company's name is Hale 3d, I think, H, E, A, E, L, E, and their specialty in their tools seems to be tools that are designed for generating good reference images for artists who draw. And so they've got one that focuses on on hands, and basically it's a it's a character poser, so to speak, but one that that looks very versatile and reminds me a lot of I clones posing tools. And this this portrait studio, one, when it's fully released, will have a fully rigged body character that you can pose the skeletal thing. And its primary use is for creating these poses to have a reference image for drawing. But the detail that caught my attention was that the when this tool is out of demo mode and is full it's going to have an FBX Export option with the rigging, with the poses. So my mind immediately went to, okay, so I clone has some very interesting pose to pose animation tools that you can do. And sometimes that's the best way to to get a particular animation, is just to have these key framed poses, and then you can change the transition curves between them and create some interesting animations. So I thought, well, that's got to keep an eye on. And I tried the demo. The demo is very crippled, like there's only a couple model, models and a couple fixed poses that you can do. But the demo, the video, shows off some of the features that will be in the full one. And when talking about it, they talk about that there is an export option planned. So I thought, well, let's keep an eye on that, because that could be an interesting for me, not as a standalone tool that doesn't have any value, but as a as an alternative way. To maybe get some poses into iClone. It looks like it might be, in some ways, easier to use than sometimes it is in iClone, when you're when you're using the motion edit tool to do stuff. So I'm going to, I'm going to keep an eye on it, and we'll keep you posted on that. I took some screenshots while I were in there, because it has a pretty decent, halfway decent, lighting engine in there, and nothing. I mean, it's, it's nothing more impressive than you could get out of iClone itself, but I'm sure it will be a less expensive tool, much less expensive tool than I clone when it's out. So it's fun to keep an eye. Damien Valentine 40:38 On a similar note, it's not going to have any of the 3d sides of it, but if any artists who are interested in a tool like that, just for drawing the practice, a friend of mine has a website called line of action, which I just put in our show notes, and basically is photos of people and animals and shapes and in different poses. Some some of the faces, some are full bodies, some are just hands and so on. The whole site is designed to help people practice their drawing, so I thought I'd just share that as well. It the site is complete. I'm sure more pictures get added all the time, but you're never going to have that three it's not a 3d model thing where you can post a character or anything like that. It's just just for artists to draw from. So from. But you know, I thought I mentioned it because anyone listening, you might find that interesting. Phil Rice 41:27 So, yeah, very cool. So there are other ways of getting motion into these, these environments that we like to use to create stuff. And the one that we've talked about many times is video mocap. Obviously, there's the motion the full motion capture suit and tools like that, which are most likely in most scenarios going to give you the best results, certainly the most accurate result. But video mocap is an interesting innovation that lowers the barrier for entry to that, because the suits are quite, quite costly, yeah, so quite tricky, and they take some some skill to learn how to use them as well. But, I mean, the cost is substantial, and I don't see that changing in the future. I mean, it's, a very sophisticated piece of equipment. It's not going to suddenly, no one's going to suddenly just come up with some cheap way to that. Because, you know, it's a physical thing. It's very sophisticated. Damien Valentine 42:32 So you're talking about now are the cheap ones? Are the cheap ones compared to hundreds of 1000s? Right? Phil Rice 42:40 Right? Well, video, mocap is an interesting way to to get motions in in another way as well. Most of those are not free, but they're certainly more affordable than hiring out a motion capture studio. There are several of those around the world. Those can be quite expensive. Last time I looked at it, I think it was around $2,000 a day for a full day's work. And you could, you can basically James Martin, I think, is, is involved with, with something like that. He's one of the early innovators related to iClone. But those are, again, that's, that's, that's an expense that maybe makes sense for a funded production studio, but for indie creators, you know that's out of reach, Damien Valentine 43:34 it'll be better off. You'd be better off buying your suit, because that's two days worth, and then you can as much as you like. Phil Rice 43:40 That's right. That's right. So in the area of video mocap, I found a video by a guy I watch pretty much everything that that he produces. He just goes by the name of freedom. I think he's I think he hails from the Philippines. I'm not certain that I've got that right. But he's somewhere out in the Far East, and his whole channel is just tutorials all centered around the ecosystem of iClone and sometimes blender and all of those things. They tend to be very practical in nature. He goes pretty quick sometimes, but that's what the pause button is for. And the accent might take a little of training of your ear to get, but once you get it, he's, I mean, he's very well spoken, very, very clear communicator, and really knows his way around the software. I don't know how he makes a living. He's doing enough of these videos to where this is a full time thing for him. I don't know if he's just making the money off of the YouTube revenue or what, but either that or he's just extremely generous. But I watch almost all his videos because inevitably, there's something. A little tip or trick or something that I pick up. Well, he put one out that was pretty interesting, where he basically was using the the video mocap feature that's built into I clone that we've talked about in a previous episode, and he used it to video mocap motion from a video capture of a video game. And I think the example that he uses is one of the combat video games where it's, you know, two fighters posed side by side. And he basically shows the whole process, if he snips out this footage and then runs it through the iClone thing, and it captures the animation. So it was just a very interesting, almost a meta mo cap moment where he didn't even have to perform the motion himself on camera. He actually was able to capture just the raw motion of a character that someone else had had mocap animated. So it was pretty fascinating. So we'll include a link to that in that video in the shorts, but I recommend his channel if you're in this space and just want to want to watch stuff that kind of triggers ideas of new ways to get things done. He's a good resource for that. I've tried that plug in. Have you tried it? I tried it a little bit. Damien Valentine 46:19 Yeah, I found that you need a lot of space because, but you need more space for the camera actually, because, yeah, as soon as your foot goes off frame, it breaks very bad, yeah. So the most successful one that I did was to have a character. So the scene I'm going to describe is not what I actually did. The character is running across the top of building, jumps off it and lands on top of someone else, knocks them down, grabs them, punches them, and pulls a gun to shoot at them. Phil Rice 46:55 So sort of simple, right? Damien Valentine 47:00 I tried various things. That's the one that came out best. Yeah, I was trying to, like conversation things. But what's happening is, because, like, my arm goes behind my body. It'll just track of it. It gets it gets weird. But because I was moving constantly, it was able to figure out what was happening. So I played both characters, the one that he falls down that broke quite a bit. My solution is that was act out the scene against the wall rather than on the floor, and then just rotate the character 90 degrees. And that made all the difference. And it wasn't because part of my body wasn't well, I guess because I was on the floor. Part of it my like, my arm, would be obscured by my body and things like that. But even though the same thing gets the wall, I guess, maybe at a slightly better angle or something, but that worked. What I actually did, instead of jumping off the roof of a building, I jumped off a footstool and then just made it look like it was a bigger jump than it really was. It came out really well. But again, space is an issue. I could do the same thing in motion capture suit in the same space and not have to worry about being in frame. I did try and do like the Golem crawling along the floor, and that didn't work, because, again, one of my arms and legs is always going to be obscured by my body when I'm in that kind of post. It didn't work for that. And of course, I don't have a lot of floor space, so being able to crawl around and stay in frame is extremely difficult. If I was wearing the suit, I can do that because it doesn't matter about any furniture that's in the way. So, yeah, there's that. But if you had a big space, like you could do outside, if the weather's nice, and hopefully you don't get if you're in a public space, you don't get too many strange looks when you're doing something like jumping off a building. Just mad? No, yeah, I can see the potential for it, and I quite liked it, but just be aware of its limitations, of what it can can and can't do, and you'll learn that as you're using it. Phil Rice 48:59 Well, fortunately, there is yet another method that is emerging for for creating threed motion that doesn't involve any suits or cameras. And that is something that really, this was inevitable, that it come, but it's, it's, it's now here and or at least is on the presses precipice of being here. And that is text to motion. Yes, it's a thing. It's an amazing thing. And basically this is cartwheel. Is the name of the company. And the feature, which I don't think has rolled out yet, but is, like on the verge, is called swing, and basically that that's one of the options that you'll find on their their website. And you can type in a text description of an animation, and then it will perform it. And you can export it, if you have the right plan, you can export it as FBX and bring it into. It to whatever your platform of choice is. There's a demonstration video of it, and it's quite amazing, quite amazing what, what can be done. So, because it's not available yet, I have not gotten to test it, but I will do so and and get back to here. But that's, that's an interesting thing, because, okay, so even if you've got a motion capture suit, or even if you've got a camera and the space to use it, if the motion that you want done isn't something that you're physically capable of, that's a that's yet another problem, right? Like jumping off a building right, or doing a backflip right, or just, you know, I'm thinking like, I have no idea how Ben Tuttle does the not so much in his Bond film, but in one of his previous films, there was some, there was some, Basically kung fu type stuff going on, if he's trained in that and does it himself, I'm impressed. Color me impressed. But doing stuff like that when you are not trained for that, or just don't have the physicality to be able to do that this, this could be an interesting avenue. Now, obviously, there's always you can go find existing motions. IClone has an incredibly large motion library, and you can actually purchase individual motion sequences for very reasonable price. And this is not you know, swing with cartwheel is not going to be free either. It's probably going to function on a credit system that we're familiar with with other forms of generative AI, because there's processing power involved to create this stuff. So there's a cost, but I think it could be, if used wisely, it could be a pretty reasonable cost. We'll see. So that's something to keep an eye on. So swing by cartwheel. That's one we'll be watching for. So I think the only other thing to mention today is there's is a new game that has been a long time in the making, but it is finally released. It's still in considered early access, but it's a mostly fully functional game. It's called hightail, h, y, t, a, l, e, this is a if you see any of the videos for this game, or if you you try it, you're going to say, Well, this looks quite a bit like Minecraft. That's not, not a coincidence. So the company behind the developers behind hightail are a group called Hypixel. And if you're at all involved with with Minecraft, you've probably heard that name, because Hypixel operates, I believe, the the most widely used and popular public server for playing Minecraft in multiplayer scenarios. They're huge, just millions and millions of participants, and they've been operating that for a decade, and are quite successful with it. Well, about, I want to say, maybe eight years ago, they announced that they're going to take some of the, you know, the profits from that, and start up a development team to make their own sandbox like game, but taking things in a little bit different direction, and maybe doing some things that they wish Minecraft would do, but doesn't seem like Minecraft is doing, and that's how the project was born. And it was when it was originally announced, it was talked about as something that, you know, yeah, we'll see in about about two or three years. We should have have something playable. Well, it's been a bit longer than that, yeah. And it kind of fell into, like the rumors that went around for the Duke Nukem Forever game, where it was kind of became a joke that is, this game is never going to be released, right? It finally did, but it was late, you know, so, and that seems to be the case here as well. And the the response publicly amongst fans of that type of game has been overwhelmingly positive, like it's even, I think, more than anyone expected. You would kind of expect that with that kind of delay, there's always a chance that people will just go, just forget it, and then even when you do arrive, they're like, who cares? But it's been very well embraced. A lot of big streamers have picked up on it, even as men gold, one of the biggest guys on Twitch right now, I believe, played it and loves it, and so it just, it's kind of exploded in this popularity. All that's interesting. If you're into a Minecraft type game, you, if you like Minecraft, you'll probably enjoy this game. It's, it's pretty. Radiographically, it's, it's a, I would describe it as a little more, a little bit more casual in the feeling of it, like it's not Minecraft can be pretty intense. If you're playing survival. There's, there's a lot out there to that can really easily kill you, you know, and and the consequences of getting killed are, like ferocious, you know, you lose all your inventory and you're taking somewhere, so they've kind of softened some of the edges on that for the gameplay, and it's a more relaxed experience. But the thing that's really interesting about it is that it has built in developer built in machinima tools actually called machinima tools, like they use the word it's a menu item in the creative mode of the game and a whole set of console commands for manipulating the environment. There are scriptable cameras and scriptable actors. It's all key, frameable, all within the game. And it's still in its very early stages, but I've played with it, and it is quite remarkable, like it is. I've never seen anything quite like it out of the box, and the fact that it's early access and they're still building that out, it's pretty incredible. And it's kind of it's kind of neat to see a developer that is from day one devoted to that it's not an add on. It's not okay. Now that the game is out, here's some tools have at it that developers have done that for years, and we're grateful for it, but this is part of the game, like it's part of the actual it's not an extra module that you launch. It's built right into the game. If you go buy hightail right now for I don't know there's various license levels, but I think the lowest is like $20 you've got it. You've got the full set. Now, again, it's not finished, so there's parts of it that don't quite work right yet. But we're talking about camera features that Hugh Hancock would have salivated over. It's not just linear key framed camera movements. You can adjust the spline, you can do Bezier curves of the camera. It's incredible, and it's all built into the game. So now you're never going to be able to make something that looks like Grand Theft Auto in this game, because, you know, the esthetic of the game is what it is. It's kind of cartoonish. The lighting is beautiful in the game. But, I mean, it's a sandbox game, it's it's a glorified Minecraft. So that's if there's a limitation to it, that's what it is. But it's pretty incredible, the fact that the the character models of all of the what are called mobs, all the creatures in the game, the NPCs, animals and humanoid they're all rigged. They're all posable, animatable on this keyframe timeline, the possibilities are just astounding. Oh, well, we look forward to that. Yeah, yeah, it's very interesting. So, yeah, that's, that's the news for for this month, brilliant. Damien Valentine 58:24 See, I gotta bet you one more thing. I was just thinking about it. This background behind me. You just got me thinking. You got me thinking about just now as you're talking about hightail, because I was going to share that story as well. But you, I haven't played it, so I don't know what it's like, but I did see that there were Michigan. Phil Rice 58:40 I've played it. I think, I think when, when I first, Tracy first posted, I said, Yeah, I've played about 12 hours. Yeah, I was quite surprised at that. I've played quite a bit more than that since then, not even, not even the Machinima stuff, just just enjoying the game. So because I haven't played Minecraft in years, and I love, I Tracy Harwood 58:57 think it had been released only about two seconds, Phil, when I put it up, that's Phil Rice 59:01 what you said, Yeah. I got, well, I was on their email newsletter, so I got notified right when it came up and got it yeah. Damien Valentine 59:08 So, so there's another platform that might be useful for missionary creators, because you only just got me thinking about it, because I like to record my animated backgrounds from games. And so I had to cyberpunk for quite a long time, and I thought it's about time I changed it. So game i got for christmas is called Surviving Mars, and the idea is you build a colony on Mars, and you can build it different domes buildings, and it's like Sim City, but in space, basically. And there's a photo mode in it, which is great. And this is how I did this. But as you were talking, I remembered that when you take photo, there's an option to unpause the game. So you've got the full camera control, little depth of fields, and you can make move it around everything. It's not as in depth as high tail one. You can move the camera around, but you have to do it manually. So you've got that manual control. You can't program it to do anything like that, but, you know, it's still a pretty powerful tool. And you can line up the camera, you want it, and you can practice it when it's paused, and then you can record it with low BS, which is what I did, and then you've got some nice, marvelous footage. Phil Rice 1:00:17 It's like an animated matte painting, almost, yeah. Damien Valentine 1:00:21 And so I put, there's a lot of photo modes. Have a frame, so you can put, like an image on it. And this has several different options, like postcards and things, but one of them's a window, which is what I used here, so it looks like a window with miles out behind me. You can turn that off. So you just got the full frame video footage, which is, if you're going to make a film, you probably want that, but I just thought worth mentioning that it's there as a tool, Phil Rice 1:00:53 yeah? Sure, just a link to that. We'll include it in the show notes. That'd be great. Damien Valentine 1:00:57 Yeah, I got it through Steam, so it's on there, I'll put in the show notes, and then people can play around with it. You'd have a huge amount of control over things happening, things about building and there are people in robots. You can move around a bit, but they have their own minds, so they'll go off and do their own thing. So I don't know it'd be interesting to see if anything, anyone does anything with it. Phil Rice 1:01:21 I'm just realized I skipped my first two items by mistake here, so I'll include them here at the end. There's a couple quick mentions that we wanted to make. One is for our dearly departed friend Frank Fox. We have put together, I've put together a playlist of some highlights of his machinima stuff, and we'll include a link to that here. It's about seven or eight short films that that he did that's a nice representation of his work. And we want to make sure people get to see that it's pretty, pretty neat stuff. And he was quite a, quite a versatile filmmaker across many different platforms. So and it closes with there's this wonderful, little short video I found it's a live recording. It's not machinima. It's just him playing guitar when he was quite young, a younger band, probably sometime in the early 90s, I want to say, playing and singing Hotel California. And it's fantastic. The fidelity on the video is kind of low and stuff, it's like, got almost like a home video kind of look, but it's just wonderful. And he had it up on his channel, so I put it up as well. The other thing I want to mention real quick is that there's a series here that we greatly loved, the first episode of by Biggs trek called Forbidden Planet, and the second episode of that Forbidden Planet, children of the Krell, the second episode of that is out. And if you enjoyed the first, you'll like this one as well. It's fantastic. And, yeah, so highly recommended. Yeah. Damien Valentine 1:02:58 I'm glad you brought this up, because I completely slipped my mind so tightly. Yeah, I need to watch the picture checks you from the planet, because I really enjoyed this first one. And I think that playlist is an excellent way to remember Frank, his work he did. And I need to watch that video of him playing because I'd be really intrigued to see Phil Rice 1:03:18 he had long hair and everything, and shirts off. Yeah, he was, he was, he was a musician at heart, for sure, through and through, yeah, Damien Valentine 1:03:29 but yeah, thank you for that. So yeah, that wraps up our news until the next time we do another newest episode. If you've got any feedback about the stories you've talked about, please send us an email at talk at completely machinery.com, and you can check out show notes for the links of everything we talked about on the blog. And we'll be back next week with film. So we'll see you, then take care and see you soon. You.