Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Inside FHLB: Ryan Donovan Talks Liquidity, Housing, and Credit Union Opportunities
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trekel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I am here with Ryan Donovan, who is the President and Chief
- 0:07Executive Officer of the Council of Federal Home Blown Banks.
- 0:11Ryan, how you doing today?
- 0:13Ryan: Doing great, mark.
- 0:13How are you?
- 0:14Treichel: I'm doing great.
- 0:15So you and I met back when you were at CUNA and I was at N-C-U-A-I I've had you
- 0:20on the podcast at least one other time.
- 0:23Ryan: That's right.
- 0:23And
- 0:23Treichel: we talked about some of the challenges at the time you had
- 0:27just moved over to your new role and I think there was the 100 year
- 0:31review which we chatted about there.
- 0:34And we've, we, we've had some things that have happened or
- 0:36not happened relative to that.
- 0:38But I thought it would be great, to just get back touch base, see
- 0:42what's happening with the federal home loan banks at this juncture.
- 0:45So I'm excited to catch up.
- 0:47Ryan: Yeah, no, that when we spoke before, we were really in the thick
- 0:51of it with that a hundred year review and that's, that started just days
- 0:55after I began my time with the council.
- 0:57So it was definitely like being thrown into the deep deep end and having
- 1:01to learn how to swim, at least with respect to the Homeland Bank system.
- 1:03Yeah,
- 1:04Treichel: What a better, what better way.
- 1:05They have to learn everything immediately.
- 1:06That's right.
- 1:07Some of our listeners might be learning about the Federal Home Loan banker,
- 1:10hearing about it for the first time, if they aren't familiar with it or if
- 1:15they're not, specifically linked to one of the federal home loan banks out there.
- 1:19If you could kinda walk through a little bit of what it is, the
- 1:22history of the organization.
- 1:24Sure.
- 1:24I think that would set the table well.
- 1:26Ryan: The Home Loan Bank system was created in 1932 and it was created with
- 1:31the express purpose of facilitating liquidity, lendable funds to financial
- 1:37institutions across the country.
- 1:39If you think back to it's the wonderful life and the whole problem that George
- 1:43Bailey ran into with not having the liquidity that he needed to meet his
- 1:47members withdrawal demands at that time.
- 1:50That's one of the.
- 1:51One of the problems that the home loan bank system solves for lenders, but
- 1:55it's really so much more than that.
- 1:57We're set up to connect Wall Street to Main Street and every day.
- 2:04Billions, tens of billions of dollars flow through the home loan banks from
- 2:09market to Main Street, and it helps local lenders, like credit unions have
- 2:14the funding that they need to make loans to their members, to their customers.
- 2:19We're 11 regionally based home loan banks, and importantly,
- 2:23especially to this audience.
- 2:25We're member owned financial cooperatives, just like credit unions.
- 2:30So I like to say home loan banks and credit unions are cooperative cousins.
- 2:34And and that brings I think a real close connection between
- 2:37the two the two systems.
- 2:40Treichel: No, that makes perfect sense.
- 2:42When I think about my times at NCUA.
- 2:45One of the guys who works for me was a capital market specialist,
- 2:48and he would always compare the, a liquidity event to a car crash.
- 2:54When you're spin, you're in the snow and you're spinning outta control
- 2:57and it's different than other issues.
- 2:59And the comparison I like to make is it's like oxygen liquidity almost.
- 3:05You don't even think about it until you need it.
- 3:08When you need it.
- 3:09It's, it seems like it's all you need at that moment, just like
- 3:13regaining control of that car, the liquidity when it's gone, yeah, no,
- 3:17Ryan: absolutely.
- 3:18One, one of the I love to, to talk through metaphors and and make comparisons and
- 3:25everything but when you think about.
- 3:27Why we use the word liquidity, it's it's really akin to water.
- 3:31So whether it's oxygen or water it's life.
- 3:34It's life sustaining.
- 3:35And and I think that really speaks to the critical role of the home loan banks.
- 3:39We want to make sure that our members have what they need to continue to serve
- 3:45the communities that they're serving.
- 3:49Treichel: When you think of the Fed is often called the lender of last resort,
- 3:52and they've had programs inter, when Silicon Valley Bank popped up, they did
- 3:56some things to create some liquidity.
- 3:59But they are the lender of last resort and the federal home loan banks.
- 4:02Can you speak to a little bit to how, it's a better source of liquidity
- 4:06than a lender of last resort.
- 4:08And then, and or if there were like things that happened that you
- 4:10wanna touch on from the, that era.
- 4:12Sure.
- 4:13That would be good to discuss too, I think.
- 4:15Ryan: Certainly not duplicative of each other in the marketplace.
- 4:19We serve different roles.
- 4:20We're complimentary to each other.
- 4:22In fact, I would I would compare.
- 4:25The home loan bank really to, to the way that a credit
- 4:28union would serve its members.
- 4:29You're there for them every day, and you're certainly there
- 4:32for them in times of crisis.
- 4:34I know the extent to which credit unions go to make sure that they're providing
- 4:39Treichel: Marie, can you turn off your, yeah.
- 4:43Are you there?
- 4:44I am back now and I'm not sure I'm in a different more I'm in a bit of a remote
- 4:48place, but it says my speed is okay, but I'm gonna guess it's on my end,
- 4:52Ryan: okay.
- 4:52Sorry.
- 4:52Treichel: That would be an example of being illiquid.
- 4:55That's right.
- 4:56Losing your internet is akin to not being liquid.
- 5:00Ryan: W you were asking me about the the different roles between the ho the Home
- 5:04Loan Bank System and the Federal Reserve.
- 5:06And, the point that I make is that they are.
- 5:09Complimentary to each other.
- 5:10And if you're thinking about it in going back to our discussion of of the different
- 5:15metaphors, I think the home loan banks are a lot like credit unions to their members.
- 5:20Credit unions are there for their members every day in all economic
- 5:24conditions, and so are home loan banks.
- 5:26And certainly when there's times of crisis, whether that's, March
- 5:30of 2023, the COVID-19 pandemic.
- 5:33Even through the great financial crisis the home loan banks have the ability to
- 5:37scale up to make sure that that their members have the liquidity they provide.
- 5:43Just as credit unions are able to make sure that they're there for
- 5:47their members in times of crisis.
- 5:50Yeah.
- 5:51Treichel: That's that's fantastic.
- 5:52And again, I can tell you when I was there situations where we were working
- 5:56with the conserved credit union, or we were working with the credit union
- 5:59that was challenged just seeing the ability of it must be that, probably
- 6:04that cooperative nature too, right?
- 6:05That their you mentioned they're cousins and they operate similarly.
- 6:08They, you try to help to the extent you can.
- 6:11Ryan: Yeah, I what I, when I talk to the home loan bank leadership, what
- 6:15they often remind me is that they've got relationships with their members.
- 6:19I think that's a big distinction between the home loan bank system and the federal
- 6:23reserve system is that relationship.
- 6:26The home loan banks have to demonstrate a value proposition to their members.
- 6:30They want their members using the institution, and
- 6:33comfortable with with putting.
- 6:36Collateral on deposit or on, pledging collateral to the home
- 6:39loan bank and being ready to borrow.
- 6:41So that relationship is something that happens every day.
- 6:46It's not something that's simply created at a time of crisis.
- 6:49I.
- 6:49Great point.
- 6:50Great point.
- 6:51Treichel: And then it's an inter it's an interesting, before we got on, we talked
- 6:54about, living in interesting times and we've had a change in the White House.
- 6:58There have been changes at most banking regulators one way or the other.
- 7:03And there's a new regulator of the federal home loan banks.
- 7:06Bill Pulte was recently confirmed as director of the FHFA.
- 7:12And he's been making some announcements and or making some changes relative to
- 7:17that can you speak to that environment and perhaps in general how the current times
- 7:24are impacting federal home loan banks?
- 7:27Ryan: Yeah, no.
- 7:27Great.
- 7:28Great question.
- 7:29A couple of observations just to lay the foundation for the response mark.
- 7:33I think, at the beginning of our conversation, we talked about the a
- 7:37hundred year review and that in some ways was a positive experience for
- 7:41the home loan banks because it gave us the opportunity to listen to what our
- 7:44members and stakeholders had to say about us, how they were feeling about us
- 7:47and what I think came through in that.
- 7:50In that process was that everybody wanted more from the system.
- 7:54Our members certainly wanted us to continue to stay in a position to provide
- 7:59them with the critical liquidity that they need, and they wanted us to be in
- 8:03an even stronger position to do that.
- 8:06We were under a lot of scrutiny in the previous administration and,
- 8:11I think we weathered that well.
- 8:12We responded to a lot of what we heard in that, in, in, in that process with
- 8:18the election, we saw an opportunity to reset our relationship with the,
- 8:24with FHFA, the, even before Mr.
- 8:27Pulte was nominated and confirmed.
- 8:29We went to work on, what is it that we need in order to continue to be.
- 8:35In a very strong position to serve our members and maybe even a stronger position
- 8:42if we could remove some regulatory burdens that had been imposed, make some
- 8:46other changes to how the agency and the home loan banks operate, and then when.
- 8:52Mr.
- 8:53Pulte was nominated.
- 8:54We had already been engaged with the administration and we made sure that we
- 8:59were really clear in the priorities that that we saw, the opportunities that, that
- 9:05we saw, trying to align those with the with the priorities of the administration.
- 9:11I had the opportunity to meet briefly with Mr.
- 9:13Pulte in a virtual meeting.
- 9:15Early on, and he recently took time to meet with with each of
- 9:20the home loan bank presidents.
- 9:21This is a guy that's hit the ground running at FHFA and he is
- 9:25really an appropriately focused on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mack.
- 9:30But he took a part of his very valuable time to meet with the home loan bank
- 9:35presidents to share a little bit about himself and his priorities,
- 9:38what he'd like to see the banks do and the message was, continue to serve
- 9:42your members, continue to operate.
- 9:44As businesses and let me know how I can help you do more of that.
- 9:49And that was a really well received message from the bank presidents and
- 9:55and we really appreciated the time and attention he has given us, especially
- 9:59given the other really critical work that that he's been doing at FHFA.
- 10:04Treichel: I think I saw somewhere that he had expressed some interest
- 10:07about affordable housing and.
- 10:10I also remember in some of our past conversations in the last administration
- 10:15you the organizations and the federal home loan banks were, there's something they're
- 10:20supposed to do relative to that, but they were doing it on hyper drive, maybe
- 10:24putting extra dollars into that program.
- 10:27If I, yeah.
- 10:28What, could you fill in some blanks there as it relates to that?
- 10:32Absolutely.
- 10:32That, and then perhaps on what Mr.
- 10:34Pulte has said about fair lending.
- 10:37Ryan: Yeah affordable lending.
- 10:38I'm sorry.
- 10:38Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 10:40Mark you're absolutely right.
- 10:41So under, under the federal Home Loan Bank Act the home loan banks are required
- 10:46each year to put 10% of their net earnings into an affordable housing program.
- 10:53And really as a result of what we heard from stakeholders during the
- 10:57during the review process, each of the 11 banks voluntarily committed to.
- 11:04Contributing 50% more than that.
- 11:06So taking that from 10% to, to 15% in net earnings.
- 11:11Last year was the first year that all of the banks achieved at least 15% in net
- 11:15earnings, and we ended up committing $1.2
- 11:19billion to affordable housing community development initiatives.
- 11:23That's a record for us, and it's saying something because we were already.
- 11:29The largest single source of private capital support for affordable
- 11:32housing in the United States.
- 11:34And here's an example of we, we listen to our stakeholders and what they
- 11:37need, what they what they were saying.
- 11:39And we responded to that.
- 11:41Director Pulte comes into to this role with a.
- 11:44Great familiarity on housing affordability.
- 11:47It's been something that he's talked a lot about in the first two
- 11:50months that he's been in this role.
- 11:53And we're continuing that important work.
- 11:55And certainly that plays out on the in terms of the affordable
- 11:59housing programs and the voluntary programs the banks operate.
- 12:03But our liquidity franchise.
- 12:06Also drives our ability to support housing affordability.
- 12:10We had, a re report done by the Filing Research Institute earlier this year that
- 12:16really focused on how credit unions derive value from the home loan bank system.
- 12:21It helps 'em grow, it helps 'em do more loans.
- 12:24And, of course credit unions are in that market in a very competitive
- 12:27way, helping to provide lower cost lending to their members.
- 12:31But a few years ago, the University of Wisconsin did a study that showed that.
- 12:36Home loan bank activity reduces mortgage rates by 18 basis points and increases
- 12:43mortgage lending by more than 16%.
- 12:46So here you have, you certainly have our contributions on one side, but
- 12:49then on the liquidity side, we're really in a position to really drive
- 12:55making mortgage lending more affordable for consumers across the country.
- 13:01And we're doing that every day.
- 13:02And we think that activity aligns very well with the priorities
- 13:07that Director Pulte president Trump and the administration have.
- 13:11And the message that we feel like we've received so far is keep doing that.
- 13:15Treichel: That's great.
- 13:16That's in the world right now to here.
- 13:18Keep doing that.
- 13:19That's about as, as good a message as you can hear.
- 13:21And when I hear the numbers 16%, that's one out six, one out of every $6.
- 13:25Yeah, that's that's absolutely amazing.
- 13:27It, I used to live in Texas back at the beginning of my days with NCUA.
- 13:31I was a supervisory examiner.
- 13:3391 to 95 down in Texas, and I remember Pulte homes, so I haven't got, I'm
- 13:38gonna go to Wikipedia, but I'm gonna guess that Bill Pulte is the son of,
- 13:43or something related to that, that company down there and the homes,
- 13:46which might be why he knows so much and cares so much about affordable housing.
- 13:50Ryan: Yes.
- 13:50He's got housing in his blood, that's for sure.
- 13:52Treichel: Yep.
- 13:53Yep.
- 13:53Yeah.
- 13:54Very good.
- 13:54So from the credit union perspective, anything you can think of that, that.
- 13:59Credit unions should be thinking about as it relates to their relationship,
- 14:04if they have a relationship with the Federal Home Loan Bank, and if
- 14:07they don't have a relationship with the Federal Home Loan Bank, what
- 14:10would you tell credit unions today?
- 14:11Yeah.
- 14:12So
- 14:12Ryan: If there's a credit union that isn't a member of the home loan
- 14:15bank system, I'd encourage 'em to.
- 14:17Look for that filing research study.
- 14:19It came out in January and what filing did was they looked at call
- 14:23reports going from 1994 to 2024, and what they found was that I.
- 14:30Credit unions that are members of the home loan bank tend to grow loans faster.
- 14:34They have more total assets.
- 14:36Their balance sheet is more flexible.
- 14:39They've got higher loan to share ratios.
- 14:41They increase, they've got an increased borrowing capacity and
- 14:45it really helps increase their access to the capital markets.
- 14:48And it does that without.
- 14:50Having any sort of statistically significant effect on
- 14:53delinquencies or charge offs.
- 14:55So this is a safe activity that makes credit unions stronger, and
- 15:00the impacts they found were more pronounced on smaller credit unions.
- 15:03So if you're a credit union out there that isn't a member of the home loan
- 15:07bank system, check out that report and then reach out to your home loan bank
- 15:10and and look into to becoming a member.
- 15:14Credit unions are the fastest growing segment of.
- 15:17Home loan bank membership and and we love working with our cooperative cousins.
- 15:22We love working with all of our members.
- 15:24You know what I would also ask is if you are a member of the home loan bank.
- 15:29When you come for Hike the Hill or for GAC make sure that's part of the messaging.
- 15:34America's credit unions put it in there.
- 15:35Their messaging this year, as did the American Bankers
- 15:38Association and ICBA as well.
- 15:41So we've got the National Banking and Credit Union trades talking about
- 15:45home loan banks, and that's really critical because there was, I don't
- 15:49wanna overstate it, but it, over the last couple of years there's been a lot
- 15:53of scrutiny in on the home loan bank side, especially on the liquidity side.
- 15:58And, earlier this year I met with the heads of the four
- 16:01major finance depository.
- 16:04Regulators.
- 16:04I met with Chairman Hotman, acting Chairman Hill acting comptroller hood,
- 16:09and fed Governor Bowman, who's about ready to become vice chair of the Fed.
- 16:14Really to reinforce the fact that the home loan bank system is safe and sound.
- 16:19Reliable.
- 16:20We're there for our members.
- 16:21We're gonna continue to be there.
- 16:23And this was a message that was very well received by, by those regulators.
- 16:28And it's an important message for credit unions to deliver to policymakers as well.
- 16:32Treichel: Great point.
- 16:33You could never, the hike, the power of hike the hill, which just happened.
- 16:36But credit unions touch a lot of members, touch a lot of
- 16:40people in good ways, so always.
- 16:42If you are a member I couldn't agree more.
- 16:44If you are a member, when you're communicating tell people how
- 16:47much your home loan bank helps.
- 16:49It's an option.
- 16:50And I'm thinking as you were thinking, as you were talking about someone
- 16:53who's not a member life's about having options and maintaining, and you.
- 17:00I think if you, from what I've seen from my clients and my time at NCA, somebody
- 17:06who is a member has just one more option and then it turns into a relationship
- 17:11that's more than just an option.
- 17:12It turns into a key and crucial relationship that
- 17:17helps you help your members.
- 17:18I couldn't agree more
- 17:20Ryan: and I couldn't have said it better myself.
- 17:21You want to have options and I think the home loan bank system is
- 17:24a great option for credit unions.
- 17:26Treichel: Very good.
- 17:27Very good, Ryan.
- 17:27Any other questions I should have asked you here today?
- 17:30Anything else you wanna chat about while while I have you
- 17:32on the video and, online here.
- 17:34Ryan: Oh, mark.
- 17:34There's so many things going on right now, but I think we've covered the the
- 17:38beachfront for for home loan banks today.
- 17:40Treichel: Very good.
- 17:40Very good.
- 17:41Let's stay focused on that, and if someone wants to reach out to you or
- 17:45your organization, what's the best way for them to get in touch with you, Ryan?
- 17:48Ryan: Yeah, so we're we're very active on LinkedIn.
- 17:51And and of course you can reach out to me there or reach out
- 17:55to the council on LinkedIn.
- 17:56That's probably the best way to get ahold of us.
- 17:58Treichel: You got it.
- 17:59Very good.
- 17:59I appreciate your time today and and thanks for sharing a little bit
- 18:03of it with my listeners here today.
- 18:05All righty.
- 18:05Thanks, mark.
- 18:06Very good.
- 18:06And listeners, I wanna thank you for listening.
- 18:08As always, this is Mark TriCal signing off with flying Colors.
- 18:13Fabulous.
- 18:14Ryan: Awesome.
- 18:15Very good.
- 18:15Thank you so much.
- 18:16Treichel: Yeah, you got it.
- 18:17My pleasure.
- 18:17Let's see.
- 18:18This will probably go out.
- 18:19I, my, my newish, my new episodes go out Tuesdays on the podcast
- 18:26apps and Wednesdays on, on YouTube, and so it'll be two weeks from
- 18:31now that this one will go out.
- 18:33Okay, that's fantastic.
- 18:34Just in
- 18:35Ryan: time.
- 18:36Treichel: Yeah.
- 18:37Ryan: We have our conference in two weeks from Tuesday okay.
- 18:40Perfect timing.
- 18:40Treichel: Alright.
- 18:41Excellent.
- 18:41Fantastic all guys.
- 18:43All righty.
- 18:44Ryan: Thanks, mark.
- 18:44Take care.
- 18:44Thanks, mark.
- 18:45Appreciate it.
- 18:46Treichel: Bye-bye.
- 18:46Thank you.
- 18:46I appreciate it as well.