Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How Treasury Buybacks Could Backfire in a 5 Percent Era
Transcript
- Lucas: So the headline this week was the debt crossing forty trillion dollars, but the story underneath that is the Treasury secretary, Scott Bessent, trying to calm a bond market that is clearly nervous about that number. Luna: And by 'trying to calm,' you mean the buyback program? The one Bessent says could be more than four billion dollars? Lucas: Exactly. The Treasury has been tiptoeing back into buybacks after a two-decade hiatus, and it's a genuinely interesting piece of financial engineering. But the market reaction so far has been, shall we say, underwhelming. The 30-year yield is sitting at 5.19 percent, down a bit from last week's 5.28, but still roughly a full percentage point higher than where it was a year ago. Luna: Right, and the ten-year is at 4.74. So Bessent's gambit is supposed to make those yields come down, but it's not exactly working yet. Lucas: No, it isn't. And the CNBC headlines are basically asking the same thing: what else can he try? So let's unpack what a Treasury buyback actually is, because I think most people hear 'buyback' and think of corporate stock buybacks. This is different. The Treasury isn't buying its own shares; it's buying back its own outstanding bonds from the open market. Luna: Why would they do that? Isn't that just paying off debt early? Lucas: Sort of, but it's more about managing the market plumbing. The Treasury issues a lot of debt, and some of the older bonds become less liquid over time. By buying them back, the Treasury can smooth out the maturity profile and improve liquidity in the market. That's the official rationale, anyway. Luna: But the skeptics say there's a hidden agenda. Lucas: Right. The timing is suspicious. We've got a federal deficit of nearly 1.8 trillion dollars for fiscal 2025, and the Treasury is flooding the market with supply. They're trying to manage the borrowing costs, and a buyback is a way to nudge yields down—or at least signal that the Treasury is paying attention. Luna: And Bessent said there's a 'very good chance' the deficit has peaked. But we're still talking about forty trillion dollars of debt and a debt to gdp ratio of 122.6 percent. Lucas: That is the crux of the problem. Even if the deficit has peaked in nominal terms, the interest bill is still climbing because the yield curve is elevated. The average maturity of the debt is pretty long—around six years—so the refi wave is coming at these higher rates. Every auction is a test of whether buyers will show up. Luna: And that's where the buyback gets interesting. If the Treasury is buying back old bonds, it's effectively creating demand for the long end. But is it enough to move the needle? Lucas: Four billion dollars is a drop in the bucket compared to the trillions outstanding. But the signal matters. It tells the market that the Treasury is willing to step in and support prices, which could shore up confidence. However, there's a flip side: some economists worry that this is a slippery slope toward yield-curve manipulation, and that could stoke inflation fears. Luna: Inflation? How does buying back debt cause inflation? Lucas: Well, if the Treasury is effectively putting a floor under bond prices, it's also putting a cap on yields. And if yields are artificially low, that could be seen as monetizing the debt—printing money to pay off creditors. That's the fear. The market might start to price in a future where the government is less disciplined about its finances. Luna: So Bessent is stuck between a rock and a hard place. If he doesn't intervene, yields spike. If he does, he risks inflation expectations. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the market hasn't rallied on this news. The headlines are saying the gambit isn't working because investors are more focused on the structural supply problem—the deficit is still enormous, and the Treasury has to keep issuing more debt. Lucas: I mean, think about it this way: the 10-year is at 4.74, but the 2-year is at 4.19. That's a fifty-basis-point spread, which is pretty steep for a healthy economy. Normally, a steep curve signals growth expectations, but here it's more about risk premium—investors demanding more compensation for holding long-term debt. Luna: And that's the term premium we talked about a few episodes ago. It's back with a vengeance. Lucas: Right. The term premium is a big part of why the 30-year is flirting with 5.2 percent. And that's a round number that gets people's attention. It's psychological, but it matters. When yields cross those thresholds, it forces a repricing across the whole curve. Luna: So what's the buyback actually doing if it's not moving yields? Lucas: It's providing a backstop, but it's also a talking point. Bessent is trying to signal that the Treasury is proactive. But the market is skeptical because the underlying fundamentals haven't changed. The debt is still 122.6 percent of GDP, and the deficit is still nearly two trillion. A four-billion-dollar buyback is a band-aid on a bullet wound. Luna: And that's the thing—this feels like an episode where we should point out that what the Treasury is doing is complex and easy to misunderstand. If you're listening and this is making sense, that's the goal. These are the kind of episodes we do best when we can dig into the mechanics without the spin. Lucas: Absolutely. And if that's landed for you, the way we keep doing this ad-free is listener support. If you find this walk through the economy useful, you can help us keep it going at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a genuine thank you if you do. Luna: Yeah, every little bit helps us keep the lights on and the analysis free for everyone. Now, back to the buyback—one more angle I want to bring up: how does this play with the Fed's own balance sheet? Lucas: That's a great question. The Fed is still in quantitative tightening—shrinking its balance sheet by letting bonds roll off. So you have the Fed selling or not reinvesting, while the Treasury is buying back. It's a bit contradictory, but they're different players with different goals. The Fed is trying to normalize policy; the Treasury is trying to manage its liabilities. Luna: So the Treasury buyback could actually ease the Fed's job by absorbing some of the supply that the Fed is no longer buying. Lucas: Potentially. But remember, the Treasury is also issuing new debt every week. It's not like they're shrinking the overall pile. They're just buying back older, less liquid issues. So the net effect on supply is marginal. Luna: And that's why the market is saying 'meh.' Four billion is not going to move the needle when the Treasury is issuing hundreds of billions every quarter. Lucas: Right. And there's another wrinkle: the buyback is funded by issuing new debt. So it's not like the Treasury is paying down debt with tax revenue—it's basically a refinancing operation. That might be why the inflation worry comes in. It looks like the government is just shuffling paper, not actually reducing its borrowing needs. Luna: So what would actually work? What could Bessent do to calm the market? Lucas: The honest answer is: he needs to change the fiscal trajectory. That means either cutting spending or raising revenue—politically difficult, to say the least. In the absence of that, he's left with financial engineering. And the market sees through it. Luna: So we're back to the same conclusion: the debt is the problem, and the buyback is just a distraction. Lucas: It's a tool, not a solution. But it's worth watching because the Treasury's actions do shape market dynamics. If they scale up the buyback program—if Bessent makes it bigger and more aggressive—that could have a more noticeable effect. For now, it's a pilot program. Luna: And we should mention that the Treasury has been pretty transparent about this being a trial. They ran a similar program back in the early 2000s, but it was short-lived. Lucas: That's right. The last time they did buybacks on a regular basis was around 2000 to 2002, when we had budget surpluses. Now we're in a different world. But the mechanics are similar. The question is whether the market trusts the intention. Luna: Given the headlines, I'd say the jury is still out. Lucas: Yeah. And one more thing: Bessent's comments about the deficit peaking are a big part of the narrative. If investors believe that, they might be more willing to buy long-term debt. But with the 30-year at 5.19, they're clearly not buying it yet. Luna: So the bond market is voting with its wallet, and it's saying 'show me the fiscal discipline.' Lucas: Exactly. The buyback is a nice tool, but it can't substitute for a credible plan to bring the debt down. Until that happens, expect yields to stay elevated and the debt to keep climbing. It's a sobering reality, but it's the one we're in. Luna: Well, and with that, I think we've painted a pretty clear picture. Thanks for walking through it with us today.