Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Vehicle Retrofit: Suitability and Benefits
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive, where we cut through the noise to give
- 0:12you the essential knowledge fast.
- 0:15Today we're actually skipping the showroom floor.
- 0:17We're diving straight into the garage, you could say.
- 0:20That's right, we're looking at DIYEV conversion, taking an old
- 0:25classic car, Oregon, even just a regular conventional car and
- 0:28turning it into a battery electric vehicle, a Bev.
- 0:31It's getting retty popular. Actually, you know, there are
- 0:33over 40 million EVs out there now and people are realizing,
- 0:37hey, maybe I don't need a brand new car to go electric.
- 0:40Exactly. So our mission today is to give
- 0:43you that practical road map, because it is technical, right?
- 0:46We're talking about the whole shebang, pulling out the
- 0:48combustion engine, the gas tank, the exhaust, and putting in an
- 0:51electric motor, a big battery pack, all the control systems.
- 0:54It sounds a bit like magic, but it's real engineering.
- 0:57Oh, absolutely. And that engineering, that
- 0:59seriousness, it really starts way before you pick up a wrench.
- 1:02The first thing, the most critical step for a safe,
- 1:06successful conversion choosing the right car to start with the
- 1:09the donor car. OK, let's get into that because
- 1:12I'm guessing you can't just grab any old banger and electrify it,
- 1:15right? What makes a car like ideal for
- 1:18this kind of major surgery? You've nailed it.
- 1:21Picking the right one makes everything easier down the line.
- 1:24Less cost, better performance, better range.
- 1:27We generally look for cars that tick 4 main boxes.
- 1:30OK, box #1, lay it on us. Wait wait, matters?
- 1:34Sounds obvious I know, but people forget every extra pound
- 1:37you're starting car has means you need a bigger, heavier and
- 1:40yeah, more expensive battery pack to get decent range.
- 1:42Lighter cars just need less power.
- 1:44So smaller batteries, cheaper build, better efficiency, it all
- 1:47connects. Makes total sense.
- 1:49Less metal to push around, less juice needed.
- 1:52OK, what's critical trait #2? Simplicity wins often.
- 1:56We're talking about older cars here, which is kind of the
- 1:58appeal for many people doing conversions.
- 2:01You want cars with straightforward mechanical
- 2:03designs and, crucially, minimal computerization.
- 2:06Fewer complex electronics, fewer ECU's already trying to manage
- 2:10things like the throttle or brakes well, the easier it is to
- 2:13integrate the new electric systems without conflicts.
- 2:16Oh, OK, so if your dashboard looks like a spaceship control
- 2:19panel, maybe that's not the best candidate.
- 2:21Fewer digital bits fighting the new electric bits.
- 2:24Exactly. Fewer fights and then the last
- 2:27two are space and strength, and these are absolutely non
- 2:30negotiable for safety. Battery packs are seriously
- 2:33heavy. We're talking 500, maybe over
- 2:361000 lbs sometimes. So you need enough physical
- 2:39space inside or maybe underneath to actually fit that battery
- 2:42mass. And just as important, you need
- 2:45a strong chassis and suspension. They can actually handle all
- 2:47that extra weight safely. You can't skip that.
- 2:50Right, you don't want the frame buckling or the suspension
- 2:52bottoming out. So let's talk specifics.
- 2:55Got any like fun examples? If I wanted a cool weekend
- 2:58project car based on these rules, what should I be scouring
- 3:01the classifieds for? Yeah, the research gets some
- 3:03great pointers, sort of the crowd favorites.
- 3:05For pure nostalgia, you can't really beat the classic
- 3:09Volkswagen Beetle. It pops up again and again as
- 3:11one of the best classic conversions.
- 3:12Why? Because it's original design,
- 3:14simple rear engine. It actually helps with weight
- 3:17distribution when you put the electric motor back there.
- 3:19Huh, that's cool. The original layout actually
- 3:21makes it better for an electric swap in some ways.
- 3:24What about something a bit more modern?
- 3:26Classic. Well, for a really nimble, fun
- 3:28weekend driver, the Mazda Miata MX5 is a fantastic choice,
- 3:32especially those early ones. The NA and NB generation say
- 3:361990 to 2005. They're light to begin with,
- 3:38under £2500 usually makes them super efficient as electric
- 3:42roadsters. Loads of fun.
- 3:44Oh yeah, I can totally picture that little electric Miata
- 3:46zipping around, but there's a whole scene around converting
- 3:49those now. Old school, cool new school
- 3:52power. There really is, and then if you
- 3:54need something more practical, maybe for work or hauling stuff,
- 3:57ladder frame trucks are great candidates.
- 3:59Thing like Toyota Hilux or maybe a Ford Ranger from the late 90s
- 4:04early 2000s up to maybe 2011. Their frames are built tough,
- 4:08designed for heavy loads anyway, so they handle the battery
- 4:11weight much more easily. OK, so you find your perfect
- 4:13Beetle or Miata or Ranger. Then comes the hardware swap.
- 4:16You mentioned the core bits earlier.
- 4:18Remind us what they are. Right.
- 4:19The key ingredients are the electric motor itself, the
- 4:23battery pack, that's the big one, the controller, which is
- 4:25like the brain managing power flow, and the BMS, the battery
- 4:29management system for the motor. For DIY projects, brushless DC
- 4:34motors are really the way to go these days.
- 4:36Why brushless specifically? What's the advantage there?
- 4:39Several things. They're pretty cost effective
- 4:41now they're very efficient, which means more range from your
- 4:43battery. And maybe most importantly for a
- 4:46custom job, they need way less maintenance than the old brush
- 4:50motors. No brushes to wear out.
- 4:53Higher efficiency equals better range.
- 4:55That's always the name of the game.
- 4:56But honestly, the motor choice is often simpler than figuring
- 4:59out the controller and the BMS integration that that leads us
- 5:03right into the common pitfalls. Right, the mechanical side seems
- 5:06somewhat straightforward, swap A for B, but the source is
- 5:09hammered home that the electrical side, well, it sounds
- 5:13like a real minefield. What are the biggest mistakes
- 5:16people make when they dive into this?
- 5:17This is exactly where projects succeed or, well, fail
- 5:21spectacularly. The experts we looked at, they
- 5:23stressed that good conversions need about 30% more planning
- 5:27time than people initially think, especially on the
- 5:29electrical side. You just can't wing the high
- 5:31voltage stuff. 30% more planning.
- 5:33OK, so let's start with the mindset mistake #1.
- 5:36Mistake #1 under estimating complexity big time.
- 5:41People think I was just like swapping an engine.
- 5:43No, no it is not. You're shifting from, you know,
- 5:47wrenches and oil to high voltage circuits and software logic.
- 5:49It's a different discipline. The pros They recommend at least
- 5:5350 hours of dedicated EV conversion training and drawing
- 5:56up detailed electrical diagrams before you even think about
- 5:59touching a high voltage wire. Wow, 50 hours of homework before
- 6:02the fun part? That's serious commitment.
- 6:04OK, what about the physical side?
- 6:05That heavy battery pack you mentioned?
- 6:07Leads straight to mistake #2 Ignoring weight distribution,
- 6:11you're adding hundreds, maybe 1000 lbs.
- 6:13It's not just the total weight, it's where you put it.
- 6:16If you don't calculate the new center of gravity properly,
- 6:19front to back and side to side, you mess up the car's handling
- 6:23badly. It can become unstable, unsafe.
- 6:26You absolutely have to factor in upgrading suspension components,
- 6:30springs, shocks, maybe even axles to handle that extra mass
- 6:34safely. It's not optional.
- 6:36Got it. Suspension upgrades are part of
- 6:38the deal now. You dropped a pretty scary
- 6:40statistic earlier. Something about almost half of
- 6:43failures tracing back to one specific area.
- 6:46Yeah, that was a sobering one mistake #3 battery system
- 6:49mismanagement, specifically issues related to the BMS, the
- 6:53battery management system. According to industry data, we
- 6:56saw problems here account for a shocking 42% of conversion
- 7:00failures. Whoa hang on, 42% from just the
- 7:03battery management? Doesn't that make this whole
- 7:05thing incredibly risky for someone doing it in their
- 7:07garage? I mean, where do you even get
- 7:08training on commercial grade BMS set up?
- 7:11And what's the BMS actually doing that makes it so critical?
- 7:13It is risky if you cut corners, definitely, but it's manageable
- 7:17if you approach a methodically. The BMS. Think of it as the
- 7:20battery packs, bodyguard, and brain.
- 7:23Its main job is voltage balancing.
- 7:25It makes sure every single cell inside that huge pack charges
- 7:28and discharges at the same rate. If one cell gets ahead, charges
- 7:31too much, that can cause overheating, thermal runaways,
- 7:34potentially fire. That's the worst case.
- 7:36OK, so the BMS is basically the fire prevention system for the
- 7:39battery pack. That's a big part of it, yes.
- 7:42So best practices choose batteries with maybe 2030% more
- 7:46capacity than you think you need.
- 7:48Gives you a buffer. Definitely implement active
- 7:50thermal management. That means cooling, sometimes
- 7:52heating for the batteries depending on the climate.
- 7:55And always, always use proper moisture resistant enclosures
- 7:59for the pack. Protected from the elements and
- 8:02a crucial safety alert here, high voltage is no joke.
- 8:06Always wear the right insulated gloves.
- 8:08Always disconnect the high voltage system properly before
- 8:10working on it. And remember, capacitors in the
- 8:12system can hold a dangerous charge for a long time.
- 8:15Even after you disconnect the battery, that residual energy
- 8:18can still give you a nasty shock or worse.
- 8:21Be careful. Hours later even.
- 8:22Vital advice, Seriously important.
- 8:24OK, we've hit weight, complexity and the critical battery
- 8:27management. What about the more mundane
- 8:30stuff like wiring and just running out of money?
- 8:32Yeah, the mundane stuff can still trip you up.
- 8:36That brings us to mistakes four and five.
- 8:39Electrical system overload. Very common.
- 8:42The car's original wiring harness just wasn't designed for
- 8:44the kind of amps and electric motor poles you have to upgrade
- 8:47key wiring runs to proper automotive grade stuff rated for
- 8:51high temperatures, usually 105° C minimum.
- 8:54And grounding. Perfect grounding is essential.
- 8:57Right. Don't melt the original wires
- 8:59and the budget. These conversions aren't exactly
- 9:01cheap, are they? No, they're not, and that's
- 9:03mistake five. Budget miscalculation or
- 9:05compromises and trying to save money by using cheap, low
- 9:09quality high voltage components like controllers, contactors,
- 9:12even chargers is asking for trouble.
- 9:14These parts handle serious power.
- 9:16If they fail, it could be catastrophic or just leave you
- 9:19stranded. Smart planning means setting
- 9:21aside a contingency fund at least 20% of your total budget
- 9:23just for unexpected problems or needing better parts than you
- 9:26first thought. Don't skimp on anything that
- 9:28touches high voltage. Prioritize quality then. 20%
- 9:31buffer. Good rule for any big project,
- 9:33but sounds absolutely essential here.
- 9:36OK, what are the last couple of pitfalls people forget about the
- 9:39ones after the build? Right, The ones that happen
- 9:42after you think you're done. Let's take 6 legal compliance
- 9:45oversights. The paperwork.
- 9:47You can't just build this thing and dried it, you need to follow
- 9:50your local rules. That usually means specific
- 9:53safety inspections for modified vehicles and definitely updating
- 9:57the vehicles registration to reflect its new propulsion type.
- 10:00Skipping this can lead to fines or insurance issues.
- 10:03Legality is just as important to safety.
- 10:05Don't get caught out by the DMV. Good tip and the final mistake.
- 10:10Mistake 7 neglecting post conversion care.
- 10:13An electric car needs different maintenance than a gas car.
- 10:16You should be doing regular, maybe monthly battery health
- 10:18checks. Looking at that cell balancing
- 10:20we talked about making sure everything's happy and probably
- 10:23getting an annual diagnostic scan by someone familiar with EV
- 10:25systems just to check the overall health and integrity of
- 10:28your conversion. It's preventative maintenance.
- 10:31OK, so plan meticulously, build carefully, budget wisely, handle
- 10:36the paperwork and keep an eye on it afterwards.
- 10:39It's a whole life cycle approach really.
- 10:41Now let's zoom out. We've talked a lot about the
- 10:43how, but why bother? Beyond just the coolness factor
- 10:46of electrifying a classic, what's the real measurable
- 10:50environmental benefit here? Yes, the why, and this is where
- 10:54it gets really interesting from an engineering and environmental
- 10:57science perspective. We look at a fascinating study,
- 10:59a proper comparative life cycle assessment and LCA.
- 11:02It specifically analyzed the impact of converting a smart 4/2
- 11:06car, the W 450 model. It really quantifies the
- 11:09environmental argument for these projects.
- 11:10And LCA on a smart car conversion, OK.
- 11:12So how did they measure the impact?
- 11:14What were they comparing it against to get that potential
- 11:16saving? Good question.
- 11:18They set up two scenarios, both covering a vehicle life of
- 11:20200,000 kilometers. Scenario A was the baseline take
- 11:25the old end of life internal combustion engine ICE smart car,
- 11:29scrap it and replace it with a brand new ICE car.
- 11:32For those 200,000 kilometers, Scenario B was take the same old
- 11:36ICE smart car but instead of scrapping it converted to a
- 11:39battery electric vehicle Bev and run it for the 200,000
- 11:42kilometers. OK, So new gas car versus
- 11:45keeping the old car but making it electric covering the same
- 11:48distance. What was the big take away the
- 11:50the aha moment? The headline finding was pretty
- 11:53striking. The study concluded that the
- 11:55retrofit route scenario B resulted in about 45% lower
- 11:59overall greenhouse gas emissions compared to just buying a new IC
- 12:01car Scenario A, nearly half the climate impact avoided, and the
- 12:05key is where those savings come from. 45% that's that's huge.
- 12:09Where does that massive saving actually happen in the cars life
- 12:11cycle? The lion share comes from the
- 12:13manufacturing phase. Scenario B.
- 12:15The conversion saved a massive 60.7% of GHG emissions just in
- 12:19manufacturing, and that's almost entirely down to something
- 12:21called glider reuse. Glider reuse, right?
- 12:24You mentioned that term. Break that down for us.
- 12:26What exactly is a glider and why is reusing it so impactful?
- 12:29So a glider in the auto industry is basically the finished car
- 12:33body and chassis before the engine and drivetrain are
- 12:36installed. Think of the painted shell, the
- 12:38interior, the frame. Making that glider involves a
- 12:41ton of energy and materials. Stamping steel panels, welding
- 12:44them together, corrosion treatments, painting multiple
- 12:47layers. It's hugely resource intensive.
- 12:50By reusing the existing glider from the old car, you completely
- 12:54avoid all that upstream manufacturing impact.
- 12:56That's the big environmental win right there, not making a whole
- 12:59new car body. Wow, OK, so reusing the shell is
- 13:03the absolute bedrock of the environmental benefit.
- 13:05You're sidestepping the single biggest chunk of a new car's
- 13:08manufacturing. Footprint, precisely that second
- 13:10life for the structure is key, but there were also savings in
- 13:13the use phase. The study found the electric use
- 13:16phase in scenario B had a 58.8% lower GHG impact than driving
- 13:20the new ICE car in Scenario A, even when you account for making
- 13:23the battery. That's impressive too.
- 13:25Did the study look at what makes the benefits even better?
- 13:28Like are there ideal conditions for a converted EV?
- 13:31Yes, they ran sensitivity analysis and the environmental
- 13:34pluses really shine under 2 main conditions. 1st, when the car is
- 13:38used mostly for urban driving, the secifically modeled using
- 13:42the WLT 1 urban driving cycle. You know lots of lower seeds
- 13:46stop start traffic like in cities.
- 13:49Doing that compared to a more mixed or highway cycle cut the
- 13:52energy consumption by 22.3%. EVs are just really efficient in
- 13:56town with regenerative braking. Right city driving plays to the
- 13:59strengths of electric drive, especially conversions which
- 14:02might have slightly less range. More regen braking helps a lot.
- 14:06Totally. And the second big factor, maybe
- 14:08the most obvious one, is the source of the electricity.
- 14:10The benefits skyrocket when the electricity used to charge the
- 14:13car comes from a renewable heavy grid mix combined urban driving
- 14:17with really clean electricity, the study showed.
- 14:19That could lead to an almost unbelievable 99.1% reduction in
- 14:24greenhouse gas emissions during the use phase compared to the
- 14:27gas car. 99% that's basically 0 emissions driving and it links
- 14:31straight into those bigger picture goals doesn't it?
- 14:34Like the UN sustainable development goals.
- 14:37SDG 13 on climate action is obvious, but also SDG 12
- 14:41responsible consumption and production.
- 14:43Giving old vehicles a second life instead of scrapping them
- 14:46fits perfectly. Absolutely.
- 14:48It shows that what might seem like a niche hobby actually has
- 14:51real data supported relevance for broader sustainable
- 14:55transport policies. It's circular economy thinking
- 14:58in action. This has been genuinely
- 15:00fascinating. We've gone from the engineering
- 15:03elegance of picking a Miata as a donor car all the way to the
- 15:07critical need to avoid that 42% battery management failure rate
- 15:11and landed on hard data showing a potential 45% greenhouse gas
- 15:15saving. It's quite the journey.
- 15:17It really highlights the twin benefits, doesn't it?
- 15:19You get to keep a car you potentially love, maybe
- 15:22something unique or classic, while also achieving real cost
- 15:25savings on fuel and maintenance and making a verifiable positive
- 15:29environmental impact. It's a compelling mix,
- 15:32especially if you're up for the challenge of the planning and
- 15:34execution. And maybe the most powerful
- 15:36point, the real kicker from that LCA studies sensitivity
- 15:39analysis, something you really chew on.
- 15:42Even the absolute worst case scenario.
- 15:44They modeled for the converted electric car assuming high
- 15:47energy use and charging it with dirty coal heavy electricity
- 15:50like the Polish grid mix they used as an example.
- 15:53Even that worst case EV conversion still had a lower
- 15:56overall lifetime GHG impact than the best case scenario for
- 16:00buying a brand new efficient internal combustion engine car.
- 16:04Think about that. Even if everything's against the
- 16:06conversion, environmentally, high energy use, dirty grid, it
- 16:10still beats buying a new gas car.
- 16:12That just underscores how massive the benefit of not
- 16:15manufacturing a whole new vehicle really is.
- 16:18That glider reuse is incredibly powerful.
- 16:20A truly powerful final thought on the environmental case for
- 16:23conversion. Well, thank you for joining us
- 16:25on this deep dive into the world of DIYEV conversions.
- 16:29Whether you're actually planning your own project or just curious
- 16:31about how will tech can get a new electric lease on life, we
- 16:34hope this gave you some food for thought.
- 16:35Some electrifying food for thought, perhaps?
- 16:38And yeah, definitely encourage you to follow the channel for
- 16:41more deep dives into interesting and common complex topics like
- 16:43this one. Thanks for listening.