Latest / Play Therapy Podcast: A Master-Class in Child-Centered Play Therapy / 433 | What Do You Say When a Child Asks If You Actually Like Them?
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Play Therapy Podcast with Dr.
- 0:03Brenna Hicks,
- 0:04your source for centered and focused play therapy coaching.
- 0:08Hi,
- 0:08I'm Dr.
- 0:09Brenna Hicks,
- 0:09The Kid Counselor.
- 0:11This is the Play Therapy Podcast where you get
- 0:13a master class in child-centered play therapy
- 0:15and practical support and application for your
- 0:17work with children and their families.
- 0:20Today's episode,
- 0:21we are going to talk about
- 0:24A kid who continually says in the playroom
- 0:28that
- 0:29the therapist does not want to be with them.
- 0:31And
- 0:32if you've been doing this any length of time,
- 0:33you will have some version of this conversation.
- 0:36So,
- 0:36I'm actually really excited about this,
- 0:38Dovi.
- 0:38Thank you for the
- 0:39email.
- 0:40Before we dive in,
- 0:41y'all,
- 0:41there's so much going on in,
- 0:43in The Hicks Group world,
- 0:44let me tell you.
- 0:47I,
- 0:47I'll give like a very fast cliff's notes and then
- 0:49I'm gonna direct you to playtherapynow.com because
- 0:52that's where all of this will live.
- 0:54So,
- 0:55playtherapynow.com,
- 0:56the one-stop shop for all things related to The Kid Counselor and The Hicks Group.
- 1:01But
- 1:02honestly,
- 1:02y'all need to be signed up for my newsletter too.
- 1:05So you can do that on playtherapynow.com and
- 1:07that will be my main channel of communication.
- 1:10And I know there's people that like have one but not the other.
- 1:12So,
- 1:12like,
- 1:13you listen to podcasts,
- 1:14but you're not a newsletter person,
- 1:15you're a newsletter person,
- 1:16but you
- 1:16aren't part of the Collective,
- 1:17whatever.
- 1:18So,
- 1:18all these different camps of connection.
- 1:22I'm trying to make sure that everyone is unified and playtherapynow.com is
- 1:26where you'll go and the newsletter is gonna be the way that I communicate.
- 1:29So,
- 1:30make sure you do that.
- 1:31But let me hit some highlights.
- 1:33As y'all know,
- 1:33we just went to Indiana.
- 1:35We are duplicating that exact same conference
- 1:38content.
- 1:39In New Jersey and that is going to be the middle of October,
- 1:42which means you have like a month and a half.
- 1:45So if you have been thinking about coming to a live event with me,
- 1:48if you've been thinking about getting deeper CCPT coaching,
- 1:52if you have been thinking about
- 1:54getting CEs.
- 1:56New Jersey is going to be your next opportunity
- 1:58and we still have early bird pricing going.
- 2:01Y'all,
- 2:01the Indiana event,
- 2:02I've already mentioned it,
- 2:03but it was so
- 2:05full and rich of
- 2:07connection and community,
- 2:08and I mean you really feel like you're around your people and it was just
- 2:13such an incredible time to be together and do CCPT for a weekend,
- 2:17so.
- 2:17I would love to have you and you might as well save money and do the early bird stuff.
- 2:21So make sure that you check that out.
- 2:23You can again,
- 2:24playtherapynow.com is where you can find out about that.
- 2:27My husband just released a book.
- 2:31I know.
- 2:32He's not the author of the family,
- 2:33but he is now.
- 2:35So,
- 2:35I'm ready to launch my 3rd book,
- 2:36by the way.
- 2:37Uh,
- 2:37details to follow on that.
- 2:38We're like actually
- 2:40getting proof copies of my 3rd book that's gonna be launching soon.
- 2:44So,
- 2:44we'll,
- 2:45we'll update you as that becomes available,
- 2:47but seriously,
- 2:47my husband just published a book
- 2:50called Happily Ever Asperger,
- 2:51and I will talk more about this in a later episode,
- 2:54but I just wanna let you all know.
- 2:56If you are working with children and their families on the spectrum,
- 2:59specifically very high functioning
- 3:02neurodivergent children,
- 3:04this is a window into
- 3:07the mind and the way of thinking and the neurodivergence
- 3:11in a child with Asperger's slash high functioning autism.
- 3:14I know technically they've done away with that diagnosis,
- 3:17but
- 3:17it's
- 3:18very relevant because it is distinct and different from
- 3:22other types of autism.
- 3:23So,
- 3:24It is
- 3:25a really helpful book for parents.
- 3:27It is a helpful book for us as therapists because I think sometimes we even struggle
- 3:31to relate to children on the spectrum from a neurotypical standpoint.
- 3:37So,
- 3:37you and or your parents,
- 3:39if you would like a little peek into the
- 3:42brain of a high functioning child with autism.
- 3:45Happily Ever Asperger is the title of it.
- 3:47A huge nod to my dad because
- 3:49he made a pun and that
- 3:51titled the book.
- 3:52So,
- 3:53Happily Ever Asperger,
- 3:54it is.
- 3:55It is on Amazon.
- 3:56If you want to order it,
- 3:57if you wanna talk to us or ask us questions,
- 4:00please reach out
- 4:01and Eric and I are happy to communicate about the book,
- 4:04but
- 4:04I'm very,
- 4:05very proud of that book.
- 4:06It is so helpful.
- 4:08Several people have read it and talked about how
- 4:10much insight and perspective it gave them.
- 4:13So that's been really exciting.
- 4:15And then finally,
- 4:17if you all have been sitting around thinking about coaching,
- 4:20I've been harping on coaching lately and I try to keep the podcast very
- 4:24teaching and,
- 4:25and valuable in content that I put out.
- 4:28But y'all,
- 4:29I've just been bombarded lately with people
- 4:32asking questions and feeling confused and,
- 4:34and doubting and not understanding and what should I do and how does this work?
- 4:38And I have no idea if I'm on track and
- 4:41Please do not struggle
- 4:42without putting yourself in a position where you have
- 4:44a mentor to help you know what to do.
- 4:47If you have confidence and competence,
- 4:50you will be effective at child-centered play therapy.
- 4:53So if you've been wondering what the next step is,
- 4:55it might be coaching.
- 4:55I have a Play Therapy Pro group starting.
- 4:57I have a Six-Figure group starting.
- 4:59One is for private practice business and then one is just clinical.
- 5:03If you're kind of on the fence and you don't really know what your next step is,
- 5:06please again reach out.
- 5:07Go to playtherapynow.com.
- 5:08There's all kinds of stuff about it on there too.
- 5:11I don't want y'all to feel like you're out there by yourselves,
- 5:15floundering in the sea and you just have no life rafts around you.
- 5:20There are all kinds of life rafts.
- 5:21You just have to find the right connections.
- 5:24So,
- 5:25please don't feel like this is too hard to do on your own.
- 5:28It is too hard to do on your own,
- 5:30but you don't have to do it alone.
- 5:31So,
- 5:32make sure that you're putting yourself in touch
- 5:34with people that can support and help you.
- 5:36And if coaching might be one of those steps,
- 5:38I've got a group starting real soon for PT Pro and another one starting in a few weeks
- 5:42for Six-Figure.
- 5:44So,
- 5:44let me know if I can help you.
- 5:45That's why I coach.
- 5:47And that's what this is all about.
- 5:49It's bringing together CCPTs from all over the world
- 5:52so that we can support and grow together.
- 5:54That's the vision.
- 5:55So,
- 5:57That those are my housekeeping updates for now.
- 5:59More to come,
- 5:59I'm sure,
- 6:00but
- 6:01all right,
- 6:01let me read you parts of Dovi's email and then we will dive in together.
- 6:05I'm working with an 11 year old boy who keeps making remarks to the effect
- 6:08that I surely don't want to spend time with him.
- 6:10I'd rather be doing something else.
- 6:12I'm only in it for the money.
- 6:14My compliments are meaningless because I probably give them to all of my clients,
- 6:18etc.
- 6:19He's a smart kid and can carry a rational conversation,
- 6:22and I think would also get especially annoyed
- 6:24if I did tracking or reflecting for everything
- 6:27without responding directly to the content.
- 6:30How would you deal with this from a CCPT perspective?
- 6:33All right.
- 6:34I'm excited about this because
- 6:36this is
- 6:38a very common dilemma.
- 6:40So let's start with
- 6:41the comments.
- 6:43We know that kids are not verbal
- 6:45nor rational,
- 6:47don't have abstract reasoning.
- 6:49Not cognitively wired.
- 6:52So if an 11 year old
- 6:53is saying something,
- 6:55We need to note that it's important.
- 6:59Actually,
- 6:59anytime any age child says something,
- 7:01we know that it's important,
- 7:02but we recognize that like 13 and up,
- 7:05they're going to naturally be more conversational.
- 7:08They're going to naturally be more verbal.
- 7:1112 and under,
- 7:12they're not.
- 7:13So when a child says something.
- 7:16There is substance there.
- 7:17There is significance.
- 7:19A child doesn't bring something up verbally
- 7:22when they can play it out
- 7:23unless they absolutely feel like it's necessary.
- 7:26So when you get comments like that,
- 7:28you don't want to spend time with me,
- 7:30you probably would rather be doing something else.
- 7:32You're just in this for the money.
- 7:34You don't actually mean your compliments because you
- 7:36give them to all of your clients.
- 7:38OK,
- 7:38we recognize
- 7:39those sentences as charged
- 7:42and loaded,
- 7:44and there's more to the story.
- 7:47Let's be very clear.
- 7:48I've been talking about this a lot lately to y'all.
- 7:50My whole life goes in waves.
- 7:52I'm just,
- 7:53I'm just riding one wave after another of the consistency of what comes into
- 7:57my world.
- 7:58So right now what's been coming into my world
- 8:01is
- 8:02the focus on.
- 8:04There's always more.
- 8:07Than what is
- 8:09at first glance
- 8:11evident
- 8:12in a play session.
- 8:12In other words,
- 8:13when a kid says something like that,
- 8:15there's more,
- 8:15and you want to know what the more almost always is,
- 8:18like 95% of the time,
- 8:20the more is their junk.
- 8:23So Dovi,
- 8:23when this kid is saying this to you,
- 8:25you don't want to spend time with me.
- 8:28Let's
- 8:29unpack that.
- 8:30Why would a child say that
- 8:32when it's their junk?
- 8:34It's very easy to
- 8:36see low self-esteem,
- 8:38very easy to see
- 8:40lack of identity,
- 8:41low self-concept,
- 8:43low self-worth,
- 8:45probably ideal versus actual.
- 8:48I ideally,
- 8:49I want you to
- 8:51want to spend time with me,
- 8:52but actually,
- 8:53you might not.
- 8:54So,
- 8:55all kinds of wrestling,
- 8:56you did not say how many sessions you've had.
- 8:59This might be early on in the process.
- 9:01In fact,
- 9:01my gut tells me it probably is early on in the process.
- 9:04Why?
- 9:04Because that kind of statement can also be the junk related to relational
- 9:08connection.
- 9:10If this kid barely knows you.
- 9:13And is trying to build connection and relationship with you.
- 9:17They're going to question.
- 9:19Is this real?
- 9:22Is this relationship valid?
- 9:24Does this person actually care about me?
- 9:28Those are all questions that we naturally process when we meet someone and
- 9:32determine if we want to have any kind of relationship with them.
- 9:36So that also aligns to the junk and the why.
- 9:39I want to believe this is true,
- 9:41but can I actually,
- 9:43I want to trust you,
- 9:44but can I actually?
- 9:45I want to think that you actually like me,
- 9:48but I don't really think that I'm that likable,
- 9:50so can those things coexist?
- 9:53So these kinds of statements,
- 9:55while we can get caught up in
- 9:58answering them or not answering them or trying to avoid
- 10:01what the question,
- 10:02uh,
- 10:03I mean,
- 10:03there's all kinds of CCPT oh,
- 10:05you're wondering if I'd rather spend time with someone else or,
- 10:08oh,
- 10:08you think that I give these
- 10:10compliments to everybody.
- 10:12We can do the dance
- 10:13of the CCPT skills
- 10:15of not answering questions and reflecting content and,
- 10:19you know,
- 10:19acknowledging what's going on,
- 10:20narrative summary,
- 10:21all that.
- 10:22But
- 10:23at the core of what this is,
- 10:25it's the kid's junk.
- 10:27So it's actually more helpful for us to identify it for what it is,
- 10:31recognize it as the work that the child needs to do.
- 10:34And then rest and trust the process.
- 10:37Because Joy,
- 10:38your response to that,
- 10:39so the kid says,
- 10:40I know you'd rather be doing something else than,
- 10:43than being here with me.
- 10:44Oh,
- 10:45you think that I'd rather be somewhere else.
- 10:46OK,
- 10:47we're gonna reflect the content.
- 10:49And then
- 10:51statement of fact.
- 10:53But I'm here playing with you.
- 10:57If you want to
- 10:59acknowledge your own experience,
- 11:01oh,
- 11:02you think that I'd rather be somewhere else,
- 11:04but I'd actually rather be right here.
- 11:08So,
- 11:08we couple what the content is with statement of fact.
- 11:11We're not trying to dissuade the child from thinking or feeling that.
- 11:14We're not trying to
- 11:15argue.
- 11:16We're not trying to have any kind of confrontation
- 11:18about it because we don't believe that it's true.
- 11:21We reflect content and then we make a statement of fact.
- 11:26As far as
- 11:27you think this child can carry on a rational conversation.
- 11:31Unlikely
- 11:33The child's 11
- 11:35And
- 11:36just because the child presents as verbal,
- 11:38just because the child presents as articulate,
- 11:41just because the child presents as articulate,
- 11:41just because the child presents as rational,
- 11:45He's 11,
- 11:46so
- 11:47developmentally
- 11:48it is
- 11:49cognitively impossible for him to have abstract reasoning yet.
- 11:54So
- 11:54I doubt that he's carrying on a rational conversation,
- 11:57although it probably presents like it,
- 12:00which is actually probably maladaptive coping.
- 12:03So here's another layer
- 12:04we see his junk in the comments that he's making
- 12:07now.
- 12:07We see his junk in the fact that he's presenting
- 12:10as so much more mature
- 12:12and logical and rational than he actually is even capable of being.
- 12:16Also,
- 12:17maladaptive coping,
- 12:19also probably faking good,
- 12:21also probably presenting differently to not be vulnerable.
- 12:25OK,
- 12:26so there's all kinds of junk there too.
- 12:29And then Dovey,
- 12:30your response,
- 12:30I think that he would get annoyed if I tracked
- 12:33and reflected everything without responding directly to the content.
- 12:36I agree.
- 12:37A child that's going to argue with you and confront
- 12:40and
- 12:41have some pessimism or
- 12:43some lack of trust in the process.
- 12:47Absolutely.
- 12:48There's going to be a desire to have an actual conversation.
- 12:51I mean,
- 12:52let's quote D Ray for a second.
- 12:54Don't be weird in the playroom.
- 12:57So it is weird
- 12:58for a kid to say,
- 13:00I know you don't want to spend time with me.
- 13:03Oh,
- 13:04you don't
- 13:05think that I want to spend time with you.
- 13:08Yeah,
- 13:08you don't,
- 13:08do you?
- 13:09Oh,
- 13:10you're wondering.
- 13:11Yeah,
- 13:12well,
- 13:12why aren't you answering my question?
- 13:13You're really curious.
- 13:15Yeah,
- 13:15and see,
- 13:16this is just proving it because you won't answer,
- 13:17oh,
- 13:18you think that you're proving that I don't wanna spend.
- 13:20I mean,
- 13:20that's weird.
- 13:21That is a weird conversation.
- 13:24So
- 13:25there's absolutely a component of finding the balance
- 13:29between being adherent to the model,
- 13:31but also recognizing
- 13:33that kids are often unsatisfied
- 13:36when we just don't give them any kind of response to what they're saying.
- 13:42So often if a kid
- 13:44is asking questions or wanting to have conversation,
- 13:48we respond appropriately.
- 13:50We don't bogart the conversation.
- 13:52We don't take over.
- 13:53We don't insert content.
- 13:55We don't make it about what we think or feel.
- 13:58We're very much still allowing the child to lead,
- 14:01but if a child asks a direct question,
- 14:03it's important to figure out where is it coming from.
- 14:06Is it rooted in the child's junk?
- 14:08That's totally different than if it's
- 14:10relational.
- 14:12For example,
- 14:13kid says,
- 14:15Why do you even
- 14:16play with me?
- 14:18It's a valid question.
- 14:20Why do you play with me?
- 14:23We have a couple of options.
- 14:25We can say,
- 14:26oh,
- 14:27you're wondering why I play with you.
- 14:29But
- 14:30I love to play with kids.
- 14:33OK.
- 14:34Reflection of content,
- 14:36fact,
- 14:37statement.
- 14:40The other option is
- 14:41reflect content
- 14:43and see if that satisfies the child.
- 14:46Oh,
- 14:46you're wondering why I play with kids.
- 14:49Some kids are not going to push anymore.
- 14:51This kid 100% will,
- 14:53but some kids won't.
- 14:55So sometimes that's enough.
- 14:57Another option is we realize that it's the child's junk.
- 15:00He's not actually asking why you play with kids.
- 15:03He's saying,
- 15:03do you actually enjoy being here with me?
- 15:05Is there anything redeeming about me?
- 15:07Because I don't really think so.
- 15:09And I don't think anyone wants to spend time with me.
- 15:11So the fact that you act like you want to spend time with me,
- 15:13I think this is crazy,
- 15:14and I think this is all made up and fake
- 15:16because this is my own junk that I'm carrying around.
- 15:20Ah,
- 15:20well,
- 15:20now we understand the motivation is much deeper.
- 15:24So then we're going to change our response a little bit because we,
- 15:26we recognize that this is the child's work.
- 15:30Oh
- 15:32You wonder
- 15:33why I play with you.
- 15:35But I enjoy when you come and play with me.
- 15:40I like spending time with you.
- 15:47Those are very powerful statements of truth
- 15:50to a child.
- 15:51We're not helping them to.
- 15:54Change their opinion,
- 15:56they're still going to think it's weird.
- 15:59But it's also their junk.
- 16:01And the beauty of this is because this happens all the time.
- 16:04This is not an outlier kind of scenario.
- 16:06Kids are going to say this all the time.
- 16:08I had a kid,
- 16:105 year old twin,
- 16:11the girl,
- 16:12it was fraternal twins.
- 16:13I had the girl in my playroom.
- 16:15I'm in on my stool,
- 16:17she's on the floor right in front of me,
- 16:18and she's playing with stuff and she just kind of looks up out of the blue
- 16:21and says,
- 16:23Is this like your job?
- 16:26And I said,
- 16:27oh,
- 16:27you're curious if this is what I do for my job.
- 16:30And she's like,
- 16:30yeah,
- 16:30like I mean,
- 16:31do you like play with kids for a job?
- 16:34And I was like,
- 16:34oh man,
- 16:35you're really curious if this is actually my job.
- 16:37I play with kids all day long.
- 16:40Notice that I gave a statement of fact without answering the question.
- 16:42I didn't say whether it was my job or not.
- 16:45I just said I play with kids all day long.
- 16:48And then she kind of looks down for a second and then looks back up and says,
- 16:51Oh,
- 16:51I feel so bad for you.
- 16:54And
- 16:55I did not expect that response.
- 16:56And so I actually laughed like before I could even
- 17:00register what she said.
- 17:01It just was an organic laugh.
- 17:02So I kind of went
- 17:04and she says,
- 17:05you just have to sit and watch kids play.
- 17:08That's so boring.
- 17:11Now,
- 17:12notice that she said I feel so bad for you and
- 17:14it was actually like she thought I must hate it.
- 17:18So the accusation wasn't that I was fake or that I was in it for the money or whatever.
- 17:22She actually had empathy for me.
- 17:23Like,
- 17:24what an awful reality that you must have that you just have to sit and watch kids.
- 17:28It's so boring for you.
- 17:30And I'm sitting in my head going,
- 17:31Sweetie,
- 17:31you have no idea.
- 17:32This is the best job in the world.
- 17:34But
- 17:34notice that I just said,
- 17:36I play with kids all day.
- 17:37That was enough of an answer
- 17:39without actually answering the question.
- 17:41Then it got to what she wanted to say,
- 17:43which was essentially,
- 17:45Man,
- 17:45sucks for you.
- 17:48And then I just said,
- 17:49oh,
- 17:49you think it would be so boring to just watch kids play every day,
- 17:53and then she moved on.
- 17:56So we engage enough
- 17:58is kind of the moral of this.
- 17:59We engage enough.
- 18:00We don't take over.
- 18:02We don't make the content ours.
- 18:05We don't lead,
- 18:06we don't push.
- 18:07We just follow where the child is.
- 18:09We give enough information so that it doesn't feel awkward to the child,
- 18:13but
- 18:14the caveat to that statement is
- 18:16we do not cave and share information just to rescue the kid from their feelings.
- 18:21So if the kid is demanding an answer,
- 18:24I mean,
- 18:25will not give in,
- 18:27will not let up,
- 18:28you have to tell me,
- 18:30insistent demand,
- 18:31that's their junk,
- 18:33you're never gonna answer that question.
- 18:37Because we have to recognize what is the root
- 18:41of what's going on for the child.
- 18:42And in this case,
- 18:43it's very,
- 18:44very low self-esteem,
- 18:45very low self-worth.
- 18:47So
- 18:48that's going to be
- 18:49the lens through which we interact and we use our skills.
- 18:54We can really highlight encouragement and esteem
- 18:56building and choice giving with this child
- 18:58because we recognize this 11 year old boy really does not think highly of himself.
- 19:03So we can use skills in child-centered play therapy that will help build those
- 19:08concepts for that little boy.
- 19:10So Dovi,
- 19:11thank you so much for the email.
- 19:12I hope that that was helpful to all of you,
- 19:14and I hope that you will go to playtherapynow.com and
- 19:16check out all the stuff that I mentioned at the beginning.
- 19:18I love y'all.
- 19:19We'll talk again soon.
- 19:20Bye.
- 19:21Thank you for listening to the Play Therapy Podcast with Dr.
- 19:24Brenna Hicks.
- 19:25For more episodes and resources,
- 19:27please go to www.playtherapypodcast.com.