Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Pygmalion Effect Shapes Your Office Reputation
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a famous experiment from the 1960s where researchers told elementary school teachers that a handful of randomly chosen students were about to experience a growth spurt in their learning. A few months later, those randomly picked kids actually scored higher on IQ tests than their peers. Luna: Wait, the teachers weren't told they were random, right? They were told those kids were special. Lucas: Exactly. The researchers, Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson, had just given the kids a normal IQ test, then pulled names out of a hat and labeled them as 'late bloomers' of learning. The teachers thought those kids were about to take off, so they unconsciously gave them more attention, more encouragement, more challenging material. And the kids rose to that expectation. Luna: That's the Pygmalion effect, right? Higher expectations lead to better performance. Lucas: That's it. And the flip side is the Golem effect, where low expectations can depress performance. But the Pygmalion effect is the one that's been replicated in workplaces for decades. It's one of the most consistent findings in organizational psychology. Luna: But does it really hold up in an office? Teachers are with kids all day. Managers have limited touchpoints. Lucas: It does, and the effects can be just as strong. There's a classic study from the 1970s with naval officers, but more recently, researchers have looked at software engineering teams. They found that when a manager labels a developer as a 'high performer' — even when that label is random — that developer gets more detailed code review feedback. And their subsequent performance improves more than peers with identical skills. Luna: So the label itself changes the way the manager interacts with the person, which then changes the person's actual output. Lucas: Exactly. The manager doesn't say anything explicitly. They just pay more attention, offer more constructive criticism, give that person more interesting projects. The employee feels trusted, works harder, and the prophecy becomes real. Luna: So if I want to be seen as a high performer, I just need to convince my boss I am one? Lucas: It's not that simple, but there's a kernel of truth. You need to signal the traits that bosses associate with high potential: curiosity, reliability, a learning mindset. If your boss believes you're someone who can grow, they'll invest more in you, and you'll grow faster. It's a virtuous cycle. Luna: But what if your boss has already pegged you as average? Can you change that narrative? Lucas: It's harder, but not impossible. One tactic is to intentionally ask for harder assignments in a way that signals confidence, like 'I'd like to take a crack at that client presentation.' The key is to give your boss a reason to update their expectation. But it takes consistent effort, because the default is to keep seeing you as they've always seen you. Luna: That's the anchoring effect, which we covered a few weeks ago, but with a different twist. Lucas: Right, and the Pygmalion effect is one of the reasons those anchors are so sticky. The boss's first impression becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, not just in their mind, but in your actual performance. Luna: Is there a dark side to this? I mean, can a manager use expectations to manipulate someone into overworking? Lucas: Absolutely, and that's an ethical tightrope. A manager who sets unrealistically high expectations can create chronic stress and burnout. The Pygmalion effect works best when expectations are high but still perceived as attainable. If the goal feels impossible, it backfires — you get learned helplessness instead of motivation. Luna: So what's the sweet spot for a manager? How do you set expectations without becoming a tyrant? Lucas: The research suggests two things. First, you need to genuinely believe the person can meet the bar — not just say it. Because your nonverbal cues, your tone, your follow-up questions, they all leak your true belief. Second, you need to pair the high expectation with support: clear feedback, resources, coaching. It's not enough to say 'you can do it' and walk away. Luna: That makes sense. But let's go back to the employee side. What if you're on the receiving end of low expectations? How do you break that cycle? Lucas: One approach is to overdeliver on a small, visible win. Pick a task that's outside your usual scope, something your boss has been avoiding, and nail it. That gives them a concrete piece of evidence that contradicts their old belief. It's not enough to do a good job on routine work, because that just confirms what they already think. Luna: So it's about changing the narrative, not just the output. Lucas: Exactly. And here's a practical tip: when you're asked to do something, don't just say 'sure.' Say something like 'I'd love to take that on. Here's how I'd approach it.' That signals foresight and motivation, which are exactly the traits that make a manager think 'this person has potential.' Luna: I like that. It's proactive, not passive. Lucas: It's also worth remembering that the Pygmalion effect applies to teams, not just individuals. A manager who believes their whole team is top-tier will create a culture of high expectations. That can lift everyone, but it can also create a toxic environment if the bar is unrealistic. Luna: Right. I remember reading about a tech startup where the CEO constantly told everyone they were 'the best of the best' and then drove them into the ground with 80-hour weeks. That's the dark side. Lucas: That's a perfect example of the expectation trap. The belief was there, but the support wasn't. The employees felt the pressure but not the resources, so they burned out. The Pygmalion effect isn't a magic wand; it's a tool that needs to be wielded with care. Luna: So, on that note, I want to mention something that's been on my mind. We've been doing this show for a while, and we deliberately keep it ad-free. No sponsors, no interruptions. That's a choice, and it's one we're proud of. Lucas: It really is. And it's only possible because some listeners, who find the show useful, decide to support us. If you're one of those people and you want to keep the shows free of ads, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple gesture, but it genuinely keeps us going. No pressure, ever. We just appreciate that you're here. Lucas: And now, back to that startup example. What's interesting is that the Pygmalion effect can also work in reverse on a team level. If a manager believes the team is struggling, they might micromanage, which actually makes performance worse. It's a downward spiral. Luna: So the manager's mindset is really the linchpin. If they think the team can't handle a project, they'll interfere, and the team lives down to that expectation. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why one of the most valuable things a leader can do is cultivate a genuine belief in their people's potential. Not blind optimism, but a realistic, evidence-based confidence. That's what separates good managers from great ones. Luna: But what about the employee's own expectations? Does self-expectation play a role? Lucas: There's a related concept called the Galatea effect, where your own expectations about yourself influence your performance. If you believe you're capable, you're more likely to take on challenges and persist. So the Pygmalion effect from your boss and the Galatea effect from yourself can compound. Luna: So it's a two-way street. Your boss's belief can boost your self-belief, and your self-belief can boost your performance. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why it's so important to be aware of these dynamics. If you're a manager, you need to check your own biases. If you're an employee, you need to actively manage up to give your boss the right signals. Because left unchecked, the Pygmalion effect can silently create a hierarchy of haves and have-nots in any office. Luna: And it's not always fair. The kid who gets picked randomly in the classroom, the developer who gets the label by chance — they didn't do anything to deserve it. Lucas: That's the uncomfortable truth. But here's the good news: because the effect is driven by expectations, it's also something you can influence. You're not powerless. You can signal, you can ask for feedback, you can take on stretch assignments. The key is to be deliberate. Luna: So, as we wrap up, I'm thinking about remote work. How does the Pygmalion effect play out when your boss can't see you in the office? Lucas: That's a great question, and it's one we haven't fully figured out. In a remote setting, expectations are often communicated more through written feedback and deliverables, so there's less room for those subtle nonverbal cues. But that also means employees need to be even more proactive in signaling their potential, because the manager's mental model of you is built on less information. Luna: So the onus is on the employee to create visibility. Lucas: Exactly. And on managers to be intentional about setting and communicating expectations clearly, because they can't rely on the office grapevine. The Pygmalion effect doesn't disappear on Zoom, but it does change shape. And that's a whole other episode, I think. Luna: That's a good place to leave it. Thanks for listening, everyone.