Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / We Come in Peace? The Religion of Alien Conspiracy Theories (with Brian Dunning)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth Andrews. Brian Dunning
- 0:57is host of The Skeptoid podcast. He is an author of several books,
- 1:03and he has produced documentaries, including the latest one released in twenty twenty three,
- 1:08the UFO movie They That Would Want you to see. Brian Dunning,
- 1:14thanks for joining me. Thank you for having me. Finally, after all
- 1:17these many years, I read that your film was shown over at SETI.
- 1:22Now wait, is it Search for Extra Terrestrial Intelligence? Is that what said?
- 1:26I'm trying to remember what SETI. Yeah, but the SETI Institute,
- 1:30Yeah, that was that was definitely my I can't pronounce it, Tour de
- 1:34gras whatever However, you said, if there was one thing that the movie
- 1:38could have done that would have made me consider it a success was to have
- 1:42the SETI Institute use it as their movie night, which they did. You
- 1:46know, they're definitely one of the most respected research institutions in the world.
- 1:51Well, what's the vibe over there? I mean, I know that we're
- 1:55talking about scientists, right, They're not people with tinfoil hats looking up and
- 1:59going away. That dot in the sky moved there for intelligent life, right,
- 2:04and this is a legit organization, right, Yeah, there's I'm sure
- 2:07they consider their name kind of unfortunate. The SETI Institute is, although it
- 2:12stands for Search for Action Trestrial Intelligence, they're a research organization. There's over
- 2:15one hundred scientists doing grant funded projects there. Basically, what they do is
- 2:22any research that touches on any one of the variables in the Drake equation.
- 2:28So I was there one day and I met a lady who was studying whale
- 2:30language. And they do have the little room with the data coming in from
- 2:35the radio telescope looking for intelligent signals, but that's a very very small part
- 2:40of what they do. Now I've got to jump in here, Brian Drake
- 2:45equation was a hang up right now, just for a lot of people,
- 2:47you explain Drake equation if you went at a good point. The Drake equation
- 2:52by Frank Drake, God, when did you come up with that? Probably
- 2:54the sixties or seventies. Is basically seven variables to give us the probable number
- 3:00of intelligent civilizations that we might be able to get in touch with. And
- 3:07Frank himself described it as a way to organize our ignorance because our guesses on
- 3:13most of these seven variables are just wild guesses because we don't just have enough
- 3:19data yet. We need really the next generation of space telescope to answer more
- 3:23of these variables. But there are things like what's the average lifetime of a
- 3:27star times what's the average number of planets that a star might have, times
- 3:31what's the average lifespan of a civilization? Times how many planets are likely to
- 3:37develop life. It's kind of all of those things, and you put them
- 3:39all together because you would need all of these things to happen in order for
- 3:44there to be a possibly intelligent civilization. Okay, so someone who is a
- 3:49I guess I need to come back to this UFO versus Alien's question, I'm
- 3:53going to put that here amount of file that away for just a second.
- 3:57But they're looking at you, going why, Brian, like, where did
- 4:01this whole interest of yours come from? Why are you qualified? How would
- 4:05you answer that? So I'm basically a science writer, and what we do
- 4:10at Skeptoid Media is our specialty is any topic where there's a lot of public
- 4:15misinformation that needs to be corrected, and our mission is to correct that,
- 4:20hopefully in a way that's positive and that adds something to the conversation rather than
- 4:26just being grumpy and telling people their ghost isn't real. So when we finished
- 4:30our last documentary film, Science Friction, which was in twenty twenty two,
- 4:34then it was time to start our next one, and we just asked,
- 4:38Okay, what are the hot topics right now? What's going to do well?
- 4:41Because it's something that a lot of people are thinking about, And kind
- 4:44of the obvious answer to that was UFOs. With these government hearings and everything
- 4:48happening these past few years, it's been a very hot topic. So that's
- 4:51why we directed our science writing and science education horsepower such as it is to
- 4:59this particular topic. There was a gallop pole. I think this has been
- 5:02two or three years that said four out of ten Americans believe in UFOs.
- 5:09I find the survey question problematic and I'm going to have you speak to this
- 5:14because UFO unidentified flying object. I think are they using EAP or is it
- 5:20the same thing? Aerial something? What is it? Yeah, the the
- 5:26UFO people tried to get the government to switch to you successfully tried to get
- 5:30the government to start using the term UAP instead of UFO for no reason other
- 5:35than the stigma associated with UFO. Well, aep must be a film company
- 5:41or say I have aep AM. I going to make that switch. Sorry,
- 5:45I'm going to use a little white out as I give away my age.
- 5:47But it's funny because people saying, I believe in a UFO, But
- 5:51if you is unidentified, what do they believe in? I believe in something
- 5:56that has not been properly identified. So are they conflating UFOs and aliens?
- 6:01I think most people when most people who are into this topic talk about UFOs,
- 6:08they mean alien spaceships. They will often say that they don't necessarily mean
- 6:13that if cornered, because you know, that's kind of a tough one.
- 6:15To defend. But when you say do people believe in UFOs, you're usually
- 6:20really asking do you believe in alien visitation to Earth? Because I mean believing
- 6:26in UFOs, that's just a question of do you believe that sometimes people see
- 6:29things in the sky they can't identify. Well, of course, yes,
- 6:31that happens every day, So we all believe in UFOs in the literal sense
- 6:36of the question. So you've got to look at what they're really asking with
- 6:40the question. Interesting too, it seems to be people consider it binary.
- 6:46So if I have skepticism about certain UFO claims, they think I'm saying that
- 6:53there's no life out there. Yeah, for some reason, one cannot exist
- 6:57without the other in their minds. Yeah, yeah, I get that a
- 7:00lot. There's a lot of kind of straw man arguments against the skeptical perspective
- 7:05on this, and that's that's one of the most common. For sure,
- 7:09no aliens have ever visited the Earth. You're saying, Oh, you're saying
- 7:12that nobody that there's no life in space. You're saying that nobody's ever seen
- 7:15anything they can't identify. It's just kind of a bunch of tiresome straw man
- 7:19arguments. So if they're watching the documentary the UFO movie they don't want you
- 7:25to see, they would be surprised that as you're speaking with actual scientists,
- 7:30cosmologists, etc. They think there almost certainly is something life out there in
- 7:36some way. That was your experience in your interviews. Yes, yeah,
- 7:41certainly. I mean you can talk to you can talk to a million astronomers
- 7:46and you'll get a million different answers on there probably aren't a million astronomers,
- 7:49good question. I don't know. You'll get a lot of different answers on
- 7:53how much life they think there is in the universe and whether any of it
- 7:58is intelligent. You'll get anything from there's probably very little life out there and
- 8:01probably none of it is intelligent, to there's probably intelligent civilizations everywhere and everything
- 8:07in between. But these are all just guesses because we don't have the data
- 8:13yet, because we can't yet resolve exoplanetary atmospheric spectra, and that's what we
- 8:18need to do before we'll be able to say, oh, there's a lot
- 8:22of planets that have, you know, water in their atmospheres and things like
- 8:24that. You know, what blows my mind is this idea that maybe we
- 8:28can't even conceive of what that life would look like. I mean beyond like
- 8:33the Tar, the Black Tar in next generation. I'm just saying, you
- 8:37know, it's possible that we our brains can't even fathom what that life might
- 8:43look like or sound like, or act like. I don't know. Do
- 8:46you get all kind of like what if about what if? In your brain?
- 8:50Oh? Sure? I remember when I was a little kid, I
- 8:54was terrified of aliens, and I thought aliens might come into my room at
- 8:58night. And I knew that whenever I saw one, it would be such
- 9:01a horrifying site that it would just terrify the living hell out of me.
- 9:05And it's weird. I don't know when I lost that. But now,
- 9:07I mean, I don't care what the alien would look like. I wouldn't
- 9:09be afraid of it at all, unless, of course, it was roaring
- 9:13and growling and running at me at high speed with large teeth and a laser
- 9:16knife of some kind. Now you bring something up, though, Brian,
- 9:20I'm going to jump in quickly. I just referenced Trek. I am actually
- 9:24listening to an audio book about the last half century of Star Trek. It's
- 9:28called The Fifty Year Mission and they were speaking about the arrival of Trek in
- 9:33the late sixties. This was on the heels of the fifties. We've got
- 9:37the Cold War, the nuclear race, so sci fi and this idea of
- 9:41aliens extra terrestrials. During the mid twentieth century, it was almost universally,
- 9:48they're coming to destroy us, and they're going to probe us, and they're
- 9:52all monsters. And then that began to shift finally into maybe if they're not
- 9:58of this earth, they still might be friendly. Have you sort of gotten
- 10:03into the cultural shifts and the thinking about UFOs, extra terrestrials, etc.
- 10:09Probably not as much as I should have. It's the context is super important
- 10:15in almost any story you're looking into. When you look at what people believed
- 10:20in nineteen hundred, something that we would consider a crazy belief now was not
- 10:24a crazy belief then. It was very common. Things like you know,
- 10:28MK Ultra and these these programs where the government was having research done that we
- 10:33would consider incredibly unethical today was perfectly ethical by the standards of the day.
- 10:41And the belief in UFOs has changed. So when you talk about what people
- 10:46thought when they first heard the Roswell story, when it got reported in you
- 10:50know nineteen forty seven was only in the news for a couple of days until
- 10:56twenty five years later. You have to know what was the cultural vibe on
- 11:01UFOs at the time and aliens, And at the time it was, you
- 11:05know, little green men in flying saucers, and the government often used that
- 11:11as an excuse whenever someone saw something they weren't supposed to see, they would
- 11:15say, Oh, it was just a flying saucer, don't worry about it.
- 11:18I'm interested in Roswell. We talked about this on the show. It's
- 11:22been like ten years. Can you flesh it out for those of my listeners
- 11:26born after a certain year who are not roswell literate. In the forties there
- 11:33was an incident that sort of sparked what has become is that eighty years of
- 11:39roswell interest and tourism and more. Can you show me the foundation of roswell?
- 11:46Yeah, I mean what happened was a very small event. A weather
- 11:50balloon train, which is a weather balloon with a bunch of different sensors hanging
- 11:56belowed over a very long line which is designed to detect nuclear tests. You'd
- 12:01have these very low frequency waves that would go around the world, and you
- 12:05would need these very long antennas to detect them up in the atmosphere. And
- 12:09so that was the purpose of these balloon trains. And one came down in
- 12:11a guy's ranch and he rode out and saw this weird tinfoil and balsa wood
- 12:16wreckage and didn't know what it was and called his friend the sheriff, and
- 12:22the sheriff called the guy from Roswell Army Airfield at the time, and they
- 12:26came and they and they took it, and someone told the news in there
- 12:31somehow, and the news reported as was their habit at the deck time,
- 12:35a flying saucer was recovered, which was just a cover story because it was
- 12:39a common thing. It was all over you know, science fiction and stuff,
- 12:43kind of a pop culture thing. And then a couple of days later
- 12:50they corrected that and they said, no, it was just this weather balloon
- 12:52thing from Roswell Army Airfield. Nerman goes on, that's the end of it,
- 12:56and that was the end of it until the nineteen seventies when the National
- 13:01Inquirer was looking for a shocking story, and so one of their writers,
- 13:07this guy named Stamton Friedman, dug up these old headlines and managed to find
- 13:11someone who had worked in Roswell at that time in nineteen forty seven and interviewed
- 13:18him. And this guy just kind of geez, I don't remember what that
- 13:20was a hell of a long time ago. And he said, what about
- 13:24this? What about this? And they just kind of strung together all of
- 13:26these events that had nothing to do with each other, and that had happened
- 13:30over a period of several years in Roswell, things like a plane had crashed
- 13:35and three guys had been killed in it. Another case where there was a
- 13:39small epidemic of I'm forgetting what in the town and a number of children died
- 13:46and they had to have small coffins, so things like this, and there
- 13:50was a red haired colonel who yelled at everyone. And Stanton Friedman just kind
- 13:54of wove together all of these events and reorganized them as if they'd all happened
- 14:01at the same time and wrote it up for the National Inquirer, and other
- 14:05UFO authors jumped on it, and before you knew it, the literature was
- 14:09full of books on the Roswell alien visitation, the crashed flying saucer with the
- 14:15alien bodies recovered. It all boils down to the Fox Mulder poster. I
- 14:18want to believe, doesn't it. I mean, they just they want to
- 14:22believe. I would love to go to Roswell just to visit the gift shops.
- 14:26There's a cheap ass sort of gas station gift shops with a I don't
- 14:31know why I find that really charming, but it has provided a kind of
- 14:37touristy identity for the region beyond the military base. And then you got the
- 14:41people, these crusaders that go to the fenced line of a guarded, secure
- 14:46military establishment and say let us in, and they are denied access, and
- 14:52that then becomes priers at fifty one. And don't confuse Area fifty one with
- 14:56Roswell. They're two very different places, very far apart. Cave me then,
- 15:00because I do conclate them in my mind. Area fifty one in Roswell
- 15:03are different, had nothing to do with each other. Yeah. Area fifty
- 15:07one is in Nevada and Roswell is in New Mexico. And Area fifty one
- 15:13is the National Classified Test Facility actually has a different name now. It's changed
- 15:16its name a number of times over the years. There's never been anything secret
- 15:20about it. Everyone's always known that it's there. It's on all the maps.
- 15:24There's a runway that's on all the aviation charts. People have landed their
- 15:28planes there, and yeah, it's part of Nellis Air Force Base, and
- 15:31so it's got that fence surrounding it. You're not allowed to cross that fence.
- 15:35I did go there one time with a couple of buddies. We drove
- 15:39there late one night, where there are probably eleven or twelve o'clock at night.
- 15:43And it's kind of fun because the sort of the mythology of the day,
- 15:48this was two thousand and one, this was shortly before nine to eleven.
- 15:52The mythology of the day said that there would be these unmarked security guards,
- 15:56security guards and uniforms with no marking on them, which are probably private
- 16:00security. They're probably not part of the Air Force, and they drive around
- 16:04in these white jeep Cherokees in the hills. And sure enough, while we
- 16:10were there, a white jeep Cherokee up on the hillside above us took his
- 16:12spotlight and just started kind of harassing us with the spotlight, just shining it
- 16:18back and forth across us like that. And we were outside the fence,
- 16:22so we were perfectly legal. We weren't doing anything, and I was just
- 16:26kind of digging the experiences, kind of from a legend tripping perspective. But
- 16:30one of our guys completely freaked out and was terrified and we had to leave.
- 16:37Still to come with Brian Dunning of the Skeptoid podcast our UFO conspiracy theorists
- 16:45stupid. I'm going to ask him next. I had been invited to speak
- 16:57and do a workshop next t mom that the Secular Student Alliance National Conference in
- 17:03Saint Lewis. That's June sixteenth through the eighteenth. If you want to find
- 17:08out more about the SSA conference, along with all of my other speaking engagements
- 17:15around the country and into Canada, go to Seth Andrews dot com slash events.
- 17:22Talking here with Brian Dunning. He is host of the Skeptoid podcast.
- 17:26I hope I'm not the only one who has just now learned what I had
- 17:32I guess incorrectly believed. I always thought Area fifty one was in New Mexico.
- 17:36I thought Roswell and Area fifty one were the same thing, like a
- 17:40lot of people think that. Education. See, we learn new things all
- 17:44the time. I'm taking the journey along with all of our viewers and listeners.
- 17:49We talk about life out there, intelligent life. Brian, I'm worried
- 17:53about intelligent life down here. You know what I'm saying UFO culture, And
- 18:00I don't want to be this way because you're talking to a guy who used
- 18:02to think that men had one fewer ribs than women because of Adam and Eve.
- 18:07Yet I never bothered to count. I'm saying, it just feels so
- 18:11stupid. But the UFO culture, a lot of the conspiracy that the wackier
- 18:15stuff just seems like I'll throw it at Are these people just stupid? No?
- 18:23No, And that's actually one of the major straw man arguments against my
- 18:29film. UFO true believers will watch five minutes of the film, they'll see
- 18:33that it's not what they were hoping it was. They'll stop watching and they'll
- 18:37go to the comments section and they'll just trash it. You're saying everyone is
- 18:41stupid and everyone's a liar. It's like, oh, well, point out
- 18:44where that is in the script and I'll edit it, because obviously I never
- 18:47say anything like that. You don't have to be stupid to be honestly fooled
- 18:52by a very convincing optical illusion. You don't have to be a liar to
- 18:56be fooled by something, you just have to be a human being. And
- 19:00we've all misperceived things, we're all wrong about some of the things that we
- 19:06believe. We're all easy to fool and that's just human. It's not stupid,
- 19:11and it's not lying. It's just being human. I think it's very
- 19:15important to separate because some skeptic people will They will say the UFO people are
- 19:22stupid. How can they still believe that that's incredibly stupid? No, it's
- 19:26not. And you're not going to be right if you just write off half
- 19:30the population as being incredibly stupid. I know that's a can of worms right
- 19:34there, but we won't. I get it. I wrote a book called
- 19:38Christianity made Me Talk like an idiot. But in the book I say I
- 19:44wasn't an idiot, I wasn't stupid. My IQ didn't change when I left
- 19:48the faith, but I held I had compartmentalized some kind of ridiculous ideas.
- 19:53I have found though, and you can back me up or correct me once
- 19:56again, Brian, since that seems to be your thing today. That intelligent
- 20:02people often are better at rationalizing the irrational, like they can sort of engineer
- 20:08the mechanisms where something that doesn't work actually works. Has that been your experience?
- 20:14I think you can probably draw draw some correlation. I mean, problem
- 20:18solving is basically the definition of intelligence, So to some degree, there's sort
- 20:22of an inherent truth to that. You know, it's really interesting to me
- 20:27to look at the demographics of belief in various weird things and belief in some
- 20:34version of UFOs or aliens. Alien visitation is something that cuts equally across all
- 20:40demographics. Conspiracy thinking is something that cuts equally across all demographics. There are
- 20:47certain populations where you can say people are slightly more or less likely to believe
- 20:51in this, but generally it's very evenly spread. So you can't say education
- 20:57necessarily makes you less likely to believe in a lot of things. Makes you
- 21:02less likely to believe in some things but not everything. Socioeconomic status, gender,
- 21:07race, these things are all correlated with different beliefs, but only to
- 21:11a very small degree. Really, these things humans are humans, and humans
- 21:15are likely to believe strange things. Interesting that I had met once a group
- 21:21of engineers. This was at a conference years and years and years ago,
- 21:25but they had a booth and it was engineers for nine to eleven Truth,
- 21:29and they believed that nine to eleven was a conspiracy and Bush was behind it
- 21:33and Building seven and Thermite and inside Job, etc. Really smart guys,
- 21:41and they were degreed professionals in the engineering profession, and yet they had sort
- 21:48of engineered this way that it happened. I don't know, It's like they
- 21:52got smarter themselves. I guess that's where I was going with that, Brian.
- 21:56But yeah, I mean, they're getting agin. Engineering does not confer
- 22:00immunity from strange beliefs. It really doesn't. But it's the nine to eleven
- 22:10truth thing is another thing that they did not come to that conclusion through rational
- 22:15analysis of engineering specifications. They came to that conclusion because it's a conspiracy theory
- 22:21that clicks very nicely with their worldview. And it's often been pointed out that
- 22:26nine to eleven Truth and the alien visitation movement, these things are really indistinguishable
- 22:32from religions. You know, they all have their judgment day, they all
- 22:34have their profits. So we're really talking of religious belief when we talk about
- 22:40nine to eleven truth and the alien truthers, as I call the people who
- 22:44insist on believing that aliens actively visit the earth and the government's covering it up.
- 22:48They're religious beliefs. They didn't reason themselves into it. You can't reason
- 22:52them out of it. All right, Well, let me let me jump
- 22:55into that, because I'm not a huge fan of that line. You can't
- 23:00reason someone out of something they weren't reasoned into to begin with. I mean,
- 23:03they really may It may have been bad reasoning, but they were using
- 23:07a kind of reasoning. I was reasoned out of my faith. You know,
- 23:11you're not writing people off, Brian in the sense that I'm saying they
- 23:15can't be saved from there, can't be reached through reason. Is that what
- 23:19I'm hearing anything? Obviously, anything like that is a generalization. You can't
- 23:23reason someone out or something because it does happen. It happens all the time.
- 23:26I've gotten many emails from people who say I was I believed all the
- 23:30conspiracy theories until I became a skeptoid subscriber. And that's great to hear.
- 23:34But you're talking a small percentage of people. You're talking I have no idea
- 23:40what the percentage is, But how many people can be reasoned out of strange
- 23:42beliefs. I believe it's a minority of people. I don't have any date
- 23:47on that, but I believe it's a minority. No. I think we
- 23:49see that in tribes and identity cultures across the board. I'm interested too,
- 23:56and this is totally you and me over coffee. I know you don't have
- 24:00data, it's all subjective, but from your experience, do you feel like
- 24:03a lot of theistic religious people hear aliens and they think end times. I
- 24:11mean, if it's not of Jesus, it's from outer space, it's visiting
- 24:15us. Is it a sinister force that is aligned with Satan? I mean,
- 24:18do you ever hear anything like that? I have been very surprised since
- 24:22this movie came out, because that's not something that I had personally put together
- 24:26a thought about much. Been very surprised since the movie came out at how
- 24:30many people consider it to be a religious phenomenon. They believe that the UFOs
- 24:34are angels visiting the earth. I have not heard too much this is signaling
- 24:40the end of days or anything like that. I haven't heard that personally.
- 24:44I've heard a lot of conflation of aliens and religious creatures of some kind,
- 24:49angels, or whatever. So, yeah, that has surprised me. It's
- 24:52interesting to see our perception of aliens based on media in our mind. In
- 24:57my mind, when I think, I always think about that sort of oval
- 25:00head with the narrow eyes and the tiny slid for a mouth. You know,
- 25:03it's the close encounters aliens. You know, does everybody you talk about
- 25:07does when you talk to people who believe in the aliens, is that what
- 25:12they are drawing or describing for you? Yeah, And you know that's another
- 25:17thing where it goes back to cultural context, this whole thing with the gray
- 25:22alien, that sort of stereotypical style of alien. How that became the pop
- 25:26culture representation of what an alien was. And the most interesting manifestation of this
- 25:33particular cultural context is in the phenomenon of these nocturnal attacks. When you get
- 25:38a case of sleep paralysis, which is not that uncommon. What is less
- 25:42common is when it turns into what they call a nocturnal assault. The typical
- 25:48case is you wake up in some sort of half consciousness, You're not able
- 25:52to move, and you see often a malevolent being standing at the foot of
- 25:57your bed or often sitting on you, and you feel their weight on your
- 26:00chest. This happened to my mom a number of times when I was a
- 26:03kid, and she thoroughly believed it was a ghost. But once I started
- 26:08doing skeptoid for a living and learned about this phenomenon, realized, oh my
- 26:12gosh, that's exactly what my mom described the weight on the chest. You're
- 26:15not able to move this being looking at you. And when I say the
- 26:21cultural context, that kind of describes what the being looks like. And if
- 26:26you go all around the world, you go to different cultures. And this
- 26:30is more the case earlier in the twentieth century, before there was so much
- 26:33cultural crossover with TV and movies and everything. We're all watching the same media
- 26:38worldwide now, but go back fifty years and we weren't. And in Slavic
- 26:44cultures, the little character sitting on your chest would be like this little nome
- 26:48type character. It's this little Slavic forest, little old man who was evil.
- 26:53In India, it's typically a beautiful woman who comes from Indian mythology.
- 26:59In West In countries prior to nineteen sixty or so, it was typically the
- 27:04old hag, this old crone witch type figure who would sit on your chest
- 27:08and be evil at you and that's where the word haggard came from. You
- 27:14look haggard today because the old hag was writing you last night, keeping you
- 27:18up. And then, really, it was the Betty and Barney Hill story
- 27:22in the nineteen sixties that popularized the gray alien. Look these little sketches that
- 27:27Betty Hill made, and ever since then is when we've had the alien abduction
- 27:33phenomenon that didn't happen. There was no alien abduction phenomenon in pop culture prior
- 27:38to the Betty and Barney Hill incident. And what happened is when people would
- 27:42have these nocturnal assaults, they would now see the gray alien character because that's
- 27:48what we're getting fed from our cultural context. And enough people interpret that as
- 27:53aliens came into my room and they must have abducted me last night or worse.
- 27:57I don't know what the probe, what the obsession is with probing in
- 28:02alien stories. I don't even bother to ask. I'm just like, thank
- 28:06you, so fascinated by these connections and how and why these stories come to
- 28:11be. And that's why I'm so excited about what I do for a living.
- 28:15It's so much fun for me to learn about these connections and what caused
- 28:18and triggered this particular event. In culture, it's much more interesting than just
- 28:23stopping at the popular paranormal explanation for something. The declassification of the Department of
- 28:30Defense footage and documents was supposed to be kind of a big gotcha moments.
- 28:34The UFO crowd, the alien's crowd, they were waiting. They said,
- 28:38ah, they've been sitting on this information. Fighter pilots have seen things,
- 28:44and they have video documentation, and the government has been hiding. But now
- 28:47it's going to all be declassified. And then the documents come out and the
- 28:52government says there is no evidence at all that these UAP represent extra to real
- 29:00technology. And then the narrative switches and they say, oh, oh,
- 29:03they're covering it up. This is even more proof that aliens are real.
- 29:07That you follow the whole DoD thing, oh very closely. I unfortunately,
- 29:11Yeah, this being what I have to do for a living, I've been
- 29:15in the thick of that the whole time. Yeah, obviously that didn't change
- 29:18anyone's mind. Again, this is a religious belief. But let me jump
- 29:23in, Brian. I mean, did you see anything in the report that
- 29:26was compelling? You know, Wow, this cannot be explained. Maybe it's
- 29:30possible. Was there anything that struck you? No? I mean there's there's
- 29:34nothing in any of these reports that suggests, oh, hey, here's something
- 29:37interesting that we couldn't figure out. They did give some numbers, like we
- 29:41had x number of cases, and X number of them still are unexplained.
- 29:47They're not unexplained because they're incredibly weird or impossible or improbable. They're unt explained
- 29:52because there's insufficient data. These unexplained cases are something like a pilot said he
- 29:57saw something shiny. That's it. There's not enough data there to solve.
- 30:02There's no data. There's one anecdote, and that's the reason for the cases
- 30:07that remain unsolved. They're just simply unsupported anecdotes with not enough data to do
- 30:11anything with. What is that line, the plural of anecdote is not evidence.
- 30:17I always thought that was a great line. I like to say,
- 30:19you can stack cow pies as high as you want, they won't turn into
- 30:22a bar of gold. However, I said that one too many times because
- 30:26someone pointed out, well, actually they can, because if you stack enough
- 30:30cowpies, they can achieve mass that exceeds the Chandrascar limit, and they can
- 30:34collapse and they can turn into a sun, and you'll generate new elements at
- 30:40the center of that, and eventually you'll get gold. So how dare you
- 30:44make a statement in front of the skeptical community. Oh, they'll find every
- 30:48chink in the armor. I remember, I'll digress for just a second.
- 30:52I think I did a video on flat Earth and I was talking on the
- 30:56video about how the Earth is a sphere and I was in undated with people
- 31:00who say, no, it's not. The Earth is an oblet spheroid.
- 31:03And then they sent me all of these specifics as to what the differences are,
- 31:07and I thought, God, they won't let me. And I appreciate
- 31:08the fact that they won't let me get away with anything. I'm sure you
- 31:11go through your inbox must be just astounding. Okay, let's say I wanted
- 31:17to fake a UFO sighting. How would I do it? How would you
- 31:22do it? How would my guest Brian Dunning do it? Let's find out
- 31:26next. Brian Dunning is my guest this week. He is a science communicator,
- 31:37documentary filmmaker, and host of the Skeptoid podcast. If you were going
- 31:44to fake a UFO sighting, right, If you were going to convince somebody,
- 31:48or try to convince somebody, what would you do, Like, how
- 31:53would you set that up? I was talking to James underdown. I think
- 31:56he threw a coffee pot lit into the air and took a photograph and it
- 32:01looked really convincing. How would you fake us out, Brian? If I
- 32:06was going to make a hoax? Yes, uh, my couple of buddies
- 32:10and I almost did this in high school. We made a little strobe light
- 32:15from pieces from radio shack and we found a party store that sold big,
- 32:22giant black balloons and would fill them with helium for you. And the plan
- 32:25was as simple as that. We never actually put it all together and did
- 32:29it. But the plan was just to hang a strobe light from a black
- 32:31balloon and release it at night. And I really think that that would be
- 32:37pretty damn compelling. I don't know that you could beat that. Do it
- 32:39over a busy city. You know, you can shine a spotlight up at
- 32:43it. You won't see anything. There's just going to be a blinking light
- 32:45that's very bright. I think that'd be a fantastic way to go. Man.
- 32:50The beauty of that is it's simplicity. Really, you didn't overthink it.
- 32:54You didn't overthink it's going to be, you know, three or four
- 32:57am in the morning when the thing finally runs out of heel and sinks to
- 33:00the ground, by which time everyone will be asleep and no one will see
- 33:04it anymore. Tell me about the documentary before we wrap it up. The
- 33:07UFO movie. They don't want you to see any surprises for you in your
- 33:13research and production as you were going through it. I mean, no surprises.
- 33:16People ask me that a lot to say, Hey, when you were
- 33:19interviewing these people, did any of them come up with something that threw you
- 33:22for a loop? And it's like, well, no. The experts tour
- 33:25in the film are all either people that I've known or people who were recommended
- 33:30to me. We did pre show interviews over the phone or zoom or whatever
- 33:36first to make sure that we were all on the same page. Everyone was.
- 33:38I mean, we talk about real science in the film, and so
- 33:43there was no issue with any of the There's a couple of astrobiologists, astrophysicists,
- 33:50and there were some pilots in the film that I didn't know very well.
- 33:52At one of them, we couldn't use him. He refused to sign
- 33:55the release. But other than that, what hang on, hang on,
- 33:59Bride because he didn't like your questions. Well, he was just a nervous
- 34:04guy. Okay, I get it. If you've seen a release for appearing
- 34:07in a TV show or a film, it is pretty crazy, draconian.
- 34:12It's a page and a half long of we get to own everything about you,
- 34:15and we can use it and abuse it. However the heck we want
- 34:19until the end of time in any form of media. And people who are
- 34:22experienced they understand, Yeah, that's how these things work, and they sign
- 34:24it. People who aren't experienced can be spooked by that, and this guy
- 34:30was just spooked by that. You have to be able to have all those
- 34:32things so you can do things like make trailers and make advertising posters and things
- 34:38like this in the future. Well I'm just saying already the alien advocate is
- 34:44going. You know, the pilot was onto something and he realized that Brian
- 34:51was acting in bad faith and he refused to further participate in the project.
- 34:54I mean, you can see how, and then Brian admitted that it might
- 34:59be used in it Drickconian way against him. You know, I can see
- 35:01how somebody could spin that. But you know it's as a member of the
- 35:06media, I totally do understand. You got to dot your eyes, cross
- 35:08your t's. You got to make sure that you're able to use the footage
- 35:12in the production room in a way that allows you to freely use it instead
- 35:16of having to walk on eggshells. And that doesn't mean we're operating disingenuously.
- 35:21It doesn't mean that you changed what was said in any of your interviews.
- 35:23I just want to make that clear, correct, Brian, Absolutely. I
- 35:27mean that was the whole subject of our film, Science Friction, is people
- 35:30who get deceptively edited in these interviews on television to make the scientists say the
- 35:35opposite of what he actually said. That's a great film, Science Friction twenty
- 35:38twenty two. If you want to check it out. It's all about where
- 35:40do I check it out? Where is it? Science Friction dot tv?
- 35:44It's on a million streaming services. Okay, okay. At Science Friction dot
- 35:47tv, there's links to four or five of the most common ones. You
- 35:52know we were talking about. As a producer, I've mentioned in a speech
- 35:55a while back that there are subtle things you can do to either build or
- 36:00detract from credibility that most people would never notice. Where you place the camera
- 36:05right. If they're closer, they look more ominous. How you light them,
- 36:07If it's more dramatic or drastic, you might make them look more sinister.
- 36:13If you want to make them look weak, you place them backward and
- 36:15then give a lot of headspace so they look like they're sinking in the frame.
- 36:20How you edit, the phrasing, the music that you choose can completely
- 36:23change the temperature of what's being done. And people are manipulated in this way
- 36:30all the time without even realizing it, right Bran, Yeah, I mean,
- 36:34and we do a certain amount of that in all of our films too,
- 36:36but it's always to make the experts look good. Well, I think
- 36:40the difference is ken Burns, the documentary filmmaker, says that all storytelling is
- 36:45manipulation, meaning that I want you to feel something about the things you're thinking
- 36:50about. But am I operating disingenuously? Am I trying to deceive? By
- 36:55using the tools of storytelling, the editing, the life, the music,
- 37:00etc. You know, the effects, the titles, the packaging of the
- 37:04thing. I can package it in a way that may manipulate emotion or try
- 37:08to propel a certain reaction without lying to you. And that's different than somebody
- 37:16going in and essentially being deceptive with their packaging. Yeah, I mean,
- 37:21I think there's a pretty clear line that you can draw, at least on
- 37:24a case by case basis. It's like the old description of pornography. I
- 37:29can't define it, but I know it when I see it. I can't
- 37:31necessarily tell you what makes a scene deceptive or not, but I can tell
- 37:36you when one is or isn't if you have access to the source material.
- 37:38In Science Friction, some of these people were telling stories as blatant as the
- 37:45Discovery Channel producers, slicing individual words out of the sentences and moving the words
- 37:50around in the sentence. And they'll do that if they want to make a
- 37:52show that says Aliens built the Pyramids. Talk to any legit egyptologists slice and
- 37:58dice as sentences and and hey, you just had a legit egyptologist say that
- 38:01Aliens built the pyramids. Now there's nothing that blatant. Two of the cases
- 38:07we talked about in the film, and I should emphasize the producers have the
- 38:12right to do this because of these releases. They have the right to do
- 38:15that, absolutely, But in two of the cases, there are educational institutions
- 38:19where these people worked made so much stink that Discovery Channel actually went back and
- 38:23re edited those segments of the show that they had deceptively misrepresented these people.
- 38:30I remember back when the History Channel used to do more history. I mean,
- 38:32it was always sensationalistic, but you know, the pre Ancient Aliens Discovery
- 38:37Channel. I kind of miss MythBusters, you know. And I've got nothing
- 38:43against ice road truckers or whatever's going on these days, right, but have
- 38:47you seen a shift over the past fifteen years networks like this that used to
- 38:52be a little more nuts and bolts. Obviously still sensationalized, but have you
- 38:55seen that seismic shift? Yeah, I think it happened pretty early and pretty
- 39:00comprehensively. Discovery Channel was probably the first, and then you had all these
- 39:04other networks like Animal Planet nat GEO is another one that completely followed their lead.
- 39:10And you know, most of their programming is fine, twenty three hours
- 39:15a day, it's fine, but look at what they've got in prime time,
- 39:17and it's always some ridiculous Ancient Aliens show or something like that. I
- 39:22think they all realized early on that that's where the clicks are, that's where
- 39:24the eyeball share is. So it's a simple business decision. Animal Planet Wait
- 39:30wait, what did Animal Planet ever do to you? Brian? Like,
- 39:34why are you going after animal? But what are they doing over there?
- 39:37They'll do a lot of cryptozoology stuff, alternative animal histories, and you know,
- 39:43is the Mega Shark still real? Where they try to create a mystery
- 39:45around something where there is no mystery at all. I enjoyed the cryptid shows.
- 39:50I do you know, Abominable Snowman, the sasquatch, the locknest monster,
- 39:54the chupa cabra. You know, sometimes I wish they would be a
- 39:59good monster. Then I'm thankful they don't, because I'm sure that we would,
- 40:02you know, hunt them down in experiment on them, or or you
- 40:06know, we'd all try to take a selfie with them in their natural habitat
- 40:10before we I'm not link to the documentaries in the description box for the video
- 40:15viewers. I see a keyboard in your background. You played keys, Brian,
- 40:20Oh, not very well. I did a lot of you know,
- 40:24hey, I'm in a band when I'm in college. But no, this
- 40:28is I just screw around with us and sometimes there's some little audio cues for
- 40:30podcasts and stuff like that that I was. I was like that, I'm
- 40:34not good, but I was in a band man we played when I was
- 40:37in the a. You're probably of the same generation as me. I always
- 40:40my dream was to own the key tar. Remember the key tar, Brian.
- 40:45You know all the guitar players, they always got all the attention,
- 40:50and we keyboard players were locked back there in this little corner and we just
- 40:53felt cheated. We wanted the key tar so we could go out and solo
- 40:57in front of everybody. So so now had gone to the retro music equipment
- 41:02shops and bought one. I think, you know, what would I do
- 41:06with it except be photographed for the internet. But I was that kid.
- 41:10I was an eighties child. One last thing, too, Brian, is
- 41:14that you strike me as someone who comes out of a radio background. You
- 41:17strike me as a broadcaster. You've got that delivery, a very polished sound.
- 41:22I was thinking maybe you and I could buy a Partridge family band,
- 41:24go hit the road, be able to just make it a double act.
- 41:28Do you hear that quite a bit? Hey, Brian, You've obviously done
- 41:30a lot of public speaking and hosting, I do, I guess. I
- 41:35guess just doing a podcast for seventeen years develop that. I mean. I
- 41:38came into being a science writer, not through science, but through writing.
- 41:43I went to college for writing for film and television, and I worked in
- 41:45that for a while, and so I came at it from the opposite direction
- 41:51of almost all of my colleagues. So I definitely appreciate the fact that podcasts
- 41:57and this whole democratization of content has happened because it has allowed me to go
- 42:01back to my roots without having to sully myself by needing to have a Hollywood
- 42:07career. Brian Dunning. He is host of the Skeptoid podcast, producer of
- 42:14the documentary Several but including the UFO movie They Don't Want You To See.
- 42:19You've been a great conversation. I'm going to throw links in the description box
- 42:23and hopefully we'll get a chance to shake hands in person down the way.
- 42:27Thanks for your great work, bro, Thank you, It's been a lot
- 42:29of fun, sir. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a
- 42:34complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the
- 42:37Thinking Atheist logo. Links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming
- 42:44free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.