Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP229: Tech Strategy - The Pros and Cons of All In One Platforms vs. Composable Stacks
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 0:05experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 0:10featuring interviews with leading e-commerce, retailers,
- 0:13industry thoughtless and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 0:24to help fine tune your ecom strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James or Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Today's episode is sponsored by Scale Commerce Engine who
- 0:38productised the scale and expertise of the fastest growing
- 0:40e-commerce business in Europe and Swap Commerce who help you
- 0:43improve every pain point in your OPS journey from shipping,
- 0:46tracking and package protection to inventory and returns.
- 0:50So let's set the scene for today's conversation.
- 0:51It's a talking heterogene me and Paul and we're going to pull
- 0:54apart the pros and cons of like all in one platforms versus more
- 0:56composable stacks with a focus on multi referrals, UGC, our
- 1:01product discovery because these tend to be two of the big areas
- 1:04within larger tech stack deliberations where people spend
- 1:07a lot of time deciding what the right solution is.
- 1:11And we'll give you some context and then we'll we'll explore
- 1:13what we see as the pros and cons and like what the decision
- 1:16making factors. So let's start why we're talking
- 1:19about this. So I think a big reason is there
- 1:22are a lot of deciding factors and influences in what tech you
- 1:24go, but one of the big ones is strategy. e-commerce strategy
- 1:27varies from business to business in terms of what is the most
- 1:30important thing for a business to execute its ecom plans or to
- 1:34deliver really good online customer experience.
- 1:36For some people, content is everything when you're a very
- 1:39content, editorial experience their business.
- 1:41For others, it's not so important as normal customers
- 1:43need and product discovery and getting really effective search
- 1:46and browse and especially if you've got a really, really
- 1:50complex product catalogue, then search and browse becomes
- 1:52massively important for product discovery.
- 1:55So strategy is a big determinant of what type of tooling you want
- 1:59to look at and what's important to you.
- 2:00But what else, Paul? Like, why else?
- 2:03You know, what are the considerations?
- 2:04Why are we talking about this? Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:08Yes. I think it's obviously a big
- 2:10topic at the minute and there's a lot of real platformings with
- 2:14a different drivers behind them. You know, typically when you
- 2:17replatform or yeah other kind of bigger change projects, you're
- 2:21going to review your vendors and either look to reduce cost or go
- 2:25you know, get better capability or you know achieve different
- 2:29goals. But I think the things that I've
- 2:30written down here, I think the main reasons people look at
- 2:34this. So from our kind of
- 2:35administering perspective, lots of people want a single solution
- 2:40where they can benefit from having you know data across
- 2:45multiple areas or you know can manage multiple areas at global
- 2:49level, stuff like that. So I think that's one driver
- 2:53reporting as another one, so kind of getting.
- 2:57So I guess point of discovery is a good example where like maybe
- 2:59you could report across all of those areas or you know look at
- 3:02trends across all of those areas.
- 3:05Performance is a is a relatively minor one, but the more you know
- 3:09third party JavaScript you're bringing onto the site,
- 3:12definitely a good percentage of opinions that I've been faced
- 3:17with when discussing this stuff. That's been a big one.
- 3:20So yeah, just reducing the number of third parties and then
- 3:24cost is obviously the biggest one I would say and maintenance
- 3:27potentially. But yeah, cost is definitely a
- 3:30big one. And often these kind of, I guess
- 3:33there's been a huge shift in the market where different vendors
- 3:37have started to kind of come together and there's a Venn
- 3:40diagram that can be applied that can be applied to a lot of
- 3:42different areas. But yeah, cost is usually a big
- 3:46part of this outset. Yeah, and we'll explore the
- 3:50those in a in a bit more detail around the pros and cons.
- 3:52But let's give some examples for some of you listening already
- 3:54think I really get, I get what you mean.
- 3:56I know what you mean in terms of vendors.
- 3:57Others might be thinking what the hell are you talking about.
- 3:59So let's take example, So loyalty referral UGC you could
- 4:03and all in one would be something like a yacht power
- 4:05stamped where you get a loyalty referrals, you get reviews
- 4:08etcetera and you get some additional you know services.
- 4:11You might stuff around SMS for example versus a more specialist
- 4:16review platform like a FIFO for example or power reviews.
- 4:22You've also got I guess one that that probably sits in between
- 4:25like a reviews dot IO which is a reviews engine, but actually
- 4:28they they acquired influence dot IO as loyalty.
- 4:32So although influence dot IO is a separate product, the two are
- 4:35building that integration. So you can have two together,
- 4:37but it's not the same as I guess a vendor that started off and
- 4:41has built out all the capabilities with without
- 4:43acquiring. And then if we talk about
- 4:46product discovery, you've got all in one platforms like
- 4:50Algolia, Klavu, Nosto attract. Well it's now a crown peak.
- 4:55There are lots of them out there versus you know you could have a
- 5:01just functional search engine, you either get them native to a
- 5:04platform or or third parties where they focus purely on one
- 5:08element of that printed discovery suite.
- 5:10So that's what we mean and now we're going to look at the pros
- 5:13and cons. So let's start with the all in
- 5:14one platforms and typically a lot of the most of the
- 5:18businesses are I work with one of the key drivers when they're
- 5:21reviewing tech stacks and this is not just when they're re
- 5:23platforming but also when they're trying to look at
- 5:26efficiencies in terms of like licensing and and managing
- 5:29multiple vendors. It is the talks about tech
- 5:31consolidation is well actually our life is easier if we reduce
- 5:34the number of third parties and and we have like a single vendor
- 5:37that we work with and in principle that makes sense but
- 5:41it doesn't always play out. So let's look at those pros and
- 5:43cons. Like what for me the pros of
- 5:46going for an all in one is that single partner.
- 5:48So you've got a single point of contact which from an escalation
- 5:51point if there are any issues makes life easier and they've
- 5:54done more work, hopefully not in all cases to make sure those
- 5:59those multiple products are integrated so that there's
- 6:01automated data flows between them.
- 6:04So if we take you know, Yop PO for example, the fact that
- 6:07reviews could automatically contribute towards like loyalty
- 6:10points or you could, you know you can use the automation
- 6:14within there without and then having to build another
- 6:16integration from another reviews platform into that loyalty
- 6:19scheme. So that adds a lot of benefit
- 6:21and that devs tend to like that when there's less effort and
- 6:25integration work where there can be fewer points of failure.
- 6:28And the other one for me is that single interface and it's not
- 6:32always but typically in these platforms you log into a single
- 6:35place and you've got all the tools and capabilities in the
- 6:38back end for you to execute of your your your dates, day
- 6:42configuration work versus having to log into two or three
- 6:44different vendors. So that's and I guess for people
- 6:48who've moved into like modern SAS world, so the likes of
- 6:51Shopify's big commerce's and are used to that that kind of like
- 6:55App Store set up and and access that can work quite nice and
- 6:59people use that interface that's that's my view of kind of the
- 7:02key pros, what do you see? Paul, hi, I'm Thomas, Director,
- 7:08Growth at Scale, the world's fastest growing e-commerce
- 7:11platform has landed in the UK with global brands like
- 7:14Manchester United, Deichmann, Snipes and Marco Polo trusting
- 7:18us to scale their commerce businesses.
- 7:20Are you ready for a new E Com experience?
- 7:22Talk to Scale today, because life is just too short for
- 7:25painful commerce. Yeah, I mean I think that is the
- 7:29price. I think the only one thing I
- 7:31would say because I we often start like discovery processes
- 7:34and people want one vendor that I would say in most cases in all
- 7:40of these areas. I haven't really seen a vendor
- 7:43that's like perfect across all the different areas and I think
- 7:46you do usually compromise somewhere.
- 7:51So I think then there's there's middle ground as well.
- 7:53So we would typically as an example or the last few projects
- 7:56we've done separate out search and category merchandising and
- 8:00recommendations as two kind of specialist areas.
- 8:05And a lot of that comes down to like the integration where I
- 8:10think people maybe that have started around category
- 8:14merchandising would maybe approach things slightly
- 8:17differently to a search vendor that maybe wants to just embed a
- 8:20JavaScript grid as an example and then kind of retroactively
- 8:23build some of the logic. Yeah.
- 8:27But I think, I mean the pros like you say, I mean it's cost,
- 8:30it's management. But yeah, I think, I think it
- 8:34really, you've just got to kind of look at everything fairly
- 8:36granularly alongside that just to kind of make sure you're not
- 8:41buying something that isn't as strong or doesn't meet the
- 8:45requirements. Yeah, we'll we'll we'll come
- 8:49back on that later about what influences the decision bath
- 8:51because I think that's a really important one to tease out the
- 8:54different things and what's horrible.
- 8:55But I think it's you touch upon them a really good con of this
- 8:59which is feature compromise for some parts of the platform.
- 9:02And I've had this conversation with a couple of clients
- 9:04recently where this all in one appeals but then it comes bound
- 9:09to and we'll expand on this a bit more about what's most
- 9:12important. And I think that's critical
- 9:14because you could if you don't have a complex site for example
- 9:19you're if you don't have a like a customer base that's highly
- 9:23demanding in terms of like rapid speed best on site digital
- 9:27experience is not really brand LED, but it's a more functional
- 9:30site with a small product catalogue where people just want
- 9:34to find products and buy them. Well actually the added bells
- 9:38and whistles and additional features you might get on a
- 9:40market leader around like the reviews for example might not be
- 9:44needed and having a single review engine that doesn't
- 9:46support like syndication for example would be fine.
- 9:49Whereas for multi brand retailers or people working with
- 9:53products across multiple domains, I can Consumer Packaged
- 9:56Goods that then have their products across multiple
- 9:58retailers. Then that more advanced package
- 10:01with a syndication for the reviews might be really, really
- 10:03important because that and then aims them to execute their their
- 10:06strategy more effectively. So I think the the pros and cons
- 10:10will will vary from business to business as well which is why
- 10:14it's important and feature compromise isn't always a bad
- 10:16thing. I, I, I, I had that conversation
- 10:18recently, my client in the US sort of saying do you really
- 10:21need this? Are you going to use it?
- 10:22Because if not, it's a vanity play and it's a really good
- 10:25conversation we're having at the moment to tease out how
- 10:28important each of these additional features is and
- 10:31whether they believe it's just it sounds like a great idea, but
- 10:33in practice they'd hardly ever use it and therefore why would
- 10:36we pay for it? The other called.
- 10:40Oh, sorry, God. Oh, you go.
- 10:45I was just going to say the only other consideration here that I
- 10:48think when it comes down to the detail of selecting a lot of the
- 10:51vendors that we've got here. I think compatibility is the
- 10:54only other one where like certain parts of the platform
- 10:57might not be compatible with Shopify markets or E Commerce's
- 11:00might be storefront or if you got multiple instances you have
- 11:04to do things 345 times stuff like that.
- 11:07And I think that's probably also been one of the biggest things
- 11:11that have determined this route as well where certain of the
- 11:15certain ones they spend, yeah, don't support not not
- 11:19necessarily across the whole product of that suite of
- 11:21products, but some products maybe just aren't compatible.
- 11:25Yeah, it's it's a good point. Ecosystem compatibility is
- 11:29critical and we, I know we talk about this a lot whether you're
- 11:32on a Shopify or a big commerce centre or a magenta cell source.
- 11:36Whatever it is, how well embedded is the vendor platform
- 11:41in that ecosystem? How are there good case studies
- 11:43of people using it properly and what does it cost an effort to
- 11:46get live at? I'm having having a conversation
- 11:48at the moment and with a Shopify project of a business that's on
- 11:51Zendesk. And Zendesk is a great tool for
- 11:53customer ticketing, customer service and management, but it's
- 11:56not quite as well embedded in the Shopify ecosystem as sake
- 12:00gorgeous. So to get to do what you want to
- 12:04do you there are some capabilities you can't enable
- 12:07but there's a bit more development and configuration
- 12:09work to get it set up. But then if you flip that and
- 12:12go, OK, well we know that Gorgeous is one of the best
- 12:14embedded for that, that customer service piece in terms of you
- 12:17know tickets having like all the order reference information and
- 12:20then within the order record within Shopify having the tick
- 12:23associated tickets etcetera and triggers from Gorgeous and OK,
- 12:28Grey. But what about the cost and
- 12:31effort of the business retraining on a new toolkit.
- 12:34So I think sometimes when looking in ecosystem and looking
- 12:38at like a maybe a tool that gives you more functionality,
- 12:41you've got to think about the impact of change.
- 12:43And and whether or not that tool just comes back to our points
- 12:47about the admin interface that reporting the capability.
- 12:50Is the effort of change justified by the added features
- 12:53you get? And my final point of that, I'm
- 12:56really intrigued to hear your view on this is if if a vendor's
- 13:00got 456 products within their platform, how are they focusing
- 13:05their their development resource on those products?
- 13:08How independent are the development pools to drive for
- 13:12the road map for each of the components or all certain
- 13:15components falling behind and are actually just becoming more
- 13:18basic over time and therefore you'll get feature decline
- 13:21versus like best in class specialist tools.
- 13:23What's your take on that? I think I think the thing with
- 13:27this is one other bit of context that I guess is important is
- 13:30it's OK. Like some of the biggest
- 13:32examples are like Yacht PO, Cando, Clavio who have probably
- 13:36been The Who have maybe done the most to expand their product
- 13:41range. So like fire SMS reviews,
- 13:43subscriptions and your opposed case, I think, yeah, definitely.
- 13:47I think the reason they've done that is for upselling and like
- 13:49increasing or at least one of the primary objectives to
- 13:52increase the ticket size per client.
- 13:56And I think in a lot of cases, you know the reason why people
- 13:59will use them as well is because the vendor say he's six months
- 14:03free, he's 12 months free, etcetera and then they'll
- 14:06gradually increase the kind of value of the customer.
- 14:11But I've been gaining the majority of cases and almost all
- 14:15of the vendors written down here.
- 14:16I think their core is usually strongest.
- 14:18And then I do think there's a number of examples where maybe
- 14:22the overall capability is then not kept up with some of the
- 14:26challenges as a result of. You know.
- 14:29Broadening the product and you know, entering new or like
- 14:33offering new services and then they're slower to become
- 14:36compatible with Shopify markets or you know, they're not able to
- 14:41release new features at the same time.
- 14:42And I think, yeah, subscriptions is another example of this, like
- 14:45Skio being a really good example where they kind of, yeah, came
- 14:50out of nowhere and then just released features at a much
- 14:52faster rate. Yeah.
- 14:54And I think you know, a Kendo is another one that we haven't
- 14:57mentioned yet and they've now entered a load of new areas
- 15:01including surveys and visual UGC loyalty I think now, yeah.
- 15:07And I think Yoppo's subscriptions is a good example
- 15:09of a solution where it obviously looks good on paper, but I don't
- 15:14think you could compare that to some of the other vendors out
- 15:17there. And obviously, it does depend
- 15:19that, yeah, I don't think there's too many tools out there
- 15:25that have gone that have gone from one to four or three
- 15:29different areas and remained best in class.
- 15:32I can't really think of any. I think you've done really well.
- 15:36Guilty actually, but yeah, so. Yeah, they've done with loyalty
- 15:40referrals and the SMS add on is is quite useful with reviews.
- 15:44Subscriptions is a hard one and I I when I see like brand
- 15:49businesses like them adding it. I think it's a sensible play
- 15:52because a lot of merchants who just need a basic subscription
- 15:55engine, it kind of ticks a box and it keeps them in in the in
- 15:59like that wheelhouse of a of their platform and extends
- 16:02revenue. I think when you have more
- 16:04complex business needs. So if you're if you're doing
- 16:07subscriptions where you have different bundles and you have
- 16:11different pricing based on different customer groups and
- 16:14you have additional functionality where you really
- 16:16want more granular control over scheduling frequency and their
- 16:20price breaks. And all of a sudden you start to
- 16:22realise that subscriptions goes from, hey, here's one product
- 16:25and it's 10. If I order it every month it's
- 16:2810% off to well actually this is a bit more complicated.
- 16:30And then when you look at the ability for price, you know if
- 16:35you go to B to B and then you have different price books and
- 16:37how can a subscription engine handle price books for different
- 16:40pricing for different, you're like well there's very few that
- 16:44can do that and then you're in specialist territory.
- 16:46So This is why let's we've got one more discussion then we'll
- 16:50talk about how that how the decision path gets made because
- 16:53requirements come into it massively.
- 16:55But you flagged something before we started this and I've been
- 16:59involved in a few discussions on this, which is what about
- 17:02building something yourself. If if you say for example, you
- 17:05want personalization, but actually what you really mean is
- 17:09product discovery, personalization where you want
- 17:12customers to see more relevant products and you want to be able
- 17:15to control the kind of the price point or the brand or the style
- 17:19of product that you're servicing to people.
- 17:21And you want to help with those recommendations and the product
- 17:25category merchandise in the search bit.
- 17:26But actually the content personalization is not as
- 17:29important because you don't do much content.
- 17:32You could build something a bit hacky yourself and save money
- 17:38and maybe that changes the view of which vendor you go for.
- 17:41But therein lies challenges. So do you want to talk people
- 17:44through about about that when you might want to consider doing
- 17:48one part yourself and then using a third party for a smaller
- 17:52subset? Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:54I think the other one would be native functionality if you're
- 17:57building on top of it. But I think 2 examples I can
- 17:59think of where sometimes 3 examples where I think some
- 18:03people could use third parties versus might not necessarily
- 18:07needing it. One is contact personalization.
- 18:10So I think in a lot of cases what people want is usually
- 18:14barely basic on that side and maybe they just want to like
- 18:17better handle gendering or you know, maybe just have better
- 18:22kind of experiences for different levels of customers
- 18:25when they're logged in. Stuff like that which is really
- 18:27easy to build in the theme and you don't need to then spend
- 18:30loads of money on a third party. And I said the other in my
- 18:35experience people that use content pay for content
- 18:37personalisation. So of all of our clients of paid
- 18:40for an expensive third party for this, none of them have got huge
- 18:43value from it because it takes quite a lot of management and
- 18:47you need a lot of volume of it in the segment to really drive
- 18:50value. So I think that's one product
- 18:53racks is another one. But again I think we're quite
- 18:55fashion orientated, but I think a lot of people prefer to build
- 19:00their own business logic around third around product racks and
- 19:04they'll build on top of you know a native offering and the same
- 19:07applies to things like car upsells and stuff like that.
- 19:11So I think obviously there's huge value for some businesses
- 19:14in product rights, particularly if you're multi brand or you've
- 19:17got a massive catalogue or you've got complexity in that
- 19:19area. But equally I think that's a
- 19:21good example where you could build something on top of native
- 19:25And then the other one that's come up a few times recently is
- 19:28bundling and I think building something yourself you have more
- 19:30control over, you know, how things are represented in the
- 19:33order, how inventory is handled, all of that kind of stuff and
- 19:38then the front end experience. So I personally think that's
- 19:40worth investing often worth investing in in terms of like
- 19:45building something that's quite unique to your business rather
- 19:49than just using an off the shelf solution.
- 19:50But again it depends on, you know, maybe you're very simple,
- 19:53maybe you need to roll it out within 12 hours, stuff like
- 19:56that. So always variables, Yeah, I'm
- 19:59just trying to think of any others.
- 20:02I think, I mean there's so many different areas now because
- 20:05obviously we're just talking about these ones that are
- 20:06probably the obvious ones and the suites.
- 20:08But yeah, there's so many other you know, third party areas like
- 20:13you know, notifications or yeah, anything else.
- 20:18So I think it obviously it depends.
- 20:20But yeah, my view is that sometimes you're better at
- 20:23investing in like the quality of a feature or building around
- 20:27your business rather than just using a third party in the way
- 20:31that it works, if that. Now let's let's talk about the
- 20:34decision part of this because we talked a lot about the
- 20:37differences, the pros and the cons.
- 20:40Now how can people make better decisions?
- 20:43And I then let's put back context.
- 20:45This is all of us work in the industry, whether it's us
- 20:48consultants, running agencies, have a lot of experience with
- 20:52lots of different tech, but we don't know it all.
- 20:54It's impossible. No one person knows every single
- 20:57bit of technology with every single integration part across
- 20:59every single e-commerce platform.
- 21:01Just it's impossible for one person to.
- 21:04And we are always constantly learning about what works
- 21:08together well and what are the nuances and what are the pros
- 21:10and cons. And one of the key things I
- 21:12think for people to to be aware aware of is is you know agencies
- 21:17might have a because those might have like me might have a
- 21:21specific experience with particular set tools that I've
- 21:24shown that those are very good, but it doesn't mean they always
- 21:26are. So you could be able to tease
- 21:27that out and make a decision on merit and a good decisions are
- 21:30made when you get positive conflict.
- 21:33By that I mean challenging each other to go oh, I'm not
- 21:35convinced about this or have you thought about X.
- 21:37So it's really good to cut to think about all these decision
- 21:40paths and then have a meaningful discussion to come out of the
- 21:42right decision. So let's start.
- 21:45So number one for me, Paul is business needs.
- 21:48You've got to let's take product discovery or product.
- 21:51Yeah, digital experience, Product discovery, I mean pick,
- 21:53pick terminology. So we're talking about search,
- 21:57merchandising, recommendations and the personalisation across
- 22:00that those journeys is it has to start with business needs.
- 22:04The strategy bears what is most important like how important is
- 22:07search versus browse, how many more percentage of sessions hit
- 22:10search. If you've got a really small,
- 22:12I've seen some clients who got less than 10% of sessions hit in
- 22:14search. It doesn't mean search isn't
- 22:16important, but it means that relative to the wider browsing
- 22:19journeys for product discovery, it's less important than on like
- 22:22an Amazon where it's like 80% plus of people go straight into
- 22:25search. So you've got to tease that out
- 22:27and you've got to understand then you've got to look at the
- 22:29personalization element and how critical is personalization
- 22:32across the full journey. What benefit is there based on
- 22:35how broad your product set is, your customer type, how often
- 22:40people come to the site as well? If if you've got a site where
- 22:42people only visit once every few months, then it's probably not
- 22:46going to be as as much of A benefit than if people are
- 22:48visiting all the time. You've got regular sessions of
- 22:50building up a stronger data profile.
- 22:52It's not to say isn't important, but maybe not as.
- 22:54So you've got to start with that because without knowing that you
- 22:57don't know which part of that product stack is the critical
- 23:00decision point. What?
- 23:02What else for you, Paul? Yeah.
- 23:05So I mean I think the, I mean it's kind of aligned with what
- 23:10you're saying, but I think the compatibility piece is a big one
- 23:12because and I do think I think the world is getting simpler.
- 23:17So I think there's less risk by choosing A vendor than it
- 23:20probably was two years ago. That one thing I'd say is I see
- 23:23a lot of like I've seen loads of sweeping comments on LinkedIn
- 23:26about, you know, Al Golia being the best search solution and you
- 23:31know then you've got another one that's slightly cheaper.
- 23:33So that would be the second best.
- 23:35But I do think there's actually, and I don't think people think
- 23:38about the operational side. And particularly, yeah, we've
- 23:41got a number of clients that have had a search vendor or
- 23:44search and merchandising vendor where they've had to do
- 23:47everything five times because there's five independent
- 23:50independent instances of Shopify mainly.
- 23:53But it's also been the same about the integration with
- 23:55Magenta or the integration with Commerce and actually that takes
- 23:59five times as long for the team. And then much better off having
- 24:03something where you can apply global rules, but you can also
- 24:06then go and like apply different logic or different overrides for
- 24:10specific markets. And that to me that can be
- 24:13absolutely critical particularly for category merchandising.
- 24:17And so I think that's one same applies to like things like
- 24:20Shopify Markets, that's definitely important.
- 24:23I think the, so I'm obviously a big proponent of using like the
- 24:29native template within a shop fire a big commerce.
- 24:33And I think that's another one where I think you know if you if
- 24:38your SEO team don't want a JavaScript grid or you know your
- 24:41developers don't want to work within the templating of a third
- 24:46party, then you have to look for a vendor that has like an API
- 24:49connection into the platform. And then you can use the native
- 24:53filtering and grid and everything else.
- 24:55And I think that's another one that's often overlooked.
- 24:57And actually when you start to add complexity into the grid
- 25:00with like swatches or different types of animation or different
- 25:04types of content, it can get buggy and complex.
- 25:08So yeah, I think that's another one.
- 25:10But yeah, I think it's like I personally think it's just
- 25:13trying to build a set of requirements and it's kind of
- 25:16like you know obviously you and I when we're working with brands
- 25:21around the platform valuation we use, I think you do as well that
- 25:25the whole kind of Moscow approach.
- 25:28And I personally think just trying to map out like the
- 25:31critical features that you can't live without is really
- 25:34important. And then trying to think about
- 25:36how best to like reviews is a good example where a lot of our
- 25:39clients now are way more focused on getting detailed sizing
- 25:44context and surfacing that at different areas of the site than
- 25:48they are about just having a reviews widget.
- 25:51So I think like that and also things like being able to test
- 25:55different timings of emails or do you know do be more advanced
- 25:58with the widget. Yeah, I think some of that
- 26:01stuff, like we're getting really specific about what you can and
- 26:04can't do, would be my most important one.
- 26:09Yeah, 100%. No, but it does.
- 26:12It fundamentally starts with what a business is trying to
- 26:14achieve and what what what does it need to do, what the use
- 26:18cases that the business team users want to be able to handle
- 26:22on a day-to-day basis. Strategically the the ecom lead
- 26:27and the CXE, what are they trying to improve and change and
- 26:30why? And then that that's the
- 26:34functional stuff. And then you're right, the back
- 26:36end, the back end bit's so important.
- 26:37So I've worked with a client recently to look at the search
- 26:39merch bit and they have a search provider that's pretty good.
- 26:43Functionally wise it's pretty good.
- 26:44But the back end is so basic and so hard to use it's it looks
- 26:49like an old school developers have built this to be
- 26:51functional, but it's not had any like UX design to align with how
- 26:56a business user, modern e-commerce user uses a tool to
- 26:59to merchandise a site. So it takes way longer than
- 27:02needed to set things up and it requires some developer support
- 27:05versus you know we mentioned a few times but clay view much
- 27:11simpler back end and easier for people to go in and use the tool
- 27:14in. So it's I think people often
- 27:16underestimate just effective admin tools and intuitive UIS.
- 27:21And the benefit that has because a lot of a lot of people end up
- 27:25doing the day-to-day might be junior mid level merchandisers
- 27:29or E com execs and they don't want something where you need a
- 27:33PhD to figure out which part of the interface to go to and how
- 27:36to do the configuration. But and the next bit which is
- 27:41linked to that is the resource and RE and anyone listening your
- 27:44resourcing is critical to this is who who is going to be doing
- 27:47this? What's the level of expertise,
- 27:49how many people do you have the bandwidth to make full use of
- 27:52the feature set. And that's whether you're going
- 27:56an all in one or whether you're going for multiple sub vendors.
- 28:00Are you going to get usage out? Because if you go for like the
- 28:03ultimate specialist or maybe you like as you do search, category
- 28:06merge, personalisation, but you also have a a a content
- 28:09personalisation engine on there on top.
- 28:13Do you have the expertise to make use and the skills and the
- 28:16resources to make use of all of the functionality in those three
- 28:18platforms? Because if the answer's no,
- 28:20you've got to question the value of that licence fee.
- 28:23Yeah, I think just going back to your previous point, but it also
- 28:27ties on to this my my favorite example of what you've said
- 28:30about that, the intuitiveness and the ease of introduce or
- 28:35ease of like adapting without need the like massive
- 28:39development hours is the CRM side.
- 28:43So pretty much every client I've worked with that has used to
- 28:47Clavio has, has been more, which is obviously very simple, very
- 28:51intuitive, has done way more advanced things than the
- 28:55enterprise CRM solutions. And that I've never seen an
- 29:00example where someone bought these solutions for like
- 29:02hundreds of thousands of pound and actually got any benefit
- 29:06pretty much of using like the feature set.
- 29:09And so I completely agree on that point.
- 29:11But that's always my favorite example.
- 29:13Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's I I love it in demos.
- 29:18When, when? Because a lot of these vendors
- 29:20are rightfully proud of what the company's built a lot of time
- 29:23and effort and emotions gone into to creating all these great
- 29:26feature sets and giving people this, this rage of choice.
- 29:30So I'm not denigrating at all, but the salespeople are
- 29:33naturally going to be evangelical about their product
- 29:36and how cool it is, but don't always understand the
- 29:40application of each of those component parts to the specific
- 29:44client they're talking to. So my favorite bit of is and not
- 29:47in the demos but afterwards it's getting people to go right.
- 29:50How would you use that not do you like the idea?
- 29:52Everyone likes that. Do you like the idea of
- 29:54personal? Yeah, I love personalization,
- 29:55How are you going to use it? So this specific, I'll give you
- 29:59an example of AI generated segments.
- 30:01So a tool that I call it DXB, a tool that automatically
- 30:05generates segments on the fly based on all the behavioural and
- 30:08transactional data. It's getting to create subsets
- 30:10of people that you can then tailor the experience to or
- 30:13tailor your product reps to. The question then becomes is OK,
- 30:16how are you? How is that going to benefit
- 30:18your customers? If you can find the times we'll
- 30:20use case well that we think it's going to give a value in XY and
- 30:23Z and and then you can measure it, great.
- 30:25But if it's, well we haven't got a clue then it's not a valuable
- 30:28feature for you. Personally that's my way way of
- 30:31doing it and I think it's a really good scrutiny to add
- 30:33after demos. That makes sense.
- 30:38I think the the other one that you've written down here that I
- 30:40think is really key is Rd., fat and rate of innovation.
- 30:45And I guess again bringing it back to like Shopify World, that
- 30:49there's obviously lots of change around Shopify with markets, the
- 30:52new checkout, you know, POS, extensions like, yeah,
- 30:57functions, whatever else. And I think having a partner is
- 31:01immediately focused on staying on top of those things and
- 31:05supporting things. Like there's plenty of examples
- 31:08without calling them out too much.
- 31:09Like mention me is a good example of someone isn't
- 31:12compatible with the new checkout in Shopify and that stuff's
- 31:15critical as well to be perfectly honest.
- 31:18Yeah. And I've had a number of clients
- 31:19that had to wait to do the new check out because of different
- 31:23third parties. And I think, yeah, like making
- 31:26sure that you've that they've got actual development resource
- 31:29focused on improving the product, improving
- 31:31compatibility, introducing new features, introducing new
- 31:36integrations with like the challenges in the ecosystem.
- 31:40Yeah, I think that's pretty critical as well.
- 31:43Yeah, it is. And then we talked about a lot,
- 31:45but cost is obviously fundamental to this.
- 31:48But there I think sometimes people underestimate costs and
- 31:50you've touched on it a few times because you've license fee is 1,
- 31:54some vendors will negotiate, others won't.
- 31:56So you've got to factor that in, how much can you push people and
- 32:01negotiation can vary across E constructs as well.
- 32:04So sometimes you find variation how much you negotiate on like a
- 32:08magenta versus a big commerce versus a Shopify for a third
- 32:10party. You've got the integration
- 32:14upfront fee and then the maintenance complexity that adds
- 32:17to your ongoing support maintenance.
- 32:19That's great. Those are the obvious costs.
- 32:20I think everyone, everyone who's in an E com team who's gone
- 32:23through event selections will understand that and we'll
- 32:25discuss that commercially. The one that that gets missed is
- 32:30and it comes back to resource and is time and effort to use
- 32:33the tool. If if one tool has a perceived
- 32:37benefit in the fact that it's quicker for you to get to market
- 32:40with setting up campaigns. So take a take a product
- 32:43discovery engine. If it's quicker for you to go
- 32:45and set up like a a search campaign, set up a redirect or
- 32:49to create a promotion or to set up category merchandising rules
- 32:53and visually change the grid and sort autism work, You know,
- 32:57merge algorithms, curated manual merchandising, whatever you
- 33:00might do or insert hero content into a grid.
- 33:03If one tool allows you to do that far quicker and you can
- 33:06timestamp that and go right, it's going to cost.
- 33:08I'll stand a campaign site an hour's work on this tour and
- 33:10it's 45 minutes and another one if you If you can't play that
- 33:13across a year, how much is that saving you in time that's used
- 33:17for other value add task And that's a bit I'd encourage
- 33:20people to think about as well. The bigger the team, the more
- 33:23impact that has in your cost analysis.
- 33:27Yeah, yeah, I think that makes sense.
- 33:29One thing we haven't talked about on this list that I think
- 33:33can be important or at least dependent on your team can be
- 33:37very beneficial. It's service.
- 33:39So you know, having good account managers, solution architects
- 33:42like just having good support when things go wrong.
- 33:45But yeah, I think that can make a big difference.
- 33:47And actually a few of the vendors that we've talked about
- 33:50today have had periods where they've maybe not resourced that
- 33:53as well. And I think that has, yeah, had
- 33:56a big impact. And equally, there's some people
- 33:58in the industry that do that really well, Clay, who do
- 34:01support really well, so do taglies and a few others.
- 34:04And I think that does make a difference and allows you to get
- 34:06more. Active on it, yeah, 100%.
- 34:09It's a really good point and it's a great one for us to end
- 34:11on and and service goes from initial engagement and my my
- 34:15personal take on this is, is if a a technology company only puts
- 34:21salespeople into the pre sales process and don't give you any
- 34:25technical person who can help you understand and articulate
- 34:28proper like integration challenges.
- 34:31Then it always concerns me because you should have a pre
- 34:35sales technical specialist who is able to buy interface with IQ
- 34:39development counterparts or more technically LED ecom leads
- 34:43because there are some ecom businesses work with where the
- 34:46ecom lead is a very technical focus person.
- 34:48You've got to have somebody who can who can't just go yes we can
- 34:51do that. But actually talk about that
- 34:52integration part about how the API works, talk about how they
- 34:55ensure the API performance, give you some metrics on like
- 34:59response times etcetera. And yeah, and then the the
- 35:04support from AI, guess a customer success point would be
- 35:07plus the ongoing technical access.
- 35:09So if there is an issue or if there is a a future integration
- 35:13problem that there is a technical person on hand to work
- 35:16with your devs. So yeah, really important point.
- 35:19Anything else we need to mention before we close this off?
- 35:21Because I feel like we've probably covered quite a lot of
- 35:24useful grounds for people, but then I'm biased.
- 35:28The the only other one thing I'd say that I think so obviously
- 35:32the last episode we did was with Hannah Spicer and I always I've
- 35:36used her as an example at some other people.
- 35:39So obviously the big part of Clavio is growth was them
- 35:42building out the ecosystem and like the service industry
- 35:46around. And I think I always say with
- 35:49Clavio, one of the reasons why I love it so much is you can
- 35:53migrate over to Clavio and can bring someone like Hannah Spicer
- 35:56in and pay 1015 grand and then she will do all of the work.
- 36:00That'll probably take a year in another, it'll work with another
- 36:04vendor. So I think I really like that as
- 36:07well like having a like an ecosystem specialists around the
- 36:10product and being able to outsource if you want to or
- 36:13having really solid documentation to do stuff, if
- 36:16you want to bring someone another team and stuff like
- 36:18that. So I think that goes a long way
- 36:20as well. Yes, yeah, really nice.
- 36:22Really nice point And that was a great and for anyone who
- 36:25listened who didn't catch that episode, it's about what's
- 36:27what's hot and trending an e-mail marketing and like using
- 36:30tools like Playbo to improve your your e-mail and strategy.
- 36:33So well worth listening. Look, thanks for listening
- 36:36everyone. We hope you found that useful.
- 36:38Give us a shout, hit us up and comments on LinkedIn or DM me
- 36:41and Paul directly. Anything we've said that you
- 36:43don't agree with anything you want to build on or what's
- 36:46what's your tips and advice. But you know whether you go for
- 36:49all in one or whether you pick best in breed or or specific
- 36:52capabilities. And make sure you're following
- 36:54Inside Commerce on LinkedIn as well.
- 36:56And we've got the Inside Commerce newsletter on LinkedIn.
- 36:58It goes out every two weeks that you can subscribe to.
- 37:00Thanks for listening. Take care everyone.
- 37:04You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 37:06Experience consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 37:09Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 37:12featuring interviews with leading e-commerce, retailers,
- 37:15industry thoughtless and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 37:17explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 37:20and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 37:22really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 37:25to help fine tune your ecom strategy and text.
- 37:29Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James Report if you'd
- 37:31like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 37:33We hope you enjoy the latest episode.