Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / "Parental rights" legislation explained by Lance (The Serfs)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Moameir and this is Van Klor,
- 0:20British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics TV talk show. We got a
- 0:25hell of a show for you tonight. For all my gripes about the lack
- 0:28of social housing and BC, let's talk about an innovative social housing health center
- 0:33project in Vancouver's downtown east Side and how it will set the standard for much
- 0:38needed social housing in this province. But first, you may have heard of
- 0:42the introduction of parental rights legislation in several provinces including New Brunswick, Saskatchewan and
- 0:49Alberta, all seemingly supported by Conservative Party of Canada leader Pier Paoliev. But
- 0:54will this legislation cause more harm than good? Here to discuss is a Meti
- 0:59comedian and entertainer. You can find him on The Surfs, the largest Canadian
- 1:03political show on Twitch, which is a live video streaming service. In case
- 1:07you're unaware, he is Lance of the Serfs. Lance. What an honor.
- 1:12Thanks for being here tonight, Dan, Thanks for having me. That
- 1:15was really nice. Intro. Oh absolutely, So let's try to make sense
- 1:18of this parental rights legislation. What are we talking about when we're talking about
- 1:23parental rights legislation. Right, So parental rights, it sounds really good,
- 1:26right, Obviously, I don't think anyone wants to be on the other side
- 1:29of the issue. That's why you often proparent Yeah, exactly right. I
- 1:32think we all are. And that's why you might hear them say things like
- 1:34parental rights or protect the kids or things like that. And it's often worded
- 1:38in a way in that it's going to incite something inside you. You're going
- 1:41to feel, you know, maybe duty calls. I should be backing this
- 1:44without knowing everything about it. Right. When you actually get into what these
- 1:47bills do, they can be very harmful to children. It's kind of like
- 1:49one of those things where it's ironic. It's framed in such a way that
- 1:53you think, hey, this actually might actually help kids, Whereas at the
- 1:56end of the day, LGBTQ plus kids exist, they go to school like
- 2:00everybody else, and these are going to both target them and other them.
- 2:02So let's get into some of this legislation that we're actually talking about. In
- 2:07Brunswick and Saskatchewan, students under sixteen who are questioning their gender identity have to
- 2:14get parental consent before teachers can use their preferred first names or pronouns or gender
- 2:19identity. Even if the teacher wants to use them, they're not allowed.
- 2:23It's far more expansive in Alberta, where upcoming legislation includes a similar piece about
- 2:29preferred names and pronouns, but also includes the following. Top and bottom surgeries
- 2:34are banned for youth under seventeen, and I'll note that bottom surgeries are already
- 2:38not performed on youth. Hormone therapies for gender affirmation is banned for youth under
- 2:43fifteen, and parents will have to opt in for any time a teacher plans
- 2:47to teach about gender identity and sexual orientation. So, for folks unfamiliar with
- 2:53these policies, what is the harm that potentially could be done to trans youth
- 2:59or non binary youth? So, just to be clear for a lot of
- 3:01these things, when you hear about gender firm in care, if it happens
- 3:05to involve a kid who's anywhere between let's say the ages of like three and
- 3:07eight, gender firm in care takes the form of using different names and pronouns,
- 3:12but there's no surgeries, there's no hormone replacement there's no puberty blockers.
- 3:15That happens once someone enters puberty. So for a lot of the age demographic
- 3:21that people are usually talking about when they talk about protect the kids or save
- 3:23the kids, it has nothing to do with surgeries, it has nothing to
- 3:27do with hormones. It just it sounds a lot more incendiary, or it
- 3:29just it makes for better headlines, right, you see something like that.
- 3:32The reality is is that a lot of these children, they are going to
- 3:36be going to school like everyone else. They should feel safe like everyone else.
- 3:38And I don't think that there's anything controversial about using pronouns the same way
- 3:43we have our entire lives, right, Right, Like if someone asks you,
- 3:45hey, by the way, i'm e him, I assume yeah,
- 3:49We've been doing that our whole lives. It's not difficult or complex, right.
- 3:52And so for children who might be trans which is a very small percentage
- 3:55of the population, they, like anyone else, should be able to feel
- 3:59safe. That's basically where I would start with that. When you're bringing up
- 4:01the fact that this has been brought up in other places like say New Brunswick,
- 4:04right, something that should be emphasized here is that a Freedom of Information
- 4:09Act revealed that there had been no complaints to parents or storry to teachers from
- 4:14parents on the behalf of this is something where I don't know about my kids'
- 4:17pronouns, or this is a problem like this was not an issue that was
- 4:20concerning parents. This is an issue that seems to be thrust upon parents.
- 4:24And then once it becomes part of the zeitgeist, the culture wars, or
- 4:27whatever you want to call it, all of a sudden we're having a discussion
- 4:30like this where it's like, well, is this about protecting kids, is
- 4:32it about keeping them sacking? Or is it just about politics? Or is
- 4:34it just about politics? Right? And again, I'm sure you know there's
- 4:38enough problems in the world right now. You've seen in the headlines and stuff.
- 4:41There's probably things that should concern voters or people who want politicians to represent
- 4:45them to be enacting in the real world, not targeting a problem that is
- 4:48effectively only going to make a marginalized community their lives harder. Right. That's
- 4:54so interesting. I mean, I feel like even when you look at these
- 4:58laws, there are a lot of things that are in consistent. As I
- 5:00said, bottom surgeries aren't performed on youth as far as I know as far
- 5:03as I've read, but even top surgeries, they have been performed cosmetically on
- 5:09youth and no one seemed to have an issue with that. But now under
- 5:13this lens of LGBTQ or trans kids, politicians suddenly have an issue with it.
- 5:17Right, Well, I mean, the same thing applies to puberty blockers.
- 5:19Pubity blockers have been given to CIS children, children who are not trans
- 5:24for a very long time. It's actually FDA approved to use preity blockers,
- 5:28sorry, puberty blockers in the United States for the purposes if you have a
- 5:30kid who's got precocious puberty the answered puberty too quickly. That's not controversial.
- 5:34It'suddenly controversial when it's used as a form of gender of ferman care. And
- 5:39I should add too that puberty blockers, the whole intent behind them is to
- 5:42be able to give someone a pause or an extension of time to be able
- 5:45to make a decision about whether or not they go on hormone replacement therapy.
- 5:48So doctors, physicians, anyone who deals with gender ferming care, they want
- 5:54kids to be off puberty blockers as quickly as possible, right Because this is
- 5:57just something that is again supposed to grant to some time to be able to
- 6:00make a very important decision. And whether it is puberty blockers or hormone replacement
- 6:04therapy therapy, there is a medical protocol for these things. That it's not
- 6:10like you just go to the pharmacist and pick up those drugs. Yeah,
- 6:12well, I mean it sounds scarier sure, like at the idea that there's
- 6:15this revolving door between you walk into suddenly a clinic and they're like, I
- 6:18might be gay and they're like, oh, you're trends and they give you
- 6:21drugs or something. That's not the case at all. There's obviously, like
- 6:25anything else, there is a set of guidelines that have to be followed.
- 6:28There's a reason that every major medical association in the United States and most major
- 6:31medical associations in Canada all agree upon gender firm and care, that it's a
- 6:35valid form of healthcare that has incredible outcomes, that it can have life changing
- 6:40effects on kids who undergo these procedures. But again, it's only a very
- 6:44small percentage of children who actually are trends, right so this is something as
- 6:47small as that percentage it estimated zero point seven percent right now, Although youth
- 6:51gen z typically are reporting much higher levels of being LGBTQ plus. But that
- 6:58has a lot more to do with, like ex basically, the proliferation of
- 7:01social media and having information and access to that. But I think what this
- 7:05comes down to is the two of us we're having this discussion. We're not
- 7:09doctors, and we're not the parents of these kids. We're not the teachers
- 7:12of these kids. We're not the guardians of these children. These are discussions
- 7:15that should be between the parents, the doctors, and the kids. Sure
- 7:18yeah, not politicians, Not not Daniel Smith, you know, not somebody
- 7:23else saying that this is something that I should inject myself into. This is,
- 7:27like any other form of healthcare, something that should be between the patients,
- 7:30the doctors, and the parents. Let's talk about the parents, because
- 7:32even though obviously there's a whole basis of medical science behind this, we are
- 7:38seeing protests of parents protesting SOGI sexual orientation and gender identity resources in schools.
- 7:44We are seeing parents coming out in support of these parental rights legislations across the
- 7:49country. What would you say to those parents who are concerned about these things.
- 7:57I'd say that any parent's concerned about the welfare of that chill grin is
- 8:00completely valid. No one wants to take that away, and no one's trying
- 8:01to be on the other side of that issue. What the unfortunate reality is
- 8:05is that people have been sold in narrative on this in that it's simply much
- 8:11more dangerous or something that is insidious, almost as if it is like an
- 8:16influence, a social contangent, a mind virus, something like that. It
- 8:18has nothing to do with that. The reported rates of people who identify as
- 8:22trands, even if that number is going up higher right now, that number
- 8:26in the same way we used to persecute people who were left handed, for
- 8:28example, right if you look at the number of people who were left handed
- 8:31and who reported being left handed, that number spikes once we started, you
- 8:35know, not saying people who are left handed are a sinister or the devil
- 8:37or stuff like that, but then at plateaus at about twelve percent of the
- 8:39population. Right the same thing is happening right now to LGBTQ plus and trans
- 8:43people who are now being you know, they feel they're safe in an environment
- 8:46to be able to talk about this, and they're reporting you know, much
- 8:50higher numbers. But the idea that children can be turned trends or be turned
- 8:54gay is simply not based in science or reality. If that was the case,
- 8:58then there wouldn't be any you know, gay kids at all. I
- 9:03mean, well, the majority of media is straight, right, like the
- 9:05majority of love that you see on Disney or something like that. They're all
- 9:09straight relationships or stuff like that. So if you could be influenced by outside
- 9:11contagions to change you, there wouldn't be gay kids. So the idea like,
- 9:16that's why torture or sorry, well it is torture, but that's why
- 9:18conversion therapy is not effective at all, because you cannot turn kids gay anymore
- 9:22than you can turn them straight. The same thing applies to students. So
- 9:24the idea for parents who think, if my kid goes to school and when
- 9:28they're attending classes, there's going to be a teacher who might use data and
- 9:31pronouns that might influence my child, it simply doesn't bear out in science or
- 9:35reality. Fascinating, it does feel like it's old school fear tactics that it's
- 9:41in other groups as well, right, Yeah, it's recycling a lot of
- 9:43the gay panic. For now what is known as a trans panic. Yeah,
- 9:46yeah, Lance, this was a pleasure. Thanks so much for your
- 9:48time to thank you so much for having folks. That's lance from the serfs.
- 9:52Find the surfs all over social media, and if you're on Twitch,
- 9:56be sure to tune into their content over there. After some business, you
- 10:01know, I'm very critical about the lack of social housing in this province,
- 10:03but I have some optimism for you tonight, let's talk about a game changing
- 10:09new project in Vancouver's Chinatown with one of its biggest champions. Up next