Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Share Buybacks to Signal Confidence
Transcript
- Lucas: Apple shares are up over five percent this week, and while there's always a lot of noise in the market—iPhone sales, services revenue—one quiet factor that's been at work for years is their share buyback program. Luna: And Apple is famous for buybacks. I think last year they spent something like $110 billion on repurchases, right? Lucas: Exactly. Roughly $110 billion annually. That's more than the entire market cap of most companies. But the question I want to dig into today is: for a company that's been public for decades, buybacks are a mature capital return tool. What about younger post ipo companies? When do they start using buybacks, and what does it signal? Luna: Because a lot of the shiny new tech stocks—think of recent IPOs like Airbnb, Roblox, or even Rivian—they don't do buybacks. They're reinvesting everything into growth. Lucas: Right. And that's actually the norm for the first several years after an IPO. You're still in hypergrowth mode, you want to invest in R&D, sales, expansion. Buybacks only become relevant when you have consistent excess free cash flow and a more predictable growth trajectory. Luna: So when a post ipo company announces its first buyback, it's a milestone. It's like saying, 'We've matured, we're generating reliable cash, and we think our stock is cheap.' Lucas: That's the signaling effect. A buyback authorization tells the market: management believes the shares are undervalued. And it's a tangible commitment because they're putting real money behind that belief. Luna: But isn't there a risk that companies do buybacks just to boost earnings per share artificially? Even if the underlying business isn't doing great? Lucas: Absolutely. That's the dark side. By reducing the share count, you mechanically increase EPS. So a struggling company can mask deteriorating operations by buying back shares. The classic example is IBM a decade ago—they spent billions on buybacks while revenue was declining. It didn't end well. Luna: So the signal only works if investors trust management. And that trust is built on a track record of good capital allocation. Lucas: Right. There's also the question of financing. Some companies borrow to fund buybacks, which adds leverage. That can be fine if you're confident in future cash flows, but it increases risk if the economy turns. Luna: Let's look at current data. NVIDIA is down nine percent this week. They've been public since 1999, but they're still growing fast. Would a buyback make sense for them right now? Lucas: NVIDIA actually does have a buyback program—they authorized $25 billion last year. But they're also investing heavily in AI infrastructure. So they're balancing. A buyback at current levels could signal confidence, but they might prefer to keep cash for R&D or acquisitions. Luna: And that's the tension for every post ipo tech company: invest in future growth or return cash to shareholders. There's no one-size-fits-all answer. Lucas: Exactly. And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link—buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep this completely ad-free. We appreciate it. Lucas: So back to the buyback signal. One interesting recent case is Shopify. They went public in 2015, and for years they didn't do buybacks. But in 2023, they announced a $1.5 billion buyback, and shares jumped. That was a clear message that they believed the stock was undervalued after a post-pandemic dip. Luna: And Shopify is up over fifteen percent this week. But I think that's more about their recent earnings and new AI tools than buybacks. Lucas: Sure, but the buyback sets a floor of confidence. When a company is actively buying shares, it creates demand in the open market, especially if the program is executed consistently. Luna: What about the mechanics? Do they have to announce exactly how many shares they'll buy, or can they just say 'we may buy up to X dollars'? Lucas: Typically it's an authorization to buy a certain dollar amount over a period, like 18 months. They're not obligated to execute fully. But they usually do, because failing to follow through would damage credibility. Luna: So it's a commitment device. Once you announce, you'd better deliver. Lucas: Exactly. And the timing matters. Smart companies buy when the stock is low and slow down when it's high. Apple has been a master of that—they've repurchased heavily during dips. Luna: But for a younger company that's still unprofitable, buybacks are off the table. They need to conserve cash. Do you think we'll see more post ipo companies initiate buybacks as the IPO market heats up again? Lucas: It depends on how their businesses mature. The class of 2020 IPOs—like Airbnb, DoorDash, Snowflake—are now five years old. Some are profitable and generating cash. I wouldn't be surprised if we see some of them announce their first buybacks in the next year or two. Luna: That would be a major inflection point for them. A signal that they've entered a new phase as a public company. Lucas: And investors will be watching closely. Because a buyback program isn't just a financial tool—it's a statement about the company's future. And in a market where sentiment can shift fast, that statement matters. Luna: Agreed. And it's always a balance between confidence and hubris. Lucas: Alright, that's our angle this week. Next time we'll look at another post ipo capital markets strategy. Luna: See you then.