Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Where Do You Draw the Line Between Advocacy, Civility, and Ethical Conduct?
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Where Do You Draw the Line Between
- 0:06Advocacy, Civility, and Ethical Conduct? I am
- 0:10Laurie Critt -Martin, a certified family law
- 0:12specialist and former vice chair of the BHBA's
- 0:15litigation section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speakers, the Honorable Wendy Wilcox, John
- 0:21Ramey, Michelle Watkins, Grace Parrish, and Rupa
- 0:24Patel. And now let's get started with the program.
- 0:28Thank you so much on grace parish and as you
- 0:32know we're here to talk about where do you draw
- 0:34the line between advocacy civility and ethical
- 0:36conduct we have an amazing panel with us today
- 0:39and before we get into it i'd like to briefly
- 0:42introduce everyone judge wendy wilcox is now
- 0:45mediator with signature resolution she spent
- 0:48nearly six years on the bench. with the LA Superior
- 0:52Court following 23 years in private practice.
- 0:55Before taking the bench, she was a trial lawyer
- 0:57and founded and grew one of the largest women
- 1:00-owned litigation firms in California and Nevada.
- 1:03She brings an interesting perspective to our
- 1:05discussion today as an advocate, a judge, and
- 1:08now a neutral. As I mentioned, I'm Grace Parrish.
- 1:11I am an associate clinical professor at Loyola
- 1:13Law School and a director of our externship department.
- 1:17I currently teach ethics and litigation -related
- 1:19courses, and before joining academia, I was a
- 1:24litigator at a defense firm. Today's topic really
- 1:27brings together two parts of my career, both
- 1:29the professional obligations we teach and the
- 1:31judgment calls lawyers have to make when the
- 1:34client's interests are on the line. Next, Rupa
- 1:37Patel is a partner with MG &M and a member of
- 1:40the firm's complex litigation practice group.
- 1:43Her practice includes construction disputes,
- 1:45product liability, and business and corporate
- 1:47litigation. She's also served as a general and
- 1:50corporate counsel for construction companies.
- 1:52So she brings both a litigation and a business
- 1:55perspective to our discussion. Next, John Ramey
- 1:59is an attorney with Axe Law and an ABOTA member
- 2:01with more than 35 years of experience. He's tried
- 2:05more than 50 cases in state and federal courts
- 2:08and has extensive experience in construction
- 2:10defect and personal injury litigation. He's also
- 2:13a frequent lecturer in both areas. John brings
- 2:16the plaintiff's perspective along with his experience
- 2:18in trying cases and seeing how these choices
- 2:21play out in the courtroom. And finally, Michelle
- 2:23Watkins is an experienced litigator who candles
- 2:26complex high exposure matters involving construction,
- 2:30transportation, government entities and catastrophic
- 2:32injuries. She brings the perspective of a lawyer
- 2:35navigating cases where the stakes are high and
- 2:37where decisions about how hard to push have real
- 2:40consequences. So we really have a range of perspectives
- 2:44represented here today from the bench to mediation
- 2:47to plaintiff and defense practice, and of course,
- 2:49legal education. This is particularly useful
- 2:51for this topic because I think we're going to
- 2:53find out as we go through some of our scenarios
- 2:56that reasonable lawyers don't always draw these
- 2:59lines in exactly the same places. On the next
- 3:02slide, before we turn to the hypos that we have
- 3:05set for you, we'd like to start by defining the
- 3:08three concepts we're going to be talking about.
- 3:10First, advocacy. As lawyers, it's our job to
- 3:13advance our clients' positions. We use the facts.
- 3:15We use arguments and procedural tools available
- 3:19to us to move the case forward and really protect
- 3:21our clients' interests. And civility, it's really
- 3:24about how we conduct ourselves while we're doing
- 3:27that. How do we treat opposing counsel, the parties,
- 3:30the witnesses, the court, and whether we're actually
- 3:33contributing to a professional and functional
- 3:35process. Finally, ethics. It's my favorite subject
- 3:39right now. That's asked whether our conduct complies
- 3:44with our professional obligations, the rules
- 3:46of professional conduct, the law, the duties
- 3:49we owe to our clients, the court, and the profession.
- 3:53I think an important point for discussion today
- 3:56is that these are all related concepts, but they
- 3:58are not the same thing. Conduct can be aggressive
- 4:02advocacy without being unethical. Conduct can
- 4:05be uncivil without violating an ethical rule.
- 4:08And as we'll see, conduct can be perfectly civil
- 4:12in tone, but still raise ethical problems. We'd
- 4:17like you to view this in the next slide as three
- 4:20lenses, one decision. So for each of the hypotheticals
- 4:24today, we're going to look at the lawyer's conduct
- 4:27through three different lenses. First is the
- 4:29advocacy lens. Does it advance the client's position?
- 4:32Then the civility lens. What's the impact of
- 4:36the conduct on the process and on the other people
- 4:38that are involved? And finally, that ethical
- 4:40lens. Is it actually permitted? Right. This last
- 4:44question is a little bit different from asking
- 4:46whether we like the conduct, whether we think
- 4:48it's good practice, or even whether we would
- 4:50personally do it. The question is whether it
- 4:53actually crosses that ethical line. And that's
- 4:55kind of where the tension comes in. Something
- 4:58can be effective advocacy, but still be perceived
- 5:00as uncivil. And something can look completely
- 5:03civil, polite, professional, respectful, but
- 5:06raise a true ethical issue. So as we work through
- 5:09these hyphals, we'd like you to think about Where
- 5:12do you draw the line? Are you simply being a
- 5:15zealous advocate for your client? When we're
- 5:19still within the rules, are we making things
- 5:22unnecessarily difficult for the other side? And
- 5:26when have we crossed over from professionalism
- 5:29and civility into an actual ethical problem?
- 5:33Before we jump into our first hypo, we do want
- 5:36to get your opinions as well. So we will be polling
- 5:39you. How it's gonna work is for each hypothetical.
- 5:43I'll read the facts. Then our panelists will
- 5:46each take one of the three lenses that we just
- 5:48talked about. One will give advocacy position,
- 5:51one will give a civilian position, and one will
- 5:53give the ethics position. And as you listen to
- 5:55them give their positions, think about where
- 5:58you kind of land on that. And what you want,
- 6:00what we want you to vote on is whether you believe.
- 6:05what vote on the which lens you believe best
- 6:08describes the conduct we're talking about, advocacy,
- 6:11civility, or ethics. Then we'll look at the results
- 6:14together and then we'll talk to the panel and
- 6:17maybe come up with a conclusion. So with that
- 6:20in mind, let's jump into our first hypo. So our
- 6:25first hypo. Defense counsel requests destructive
- 6:28testing of the allegedly defective product plaintiff's
- 6:31counsel agrees but requires a detailed testing
- 6:34protocol limits where the testing might occur
- 6:36requires designated experts for both sides to
- 6:39be present and insists that parties agree on
- 6:42the protocol before testing proceeds. Let's talk
- 6:45about the advocacy lens first. Thanks, Grace.
- 6:50So First, let's talk about what's inbound. What
- 6:53can we ask about legally per the code? What is
- 6:56the protocol? And how can we do that in the best
- 7:00way so that we don't run foul of civility or
- 7:02ethical rules? So we're looking at civil code
- 7:06of procedure, 2031 .010. And that's the code
- 7:11of procedure that's going to apply whether you're
- 7:13asking for a demand for documents, photos, whether
- 7:15you want to test the functionality of a didgeridoo
- 7:18or a product, right? Or whether you want to do
- 7:21destructive testing of a building, whether you
- 7:22want to spray windows or take concrete cores
- 7:24in a garage. And it's a pretty liberal and broad
- 7:28code. What it tells you is that as a opposing
- 7:32party, right, you've got the ability to ask the
- 7:34plaintiff to test and plaintiff also has the
- 7:37ability to ask for the same thing. It is silent
- 7:40as a protocol and all it says about who has to
- 7:43be there or who may come is that it can be the
- 7:46party or anyone acting on the party's behalf.
- 7:50So what is the ask here? We're asking for the
- 7:52experts to come and an agreement for a detailed
- 7:55protocol. If you wanted to challenge that, the
- 7:59only way to do it is for you to file a motion
- 8:03for a protective order. And the grounds to do
- 8:05that would be privilege. Well, nothing here is
- 8:09privileged exactly, right? Burden or privacy.
- 8:13Depending on the protocol you come up with, maybe
- 8:15you could argue that it's a burden cost -wise,
- 8:18especially if you haven't retained an expert
- 8:20yet and opposing counsel is telling you the expert
- 8:22needs to be there. But let's think that through.
- 8:25Would you really want to tell your client to
- 8:28go through destructive testing and not have an
- 8:31expert there. You're going to need the expert
- 8:33there to observe it. Maybe there will be commentary
- 8:36or criticisms of the mechanisms or the equipment
- 8:40used for testing. So it's a good idea. If you
- 8:43wanted to file your motion for protective order,
- 8:45I don't think that the court would view this
- 8:47as unreasonable based upon the three grounds
- 8:50that are available to you for a protective order.
- 8:54That said, I also think if you're on the other
- 8:56side of this, it's not a crazy ask. Wouldn't
- 8:59you want your expert to be there? And wouldn't
- 9:01you want the protocol to be detailed? So everyone
- 9:03agrees upon the scope before you start, and there
- 9:06won't be any objections going forward. All right.
- 9:11How about the civility lens? Thank you. So from
- 9:15the civility perspective, The state bar has revised
- 9:18the civilian guidelines recently in September
- 9:21of 2026. So it's important that we're respectful
- 9:25and courteous, especially when this is a reasonable
- 9:27request. It's asking for a testing protocol.
- 9:31As long as none of this is done to delay or increase
- 9:35costs, the rules of civility seem to indicate
- 9:39that we should work with council and try to reach
- 9:41a resolution as amicably as possible. All right,
- 9:48how about the ethics lens? I think from an ethical
- 9:50perspective, it's really a balancing test, recognizing
- 9:53the need of the defense in this case to conduct
- 9:56a reasonable investigation and testing of the
- 9:59allegedly defective product and understanding
- 10:02that in doing so, there needs to be reasonable
- 10:04conditions associated with that. And that's where
- 10:07you have to look at. Are the conditions being
- 10:10requested or imposed by plaintiffs' counsel?
- 10:13reasonable in light of the need of the defendant
- 10:15to conduct their investigation and discovery.
- 10:18It seems clear that the limitations or the conditions
- 10:21are unreasonable and designed primarily to make
- 10:24it overly burdensome for the defense, the defense
- 10:27expert to conduct their investigation. That's
- 10:29crossing the ethical line. So again, I think
- 10:32it really comes down to balancing tests and weighing
- 10:34the needs of the defense versus the objectives
- 10:36of the plaintiff. Let's wrap up the polling.
- 10:42And see what the audience thinks so 63 % have
- 10:49described the conduct as advocacy. Anything Michelle
- 10:55since you took the advocacy lens into you, I'm
- 10:58sure you agree. It's all I have. Yeah, I do think
- 11:04that this is advocacy, right? You're protecting
- 11:07the evidence. And especially, you know, we're
- 11:10talking about a product, but if you want to extend
- 11:12this to real property, you want to know the scope
- 11:15before you start testing. Grace and I have had
- 11:17cases before where we were spray testing windows
- 11:20in a huge condominium complex over a number of
- 11:22days, right? You're going to want to let people
- 11:24know how invasive the testing is going to be,
- 11:26how long it's going to be there. Or if you've
- 11:28got a single family home and you're test taking
- 11:30core. out of a garage, how long they're not going
- 11:32to be able to access it, and how long it's going
- 11:34to look like Hurricane Katrina hit in their garage.
- 11:37So all of this is good practice, and all of this
- 11:40is everyone protecting their clients. Yeah. So
- 11:43what I really take from this is that putting
- 11:45the conditions on the Destructive Destiny is
- 11:47not the problem in and of itself, right? Protecting
- 11:51evidence is a perfectly good reason the real
- 11:53question is what are the conditions doing if
- 11:56they're protecting the evidence great if they
- 11:58keep stacking up and making the testing hard
- 12:01to do then I think that's something different
- 12:03kind of that balancing test that John talked
- 12:06about let's look at the next one. At mediation,
- 12:15defense counsel makes an opening offer far below
- 12:17the plaintiff's claimed medical expenses and
- 12:20states that there is little room to move. Throughout
- 12:22the mediation, defense counsel is polite, professional,
- 12:26and complimentary of plaintiff's counsel. Judge
- 12:29Wilcox, will you take us through the advocacy
- 12:31lens? Yikes. Okay, so I've had this before both
- 12:39in mandatory settlement conferences and mediation.
- 12:42And I appreciate counsel being polite and complimentary
- 12:48and professional. But I also think a lot of work
- 12:53needs to be done before you go into mediation
- 12:55or an MSc. And if you're at the point of the
- 13:01being far below the plaintiff's claimed medical
- 13:04expenses that a conversation is had before the
- 13:09mediation. So I'm going to assume that that occurred
- 13:12and that both sides know what they're going into
- 13:15the mediation or the MSC with knowing this from
- 13:20defense counsel. It's hard to take an advocacy
- 13:24position to this without the other side understanding
- 13:29where you're coming from. And if this is just
- 13:31the way that defense counsel is coming, it's
- 13:34tough. Other than to say that I do know that
- 13:37out there on the defense side, there's a lot
- 13:41of talk about anchoring, but that's in front
- 13:43of the jury. It's not appropriate conduct to
- 13:47me at a mediation or an MSC. So I'll... to just
- 13:52say, OK, maybe it's to test the plaintiff's settlement
- 13:56position or limit the client's exposure. Those
- 14:02are both with question marks. But I think that
- 14:05that's a tough one for advocacy for me personally,
- 14:09because I think both sides should go into it
- 14:12knowing what you're going into. And I'm sure
- 14:14that John Ramey is going to. chime in here because,
- 14:18and I, and I welcome that position too. Um, okay.
- 14:21That's what I have to say. It's a little cringy,
- 14:25but yes. Okay. That's what it is. Uh, moving
- 14:30to civility. I think that's me. So, all right.
- 14:35Tail is all this time, right? Puffery, uh, exaggerations,
- 14:41dramatics. We've all seen this. Maybe some of
- 14:44us have participated in it at mediation. Remember,
- 14:49our rule of stability that now we all have to
- 14:51renew annually. So it's an oath that we are going
- 14:54to pledge to act with dignity, we're going to
- 14:56act with courtesy, and we're going to act with
- 14:59integrity at all times, right? We also have a
- 15:01duty of candor. We have a duty of honesty. And
- 15:05some of us like to look at the business and professions
- 15:09code. We know that if you are overly zealous
- 15:13in your advocacy, you cannot run afoul of these
- 15:19ethical and civility rules, or you will be in
- 15:22violation actually of the Business and Professions
- 15:24Code as well. So why would you want to do something
- 15:28like this? Well, maybe it's just to let the other
- 15:30side know I've got a secret bomb, right? I've
- 15:35got a nuclear bomb. I'm not going to interrupt
- 15:37you, counsel, while you're making a mistake.
- 15:39And I can't release this nuclear bomb until later
- 15:41because I don't want to give you time to correct
- 15:43it. All you're doing at the mediation with that
- 15:46tactic is telegraphing that you have a nuclear
- 15:48bomb. Council is going to start thinking about
- 15:50it and saying, what am I missing? Why are they
- 15:53coming here with this lowball offer, right? It
- 15:56could just be a tactic. It could just be you
- 15:58maybe being less than honest. Either way, you're
- 16:00wasting everybody's time. And if, and if you're,
- 16:03if your idea was to hide something big that you're
- 16:06going to, you know, an October surprise, if you
- 16:08will, that you're going to announce later, you're
- 16:10telegraphing it to council. So it's a bad idea,
- 16:14particularly if it means you're going to run
- 16:16a foul of your civility obligations. All right.
- 16:20How about. When does it become an ethical issue?
- 16:24So a love all offer in and of itself is not an
- 16:28ethical issue, but it is fact specific. If you
- 16:31are affirmatively misrepresenting a material
- 16:34fact, that is where you cross the line in your
- 16:37ethics because they do allow puffing and bluffing
- 16:44a little bit in mediation, but it's when you're
- 16:46going beyond that to make statements that people
- 16:50are going to rely on. So, you know, if it's a
- 16:54misrepresentation of a material fact, if there
- 16:57is room to move or you say, you know, I only
- 17:01have X amount in the client has X amount of authority
- 17:06because that's how much their insurance policy
- 17:08is. And that's not a true statement. You know,
- 17:11that's independently verifiable the amount of
- 17:14limits they have. And that could be a problem.
- 17:16So it's really the Just stating that there's
- 17:20a little room to move in and of itself is not
- 17:22it is not an ethical violation, but it's the
- 17:25affirmative state misstatements and misrepresentation
- 17:29that becomes problem. I could just add to that
- 17:31maybe grace. I think oftentimes unfortunately
- 17:35it's a reflection of what the defense thinks
- 17:37of the plaintiff's opening demand. Uh, that they
- 17:40think it's somewhat excessive and reasonable.
- 17:43They're trying to send a message by making it
- 17:46a similarly in their mind and reasonable. Offer
- 17:49hopefully that may delay fruitful negotiations.
- 17:53You can move past that. I just want to add 1
- 17:571 thing to is when. I get something like this
- 18:02in mediation and when I would get it in the MSC,
- 18:06I look to find out where is this coming from?
- 18:09Is it coming from the principal or the insurance
- 18:12person or is this coming from the lawyer? Because
- 18:15for me, I need to know what I'm working with
- 18:18and we need to figure out where we're going,
- 18:20right? So it brings up a lot of great questions
- 18:24and I appreciate that. Right and as defense lawyers
- 18:28you think about why would you do this sometimes
- 18:30it's as John said because you're insult gravely
- 18:33insulted right at the opening demand but sometimes
- 18:35you know they've got a terrible expert that's
- 18:38been disqualified three times and you're sitting
- 18:40on it right but As I said, if you have some information
- 18:45that you know affects the value of the case,
- 18:47you doing this, not only is it going to insult
- 18:50everyone and waste everyone's time, but it telegraphs
- 18:53a little bit to the other side that you may be
- 18:56onto something. Should we see what the audience
- 19:00thinks? Yeah, let's see. I don't know what, oh,
- 19:05there we go. So we got a little bit mixed, 57
- 19:08% advocacy. And then the next was civility at
- 19:1126%. Anybody have thoughts on that? Nobody really
- 19:17voted ethics, but I will throw it in there, because
- 19:21being the ethics professor and teaching all of
- 19:25these rules, when I do talk about negotiations,
- 19:29I give the car example in terms of what would
- 19:32you be mad about the car salesman in terms of
- 19:34how he negotiated with you. But we always look
- 19:37at 4 .1 under the rules of professional conduct
- 19:39and think about, are we drawing the line in terms
- 19:42of Driving a hard bargain, or is this really
- 19:46crossing the line into a misrepresentation? So.
- 19:50Let's get into the next one. Defense counsel
- 19:56produces thousands of documents that pages are
- 19:59thousands of pages of project documents in a
- 20:01disorganized format. Technically responsive and
- 20:04based labeled, but difficult to navigate. John,
- 20:09you have thoughts on advocacy. We have a good
- 20:11standpoint. We have to look at the code and what
- 20:13the code requires in that regard. Here, we're
- 20:16looking at CCP 2031 .280 paragraph A. Until about
- 20:23six years ago, all you had to do was to produce
- 20:26documents kept in the usual course of business
- 20:29as they were. Effective in 2020, however, we
- 20:33now are required to make sure that the documents
- 20:37are at least identified in relation to the specific
- 20:40request number that they're being produced in
- 20:43response to. So that's what you have to really
- 20:45look at. And I think so long as you're complying
- 20:49with the requirements in that code section, the
- 20:52new code section, I guess I'll refer to it as,
- 20:55then you are fulfilling your obligation to that
- 20:58code section. And you're not required to spend
- 21:00hours and hours organizing the documents for
- 21:03opposing counsel. So again, I think if you've
- 21:06satisfied the code requirement, then you're perfectly
- 21:09fine in doing that. Judge Wilcox, do you have
- 21:13anything on civility? Well, I don't think it's
- 21:17civil to do that. Also, you have to think about
- 21:23that when you're baits labeling, you don't want
- 21:26it in a disorganized format. It's just going
- 21:28to make your life harder too, especially if you
- 21:32move it into an exhibit binder for trial. You
- 21:37also have to do it in such a way where it responds
- 21:40to each of the document requests, and you have
- 21:43to identify those numbers. So it's going to make
- 21:46it that much more difficult for you and the other
- 21:48side, because you do have to identify those numbers.
- 21:53And so it just increases time unnecessarily to
- 21:58me. And like I said, I don't think it's civil.
- 22:03It doesn't help you. It doesn't help the other
- 22:06side. And it is intentionally burdensome to me.
- 22:15Michelle, does it matter how it was produced?
- 22:17It does matter ethically. So we all have a duty
- 22:21to abide by the Discovery Act, right? We also,
- 22:25California Rule Corps 1 .1, have a duty to conduct
- 22:29discovery with competence. So John gave you the
- 22:32code section and it basically now prevents us
- 22:35from the document dump, right? Producing a disorganized
- 22:39heap, which is my favorite thing during a deposition,
- 22:41a disorganized heap of 5 ,000 documents. without
- 22:45matching the files to a specific request. I think
- 22:48we bid for you to do. This is now a violation
- 22:52of code. And if you're violating the code and
- 22:54you're doing so knowingly, that is also against
- 22:57your ethical obligations. So there are ethical
- 23:00concerns involved in this. What does the audience
- 23:05think? Oh, now we're really split. 27 % advocacy,
- 23:1434 % civility, 39 % ethics. I feel like we took
- 23:19this from my lecture this morning because I spent
- 23:2090 minutes on discovery and talking about how
- 23:24we produce things in reasonably usable formats
- 23:26and what that means. And if I added another fact
- 23:29into this fact pattern, I think we'd get more
- 23:31into Michelle's ethics question when you produce
- 23:34things in PDF and then you make it unsearchable.
- 23:38I remember these are the days I don't miss where
- 23:42I have to do doc review and some of you still
- 23:44do is having. Council come back and say, no,
- 23:47you do need to match up every document to those
- 23:50requests and go back through your thousands of
- 23:52pages and tell me the baits range for each one.
- 23:55So I think in this part, it depends, right? Like
- 23:58they are technically compliant in some ways,
- 24:00but are we doing it and dumping it in a way or
- 24:04producing it in a way that, you know, kind of
- 24:07crosses the line a little bit. But I think as
- 24:10to Judge Wilcox's point, we're also just making
- 24:13it harder for ourselves. if we're not doing it
- 24:16right the first time. Next hypo, plaintiff's
- 24:23council sends a polished respectful meet and
- 24:26confer letter outlining deficiencies in plaintiff's
- 24:28discovery responses. The letter cites authority,
- 24:31avoids inflammatory language, and invites resolution.
- 24:34At the same time, it could be viewed as mischaracterizing
- 24:37what was actually produced to strengthen a future
- 24:39motion. Rupa? So from an advocacy perspective,
- 24:44it is okay to write a respectful meeting for
- 24:47a letter where you outline the deficiencies as
- 24:50you see it. And that is advocating the position
- 24:52for your client in terms of their deficient discovery
- 24:55responses. You know, you invite a resolution
- 24:58and now the code requires that parties meet and
- 25:02confer either telephonically, remotely or in
- 25:05person. So if there's any issues with the framing
- 25:09of the initial meet confer letter, whether it
- 25:12mischaracterizes anything, you know, there could
- 25:14be the discussion that is had to clarify anything.
- 25:18But as long as you're being an advocate as to
- 25:21what your position is, as you see it in site
- 25:23authority, you can do that. And then the other
- 25:27side can raise any issues with mischaracterization
- 25:29during the actual meet confer that's required
- 25:32by the code. John, this looks good on the civility
- 25:36point. I think it is. Again, if it's using appropriate
- 25:41and professional language and citing to particular
- 25:45requests that are deemed to be insufficient,
- 25:48inviting resolution is important, I think, as
- 25:50part of a media confer. I guess my problem would
- 25:53be if it's mischaracterizing some aspect of the
- 25:57response, then I think it's appropriate for you
- 26:00to write back and point that out. in a similarly
- 26:03professional and civil manner. Otherwise, I think
- 26:06that's the way media conferred literacy should
- 26:07be, always should be written and refraining from
- 26:10personal insults or accusations or anything of
- 26:12that nature. Judge Wilcox, does a professional
- 26:15tone matter in our ethics analysis? It does matter,
- 26:21but I do think the same as John as far as if
- 26:25it could be viewed as mischaracterizing what
- 26:30took place. And I would get, A lot of discovery
- 26:34motions, you know, when I was on the bench and
- 26:37I would jump to the discovery requests and the
- 26:41responses as well as I would look at those first
- 26:45to see what are those issues with which discovery
- 26:48requests and responses there are and then go
- 26:51back to the letter for the timing because if
- 26:55it is a timing thing, I think that's important
- 26:58and. And here we don't know exactly what is being
- 27:01mischaracterized. But the mischaracterization
- 27:06part, I do think for the purpose of strengthening
- 27:11emotion is an issue because then it translates
- 27:16to what you're going to represent to the court.
- 27:20And it's really not necessary because if it is
- 27:23based on timing, it's easy. To document that
- 27:26right because it's all in typically emails so
- 27:31that's not going to help your position in court
- 27:34necessarily. Alright, let's see what the audience
- 27:38thinks so 45 % split between advocacy and ethics.
- 27:46I actually think that's probably a good split
- 27:49in where it probably should land. because this
- 27:53is really where civility and ethics are separate
- 27:55lenses letters great it's professional respectful
- 27:58sites authority but then if we have a misstatement
- 28:02of what's actually produced you know the tone
- 28:04doesn't cover that up the tone doesn't ever fix
- 28:06that and we still have to think about you know
- 28:08the duty of candor both to the court and to the
- 28:11opposing council in how we communicate and what
- 28:15we're communicating um next next hypo Okay, in
- 28:23a construction accident case, the subcontractors
- 28:25council notices the general contractors notices
- 28:28the general contractors PMK deposition on 10
- 28:31days notice as trial approaches. The general
- 28:34contractors council requests a 2 -week continuance
- 28:36due to conflicting depots and trial prep and
- 28:39other matters. The subcontractors council refuses
- 28:42citing the approaching trial date in compliance
- 28:45with the CCP. Michelle, you want to take a stab
- 28:49at advocacy? Sure. So what part of the code are
- 28:52we in? We're in 2025 .23 up, right? And all it
- 28:56says is 10 calendar days. That's the requirement
- 28:59for a notice of deposition. Now this hypothetical
- 29:02is silent on how it was served. We don't know.
- 29:06We may add a couple of days for the method of
- 29:08service, but let's assume they did this properly
- 29:10and it was hand -served and you have a flat 10
- 29:12days. This is advocacy, right? We are up against
- 29:17a looming trial date. This is a critical witness
- 29:20that needs to be deposed. We know there's no
- 29:23limit in the code for a PMK deposition. This
- 29:26could go a couple of days. So we need to get
- 29:28all of the testimony and all of the categories
- 29:30out prior to trial. And as the person who noticed
- 29:35this deposition, I'm well within my rights in
- 29:37the code to notice it when I did. You've had
- 29:39enough notice. Is it a civil thing to do? Is
- 29:42it a nice thing to do? Is it an ethical thing
- 29:44to do? That's another question. You are zealously
- 29:49advocating for your client by holding firm to,
- 29:51I follow the code. Here's the notice of deposition.
- 29:54If you fail to produce your client, we'll put
- 29:56it before the court, but I follow the code. All
- 30:01right, Rupa. But I think from a civility perspective,
- 30:04there is a reason for why the subcontractors
- 30:06council is refusing. It's exciting approaching
- 30:09trial date. And I think that is an important
- 30:12factor. If you're just refusing for the sake
- 30:14of refusing, just saying, well, there's the code.
- 30:17I follow the code. You have to follow the code.
- 30:19I think that's where civility is lost. But as
- 30:24long as you're not prejudicing your client by
- 30:27granting a short continuance, kicking this out
- 30:30doesn't seem to be unreasonable, but here when
- 30:33the council is citing an actual reason that seems
- 30:37reasonable and will, could impact their client,
- 30:39you know, the approaching trial date, I think
- 30:42the response is simple. John? Ethical perspective,
- 30:49really looking at, you know, the reasoning behind
- 30:52why the notice was served with minimum 10 days
- 30:56notice. Was there an effort made? to mean to
- 30:58confer on dates before the notice was sent out.
- 31:02If the attorney is refusing to postpone or move
- 31:07the deposition, why are they doing that? Is that
- 31:10for legitimate purpose or are they simply trying
- 31:13to be difficult and create, I think, probably
- 31:17problematic relationship with opposing counsel?
- 31:21So, you know, I think in a situation like that,
- 31:24from an ethical perspective, you really want
- 31:25to Try to work with opposing counsel that kind
- 31:27of bleeds over to civility as well. But really
- 31:30what's the intent here behind the short notice,
- 31:33the minimum notice that's provided and the reason
- 31:35for counsel refusing to produce the witness in
- 31:38response to that notice. Okay. How does the audience
- 31:42feel? So split between advocacy and civility.
- 31:51I don't necessarily disagree with that. I think
- 31:56kind of both on Michelle, what you said. You're
- 32:00entitled to you to notice your deposition but
- 32:03then there were other points brought up in terms
- 32:04of you know why are we refusing or did we meet
- 32:08and confer over depot dates i mean that's just
- 32:10the nice thing to do and the professional thing
- 32:12i always remember when people unilaterally you
- 32:16know notice depots i would cite back to the civility
- 32:18code and say you should at least confirm and
- 32:22ask me about dates first before you just unilaterally
- 32:25set this depot michelle no just kidding. I hand
- 32:29served it. So I know within the rules can still
- 32:34feel a little uncivil and if it's tactical and
- 32:38depending on why we're either noticing without
- 32:41asking each other or refusing to a continuance,
- 32:45right? Okay, next hypo. At mediation, defense
- 32:54counsel is courteous, engaged and respectful.
- 32:57represents having full authority, but in reality
- 33:00has a capped number and no real flexibility.
- 33:03Of course, we want to hear from Judge Wilcox
- 33:05as to what she feels about this. Where do I get
- 33:07both of these? For the advocate part. John, you
- 33:13need to speak up. So the person has full authority,
- 33:19so there's that. However, I think the thing that
- 33:25bothers me a little bit is the latter part of
- 33:28that sentence saying, but in reality has a cap
- 33:30number and no real flexibility. So the full authority
- 33:35part is the advocacy part, right? You're representing
- 33:40your client with the full authority that you
- 33:42have, and you're there to do that, which I think
- 33:44is important. But the latter part of the sentence,
- 33:49I'll leave to the other two positions to be asserted,
- 33:54because they're I think they fall in those to
- 33:57me. I think we should hear from everybody on
- 34:00this one, but we'll go with Michelle and civility
- 34:02first. Okay. So we're back to our puffery and
- 34:07I like to call this one the stick, right? You're
- 34:10going to stick to your position all through the
- 34:12mediation. It doesn't matter if it's Monday,
- 34:14Tuesday, Christmas and you're sticking. So we're
- 34:18back to rule nine, seven, right? Are we being
- 34:21professional? Is this a professional thing to
- 34:23do? Are we being courteous? This is an oath we
- 34:25take annually. Is that the courteous thing to
- 34:28do? Show up at mediation and pull a stick and
- 34:31not tell the other side that we're pulling the
- 34:33stick or we're just representing that we have
- 34:35full authority. On the other hand, How many of
- 34:39us have been to these mediations where you know
- 34:41maybe it's a it's a huge case like a construction
- 34:43defect case and you know your client has minimum
- 34:47minimal exposure and you're just there to put
- 34:49up the cost of defense so while the other side
- 34:52may think you're off for a small that is your
- 34:55full authority right you're there literally to
- 34:57put up the cost of defense because there's no
- 35:00liability or at least there's not enough connective
- 35:02tissue for you between their theories of liability
- 35:04and damages right for you to put up more so you
- 35:07You really have to ask yourself when you're thinking
- 35:09about this through the civility lens, am I being
- 35:12professional? Am I being courteous? Am I being
- 35:14honest? Am I actually complying with the ethical
- 35:20rules that would kind of make me run afoul of
- 35:23the civility rules as well? Rupa? So ethically,
- 35:29attorneys have a duty to be truthful. representing
- 35:31you have full authority, but in reality, that
- 35:33may not be the case and you have no flexibility.
- 35:36It does seem a problem ethically. Now, there
- 35:40could be differing understandings of what full
- 35:43authority means in the context of your case,
- 35:45as Michelle discussed, because maybe there's
- 35:48coverage limitations. Maybe there's a limited
- 35:51amount of policy available. But I do think that
- 35:56with this scenario, the representing having full
- 36:00authority when in reality you have a cap number
- 36:03and no real flexibility does not seem like you're
- 36:06being very truthful to the parties. I could just
- 36:10add to that. Go ahead. I was going to turn it
- 36:13to you before you heard from the audience. I
- 36:15know you have something to say. It's an interesting
- 36:17term, full authority. What does that really mean?
- 36:21I think that's my issue. they have a number they're
- 36:26coming in with, that's all they have, then why
- 36:29are you there? Mediation is a voluntary process
- 36:32and you've got to be flexible coming in with
- 36:36a goal and expectation of trying to get the settlement
- 36:39for your full authority, but having the ability
- 36:42to go back and get more if that's not enough,
- 36:45but you're in a situation where you can settle
- 36:47a case for reasonable value. I think that's true.
- 36:52And sometimes, you know, I've had a case with
- 36:53John before where I did the stick, right? My
- 36:57client and I did the stick and we weren't moving.
- 36:59We offered one thing and that's what we were
- 37:01offering every time we came. But I knew that
- 37:05my obligation was I had a general contractor.
- 37:08So my obligation was to get the parties who actually
- 37:10owed my client indemnity to get their dollars
- 37:13up. And maybe when you're saying full authority,
- 37:18you think about it in the broader context of
- 37:20the mediation. If you've got other parties there
- 37:22who maybe owe your client a defense or who don't,
- 37:25or maybe it's just joint and several, but you
- 37:28know that they need to come up, having full authority
- 37:31may also mean doing what you need to do to make
- 37:34sure everybody is where they need to be for mediation.
- 37:39Let's see what the audience thinks. So 33 % advocacy,
- 37:4612 % civility, 55 % ethics. So I'm just gonna
- 37:49throw out that ethics, the rule of professional
- 37:52conduct out there, 4 .1, truthfulness and negotiations.
- 37:56And what I always harp in on my students is there's
- 38:00a fine line between negotiations and misrepresentation
- 38:04and misleading. So I think. Kind of this hypo
- 38:07is kind of the best example of why we need all
- 38:093 lenses is that the lawyers, civil, the lawyers,
- 38:12demeanors, nice, they're engaged or respectful.
- 38:15But they're kind of creating a false impression
- 38:17about something that's really material and a
- 38:19misrepresentation, perhaps, depending on, again,
- 38:21what we think full authority means, right? I
- 38:24was like, what do we mean when we come and say,
- 38:27do you have full authority? So you can be perfectly
- 38:30civil and still obviously mislead, oppose and
- 38:33counsel and good manners and good ethics are
- 38:35not the same thing. I did want to pause really
- 38:39quickly because I noticed there are some questions
- 38:41in the chat and so we'll try to get to those
- 38:44once we finish the hypos. Hopefully we'll have
- 38:47a little bit of room to answer those questions.
- 38:52Hypo seven. During the depo of plaintiff, defense
- 38:55counsel repeatedly challenges the plaintiff's
- 38:57answers, uses a sharp tone, asks the same questions
- 39:00in different ways. After receiving answers, counsel
- 39:02believes are evasive. Plaintiff's counsel objects
- 39:05that the questioning is argumentative and asked
- 39:07defense counsel to move on. John, you're on deck.
- 39:12I think from an advocate standpoint, it's really
- 39:15a matter of Is the witness avoiding the question,
- 39:19not answering the question? And I think in that
- 39:21situation, you're perfectly right in essentially
- 39:27pressing for the testimony, the question to be
- 39:30answered. And I think in that situation, the
- 39:34more the objections come in, the more I think
- 39:37that there's coaching going on there and they're
- 39:40trying to have. their client avoid answering
- 39:42the questions. So I think it's very fair that
- 39:45you would press on. I mean, there is the Los
- 39:47Angeles Superior Court rule regarding guidelines
- 39:50for civility that talks about how counsel should
- 39:52refrain from repetitive or argumentative questions
- 39:55or ask solely for purposes of harassment. So
- 39:58if that's the intent, then that's problematic.
- 40:01If the issue really, though, is one where you're
- 40:03not getting the answer to the question, I think
- 40:05you're entitled to take a more aggressive approach.
- 40:09Judge Wilcox? I do agree with John. And in the
- 40:15way that this is explained as far as repeatedly
- 40:19challenging the plaintiff's answers using a sharp
- 40:22tone, I guess it depends on your perspective
- 40:25of what that is, because that could look uncivil
- 40:28depending on what is meant by sharp tone. And
- 40:33I think that there's a balance between getting
- 40:37the answers that you need, especially if a witness
- 40:41is being evasive and not answering and being
- 40:45respectful in that, which can be difficult because
- 40:49if you're asking it and you're asking different
- 40:52ways and you're still getting the same evasive
- 40:54response, it could be at that point, then you
- 40:58do a meet and confer because I do agree with
- 41:01John with. What he said and why you would have
- 41:05to have that balance. It is important, but it,
- 41:08but you also, you need to. Advocate for your
- 41:12client to write and get that and get that answer.
- 41:16So. Michelle. Okay, so is this ethical? I do
- 41:22hope that if this happens to any of you at deposition,
- 41:25you're objecting to form, right? Because later
- 41:27on, you're going to want to judge to look at
- 41:29some of this. And you can also suspend the deposition
- 41:32if you really believe that the badgering is at
- 41:35hand. But ethically, we're looking at California
- 41:38rule of court 8 .4 .1, which, similar to John's
- 41:42local rule that he cited, is also meant to be
- 41:45a prevention mechanism for harassment, bullying,
- 41:48or just bad faith obstruction. So not only is
- 41:52this likely objectionable conduct, but it's also
- 41:57non -ethical conduct. If it is the scenario that
- 42:00John mentioned where you're actually just you're
- 42:02questioning and you're not getting an answer
- 42:04and sometimes this just happens out of sheer
- 42:06frustration, you also can move to strike and
- 42:11do what you need to do to compel your answer.
- 42:13Maybe using a sharp tone is not the way to go
- 42:16about that civilly, ethically, or is it particularly
- 42:21good advocacy? Let's see what the audience thinks.
- 42:28While we're doing that, Grace, I would just add
- 42:29that this is oftentimes where you're looking
- 42:32at, is the deposition being videotaped or not?
- 42:36Because a sharp tone doesn't really show up in
- 42:38a transcript, but it certainly can show up in
- 42:40a videotape. That's a good point. Yeah, that
- 42:42is a good point. So I think you've successfully
- 42:46convinced them that it's not necessarily an ethics
- 42:48issue, Michelle. So 48 % advocacy, 38 % civility.
- 42:54I think it really comes down to purpose and manner.
- 42:57We have some tools, obviously, we can use. Again,
- 43:01kind of exactly what you said, John, sharp tone
- 43:03doesn't necessarily come out in a transcript.
- 43:06So, you know, what do we do about that? But I
- 43:10mean, we're all entitled to test the credibility
- 43:13of a witness finding consistency. It's just a
- 43:15matter of. why we're doing it, how often we're
- 43:18doing it, the tone we're taking, all of it put
- 43:20together. A couple more hypos. Next one. Before
- 43:27the deposition of a retained expert, counsel
- 43:29spends several hours preparing the expert reviewing
- 43:32prior testimony, identifying weaknesses in the
- 43:35opposing expert's opinions, and discussing how
- 43:38certain answers could affect the case. At deposition,
- 43:40the expert repeatedly uses language that closely
- 43:44tracks counsel's theory of the case. I'm not
- 43:46using that expertise. Rupa. Being an advocate
- 43:53is also making sure you're actually preparing
- 43:57your expert to understand what their opinions
- 44:00are, what's the basis for their opinions, what
- 44:03documents are they relying on to get there. And
- 44:07it is important that you let the expert know
- 44:13some weaknesses and strengths and other opinions,
- 44:16understand how The issues are are coming out
- 44:21in this case. So I think preparation of an expert
- 44:24is very important It's when an attorney may tell
- 44:28an expert to say certain things in which case
- 44:30that is an issue But you know making sure you're
- 44:34preparing your experts so that they know What's
- 44:38happening in the case making sure you understand
- 44:40what they're going to testify to and why I think
- 44:42that's important What does this look like from
- 44:46the civility perspective, John? I think from
- 44:48a civility standpoint, I mean, if it becomes
- 44:50apparent as you're deposing the expert, they're
- 44:53simply mirroring the, you know, the theory of
- 44:57the case from the other side's perspective and,
- 44:59you know, pre -conditioned conclusions have already
- 45:02been reached without even looking at the evidence.
- 45:05I think you're, you know, that's very, in my
- 45:07mind, problematic from the civility standpoint.
- 45:10I mean, I think you really should press the issue
- 45:12with the expert. tied out if they're really,
- 45:15this is truly their opinions, the opinions they
- 45:17hold based on an objective analysis using their
- 45:20expertise as opposed to simply echoing the opinions
- 45:23of, or the theories at least, of the attorney
- 45:25that retained them. Is there an ethical issue
- 45:31Judge Wilcox? I think there is, and I think that
- 45:36you need to look at what is it that you mean
- 45:38by preparing the expert. If you have an expert,
- 45:42there shouldn't be preparation of the expert
- 45:45necessarily for deposition. And it's one thing
- 45:47to talk about your case or talk about the facts
- 45:51of the case, but preparing that expert like you
- 45:54would prepare your client, for example, is not,
- 46:00I mean, I do agree with Grace. You might want
- 46:02to question who you have as an expert if that
- 46:05person needs that much preparation. But it's
- 46:09not the same thing. And also, there's no privilege.
- 46:16So they can ask, what did you talk about? And
- 46:20then you are going to run into, I think, potentially
- 46:23ethical issues if that expert is honest and candid.
- 46:33Audience, how do you feel? Advocacy 64 % none
- 46:40for civility and 36 % for ethics. So I think
- 46:46everybody agrees that you should prepare your
- 46:49experts and preparation is advocacy. I think
- 46:53the line is obviously when you're encouraging
- 46:56testimony that is not truthful or having them
- 46:58change their testimony. Alright, so I think we've
- 47:01already moved on to the next one. At mediation
- 47:04plaintiff's counsel tells defense counsel that
- 47:06unless the case settles that day, the demand
- 47:10will increase substantially because plaintiff
- 47:12intends to incur, intends to incur significant
- 47:15additional costs preparing for trial. Plaintiff's
- 47:18counsel has not yet decided whether the demand
- 47:20will actually increase if the case does not settle.
- 47:24I know we have drawn on the ethics portion. Michelle
- 47:28on the advocacy one. Yeah, so we're back to our
- 47:32negotiation strategies, right? The puffery, the
- 47:35stick, the dramatics, the defense version of
- 47:38this might sound something like, here's my offer,
- 47:41don't come back to me or it'll go down, right?
- 47:44I'll have spent all the money I needed to prep
- 47:46for trial and I'm ready to go to trial. So, is
- 47:50this advocacy? Well, we know from our other hypotheticals
- 47:54on negotiation tactics, right, that It doesn't
- 47:59really run afoul of ethical or civility rules,
- 48:03right, unless you're doing so in an unprofessional
- 48:05manner or you are knowingly telling someone a
- 48:09falsehood. You're deceitful. And here we have
- 48:12the hypothetical telling us that Plainness Council
- 48:14has not yet decided whether the demand will actually
- 48:17increase. I think we do have some ethical concerns
- 48:22about a plaintiff's behavior. Will the other
- 48:24side know that necessarily? I don't know. But
- 48:29from an advocacy position, this lawyer is probably
- 48:33thinking, well, I'm not here to help your client
- 48:36through the negotiation. This is what my client
- 48:38would like to see in the form of a settlement.
- 48:40So I'm going to try to get it. Rupa? We've all
- 48:46heard this in mediations. Every defense counsel
- 48:50heard this from plaintiff's counsel. If you don't
- 48:53take this, you know, my demand is going to go
- 48:56sky rock, right? Because I got to prepare for
- 48:59trial. The reality is, you know, everybody has
- 49:01to prepare for trial. As long as it's done in
- 49:04a civil way, they're not threatening, you know,
- 49:07creating deadlines, arbitrary deadlines may be
- 49:10difficult, may cause difficulties in trying to
- 49:12settle the case. And it also if it doesn't end
- 49:15up happening, it may undermine that. that counsel's
- 49:19credibility the next time you have a conversation
- 49:21with them or mediation with them, knowing that
- 49:24they're going to, you know, puff things up just
- 49:27to try to make these deadlines happen. So, I
- 49:32mean, I think as long as it's respectful in the
- 49:35way it's presented, you know, there is that fine
- 49:38line with civility and you're just not sure whether
- 49:43or not it will increase it, but we've all heard
- 49:45it. John, I think that's a very good point about
- 49:52credibility in this situation. I think credibility
- 49:54in the ethical aspect of it comes goes hand in
- 49:58hand. I mean, looking at where are you in the
- 50:00case if you're 30 days before trial and you've
- 50:03got a bunch of expert depots you've been putting
- 50:05off that are teed up, ready to go. If you don't
- 50:07settle, it's obvious that. Costs are going to
- 50:10increase substantially for both sides. If you're
- 50:13months away from trial of not disclosed expert
- 50:15witnesses, it looks like it's an empty threat.
- 50:19And I think it's going to cost you as a plaintiff's
- 50:21counsel down the road with the credibility with
- 50:24both mediator and also with your opposing counsel.
- 50:27So you got to think about painting yourself into
- 50:29a corner like that and then having to walk it
- 50:33back perhaps down the road if they don't buy
- 50:35it. Okay. Let's see what the audience thinks.
- 50:4472 % advocacy, only 5 % civility, 23 % ethics.
- 50:50I mean, I think we all agree that aggressive
- 50:52negotiation is not the problem. I kind of take
- 50:55into what John said, context, right? Where are
- 50:58we in the case? What does it mean? I'm not sure
- 51:01whether there's ethical implications other than
- 51:03what we've talked about in terms of misrepresentation.
- 51:05So let's get into our last hypo, and then we'll
- 51:09answer some questions that are in the chat. So
- 51:14during the deposition of the defendant's PMK
- 51:16in a construction accident case, plaintiff's
- 51:18counsel asked a series of questions about site
- 51:20safety practices. Defense counsel makes frequent
- 51:23objections, including objections to form Michelle's
- 51:26favorite foundation and incomplete hypotheticals.
- 51:30The objections are proper, but their frequency
- 51:32repeatedly interrupts the examination and appears
- 51:35to affect the witnesses answers. Judge Wilcox.
- 51:39Well, I think. This is a good example of advocacy,
- 51:43because you do need to protect your record. You
- 51:48need to preserve valid objections. And if they're
- 51:55truly objectionable, which the hypo provides
- 51:58that they are, then interrupting the witness's
- 52:02answer is on the witness or council preparing
- 52:07that witness that you have to wait until The
- 52:10objections are stated, right? So I think this
- 52:14is clear advocacy. Michelle, you want to civility?
- 52:19Yeah. So again, we're back to rule 9 .7, right?
- 52:23Our duty to act with professionalism at all times.
- 52:26And also, if you're practicing in Los Angeles
- 52:29County, the local rule that John cited in the
- 52:31appendix 3A6, right? We can't harass. Bully or
- 52:37obstruct knowingly obstruct a deposition. A lot
- 52:40is missing from the hypothetical, right? Which
- 52:42is counsel's intention. We don't know if this
- 52:45conduct is meant to be obstreperous or to obstruct
- 52:48the testimony. Or maybe this is just a nervous
- 52:52lawyer who wants to make sure whoever's going
- 52:55to read the transcript after them thinks that
- 52:57they've done a good job. Either way, a constant
- 53:01sort of baseless stream of objections is not
- 53:08exactly acting with professionalism. So I think
- 53:10you really need to make sure that your objections
- 53:13are necessary and are not to kind of disrupt
- 53:17the flow of evidence. Knowing that that's coming
- 53:21from a partner. So you're looking for this. Rupa,
- 53:27anything unethical about this? Not in and of
- 53:30itself, I guess it goes down to the intention
- 53:33if it's done as a design to Compete, you know
- 53:38the access to the testimony to stop the testimony
- 53:41But I think that is an issue even though it might
- 53:43be proper I think it's the intention behind it
- 53:47and the behavior behind it because that you are
- 53:50allowed you are permitted to object You know
- 53:53if it's proper objection And as long as it's
- 53:56not speaking objections or coaching the witness,
- 53:58that's acceptable. But it's, again, the intention.
- 54:00If it's really designed to either throw the asking
- 54:05attorney off of their game or if it's done to
- 54:09just interrupt the flow so that the witness isn't
- 54:12able to provide clear or thorough answers, then
- 54:15I think that's an ethical issue. If I could just
- 54:18add to that, Grace, the Los Angeles Superior
- 54:20Court guidelines with civility and litigation
- 54:23talk specifically about counsel not engaging
- 54:26in any conduct during a deposition that would
- 54:28not be allowed in the presence of a judicial
- 54:30officer. So think about it from the standpoint,
- 54:33if you're taking a deposition and Judge Wilcox
- 54:36is sitting 10 feet away, how would she perceive
- 54:39that? Would you perceive it as you're being an
- 54:41aggressive advocate or you're being. Obsessive
- 54:44and just trying to flow off the attorney and
- 54:47really disrupt the proceeding. That's what it
- 54:49comes down to. Yeah, good brain audience. 79
- 54:58% advocacy, 14 % civility, only 7 % ethics. I
- 55:04think the one that the part of the hypo that
- 55:06makes it tricky is that every objection is proper.
- 55:08I may be a culprit. And when we teach depots
- 55:10to our students, we say to try to make every
- 55:12objection to protect the record. But, you know,
- 55:15that's because they're learning and they don't
- 55:16know when to not, you know, protect the record.
- 55:20So I think kind of what we talked about, as long
- 55:22as it's not speaking objections and trying to
- 55:24coach them, you know, there's this debate as
- 55:28to whether this is really, you know, bad or not.
- 55:33Right. I wanted to, there's two questions. We
- 55:38have like four more minutes. So I wanted to kind
- 55:40of get to the question. So there was one question
- 55:43here that says, or no, did I skip one? It's fine.
- 55:48Oh, okay. Yeah. How do you deal with an angry,
- 55:52volatile and unreasonable older attorney that
- 55:54files perjury and misrepresents facts intentionally?
- 56:00Sounds like someone specific. Now we're getting
- 56:03more questions in the chat. Let's problem solve
- 56:07all these. What was the part about committing
- 56:10perjury? I missed that. They file that files
- 56:15perjury. I'm not sure what that meant, but maybe
- 56:17it was a declaration that's got no false information.
- 56:21Yeah, misrepresents facts intentionally. Well,
- 56:24I know that Rupa and I have definitely had cases,
- 56:27contentious cases with counsel who had some Similar
- 56:32tactics. Wendy and I've definitely had cases
- 56:34like this. The thing to do is to be clinical
- 56:38and surgical in your communications with that
- 56:41person and keep them all to writing and try to
- 56:44keep the emotion out of it. And always meet and
- 56:48confer and document everything that you think
- 56:51is happening that runs afoul of the code or that
- 56:53runs afoul of, you know, ethics or whatever have
- 56:57you and explain your basis for why. If you have
- 57:01to put the issue before the court, and Rupa and
- 57:03I did in our case, we needed a discovery referee.
- 57:06We needed a lot of things. Sometimes cases need
- 57:08a professional babysitter because you have some
- 57:11people that believe that what they're doing is
- 57:14good advocacy when actually it's driving up the
- 57:17costs and it makes everyone else question whether
- 57:20they're submitting truthful statements to the
- 57:22court. So be clinical. Be clear, keep it to writing,
- 57:27and if you need a professional babysitter, petition
- 57:29the court for a discovery referee. I would say
- 57:32in keeping with your writing, just make sure
- 57:33your tone is civil and, you know, obviously make
- 57:37sure that you're coming across clear, like Michelle
- 57:39said. Yeah, I would just add to that. Don't let
- 57:44someone like that pull you into the gutter. You
- 57:46know, stay on the high road. Whether it's in
- 57:48deposition, whether some sort of confrontation
- 57:50going on, make your record. If it's being videotaped,
- 57:54better yet, the court can see what's going on.
- 57:57But again, don't take the bait. I mean, if you
- 57:59get a nasty, ridiculous letter, write a letter
- 58:03back. It's professional, courteous, pointing
- 58:05out the ridiculousness of some of the accusations.
- 58:09But the court, ultimately, if the court becomes
- 58:11involved, they want to see that you're the one
- 58:14taking the high road, not the other guy. And
- 58:16take advantage of the rules that we cited, as
- 58:19well as the new ones, because those could be
- 58:26very useful in putting under those rules what
- 58:31they're saying and showing how they're maybe
- 58:35violating those rules. There's another very specific
- 58:41question. What about posting a blog calling your
- 58:44opposing counsel a toxic law firm that is full
- 58:47of evil people? There's also a link if you wanted
- 58:51to check it out, but is that advocacy, civility,
- 58:54or ethics? I don't see it as advocacy. Or civil.
- 59:00Or civil. Yeah, I think that's a problem. Yeah.
- 59:05Because it doesn't advance your case. right?
- 59:08And I think that that's the bottom line, like,
- 59:10is this something that's personal between two
- 59:13people, or is this something that really advances
- 59:15the case? And that's how we started that definition
- 59:18from the very beginning. Especially like for
- 59:24slide two, we had, does it advance the client's
- 59:26position? That doesn't, right? So I don't see
- 59:30that as advocacy, but I do see it as a stability
- 59:33and ethical problem. There's two more really
- 59:38quickly. Expert witness had to postpone a depot
- 59:42due to a death in their family. When the depot
- 59:44finally commenced, opposing counselor persisted
- 59:46in questioning the expert about their family
- 59:48member's death, ethical, civil, or other, is
- 59:52the question. Yeah, that's, well, that's, I don't
- 59:56see that being appropriate. It doesn't advance
- 59:58your client's position. And I guess that the
- 1:00:02person likely felt that maybe it wasn't true
- 1:00:07and it was for another reason and that's why
- 1:00:09the questions were there. But I think that that's
- 1:00:13something between council, not necessarily asking
- 1:00:16in a deposition. Yeah, and I've seen, you know,
- 1:00:20sometimes someone will want a trial continuance
- 1:00:22and the basis for it will be, oh, someone's having
- 1:00:24a surgery or someone has a prepaid trip or someone
- 1:00:27has a wedding. If you have any reason to believe
- 1:00:30that this is a tactic and it's not true and it's
- 1:00:33false, you can put that issue before the court
- 1:00:36and you can file a motion and let the judge decide.
- 1:00:40And sometimes I've seen a judge do this, make
- 1:00:42the other side prove or provide a declaration.
- 1:00:47supporting it. And maybe that is a bit of a safer
- 1:00:50method than a deposition. It feels sort of less
- 1:00:52combative. And then finally, I think this is
- 1:00:57an opinion, but you guys can probably answer
- 1:00:59this one. If you practiced in northern Southern
- 1:01:01California, would you say one jurisdiction is
- 1:01:04more civil than the other? I started my practice
- 1:01:10in Northern California, and I'm happy I did.
- 1:01:15There is a bit of a difference, I would say,
- 1:01:19just culturally in the way that the litigation
- 1:01:22is handled. But I would say when I got to LA,
- 1:01:26I was not ready for the law and motion practice
- 1:01:29that I would fall into. I would say that in Los
- 1:01:32Angeles, there's a very heavy law and motion
- 1:01:34practice. Whereas in Northern California, Rupa,
- 1:01:37maybe you can speak to this, there are far fewer
- 1:01:39motions. Rupa and I often banter and run cases
- 1:01:43by each other. And I'm like, this motion, Rupa.
- 1:01:46Now, Rupa, you've got to file this motion. Now,
- 1:01:47Rupa, you have to file this motion. And she's
- 1:01:49like, God, don't tell me to file a motion. But
- 1:01:52I would say that's one major distinction. Definitely
- 1:01:55in Northern California, we are not as motion
- 1:01:58heavy. It's just not for various reasons. But
- 1:02:06yeah, definitely seeing the Southern California's
- 1:02:09aggressive motion practice was a bit of a surprise.
- 1:02:15But in my practice, I try to file those motions
- 1:02:18that I need to, not. Because I can if it's really
- 1:02:22those that will help me get where I need to go.
- 1:02:25I will do it as opposed to just every motion
- 1:02:28that I. Okay, sure. Why not? I can. So. That's
- 1:02:32just my opinion. All right. Oh, God, there are
- 1:02:39more questions. We could go online. We're already
- 1:02:42over. Yeah. So, let me just kind of just say.
- 1:02:50Obviously what we've seen or we're done right
- 1:02:52or is that did they stop or the slides are off,
- 1:02:54but let me just say from the hypos is that this
- 1:02:59rarely is it a question of is this allowed right?
- 1:03:01So maybe what we're asking you to think about
- 1:03:03is can I do this? Why am I doing it? What effect
- 1:03:06is it? Does it advance my clients objectives?
- 1:03:10Is this the kind of advocacy that's really serving
- 1:03:12both my client and my obligations as a lawyer?
- 1:03:15So that's what we've asked you to think about.
- 1:03:17Hopefully you got some ideas from what we discussed.
- 1:03:21I want to thank you all for joining us. Thank
- 1:03:23you for our panelists. That's it. Thank you so
- 1:03:28much. Thank you.