Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How Will the Recently Enacted Partition of Real Property Act Impact Partition Practice?
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everyone. You are in the Beverly Hills
- 0:06Bar Association Real Property Section program
- 0:10on how will the recently enacted Partition of
- 0:13Real Property Act impact partition practice?
- 0:16I'm Howard Gould, and I am a co -chair of the
- 0:19Beverly Hills Bar Real Estate Law Section. I
- 0:22have been for a number of years now. Very happy
- 0:26to have a really big group attending today's
- 0:28program. I want to let you know what the upcoming
- 0:31programs are going to be December we have no
- 0:34program for the public. It's the executive committee
- 0:38will have our holiday dinner, but I want to invite
- 0:40everyone who's a member of the real estate section
- 0:43to come to our executive committee meetings to
- 0:46join the executive committee and help us plan
- 0:48programs and learn what is new from other XCOM
- 0:51members. And sometimes some of us need help on
- 0:54our matters, and you never know what may come
- 0:57your way if you attend the executive committee
- 0:59meetings. On January 15th, we have a program
- 1:03by Heather Rosing, a prior president of the California
- 1:07Bar Association. Heather is an expert on legal
- 1:12ethics and will put on a program on risk management
- 1:16for real estate lawyers and that will qualify
- 1:18for ethics credit. February 19th, we have our
- 1:22annual California Association of Realtors. form
- 1:25update with Jana Gardner visiting us again, which
- 1:28she's done now for a number of years. And if
- 1:30you want to learn about the important changes
- 1:33in the car forms from somebody who is intimately
- 1:36familiar with them, that's the program to attend.
- 1:39February 26, we're going to have a second program
- 1:42in February on real property taxes. Two lawyers
- 1:45from Greenberg Towering, including Chris O 'Neill,
- 1:47who has been a frequent speaker for us on California
- 1:51real property taxes. March 19th is our annual
- 1:54review of the prior year's real estate cases
- 1:56with Lawrence Jacobson, former chair of this
- 2:01section and president of the association. And
- 2:03April 16th, another former president of the Beverly
- 2:06Hills Bar, Howard Fisher, is going to do a program
- 2:09on 1031 exchanges. I want to let everybody know
- 2:14that you should, when you have questions, put
- 2:16them in the Q &A. The chat is not being used
- 2:18for that. You can find announcements from the
- 2:21bar in the chat, including a link to the program
- 2:23materials. Finally, the MCLE certificates are
- 2:27sent out by the Beverly Hills bar very promptly
- 2:29after the programs, so you should look for those
- 2:31in your emails. I am delighted today to introduce
- 2:36our speakers, Curtis Holdsworth, Matthew Taylor,
- 2:39and Judge Elizabeth Feffer, retired. Curtis Holdsworth
- 2:43is of counsel at Bartko Pavia LLP and a member
- 2:47of their litigation practice group. He's represented
- 2:50clients in state and federal courts as first
- 2:52chair trial counsel in matters involving partition
- 2:55claims, unfair business practices, fraud, breach
- 2:58of contract, trade secrets, and other complex
- 3:00business disputes. And he's done this across
- 3:04a variety of industries, including banking, investment,
- 3:07retail, and manufacturing. In addition to his
- 3:11legal practice, Curtis is the founder of Bot
- 3:13Mediation Inc, an artificial intelligence based
- 3:16mediation platform that facilitates neutral data
- 3:20informed dispute resolution. Curtis attended
- 3:25UCLA where he obtained his degree in economics
- 3:28and then the USC Gould School of Law for his
- 3:31law degree. Matthew Taylor Our second panelist
- 3:35is an attorney and founder of his own law offices
- 3:38where he focuses on civil litigation and court
- 3:40appointments as a receiver or partition referee.
- 3:44He's a licensed California real estate broker
- 3:46and experienced litigator. He sells 30 to 50
- 3:49properties annually in court sales, and that
- 3:52includes residential, commercial, industrial,
- 3:55and vacant land. He's admitted to practice before
- 3:58numerous state and federal courts, and is also
- 4:00a mediator, Judge Pro Tem, and published appellate
- 4:03attorney with decades of experience in complex
- 4:06disputes. He attended Pomona College and then
- 4:10the UCLA School of Law. Our moderator today,
- 4:13we're very pleased to have the Honorable Elizabeth.
- 4:16Feffer retired. She's been providing mediation,
- 4:19arbitration, and referee services full time since
- 4:222020. She has an impressive track record of successful
- 4:25settlements across a broad spectrum of civil
- 4:28cases. She's also arbitrated numerous cases through
- 4:31hearing and final award. As a judge of the LA
- 4:35Superior Court for 13 years, Judge Pfeffer served
- 4:37in various roles, including as an unlimited jurisdiction
- 4:41civil independent calendar court and civil trial
- 4:45court judge. During that time, Judge Pfeffer
- 4:48presided over more than 75 civil jury trials,
- 4:51more than 500 civil bench trials, hundreds of
- 4:54evidentiary hearings and numerous settlement
- 4:56conferences covering a diverse range of complex
- 4:59factual and legal issues. is also a UCLA grad
- 5:05in communication study in 1990 and in 1993. She
- 5:09received both her law degree from the Gould School
- 5:11of Law at USC and her master of arts in communication
- 5:14management also from USC. Thank you all for joining
- 5:18us and please proceed with our program for today.
- 5:22Yes and thank you Mr. Gould for the great introductions.
- 5:25So this this program kind of came about because
- 5:28I went to college in law school with my esteemed
- 5:31panelist, Curtis. And when I was on the bench
- 5:33in downtown LA, many, many partition actions.
- 5:36And many, as we'll discuss today, many of them
- 5:40are really, I mean, a judge looks at it almost
- 5:44like a probate dispute that, I mean, obviously
- 5:46it's a civil case, but oftentimes it's, you know,
- 5:49siblings who inherit property from their parents
- 5:51and one wants to keep it, one wants to sell and
- 5:55a partition action ensues. And so, Curtis had
- 5:58a case in my court that involved multiple properties
- 6:01on a golf course, a lot of really complicated
- 6:03issues. He got through it very well and I found
- 6:07out later that Matthew was a referee behind the
- 6:10scenes. So there's a lot of great information
- 6:12even before the 2023 Partition of Real Property
- 6:16Act was enacted and kind of added on to the existing
- 6:20partition statutes in California, kind of at
- 6:23the end of it. I think it's CCP section 874 .311.
- 6:28Already there were many tactical issues to consider
- 6:32when filing a partition action. And then this
- 6:36new statute, which again enacted recently, but
- 6:39there really haven't been published cases on
- 6:41it, that kind of changed not just the procedure
- 6:44on how one gets partitioned in court, but tactical
- 6:47considerations as far as Maybe you're the one
- 6:49who wants to file first, or maybe you're the
- 6:51one who shouldn't be filing, and you should be
- 6:53responding. So a lot of things to think about,
- 6:55and I'm really thrilled to present this to you.
- 6:59So we're going to go through a number of things.
- 7:02Pre -litigation, how they come up, when you might
- 7:04see them. Curtis will be discussing them. Remedies
- 7:07of jury trial, sales and the rule of mediation.
- 7:10Curtis will all kind of discussing that. Partition
- 7:13references. This is where Matthew comes in, and
- 7:16I'm on the bench. You don't see all the behind
- 7:17the scenes things. that go on with these litigations
- 7:21over the real property. But the partition referee
- 7:23really makes a huge difference and all that.
- 7:26And so Matthew will be talking about that. And
- 7:28then some post -sale and closing thoughts. So
- 7:31with that, Curtis, if you want to pick it up
- 7:34and talk about the statute and the new enactment.
- 7:38Certainly. I am quickly responding to one of
- 7:41the questions here as fast as I can. So pardon
- 7:43me for the delay. One of the first things you
- 7:47need to figure out as a practitioner is the manner
- 7:51in which the property is held because it has
- 7:54significant strategic implications for your client
- 7:57in a partition case in a way that's very different
- 8:02than what was the case in my most recent partition
- 8:06action. Specifically, you need to determine whether
- 8:09the property is held as a joint tenancy or as
- 8:13tenants in common because that is a major fork
- 8:16in the road for you procedurally. And it's something
- 8:21that needs to be determined pre -filing because
- 8:24there could be an irreversible effect or consequence
- 8:27of not determining how property is held before
- 8:31you initiate a partition action. So with that,
- 8:34I'll let Matthew take it and run with it further.
- 8:38Yes, Matthew. Well, sure. So the primary issue
- 8:40that we have is that the enactment of the Partition
- 8:44of Real Property Act set a date of January 1st
- 8:47of 2023, and any actions that are filed after
- 8:51that date that involve tenants in common has
- 8:55to go under the rules of the Partition of Real
- 8:57Property Act. If you're filed before that date
- 9:00or if you're a joint tenant, then you're still
- 9:02under what we're going to call the old rules.
- 9:04And by the old rules, we mean the ones basically
- 9:06the accumulated rules that have been around since
- 9:08the state of California was founded and amended
- 9:11several times up until the Partition of Real
- 9:13Property Act. But what it means is that after
- 9:15anything filed after January 1st, 2023, you've
- 9:18got two separate pathways and procedural tracks
- 9:21that are existing side by side. And you're going
- 9:24to have to decide with your case which one it
- 9:26goes under and follow the rules for that particular
- 9:29pathway. Yes, that makes sense, which takes us
- 9:33to the next, and we'll briefly touch on it, and
- 9:35then we'll take down the slide in a moment. So
- 9:38the types of partition in kind, and this is our
- 9:41land, CCP section 872 .810, as you can see, by
- 9:45a court -ordered sale. And many of these do resolve,
- 9:49and you don't need to do that. But that is, of
- 9:51course, the option. And then appraisal and buyout,
- 9:53which is the mutual consent. So, Curtis, is there
- 9:58kind of a presumption that, you know, that the
- 10:00court would apply that one is more favorable
- 10:02than the other or anything you want to kind of
- 10:04touch on and the types of partition? Yes, Judge
- 10:08Pfeffer, my understanding there is a presumption,
- 10:12but I will qualify that with. the new enactment
- 10:17changing that presumption. And so again, I'll
- 10:20let Matthew elaborate on that. But in a conventional,
- 10:24we'll call it partition when the property is
- 10:28held as a joint tenancy as opposed to tenants
- 10:32in common. This is articulated here in the waterfall
- 10:37as expressed in the code of priority. So the
- 10:41presumption, if you will, is in kind. Partition
- 10:46as opposed to a court order sale or by by appraisal
- 10:51in my experience in kind is is quite rare Because
- 10:56most partition matters involve at least a component
- 11:00if not entirely dirt or or other form of real
- 11:06estate, which is very difficult to be divisible
- 11:10in fairness to the parties involved. So normally
- 11:14you're going to end up in a court sale or a appraisal
- 11:18and buyout scenario as opposed to in kind. I
- 11:22will say this, however, I don't think you should
- 11:25give short shrift to the in kind presumption.
- 11:28I view that as a rebuttable statutory presumption
- 11:32that still should be affirmatively addressed
- 11:35in the litigation. So my tactic number one is
- 11:39I will allege if I am angling for a court ordered
- 11:43sale or an appraisal and buyout. that an in -kind
- 11:48partition should not be ordered by the court.
- 11:53And I believe that there's a statutory rubric
- 11:58for that determination to be made by a judicial
- 12:00officer. I think it's articulated. um in ccp
- 12:04a 74 .319 there are several uh factors in fact
- 12:09seven and the statute doesn't indicate one factor
- 12:12being you know more weighty than another factor
- 12:15but you should certainly be aware of what those
- 12:18factors are and i think as a practitioner it's
- 12:20prudent to assert um if you do not want an in
- 12:24-kind um partition as to why, explaining why
- 12:29a partition would result in an injustice. And
- 12:32to double down on the allegation, my practice
- 12:35is to propound discovery. So in the form of a
- 12:39request for admission, to pin the other party
- 12:41down to get an admission on their part as to
- 12:44the type of partition that is the most appropriate.
- 12:48Right. And that makes sense. And one thing, before
- 12:50I go to Matthew, maybe Curtis, you can address
- 12:52it. a complaint for partition under either the
- 12:56traditional scheme of joint tenancy versus the
- 12:59new statute on tenancy in common, that complaint
- 13:03does not need to be verified, correct? That's
- 13:08true. However, it is an area of the law where
- 13:13I expect it would be verified more frequently
- 13:16than other types of litigation. It does give
- 13:20you a bit of a shortcut in certain respects.
- 13:26So I wouldn't be surprised to see a verified
- 13:29bleeding because it's a fairly cut and dried
- 13:33piece of litigation. Not that there aren't intricacies,
- 13:36but it can give you or save you a step or two.
- 13:41But my preference is to file an unverified version
- 13:45and then to see. to pin people down with discovery
- 13:48or by virtue of stipulation. Correct. And that
- 13:53might be a discussion to have with the client.
- 13:56Even though a verified complaint is not required,
- 13:58perhaps you want a verified complaint. And that,
- 14:01of course, would prompt a verified answer versus
- 14:05a general denial. So that's kind of one thing
- 14:07to think about. Matthew, before we move on, is
- 14:10there anything you wish to talk about with respect
- 14:13to the types of partition and maybe some tactical?
- 14:15Well, tactical consideration that I have seen,
- 14:18and again, keep in mind, although I'm an attorney,
- 14:20I'm here in my role as a frequent partition referee
- 14:23for the court system. So I'm going to be kind
- 14:24of giving the perspective of the referee. But
- 14:27what I have seen many times is that practitioners
- 14:31representing, especially plaintiffs, want to
- 14:35know how you get as quickly as possible to the
- 14:38next stage of the partition cases and the next
- 14:41stage of the partition cases where you get to
- 14:42what's called an interlocutory judgment. And
- 14:44that's where the court has determined that you're
- 14:47entitled to partition and orders the partition
- 14:49and the method of partition. One way that I have
- 14:52seen people do that is by filing a verified complaint
- 14:57that prompts the other side to file a verified
- 14:59answer. And then based on the verified answer,
- 15:02they'll do a motion for judgment on the pleadings.
- 15:05Because in order to get to the interlocutory
- 15:08judgment stage, especially under the old system,
- 15:10and so the one's dealing more now with the joint
- 15:13tenancy, you really have a very low threshold.
- 15:16You basically have to show that you're an owner
- 15:17and that you haven't waived the right to partition.
- 15:19And if you can show those things, then you've
- 15:23got yourself about 90 % of the way towards where
- 15:24you need to get as to get your interlocutory
- 15:27judgment. And that's something I've seen a lot
- 15:29of people do by way of these verified complaints.
- 15:32Right, certainly. And it's kind of from the judicial
- 15:34perspective. When I was sitting downtown for
- 15:37a number of years in the independent calendar
- 15:38court, there are many, many partition actions
- 15:40filed. And very few would go to trial. And the
- 15:42ones that would go to trial really said this
- 15:45interlocutory judgment stage. Those were basically
- 15:48stipulated too, that the trial would basically
- 15:50be for the reimbursements of who paid the property
- 15:53tax, who paid this, who paid that, not. not really
- 15:56the right to partition or the method of partition
- 15:59that typically was something that was resolved,
- 16:01although certainly it's not always resolved.
- 16:04The trial was on the other later stage issues.
- 16:09So of course, part of this is, what does your
- 16:13client want? And so part of determining who the
- 16:15client is and the stakeholders occurs if you
- 16:19want to talk about litigation guarantee and how
- 16:21that's so important before you file a partition
- 16:24action. Sure, I'll just to the point or issue
- 16:29that Matthew raised I will I will raise anecdotally
- 16:33It is uncertain whether a judicial officer would
- 16:37entertain a motion for judgment on the pleadings
- 16:41I filed a motion to obtain a in order interlocutory
- 16:48judgment in my favor with I believe many of the
- 16:52same admissions in the form of discovery rather
- 16:55than in the form of a verified complaint. And
- 16:59that motion failed in front of Judge Pfeffer.
- 17:04And she felt firmly that summary judgment motion
- 17:07is the most appropriate procedural mechanism
- 17:11to award interlocutory judgment. So I would be
- 17:15cautious about attempting to do any other pre
- 17:20-trial motion to obtain an interlocutory judgment
- 17:24other than MSJ. Right. And it is tricky. Again,
- 17:30this isn't something that is frequently litigated,
- 17:34even though the LA Superior Court has the highest
- 17:36volume of any civil division in the world. This
- 17:41portion of a partition action is not litigated
- 17:46that often. So you may have a judge who's presided
- 17:49over many partition trials. The end of, again,
- 17:54the offsets of this and that. But as far as the
- 17:56interlocutory judgment, the courts just don't
- 17:58see that that often. It's not to say it doesn't
- 18:00happen. And I'm sure many viewers who are members
- 18:04of the real estate section and just the bread
- 18:06and butter of your practice as real estate law
- 18:08will have done those trials. But from any one
- 18:10particular judge's standpoint, that doesn't come
- 18:13up. that often so but certainly kind of the really
- 18:18the back to the basics who are the stakeholders
- 18:19and how do you determine you have to have all
- 18:21the parties before the court of curtis or math
- 18:24if you wish to speak to this issue well yeah
- 18:28sure go ahead matthew yeah i was going to say
- 18:31that um By statute, one of the most important
- 18:34things you have to do is you have to join in
- 18:35all the people or potential owners. And so that's
- 18:38really why what you'd probably want to do beforehand
- 18:40is get some sort of a litigation guarantee or
- 18:43a title report or something like that from a
- 18:44title insurance company to identify all the possible
- 18:47owners and lienholders that you'd want to have
- 18:50joined in to a lawsuit. Yes. Yeah, this is the
- 18:55one that I am most attention detail oriented
- 18:58towards when I do a partition case No matter
- 19:01how many times I look at it. No matter how many
- 19:03times I think I figured it out I assume that
- 19:07I got it wrong and I double triple quadruple
- 19:10check my work my practice would be to prepare
- 19:13a list or a matrix to identify the property owners
- 19:18because You can't trust what your clients tell
- 19:21you. Oh, yeah, I own it. You know, and you come
- 19:23to find out, well, they're, you know, part of
- 19:26an LLC that owns the property or, you know, oh,
- 19:30yeah, yeah, I own it. But then, you know, they
- 19:32got a grant deed that they never recorded. So
- 19:34they don't appear on title and all kinds of wacky
- 19:38things that can happen. So absolutely, you have
- 19:41to obtain a litigation guarantee, which is essentially
- 19:45a full blown title report. But you can save,
- 19:49spare some expense early on. I like to pull what's
- 19:52called a prelim. So if you're close to the real
- 19:55estate attorney or you have one in your side
- 19:57of your firm, if you don't, I would certainly
- 19:59get one involved, get a real estate expert involved
- 20:03to pull a prelim on the property. It'll give
- 20:09you a good snapshot. You can't rely on it completely,
- 20:12but it'll get you started. And it's normally
- 20:16correct. And then you can pull the full title
- 20:19report, a litigation guarantee to verify everything
- 20:22in terms of who the owners are and getting that
- 20:25right. And I will also say that as tricky as
- 20:29it is to identify who the owners are, in some
- 20:32instances, it can be very, very murky and tricky
- 20:36to figure out what the property is. And it may
- 20:40not be the case if you're talking about a single
- 20:43APM on like a SFR, like a single family residence
- 20:47that may be fairly cut and dried. But I'll tell
- 20:50you, if you're talking about raw dirt, if you're
- 20:53talking about some other unimproved property,
- 20:55if you're talking about contiguous parcels, there
- 20:58can be a whole host of pitfalls. So you need
- 21:01to study not just who the owners are, but what
- 21:05is the property because that needs to be delineated
- 21:09with precision. And I always articulate verbatim
- 21:14legal description of the subject property and
- 21:17then attach and incorporate by reference the
- 21:20litigation guarantee to the complaint before
- 21:23it's been filed. It's not a mandate. that you
- 21:27have a lit guarantee beforehand, but there's
- 21:30a provision in the code that I'm sure Matthew
- 21:33knows better than I do, whereby the opposing
- 21:35party can demand procurement of a litigation
- 21:39guarantee early on in litigation. So you're going
- 21:42to need it any way the court could order it as
- 21:45well, Sue Espante. So you might as well go get
- 21:48it, because eventually somebody's going to make
- 21:50you do it. The opposing counsel or the judge
- 21:52is going to make you go. get that document and
- 21:55then just anecdotally Matthew may recall we had
- 21:59savvy parties in a complex partition case and
- 22:02everybody thought we knew what the subject property
- 22:05was but I don't know if you recall Matthew there
- 22:08was a crazy little sliver of an APN that wasn't
- 22:13included in the original APNs and so technically
- 22:16the interlocutory judgment that we had procured
- 22:19did not cover that sliver. And in our instance,
- 22:23it wasn't an impediment to sell the property
- 22:26or develop it. But it was an interesting wrinkle.
- 22:30And I think even the title report missed it or
- 22:32got it wrong. Yeah, I'll usually order a title
- 22:36report fairly early on after I'm appointed because
- 22:39one of the things that I don't want to do is
- 22:41I don't want to end up on the eve of when we're
- 22:43closing escrow. And that's the first time people
- 22:45realize that there's a discrepancy between the
- 22:48court orders and what the title insurance company
- 22:50thinks the title is or the legal description
- 22:52for the property is. So that's something that
- 22:54we tend to try to deal with fairly early on.
- 22:57And we have some tips on the PowerPoint as well.
- 23:01Again, the lease pendants that will be filed,
- 23:03you have to have the legal description. And certainly
- 23:05the court will want to make sure that all the
- 23:08interested parties are before the courts. Again,
- 23:10courts are just... The courts have 1 ,000 to
- 23:141 ,200 cases now throughout LA County in the
- 23:17Civil Division. And so... just time is so limited
- 23:21and it's double what it was five, six years ago.
- 23:24So it's really important that when you go to
- 23:26court that everything is lined up and we don't
- 23:28know and we haven't run it. Might be lien holders
- 23:31and the description. So just it all has to be
- 23:34there. So we'll put the tips for filing a partition
- 23:36complaint. And this is really important because
- 23:40of the new Partition of Real Property Act and
- 23:43how it applies to properties held. you know,
- 23:47the joint Tennessee versus Tennessee in common,
- 23:49because there are some unique strategic considerations
- 23:52with respect to filing. So, Curtis, if you wanted
- 23:55to pick that up, and then Matthew? Sure, and
- 24:01is there a slide before or right after this that
- 24:04is more pertinent to this part of the discussion?
- 24:07Yes, but this is part of the remedies as well.
- 24:11I see. Part of the remedy is, you know, who's
- 24:13first? Right, so the things that that really
- 24:16don't affect or that aren't affected by the change
- 24:18is a filing county. Obviously, you have to file
- 24:20a complaint in the county in which a subject
- 24:22property is located. We've discussed the litigation
- 24:25guarantee. We've discussed the naming of the
- 24:27owners. This is more of once you get into the
- 24:29remedy. So think very carefully of what remedy
- 24:31you want. And again, maybe maybe your client,
- 24:34maybe your client isn't the one who should file
- 24:36first. So, yeah, yeah, great, great point. And
- 24:40I'll let I'll let Matthew elaborate, but. I would
- 24:43be thinking about the remedy that I'm seeking.
- 24:47Normally the client will have a pretty clear
- 24:51goal one way or the other. Either they want to
- 24:54be cashed out and they don't have an attachment
- 24:57to the property or it's the opposite and they
- 25:00have an attachment that could be very, very,
- 25:03very strong to hold on to the property. So you
- 25:07just have to take the pulse of your client to
- 25:10see which side of that fence they want to be
- 25:13on. If it's the latter and they're very, very
- 25:16attached to the property, then you need to tread
- 25:19very lightly in instigating a litigation because
- 25:23it could boomerang right back at you in terms
- 25:27of the defendant's statutory right to purchase.
- 25:32And I'll let Matthew run with that. Yes. Sure.
- 25:36Well, I mean, Ultimately there's a range of remedies
- 25:41that you can that you can seek and this deals
- 25:44with whether or not you're going to be under
- 25:45the the partition of real property act or not.
- 25:49What I think the biggest issue that you have
- 25:51is a strategic consideration on the filing is
- 25:53that if you're under the partition of real property
- 25:55act, so that means you have tenants in common,
- 25:58you have to go down a route that has a mandatory
- 26:01appraisal and then a mandatory buyout period
- 26:03before you even get to the point about whether
- 26:06you can divide it or sell it. And so those are,
- 26:09that's a, a procedure that doesn't even exist
- 26:12under the old system. And under the new system,
- 26:15basically what happens is that the inception
- 26:17of the lawsuit, the court is supposed to determine
- 26:19the value of the property mostly by appointing
- 26:22an appraiser and then conducting a hearing. And
- 26:25then after they have done that, then anybody
- 26:28who is not the person seeking to sell it has
- 26:31the right to buy out. the ownership interest
- 26:34of the person who is seeking to have it sold.
- 26:37They can buy it out at a purchase price that's
- 26:39basically their ownership interest multiplied
- 26:41by the appraised price of the property. There's
- 26:48a whole bunch of statutes dealing with that under
- 26:50the new Partition of Real Property Act. Most
- 26:52of them is going to be around 874 .316 and 0
- 26:56.317. criticisms of the way the statute was written,
- 27:01because I think the statute was written in ways
- 27:03that are both sort of ambiguous and unrealistic
- 27:05for the buyout. Main problem with the buyout...
- 27:09option is that it doesn't take into account values
- 27:14of the equity in the property versus what the
- 27:16actual value of the property is. So it doesn't
- 27:18deal with how you handle things like mortgages
- 27:20or liens or things like that. It's just silent.
- 27:24And then the other problem that I have is that
- 27:25the mechanism for how you purchase the property
- 27:27is that the person who wants to purchase the
- 27:30property just deposits the money with the clerk
- 27:32of the court and then eventually later gets a
- 27:35court order confirming their ownership of the
- 27:37property. I don't know about how people you guys
- 27:40represent. Most of the folks that I see don't
- 27:42just happen to have that money sitting around
- 27:44to do that, to just simply walk down to court
- 27:47and write them a check for a million dollars
- 27:49or something like that. Most people purchase
- 27:51property through some sort of a loan or an escrow
- 27:55where they're borrowing money, and that's not
- 27:57addressed or potentially allowed under the statute.
- 28:01So there's some real big issues in terms of whether
- 28:03you want to go down that route also. So Matthew,
- 28:06just to kind of go back on that. So the ones
- 28:10that would typically go to trial, typically siblings.
- 28:12So it could just be two siblings. So 50 -50 interest
- 28:16that makes it easy. One wants to sell, one doesn't
- 28:18want to sell. Or sometimes I've seen the three
- 28:21siblings. One wants to sell, one doesn't want
- 28:23to sell. And then they're kind of hashing out
- 28:25their childhood issues. And the one in the middle
- 28:27goes this way or that way, depending on whatever's
- 28:30going on behind the scenes. And Curtis, you're
- 28:34free to weigh in on this. So you're the lawyer
- 28:37representing the owner who wants to sell. And
- 28:42now you're the lawyer for the owner who does
- 28:45not want to sell. And it's held under the new
- 28:49statute, the tenancy in common. So what kind
- 28:52of strategic considerations for the one who wants
- 28:55to sell and for the one who doesn't want to sell
- 28:57as far as filing first and depositing the money
- 29:00and what? Any nuances to that that we should
- 29:03be made aware of? Sure. Do you want me to take
- 29:07that one or do you want to have Curtis handle
- 29:08that one? Yeah. I mean, the buyout option is
- 29:13an interesting buyout option because it's a unilateral
- 29:16buyout option. It is the people who don't want
- 29:19to sell have the right to buy out the people
- 29:22who do want to sell. So if you're going to file
- 29:25a lawsuit, Asking to have the property sold you
- 29:28don't have a right to buy out your opponent You
- 29:31know, so you don't have a right to buy out the
- 29:32other side, but the other side is right to buy
- 29:34you out So, you know if you have a situation
- 29:38where both parties would like to end up with
- 29:41the property and would like to buy out the other
- 29:42one You may want to pause before you file the
- 29:46lawsuit. You might want to hope the other person
- 29:48goes first Because that gives you a right to
- 29:50buy them out rather than having them buy you
- 29:53out That's the primary consideration. There's
- 29:57some other considerations with the Partition
- 30:00Real Property Act having to do with allocation
- 30:01of costs of sale, depending on whether you've
- 30:04asked to have it partitioned or whether you're
- 30:07opposing it or not. But the primary one with
- 30:09regard to the buyout is basically who goes first
- 30:11and who's asking to have it sold. Chris, anything
- 30:16you wanted to add? And this also may go into
- 30:20who's entitled to attorney's fees, as far as
- 30:22who files first versus who files second. Anything
- 30:25you want to add Sure, um, there's some I guess
- 30:30what I would call an accounting component and
- 30:33and when I say that You know in terms of the
- 30:37property being tied up in a partition action.
- 30:39You still have you know property taxes do you
- 30:43know if it's a commercial property that could
- 30:45be repair expenses and and things of that nature
- 30:48and in my experience those things get deprioritized
- 30:52or there's not a lot of incentive sometimes by
- 30:55one party to be on top of that. And so the other
- 30:58party to prevent a default or a punitive late
- 31:02fee will carry those costs throughout the course
- 31:05of the partition. So it is something that's worth
- 31:09tracking. I mean, that would be something that
- 31:12my client and I would keep track of in terms
- 31:14of the incursion of those costs over time, because
- 31:17that's something that you'd want to be credited
- 31:19for, you know, upon liquidation of the property.
- 31:23And I think a judge, as long as that's well documented,
- 31:26will not necessarily apportion, you know, proceeds
- 31:2950 -50 if one side has incurred, you know, reasonably
- 31:34costs associated with carrying the property.
- 31:36And I think the terminology is something like
- 31:38for the common benefit of. The owners of the
- 31:41property, I think, would be properly credited
- 31:43in your client's favor if they're solely bearing
- 31:46those costs for the community benefit of the
- 31:49owners collectively of the property. That makes
- 31:53sense. And then, Curtis, before we go on to the
- 31:54next subject, anything you wanted to add with
- 31:57respect to cases that need to be filed under
- 32:00the new rules, the Partition of Real Property
- 32:02Act for properties held in Tennessee in common?
- 32:04Again, you're the lawyer for the party. who wants
- 32:08to sell, and you're the lawyer for the party
- 32:10who wants to keep it. And that might even change
- 32:14during the course of litigation. I want to keep
- 32:16it. Well, OK, well, it's this much. It costs
- 32:19me this much to keep it. Oh, I don't have that,
- 32:21right? So as far as considerations of cases filed
- 32:25under the new statute, anything you want to add?
- 32:30Sure. I think given the new statute, You'd want
- 32:35to map out the implications the ramifications
- 32:38of the by the buyout option and You could actually
- 32:43have the manner which property is held reconfigured
- 32:48by But with the help of a real estate lawyer
- 32:51and have it recorded in advance So if I did not
- 32:54like the the potential implications of a tenant
- 32:59in common scenario, it's possible I would try
- 33:02to broker a deal and have the ownership reconstituted
- 33:06as a joint tenancy. I think beyond that, it's
- 33:10really just a matter of setting expectations
- 33:13with your client. If my client wants to liquidate
- 33:17the property, then I'm going to basically tell
- 33:21them it's a matter of time, but there are very
- 33:25few defenses that are going to end up defeating
- 33:27a partition. There are some corner cases where
- 33:31extremely bad behavior on your part because the
- 33:35court is sitting in equity, I believe, in this
- 33:37type of dispute. So you shouldn't come in the
- 33:40court with unclean hands. And if those unclean
- 33:43hands are in conjunction with the property itself
- 33:47or the manner in which it was acquired, then
- 33:50you could be deprived of that remedy. But it
- 33:54has to be fairly egregious behavior to to prevent
- 33:58a partition from occurring and likewise it has
- 34:01to be fairly egregious behavior for a court to
- 34:04award attorney's fees to one party. It's not
- 34:09a prevailing party standard at all. There's its
- 34:13own provision in the partition statute that refers
- 34:17to attorney's fees and there certainly is some
- 34:20reported case law. about the award of attorney's
- 34:23fees, and Matthew probably knows them very, very
- 34:26well. But the threshold is quite high. So I would
- 34:31counsel my client, A, very, very likely that
- 34:34the property will be partitioned, whether you're
- 34:37a plaintiff or a defendant. And B is also. very,
- 34:40very difficult to recover attorney's fees, which
- 34:43is why it is most beneficial to your clients
- 34:47to come to agreement and try to accomplish most
- 34:50things in a partition by virtue of stipulation
- 34:53and order and cooperation rather than full tilt
- 34:56litigation because the end result generally.
- 34:59Right. That was always the goal. But again, sometimes
- 35:02you're dealing with the warring siblings. And
- 35:03again, so many, I mean, whenever there's a partition
- 35:06case that looked as if it was headed for trial
- 35:08and I spend a lot of time. lawyers and chambers.
- 35:11You know it's going to happen, right? And yeah,
- 35:13we do. But the parties just won't stipulate.
- 35:17So we've had a number of questions. And so before
- 35:19we kind of leave this topic, Eric, just this
- 35:23alone can be like a four -hour presentation on
- 35:27all the nuances of this, because it is substantial.
- 35:31But going back to the appraisal issue, because
- 35:36I know we very lightly touched on that. So with
- 35:40respect to the new statute, how does that appraisal
- 35:42process work and what if your client's on the
- 35:45receiving end of a not so favorable appraisal?
- 35:47How do you challenge that? Does each side just
- 35:50go to court with their own appraisal? the referee
- 35:53or Matthew, if you want to weigh in on sure.
- 35:56I mean, if we're dealing again, we're dealing
- 35:57with the partition of real property, actually
- 35:58doing with the new one. And there's actually
- 36:00this will answer a couple of the questions that
- 36:01are coming up in a question bubble as well. The
- 36:04statute that deals with appraisal is CCP eight
- 36:07seven four point three one six. And it's got
- 36:10some fairly specific rules. It says basically
- 36:13that if the parties can agree on a method of
- 36:15appraisal or the value, then the court follows
- 36:17that. If the court determines that a full blown
- 36:20appraisal doesn't make economic sense, then they
- 36:22can determine the value some other way. But if
- 36:25you don't have either one of those two, then
- 36:27the default is that the court orders an appraisal.
- 36:28So the court orders an appraisal to happen. The
- 36:31appraisal then is filed at court. And then you
- 36:35have to give, I believe it's 30 days notice after
- 36:37which the court has a hearing. Presumably, someone
- 36:42who's aggrieved by the appraisal could bring
- 36:44in their own evidence that might, and then the
- 36:47judge is supposed to weigh all that evidence
- 36:49and come up with an answer of what is the actual
- 36:51value for the purpose of going forward. And so
- 36:55that's really the first step in the whole process
- 36:57is this appraisal process. Now, is the appraisal
- 37:01process under the new partition of your property?
- 37:03It's under the new one. It's under the new one,
- 37:05yeah. Is that before or after the method of partition?
- 37:10It's before the method of, if you actually go
- 37:13by the statutory guidelines, my understanding
- 37:15is that is the first thing, literally like first
- 37:18step out of the gates, no matter which way you
- 37:21go, is you get this appraisal. Now I'm not positive
- 37:24why they have the appraisal for the partition
- 37:26and kind, because it doesn't seem quite as applicable,
- 37:29but you go by that route. And then only if someone's
- 37:32asking for a buyout route, then you go the buyout
- 37:36route. Okay. And then if no one has, you know,
- 37:39and if you've, if you've settled the entire claim
- 37:41with the appraisal and the buyout, well, then
- 37:42the lawsuit's over because the people who are
- 37:44grieved have purchased each other out. And then
- 37:46after that point, then the next step would be
- 37:49for the judge to determine what's the method
- 37:51of partition. If you're still around and you,
- 37:54and you haven't, people haven't bought each other
- 37:55out. Um, then they, then they go to the next
- 37:58step, which is figuring out what's the method
- 37:59of partition and, and going from that. Well,
- 38:02maybe it's because if this is a, if this is a,
- 38:05as a state, It may not be worth as much as the
- 38:08litigants think it is. And again, are you going
- 38:10to spend hundreds and hundreds of thousands of
- 38:13dollars litigating something that's worth this
- 38:15much versus this much? And that might even go
- 38:18to the prevailing party attorney's fees of you
- 38:23litigated this. And again, the court may not
- 38:26think that it was really worth everyone's time
- 38:28to go to trial of, well, I paid the property
- 38:30tax this year and I paid the gardener and I did
- 38:32the roof. for this amount of money and you spent
- 38:35all this so you know that that can all be taken
- 38:37into account just like any attorney's fees analysis
- 38:40so what we talked about the uh just the whole
- 38:45uh appointing a referee and again this is you
- 38:48know really important uh Matthew but again the
- 38:51statutory authority appointment of a referee
- 38:54Sure. I mean, the statutory appointment for referee
- 38:56is that if the court is determined that it's
- 38:58supposed to be a partition, so this is you've
- 39:00kind of gone through the process of whatever
- 39:03you're going to do, preliminarily determine that
- 39:05it's appropriate for a partition, then the court
- 39:06has the option of appointing a referee for the
- 39:09purpose of carrying out the court's judgment.
- 39:11That would either be doing one of two things.
- 39:15processing the partition in kind, so that would
- 39:18be like a subdivision of the land, or in a case
- 39:21of a partition by sale, the job of the referee
- 39:23is to hire a real estate agent and basically
- 39:26manage the sale. And this is actually really
- 39:29the most important part of the job of the referee
- 39:33is to manage the sale. Now you've got a statute
- 39:35up there that talks about who can and can't be
- 39:38a referee. The general rule, and there's a slightly
- 39:42different statute for referee appointment under
- 39:46the Partition of Real Property Act, but the basic
- 39:48rule is you can't be a referee if you're one
- 39:50of the parties to the action or one of the attorneys
- 39:52or someone like that. But if you're uninterested
- 39:55and in part, then you can be a referee. There
- 39:58isn't a specific requirement to have a particular
- 40:01license or anything like that. Usually the way
- 40:03that a referee is appointed is that one of the
- 40:06other sides will request from the court that
- 40:08a referee be appointed. The judge will either
- 40:11have someone that they have in mind from past
- 40:12experiences or the parties will nominate someone
- 40:14and the judge ultimately picks. So the decision
- 40:16on who's gonna be the referee is made by the
- 40:19judge. Correct. And so it seems the value is
- 40:25when you have someone who has to sell begrudgingly.
- 40:29It's the party that wanted to keep it, but now
- 40:32has to sell the property and won't sign the listing
- 40:35agreement, won't act on an offer, won't sign.
- 40:40What kind of difficulties do you deal with, Matthew?
- 40:42Well, yeah. I mean, look, if you have a standard
- 40:45Real estate transaction that doesn't involve
- 40:48the court and doesn't involve court orders and
- 40:50it's owned by more than one person You can't
- 40:52even hire a real estate agent if one party isn't
- 40:55gonna sign let alone doing any of the other things
- 40:57You know responding to offers setting a listing
- 41:00price any of those things So basically if you
- 41:03don't have a court order and a referee Then any
- 41:06one of these co -owners has the the right to
- 41:09basically veto the sale effectively and stalled
- 41:11out just by doing nothing then so one of the
- 41:15Primary things that the referee has as a power
- 41:19is the authority to sign on behalf of the existing
- 41:22owners. So it's the referee's job to hire the
- 41:26real estate agent, set the prices. respond to
- 41:29offers, sign the contract, sign the escrow documents,
- 41:32all that stuff, and it's done with just the referee's
- 41:34signature. It's not done with the requirement
- 41:36to get the signatures of both owners or multiple
- 41:39owners. Now there's a court confirmation process,
- 41:42so the referee, after he's appointed, can't complete
- 41:45the sale without going back to court. where there's
- 41:47an evidentiary hearing and the judge determines
- 41:49whether or not it's an appropriate sale and things
- 41:51like that. But short of that, it's basically
- 41:54the referee's job to push the sale through. Because
- 41:56by the time you get to this point, the judge
- 41:58has already determined there will be a sale.
- 42:00And we're going to put it on the market. And
- 42:02so the referee mechanism is the way that it happens.
- 42:06Right. And I can tell you from having these cases
- 42:08where it's the one, you know, again, typically
- 42:10the siblings who inherit the property, it's one
- 42:12does not want to sell. And so, oh, we're going
- 42:14to agree on appraisal. Oh, you know, won't agree.
- 42:17We're going to list it for sale. Oh, no, this,
- 42:20this co -owner won't sign the listing agreement.
- 42:23And then on and on, or there's an offer that
- 42:26expires because it's not acted on. So the referee
- 42:29can really short circuit a lot of these issues
- 42:31and the statutory authority. for the referee's
- 42:34powers is on the screen. But Curtis, anything
- 42:37you want to add with respect to using a referee
- 42:39as a litigant and as an attorney? Yeah, what
- 42:44I would add is that they're just a great quarterback
- 42:47for a host of issues. If it's a fairly cut and
- 42:51dried situation and lots of cooperation, and
- 42:54I would say maybe if you're only dealing with
- 42:56one APN, I pursue a referee if there's any friction
- 43:02at all. especially early on. If I'm in a frictionalist
- 43:06plane scenario where the other side is not resisting
- 43:09the partition litigation process on our end,
- 43:14and or if I'm dealing with a single APN, it's
- 43:18straightforward, then I'm comfortable going A
- 43:21to Z. But if there's any interference or complexities
- 43:24with a multitude of parties or multiple APNs,
- 43:28then you can quickly end up with a downward spiral
- 43:32without a referee in place. Because a lot of
- 43:35it is just organization and getting things done
- 43:39just exponentially faster than without a judge.
- 43:44Because it's just like herding cats. Even if
- 43:47everyone is cooperative. If you have seven or
- 43:49eight different owners and you've got a letter
- 43:52of intent to try to sell a property that has
- 43:54some significant value, you spend weeks tracking
- 43:57people down just to get them to sign a letter
- 44:00of intent or to enter into a listing agreement
- 44:02to get the property on the market. That's a lot
- 44:06of lost time. The one property owner who's on
- 44:09a cruise somewhere in the South Pacific and can't
- 44:11be reached. Precisely, precisely. And you can't
- 44:15get any material you know, decisions made without,
- 44:19you know, 100 % cooperation. So when that power
- 44:22is under the roof of a referee, you can really
- 44:26get stuff done quickly. A simple, you know, non
- 44:30-loyalty way to describe it would be referee
- 44:33is, you know, like a power of attorney with respect
- 44:36to. whatever needs to be done to effectuate a
- 44:39sale that's that's reasonable that a court would
- 44:42do if the court could make that decision, you
- 44:45know, in a day. That's that's kind of the huge
- 44:48advantage you get. Think of it as like getting
- 44:50like an expert judge that can act ex parte on
- 44:53what you need when you need it in that amount
- 44:56of time, like 24 hours. You can get an adjudic
- 44:59basically an adjudication from a referee without
- 45:02waiting three or four or five weeks to get in
- 45:04front of a judge. every single time you need
- 45:07something done. Even getting a stipulation signed
- 45:09takes time with a judicial officer. So that's
- 45:12the way I think of it. It's like having a sort
- 45:16of a judge in place for all purposes. Right.
- 45:19And before we move on, and that does make sense.
- 45:21And one thing I wanted to note, and it's on the
- 45:23screen, of the referee or the purchaser or any
- 45:27party may move the court to confirm or set aside
- 45:29the sale. So my docket in downtown LA, 2018 2019
- 45:34was about 500 cases and Now the judge who has
- 45:38my old assignment old department has it's it's
- 45:42out a thousand to twelve hundred. It's it's it's
- 45:44too much and so again when if you record plenty
- 45:49of free time you could go to court on the motions
- 45:51of the other the other side won't sign the listing
- 45:54agreement or the other side won't sign the sign
- 45:57-off document or we can't get it recorded and
- 46:00again, there would be a shorter time frame, but
- 46:01now The judges are so busy. And look, it's not
- 46:05an emergency that warrants an ex -party application
- 46:08of, we're trying to sell the property and the
- 46:10other side won't sign the listing agreement with
- 46:13the realtor. That's not an emergency. Those aren't
- 46:16exigent circumstances. So you can't come in ex
- 46:19-party. So they encourage your point that is
- 46:21apt, that the referee is kind of the judge sitting
- 46:24on an ex -party basis. The other thing about
- 46:26this point I want to make, not speaking for any
- 46:29judges in all circumstances and whatnot, but...
- 46:32Again, especially when the courts have such a
- 46:35limited amount of time and they are sober worked.
- 46:37If you had to keep coming in of this side won't
- 46:40sign this and this side won't say that, and the
- 46:42referee submits a report to the court. Again,
- 46:45if it's a professional referee like Matthew,
- 46:47it's completely arm's length, completely professional,
- 46:50a referee who's known to the court. It's not,
- 46:52you know, the party's brother -in -law's best
- 46:55friend's butcher is the referee, right? It's
- 46:57a true arm's length professional referee. the
- 47:01court's going to give a substantial amount of
- 47:03weight to that report. So that's something to
- 47:07think about too. Yeah, I would add to your point,
- 47:11Judge Befor, that the referee can really be an
- 47:14advocate for both sides. I mean, they're a neutral
- 47:17extension of power from the judicial officer
- 47:21assigned to the case. And there are a lot of
- 47:24instances where I did not have to be the bad
- 47:27cop. An example would be you get an offer, you
- 47:30know, a proposal from a prospective buyer and
- 47:34they want to do like, you know, four months of,
- 47:36you know, due diligence on the property. You
- 47:39know, I don't have to be the bad guy. My client
- 47:41doesn't have to be a bad guy. Matthew might step
- 47:43in and say, well, I'm looking at the interlocutory
- 47:45order. And it says, I don't get an offer on this
- 47:47thing within 90 days. It's going to core sale
- 47:50or in my, you know, in my opinion, given the
- 47:55market right now on real estate and how uncertain
- 47:58it is, it could be very precarious for this transaction
- 48:02to be delayed by four months. I'm not going to
- 48:05sign off on that. I'm going to solicit offers
- 48:08from buyers that will complete due diligence
- 48:10within 60 days. So those are just the types of
- 48:13things the referee can really flex. and present
- 48:21it to the court that way, or even before it gets
- 48:23to the court, can push back against buyers, get
- 48:28more dollars for you, get better terms for you,
- 48:31and you don't really have to be the bad cop.
- 48:34And it's pretty powerful when a referee just
- 48:36says, I don't think the court's gonna go for
- 48:38this if I send a report, or I've done this many,
- 48:41many times, and judges almost always reject this
- 48:44sort of exotic provision, or whatever the case
- 48:47may be, it's very authoritative to have it come
- 48:49from a referee. Right. That makes sense. So I
- 48:52know we have just about 10 minutes left. So Matthew,
- 48:55I have this up. What happens if the cell proceeds
- 48:57and not sold? Now, what do you as a referee do?
- 49:00Sure. Well, by statute, the sale proceeds go
- 49:03to the referee who's supposed to hold them. And
- 49:06then the CCP 873 .850 is a really, really important
- 49:11statute that everybody who practices this area
- 49:13should know about. It answers a couple of the
- 49:16questions, by the way, in our open dialogue or
- 49:18question and answer dialogue from the audience
- 49:20members. And it's basically what happens to the
- 49:23money afterwards. And so what happens is that
- 49:26partition cases have this weird two phase process.
- 49:30Process one is you get this thing called interlocutory
- 49:32judgment that usually just appoints the references,
- 49:35go forth and sell the property, but it usually
- 49:37doesn't divide up the money because until you
- 49:39sell the property, you don't know how much you're
- 49:41dividing. And then CCP 873 .850 is the statute
- 49:46that gives the court the continuing jurisdiction
- 49:48to divide the money afterwards. And that's really
- 49:51the key to this entire process. If you're selling
- 49:53the property, somebody has to ultimately end
- 49:56up dividing the property. And so that's What
- 49:59ends up happening is that the referee would either
- 50:01report back to court and say judge I've sold
- 50:03the property. Here's the cost of sale Here's
- 50:05what I'm holding. Tell me what to do with it
- 50:07in which case then that then the judge takes
- 50:09over again and sets the matter for trial or what
- 50:12I've seen a lot of times that that statute also
- 50:15allows the court to to empower the referee to
- 50:20gather evidence on the subject and The way that
- 50:23I have seen that enacted most often is that the
- 50:26court will basically tell the referee go out
- 50:28set a claims period, gather claims from the parties,
- 50:31come back and make a recommendation, how to divide
- 50:33it up. And then at that point, then it would
- 50:35be, I would then file my report at the court
- 50:37and the judge would decide whether to accept
- 50:40my recommendation or reject it or start all over.
- 50:43But for a lot of the judges, and Judge Feffer
- 50:45can comment on this, sitting down and spending
- 50:48days going through receipts is not really at
- 50:51the top of your wish list. One day. It's fun.
- 50:54You get your day in court. Yeah and and so you
- 50:58know basically having someone who's who's empowered
- 51:01to go off and do that and organize it and then
- 51:03come back and present it all nights and tied
- 51:05up with a little bow on top is something that's
- 51:07very appreciated by many judges. So Matthew would
- 51:10you oftentimes put this in your report of of
- 51:15you know you you've almost kind of done the accounting
- 51:17of this is what was paid on this date so there's
- 51:19really no dispute it's just this party has paid
- 51:22these expenses and this party's paid these expenses.
- 51:25Yes. Okay. Yep, and it would come down to like,
- 51:28everybody, yeah, this party made these claims.
- 51:31They want to be reimbursed for their, you know,
- 51:33they pay the property insurance and they say
- 51:34the other guys collected the rent and didn't
- 51:36share it. And then basically, you know, the job
- 51:39of the referee is to gather the claims from the
- 51:41parties, have them submit the evidence, and then
- 51:44assemble that all and make a coherent report
- 51:46to the court about, here's how you should divide
- 51:48up the money. Because, I mean, look, the sale
- 51:50proceeds are a fixed sum. You're not going to
- 51:52get more than that. So the sale proceeds have
- 51:55to be divided somehow. And this is basically
- 51:57a process by which the sale proceeds get divided.
- 51:59Right. Makes sense. Chris, anything you want
- 52:01to add with respect to the sale proceeds? No,
- 52:06the only thing I would add is that there tends
- 52:09to be a waterfall that's fairly straightforward.
- 52:11And normally, in a complaint, I try to articulate.
- 52:14that waterfall and, or it would typically be
- 52:18articulated in the interlocutory judgment. And
- 52:20I think a referee who's assigned to the case,
- 52:24if you fail to articulate the waterfall would
- 52:27likely redline, you know, or be involved in commenting
- 52:31on a interlocutory, proposed interlocutory judgment
- 52:35to help ensure there's no surprises and that
- 52:39expectations across the board are. met rather
- 52:44than people being confused or surprised, if you
- 52:48will, by how the proceeds are divided at the
- 52:51end. But I will say it's not a lot different
- 52:54than the sale of a property in accordance with
- 52:59an escrow. There's just a priority of payments
- 53:02that have to be dispersed in order. And the statute
- 53:05is pretty cut and dried on that. Well, and I
- 53:08think this is a point at which it's actually
- 53:10really useful to think about if you're representing
- 53:13parties in action, this is a good point to talk
- 53:15about maybe getting your clients to some sort
- 53:16of a mediation. Because this is the point at
- 53:19which I think that from what I've seen based
- 53:21on owner psychology, you don't have any holdouts
- 53:24anymore thinking that they're going to stay in
- 53:25the property because the property's already been
- 53:27sold. There's a fixed amount that everybody knows
- 53:30exactly what it is and everybody that's an attorney
- 53:33or referee or anybody that's billing against
- 53:35the case is billing and taking out of that pile
- 53:37of money before the owners and So this is the
- 53:40point at which for the owners they got really
- 53:42two choices choice one is let's figure out how
- 53:44to divide it up or choice two is let's keep on
- 53:46fighting about it for a year or two years or
- 53:48three years through the court system while the
- 53:50money for us gradually is diminished and You
- 53:53know given those two choices most people I have
- 53:56found even the even like hardliners who don't
- 53:58want to be selling their property will often
- 54:01come around. And it's a great time to get to
- 54:03somebody who's a mediator, who has experience
- 54:05handling these things, who can say, hey, here's
- 54:08what a judge would likely do. So why don't you
- 54:11just save yourself the trouble and agree to an
- 54:13advance? Right. Yeah. No, certainly. And that's
- 54:16a problem with it. I mean, we all love early
- 54:19mediation because you're not spending the money.
- 54:21But Again, that's why I mentioned this is kind
- 54:23of a probate case, philosophically. Oftentimes,
- 54:27their parties had some familiar relationship,
- 54:30or a family law case. They just kind of need
- 54:33to hash out those issues first. And sometimes,
- 54:36if the lawyers agree, you should be settling
- 54:37this. The judge is going to do this. It will
- 54:40be ordered sold. You will be spending all this
- 54:41money. Why not just do this now before you spend
- 54:44the fees? And unfortunately, lawyers... Parties
- 54:47sometimes get caught up in that but but certainly
- 54:49she said Matthew. This is an excellent point
- 54:51of yes, it's going to be sold We've submitted
- 54:54all the receipts the referee is writing up the
- 54:56reimbursement and here's how much money we have
- 54:59from the sale Do we keep litigating to diminish
- 55:02it? Do the parties want to get some money from
- 55:05the sale or is it all gonna go to the lawyers?
- 55:07And so that's that's a critical point to discuss
- 55:10speaking of money. I know we just have a few
- 55:12more minutes left is How does the referee get
- 55:16paid and get on the bench many times and say
- 55:19hey Parties work this out because it's going
- 55:22to get Expensive it's going to keep being expensive
- 55:25and there's a certain amount of money that you're
- 55:28going to get from the sale But again, there's
- 55:31certainly an excellent point if you have a party
- 55:34Parties who do not want to go forward with the
- 55:37sale and want to obstruct it that the referee
- 55:40can really smooth the path, especially with the
- 55:42courts being so busy. So Matthew, if you want
- 55:44to speak to this issue. Yeah. I mean, the question
- 55:47of how a referee is paid. The default rule is
- 55:49that a referee is paid from the sale proceeds
- 55:50that are generated by the sale. So the referee
- 55:53is not like an expert witness who's hired by
- 55:56one side or the other, or given a retainer by
- 55:58one side or the other, or anything like that.
- 56:00The thing that hires the referee is the order
- 56:02from the court, and the court has the authority
- 56:05to set the fees of the referee. Most commonly,
- 56:08the fees of the referee are on an hourly basis,
- 56:11and most commonly what happens is that at the
- 56:13conclusion of the sale, the referee goes back
- 56:14to court and says, Judge, I've done what you
- 56:16asked me to do. Here's my hourly fees, and I'd
- 56:19like to get paid. And then the court has the
- 56:20jurisdiction to approve or disapprove those fees
- 56:22and has the jurisdiction to allocate among the
- 56:25parties who's going to be responsible for it.
- 56:27Curtis had mentioned several times sort of a
- 56:29waterfall of who gets paid when, and there is,
- 56:31by statute, there's a waterfall of who gets paid
- 56:33paid out of these cases. And the first priority
- 56:35are the costs of sale. So this would be things
- 56:37like escrow costs, stuff like that. Second priority
- 56:40is what are called the cost of partition. That
- 56:42includes the referee fees. It also includes the
- 56:44fees of the attorney's fees and costs for the
- 56:47litigants parties. So those are the second priority
- 56:50if the court awards them. And then you get into
- 56:53lien holders. And then you get finally at the
- 56:55end of the waterfall, you get to the actual owners
- 56:56of the property. Yes, that's important. I know.
- 57:00Chris, anything you want to add? No, I am working
- 57:05on a quick answer to a question here. I think
- 57:07you pretty much nailed that. Sure. Then one question
- 57:10to each of you, and maybe each of you would know
- 57:12this, but one of the questions that's come in
- 57:14is, what about leans? That you have a property
- 57:17that's going for sale and all the leans have
- 57:19been identified. At what point are those satisfied
- 57:23in the waterfall? Yeah. By statute, those are
- 57:27actually. third in the priority, but as a practical
- 57:31matter, if you're selling the property, they
- 57:33get paid from the sale proceeds because in order
- 57:36to get title insurance on the sale, the title
- 57:39insurance company will insist that the liens
- 57:41get paid. So basically, if you've got liens,
- 57:44these are things like mortgages on the property,
- 57:45tax liens, child support liens, whatever, those
- 57:48get paid from the sale proceeds because you can't
- 57:49close escrow in a regular commercial transaction
- 57:52without handling those things. The title insurance
- 57:54company won't write a title policy unless you
- 57:56do that. Yeah, and just to follow on to that
- 57:59is my practice I think generally is to include
- 58:04lien holders in the litigation You might I call
- 58:09them nominal defendants. It's not a you know,
- 58:12it's sort of a you know, I may have culpa You
- 58:15know case against them often. It's a bank, you
- 58:18know, so if it's a partition between a you know
- 58:21a brother and sister and the properties encumbered
- 58:25you know, by Bank of America, you know, deed
- 58:28of trust, then I'm going to, I'm going to name,
- 58:31you know, B of A and, you know, serve their legal
- 58:34department or, you know, the, the proper agent
- 58:36for service or process to make sure that they're
- 58:39in the loop because I don't want to have any
- 58:41open, open issues. And I don't like having a
- 58:44disparity between what the title report shows,
- 58:46namely they're lean on the one hand, and then
- 58:50them not being a participant in the lawsuit.
- 58:53Um, on the other hand, because it could create
- 58:56problems at the end. Right. Very good. Well,
- 59:00good. Well, that takes us to the end. Again,
- 59:02I know there's a lot. And again, you have the
- 59:05one -hour format. I think we covered as much.
- 59:08I mean, we could do this for another three, four
- 59:10hours to all the nuances. But it's important
- 59:12that lawyers know that there is the new statute.
- 59:15Again, relatively new, but all cases. filed with
- 59:19the Tennessee common have to be filed under the
- 59:21new statute with the new procedures and that
- 59:24I think math incurs I mean as of now I think
- 59:26there are still no published cases I'm not aware
- 59:29of any published case under the new statute correct
- 59:31that's still kind of new so it's very important
- 59:33when you're facing a judge that they may not
- 59:35have seen these cases so it's important to brief
- 59:37these issues and provide the statutory authority
- 59:39and curse anything else you want to say about
- 59:41that I think you started no um you know super
- 59:46super helpful um Even though I'm presenting here,
- 59:49I learned something new every time I get on this
- 59:51panel discussion like this. So thanks, Judge
- 59:54Feffer and then Matthew as well. Yes. Thank you
- 59:59to both of you. So our contact information is
- 1:00:01there and it's been a pleasure spending the lunch
- 1:00:04with everyone here. Thank you. I enjoyed it very
- 1:00:07much and thank you for having by the way to the
- 1:00:10audience members Thank you for the questions.
- 1:00:11Those are great questions. They're great questions
- 1:00:13Sorry, we couldn't get to all of them, but we
- 1:00:14tried to get as many as we could and they were
- 1:00:16very insightful So, thank you so much Thank you