Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 322. Talk Back: Why Arguing With Yourself Can Help You Flourish
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Arguing with yourself may be the best way to flourish.
- 0:06My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:09Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:11Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:15Today, I'm excited to speak with Martin Seligman.
- 0:17Marty is a world-renowned psychologist and professor at
- 0:20the University of Pennsylvania.
- 0:22He's the director of the Positive Psychology Center.
- 0:25His groundbreaking research has fundamentally reshaped how science
- 0:29understands human wellbeing.
- 0:31He has authored more than 30 books, including Flourish, Authentic
- 0:35Happiness, and his latest, Agency: The Psychological History of Human Progress.
- 0:41Well, welcome, Martin.
- 0:42I first learned of your work when I was an undergraduate.
- 0:46The work you did in learned helplessness was really fascinating and actually helped
- 0:51me want to study more in psychology.
- 0:53Thank you, and thank you for being here.
- 0:56Martin Seligman: I'm pleased to be here, Matt.
- 0:58I have to confess I'm intimidated by the title of your endeavor.
- 1:03I used to be fast, and now I'm slow, and I used to be smart, and now the
- 1:08best I can do is be contemplative.
- 1:11Matt Abrahams: Oh, well, I appreciate that, and we will have a lovely
- 1:14conversation that goes deep and contemplates lots of important things.
- 1:18Shall we get started?
- 1:19Martin Seligman: Okay.
- 1:20Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 1:21So it is rare to get the opportunity to speak with somebody
- 1:24who started an entire field.
- 1:26You started the field of wellness and wellbeing and
- 1:30happiness research in psychology.
- 1:32We've had several guests on the show who've talked about things
- 1:35in this field, Sonja Lyubomirsky, Laurie Santos, Arthur Brooks, and
- 1:40I'd love to get your take on it.
- 1:41You, across the studying you do, have studied something called flourishing.
- 1:46Can you share with us a bit about what flourishing is and
- 1:49what we can do to achieve it?
- 1:51Martin Seligman: Well, my interest in flourishing started because it was a
- 1:55field that psychology wouldn't touch, the question of how to be happy.
- 2:00And my experience, and probably yours, Matt, when you lie in bed at night,
- 2:05you're not thinking about how to go from minus eight to minus three.
- 2:10You're thinking about how to go from plus three to plus eight in life.
- 2:14Well, there was no psychology of that, and that was my motive for
- 2:19founding, when I was president of the American Psychological Association,
- 2:24the field of positive psychology, which is about flourishing.
- 2:28And for me, flourishing has five elements.
- 2:33The acronym is PERMA.
- 2:35P is positive emotion, subjective well-being.
- 2:41E is engagement, how absorbed you are right now in our conversation.
- 2:47R is relationships, good relationships.
- 2:51M is one sense of meaning and mattering.
- 2:55And A is accomplishment and achievement.
- 2:59So for me, flourishing relies on five pillars I call PERMA.
- 3:06Matt Abrahams: It's very clear that each of those can help us all feel better.
- 3:11In your work and in your research, do all five need to be in place
- 3:15for someone to feel that sense of wellbeing and flourishing?
- 3:18Or is it just having one or two areas where you really feel
- 3:21accomplished or passionate?
- 3:23Is that enough?
- 3:24Martin Seligman: Not at all.
- 3:25It's like a dashboard on an airplane.
- 3:28So there are lots of dials on an airplane, but if you wanna get
- 3:32there as cheaply as possible, it's the central dial that matters.
- 3:37If you wanna get there as comfortably as possible, it's the radar that matters.
- 3:42Similarly with PERMA, I'm a high meaning and accomplishment person.
- 3:48Those are the two of the five that really matter for me.
- 3:52So for me, flourishing is knowing about the techniques of more meaning in my life
- 4:00and the techniques of more accomplishment.
- 4:04It's secondary to me, the hedonics, how much joy I feel and how engaged I am.
- 4:11Like the dashboard on an airplane, it depends on what you care about.
- 4:17Matt Abrahams: Ah, so each of us can reflect what's most important.
- 4:20So as I look at PERMA, I feel that relationships and meaning are what's
- 4:25most important in my life, and I can try to optimize for those as almost
- 4:29a roadmap for how we can find our way to deeper fulfillment and flourishing
- 4:35simply by thinking through these five variables and what's important for
- 4:39us, and then how to optimize for them.
- 4:41I appreciate that, and challenge everybody listening to think about
- 4:44where you fall on passion, enjoyment, relationship, meaning, and accomplishment.
- 4:51Some of your work talks about the internal conversations we have
- 4:55with ourselves, the monologue, that self-tape we have playing in our head.
- 5:00How does this shape our worldview?
- 5:03And if we're not happy with that chatter, are there things we can do to change it?
- 5:08Martin Seligman: Well, I think the most important revolution in psychology in my
- 5:12lifetime was the cognitive revolution.
- 5:15Before that came along, people believed that emotion was primary,
- 5:21and what you said to yourself, what you thought, was a product of emotion.
- 5:27We now know at least that what you think very often determines
- 5:33your emotion and your action.
- 5:36What you think is not gospel.
- 5:39It's often whispered to you by someone whose mission in life
- 5:44was to make you miserable.
- 5:47So it's very important to be on top of your internal dialogue, and then if
- 5:54you're finding it makes you depressed and anxious, to argue against it rationally.
- 6:02So a lot of what one does in flourishing and positive psychology, which came
- 6:07right out of cognitive therapy, was to become very sensitive to what
- 6:13we're saying to ourselves and learn how to argue against it when it was
- 6:19leading you places you didn't wanna go.
- 6:22Matt Abrahams: This idea of listening to that chatter can be hard for many of us.
- 6:26Are there techniques that you know of or perhaps use yourself
- 6:30that give us insight to it?
- 6:32I mean, the voice in my head, I'm just so used to hearing, I don't
- 6:35really sit and reflect on it.
- 6:36How can I best dispassionately learn about it?
- 6:39Martin Seligman: As a pessimist and a depressive, I've spent a lifetime
- 6:43inventing these techniques and using them.
- 6:47And on the pessimistic depressive side, the voices are
- 6:51always going to occur to you.
- 6:53They're not eliminated.
- 6:55What happens is you can counter them.
- 6:58And so for example, Matt, before I came on the show with you, I was
- 7:03quite anxious about it, and I was thinking, "Good heavens, I'm in my 80s.
- 7:07Can I really keep up with Matt and talk fast and smart?
- 7:13And gee, I'm too old for this." And when we came on together, indeed I
- 7:19was thinking something like that.
- 7:21But as the listener doesn't know, we had three technical difficulties.
- 7:27During the time you and I made friends, I argued against that.
- 7:32Here I'm dealing with one of the experts on impromptu speech, and I'm doing great.
- 7:38And so I essentially argued against, "I just can't be fast and smart."
- 7:44So I've become an expert both at hearing what I say to myself, but at
- 7:50realistically marshaling evidence against depressive and pessimistic thoughts.
- 7:58Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate that.
- 8:00Thank you for enduring the technical difficulties, and I actually
- 8:02have enjoyed our conversation in between those very much.
- 8:06And what I really like about what you have said is that the words
- 8:11that we say to ourselves are merely arguments that can be countered, and
- 8:16they can be countered with evidence.
- 8:18So in a lot of my coaching work and some of my teaching work, there are a lot of
- 8:22people who experience what I think would generally be defined as imposter syndrome.
- 8:27The stories they're telling themselves is they don't deserve this, or
- 8:31they're not up to the challenge.
- 8:34And what I hear you saying is you can use evidence to counter that position.
- 8:38You can say, "Look, you were invited to give this talk. You were
- 8:42promoted to this position." This is all evidence that runs counter to
- 8:46that story you're telling yourself.
- 8:49And I can see how that would lead to more positive feeling, or at least
- 8:52a reduction of the negative feeling.
- 8:54Do I have that right?
- 8:55Martin Seligman: The two things to know about the imposter syndrome
- 8:59are first, those voices that are telling you you're an imposter
- 9:03have nothing to do with reality.
- 9:06They have to do with deep worries, with childhood, what
- 9:11your parents used to say to you.
- 9:13That's part one.
- 9:14They're not realistic, so you should treat them as not realistic, and then
- 9:21marshal all the evidence about why you got here and what your credentials
- 9:26were, and that it's not an accident that you're sitting in this position now.
- 9:32So the imposter syndrome can be dealt well with those two steps.
- 9:38Matt Abrahams: Absolutely, and thank you for that.
- 9:40And I think all of us can talk back to some of that chatter
- 9:43that we have in our head.
- 9:45A lot of what you have shared with us so far in your work is about
- 9:49becoming aware of these patterns, habits, just inclinations we have.
- 9:54With the realization of the future looms large in how we feel and what
- 10:00we do, what are some things we can do to maximize wellness, relationships,
- 10:07communication with that knowledge?
- 10:10Martin Seligman: From the point of view of happiness, I think the notion
- 10:15of agency becomes very important.
- 10:18And indeed, agency is what my new book is about.
- 10:23It's the culmination of 60 years of work, and I think it's the most
- 10:28informative tool we have both about our futures and the human future.
- 10:34Matt Abrahams: Can you define what you mean by agency?
- 10:36I found your book fascinating.
- 10:38And what are some of the key components that make up our sense of agency?
- 10:43Martin Seligman: I think there are three.
- 10:45The first is efficacy, and that's to what extent do you believe that you can
- 10:52achieve your goals in the here and now?
- 10:56The second is optimism.
- 10:58To what extent do you believe you're gonna be able to achieve those goals
- 11:04in the future and far into the future?
- 11:07And the third is imagination, and that is the range of goals that
- 11:13you can envision about your future.
- 11:18So a complete sense of efficacy, of agency as efficacy, optimism, and imagination.
- 11:27Matt Abrahams: You helped found the field of positive psychology.
- 11:30You are the founder of that field.
- 11:32I know from talking to people and having seen it develop that there were some
- 11:37naysayers, there was some resistance.
- 11:39What advice do you have for people who are initiating new ideas, new
- 11:45approaches for helping be persuasive and influential to at least get people
- 11:51to consider a different approach?
- 11:53Any insights from the experience you went through getting to where you are today?
- 11:59Martin Seligman: Well, I think it's important to put yourself in the
- 12:01shoes of your critics, to anticipate what's wrong, to become comfortable
- 12:08with their arguments, and to make your best arguments against it.
- 12:12And I, I'm just remembering the late Barbara Ehrenreich, who was one of
- 12:17the critics of positive psychology.
- 12:20She wrote a book called Bright-sided, which compared me to The Wizard of Oz.
- 12:26And in the last few months of her life, we got into a dialogue together in which she
- 12:34said something like, "Well, you probably have a very dim view of me, Marty, and
- 12:39you probably think my prospects are not very good because I'm not a promo person."
- 12:45And I said, "Well, not at all, Barb.
- 12:47You're so engaged in these issues of social justice that your engagement
- 12:54is enormous, and that is a health and optimism and life-preserving force."
- 13:02And I remember Barbara writing me shortly before her death, telling me how
- 13:06meaningful that was in the face of this merciless criticism that she had given me.
- 13:13So owning and befriending your critics is important.
- 13:18Matt Abrahams: That reflection on what's important to them and where they're
- 13:21coming from can allow you to have a much more meaningful conversation.
- 13:26Well, Marty, this has been a phenomenal conversation.
- 13:29Thank you so much.
- 13:30As you well know, we end with three questions, one I will make up for you
- 13:35and two that I've been asking everybody.
- 13:37And we've spent a lot of time talking about the internal communication we have.
- 13:41I'm curious to understand your perspective on the external communication.
- 13:44How do we maximize our communication to help ourselves and help others?
- 13:49Martin Seligman: Well, something happened 20 years ago which turned this field
- 13:53around for me, and that was let's think about how people celebrate together
- 13:59rather than how they fight together.
- 14:02So the question is not how you go wrong, but what do you say to your spouse
- 14:09or your best friend when they come to you with a victory, with a triumph?
- 14:16And that's something that people have not worked on.
- 14:19If you can imagine a two by two destructive, constructive, active,
- 14:25and passive, the only one that really works is active constructive.
- 14:31So let me just give you an example of that.
- 14:34My wife Mandy is a amateur black and white photographer.
- 14:40And a few years ago, she came downstairs and said to me, "Marty, the editor
- 14:45of Black and White Magazine just called me, and I won the international
- 14:50award for the best black and white photograph." Okay, what should I say
- 14:56to Mandy when she comes down with that?
- 15:00Well, what I would have said until I had read the revolutionary work
- 15:04on communication and marriage was, "Congratulations, dear. You deserve
- 15:11it. You're a great photographer." Well, that's called passive-constructive,
- 15:17and it has no effect.
- 15:18It's wallpaper.
- 15:20But I knew the literature on active-constructive.
- 15:24And so here's what I said.
- 15:27First, I had to show Mandy that I really knew what she was talking about.
- 15:31So I said, "Was it the black and white picture of the swan that you took in
- 15:38Blenheim last summer that won it?" And she said, "Yes, it was, in fact." I
- 15:43said, "Well, you know, Mandy, that's the most beautiful black and white
- 15:46picture of an animal I've ever seen." So that was part one, showing that you
- 15:52really knew what the triumph was about.
- 15:55But here comes the part that's important and we neglect out of haste often,
- 16:01and that's to put Mandy in touch with this great victory she just had.
- 16:07So I said, "Mandy, tell me verbatim, what did the editor of Black and White say?"
- 16:14And so she went through it.
- 16:16I said, "Well, then, what do you think it is about your photography that could
- 16:21have snatched the prizes away from The New York Times Pulitzer Prize winner?" And she
- 16:27said, "I think I'm very good with gray, and I do a lot with nuances." And then
- 16:33I said, "Okay, well, how can you teach kids this technique in their drawing and
- 16:39photography?" And so we talked about that.
- 16:42Then I said, "Mandy, let's go to the refrigerator and open that
- 16:46bottle of Dom Perignon that's been sitting there for a decade."
- 16:50Matt Abrahams: That idea of being constructive and engaged in
- 16:53dialogue around that, really, really insightful because most people
- 16:58just act in a very heuristic way.
- 17:00"Hey, you won an award. Congratulations." This requires
- 17:03a bit more thought and presence.
- 17:05Martin Seligman: It takes a lot of work.
- 17:07And the reason we say things like, "What's for dinner?" or, "Congratulations,"
- 17:13is we, we're not used to doing that work, and it doesn't come naturally.
- 17:17But the other person knows that, and that's why it's wallpaper.
- 17:21So active-constructive communication is a difficult technique, and it takes
- 17:28practice, and we can get better at it.
- 17:31Matt Abrahams: The rewards for doing that are a deepening of the
- 17:34relationship, and I appreciate that.
- 17:37Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 17:42Martin Seligman: I'm thinking Ludwig Wittgenstein, actually, although
- 17:45I've never heard him in speech.
- 17:48But I've read some of the impromptu things that he had to say, and the one
- 17:53that's on my mind right now, because I've been thinking about the question
- 17:58of what is the meaning of life, and it is not a good question at all.
- 18:03Wittgenstein said, impromptu, I'm told, "I don't know why we're here, but I'm
- 18:11pretty sure it's not to be happy."
- 18:17Matt Abrahams: I can see why somebody who founded positive
- 18:19psychology would be enamored with that or, or curious about it.
- 18:22I have to ask, you said that the meaning of life is a bad question.
- 18:26What is the meaning of life?
- 18:27Martin Seligman: Yeah, and the reason I think it's bad is that
- 18:30meaningless wears the pants here.
- 18:34And so I think it's a yearning in which what we understand is meaningless and
- 18:41empty, and that meaning means something like not empty and not meaningless.
- 18:48So that's kind of where I am about why it's not a good question.
- 18:53Matt Abrahams: I appreciate that.
- 18:54Final question for you.
- 18:56What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:02Martin Seligman: Well, Matt, that's really difficult because I've
- 19:04never prepared for speeches, and I've always wanted spontaneity.
- 19:12Uh, so for me, I don't go through any conscious ingredient.
- 19:20And the older I've gotten, the more I've just hoped that the
- 19:24words would come, and they have.
- 19:28Matt Abrahams: I think one of the key ingredients that you deploy, you just
- 19:30mentioned, is spontaneity, and you've certainly talked about this notion
- 19:35of empathy or perspective taking as well, and then being good at arguing
- 19:40or putting forth rational explanations.
- 19:43So I think you do have some principles that you follow.
- 19:45You might just not see them in the forefront.
- 19:48This has been a fantastic conversation.
- 19:50It's a bit of a fanboy moment for me to meet you.
- 19:53Your work has always been meaningful to me, and the work that you have done
- 19:58really matters, and this idea of agency and how we can all develop agency in
- 20:03ourselves and others, really, really significant to well-being in general.
- 20:08Marty, thank you for your time, and thank you for all the work you have done.
- 20:11Martin Seligman: Thank you for the opportunity not to
- 20:13be fast and not to be smart.
- 20:17Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think
- 20:20Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:21Speaking with Marty was a true pleasure.
- 20:24Among the many ideas he shared, the one that stands out most to me is that we can
- 20:28change our negative self-talk and feel better by providing logical arguments
- 20:33that counter our negative narratives.
- 20:36To learn more about happiness and wellbeing, please listen to our
- 20:39special miniseries on the topic, including episodes 179 through 182.
- 20:44You'll hear from guests like Laurie Santos and Arthur Brooks.
- 20:48This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, Alex
- 20:51McCarthy, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 20:54Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 20:58Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:02Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:04Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram