Latest / Her Culture: Books, Film, Music & Women in the Arts / Unearthing the Past: Writing Memoirs of Family Secrets | Her Culture
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that lives in a family home, heavy and thick, waiting for someone brave enough to breathe it out. It starts not with a shout, but with a whisper that you swear you heard when you were seven, and now, twenty years later, it won’t let you sleep. Let’s unpack that feeling for a moment, because I know so many of you are sitting there right now, maybe scrolling through your phone with one hand while the other rests on your heart, trying to steady it. We carry these invisible archives inside us. They aren’t organized in boxes or labeled with dates; they’re just there, tucked behind our ribs, humming at a frequency only we can hear. For years, I thought this was normal. I thought every family had these little ghost rooms, places where the light doesn’t quite reach and where the air tastes different. But then I started reading memoirs—real ones, not the polished, highlight-reel versions we see on bestseller lists—and I realized that what I was experiencing wasn’t just nostalgia or confusion. It was the raw material of storytelling. Writing about family secrets isn’t about exposing people for the sake of scandal. It’s not about pointing fingers or demanding apologies from ghosts who can no longer defend themselves. It’s about reclaiming your own narrative from the shadows. When we write these stories down, we are essentially building a lantern. We are walking into those dark rooms of our past and turning on the switch. And yes, it is terrifying. You might find things you didn’t want to see. You might realize that the person you looked up to most was deeply flawed, perhaps even dangerous in ways you never imagined. But there is also a profound relief in finally naming the thing that has been eating you alive. The secret loses its power when it is spoken, especially when it is written. There’s a texture to this... memory that is often overlooked. We tend to think of recall as visual, like watching a movie in our heads. But really, memory is sensory. It’s the smell of burnt toast that reminds you of an argument. It’s the sound of a screen door slamming that triggers a panic attack you can’t explain. It’s the taste of metallic fear in your mouth when you walked into a room and sensed tension before you even saw who was there. As writers, if we want to convey the weight of a family secret, we have to use these senses. We have to make the reader feel the chill in the hallway, not just tell them it was cold. I remember writing a draft last year about my aunt, a woman who never spoke of her early adulthood. She would hum when she cooked, a tuneless, anxious vibration that filled the kitchen. For decades, I thought it was just habit. It wasn’t until I sat down to write her story that I understood the hum was a suppression mechanism. She was holding herself together by vibrating. When I wrote that scene, focusing on the sound rather than the facts of her life, something shifted. The truth didn’t come out in dates or names; it came out in the rhythm of her breathing. This is why craft matters so much. You aren’t just reporting history; you are translating emotion. You are taking the abstract weight of secrecy and giving it a body, a voice, a presence. If you can describe the texture of the silence, your reader will believe in it. Now, I need to talk about the guilt. Because it is there, and it is loud. Many of you hesitate to write because you love your family. You worry that putting these truths on paper is a betrayal. That it will hurt them, or worse, that it will change how they see you. This is a valid fear. Stories have consequences. Once a secret is published, it cannot be un-said. It becomes public record, shared knowledge, part of the cultural landscape. But here is the counter-argument that I’ve had to learn to live with: silence is also a choice. And silence can be violent. By keeping the secret, you might be protecting their ego, but you are often sacrificing your own peace. You are letting the lie dictate your present. I think about the episode we did a few weeks back on reclaiming creative time. We talked about how busywork keeps us from the real work. Well, maintaining family myths is the ultimate busywork. It’s exhausting labor to keep the facade intact. Writing the truth is not an act of aggression; it’s an act of liberation. It frees you from the role you were cast in—the peacemaker, the scapegoat, the naive child. When you write your memoir, you are stepping off the stage and becoming the director. You get to decide what is important. You get to decide who gets dignity and who gets complexity. It’s okay if that makes some people uncomfortable. Their discomfort is not your responsibility to manage. So, how do we actually start? How do we take this chaotic, emotional mess and shape it into a story that holds together? The first step is to stop trying to be objective. Memoir is not journalism. You don’t need to be fair to everyone. You need to be true to yourself. Start with the question: What do I want the reader to feel? Do you want them to feel angry on your behalf? Do you want them to feel a sense of catharsis? Or do you want them to sit in the ambiguity, to wrestle with the same questions you are wrestling with? I recommend starting small. Don’t try to write the whole family saga in one go. Pick one object. One letter. One photograph that doesn’t match the story everyone tells. Use that as your anchor. Let it lead you down the rabbit hole. In my own practice, I’ve found that structure helps contain the chaos. Maybe your book is structured around seasons, or rooms in a house, or letters you never sent. Give it a container. This gives the reader a place to rest while you dismantle their expectations. And please, give yourself permission to revise. The first draft is just you talking to yourself. The second draft is you talking to your readers. You will cut scenes that are painful but unnecessary. You will add details that bring clarity. It’s a process of distillation, like boiling down a sauce until it’s rich and concentrated. Be patient with it. Trust the process. One of the hardest parts of writing about family is dealing with the noise. The voices of your relatives echoing in your head, telling you what happened, how it happened, and what it means. ‘You remember it wrong,’ they’ll say. ‘It wasn’t that bad.’ ‘Why are you making such a big deal?’ This gaslighting can seep into your writing, making you doubt your own perception. I want to remind you that your perception is valid. Even if others disagree, your experience is your reality. You are the expert on your own life. Use this tension in your writing. Let the characters in your memoir argue with each other. Let the narrator question the reliability of the memories. Metafiction can be a powerful tool here. Acknowledge the gaps. Say, ‘I don’t know what really happened, but this is what it felt like.’ This honesty builds trust with your reader. They know you aren’t presenting a perfect, polished history lesson. They know you are sharing a human attempt to understand the past. And that vulnerability is magnetic. People connect with struggle more than they connect with perfection. So don’t hide your confusion. Lean into it. Tell me more about why that landed. Why does this memory still sting? Let the reader feel the sting with you. Finally, let’s talk about the aftermath. What happens after you hit send? After the book is published? There is a strange grief that comes with finishing a memoir. You’ve spent months, sometimes years, living inside these memories. You’ve visited places you’d rather forget. You’ve re-experienced pain. When you finish, there is a void. A quietness that feels different from the silence of secrecy. This silence is clean. It’s open. It belongs to you. Many writers find that completing this work brings a sense of closure that therapy alone couldn’t provide. It’s the difference between talking about a wound and stitching it up. The act of creation is an act of healing. It transforms pain into art, and art into something shareable. You are no longer carrying the burden alone. You are passing it to the reader, who will hold it with care, and in doing so, lighten the load. This is why we write. Not for fame, not for money, but for connection. To say, ‘I am here. I survived this. And you are not alone.’ If you are thinking about starting this journey, I encourage you to begin. Grab your notebook. Open your laptop. Write one page today. Just one. Don’t worry about quality. Just get it out. The rest will follow. There’s a texture to healing, and it feels like ink on paper. Thank you for listening, for trusting me with your time, and for being willing to sit in the messy, beautiful middle of your own history. Keep writing, keep remembering, and keep being brave. I’ll see you in the next one.