Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Two Trillion Dollar SpaceX Martian IPO Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine opening a financial document for an upcoming IPO.
- 0:03You're expecting the usual, you know, dry corporate metrics,
- 0:09profit margins, supply chain logistics, maybe some standard
- 0:12risk disclosures. Right, the standard stuff.
- 0:14Exactly. Instead, buried in the fine
- 0:16print, you find a legally binding performance clause
- 0:19requiring the construction of a permanent million person city on
- 0:22Mars. Which is just, it's completely
- 0:24unprecedented. It is, and if you don't build
- 0:26the Martian city, the CEO doesn't get his bonus.
- 0:28That is not science fiction. That is literally written into
- 0:32the 600 page prospectus for the SpaceX initial public offering.
- 0:35Yeah, it's really something else.
- 0:37We are talking about what is arguably the most highly
- 0:39anticipated massive financial event in modern history.
- 0:43A target raise of $75 billion. A staggering $2 trillion
- 0:48valuation on day one. And that's just day one.
- 0:51Right. And a total addressable market.
- 0:53They're Tam. The total revenue they believe
- 0:55they can eventually capture listed in the prospectus at
- 0:57$28.5 trillion. For context, the entire gross
- 1:02domestic product of the United States is around 27 trillion.
- 1:06It is the absolute definition of a paradigm shift.
- 1:09What's fascinating here is that we are not just looking at a
- 1:12company raising capital to build widgets, we are looking at an
- 1:16entity trying to privately finance the multi planetary
- 1:20future of the human species. Yeah.
- 1:22Which sounds amazing, but. But they are asking retail
- 1:25investors to foot the bill under some of the most extraordinary
- 1:29restrictive terms ever committed to paper.
- 1:32Exactly. And that is the mission of our
- 1:34deep dive today. We aren't just reading the
- 1:37headlines or, you know, getting swept up in the hype of rocket
- 1:40launches. We are tearing through this
- 1:42massive SpaceX IPO prospectus to decode the legal fortresses, the
- 1:47hidden financial maneuvers, and the sci-fi level ambitions
- 1:50lurking in the fine print. There's a lot hiding in.
- 1:52There. Oh absolutely.
- 1:53But real quick, before we jump into the numbers, a quick note
- 1:55to access more advanced researches, applications and our
- 1:58latest published personal intelligent multi agent Deep
- 2:01Value Intelligence. Welcome to explore and join the
- 2:04Deep Values dot AI community. Always a great resource.
- 2:07Yeah, and to track total market temperature, welcome to search
- 2:10and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple App
- 2:14Store. And a quick reminder for you,
- 2:16our listener, all analysis today is based on publicly available
- 2:20sources and may be subject to revisions or differing
- 2:23interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 2:26are for information and research purposes only and do not
- 2:30constitute investment advice. Right.
- 2:31Definitely do your homework. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:34before making investment decisions.
- 2:37If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 2:40investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel,
- 2:43Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 2:45Much appreciated. OK, so let's unpack this.
- 2:48If you are out there thinking of buying in, if you want a piece
- 2:51of this $2 trillion pie on opening day, you absolutely need
- 2:55to hear what's actually under the hood.
- 2:56Because it's not your typical offering.
- 2:58Not at all. Give us the high level view of
- 3:00what this document really is because it just it doesn't read
- 3:03like a normal S1 filing. It doesn't because it isn't just
- 3:07a business plan. It is a master class in blending
- 3:10extreme world changing engineering with extreme
- 3:14financial leverage and control. Control being the keyword there.
- 3:17Exactly at its core, the central tension of this document is
- 3:22between the aw inspiring physical achievements of the
- 3:25company. Landing rockets backward,
- 3:27beaming Internet from space, and a governance structure
- 3:30specifically engineered to strip the public investor of almost
- 3:34all traditional rights. Wow.
- 3:36Yeah, it's an entirely new kind of corporate architecture.
- 3:39Well, let's dive straight into that architecture, specifically
- 3:42this idea of control. Because for anyone buying stock,
- 3:45there's a a baseline assumption of how American capitalism
- 3:49works, right? You buy shares, the shares give
- 3:51you voting rights, you pool those votes to elect a board of
- 3:54directors, and that board acts as your representative to
- 3:57oversee the CEO. It's a basic system of checks
- 3:59and balances, right? That is the standard 3 tier
- 4:02system, Shareholders at the top, the board in the middle acting
- 4:05as the fiduciaries and the executive management at the
- 4:08bottom executing the vision. Makes sense?
- 4:10In a standard mega cap tech company, say Apple or Microsoft,
- 4:14they use a single class share structure.
- 4:17One share equals one vote. Tim Cook holds less than 1% of
- 4:21the voting power at Apple. Oh really?
- 4:23I didn't realize it was that low.
- 4:25Yeah, the other 99% is held by external shareholders.
- 4:28So if the board fails in its duties, or if Cook makes
- 4:32terrible strategic decisions, the shareholders have the
- 4:35mathematical power to vote them out.
- 4:36But SpaceX is radically departing from that.
- 4:39They are utilizing A superclass share structure.
- 4:42If you go to your brokerage app on IPO day and buy a share of
- 4:45SpaceX, you are buying a Class A share and.
- 4:48What does that get you? That gives you exactly 1 vote,
- 4:50but there are Class B shares held almost entirely by Elon
- 4:54Musk, and those get 10 votes per share.
- 4:56Right, the 12:50 ratio. Exactly because of this 12:50
- 5:00ratio, the prospectus reveals Musk holds 85.1% of the total
- 5:04voting power of the entire company.
- 5:06Which is massive. But you know, if we connect this
- 5:08to the bigger picture, this dual class structure isn't entirely
- 5:11unprecedented. Google famously implemented it
- 5:14in 2004 and Meta did it shortly after.
- 5:16True, they kind of set that trend.
- 5:18They did. The original philosophical
- 5:20argument was to protect visionary founders from the
- 5:23short term quarter by quarter pressure of Wall Street.
- 5:27It theoretically allows a founder to focus on a 10 year
- 5:30horizon without worrying about activist hedge funds staging A
- 5:34boardroom coup because they missed a quarterly earnings
- 5:37target. Right.
- 5:38Like Mark Zuckerberg for instance has about 62% of the
- 5:41voting power at Meta. Exactly.
- 5:43But 85.1% is an entirely different stratosphere of
- 5:46control. And reading through the Charter,
- 5:48that 85% isn't even the most aggressive part.
- 5:52There's a structural defense mechanism built into the
- 5:54paperwork that acts as a second layer of.
- 5:57Well, absolutely, because even with 85% of the vote today,
- 6:01share dilution is a mathematical reality over time.
- 6:04Yeah, they're going to have to issue more stock eventually.
- 6:06Right. If SpaceX decides to issue
- 6:08massive amounts of new stock over the next decade to acquire
- 6:11other companies or to fund these massive capital expenditures
- 6:15we'll talk about later, that 85% could theoretically drop below
- 6:1950%. So what do they do?
- 6:21So Spacex's legal charter explicitly states that Class B
- 6:26shareholders, meaning essentially Musk alone, get to
- 6:30elect more than half of the board of directors no matter
- 6:32what. Wait, no matter what their
- 6:34actual voting percentage drops to.
- 6:36No matter what. Specifically, 5 out of the eight
- 6:38seats, the Class A shareholders, the public who puts up the $75
- 6:43billion, have absolutely zero say in these five seats.
- 6:46You don't even get a ballot for them.
- 6:47It's like setting up a rigged election system where it doesn't
- 6:50matter how many new citizens move into the town, the mayor
- 6:53legally has the right to unilaterally appoint the
- 6:56majority of the City Council forever, regardless of the
- 6:59population. That's a really good way to put
- 7:01it. So mathematically, his voting
- 7:02percentage could dip to 10% and he still legally owns the
- 7:06boardroom. Let's look at who is actually
- 7:08sitting in that room. There are 8 members total.
- 7:12Three are non independent, meaning they are company
- 7:14insiders. Musk himself, President Gwen
- 7:17Shotwell and Antonio Gracias, right?
- 7:19That leaves five supposedly independent directors.
- 7:23And here is where the legal definition of the word
- 7:26independent gets stretched to its absolute breaking point.
- 7:29Remember those five board seats that are exclusively elected by
- 7:32the Class B shares? Yeah, Musk uses that unilateral
- 7:36power to appoint the three insiders +2 of the independent
- 7:40directors. The remaining three independent
- 7:43directors are technically voted on by all shareholders, but
- 7:46since Musk holds 85.1% of the total general vote anyway, he
- 7:51essentially dictates the outcome for those three as well.
- 7:53He controls the entire room from top to bottom.
- 7:56I looked into the backgrounds of these supposedly neutral
- 7:58directors, and these are not exactly impartial arbiters.
- 8:02We were looking at a roster of ultimate superfans.
- 8:05To put it mildly. Yeah, you have Steve Trevetson,
- 8:07who has a 30 year friendship with Musk.
- 8:09Trevetson bought the very first Tesla Roadster ever made, and
- 8:13the very last one back in 2008, when Tesla was days away from
- 8:17bankruptcy, Jurvetson was the guy out there hustling to save
- 8:20it. A very loyal ally.
- 8:22Extremely. Then you have Ira Erin Price, a
- 8:2420 year ally. You have Luke Nosek who Co
- 8:28founded Founders Fund and literally launched a special
- 8:31purpose vehicle called Gigafund just to funnel continuous
- 8:35capital into SpaceX. These guys have made vast
- 8:38fortunes betting on Musk. Their loyalty is absolute.
- 8:41Which is highly effective for a scrappy private startup trying
- 8:45to survive early rocketry failures, but it is highly
- 8:49problematic for a $2 trillion public entity asking for retail
- 8:53investment. Right, because the rules change
- 8:55when you go public. Exactly.
- 8:57In a normal public company, the CEO answers to the board.
- 9:00At SpaceX, the CEO effectively is the board.
- 9:04The traditional institutional checks and balances do not exist
- 9:07here. The director's continued
- 9:08presence in that room is entirely dependent on the
- 9:11goodwill of the CEO they are legally mandated to oversee.
- 9:14So if you are buying SpaceX stock, you have to understand
- 9:17the reality of what you own. You are buying an economic
- 9:20ticket to a roller coaster. You get to experience the highs,
- 9:22the lows. You are entitled to the
- 9:23financial gains, but you are completely locked out of the
- 9:26steering cabin. You're just along for the ride.
- 9:27You have 0 voice. If the company decides to issue
- 9:31a billion new shares tomorrow and dilute your value by half,
- 9:35you cannot stop it. If they decide to buy a failing
- 9:38company for $60 billion using your equity, you cannot vote
- 9:42against it. You are purely a passenger.
- 9:45And that total lack of oversight becomes critically important
- 9:48when we examine how this specific board handles the
- 9:51company's checkbook. Governance isn't just an
- 9:54abstract legal concept. It dictates where the money
- 9:58flows. Which is where things get really
- 9:59crazy in this prospectus. Yeah, the way SpaceX manages
- 10:02conflicts of interest is frankly unprecedented for an IPO of this
- 10:07scale. Let's get into the weeds on
- 10:09that, because the way they're handling executive compensation
- 10:11and related party transactions blew my mind.
- 10:14We need a quick history lesson first, though.
- 10:17In the early 2000's, the stock market was rocked by massive
- 10:20corporate scandals. Enron.
- 10:21Worldcom. Right, the big ones.
- 10:23These were Titans of industry that completely evaporated
- 10:25because executives were hiding debt and inflating profits while
- 10:29friendly hand picked boards just looked the other way and signed
- 10:31the checks. Yes, Enron was $100 billion
- 10:35energy juggernaut that collapsed into bankruptcy in a matter of
- 10:38months due to systemic accounting fraud and the post
- 10:41mortem investigations revealed a glaring flaw in corporate
- 10:45America, which was well, while Enron technically had
- 10:49independent directors, those directors were far too close to
- 10:52management. The audit committee, the
- 10:54compensation committee, they just rubber stamped whatever the
- 10:57CEO wanted because they lacked true independence.
- 11:00So to stop that from ever happening again, Congress
- 11:02stepped in and passed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, commonly
- 11:06known as Sox. Correct.
- 11:07The Sox Act fundamentally rewired corporate governance.
- 11:12It legally mandated that the audit, compensation and
- 11:15nominated committees of a public board must be composed entirely
- 11:18of genuinely independent directors.
- 11:20Meaning no company executives. Right.
- 11:21No company executives, no major shareholders, and absolutely no
- 11:24one with significant financial ties to the company's
- 11:27management. The idea was to create a rigid
- 11:29firewall. If the CEO wants a massive bonus
- 11:33or wants to appoint a new director, they have to convince
- 11:35a room of people who have zero financial incentive to just
- 11:38blindly say yes. Wait, hold on, if Sox was
- 11:41designed to prevent another Enron, how is SpaceX legally
- 11:45bypassing it? Because reading the prospectus,
- 11:47they are completely ignoring the requirement for independent
- 11:50compensation and nominating committees.
- 11:53Is this just a loophole or are they daring the SEC to sue them?
- 11:57This raises an important question about legal exemptions.
- 12:01It is a known loophole. SpaceX is utilizing what the SEC
- 12:05calls the controlled company exemption.
- 12:07How does that work? The rule states that if an
- 12:10individual or a group holds more than 50% of the voting power,
- 12:14the company is exempt from the requirement to have a majority
- 12:17independent board and critically, they are exempt from
- 12:19having independent compensation and nominating committees.
- 12:22That seems. The logic, flawed as it might
- 12:24be, is that if one person owns the majority of the company,
- 12:27they're primarily risking their own capital, so they don't need
- 12:30the same paternalistic protections from the government.
- 12:33That seems completely backwards. The law meant to protect public
- 12:36investors from dictators says, well, if the CEO is an absolute
- 12:40dictator with 85% of the vote, we won't make him use
- 12:43independent committees. That defeats the entire purpose
- 12:46of the firewall. It is a highly controversial
- 12:49exemption. Early on, companies like Google
- 12:52and Meta qualified for it, but in practice they generally still
- 12:55try to staff those critical committees with independent
- 12:58directors just to maintain good optics, build market trust, and
- 13:02appease institutional investors. But not SpaceX.
- 13:05No, SpaceX is taking the opposite approach.
- 13:07They are fully utilizing the exemption to its maximum legal.
- 13:11Limit, and the absolute poster child for this utilization is
- 13:14Antonio Gracias. Let's talk about Antonio,
- 13:16because this is where the conflict of interest becomes
- 13:18staggering. He is a director on the board.
- 13:20He sits on both the compensation committee and the nominating
- 13:23committee. But he is a designated insider.
- 13:26He is He is the founder and CEO of a massive private equity fund
- 13:30called Valor Equity Partners. And buried in the prospectus is
- 13:34a disclosure that Valor has signed three equipment lease
- 13:37agreements with a SpaceX subsidiary called XAI, totalling
- 13:41$20 billion. Let.
- 13:43The mechanics of that number sink in $20 billion.
- 13:47It's just an unfathomable amount of money.
- 13:49The setup works like this. Valor Equity Partners uses its
- 13:53capital to buy massive amounts of AI computing hardware,
- 13:56servers, GPU's, networking gear. They then lease all of that
- 14:00hardware back to Spacex's AI division on a monthly basis.
- 14:04Wait, so. This means a sitting board
- 14:06member who serves on the very committee that dictates the CEO
- 14:09salary, and the committee that decides who else gets to be on
- 14:12the board is simultaneously running an outside fund that is
- 14:16extracting billions of dollars in lease payments directly from
- 14:19the company. If I'm a retail investor looking
- 14:21at this, my immediate thought is why in the world is Space XA
- 14:24company that is about to raise $75 billion in cash from the
- 14:28public renting its servers from its own board members private
- 14:31equity firm? It's a very fair question,
- 14:33right? Why not just buy them directly
- 14:35or finance them through a traditional bank?
- 14:37The Otics are incredibly conflicted.
- 14:39It is the textbook definition of a related arty transaction, and
- 14:43it illustrates exactly why the OX Act originally mandated
- 14:47independent committees. Because you have to ask the
- 14:50logical question. How can Antonio Gracias
- 14:52objectively and aggressively negotiate the CE OS compensation
- 14:56package on behalf of the shareholders when his own
- 14:58outside fund relies entirely on that same CE OS ongoing approval
- 15:02to maintain a $20 billion revenue stream?
- 15:04Can't human nature and financial incentives suggest that is an
- 15:08impossible tightrope to walk? And Speaking of that
- 15:10compensation package, let's look at what Gracias and the rest of
- 15:13the compensation committee actually approved for Musk.
- 15:15The prospectus states Musk's base salary is 54,000 $80, which
- 15:20is purely theatrical, right? It's tied to the 2019 California
- 15:23minimum wage. Purely theatrical, the actual
- 15:26compensation is structured in two unprecedented milestone
- 15:29based equity packages. Together, they represent the
- 15:32authorization of 400 million brand new Class B shares.
- 15:36And what's that actually worth? Well, based on the target IPO
- 15:39valuation and the inherent premium placed on 10 vote
- 15:42shares, this compensation package could ultimately be
- 15:45worth well over $200 billion. $200 billion for one person and
- 15:50the milestones to unlock this stock.
- 15:52They don't even sound like traditional business metrics.
- 15:55Usually you see things like achieve a 15% operating margin
- 15:59or grow revenue by $5 billion. These sound like victory
- 16:02conditions for a sci-fi video game.
- 16:04They really do. The first package is dubbed the
- 16:07SpaceX CEO Award. It triggers in escalating
- 16:10tranches as the company's market capitalization grows to $1.75
- 16:14trillion. OK.
- 16:15So a market cap goal? Yes, but there's an operational
- 16:18milestone firmly attached to it. To unlock the final tranches,
- 16:21the company must successfully establish a permanent,
- 16:24self-sustaining human colony on Mars, and the total population
- 16:28of that colony must reach at least 1,000,000 people.
- 16:30A million people on Mars as a corporate performance metric to
- 16:33unlock a stake bonus? How do accounts even audit that?
- 16:36Do they send PwC auditors to Mars to do a headcount?
- 16:40It is wild. The audacity of the goal is the
- 16:43point and the second package is the AICEO award.
- 16:47This one triggers as the market cap scales up to an astronomical
- 16:50$6.565 trillion. That's a massive valuation.
- 16:54Huge, and the operational requirement here is equally
- 16:58staggering. The company must successfully
- 17:01build and deploy a non Earth data center, meaning a facility
- 17:05in orbit or in deep space with a 100 terawatt compute capacity.
- 17:09OK, so let's synthesize this. You have a board member making
- 17:12billions off the company through a private equity lease.
- 17:14That same board member approves a $200 billion pay package tied
- 17:18to building a Martian city in space supercomputers.
- 17:20If a normal institutional shareholder, say a massive
- 17:23pension fund looks this and says this is insane, this is a gross
- 17:26breach of fiduciary duty, we're going to sue the board, What
- 17:29actually happens? Nothing happens because the
- 17:32prospectus has engineered a legal fortress specifically
- 17:35designed to prevent shareholder litigation.
- 17:38First, the corporate charter completely bans class action
- 17:40lawsuits. Wait, completely bans them?
- 17:42That is massive. Class actions are effectively
- 17:45the only weapon retail investors have.
- 17:47If I lose $5000 because a company blatantly lied on its
- 17:51financials, I cannot afford to hire a corporate litigator to
- 17:55fight a $2 trillion mega corporation.
- 17:57No, you can't. But if 100,000 people pool their
- 18:00$5000 claims together, a major law firm will take the case on
- 18:04contingency. That exact mechanism is how
- 18:07investors clawed billions of dollars back from the executives
- 18:10at Worldcom and Enron. SpaceX just deleted that entire
- 18:14mechanism from their reality. Exactly.
- 18:16The Charter mandates that all shareholder disputes, no matter
- 18:19how egregious the claim, must go to mandatory binding arbitration
- 18:23on an individual basis. Furthermore, if a large
- 18:25shareholder wants to file what is called a derivative suit,
- 18:28what's that? It's a specific legal action
- 18:30where a shareholder sues the board of directors on behalf of
- 18:33the company itself for gross negligence or self dealing.
- 18:37The Charter imposes an almost impossible threshold for that.
- 18:40It requires that the complaining shareholder must individually
- 18:43hold at least 3% of the total voting power of the company, and
- 18:48they must have held it continuously for six months
- 18:50prior to the lawsuit. Let's do the math on that 3% of
- 18:53the voting power in a company valued between 1.5 to 2 trillion
- 18:57dollars. 3% is roughly 45 to $60 billion worth of stock.
- 19:02Astronomical. There is not a single retail
- 19:05investor on earth, and frankly, there are very few institutional
- 19:09asset managers in the world who hold a $60 billion position in a
- 19:13single stock individually. They have literally set the
- 19:17barrier to entry for a lawsuit higher than the GDP of dozens of
- 19:21countries. It's a fortress designed to
- 19:23communicate one thing clearly. You literally cannot sue us.
- 19:26Ever. Which brings us to the ultimate
- 19:28synthesis of the governance side of this prospectus.
- 19:31Investors might look at this structure, the total loss of
- 19:34voting rights they heavily conflicted board, the $20
- 19:36billion related party loopholes, the astronomical compensation,
- 19:40the absolute ban on litigation, And they might swallow all of.
- 19:44It they might just accept it. They might accept these
- 19:46draconian terms without blinking, but they will only do
- 19:50so if the underlying business, the actual engine generating
- 19:54revenue, is an absolute unstoppable juggernaut that
- 19:58justifies the dictatorship. Right.
- 20:00History shows people will put up with an autocrat if the trains
- 20:03run on time and the stock portfolio goes up 1000%.
- 20:07So let's look at the actual business, the engine room, the
- 20:10Rockets and the Starlink cash cow.
- 20:12Let's start with the launch vehicles, because this is the
- 20:15foundational technological mode of SpaceX.
- 20:18So I understand the economics here.
- 20:19We have to look back before 2010.
- 20:21OK, set the scene. The entire global aerospace
- 20:24industry, NASA, the ESA, Boeing, Lockheed operated on a single
- 20:28incredibly wasteful paradigm. Rockets were expendable.
- 20:32Meaning they just threw them away.
- 20:33Exactly, you build a multi $1,000,000 machine, it flies
- 20:36exactly once and drops its payload into orbit and the rest
- 20:38of multi stage rocket either burns up in the atmosphere or
- 20:41crashes into the ocean to sink. Which is an insane business
- 20:45model when you think about it. It's like buying a brand new
- 20:47Boeing 747, flying a load of cargo from New York to London,
- 20:52and then throwing the airplane in the trash the moment it
- 20:55lands. It made the economics of
- 20:57spaceflight impossibly expensive.
- 20:59It did. But SpaceX fundamentally changed
- 21:01the laws of physics, or at least the economics of physics.
- 21:04In 2015, they did the impossible.
- 21:06They successively landed the first stage of a Falcon 9 rocket
- 21:09on a drone ship in the ocean. They proved you could fly, land,
- 21:13refurbish, and fly again. The.
- 21:15Economic impact of that engineering breakthrough cannot
- 21:18not be overstated. According to NASA data cited in
- 21:21the analysis within the prospectus, the reusable Falcon
- 21:249 reduce the cost of launching a kilogram of mass into low Earth
- 21:28orbit from roughly $18,500 down to 2700.
- 21:32Dollars. That is an 85% collapse in cost.
- 21:34Well, because the Rockets are reusable, they can fly with a
- 21:36frequency no one else can match. By the end of the first quarter
- 21:39of 2024, SpaceX had completed roughly 650 orbital launches.
- 21:44To put that scale in perspective, they are currently
- 21:46launching more mass to orbit than all other nations,
- 21:50including the combined efforts of China and Russia and all
- 21:53other private companies combined multiplied by 4.
- 21:55It is a total, undisputed monopoly on access to Earth's
- 21:58orbit. But here's the crazy part I
- 22:01found in the financials. The launch business.
- 22:03The very thing they are famous for, The thing they have a
- 22:05monopoly on, it actually loses money.
- 22:08It does. In Q1 of 2024, the rocket launch
- 22:11division had $610 million in revenue but posted a $660
- 22:16million operating loss. How is it mechanically possible
- 22:20to lose money when you dominate the market and have the cheapest
- 22:23rockets in history? The answer is Starship.
- 22:26Falcon 9 is the workhorse paying the daily bills, but Starship is
- 22:29the future of the company. It is a massive 124 meter tall
- 22:33vehicle powered by 33 Raptor engines, designed to be fully
- 22:37and rapidly reusable and capable of carrying over 100 tons to
- 22:40orbit. It's just a monster of a rocket.
- 22:43It is the absolute linchpin for every other ambitious project
- 22:46the company has, from the Mars colony to launching the next
- 22:50generation of massive satellites to lifting those 100 terawatt
- 22:54space data centers. But the research and development
- 22:57required to tame that beast is a financial black hole.
- 23:00How much are we talking? The company burned $3 billion on
- 23:03Starship R&D in 2023 alone. In just the first quarter of
- 23:072024, they burned another $930 million on it.
- 23:11So the Rockets are bleeding cash to build bigger rockets.
- 23:14If the core launch business is losing money, where is the
- 23:17actual cash coming from to keep the lights on?
- 23:19Enter the cash cow, Starlink. Starlink is the true economic
- 23:23engine of SpaceX. Today, by aggressively launching
- 23:26their own payloads on the Falcon 9:00, they have put 9600
- 23:29Starlink satellites into low Earth orbit.
- 23:32They've created a dense planetary mesh network for
- 23:34Internet access. And 9600 satellites thus.
- 23:37Those 9600 satellites represent an astounding 75% of all active
- 23:42satellites currently orbiting Earth.
- 23:43It's incredible. They essentially own the sky.
- 23:45They cover 164 countries. If you are a soldier in a war
- 23:50zone in Ukraine, a doctor in a remote village in Nigeria or a
- 23:54researcher on a boat in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, you
- 23:57buy a terminal, point it at the sky and you instantly have high
- 24:01speed broadband. And the consumer growth is
- 24:02explosive. Yeah, the prospectus notes
- 24:05subscribers doubled from 5 million to 10.3 million in just
- 24:08a single year. And the financials clearly
- 24:10reflect that explosion in adoption.
- 24:13In 2023, Starlink generated $11.4 billion in revenue,
- 24:17producing an operating profit of $4.4 billion.
- 24:21That is a 39% operating margin. 39% that is nearing Apple
- 24:25territory. That is software as a service
- 24:27level margins on a business that requires launching thousands of
- 24:30pieces of heavy hardware into space.
- 24:32So Starlink is like the highly responsible older sibling
- 24:35working a lucrative corporate job to pay the family mortgage,
- 24:37while the younger siblings, the Rocket division and the AI
- 24:40division are out in the garage spending billions building
- 24:42sci-fi projects. That is a highly accurate
- 24:44analogy. However, if we dig deeper into
- 24:47the prospectus, it reveals a very concerning trend hidden
- 24:51just beneath Starlink's explosive subscriber growth.
- 24:54It's a metric called ARPU, Average revenue per user.
- 24:57And looking at the chart, it is dropping like a rock.
- 25:00In 2022 the average Starlink user was paying $91.00 a month.
- 25:04In 2023, that dropped to 81 dollars.
- 25:08By Q1 of 2024, it was down to $66.
- 25:11That is a massive slide in pricing power.
- 25:13Why is it falling so fast? There are two main mechanics
- 25:17driving that drop. First, international expansion.
- 25:20To conquer the globe and hit that massive $28.5 trillion
- 25:24total addressable market, Starling has to aggressively
- 25:27move into emerging markets. Right, because people in
- 25:29different countries have different purchasing power.
- 25:31Exactly. A satellite terminal that sells
- 25:33for $500 in the US has to be heavily subsidized by the
- 25:36company to sell in a developing nation like Nigeria.
- 25:40Furthermore, a monthly subscription that easily
- 25:42commands $120.00 in California might only pull in $50.00 in
- 25:46Brazil or India. And what's the second mechanic?
- 25:48Second, they are actively introducing cheaper domestic
- 25:52tiers, like a $50.00 per month rural plan to capture lower
- 25:57income demographics within the United States.
- 25:59So what does this actually mean for the bottom line?
- 26:02It means they are growing their overall user base by an
- 26:05impressive 105% year over year. But because the price per user
- 26:10is falling so rapidly, their actual operating profit only
- 26:13grew by 15%. Which means they have to work
- 26:15harder. Exactly.
- 26:17They have to run twice as fast, launching twice as many
- 26:20satellites and selling twice as many terminals just to stay in
- 26:23place financially. Precisely the theoretical scale
- 26:26dividend is being eaten alive by price compression, and to fight
- 26:30this, to find a new vector for massive growth, SpaceX is making
- 26:34another incredibly expensive pivot direct to cell technology.
- 26:37Oh, this is fascinating. They want your normal,
- 26:40unmodified smartphone to connect directly to a Starling satellite
- 26:43overhead, completely bypassing traditional telecom cell towers.
- 26:46But to legally do this, they needed spectrum rights, the
- 26:49specific radio frequencies permitted by governments to
- 26:52transmit cellular data. And they didn't just apply for
- 26:55those spectrum rights, they bought them outright.
- 26:58The prospectus shows they spent $19.6 billion acquiring a legacy
- 27:04telecom company called Echostar just to get their hands on those
- 27:08spectrum rights, $19.6 billion just for the legal right to use
- 27:13invisible radio waves. It's a huge gamble.
- 27:16But if you thought $19 billion for radio waves was a big
- 27:19gamble, wait until we look at the true sci-fi heart of this
- 27:22document. This is perhaps the most
- 27:24shocking revelation for the average investor.
- 27:26It absolutely is because SpaceX executed what accountants call a
- 27:32reverse acquisition under common control.
- 27:35This is a complex accounting maneuver where entities
- 27:37controlled by the same majority owner are merged.
- 27:40So what did they merge? In this case, they essentially
- 27:42folded Elon Musk's social media platform ex, formerly Twitter,
- 27:47and his artificial intelligence startup XAI directly into
- 27:51Spacex's consolidated financials.
- 27:53Walk us through how that actually works, because if
- 27:55you're an investor, you think you're buying a space company,
- 27:57but you're actually funding an all out trillion dollar war for
- 28:01AI supremacy on Earth. That's exactly what's happening.
- 28:03Let's look at the numbers for this newly merged AI division.
- 28:07In 2023, it brought in $3.2 billion in revenue.
- 28:11Most from advertising and premium subscriptions on X, but
- 28:15it lost $6.4 billion operating the business.
- 28:18The operating loss is staggering, but the capital
- 28:21expenditure, the CapEx, the money spent on physical assets
- 28:24is the real story here. In 2023, the AI division spent
- 28:27$12.7 billion on CapEx. In just the first quarter of
- 28:322024, they spent $7.7 billion. That's just wild.
- 28:36They're buying graphical processing units.
- 28:38The specialized GPU is required to train large language models
- 28:41at a rate that is difficult to fully comprehend.
- 28:43They're buying NVIDIA chips like they're going out of style, and
- 28:45what they're doing with them is where the unique SpaceX
- 28:48engineering mode comes in. We talked about how SpaceX
- 28:51builds rockets faster and cheaper than NASA.
- 28:53They're applying that exact same hardcore rapid iteration
- 28:56engineering culture to building AI data centers.
- 28:59The prospectus details the construction of a facility named
- 29:02Colossus One. This is a massive supercomputer
- 29:05cluster utilizing 100,000 NVIDIA H-100 GPU's.
- 29:10For context, it normally takes industry giants like Amazon's
- 29:13AWS or Microsoft Azure over a year, sometimes 2, to design,
- 29:17permit, build, supply power 2 and network a data centre of
- 29:21that colossal scale. But SpaceX didn't take a year.
- 29:25No, SpaceX retrofitted an abandoned factory in Memphis and
- 29:28brought Colossus One online in exactly 122 days. 122 days.
- 29:33That breaks every rule of traditional infrastructure
- 29:35development, and they are already building Colossus 2,
- 29:37which the prospectus says will use hundreds of thousands of the
- 29:40next generation NVIDIA GB 200 and GB 300 ships, and they plan
- 29:44to deploy it in a matter of months.
- 29:46They are moving at rocket speed in a silicon world.
- 29:48Literally. If they can deploy compute
- 29:50infrastructure five times faster than the legacy cloud providers,
- 29:53they effectively become the ultimate Neo cloud, offering
- 29:56compute power to AI startups faster than anyone else.
- 29:59And they already have their first mega client to prove the
- 30:02model. The prospectus outlines a
- 30:04massive compute contract with Anthropic, one of the world's
- 30:08leading AI foundation model companies.
- 30:11Anthropic has agreed to pay SpaceX an astonishing $1.25
- 30:15billion per month for access to this compute power.
- 30:19Per month. Yes, if the contract runs its
- 30:22full anticipated course to 2029, it is worth up to $45 billion.
- 30:27That immediately makes Anthropic one of Spacex's largest single
- 30:31sources of revenue. But, and there is always a but,
- 30:34when reading the fine print of this prospectus, there was a
- 30:37massive catch. There usually is.
- 30:39The contract has a 90 day rolling cancellation clause.
- 30:41Wait, Canthropic can just cancel?
- 30:43They can walk away with essentially 3 months notice.
- 30:45That is an incredibly fragile foundation for a $45 billion
- 30:49projection. It is extreme high risk, high
- 30:51reward. Furthermore, the prospectus
- 30:53details a complex buyout option with a company called Core
- 30:56Weave, which is a specialized AI cloud provider.
- 30:59SpaceX has secured the option to acquire Core Weave for $60
- 31:02billion. OK, but what if they don't?
- 31:05If SpaceX chooses not to execute that buyout by the deadline,
- 31:09they are legally hit with a $10 billion penalty fee.
- 31:12So they're willingly locking themselves into these massive
- 31:15multibillion dollar binary decisions.
- 31:18But let's look at the ultimate end game here.
- 31:20Why is a space company getting this deeply involved in AI?
- 31:24It's not just to compete with Amazon and Google on Earth.
- 31:28It's about the space data centers.
- 31:30Yes, the 100 terawatt vision we mentioned earlier in Musk's
- 31:33compensation package. If we connect this to the
- 31:36physics of the real world, earthly data centers are
- 31:39currently constrained by three insurmountable physical limits.
- 31:43Land, water and power. Right, exactly.
- 31:45Land to build on, massive amounts of water required for
- 31:48cooling the chips and most importantly power from the
- 31:50electrical grid. AI models are becoming so
- 31:53massive they are literally running out of electricity to
- 31:55train them. Entire cities cannot support the
- 31:57gigawatts needed. But in space you have 0 land
- 32:00constraints. You have the vacuum of space,
- 32:02which is incredibly cold, making cooling virtually free, and most
- 32:05importantly, you have the sun. Unfiltered, unlimited solar
- 32:09radiation. By deploying massive solar
- 32:12arrays in orbit, you have access to a constant, inexhaustible
- 32:15power supply that never experiences night time or
- 32:18weather interruptions. Which solves the power problem
- 32:20entirely. The physics of beaming data down
- 32:23are complex, involving advanced laser communications to mitigate
- 32:27latency. But the goal is clear.
- 32:29SpaceX wants to launch AI compute clusters into orbit,
- 32:32beam the data up and down via the Starling constellation, and
- 32:35completely bypass the terrestrial power grid and
- 32:39regulatory environment. It sounds like the plot of a
- 32:41sci-fi blockbuster, but to launch thousands of tons of
- 32:44servers and solar panels into space, you need cheap, massive,
- 32:47heavy lift capacity. Which brings us full circle
- 32:50right back to Starship. Every single thread in this
- 32:53company, Starlink's growth, the AI space data centers, the Mars
- 32:56colony, it all relies on Starship successfully flying
- 32:59regularly and reliably. It's a vertically integrated
- 33:02dream, a closed loop ecosystem of technology.
- 33:05But that ecosystem requires capital, mountains and mountains
- 33:09of capital. It's not cheap.
- 33:10The cash burn required to sustain the rocket R&D heavily
- 33:13subsidized Starling terminals globally and by hundreds of
- 33:16thousands of AIGPUS is astronomical, which logically
- 33:21leads us to the true financial reality of this company and the
- 33:24deeply hidden reason for this IPO.
- 33:26Let's talk cash flow, because this is where the math gets
- 33:29scary. In 2023, SpaceX generated $6.8
- 33:33billion in operating cash. That's the actual money coming
- 33:37in the door from selling Internet and launching rockets.
- 33:39But as we mentioned, they spent $20.7 billion in CapEx on chips
- 33:44and Starship. Right, which leaves a gap.
- 33:45A massive gap that leaves them with a negative free cash flow
- 33:48of roughly $14 billion for the year.
- 33:51And the burn rate is accelerating at an alarming
- 33:53pace. In Q1 of 2024 alone, they burned
- 33:56$9 billion. If you extrapolate that
- 33:58trajectory, they're pacing for a 30 billion to $40 billion cash
- 34:02hole this year alone. You cannot sustain that level of
- 34:05burn without massive external funding, regardless of how
- 34:08visionary the CEO is. Which explains the debt.
- 34:12The balance sheet shows SpaceX is carrying $29.1 billion in
- 34:17long term debt pre IPO. Their debt to equity ratio is
- 34:21sitting at a terrifying 84% in the tech world.
- 34:25Unless you are Apple buying back your own stock to artificially
- 34:28lower your equity base, an 84% debt ratio is a massive red
- 34:33flag. It is a highly stressed over
- 34:35leveraged balance sheet. Very stressed.
- 34:37And the most critical immediate piece of that debt is a specific
- 34:40$20 billion bridge loan. A bridge loan is exactly what it
- 34:44sounds like short term financing meant to bridge a company to a
- 34:47larger liquidity event like an IPO.
- 34:49Right? SpaceX took this loan out
- 34:51recently to pay off the high interest debt that was sadly the
- 34:54X and XAI entities when they were merged in.
- 34:57The bridge loan carries A5 to 6% interest rate, which is
- 34:59relatively favorable, but it is fundamentally a short term
- 35:02lifeline. And who provided this $20
- 35:03billion lifeline? 5 major investment banks,
- 35:06Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, Citi and JP
- 35:10Morgan. Now here is where we must
- 35:12examine the internal mechanics of Wall Street.
- 35:14The IPO prospectus contains a mandatory use of proceeds
- 35:17clause. And what does that mandate?
- 35:20It legally dictates that the very first dollars raised in
- 35:23this $75 billion IPO must be used to completely pay off that
- 35:27$20 billion bridge loan within six months of the offering.
- 35:31OK, so the company raises money from the public, immediately
- 35:34hands $20 billion right back to those five banks.
- 35:38Now guess who the lead underwriters are for this exact
- 35:41IPO? Guess who is charging massive
- 35:44percentage fees to manage the sale of these shares to the
- 35:47public? I guess it is the exact same 5
- 35:50banks, Goldman, Morgan, Bank of America, Citi and JP Morgan.
- 35:55Wait, that is brilliant daylight robbery.
- 35:57Imagine the bankers sitting down with Elon.
- 35:59Hey, we see you're burning billions on AI chips and giant
- 36:02rockets. We'll give you a great rate on
- 36:04this $20 billion bridge loan today to keep you afloat.
- 36:07But there's a catch. You have to let us run your IPO
- 36:10next year. We'll take a hefty percentage
- 36:12fee for organizing the IPO, and we'll legally write a rule into
- 36:15the prospectus that the public's IPO money goes directly into our
- 36:18pockets to pay off our own loan. Wall Street never loses.
- 36:22It's essentially a bank bailout funded by retail investors
- 36:25hyping up a Mars colony. What's fascinating here is that
- 36:28the IPO is being aggressively marketed to the public as a
- 36:32massive growth event, raising capital to conquer Mars and
- 36:35build AI. But financially, structurally,
- 36:39the primary function of this IPO is a massive deleveraging event.
- 36:43To fix that balance sheet. Exactly.
- 36:45By raising $75 billion, instantly wiping out the $20
- 36:49billion bridge loan, and adding the remaining cash to the equity
- 36:52side of the balance sheet, that terrifying 84% debt to equity
- 36:57ratio drops to under 10% overnight.
- 37:00The IPO doesn't just fund the future, it retroactively saves
- 37:04the balance sheet. And the auditors absolutely know
- 37:06how complex and precarious this all is.
- 37:09Let's look at the audit report, specifically the Cams.
- 37:11The critical audit matters for anyone who doesn't read
- 37:13financial statements for fun. Cams are the glaring red flags
- 37:16the accountants are legally obligated to point out to
- 37:18investors. Right.
- 37:19The areas where they essentially say this math involves a lot of
- 37:22guesswork, proceed with caution. Exactly.
- 37:25There are three major flags raised by Pricewaterhouse
- 37:28Coopers, the auditors for SpaceX.
- 37:30The 1st is regarding Bitcoin. The prospectus reveals SpaceX
- 37:34holds exactly 18,712 Bitcoin, valued at roughly $1.45 billion.
- 37:42Making them one of the largest corporate holders of crypto in
- 37:44the world, even more than Tesla. Yes, and under recent accounting
- 37:48real changes, crypto assets must be marked to market.
- 37:52This means any wild swings in the spot price of Bitcoin will
- 37:55hit Spacex's income statement directly.
- 37:57It adds a layer of extreme, unpredictable volatility to
- 38:00their quarterly earnings reports that has absolutely nothing to
- 38:03do with their actual business performance of launching rockets
- 38:06or selling Internet. It's just pure price speculation
- 38:08hitting the books. Right now, flag #2 the Valor $20
- 38:11billion transaction. The auditors explicitly point to
- 38:15Footnote 18, highlighting the related party transaction with
- 38:18Antonio Gracias's private equity fund.
- 38:20They are basically waving their arms saying, hey, we signed off
- 38:23on the math of the lease payments, but you, the investor,
- 38:26really need to look at the ethics and the governance
- 38:28structure of this specific deal. They want you to read the fine
- 38:31print on that. One very closely.
- 38:33And the third flag, which is the sole official critical audit
- 38:36matter, relates to something called percentage of completion
- 38:40accounting. SpaceX engages in massive multi
- 38:43year contracts like launching classified government
- 38:46satellites. They don't wait to recognize the
- 38:49revenue all at once. At the very end, they recognize
- 38:52it gradually based on how much of the contracts they estimate
- 38:55they have completed. Explain how that actually works
- 38:58for a reusable rocket, because the auditor points out that
- 39:01estimating the cost of a reusable rocket is incredibly
- 39:04subjective. It is entirely subjective.
- 39:07If management guesses a Falcon 9 rocket will fly 30 times before
- 39:11it needs to be retired, the amortized cost per flight is
- 39:14very low, and therefore the recognized profit they report
- 39:17today looks incredibly high. But.
- 39:19What if they're wrong? Well, if that same rocket only
- 39:22ends up flying 10 times, the true cost per flight is much
- 39:25higher and the profit evaporates.
- 39:28The auditors are warning that Spacex's current revenue numbers
- 39:31rely heavily on internal management guesses about the
- 39:33future physical lifespan of their hardware.
- 39:36So if management's guesses are overly optimistic today to juice
- 39:39the IPO numbers, there could be massive downward revisions in
- 39:43revenue in future quarters when the Rockets wear out faster than
- 39:47expected. Exactly.
- 39:48It's a huge risk. And investors need to be acutely
- 39:51aware of the timeline here, specifically regarding lock up
- 39:54periods. Musk himself is logged in.
- 39:57He cannot sell any of his shares for 365 days post IPO.
- 40:01However, the other early investors, including those
- 40:04superfan board members we talked about, have a tiered unlock
- 40:07schedule that begins to open up after just 180 days.
- 40:10Which puts us right around August to December.
- 40:13So if you buy in at the IPO price, you must be prepared for
- 40:16a potential massive wave of insider selling pressure hitting
- 40:19the market right around the holidays as the early venture
- 40:21capitalists who funded this company over the last decade
- 40:24finally cash out their historical.
- 40:26When you zoom out and look at this entire picture, it is the
- 40:30ultimate dichotomy. On one hand, you are looking at
- 40:33a company that has successfully landed orbital rockets
- 40:36backwards, a company that provides life saving Internet to
- 40:39active war zones, and a company that is building AI
- 40:43supercomputers at a speed that terrifies Google and Amazon.
- 40:47They are achieving genuine, undeniable miracles in physics
- 40:51and engineering. But that undeniable genius is
- 40:54wrapped in a financial and legal structure that asks you, the
- 40:57public investor, to foot the bill for humanity's most
- 40:59expensive dreams while giving you absolutely 0 rights in
- 41:03return. You really get nothing in terms
- 41:05of control. You have no vote, no independent
- 41:07board oversight, and no ability to sue when things go wrong.
- 41:10It's incredible. So for you evaluating this
- 41:13opportunity, the call to action here is deep self reflection.
- 41:16Before you get caught up in the hype of a $2 trillion valuation,
- 41:20the thrill of a Mars colony, and the speed of AI data centers,
- 41:24evaluate your own risk tolerance.
- 41:26Are you comfortable handing your money to a visionary with
- 41:28absolutely no strings attached? Are you OK being a pure
- 41:31passenger on a rocket ship or you have no say in the
- 41:34destination? Consider this as a final,
- 41:36broader implication. If a single entity controls
- 41:40global broadband access, the only viable transport to the
- 41:43Moon and Mars, and the largest orbital AI compute clusters in
- 41:48existence, and all of this power and infrastructure is governed
- 41:52by one individual with 0 Shareholder oversight, 0.
- 41:55Legal accountability to the public market, at what point are
- 41:58you no longer investing in a traditional corporation, but
- 42:02effectively funding an autonomous sovereign nation
- 42:05state? Wow.
- 42:06Think deeply about that before you buy your shares.
- 42:08I think my brain just short circuited A publicly traded
- 42:10nation state. What an incredible way to frame
- 42:12it. Thank you for joining us on this
- 42:13deep dive into the SpaceX prospectus.
- 42:16Remember to check out the deep values dot AI community and the
- 42:18Buffett Indicator app to stay in formed.
- 42:20We'll catch you on the next Dee dive.