Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / Harold Shipman: Doctor Death Who Killed 250 Patients - True Crime Documentary
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: M h.
- 0:09Speaker 2: He was kind, thoughtful, friendly, pathological.
- 0:14Speaker 3: Liar at the time when we said, an answer to prayer,
- 0:18Speaker 3: just what we.
- 0:19Speaker 4: Needed, access to death dealing drugs, always well managed, very quiet,
- 0:26Speaker 4: perfect predator.
- 0:29Speaker 5: Good company outside and extremely popular with everybody.
- 0:34Speaker 4: Trust of the victims.
- 0:37Speaker 6: It was a nice guy. He was a good guy,
- 0:39Speaker 6: perfect killing machine.
- 1:21Speaker 7: His patients were mainly elderly women, living alone and vulnerable.
- 1:26Speaker 7: They adored their doctor, Harold fred Shipman, and even when
- 1:30Speaker 7: their contemporaries began dying in unusually high numbers, patients remained loyal.
- 1:37Speaker 7: The number of patients that doctor Shipman murdered is still unknown,
- 1:42Speaker 7: but his murderous role call eclipses the toll of any
- 1:45Speaker 7: other serial killer caught to date. Did events in his
- 1:49Speaker 7: life turn him to murder? Or more simply, was Harold
- 1:52Speaker 7: Shipman born to kill?
- 1:55Speaker 8: Harl Frederick Shepman is an interesting case to examine. A
- 2:00Speaker 8: very remarkable nature of his case is the fact that
- 2:04Speaker 8: he was not remarkable. We could say he can't be
- 2:08Speaker 8: a killer because he's a bit like us. Harold Shipman
- 2:12Speaker 8: fitted in with society to a great degree, and this
- 2:18Speaker 8: was the very important feature which made it possible for
- 2:22Speaker 8: him to go on and on to be one of
- 2:26Speaker 8: the most prolific serial killers of all time.
- 2:32Speaker 7: For his victims, death came in the afternoon, but for
- 2:36Speaker 7: Harold Frederick Shipman, it came in the early hours of
- 2:39Speaker 7: the morning. At Wakefield Prison on Tuesday, the thirteenth of
- 2:43Speaker 7: January two thousand and four. Prisoner CJ eight one ninety nine,
- 2:49Speaker 7: the expert in death, had timed his final act well.
- 2:53Speaker 7: He was beyond saving. He had been alive at five
- 2:56Speaker 7: a m. When the last check was made on him,
- 2:58Speaker 7: and he knew the next check was not for another hour.
- 3:02Speaker 7: As a doctor, he also knew that four minutes was
- 3:05Speaker 7: the maximum time he needed.
- 3:09Speaker 9: What he has done is he's taken to his grave
- 3:11Speaker 9: them reason and the motivation behind his killing, and left
- 3:18Speaker 9: everybody getting in relation to that and sort of perplexed forevermore.
- 3:30Speaker 7: His suicide caused shock waves through Hyde, the town in
- 3:34Speaker 7: Greater Manchester where most of his victims and their families lived.
- 3:38Speaker 10: Hyde was such a lovely town.
- 3:39Speaker 11: It was a proper old fashioned, traditional community where sons
- 3:43Speaker 11: and daughters still lived on the parents' doorsteps.
- 3:46Speaker 10: And they all lived near each of them. They all
- 3:48Speaker 10: understood each other. It was a very close community with
- 3:50Speaker 10: a warm heart.
- 3:52Speaker 11: So for Shipmen to be able to kill so many
- 3:54Speaker 11: people in such a small.
- 3:56Speaker 10: Safe community was doubly devastating.
- 4:00Speaker 7: Over the years, doctors, funeral directors, and even pharmacists had
- 4:04Speaker 7: raised suspicions about doctor Shipman, but such worries were swept
- 4:08Speaker 7: under the carpet.
- 4:09Speaker 11: I found out that the police had actually investigated Shipman before.
- 4:12Speaker 11: In March nineteen ninety eight, quite soon after breaking the story,
- 4:16Speaker 11: I spoke to doctor Linda Reynolds, and she was the
- 4:18Speaker 11: GP who courageously went to the local coroner, John Pollard
- 4:23Speaker 11: and told him that she.
- 4:25Speaker 10: Was worried that Shipman had killed his patients.
- 4:30Speaker 12: On that basis, I then instructed the police to make
- 4:33Speaker 12: an investigation, and that is what has now been referred
- 4:36Speaker 12: to as the failed investigation, because the police came back
- 4:40Speaker 12: to me about a fortnight later and said they'd investigated
- 4:43Speaker 12: and quite frankly, they could find nothing wrong.
- 4:45Speaker 11: The fact is they came back to Dodr Linda Reynolds
- 4:48Speaker 11: and told her she was mistaken, that Shipman was a
- 4:51Speaker 11: pillar of the community and you know, she must be
- 4:54Speaker 11: careful what she's saying about such people. And Shipman went
- 4:57Speaker 11: on to kill three more women after that.
- 5:00Speaker 7: Doctor Shipman might have carried on killing for years if
- 5:03Speaker 7: it had not been for the suspicious death of Kathleen
- 5:06Speaker 7: Grundy on the twenty fourth of June nineteen ninety eight.
- 5:10Speaker 7: The last person to see her alive was doctor Harold Shipman,
- 5:14Speaker 7: when he'd gone to her home to take routine blood samples.
- 5:17Speaker 13: When Kathleen Grundy died, she left a will. That will
- 5:23Speaker 13: was made out in favor of doctor Shepman, but her daughter,
- 5:26Speaker 13: Angela Woodruff I got this copy of a will, and
- 5:30Speaker 13: she was absolutely astonished because if you look at the
- 5:33Speaker 13: actual will, it's so amateur. If you've got a forger will,
- 5:37Speaker 13: then even about two out of ten for forery, it
- 5:40Speaker 13: simply wasn't very good.
- 5:43Speaker 9: Kathleen Grundy's daughter believed that the signature was not actually
- 5:46Speaker 9: her mother's, so consequently the document needed to be examined.
- 5:54Speaker 13: The officer who was given the case to handle started
- 5:58Speaker 13: onto a couple of people he knew, one of them
- 6:00Speaker 13: being the local undertaker, Alan Messi, who said, well, I've
- 6:05Speaker 13: been really worried about the number of commotion certificates. Have
- 6:09Speaker 13: mentioned it to people before they had taken no interest,
- 6:11Speaker 13: but has so many of.
- 6:13Speaker 9: Them There was the fact that Shipman's fingerprint appeared on
- 6:18Speaker 9: the will when an actual fact in interview, Shipman denied
- 6:21Speaker 9: that he'd ever seen the will, the fact that Shipman
- 6:24Speaker 9: actually owned the typewriter, that the will had been typed on,
- 6:28Speaker 9: and that in interview he suggested that Missus Grundy used
- 6:32Speaker 9: to borrow the typewriter, but he couldn't suggest to us
- 6:36Speaker 9: who had returned it to him. After the will had
- 6:38Speaker 9: been prepared.
- 6:39Speaker 7: It was decided that Kathleen's body needed to be exhumed
- 6:43Speaker 7: and forensically examined to discover the true cause of her death.
- 6:48Speaker 9: The investigation into Kathleen Grundy's death was undertaken in the
- 6:54Speaker 9: knowledge that there had been an earlier investigation into doctor
- 6:58Speaker 9: Shipman's activities had involved nineteen deaths. About a fortnight into
- 7:04Speaker 9: the inquiry, there was interest from a local newspaper.
- 7:08Speaker 11: My news desk at the Manchestrict new News was tipped
- 7:10Speaker 11: off about the death of Kathleen Grundy in the fact
- 7:14Speaker 11: the police were investigating her. Gp I rang the police
- 7:17Speaker 11: and they didn't want to comment any further.
- 7:21Speaker 7: The police decided that the families of the nineteen people
- 7:23Speaker 7: who died should become aware of the reinvestigation before the
- 7:27Speaker 7: story broke.
- 7:29Speaker 11: I then went into hide to find out more about
- 7:32Speaker 11: the case from the people who knew Kathleen Grundy.
- 7:34Speaker 10: Almost immediately I.
- 7:35Speaker 11: Bumped into two old ladies and they said, oh, you
- 7:37Speaker 11: mean DoD to death there, And I said, I beg
- 7:40Speaker 11: your pardon and they said, well, they say, he's a
- 7:41Speaker 11: good dot, but you don't last.
- 7:43Speaker 10: Lots of old ladies have died.
- 7:44Speaker 7: With dotor ship.
- 7:47Speaker 9: Family members then told us very similar stories to the
- 7:52Speaker 9: story that we had already uncovered in relation to Kathleen Grunde.
- 7:56Speaker 9: That is when I started to realize that this was more,
- 8:00Speaker 9: much bigger than one death that Dr Shipman had been
- 8:04Speaker 9: involved in. We carried out the exhamation and a pathologist
- 8:24Speaker 9: actually performed a post mortem. Shipman, of course, had certified
- 8:30Speaker 9: the death at the time it had occurred as being
- 8:32Speaker 9: old age. He could not confirm the cause of death
- 8:35Speaker 9: that Shipman had put and consequently we sent samples off
- 8:40Speaker 9: for analysis.
- 8:42Speaker 12: There were levels of diamorphine in the body of the decease,
- 8:46Speaker 12: which was sufficient to have led to her death.
- 8:51Speaker 9: Of course, missus Grundy had not been suffering from any
- 8:54Speaker 9: serious illnesses that required her to be administered diamorphine age.
- 9:00Speaker 12: I was totally convinced that they were onto someone here
- 9:04Speaker 12: who had committed many heenous crimes.
- 9:11Speaker 11: The community were absolutely wholeheartedly behind dodd Shipment at this point.
- 9:15Speaker 11: He'd groomed that community so that they truly believed in
- 9:18Speaker 11: him and thought that he was looking after them, when
- 9:20Speaker 11: in fact he was killing them by the hundred.
- 9:35Speaker 14: The kind of.
- 9:35Speaker 8: Victims he picked the elderly people who what we call
- 9:38Speaker 8: the category of less than dead, in other words, the
- 9:40Speaker 8: kind of people that if they passed away, you don't.
- 9:43Speaker 7: Actually notice so well.
- 9:45Speaker 8: They're not the kind of people that are going to
- 9:46Speaker 8: cause a big fuss because almost it's expected, and in fact,
- 9:51Speaker 8: counter to most serial killers, he's one of the few
- 9:54Speaker 8: people who could probably get the relatives or the council
- 9:57Speaker 8: to take away the body for him.
- 9:59Speaker 12: The way in which the victims were found was in
- 10:02Speaker 12: itself quite disturbing. Many of them were found fully clothed
- 10:07Speaker 12: in the middle of the daytime, often sitting upright in
- 10:11Speaker 12: a chair or on a sofa. In some of those cases,
- 10:20Speaker 12: Shipman had actually certified on the cremation form that he'd
- 10:23Speaker 12: carried out a full external examination of the body, and
- 10:27Speaker 12: yet the victim was still sitting there fully closed, shoes on,
- 10:31Speaker 12: you know, the sleeves buttoned down to the wrist, dresses
- 10:34Speaker 12: that buttoned to the neck. Well, how you can carry
- 10:37Speaker 12: out a full external investigation in those circumstances, I just
- 10:41Speaker 12: don't understand.
- 10:47Speaker 15: Often in the medical notes which he'd made up, suggesting
- 10:51Speaker 15: that these people had had heart conditions, for example, when
- 10:54Speaker 15: they hadn't really and then saying, well, they must have
- 10:57Speaker 15: had a heart attack. Of course, somebody having a heart
- 10:59Speaker 15: act doesn't just simply fall asleep sitting in a chair
- 11:03Speaker 15: looking very relaxed. Life just isn't like that.
- 11:10Speaker 7: Police investigated Shipman's book of death certificates. They made a
- 11:14Speaker 7: list of fifteen deaths that they decided should be investigated
- 11:17Speaker 7: as a priority. Of the victims on this list, nine
- 11:21Speaker 7: had been buried and six cremated. More exhumations were ordered.
- 11:27Speaker 7: Police also learned that doctor Shipman had often encouraged the
- 11:30Speaker 7: relatives of his victims towards cremation.
- 11:33Speaker 12: In each of the exhumations that took place, tests were
- 11:36Speaker 12: carried out, and in most of those morphine was discovered
- 11:40Speaker 12: in the body, and that led to a prosecution in
- 11:42Speaker 12: relation to that death.
- 11:45Speaker 7: The police inquiry would also reveal Shipman's modus operandi. He
- 11:49Speaker 7: would often kill his victims, most of whom were elderly,
- 11:52Speaker 7: with an injection of morphine, and then returned to his
- 11:55Speaker 7: office to falsify their medical records on his computer to
- 11:59Speaker 7: exaggerate their poor health. In the case of Kathleen Grandy,
- 12:02Speaker 7: he had backdated several entries to suggest she had become
- 12:06Speaker 7: addicted to morphine.
- 12:07Speaker 12: The thought of an eighty odd year old former Lady
- 12:10Speaker 12: Mayoress of the town of Hyde scoring bags of heroin
- 12:14Speaker 12: in the backstreets of Manchester seems to meet ludicrous and
- 12:17Speaker 12: ridiculous and a gross insult to her memory. Quite frankly, being.
- 12:21Speaker 8: A GP placed Harowdshipman in a position where in.
- 12:25Speaker 16: Public he can actually carry out the very activities in
- 12:29Speaker 16: private he wished to carry out and actually project them
- 12:33Speaker 16: in the community and wander around the community and make
- 12:36Speaker 16: it quite clear to people that you know, I am
- 12:39Speaker 16: a great doctor.
- 12:42Speaker 7: On the seventh of September nineteen ninety eight, Shipman was
- 12:45Speaker 7: arrested on suspicion of murder. Who was the real doctor Shipman?
- 12:56Speaker 7: What made him a monster?
- 12:58Speaker 8: In order to actually find out about this actual behavior
- 13:02Speaker 8: and how it developed.
- 13:04Speaker 9: We have to look.
- 13:05Speaker 8: Back in time very closely at his childhood and even beyond.
- 13:20Speaker 7: In September nineteen ninety eight, Harold Shipman was convicted for
- 13:24Speaker 7: fifteen murders. The Shipman Inquiry now documents that he killed
- 13:28Speaker 7: two hundred and eighty four people over a period of
- 13:31Speaker 7: thirty years before he aroused suspicion. However, no one really
- 13:36Speaker 7: knows the true number.
- 13:37Speaker 14: Of his victims.
- 13:39Speaker 7: The Shipman case is unusual. There was no highly publicized
- 13:43Speaker 7: trail of bodies, no madman on the loose. Until Shipman
- 13:48Speaker 7: was arrested in connection with the Kathleen Grundy case, no
- 13:51Speaker 7: one could have known just how many murders had taken place.
- 13:56Speaker 8: If we wished to find out whether Harold Shipman was,
- 13:59Speaker 8: in fact want to kill, we need to examine early
- 14:02Speaker 8: childhood looking for patterns of behavior which would indicate that
- 14:07Speaker 8: they carry traits, that their temperament is different.
- 14:11Speaker 16: With Harold, we.
- 14:13Speaker 8: Realized that on the surface, it seems like a very
- 14:16Speaker 8: ordinary childhood, a very ordinary background. But if we dig deeper,
- 14:22Speaker 8: we know that there are going to be clues as
- 14:24Speaker 8: to why he ended up where he did.
- 14:28Speaker 7: Harold Frederick Shipman nicknamed Fred or Freddie, was born into
- 14:32Speaker 7: a working class family on June the fourteenth, nineteen forty six,
- 14:36Speaker 7: in Nottingham. He was a distant and slightly aloof child,
- 14:40Speaker 7: maintaining a distance between himself and his contemporaries, mainly due
- 14:45Speaker 7: to the influence of his mother, Vera.
- 14:48Speaker 13: I think his mother certainly encouraged him to the but
- 14:54Speaker 13: the path of righteousness, but she thought fred was special.
- 14:58Speaker 13: She wanted him to be sp and now he was
- 15:01Speaker 13: the middle child and the elder sister, Pauline, left school
- 15:05Speaker 13: at fifteen, was no great academic. His brother Clive wasn't
- 15:09Speaker 13: as bright as younger brother, but Fred brought her in
- 15:13Speaker 13: a decent and fairly new council estate in Nottingham Passes
- 15:17Speaker 13: eleven plus got into the local grammar school, High Pavements,
- 15:21Speaker 13: which was extremely prestigious to do so he studied hard.
- 15:26Speaker 13: He didn't mix very much with local kids.
- 15:29Speaker 2: And his parents, like my parents, like lots and lots
- 15:32Speaker 2: of other working class parents, would have been so proud
- 15:37Speaker 2: are boys going to a grammar school.
- 15:40Speaker 7: Shipman's school days at High Pavement were largely unspectacular. Like
- 15:44Speaker 7: so many other grammar school entrants, he went from being
- 15:47Speaker 7: one of the bright kids at junior school to being
- 15:49Speaker 7: run of the mill amongst so many other clever boys.
- 15:52Speaker 17: Fred was very serious, and I think it may be
- 15:55Speaker 17: that he had to work harder than the most I know.
- 16:00Speaker 7: He had.
- 16:02Speaker 17: A real respect for his family, and I think he
- 16:05Speaker 17: thought that they'd made an effort. His parents had made,
- 16:08Speaker 17: perhaps of sacrifice.
- 16:12Speaker 8: His mother really didn't want Fred to be, as it
- 16:15Speaker 8: were in this area, I'd have the same kind of
- 16:17Speaker 8: career as other boys. And having him focus exclusively about
- 16:21Speaker 8: his studies meant that Fred was not really integrated into
- 16:23Speaker 8: the real world, and he was allowed to build up fantasies,
- 16:27Speaker 8: fantasies of power, and fantasies that perhaps might have had
- 16:30Speaker 8: a sexual connotation because Fred was not really allowed to
- 16:34Speaker 8: develop socially and sexually normally.
- 16:37Speaker 7: Vera decided who Fred could play with and when she
- 16:40Speaker 7: wanted to distinguish him from other boys. She was more
- 16:43Speaker 7: ambitious for Harold than her other children, perhaps.
- 16:46Speaker 17: Because he seemed more mature. You seem much older. And
- 16:52Speaker 17: when certain incidents occurred at school, which perhaps had it
- 16:56Speaker 17: mean anybody else had a good laugh and he had
- 16:59Speaker 17: met him pay for it. With Freddie didn't one of
- 17:01Speaker 17: the best examples of that other rugby club dancers that
- 17:05Speaker 17: we had. He turned up with his sister and they
- 17:07Speaker 17: used to dance together in this strangely uncoordinated way, totally different,
- 17:12Speaker 17: and I think she was taller than him as well.
- 17:14Speaker 6: We just respected him. It's strange.
- 17:18Speaker 8: The fact that Fred got respect from his friends is
- 17:21Speaker 8: a little bit surprising because of his social alienation. However,
- 17:25Speaker 8: by playing it by the rules, by creating an act,
- 17:28Speaker 8: Fred just simply coexisted with these people and formed no
- 17:32Speaker 8: real problem in relating to other people. So he was able,
- 17:38Speaker 8: if it were as it were, just to slot in.
- 17:40Speaker 8: He didn't really have any difficulty because he didn't create
- 17:44Speaker 8: any difficulty.
- 17:47Speaker 7: On Friday, the twenty first of June nineteen sixty, when
- 17:50Speaker 7: Fred was just seventeen, his mother, Vera, died of lung cancer,
- 17:55Speaker 7: an illness that he had kept strangely secret from his classmates.
- 18:00Speaker 7: The family GP visited the house regularly in the weeks
- 18:03Speaker 7: before Vera's death, giving her welcome injections of morphine in
- 18:07Speaker 7: ever decreasing dosages. He met schoolmate Michael Heath on his
- 18:11Speaker 7: way to school the following Monday morning, when he told
- 18:14Speaker 7: him his tragic news.
- 18:15Speaker 17: In most days Fred would be coming along along the
- 18:19Speaker 17: road here from his house and we'll meet at the
- 18:21Speaker 17: bottom of the road here, and we'd stop here and
- 18:24Speaker 17: just say a few words, and then we'd walk walk
- 18:27Speaker 17: on to the school. And he was on one of
- 18:31Speaker 17: those those mornings, Monday morning when I met him at
- 18:36Speaker 17: the point just there and just ask him, what's the
- 18:38Speaker 17: weekend he's had, And he was and he said.
- 18:41Speaker 6: My mama died.
- 18:43Speaker 17: His mama died, and you know, that's that's part of
- 18:46Speaker 17: chock round it.
- 18:47Speaker 2: Pred never said anything.
- 18:51Speaker 14: To me.
- 18:53Speaker 2: Other than once on a bus. I seemed to remember
- 18:56Speaker 2: him saying, my mum's not very well. That could have
- 19:00Speaker 2: been that she got a cold.
- 19:01Speaker 17: That must have been terrible.
- 19:02Speaker 11: What did you do?
- 19:03Speaker 16: How did you cope?
- 19:05Speaker 17: And he said, well, got my gear on, went for
- 19:07Speaker 17: a run and he ran the pouring rain, so he
- 19:10Speaker 17: must have been absolutely saturated.
- 19:14Speaker 13: He grieved in a very strange way. He ran for
- 19:18Speaker 13: months and miles, months, all through the night in his school,
- 19:25Speaker 13: running shorts and t shirts, and it was quite an
- 19:29Speaker 13: amazing thing.
- 19:32Speaker 17: He just seemed the same as he did any other day.
- 19:35Speaker 17: But he must have been going through hell for the
- 19:37Speaker 17: weeks months.
- 19:38Speaker 13: Before Fred would be the one who sat with her
- 19:42Speaker 13: and waited for the doctor to come round and to
- 19:45Speaker 13: give her an injection of morphine. And he was at
- 19:48Speaker 13: her bedside when she died, and that was a moment
- 19:53Speaker 13: that obviously impacted on him greatly.
- 19:55Speaker 17: He's a school Gates plot was the school There's there's
- 20:00Speaker 17: ten minutes on that particular morning that he told me
- 20:02Speaker 17: that it was mom a diver awkward to say the least,
- 20:06Speaker 17: and I must admit when we arrived he was a
- 20:09Speaker 17: bit of a relief trust again current separate ways.
- 20:15Speaker 13: It's interesting that he'd shown no interest in medicine or
- 20:21Speaker 13: said he wanted to be a doctor until after his
- 20:24Speaker 13: mother passed away.
- 20:26Speaker 8: Many have drawn the comparison between Fred's experience of his
- 20:29Speaker 8: mother dying under morphine and his later use of morphine
- 20:33Speaker 8: to actually execute the old ladies. Now there has to
- 20:36Speaker 8: be a connection, and very few people have actually.
- 20:38Speaker 4: Drawn why one leads to the other.
- 20:41Speaker 8: If you look back in Fred's history, he constantly used exercise.
- 20:46Speaker 8: Exercise generates what we call endorphins. Endorphins are extremely powerful opiates,
- 20:52Speaker 8: one hundred, sometimes a thousand times more powerful than heroin.
- 20:56Speaker 8: Now Fred was accustomed to this, if you like, when
- 20:59Speaker 8: his mother passed away. He experienced what many people experienced
- 21:02Speaker 8: when a family member finally passes away after a grueling period.
- 21:06Speaker 8: He felt relief, he felt a certain lift, and this
- 21:11Speaker 8: experience was then compounded because he went out for whatever
- 21:14Speaker 8: reason and ran all night, and that extra opiate running
- 21:18Speaker 8: around his body will have given Fred a euphoric high. Hence,
- 21:23Speaker 8: this situation was likely to be repeated and give him
- 21:27Speaker 8: pleasure in the future.
- 21:30Speaker 7: Fred failed to get the grades he needed to study
- 21:33Speaker 7: medicine at Leeds Medical School.
- 21:35Speaker 4: Common with many serial killers with lower self esteem, they
- 21:39Speaker 4: always aspire to be better than They want to be
- 21:42Speaker 4: up with their peers. You know, they envy their peers.
- 21:45Speaker 4: Kenneth bi Anger the Hillside Strangle, always wanted to be
- 21:47Speaker 4: a cop. Everybody, all his schoolmates are all succeeding around
- 21:50Speaker 4: him with good grades. He was a failure. They're always
- 21:53Speaker 4: scrabbing to get out, scrabbling to get somewhere.
- 21:56Speaker 7: After resetting his exams the following year, he was eventually
- 21:59Speaker 7: accepted into Leeds Medical School in nineteen sixty five. Did
- 22:05Speaker 7: Shipman decide to become a doctor to save people or
- 22:08Speaker 7: to have the power to kill them?
- 22:13Speaker 13: When Shipman first went to Leeds he regularly got a
- 22:17Speaker 13: bus into Leeds every morning. And on that same bus
- 22:20Speaker 13: with there was a young girl called Primrose Oxterby, who
- 22:25Speaker 13: like Shipman, had and a rather auster year upbringing. She
- 22:29Speaker 13: left school at fifteen without any qualifications and she got
- 22:33Speaker 13: onto an art and design course at a college in Needs.
- 22:37Speaker 13: And on that bus it was the very good looking
- 22:41Speaker 13: at the time Shipman and they hit it off, but
- 22:44Speaker 13: very quickly after meeting, after about six months, she was pregnant.
- 22:47Speaker 13: Shipman was careless, reckless for the first time in his life.
- 22:53Speaker 13: They're not married at a register office. There isn't even
- 22:56Speaker 13: a photograph in existence of that wedding.
- 23:01Speaker 7: Shipman qualified from Leeds Medical University and went on to
- 23:05Speaker 7: Pontefract General Infirmary to train as a junior doctor. After
- 23:09Speaker 7: twelve months he was duly licensed to practice medicine. According
- 23:13Speaker 7: to the Shipman Inquiry, this was where his first recorded
- 23:16Speaker 7: murder took place.
- 23:18Speaker 11: The Shipman Inquiry found that he killed a four year
- 23:21Speaker 11: old girl, for example, and she was very very ill
- 23:24Speaker 11: and dying, and her mother left the room saying please
- 23:28Speaker 11: be kind to her, and.
- 23:30Speaker 10: He took that as his cue to kill her.
- 23:32Speaker 11: He might have pretended that that was euthanasia and that
- 23:35Speaker 11: he was doing that child of favor. But he wasn't
- 23:38Speaker 11: because that child didn't die in her mother's arms. Her
- 23:40Speaker 11: mother was having a cup of tea in the hospital cafe.
- 23:43Speaker 11: So I think even then he had a very cruel
- 23:45Speaker 11: streak that wanted to end lives come what may.
- 23:49Speaker 8: It is absolutely uncertain exactly where Harold Shipman began to
- 23:54Speaker 8: kill people. It may have been the case of the
- 23:58Speaker 8: four year old girl, but we do know that as
- 24:02Speaker 8: he approached that time, Harold will have had some swelling
- 24:06Speaker 8: and some strangely inexplicable pleasurable feelings that were probably associated
- 24:12Speaker 8: with the event with his mother, and he would suddenly
- 24:16Speaker 8: start to feel he was in that powerful role, that
- 24:19Speaker 8: controller of life and death in a right way. It
- 24:23Speaker 8: harks back to that very moment when he thought he
- 24:27Speaker 8: should be that gp by his mother's bedside.
- 24:33Speaker 7: By nineteen seventy four, he was a father of two
- 24:36Speaker 7: and had joined a medical practice in the Yorkshire town
- 24:39Speaker 7: of Toddmden. In this North English setting, Fred seemed to
- 24:43Speaker 7: change character. He became an outgoing, respected member of the
- 24:49Speaker 7: community in the eyes of his fellow medics and patients.
- 24:53Speaker 13: Boom Inter General Practice as Julia partner was clearly very attractive,
- 24:58Speaker 13: and he went and worked the abrahm Omad practice in Toddmada,
- 25:02Speaker 13: where there was illness among the partners. Doctor Michael Grave
- 25:06Speaker 13: welcomed in with open arms.
- 25:10Speaker 3: He was extremely good, almost manic in the way he
- 25:15Speaker 3: carried out his duties and brought us all the latest
- 25:20Speaker 3: techniques and kept us very much up to the mark.
- 25:24Speaker 3: He was really at the time when we would have
- 25:27Speaker 3: said an answer to prayer, just what we needed. The
- 25:34Speaker 3: doctors did not choose their patients. The patients chose the
- 25:38Speaker 3: doctor that they liked, and Fred had quite a devoted
- 25:45Speaker 3: following who felt that he was the bee's knees and
- 25:50Speaker 3: would do the best for them in all circumstances.
- 25:53Speaker 8: Rol Shipman underwent a metamorphosis. He changed from being the
- 25:57Speaker 8: very asocial Mummies boy who didn't really get on very
- 26:01Speaker 8: well with people, into a GP who would establish himself
- 26:06Speaker 8: in this area and find that suddenly he could relate
- 26:09Speaker 8: to people and grow, if you like, as a pillar
- 26:12Speaker 8: of the community. However, Harold Shipman did have a different agenda.
- 26:18Speaker 7: But the staff in the medical offices where he worked
- 26:21Speaker 7: saw a different side of the young practitioner.
- 26:26Speaker 3: He wouldn't delegate, He wouldn't let the nurses give injections
- 26:30Speaker 3: for him. For instance, he wouldn't let the pathology technicians
- 26:34Speaker 3: when they came out once a week to take blood
- 26:36Speaker 3: x armceles for patients. Now Fred would insist on doing
- 26:41Speaker 3: all these himself.
- 26:45Speaker 13: Nobody had any idea that he was guilty of any
- 26:51Speaker 13: kind of malpractice, although would emerge the editor in Tommoden
- 26:56Speaker 13: that there was an instance where three patients of his
- 26:59Speaker 13: diet and in one day and for a long time.
- 27:02Speaker 13: One of the Meva lions was thought to be his
- 27:05Speaker 13: very first victim.
- 27:13Speaker 7: But the village doctor wasn't as perfect as the fellow
- 27:16Speaker 7: GP's thought. It was discovered that he had a drug addiction.
- 27:22Speaker 13: One of the other doctors in the practice had to
- 27:26Speaker 13: be in the pharmacist and showed the book and said
- 27:28Speaker 13: generally you should look at this, you know, And there
- 27:31Speaker 13: were scores of entries and he'd amassed huge amounts of pathody,
- 27:37Speaker 13: clearly not for patients, but for himself well.
- 27:41Speaker 3: He said he was addicted to pathodion because they were
- 27:45Speaker 3: told you shouldn't give your patient anything that you haven't
- 27:50Speaker 3: tried yourself, and finding that it sustained him in his
- 27:53Speaker 3: manic because he was quite manic in what.
- 27:55Speaker 14: He would do.
- 27:56Speaker 3: He'd take on these enormous loads and get through them,
- 28:01Speaker 3: and perhaps the pathoden was enabled him to do it.
- 28:04Speaker 13: And he was sorry for had you am to go?
- 28:07Speaker 13: And he booted his medical across the surgery whether I'm
- 28:10Speaker 13: in the mid or sodulent, and off he went.
- 28:14Speaker 3: He thought that I was the devil incarnate and I
- 28:19Speaker 3: never spoke to him again.
- 28:25Speaker 4: At that point. When a serial killer is confronted with
- 28:29Speaker 4: the offeus, they retreat either with the excuse societies fitted
- 28:34Speaker 4: me up, It's not my fault, or they explode. And
- 28:39Speaker 4: that's what Shipman was basically doing. How dare these little doctors,
- 28:42Speaker 4: these little people, these people that are lower than me?
- 28:45Speaker 4: How dare they question me? How dare they because he
- 28:48Speaker 4: believes he's got this thing? How dare that these people
- 28:50Speaker 4: are much lower than me? My mother's always taught me
- 28:52Speaker 4: this way. How dare they interrogate me? Who are they?
- 28:55Speaker 7: Shipman was ultimately forced out of the practice and into
- 28:58Speaker 7: a York drug rehabilitation center in nineteen seventy five. Two
- 29:03Speaker 7: years later, his many convictions for drag offenses, prescription fraud,
- 29:07Speaker 7: and forgery cost him a surprisingly low fine of six
- 29:11Speaker 7: hundred pounds.
- 29:12Speaker 13: After about a year or so, he saw an advert
- 29:17Speaker 13: for a junior partner in a practice and hired and
- 29:21Speaker 13: he applied for it, and when he went there, he
- 29:24Speaker 13: was totally open about his previous drug habit since a
- 29:28Speaker 13: look completely clean. I was under enormous stress. The general
- 29:33Speaker 13: medical counselor has gone to allow at to carry on
- 29:36Speaker 13: working as a doctor, and I'd love another chance, and
- 29:40Speaker 13: they believed him and took him in.
- 29:43Speaker 7: In nineteen seventy seven, he was accepted to practice in
- 29:46Speaker 7: the Donnybrook Medical Center in Hyde, and it was here
- 29:50Speaker 7: that he felt free to kill.
- 29:53Speaker 5: High is not a very big town, and obviously we
- 29:55Speaker 5: had a shot. We knew lots of people that were
- 29:57Speaker 5: Fred's patients, and everybody seemed to the same opinion that
- 30:02Speaker 5: he was a caring guy. You know, he just seemed
- 30:05Speaker 5: a normal guy.
- 30:06Speaker 14: Again.
- 30:07Speaker 7: He played the role of the dedicated, hard working and
- 30:09Speaker 7: community minded doctor, highly respected in the area and making
- 30:13Speaker 7: many friends.
- 30:14Speaker 5: We went to a couple of social functions with there
- 30:17Speaker 5: were good company outside and extremely popular with everybody that
- 30:21Speaker 5: was there, giving the impression the guy who's just a
- 30:24Speaker 5: normal guy, you know.
- 30:27Speaker 8: Harold Shipman found it very much more comfortable to kill
- 30:31Speaker 8: and be in hide Hyde was a fairly small, naive
- 30:34Speaker 8: community where he would be accepted. This you know, tweed wearing,
- 30:38Speaker 8: friendly local GP character. Harold Shipman had had what we
- 30:44Speaker 8: call career development.
- 30:46Speaker 7: As a killer.
- 30:46Speaker 8: He had actually developed as a killer to the stage
- 30:49Speaker 8: of being doctor god.
- 30:59Speaker 11: I think I went into single handed practice purely to
- 31:02Speaker 11: continue killing.
- 31:05Speaker 13: Clearly, if he worked on his own, nobody would know
- 31:09Speaker 13: exactly what he was up to.
- 31:12Speaker 5: Most times it was okay, but the odd time he
- 31:15Speaker 5: was a bit of offish. So you know, you tend
- 31:18Speaker 5: to wonder what were those days? Were those days maybe
- 31:22Speaker 5: when something happened you don't know? It makes you think.
- 31:35Speaker 7: Because of the nature of the Shipman case, it may
- 31:37Speaker 7: never be possible to document the exact number of murders
- 31:40Speaker 7: he committed. The number and patterns of deaths in doctor
- 31:44Speaker 7: Shipman's practice was examined. When it was compared with those
- 31:48Speaker 7: of other practitioners, significant differences appeared, notably that the rate
- 31:53Speaker 7: of deaths of elderly patients was disproportionately high. Other variations appeared.
- 32:01Speaker 7: Deaths were often clustered at certain times of the day.
- 32:04Speaker 7: Patients records and previous symptoms were mismatched, and doctor Shipman
- 32:10Speaker 7: was usually in attendance. The question remains, why wasn't he
- 32:15Speaker 7: stopped earlier?
- 32:19Speaker 8: In order to ascertain why, Harold Goodruthy, did you have
- 32:23Speaker 8: to examine those little chinks, those flaws that show a
- 32:26Speaker 8: glimmer under the surface of this projection as the good doctor,
- 32:31Speaker 8: as the average man.
- 32:39Speaker 7: There's little doubt that some owe their lives to A
- 32:42Speaker 7: determined and intelligent woman named Angela Woodruff. Determination to solve
- 32:47Speaker 7: a mystery about her mother's will helped ensure that. On Monday,
- 32:51Speaker 7: the thirty first of January two thousand, the jury at
- 32:54Speaker 7: Preston Crown Court found Shipman guilty of murdering fifteen of
- 32:59Speaker 7: his patients and forging the will of Angela's beloved mother,
- 33:03Speaker 7: Kathleen Grundy.
- 33:05Speaker 5: It's difficult to believe that we were friends with Fred Shipman,
- 33:10Speaker 5: who was one of the biggest serial killers in Great Britain.
- 33:14Speaker 5: But when he's such a normal guy, he just fooled everybody.
- 33:23Speaker 5: He shouldn't be playing god anyway, I hope he should
- 33:25Speaker 5: be doing.
- 33:30Speaker 15: Many of his victims lived on their own, A lot
- 33:34Speaker 15: of them used to regard his visits to them as
- 33:39Speaker 15: being something to look forward to. There were many instances
- 33:44Speaker 15: of them being dressed in their best clothes as if
- 33:48Speaker 15: they were getting a visitor, and it was something to
- 33:50Speaker 15: look forward to.
- 33:50Speaker 5: And therefore, you.
- 33:51Speaker 15: Know, let's put on something nice because the doctor's coming
- 33:54Speaker 15: to visit.
- 33:57Speaker 11: That was all part of this great chip that he
- 34:00Speaker 11: was on that their last words would have been thank
- 34:02Speaker 11: you doctor.
- 34:17Speaker 7: Mistake number one Shipman's use of the drug morphine. Morphine
- 34:22Speaker 7: is one of the few poisons that can remain in
- 34:24Speaker 7: body tissues for centuries.
- 34:27Speaker 12: There are other substances which he could have used, which
- 34:30Speaker 12: would have been either less traceable or even not traceable
- 34:33Speaker 12: at all within the body. Why he chose to use diamorphine,
- 34:39Speaker 12: I don't know. One reason might be that he was
- 34:41Speaker 12: simply not quite as clever as he thought he was
- 34:44Speaker 12: and didn't realize that it would be so traceable so easily.
- 34:47Speaker 12: The other reason may be that he actually was quite
- 34:50Speaker 12: willing and wanted to be found out at some stage.
- 34:54Speaker 7: Mistake number two The typewriter and the badly forged will.
- 34:58Speaker 13: So when and murdered Missus Grundy and forged a will,
- 35:04Speaker 13: what was happening? Did he want to get caught. Was
- 35:08Speaker 13: he looking for a way out or what? Having Coltundan
- 35:14Speaker 13: eighty three people, he comes to Catherine Grundy, Well, anybody's
- 35:19Speaker 13: fair game. He's not being found out so far, even
- 35:23Speaker 13: though he most certainly should have been. But the fact
- 35:27Speaker 13: is he was a hospital doctor and a GP who
- 35:30Speaker 13: was never challenged.
- 35:35Speaker 11: I was very surprised to see that will on what
- 35:38Speaker 11: a mess it was, so I think at that point
- 35:40Speaker 11: maybe he wanted to get caught.
- 35:41Speaker 10: On the other hand, maybe he felt invincible.
- 35:49Speaker 8: I think that Harold was becoming a little bit paranoid
- 35:52Speaker 8: as to whether he was in safe territory, and he
- 35:56Speaker 8: was testing the ground to find out whether or not
- 36:00Speaker 8: people were suspicious of him, and also to prove to
- 36:04Speaker 8: himself that he could talk his way out of this
- 36:08Speaker 8: amongst these people that were his intellectual inferiors.
- 36:13Speaker 5: His actual reason for doing it, I'm not sure, I
- 36:17Speaker 5: must be honest, I really don't know.
- 36:21Speaker 11: I think he expected to set the world on fire,
- 36:23Speaker 11: but instead he faced a series of setbacks.
- 36:26Speaker 10: He got Primrose pregnant.
- 36:27Speaker 11: While he was a medical student, he became addicted to
- 36:30Speaker 11: pethodine and was caught so so in the end he
- 36:32Speaker 11: was quite disappointed with what he appeared to be. He
- 36:36Speaker 11: was quite small and lowly, quite a small man, and
- 36:39Speaker 11: I think that disappointment fueled an anger and an addiction
- 36:43Speaker 11: to killing.
- 36:46Speaker 13: Certainly there is grandiosity involved. He acted like a supreme being,
- 36:53Speaker 13: a godlike figure who clearly had the power over life
- 36:58Speaker 13: and death. And he chose to kill people at the
- 37:01Speaker 13: time when he wanted to kill them.
- 37:04Speaker 7: So why did he kill? Some speculate he hated older women,
- 37:08Speaker 7: citing comments he made about the elderly being a drain
- 37:11Speaker 7: on the health system. Others feel he was recreating his
- 37:14Speaker 7: mother's death scene in order to satisfy some deep mesochistic need.
- 37:19Speaker 11: I think his mother's death informed the murders, gave him
- 37:24Speaker 11: a theme, but I don't think it's a reason. A
- 37:26Speaker 11: lot of people lose their mothers when they're teenagers to
- 37:28Speaker 11: cruel and painful diseases, and we don't all go out
- 37:32Speaker 11: and start killing hundreds of people. I think he had
- 37:35Speaker 11: a personality disorder to start with. But the fact that
- 37:38Speaker 11: his mother used to wait for him to return from school,
- 37:42Speaker 11: sitting in the wind over the cup of tea, and
- 37:44Speaker 11: the dots would turn up and give her a morphine
- 37:46Speaker 11: and that was her relief from the terrible pain of
- 37:48Speaker 11: the cancer. I think that was very important to him
- 37:51Speaker 11: when he did start killing.
- 37:55Speaker 8: The first time that Harold Shipman actually killed someone, it
- 38:00Speaker 8: is probable that in his mind there was rising pleasure
- 38:03Speaker 8: associated with the incidents of his mother's death. At that point,
- 38:08Speaker 8: he will have felt a certain amount of power and
- 38:11Speaker 8: control and a certain calmness associated with the euphoria with
- 38:17Speaker 8: his mother, and this would have been rewarding enough to
- 38:21Speaker 8: propel him forward. But I feel that that form of euphoria,
- 38:25Speaker 8: in contrast to many other serial killers, would have died
- 38:29Speaker 8: out fairly quickly after the incident.
- 38:33Speaker 7: Despite overwhelming evidence of his guilt, Harold Shipman continued to
- 38:38Speaker 7: maintain his innocence and shield the motives of his crime
- 38:41Speaker 7: even in prison.
- 38:43Speaker 5: And when Fred first went into prison, her wife started
- 38:46Speaker 5: to correspond with him because you know, she firmly believed
- 38:50Speaker 5: that he was innocent. There are round about twenty five
- 38:56Speaker 5: letters which were written. In all the letters, there's obviously
- 39:02Speaker 5: no reference to the fact that he's admitting to anything
- 39:05Speaker 5: at all. He was definitely trying to keep as much
- 39:08Speaker 5: normality about his actions as he possibly could, so that
- 39:13Speaker 5: anything that people might come up with about what he's
- 39:17Speaker 5: supposed to have done. Seemed totally illogical.
- 39:21Speaker 1: Into a house, rolled a sleeve, administered Marphie killed her.
- 39:28Speaker 1: That's what happened, isn't it.
- 39:29Speaker 18: Doctor Harold always maintained his innocence to me. He never wants,
- 39:39Speaker 18: as far as I know it, to me or any
- 39:41Speaker 18: of the other prisoners, admitted to the guilt of actually
- 39:45Speaker 18: emerging any of the patients.
- 39:49Speaker 1: The levels of such of this woman actually died from
- 39:52Speaker 1: the toxicity of marphine, not as you wrongly diagnosed in
- 39:57Speaker 1: place speaking, you murdered her.
- 40:01Speaker 5: When doctor was finally convicted, my wife was very upset
- 40:06Speaker 5: and I said, well, there's only one thing you can do.
- 40:08Speaker 5: I said, you can't write to the guy. I said,
- 40:11Speaker 5: I think, you know, judging him by the amount of
- 40:13Speaker 5: evidence has been put forward and the time it's taken,
- 40:17Speaker 5: I said, I think it's pretty conclusive that he is guilty.
- 40:21Speaker 18: I remember when they first tried charging him for two
- 40:23Speaker 18: hundred and eighteen murders on top of what they already
- 40:25Speaker 18: accused him of. That was the first time I'd ever
- 40:28Speaker 18: actually shin him reacted to his title on what was
- 40:31Speaker 18: going on. I remember when he came back from court,
- 40:35Speaker 18: he just brought down in tears and explained to me
- 40:38Speaker 18: what's gone, And he said the China pining oundre and
- 40:41Speaker 18: eighteen murders on top of me. I mean, I don't
- 40:44Speaker 18: know where it's coming from, or whether getting no evidence
- 40:48Speaker 18: from or anything, you know, whether getting his stories used
- 40:50Speaker 18: to scoll them. That was the first time, actually shiner
- 40:54Speaker 18: reaction from him. You smashed hisselut. Actually he's just went berserk.
- 41:01Speaker 8: Harold Shipman never admitted to his crimes, not to prison warders,
- 41:07Speaker 8: not to prison inmates. Harold Shipman maintained the act that
- 41:11Speaker 8: he had started in childhood, where he, as it were,
- 41:15Speaker 8: acted out the role of a social person, where he
- 41:18Speaker 8: acted out the role of the good doctor. He could not,
- 41:22Speaker 8: at the end of his existence, change that because if
- 41:26Speaker 8: he had admitted that he had done this, he would
- 41:30Speaker 8: unpick and undo the fabric of his entire life, which
- 41:34Speaker 8: was built on a facade.
- 41:37Speaker 7: In an extraordinary turn of tables, Shipman saved his cellmate's life.
- 41:42Speaker 18: That's all shared of being in a sold doctor Shipman.
- 41:45Speaker 18: Because of the reputation the rest of the prisoners used
- 41:48Speaker 18: to saying to me, that's not so, he's that doctor's
- 41:51Speaker 18: killed all patients. I mean ah, I was for your
- 41:56Speaker 18: life so much. I attempted to take me online himself
- 42:01Speaker 18: because I was that much scared. I mean, he put
- 42:04Speaker 18: me down and saying me But after that was seem
- 42:08Speaker 18: to get on pretty well. And he was so intent
- 42:11Speaker 18: on murder that was his pleasure. Why didn't he leave
- 42:15Speaker 18: me to die?
- 42:16Speaker 4: Shipman had a particular victim type with a method of
- 42:21Speaker 4: killing them that he was comfortable with in locations again,
- 42:27Speaker 4: either the victim's territory or somewhere where he was in control.
- 42:31Speaker 4: The guy he revived was most certainly not sick in
- 42:37Speaker 4: the clinical sense. He was not the preferred victim type
- 42:42Speaker 4: of Shipman, and I think Shipman probably did then the
- 42:47Speaker 4: only decent thing he'd ever did is becoming a doctor.
- 42:50Speaker 4: Instead of taking lives, he saved one.
- 42:53Speaker 18: I'm still confused because I can't understand as a man
- 43:00Speaker 18: such as Cherald at to me as a friend, ow
- 43:05Speaker 18: he could have gone about doing it all those people.
- 43:08Speaker 18: I mean, it's not something. I mean, it's not a
- 43:11Speaker 18: natural thing, is it to take human life?
- 43:14Speaker 7: To many of doctor Shipman's victims, his suicide is a
- 43:18Speaker 7: final betrayal. Not only did he kill their loved ones,
- 43:22Speaker 7: but he escaped the punishment of spending the rest of
- 43:24Speaker 7: his natural life in prison.
- 43:27Speaker 5: I think Fred planned his suicide. I think he knew
- 43:32Speaker 5: exactly what he was doing. I think he knew about
- 43:35Speaker 5: the fact that Primrose would be and actually better off
- 43:39Speaker 5: if he died before a certain age.
- 43:41Speaker 10: He made sure Primrose as well looked after.
- 43:43Speaker 11: And again he was winning the game and he was
- 43:46Speaker 11: beating the authorities. Not only that, he was taking his
- 43:50Speaker 11: secrets to the grave.
- 43:56Speaker 15: I think one of the main issues with regard to
- 43:57Speaker 15: hawlship was that he was a doctor. We all learn
- 44:00Speaker 15: from a very early age that doctors are to be trusted.
- 44:04Speaker 8: From the evidence we have, the question is was Harold
- 44:07Speaker 8: Shipman born to kill? When we look back at his
- 44:11Speaker 8: early life, we see a trait that seems to run
- 44:14Speaker 8: through That trait seems to make him objectify people, stops
- 44:18Speaker 8: him feeling the feelings of others in the way that
- 44:21Speaker 8: we do and call empathy. He also seems to have
- 44:24Speaker 8: prevented him from normal childhood development, to created a world
- 44:28Speaker 8: of fantasy, to actually have led and helped certain incidences
- 44:33Speaker 8: in his life where he adopted the role of a
- 44:36Speaker 8: gp of a trusted person who then went on to
- 44:40Speaker 8: kill people. Rather than prolong their lives. Yes, it would
- 44:44Speaker 8: seem that without that early characteristic, none of the other
- 44:48Speaker 8: events would have had sufficient impact to actually lead to
- 44:53Speaker 8: that line of behavior. Therefore, it would seem that Harold
- 44:57Speaker 8: Shipman was in fact born to kill.
- 45:02Speaker 5: How do I feel towards him now? Indifferent?
- 45:09Speaker 14: Mmm mm hmmm
- 45:28Speaker 15: Mm hmmm