Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 135: Olympic Fever, Tourism, & Better Travel with Paige McClanahan
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trimuta. After years of planning and a
- 0:14solid seven months of complaining, the Olympics have
- 0:17finally begun. Over their history, they've put
- 0:20some tourist destinations on the map, attempted to build unity
- 0:24and accelerate social and infrastructural change in host
- 0:27cities. Of course, not everyone
- 0:29benefits, and the legacy of the Olympics, including on tourism,
- 0:33is rather fraught. That's why I wanted to discuss
- 0:36both Paris 2024 and the broader issue of tourism, the good, the
- 0:40bad and the complicated. With someone who literally.
- 0:43Wrote the book on it. Paige Mcclanahan is a fellow
- 0:47travel journalist and the author of the new book The New Tourist,
- 0:50Waking Up to the Power and Perils of Travel.
- 0:55Based most of the time in Paris, she joins me today to dig into
- 0:57what makes travel such a big economic power, how it helps
- 1:01local communities, how it hurts them, and where Paris and the
- 1:04Olympics fall into the global tourism picture.
- 1:08And just a note, we recorded this conversation several hours
- 1:11before the Olympics opening ceremony before I saw just how
- 1:14triumphant and spectacular it would be.
- 1:17My comments on the value of such a spectacle still remain true,
- 1:21but as a piece of legacy art and entertainment, the team knocked
- 1:25it out of the park. And with that, on Eva.
- 1:32Hey, Paige, welcome to the show. Hey, Lindsay, thanks so much for
- 1:35having me. So your book, which I think
- 1:39comes at the perfect time, it comes in the perfect season as
- 1:42tourism is, you know, operating full throttle as it usually does
- 1:48during the summer in our in our hemisphere.
- 1:52And, and as we're recording this, we are the day of the
- 1:55opening ceremony for the Paris Olympics.
- 1:58And by the time this runs and people are listening to it,
- 2:01they're going to be immersed in Olympics events, you know,
- 2:05whether here on the ground or from afar, watching on
- 2:08television. And, and, and while your book
- 2:11does not speak specifically to tourism in Paris, it speaks to
- 2:15the broader issues of tourism. And Lord knows, Paris is a city
- 2:19that thrives and makes quite a lot of money on on tourism.
- 2:23And, and so I thought that through your research and your
- 2:26work and the timely events that we're seeing here, that would be
- 2:30a good time to have you talk about some of these things.
- 2:33Obviously, in Paris in the last week, we've been experiencing a
- 2:37lot of tensions. There's a lot of excitement and
- 2:40a lot of fanfare, but the security measures and
- 2:42limitations feel worse than during the first Covad lockdown
- 2:45and there's a lot of confusion. And it doesn't all come with a
- 2:48bag of positives. Let's just say that the sort of
- 2:50posting of these sorts of events.
- 2:51So anyway, that's that's the context.
- 2:53And the other thing I want to lay out for our listeners is
- 2:56that we're gonna do something a little bit different, which is
- 2:57I'm gonna ask you questions and you're going to ask me a few
- 3:00questions about the Olympics and and maybe about Paris.
- 3:03So it's really going to be a back and forth.
- 3:05Yeah, I'm excited for it. And you have your own podcast
- 3:08and have interviewed people about the broader travel space
- 3:13you've had me on. And so this is sort of, it's
- 3:16going to be a different kind of conversation and I'm excited for
- 3:18it. Yeah, Lindsay was the very first
- 3:20guest, the inaugural guest on my podcast, which I will be forever
- 3:24grateful to you, Lindsay, for, for doing that.
- 3:26I have to say that the podcast has been on hold for a little
- 3:29while now. When the sort of when crunch
- 3:31time came from my book manuscript, I had to sort of
- 3:34drop everything and focus on the book.
- 3:35So there are 36 episodes up and, you know, findable.
- 3:39You can listen to them online now.
- 3:41But yeah, it's kind of on hold at the moment.
- 3:44Well, it's always something you can pick back up.
- 3:46There's always as as you've done through your reporting as well
- 3:49for the New York Times, you know, there's always something
- 3:51new to report about the broader travel industry.
- 3:54And so I guess, yeah, I mean, constantly.
- 3:57In fact, you this morning were returning to Paris on a train,
- 4:01ATGV train, the only one that was not impacted by the attacks
- 4:07on the railways that we woke up to to hearing about.
- 4:10Exactly. Yeah.
- 4:10So I didn't even discover this until I was actually sitting on
- 4:13the train because it was like such a Sprint to get me and the
- 4:16kids and the cat like all together into the to the train
- 4:19station on time. And then I sit down the train
- 4:22and like, pull up my phone and I'm seeing these, you know, news
- 4:25updates about like attack, you know, coordinated attacks on,
- 4:29you know, major French TGB lines.
- 4:31And I'm what? What?
- 4:32But my train was exactly on time.
- 4:34So, yeah, of the four major sort of TGB arteries, all four were
- 4:38targeted. But like the attack on the the
- 4:40sudest line that I was on with my kids, it didn't like, it
- 4:45didn't sort of go off. It didn't.
- 4:46It didn't work. So we were spared and we made it
- 4:48to Paris. Exactly.
- 4:50Allah, thank goodness. And you were with the cat.
- 4:53I can't believe. That my cat was never allowed
- 4:57for a train ride. Never.
- 4:58Oh, it's she's getting a little bit more used to it now because
- 5:01so we lived in this little village in the French Alps for
- 5:03five years and just last summer at the end of August, moved to
- 5:07Paris. And so she had, you know, her
- 5:09first couple of years of life as a sort of a wild free animal in
- 5:13Otsevois and is adapted to, you know, city life here in Paris.
- 5:17But she enjoys going back and, you know, exploring her old sort
- 5:21of stomping grounds. But yeah, she's gotten used to
- 5:24the gotten used to the train ride a bit.
- 5:26She still makes a lot of noise though sometimes.
- 5:28Well, as as do all travelers, right?
- 5:30So she's just a a good little adventurer like her mom.
- 5:34So just to go to lay the groundwork about your book,
- 5:38which is called The New Tourist Waking up to the Power and
- 5:41Perils of Travel, your work essentially looks at the good,
- 5:45the bad and the complicated of global tourism.
- 5:47And there really is sort of a healthy dose, a healthy helping
- 5:50of all of those things. And it's an industry that you
- 5:53say has become humanity's most important means of conversation
- 5:57across cultures. And it seems so obvious.
- 5:59But I was struck by this observation that you included,
- 6:02which is that we can largely thank the influence of tourism
- 6:04and and the marketing behind destinations for some of the
- 6:07most commonly held associations that we have.
- 6:10You know, like a a little hula girl doll dancing on the
- 6:13dashboard of a car and that being tied to Hawaii in our
- 6:16minds and a flamenco dancer and Spain and the list goes on.
- 6:21What do you think is the impact though, of that kind of myth
- 6:25making? And is it something that happens
- 6:26quite quickly or does it take sort of years of trying to put
- 6:30someplace on the map? Yeah, I mean, I think it can
- 6:33take years and and it can really just stick in our imaginations.
- 6:37Like the two examples you just gave, which I, you know,
- 6:39mentioned in the book, like the hula girl in Hawaii.
- 6:41This was a really explicit choice of people who are
- 6:45promoting tourism in Hawaii starting from, like, the 1950s
- 6:48and 1960s because they were like, how do we get people to
- 6:52fly, you know, halfway across the Pacific Ocean to go to a
- 6:54beach when they can go to a beach in Mexico or the
- 6:56Caribbean? Let's choose, you know, a symbol
- 7:00that represents only Hawaii. What can you see or do
- 7:03experience in Hawaii that you can't do anywhere else in the
- 7:05world? And they very explicitly chose
- 7:07the hula girl. And this was like, a feature of
- 7:10their marketing. And they sent Native Hawaiians
- 7:12to kind of expose in North America to promote Hawaii
- 7:16tourism. And so this is a really
- 7:18deliberate choice. And it one, it's one that sort
- 7:20of echoes today with Hawaii tourism.
- 7:22But now you're seeing the Native Hawaiian community really kind
- 7:26of rising up and wanting to take back claim back the narrative
- 7:30about how tourism in Hawaii is, you know, the how this story is
- 7:33told and how, you know, Hawaii is sold to people coming from
- 7:36outside of the state. So I mean, I think that, you
- 7:38know, So what is the impact of this myth making?
- 7:41I mean, it can be really profound.
- 7:43I mean, tourism is the lens through which we understand
- 7:47other cultures. And, you know, in 2024, we're
- 7:49going to have 1.5 billion international tourist arrivals,
- 7:53so more people than ever crossing an international
- 7:56border. We're going to break the record
- 7:57set in 2019. So the impact of this on a
- 8:02global scale is just huge. And I think it's why I encourage
- 8:07people in the book and just in life in general to wherever
- 8:10you're going, the importance of seeking out narratives that are
- 8:13other than the ones that you get from the, you know, through the
- 8:15marketing. And it's, you know, it's not the
- 8:17most obvious thing. It's maybe not going to show up
- 8:19on the first page of your Google search or whatever.
- 8:21But like there's such a richness to going to whether it's a major
- 8:25European city or a place like Hawaii or even, you know, a city
- 8:28in your your home state and looking for other voices, other
- 8:32narratives and sort of traveling with the with a view to having
- 8:36your mind change or your sort of perspective shifted about the
- 8:39place that you're visiting. But to switch it back to you,
- 8:42Lindsay, I mean, I think Paris is probably one of the most
- 8:44mythologized cities in the world.
- 8:47I what I love about your work, you know, your journalism, your
- 8:50podcast, your books, is that you really, it seems like one of
- 8:54your major goals is to pick apart this myth of Paris.
- 8:57But I mean, it's a pretty solid myth that we have here in this
- 9:01city. Yeah, it's it's it's really a
- 9:03question of working to about understanding where the myth
- 9:07comes from and how many generations deep it runs and and
- 9:12where are associations come from.
- 9:14And if you look back at, you know, the 18th century, which
- 9:19is, which is primarily when Paris was really the global
- 9:22leader in all matters of culture and gastronomy, you, you start
- 9:27to see where, where the reputation really grows and gets
- 9:31more powerful and then how that gets exported.
- 9:34And I think Paris is one of the, the few examples of a city that
- 9:38has managed to sort of maintain its reputation.
- 9:42There have been ups and downs, obviously, but that hasn't
- 9:44necessarily slowed tourism in any massive way.
- 9:48And the myth is is a deep part of what keeps it alive.
- 9:50And certainly, as you talk about in the book, the role of
- 9:53government and the and the role of, you know, the powers that be
- 9:57in shaping the narrative that they try to put forward about
- 10:01their destination. I mean, Paris is that's the
- 10:03whole reason they're hosting the Olympics right now.
- 10:05I mean, it's not to put Paris on the map as a tourist
- 10:08destination. It already is.
- 10:09So it's like, what else is this meant to do?
- 10:12And in this case, I think it really tries to shore up the
- 10:15soft power of, of not only Paris, but of, of France.
- 10:19And so it's endlessly appealing. There's a lot of money that goes
- 10:23into promoting the destination from all facets.
- 10:26And I think it's, it's, it's almost hard to compare Paris to
- 10:30some of the other cities. I think that you looked at,
- 10:31although Hawaii is a very interesting one because of the
- 10:35indigenous culture that is at risk and and also, you know,
- 10:40very much in conflict, I think with the travel industry and
- 10:44understandably so. But you get this sense that
- 10:47people are not always willing to do things differently when
- 10:50they're traveling to these destinations because they have
- 10:53something in their mind about what they want to experience and
- 10:55what has been promised to them through all these stories.
- 10:59And then what that needs to translate to on the ground in
- 11:04order to fill fulfill the fantasy.
- 11:05So they're all these competing elements and and yet we're still
- 11:09in a time when we need to be very mindful about the the
- 11:12impact of our travel, whether that's on the environment or all
- 11:15in local communities or, or just simply what is it doing to a
- 11:19place that we continue to go in and experience it the way we
- 11:23might have done 20 years ago. Just thinking about the, the
- 11:27myth making and, and the sort of the gap between maybe our
- 11:30tourist kind of projections or maybe fantasies about the place
- 11:33and the reality isn't there. The Paris syndrome.
- 11:36Isn't there a word for this? Like in Paris particularly,
- 11:39where is the this idea that people come to Paris and they're
- 11:43so disappointed that they actually fall physically like
- 11:46I'll is this, is this for real? Yeah, it's, it's it's usually
- 11:50sort of a psychological distress.
- 11:52And it typically happens with Japanese tourists.
- 11:56And that will tell you also, I mean, not that I'm on the ground
- 11:58there, but from what I understand from some
- 11:59journalists, Japanese correspondents that I've spoken
- 12:02to who are based in Paris, the way that the city is depicted,
- 12:06certainly abroad or at least in in Japan specifically, is very
- 12:11romantic. It's very much built around the
- 12:13fantasy. They love savoir faire.
- 12:16They want to know about these long traditions that have
- 12:19existed around certain crafts. And so they probably tame or, or
- 12:25tone down the stories about some of the real issues that are
- 12:29plaguing Parisian society. And, and So what happens is
- 12:32there's this disconnect when you get on the ground.
- 12:34And some of that is surprising, whether it's rudeness or filth
- 12:38or some sort of catastrophe. I think there really is an
- 12:41issue, a dissonance between, you know, expectation and reality
- 12:46and where the tourists should find themselves in that
- 12:50spectrum. I don't know, like how often it
- 12:53comes up today, but the Paris syndrome is a real phenomenon.
- 12:56And and how interesting that, you know, the word Paris has is
- 13:00attached to that syndrome because, you know, I'm sure
- 13:03tourists have similar reactions at many tours make in front of
- 13:06like, you know, the pyramids, the great pyramids or in front
- 13:09of Mount Fuji or I don't know where their their expectation is
- 13:14not met by reality. But Paris, the perhaps the
- 13:18world's most mythologized city, is the place that that got the
- 13:21name attached to it. That's an amazing point.
- 13:24And I think it relates also to the way that we mythologize
- 13:27Paris in a way that we don't even really mythologize parts of
- 13:31Italy. I mean, there Italy is like the
- 13:33often the the other destination, other country that I like to
- 13:37compare to because I think there is sort of a similar
- 13:39fascination, particularly among Western travelers.
- 13:42But, you know, you don't hear the same kinds of stories about
- 13:45Rome or even Florence the way you do about Paris and not its
- 13:49people either. I mean, that's why I wrote a
- 13:50book about women, because the Parisian women are sort of on
- 13:54another level and have another role in place branding.
- 13:58If we're going to look at, you know, sort of the, the.
- 13:59Marketing of a place isn't that fascinating?
- 14:01Yeah, then, then, then Italian women I think would you know,
- 14:05and I don't know that we make the same distinctions.
- 14:08I don't think we have the same images anyway.
- 14:10So I mean, it, it, it's really quite fascinating.
- 14:13And Paris is this beast. I mean, that's why it continues
- 14:15to sell magazines and books. And it's like the never ending
- 14:19gift, I guess, for the media. But that's where we get into
- 14:22dangerous territory. As you know, we both write for
- 14:26newspapers and magazines and we're both often asked to look
- 14:30into stories. And sometimes, and I don't know
- 14:32if this has happened to you, but look into stories that seem like
- 14:34we're just sort of repeating things that have already been
- 14:38said and done and that don't help go deeper, don't help the
- 14:42traveler go deeper. And so I try to reject doing a
- 14:44lot of that kind of work because if it doesn't allow me to at
- 14:47least uphold my goal of trying to help people experience
- 14:52something better here, then it's just, you know, perpetuating the
- 14:54same issues. Yeah, interesting.
- 14:57I mean, I've experienced that tension, but because, you know,
- 15:00I haven't focused on one particular place in my writing,
- 15:03I haven't gotten it so much about like one place.
- 15:05But I, you know, have gotten. It's like, OK, well, it's a fine
- 15:08line to walk, right? Are we sort of going out and
- 15:11creating a story or like following a story or actually
- 15:15reporting something that's that's actually happening?
- 15:17I mean, it's, it's a very fine balance.
- 15:19And usually it's, it's somewhere in between all of those.
- 15:21But but really tricky and, and especially for you as somebody
- 15:24who identifies so closely and is identified so closely with
- 15:27Paris, that's a big, that's a big responsibility to to carry.
- 15:32Yeah, And I also think in some ways it does not that it does me
- 15:36a disservice, but it makes it very difficult for me to just
- 15:39like close my eyes to some of the ills in writing that I see,
- 15:43you know, that get published where you're just like, why are
- 15:45we doing this? What is the, who is this
- 15:47helping? You know, is this is this
- 15:49appropriate journalism? You know?
- 15:50But we see that in all, you know, fashion.
- 15:53You see it across subjects. And the Olympics is another, you
- 15:57know, is another moment where I am now finally starting to see
- 16:02more stories that are in the run up when they know people are
- 16:05going to be very excited about it are a little bit more
- 16:09nuanced. But some of the stuff that I
- 16:11wanted to write was like not now, not now or I think it was
- 16:15no one really wanted to. I don't know whether it's take a
- 16:18risk or go up against the IOC or I don't know.
- 16:21But that that leads me to want to talk about something you also
- 16:23included in the book, which was a look at Barcelona, which is
- 16:28sort of the ultimate case study that I think that is is often
- 16:31trotted out about the Olympics as a, at least at a first
- 16:34glance, a net positive experience for tourism.
- 16:38And that was in 1992. And you sort of layout in in
- 16:43Chapter 4 what Barcelona was like before and then what
- 16:47happened after. Can you talk about what happened
- 16:50there and why the positive effects of their hosting was
- 16:54somewhat short lived? Yeah, I think the Barcelona
- 16:57example is really interesting. Barcelona, before the Summer
- 17:01Olympics of 1992, it was an industrial port city that had
- 17:05been on the decline for a long time.
- 17:07And it wasn't really on, you know, anybody sort of top ten
- 17:10list of things to do as a tourist in Europe.
- 17:13Leaders in Barcelona really saw, you know, they got the Olympics
- 17:16and they saw this as an opportunity to reinvigorate the
- 17:19city's economy by turning to this aspect of the service
- 17:23sector, by turning to tourism. And they spent a huge amount of
- 17:26money to beautify the city. And they created a beach.
- 17:29They shipped in sand from Egypt to create this beach, you know,
- 17:33along the city's coastline that didn't exist before, which still
- 17:36exists today. And in a lot of ways, the
- 17:38residents of Barcelona benefited from these things.
- 17:40You know, they got nice parks. They got sort of newer culture,
- 17:43sort of refreshed cultural institutions.
- 17:46The whole area around Barcelona, the most weak area was, was
- 17:49revitalized. So in in a lot of ways, the city
- 17:52benefited from this. And then after the Olympics, the
- 17:55city continued to embrace tourism and continued to market
- 17:58tourism really heavily because they wanted to grow this part of
- 18:01the economy. They continued to do so all the
- 18:04way up until 2015 with the election of ETA Kalau as the
- 18:08city's mayor then. So over that time they there was
- 18:11a huge push on tourism in Barcelona.
- 18:13And at the same time there wasn't nearly as much sort of
- 18:16regulation or new tax policies or new laws governing tourism
- 18:21that, you know, they needed to put in place to make sure that
- 18:25all of these new tourists didn't negatively impact the quality of
- 18:28life of the people who lived in Barcelona.
- 18:30And so already by 2013, we started to see the first kind of
- 18:34tourism protests or tourism demonstrations, anti tourism
- 18:37demonstrations in Barcelona. And of course, we saw this again
- 18:40in the news this summer, right, with some anti tourism
- 18:42protesters spraying tourists with water guns at cafes in
- 18:46Barcelona. So I think it's it's a really,
- 18:49you know, it's a cautionary tale, right?
- 18:51And it's a tale that of tourism can revive a place, it can bring
- 18:55new life. It can, you know, invigorate an
- 18:58economy. And at the same time, the
- 19:00government needs to make sure it's prioritized rising the
- 19:02quality of life of its residents, that it's, you know,
- 19:05that it's regulating sort of ahead of the curve and that it's
- 19:08just making sure that this tourism is going to happen in a
- 19:11way that doesn't negatively impact its residents.
- 19:13And in Barcelona, you know, it's we see the housing market being
- 19:16affected. But the most sort of visible and
- 19:20striking effect that I saw in going there and in touring
- 19:23Barcelona with this wonderful city planner and, you know,
- 19:26architect who who took me around Mar is, is how just seeing how
- 19:31the sort of the very fabric of the city has has shifted.
- 19:34So it's really the city center, the historic center, Barcelona
- 19:37is really caters to tourists now and not to residents.
- 19:41A lot of lessons there. But I think what we're seeing
- 19:44with Paris and the Olympics now, I mean it's so different in so
- 19:47many ways. Like you said, Paris is already
- 19:50well, you know, at the top of many people's to do lists as
- 19:54tourists and the cities economy is isn't a very different place.
- 19:57So I will be really curious to see how the, you know, these
- 20:01Olympics, the 2024 Olympics play out for Paris.
- 20:04And I would be curious to hear your thoughts on that.
- 20:06I mean, do you see they're not building really big new
- 20:10infrastructure in Paris like they did in in Barcelona, But
- 20:13like, do you think? These Olympics will have lasting
- 20:16impacts on the city. Or do you think this will be
- 20:18kind of like a big kerfuffle When summer Parisians got
- 20:22annoyed and left the city, there were a lot of police officers
- 20:24for a while, and then it it came and went and everybody kind of
- 20:27forgot about it. What do you think?
- 20:29Very good question. So I did a lot of reporting
- 20:32around what makes this Olympics different.
- 20:35And it's true that on the one hand, there have been so many
- 20:38cities that have dropped out of bidding wars to try to, you
- 20:43know, host the Olympics, that the way Paris won was very
- 20:48different than it had operated in the past.
- 20:49So it was basically between Paris and Los Angeles, and then
- 20:52Paris won this one and Los Angeles won the next one, and it
- 20:55was really just between those two.
- 20:57That alone was different. And they knew right from having
- 21:00seen Rio that they were going to need elements of of the
- 21:04organization of the actual event to incorporate sustainability in
- 21:08a big way, not just like a, OK, we're going to have less single
- 21:12use plastic. No, like it really needed to be
- 21:13part of the conception of the whole thing.
- 21:16Now, how that plays out is obviously more complicated than
- 21:19the story, but certainly there the hope is that it is less
- 21:23disruptive because there are not that many new structures that
- 21:27are being site specific structures.
- 21:29So the only site specific new build in Paris is at Port de de
- 21:33Chapel. It is now called the Adidas
- 21:35Arena. Also missed opportunity to name
- 21:37it after an important figure for that neighborhood.
- 21:40But they did not do that. There's a new build in Saint
- 21:43Duni, the Aquatic Center, and then you also have the Olympic
- 21:46Village. And those two structures are
- 21:48really meant to transform St. St.
- 21:51Duni. So we're calling this the Paris
- 21:52Olympic, but really this is greater Paris and then all of
- 21:55France because there are other cities that are involved as
- 21:57well. So in terms of new builds, I
- 21:59mean, construction represents the second biggest pollutant
- 22:04when we're looking at the overall impact of of games like
- 22:07this. But the number one is incoming
- 22:10travel from around the world. So you're talking about people
- 22:14flying in from all corners of the globe.
- 22:17You know, maybe there's some trains in there, but like mostly
- 22:19we're talking about people flying in, and that is the
- 22:21biggest impact. So it's really great to have
- 22:23done all these things, but you still have all these bodies
- 22:26coming in. And then I'd say what I feel
- 22:29very concerned about is the repeated issues, the ones that
- 22:33we see time and again with Olympics, regardless of how the
- 22:37actual event itself is organized, it always seems to
- 22:41involve displacing people. It always seems to involve some
- 22:45sort of security measure that is harmful to people's everyday
- 22:49lives. And harmful in the sense that,
- 22:51you know, for someone who just like has to walk a little bit
- 22:54further to get to the the metro or to to reach their home
- 22:57because of, you know, security barriers, that's one thing.
- 23:00But we're also talking about people who might need at home
- 23:03care from nurses who were badly disrupted by by these measures
- 23:08that were not properly communicated in advance.
- 23:12You know, they talk about, yes, we will have these security
- 23:14zones and their high security leading up to the opening
- 23:16ceremony. But no one really understood,
- 23:19including some of the police you speak to who are like stationed
- 23:23at checkpoints. Not everyone knew exactly how it
- 23:26was going to unfold. So that means businesses didn't
- 23:28know. And a friend of mine, her
- 23:30mother-in-law had knee surgery just before these security
- 23:34barriers went up. She lives near Toca Deol.
- 23:37She still has to go see a doctor and get care.
- 23:39I mean, it's an absolute nightmare.
- 23:41And I'm sorry. Like, who is this for?
- 23:43This is just so that France, again, can nurture its soft
- 23:48power look we're talking about and be able to say they were the
- 23:51first to host the opening ceremony outside of a stadium.
- 23:54This would not be the same issue if this were being held at the
- 23:57Sted de France. They're used to getting people
- 23:59in and out of that stadium, but that's not what they're doing.
- 24:01Well, just just to just to like interject quickly.
- 24:04I mean, I love your point about soft power and the this Olympics
- 24:07and the the fact that they chose to hold not only the opening
- 24:10ceremony on the send, but also so many of the sites are right,
- 24:13like, you know, the place de la conquer, like in front of the
- 24:16Eiffel Tower. You know, this is really putting
- 24:19the city on display. And like that was a strategic
- 24:23choice that feels so political in so many ways.
- 24:27It's really just like, look at, look at us, Paris.
- 24:30Like here we are really showing off.
- 24:33Yeah, yeah, it's, it's showing off.
- 24:35And like, I don't blame them for wanting to use what they have in
- 24:39the city. Like, obviously someone watching
- 24:42from afar wants to see the Eiffel Tower.
- 24:44OK, get it? And it is quite spectacular when
- 24:46you see the juxtaposition of the the beach volleyball set up
- 24:51right in front of the Eiffel Tower or the skateboarding at
- 24:55Concorde. Like it is astounding as someone
- 24:57who lives here to see her home transform, like, yeah, it's
- 25:01super cool, but what are the pros and cons?
- 25:04And like, who does it harm? And, you know, people who are
- 25:07really super supportive of the Olympics are like, look, it's
- 25:10only a couple of weeks, Like just get over it.
- 25:12But it's not just a couple of weeks because the amount of time
- 25:15that it takes to build these structures, even though they're
- 25:18temporary, the amount of people it mobilizes, these are colossal
- 25:24investments. The send cleanup.
- 25:26Yes, that is that is something that like, yes, the Olympics was
- 25:29a good goal, a good objective, and it is something that has
- 25:33been tried time and time again, right.
- 25:36So the sort of the broader purpose of Ascend cleanup goes
- 25:40far beyond the Olympics. But pushing to get it done now,
- 25:44you know, trying to race against the clock to do all these
- 25:46things, trying to rally funds, you know, a mix of public and
- 25:51private funds in this case, for all of the event, all of the
- 25:54structures and, and to pull all of it off.
- 25:57You know, you're sort of like, wouldn't it be nice if our
- 25:59political parties could just agree separate from a mega event
- 26:04to be able to fund projects, you know, like the Grand Paris
- 26:07Express, which is delayed and you know, the metro extensions
- 26:11and whatever. Like why does it require an
- 26:13event like this? Yeah, that's a really good
- 26:15point. And I'm, I'm having so many
- 26:18flashbacks now in the the run up to these Olympics, to the summer
- 26:22of 2012. I was actually in London that
- 26:24summer and I remember Brits were so like, Oh my God, oh, it's
- 26:30going to be awful. The weather's going to be
- 26:31terrible, the traffic's going to be awful.
- 26:34And, and I guess it wasn't so much in the middle of the city
- 26:37as as Paris was, but just the sort of general attitude toward
- 26:40the, you know, kind of sports and, and the city was, was
- 26:44pretty down. And then it ended up, I mean,
- 26:45Britain had a wonderful year in terms of medals or a wonderful
- 26:49sort of Olympics in terms of the medals.
- 26:51And, and it was really, it turned into a moment of bringing
- 26:54people together and this sort of the positive Olympic spirit that
- 26:56you, that you hear about and that we hear French politicians
- 26:59saying we should be looking forward to.
- 27:02And I remember noticing that transformation and really seeing
- 27:04it and feeling it in London in the summer of 2012.
- 27:07And now I'm like, are we going to have the same transformation
- 27:10in Paris? I feel like the French and
- 27:12Parisians are just somewhat less, there's somewhat, you
- 27:15know, more skeptical in general. And I, I wonder if there's going
- 27:18to be an uptick in in mood, but I think a lot of it, like you're
- 27:24saying, will come down to the actual day-to-day impacts on the
- 27:28lives of people who live here in Paris.
- 27:29And if it's if it's too much, if it's too extreme, if people are
- 27:33really, really deeply inconvenienced or or worse, you
- 27:36know, actually sort of harmed by this, then then yeah, that will
- 27:39be the story that we're talking about, you know, 1520, thirty
- 27:43years from now. So we'll see how they do.
- 27:46And also, as, as you reported about Barcelona, the what the
- 27:51IOC calls legacy, right? This is now a word that they've
- 27:54really adopted into their vernacular to talk about the
- 27:57long lasting effects of the Olympics that won't be known for
- 28:01many, many, many years. I mean, there will be some
- 28:03immediate metrics we can look at.
- 28:05You know, once the athletes have left the Olympic Village,
- 28:08they're going to be converted into these apartments, some of
- 28:11which are for social housing, You know, how quickly people are
- 28:14able to access these spaces, what the Olympic Village looks
- 28:17like in a year's time, in a year and a half.
- 28:20But, you know, we have to wait and see.
- 28:23And in my research, I had come across some pretty interesting
- 28:27Economic Research that showed that with the exception of
- 28:31again, like a couple of cities, perhaps Barcelona being one of
- 28:34them, there is 0 short term or even middle, mid, mid term
- 28:40economic benefit to hosting the Olympics.
- 28:43So you're, you're talking about also mobilizing a lot of tax
- 28:46money in some cases, like I don't think our taxes are paying
- 28:49for most of the creation of the structures because they actually
- 28:52went with a lot of private funds for, for Paris.
- 28:56But the security that's mobilized for this, the way the,
- 28:59the city, certain city changes, that is all our, our tax
- 29:04dollars. So, you know, I, I wonder, I
- 29:07think Mayor Hidalgo is, is in some cases someone who straddles
- 29:12the line quite well between like what needs to be done to improve
- 29:15the lives of Parisians. I mean, look at all the bike
- 29:18lanes. She comes short in some aspects.
- 29:21And her and her team, I think come short because, you know,
- 29:25there's a, there's a lack of education in, in proper biking
- 29:28etiquette. And, you know, people are not
- 29:29stopped. You know, there should that we
- 29:31should have police on bikes finding people who aren't
- 29:34following the rules. Like there should be other.
- 29:36This needs to go like a step or two further.
- 29:38But for the most part, you know, giving the river and giving the
- 29:41road back to citizens and not vehicles, I think is is
- 29:44something that puts us first. But then you have an event like
- 29:48this and you have other things that the city has hosted where
- 29:51you're just like, who is this for?
- 29:52Because we're not even welcome. Yeah, and you made a really
- 29:55interesting point before that actually, you know, in competing
- 29:58to host, you know, and making a bid to host this year's Olympics
- 30:01and the 2028 Olympics. It was only it came down to
- 30:04Paris and Los Angeles. And I think there were
- 30:06originally 6 cities, I'm forgetting maybe Hamburg.
- 30:09They were originally six and four all but, you know, all but
- 30:13two. Paris and LA were the only two
- 30:14that didn't drop out. And I I think, you know, the the
- 30:17other cities just didn't have the sort of local support they
- 30:20needed to put forward a compelling bid.
- 30:23So, you know, that wasn't the case 20 or 30 years ago with,
- 30:27you know, cities bidding for the Olympics.
- 30:29I remember really heated competitions among cities.
- 30:31So I think more and more cities are kind of waking up to the
- 30:34fact that actually this is this is a headache and our residents
- 30:38might not be happy about it. So it will be really interesting
- 30:42to hear. Yeah.
- 30:42Boston was one of them. That's right.
- 30:44Yeah, Boston and there were there were activists that
- 30:46basically basically, you know, shut the whole thing down.
- 30:50You know, the power of the local community is quite is quite big.
- 30:53And also bidding cost a lot of money.
- 30:57And so they're also did the IO CS also changing that process.
- 31:00So there's not this let's fund these projects just to sell the
- 31:04thing and then, you know, you don't win and that money just
- 31:07disappear. You just spent all this money on
- 31:08basically like a proposal essentially that is being done
- 31:12away with. But there's certain, you know,
- 31:14there's certain other aspects like should we really be hosting
- 31:18people coming from all corners of the globe in today's
- 31:21environment, in today's ecological state?
- 31:26Again, that's a that's a broader conversation.
- 31:30I did want to ask you though, because you're talking about who
- 31:33is this for? And when these cities and
- 31:35destinations are spending money on bringing in tourists, the
- 31:38question is how do there's this idea that tourists should behave
- 31:45better, right? And there are a lot of articles
- 31:47and stories about individuals need to know how to be more
- 31:51respectful when they travel. But you seem to argue that it's
- 31:53not just on the tourists to shape what happens, but also the
- 31:58local governments and managing tourism properly.
- 32:00Earlier you talked about, you know, Barcelona not having
- 32:03enough regulation or not having the foresight to include taxes
- 32:08and, and, and better control and also regulating and creating
- 32:12infrastructure to accommodate an influx of new, of new travelers.
- 32:16And, you know, so like, who is this benefiting?
- 32:18Are there other examples you think where this needs to be
- 32:22done in a more considered way, like other cities that you came
- 32:25across in your research, where you feel like there's a we're at
- 32:29a breaking point and something needs to be done to sort of fix
- 32:34what tourism looks like? Yeah, I, I think of a couple of
- 32:37examples, but yeah, just to go back to your point, I mean, I
- 32:40think, you know, in the media we see these headlines about
- 32:43misbehaving tourists. And I think, and those are
- 32:45important, right? It's really important that we
- 32:47call, you know, attention to people who are doing things that
- 32:50they ought not to do. But the the risk is that, you
- 32:53know, we tourists who sort of tend to follow the rules that we
- 32:57see those people who make the headlines as the, the owners of
- 33:01the problems with tourism. And we sort of don't think to
- 33:04kind of look at ourselves as well.
- 33:06But yeah. So I think that the onus of
- 33:08making sure that tourism functions well and functions
- 33:11sustainably does lie with tourists to some extent.
- 33:15But I think it also really, and even more so in a lot of cases,
- 33:19lies with with the governments. And this is a story that I think
- 33:22that we in journalism and travel media more broadly really need
- 33:26to get better about telling because that misbehaving tourist
- 33:29makes a headline. But you know, the government
- 33:31that failed to implement attacks 10 years ago, that's kind of
- 33:35less of a clickable headline, right?
- 33:38So have a few examples. I mean, in Amsterdam they are
- 33:42like, this is one of the, I would say, you know, a really
- 33:45positive example in some ways of a place that has experienced
- 33:49really major problems with tourism.
- 33:51But where we're, where we're seeing the government being
- 33:53incredibly proactive in managing tourism in the city.
- 33:58And at just a year ago, the tourist tax in Amsterdam, like
- 34:01the hotel tax in Amsterdam was at 7%, which was already one of
- 34:04the highest tourist taxes in Europe.
- 34:06And as of January 1st of this year, it, it's gone up to 12,
- 34:09it's either 12 or 12.5%. So they're really actively
- 34:13working. And I for the New York Times, I
- 34:16interviewed the city's deputy mayor last year and she told me
- 34:19how they're really working to take the money that they that
- 34:23they earn through the, the tourism tax and distribute that
- 34:26to people who live sort of on the outskirts of Amsterdam to,
- 34:29to build parks and like clean up the city in areas where tourists
- 34:33will never go. So a way to make sure that
- 34:35actually tourism contributes to the quality of life of everyone
- 34:38who works in Amsterdam, not just those who actually earn their
- 34:40income by in, you know, interacting with tourists in
- 34:43some way. So I think Amsterdam is, you
- 34:46know, they have a lot of challenges there, but they're
- 34:48really being proactive. So I, this is one example that I
- 34:51write about in the book, but another, you know, I think
- 34:54Hawaii is really a place that's very dear to my heart.
- 34:58And my sister has lived in Hawaii since 2003.
- 35:00So I've been there a lot over the years.
- 35:02And it's been interesting to see how tourism sort of has evolved
- 35:05and resident sentiment toward tourism has evolved since then.
- 35:09And that's a place that really I think is, I mean, breaking point
- 35:12is a strong word, but it's, it's a place where the tensions are
- 35:14continuing to rise. And they're, they're really
- 35:17working hard to find a new way forward for tourism in Hawaii.
- 35:22And a lot of this is coming through sort of Native Hawaiian
- 35:25voices coming more to the fore and they're really coming up
- 35:29with ways to include resident voices and the active management
- 35:34of specific sort of tourist hotspots on the different
- 35:37islands and on the different Hawaiian islands.
- 35:39So I think Hawaii is a place where, you know, the challenges
- 35:42have grown so much that the government has been forced to
- 35:45respond as an Amsterdam. And my hope is that the tourist
- 35:48destinations that are kind of up and coming because there's so
- 35:51many places that would love to see more tourists, right, and
- 35:54that are working really hard to promote tourism.
- 35:56I really hope that they are keeping an eye on the Amsterdams
- 36:00and the Hawaii's of this world and learning and Barcelona's of
- 36:02this world too, and learning from their mistakes and watching
- 36:06the the policies that they're coming up with now, you know, a
- 36:09little bit after the fact, but a place like Copenhagen, for
- 36:12instance, I mean, this story got some play just a couple of weeks
- 36:14ago. They're come up with positive
- 36:16incentives for tourist behavior. So, you know, if you do
- 36:19something, you know, you can earn free meals or concert
- 36:22tickets or something if you like ride your bike to the place or
- 36:24something. It's, you know, finding ways to
- 36:27incentivize positive tourist behavior.
- 36:28So I think that there are a lot of solutions out there and I
- 36:31hope that people who who work in government can implement these.
- 36:34And I hope that tourists are paying attention too, and taking
- 36:37the time to educate themselves about the challenges of tourism
- 36:39in a place before they visit so they can make sure that they
- 36:41don't contribute to a problem. Well, I feel like the next step
- 36:45is also for them to everyone who allows cruise ships to come in
- 36:50to, to curb those. I mean, I was in Lisbon for a
- 36:53couple of days a few weeks ago and I mean, it's just shocking,
- 36:57it's ugly, it's disruptive, it's polluting.
- 37:01I just why are we even allowing these monster ships to, to
- 37:05cruise the, the seas? I don't, I just physically don't
- 37:08understand. And you know, a city like Venice
- 37:10with their attempt at the, the city tax and coming in and out,
- 37:13which was kind of bogus. I mean, 5 euros is not is not
- 37:18discouraging enough, you know, And so actually there was an
- 37:21interesting piece in the Times also about that, where it was
- 37:24like the mayor was like, no, no, it's great.
- 37:26We brought in a lot of money. It's like, yeah, that means that
- 37:29it wasn't an incentive enough for people to not come just for
- 37:33the day. It's not, you know, it's not
- 37:35prohibitive. And that's like, you know, in
- 37:37Amsterdam, they told me that too.
- 37:39Like when I was seeing, they were talking about when I was
- 37:41there last year, they were talking about raising the, the
- 37:43tourist tax, but they hadn't done it yet.
- 37:44And they're like, listen, our our studies show that tourists
- 37:48are incredibly price inelastic. Like they will keep paying.
- 37:52They're not. It's you have to increase the
- 37:54tax, but it was like, I forget how much, but like a huge amount
- 37:57before you actually see a drop in numbers.
- 37:59So what fees and taxes are really good at doing, They're
- 38:02really good at raising revenue. They're not so good at
- 38:04discouraging people from coming. So it depends on what your goal
- 38:08is. Is your goal to raise revenue to
- 38:10build new parks in poorer parts of Amsterdam?
- 38:12OK, Is it to lower the numbers? It might do that a little bit,
- 38:16but you're going to need to do something else on top of the tax
- 38:20to bring numbers down. And I think the Venice example
- 38:22is interesting. I've heard some really varied
- 38:24perspectives on that new sort of the day tripper fee.
- 38:28It'll be interesting to, I haven't been to Venice to see
- 38:31this sort of an action. It'll be interesting to see what
- 38:33kind of effect it has in the end.
- 38:36Well, it looks like after a year they may re evaluate and not
- 38:40necessarily re implement because clearly it didn't do what they,
- 38:44at least on paper said it was going to do.
- 38:47But before we close, I want to make sure to talk to you about
- 38:51something, which is what you describe in the book as sort of
- 38:55a, a new paradigm shift for for the tourist.
- 38:58You have the old tourist and the new tourist.
- 39:00And I'm, I, I like that you sort of admit in the book that you
- 39:05are probably yourself somewhere in the middle.
- 39:08And it's like a sliding scale, right?
- 39:09Like sometimes you probably lean a little bit more old school and
- 39:12then sometimes you're, you know, but what are each of those
- 39:15categories or sort of traits? And if you had to encourage
- 39:20listeners to be more like the new tourist, what would that
- 39:24entail? What can?
- 39:25They do. Thank you.
- 39:26So yeah, I have to say, like the idea for this kind of sliding
- 39:29scale really originated in June 2023.
- 39:33So just every year it came to me like kind of in a flash and
- 39:36reading this essay by Agnes Caller that was published in The
- 39:39New Yorker called The Case Against Travel.
- 39:41And I remember seeing this like headline pop up on my phone and
- 39:44being like, oh, God, because I knew her like name and I
- 39:49respected her writing. And I was like, oh, coming from
- 39:51her, this is going to be, this is going to, this is going to
- 39:53hurt. You know, I really appreciate
- 39:56that essay. And she because she like wrote
- 39:59this beautiful, I think, and very helpful definition of what
- 40:03I consider to be the old tourists, like the wrong
- 40:06approach to tourism or an old approach to tourism that we want
- 40:09to move away from. And she describes in this essay,
- 40:12she describes tourists as unchanged changers.
- 40:15And, and for Calor, this is like, you know, all tourists
- 40:18fall into this category. And she says the unchanged
- 40:21changer is somebody who goes to a place, inflicts their presence
- 40:24on. And comes away completely
- 40:26unmoved by the experience. And I was like, yeah, I mean,
- 40:29how many of us have done that? Like, I'm raising my hand, you
- 40:32know, like, I've been there, I've done that.
- 40:34I've like ticked the box, right, But have I done something more
- 40:37profound as a tourist? You know, have I been moved to,
- 40:40have I tried to contribute to the place in a positive way?
- 40:44Have I taken my the time to learn about the place?
- 40:45Yeah, yeah, yeah, I can. I can do better.
- 40:48And so I kind of used her definition of the tour of of the
- 40:52tourist as an unchanged changer, as my sort of old tourist.
- 40:56And this is a consumer who sees themselves as superior, who to
- 40:59go back to our myth making discussion, who takes as a given
- 41:04the sort of the narratives that they're fed through the
- 41:05marketing and doesn't question or go below that.
- 41:08And then at the end of the other end of the spectrum, we have a
- 41:11very different approach to tourism.
- 41:13And this is, I like to think of the new tourist as a changed and
- 41:17enlightened changer. So a changed changer.
- 41:20So they go and they they take the time.
- 41:22First of all, they're enlightened.
- 41:23They take the time to educate themselves about the place and
- 41:27the challenges it's experiencing.
- 41:28And they open themselves up to be changed while they're
- 41:32traveling. They're, you know, they see
- 41:33themselves as on the same plane as the, you know, they're not
- 41:36superior to the, the people or the place they're visiting.
- 41:39They're traveling with a huge amount of curiosity, with a
- 41:42level of humility and with, you know, just a real goal of
- 41:46creating sort of authentic human connection with people they're
- 41:50meeting in the place they're they're visiting.
- 41:52So I think, you know, this is a type of tourism that we can all
- 41:56aspire to. And it's, I don't think I think
- 42:00it's really a win win. I think it's it's good for the
- 42:03people who live in tourist destinations.
- 42:04It's good for the physical, you know, environment and it's good
- 42:08for for us as tourists, like we come away with, you know, the
- 42:11most beautiful gift that you can get from travel, as, you know,
- 42:14the great Rick Steves likes, likes to say is a changed
- 42:17perspective. And I think this is like, so
- 42:19having this new approach to tourism, I hope no one would see
- 42:22as sort of a homework assignment.
- 42:23But really it's just, you know, might require a little bit more
- 42:26investment, but it's going to pay off in a really beautiful
- 42:29and rewarding way in the end. So I guess the bonus question
- 42:33for you is have you so far and you're not a tourist because you
- 42:36do live here, but are you, have you found yourself changed?
- 42:39By Paris, absolutely. And I should say, I mean, of
- 42:42course I was a tourist in Paris before I, I moved here.
- 42:46But yeah, what I'm really enjoying about being able to
- 42:49spend more time in the city and what I, you know, encourage now,
- 42:52like friends and family who come to visit is to really seek out.
- 42:56And this is exactly, you know, your your take on things too,
- 43:00Lindsay. So I'd love to hear your ideas.
- 43:01But yeah, to seek out unexpected stories or narratives or voices
- 43:06when they come here and sure, go see the Louvre.
- 43:08Go see the Musee Del say, you know, take a selfie in front of
- 43:11the Eiffel Tower on your send boat tour.
- 43:14You know, I've done all of those things.
- 43:16And then go like, you know, go on the like packing noir, like
- 43:20walking tour or like go visit the Muskete Paris and learn
- 43:24about the sort of Arab and Muslim sort of culture and
- 43:27influence here in Paris. Explore neighborhoods that
- 43:30aren't, you know, at the sort of the the most kind of the
- 43:33classics or touristy places to visit in Paris and, and have
- 43:36your mind open, have your mind shifted about this iconic and
- 43:40mythologized city. But I mean, but Lizzy, you will
- 43:44have like so many more ideas than I will on.
- 43:47I mean, even through the cuisine, right?
- 43:49I mean this is your. Sure, but that's an that's an
- 43:53extension, right? You're, you're seeking, if
- 43:54you're going to seek out a tour or an experience, a walking tour
- 43:58or something that takes you through a different facet of, of
- 44:01Paris, then you should do the same through your food choices.
- 44:05Go to a Bistro one day, maybe check out the Moroccan place
- 44:09that has, you know, been running for 39 years and is a real
- 44:12anchor in a different neighborhood.
- 44:13You know, like, I think it's about blending those experiences
- 44:16and talking to people. And I, I think ultimately that's
- 44:19what made me fall in love with Paris, you know, going beneath
- 44:23the surface quite quickly and realizing how much was actually
- 44:26there. And I think the people who
- 44:28listen to the show and who have reached out to me for, you know,
- 44:32tasting tour to take interesting tours with me and things like
- 44:34that are, are the people who are looking for those kinds of
- 44:37perspective shifts or just learning a little bit more.
- 44:40And I think that's that's reassuring to me that we are
- 44:42moving into an area where, yes, there's still people who are
- 44:46having trouble shifting away from the old tourist model, but
- 44:50are there are plenty of others who are really inhabiting the
- 44:54role of the new tourist in all the best ways.
- 44:56And I think Paris is a is is a tourist dense city and at some
- 45:00point we will need to have more of the new tourist to make it
- 45:03sustainable for us. But everyone can read more about
- 45:07your thinking with the new tourist waking up to the power
- 45:11and perils of travel. It came out only a couple of
- 45:15months ago and it's published by Scribner Page.
- 45:18Fantastic work and thank you for coming by.
- 45:20I think we'll have way more to talk about after the Olympics
- 45:23are over. Oh yes, we will.
- 45:25Thank you so much for having me Lindsay.
- 45:27This has been a lot of fun. If you enjoy the show, it would
- 45:31mean the world if you would rate and leave a review on Spotify,
- 45:35Apple or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 45:38Until next time, Abiento.