Latest / The Vegan Report / Plants Have Feelings: The First Person Who Said It
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to the vegan report.
- 0:03I'm Ryan and today we're doing a solo episode.
- 0:07It's been a while since I've done one of these.
- 0:10I want to take you back in time to the very first
- 0:14recorded moment someone used the phrase plants
- 0:18have feelings or a version of that as an argument
- 0:22against animal sentience. did not happen on Reddit
- 0:26nor Twitter. We're talking the year 1391 in the
- 0:32late Middle Ages, and the person who said it
- 0:35wasn't some random guy in a tavern. It was a
- 0:39Byzantine emperor using this line of reasoning
- 0:43in a debate with an imam. Yes, really intrigued
- 0:49yet? Before we dive into this wild Story, I'd
- 0:53love for you to follow and subscribe to the show
- 0:57share this episode with the vegans You know,
- 1:00it generally helps the podcast grow and if you
- 1:03can leave a five -star review Do it. Don't be
- 1:07shy. That support is always appreciated. Thank
- 1:10you Hagia Sophia was surrounded by a sea of people,
- 1:17all cheering as officials offered largesse in
- 1:20the form of gold, silver, and bronze coins. The
- 1:24crowd had gathered long before dawn, when the
- 1:28emperor -to -be left the great palace in a royal
- 1:31procession and entered the church for his coronation.
- 1:36Inside Saint Sophia were assembled noble families,
- 1:40dignitaries, and ecclesiastics. Their attention
- 1:44was directed to the heart of the sanctuary, where
- 1:48Manuel II Palaiologos was being anointed by the
- 1:52Patriarch of Constantinople. When his sacred
- 1:56task was completed, the Patriarch shouted, as
- 1:59tradition required, Holy, Holy, Holy! The assembly
- 2:04bowed before erupting in a brouhaha of excitation
- 2:08soon echoed outside. This ceremony was held about
- 2:1360 years before the fall of the city to the Ottomans,
- 2:17who converted Saint Sophia to a mosque. At the
- 2:21time, the decline of the Byzantine Empire was
- 2:24already apparent. The new emperor was a vassal
- 2:28of Sultan Bayseid I, who called upon him to join
- 2:32the military campaign in Anatolia not long after
- 2:36the coronation. Manuel II Palaiologos was a unique
- 2:41man. As royalty of the last remnant of the Roman
- 2:45Empire, he benefited from the best education
- 2:49of his era, better than any other European monarch.
- 2:54In addition to being an accomplished monarch,
- 2:57he was a theologian and prolific author who was
- 3:01not afraid to think outside the box. When a harsh
- 3:05winter halted the Sultan's military campaign
- 3:09to Ankara, he took refuge into the house of an
- 3:13Islamic scholar with whom he debated heated issues
- 3:18of faith. The account of the debates, 26 in total,
- 3:23was compiled in a book titled, A Dialogue with
- 3:27a Certain Persian, by Profession a Teacher, held
- 3:31in Ancyra of Galatia. Now, I was never able to
- 3:36find a complete translation of this book, from
- 3:39ancient Greek, the original language, to English,
- 3:43French, or any other language I speak, except
- 3:46for the seventh. chapter which is called the
- 3:49Seventh Controversy and in which the emperor
- 3:53debates the merits of Christian, Jewish, and
- 3:55Islamic morality with the Imam. That chapter
- 4:00was partially translated to English and fully
- 4:03translated in French for a book adaptation. It's
- 4:07a very interesting exchange. I highly recommend
- 4:10reading it. Why do I care about finding a readable
- 4:15translation of this work? Well, firstly, I'm
- 4:19a bit of a nerd when it comes to the topic of
- 4:22religions. But also, get this, one of the questions
- 4:27they debated was, do animals have a soul? And
- 4:33now that's two of my nerdy interests colliding,
- 4:37religion and animal rights. So I just had to
- 4:41read that chapter. And thankfully, I found an
- 4:45old German translation of the book. I then copy
- 4:48-pasted the chapter on animals in Google Translate.
- 4:53And voila! Happiness! I will not read the complete
- 4:57translation to you because I don't know how accurate
- 5:01it is. I mean, it's still Google Translate. But
- 5:05I want to go through some highlights with you.
- 5:07It's very short, but oh so fascinating. He begins
- 5:12by calling animals, and I quote, animated beings
- 5:16who perceive and move, simple and foolish and
- 5:21minor. For him, the thought that the soul is
- 5:25not the soul ownership of humanity is beyond
- 5:29ridiculous. After all, it would mean among other
- 5:33things that at the end of times, frogs and even
- 5:36mosquitoes would be resurrected. Recently, we
- 5:40had Joy De Silva on the podcast. She wrote Animal
- 5:44Welfare in World Religion, Teaching and Practice.
- 5:48And she jokingly said, if there is a heaven,
- 5:51it would be filled to the brim with chickens.
- 5:54I actually asked Copilot and AI how many chickens
- 5:58have been born and died since the beginning of
- 6:01humanity. And that estimated number is between
- 6:055 to 10 trillion. 5 to 10 trillion. Counting
- 6:11to 5 trillion would take longer than all of recorded
- 6:15human history. Can you imagine that? He then
- 6:20expresses how absurd he feels for even giving
- 6:23breath to refuting such ideas, for it is evident
- 6:27that everything is created for man's sake. He
- 6:32asks how could the servant be equal to the master?
- 6:36Why would rational beings be allowed by God to
- 6:40slaughter other rational beings. Now, I think
- 6:44it is a pertinent question. It is a question
- 6:47I raised with Rabbi Akiva Gersh in another episode
- 6:51of the show. I asked him if God is real, why
- 6:54isn't he intervening to stop factory farming?
- 6:58And it all points to the problem of evil, which
- 7:02can be encapsulated in this amazing quote from
- 7:06philosopher Epicurus. Is God willing to prevent
- 7:11evil but not able? Then he is impotent. Is he
- 7:16able but not willing? Then is he malevolent?
- 7:22Is he both able and willing? Whence then is evil?
- 7:28Manuel II Palaiologos adds, Men is gifted, but
- 7:34other living beings are not. He then defines
- 7:38the gift of man as a soul guided by reason and
- 7:42free in its will, and cautions that the actions
- 7:46of unreasonable beings can seem rational but
- 7:50are in fact only the product of their natural
- 7:54predisposition. and 46 years later, that's about
- 8:07the age of America, I think, Manuel II Palaiologos
- 8:11and later Descartes objectify animals and reduce
- 8:16them to basically machines, animal machines.
- 8:21Let me read you a quote from Descartes. These
- 8:25functions all follow naturally in this machine,
- 8:29solely from the disposition of its organs. Neither
- 8:34more nor less than the movements of a clock or
- 8:38other automaton. It is not at all necessary to
- 8:43conceive for their operation any other vegetative
- 8:48or sensitive soul. His claim that humans are
- 8:53guided by reason, I find it so shocking. You
- 8:58know, most often we are unreasonable. We are
- 9:01guided by our wildest emotions and conditioning.
- 9:06But his core point is about free will. He basically
- 9:11says free will has been given to men, not those
- 9:15machine animals. So that makes men superior than
- 9:19animals. But is that even true? Do humans have
- 9:24free will? The philosopher Schopenhauer wrote
- 9:28against the idea of free will and his thoughts
- 9:30are just genius. But today, the philosopher who
- 9:34champions the idea that free will is an illusion
- 9:37is undeniably Sam Harris. He talks about it so
- 9:42well. Take a listen. I've argued that there's
- 9:45no such thing as free will. So what is there?
- 9:49Well, there's luck, both good and bad, as well
- 9:53as what we make of it. Actually, that's not quite
- 9:55true. What you make of your luck is also just
- 9:58more luck. Once again, you didn't pick your parents.
- 10:02You didn't pick the society into which you were
- 10:04born. There's not a cell in your body or brain
- 10:07that you created. Nor is there a single influence
- 10:10coming from the outside world that you brought
- 10:13into being. And yet everything you think and
- 10:16do arises from this ocean of prior causes. So
- 10:21what you do with your luck and the tools with
- 10:25which you do it, even down to the level of the
- 10:28effort and discipline you manage to summon in
- 10:30each moment, is more in the way of luck. Now,
- 10:34most people resist this idea, seemingly at any
- 10:37intellectual cost, for reasons that I can't understand.
- 10:40Because this single insight is the antidote to
- 10:43arrogance and hatred, and a profound basis for
- 10:47compassion for others who are less lucky than
- 10:49you are. But before we get into the ethics, we
- 10:53need to clear away some more confusion. I once
- 10:57met a rabbi who seemed to understand my views
- 11:00about free will the moment I expressed them.
- 11:02And he conceded that the notion of free will
- 11:05made no sense in a naturalistic world, only to
- 11:09then claim that we were therefore lucky to live
- 11:12in a world fashioned by a just and loving God
- 11:14who has given each of us a soul endowed with
- 11:17free will. Hence the possibility of sin. and
- 11:21our victory at overcoming it, and hence the reality
- 11:24of God's justice if we fail. Of course, this
- 11:27equation wouldn't apply to children born with
- 11:29congenital diseases, who in most cases didn't
- 11:33even have brains with which to sin before they
- 11:36reaped more than their fair share of justice.
- 11:38But nor does it apply to anyone else when you
- 11:41really think about it. But I knew not to take
- 11:43this line with the rabbi, because he was just
- 11:46the sort of man who would say that God's will
- 11:48is a mystery. as though merely reiterating this
- 11:51platitude could render an all -knowing and all
- 11:53-powerful God also good in the face of all the
- 11:57needless misery and death we see all around us.
- 12:01The topic of our conversation was free will and
- 12:03whether or not a soul could confer it. So I did
- 12:06my best to stay on point. I asked the rabbi how
- 12:08much credit he wanted to take for the fact that
- 12:11he hadn't been given the soul of a psychopath.
- 12:13He was aware, of course, that some people have
- 12:16such souls. I suggested that he and I were both
- 12:19very lucky not to have been so endowed. But the
- 12:22rabbi just waved this question away and declared
- 12:25that there was nothing I could say on the topic
- 12:27that could change his mind. Because you see the
- 12:29workings of the human soul are, wait for it,
- 12:34a mystery. I suppose I should have seen that
- 12:37coming. Now this is where a wiser man than I
- 12:40would see life as a comedy and enjoy a good laugh.
- 12:45I'll admit that these encounters sometimes bring
- 12:47out the nihilist in me. A claim this empty, expressed
- 12:53with such evident self -satisfaction, causes
- 12:58some part of me, some small part that other parts
- 13:01are struggling even now to expunge, to hope that
- 13:05a distant asteroid will just be nudged out of
- 13:08its orbit and set on a collision course with
- 13:10Earth. The fact that this educated man with a
- 13:15large congregation who was in a position to lead
- 13:18others intellectually and ethically could present
- 13:23such an ugly tangle of ignorance and superstition
- 13:25to the world as though it were some marvelous
- 13:28puzzle of his own invention that no mortal could
- 13:31solve. Actually made me furious. Now he must
- 13:36have mistaken the look on my face for a blow
- 13:38landed in debate because his eyes now acquired
- 13:42a triumphant gleam, and he then claimed that
- 13:47without free will, there could be no such thing
- 13:49as reason, because people would be doomed to
- 13:52think whatever they would based on the laws of
- 13:54physics. Indeed, the very effort I was making
- 13:57to reason with him now proved that I too believe
- 14:02in free will. In fact, if you search YouTube,
- 14:05you can find Noam Chomsky saying the same thing
- 14:08in response to a question after one of his lectures.
- 14:10This is a very common claim. It is also ridiculous.
- 14:16But the rabbi paused dramatically at this point
- 14:18to let the meaning of his words sink in. And
- 14:21here you should picture a peacock plumage spread
- 14:25in full wearing a yarmulke. So now please consider
- 14:29what this rabbi wouldn't. Your thoughts and choices
- 14:32arise out of each present state of the universe,
- 14:36which includes your brain and your soul. if such
- 14:39a thing exists, along with all of its influences,
- 14:44whether random or not. Your thoughts, intentions,
- 14:47and choices are part of this causal framework.
- 14:51So your thoughts, intentions, and choices matter,
- 14:54because whether they are the product of a brain
- 14:57or a soul, they're often the proximate cause
- 15:00of your actions, and yet they are caused in turn
- 15:04by events that you did not bring into being.
- 15:08Reasoning is possible, not because you're free
- 15:12to think however you want, but because you are
- 15:14not free. Reason makes slaves of us all. This
- 15:20is why the rabbi's point and Chomsky's point
- 15:23make no sense. It matters that 2 plus 2 equals
- 15:274, and it matters that you understand this. Are
- 15:32you free not to understand it? No. Not if you
- 15:37do, in fact, understand it. Are you free to understand
- 15:41it if you don't understand it? Again, no. Whether
- 15:45you understand or not isn't under your control.
- 15:49But the difference matters, absolutely. Anyone
- 15:52who believes that 2 plus 2 equals 5 will find
- 15:55no end to his troubles, because the world will
- 15:58oppose him at every point, beginning with his
- 16:01own fingers. You are part of reality. whatever
- 16:06it is altogether. Where is the freedom in this?
- 16:11Your beliefs about the world are formed in a
- 16:14perfect crucible of prior causes. If I say something
- 16:17now that changes your mind, it will be through
- 16:20no free will of your own. And if you're left
- 16:23feeling merely doubt or confusion, or you come
- 16:27away convinced that I'm a lunatic, you won't
- 16:29have chosen those responses either. So freedom
- 16:33never enters into it. the universe is pulling
- 16:36your strings. But our beliefs about the world
- 16:40matter because there's an enormous difference
- 16:41between knowledge and delusion. The physicist
- 16:45David Deutsch, who I had on my podcast, has argued
- 16:48that knowledge can produce any change in the
- 16:51universe compatible with its laws. Because if
- 16:54a change can't be accomplished with sufficient
- 16:56knowledge, this could only mean that some law
- 16:59of nature prevents it. The Emperor marks further
- 17:03the difference between humans and animals. They
- 17:07also have no trace of shame and abstinence, no
- 17:11lust for fame, which all men lust for, and neither
- 17:16craft science nor art. All of this and the ability
- 17:21to learn from each other can only be achieved
- 17:24by us. Of course, all of those claims are wrong.
- 17:29I could quote hundreds of biologists who have
- 17:32observed how intelligent and complex animals
- 17:35and animal societies are. Plutarch, a Greek philosopher
- 17:43who lived nearly 1300 years before the Byzantine
- 17:49emperor. It's twice more time than between us
- 17:53in 2026 and when the Byzantine emperor was having
- 17:57his debate. So Plutarch writes, for my part,
- 18:02I cannot see what right you have to assert that
- 18:05animals are without reason. What proof have you
- 18:10that they do not think, or that they do not use
- 18:14their intelligence? You should rather ask what
- 18:17proof you have that they do not. We say that
- 18:21animals have understanding, not in the same degree
- 18:25as men, but each according to its nature. They
- 18:29learn, they remember, they love, they fear, they
- 18:32defend themselves, and they seek what is useful
- 18:35to them. The emperor then concludes by posing
- 18:40this question, and that's the killer line people.
- 18:45If animated living beings are gifted with reason,
- 18:50then what prevents plants from being rational
- 18:54too? Of course by that, like any other people
- 19:00in 2026 using that argument, tries to show that
- 19:05Animals are nothing but mere plants. And just
- 19:09as ridiculous it would be to think of plants
- 19:12as being rational, it is ridiculous to think
- 19:16of animals as being anything more than what did
- 19:20they say at the beginning of this? Animated beings
- 19:25who perceive and move simple and foolish and
- 19:28minor. In any case, Here you have it folks, the
- 19:32oldest documented, plants have feelings argument.
- 19:37You're welcome for that historical nugget of
- 19:40knowledge. To this the Islamic scholar replies,
- 19:44rest assured you have convinced me on this matter
- 19:48before rising a new topic of conversation. Today
- 19:53most people, pious or atheist, would defend their
- 19:58views and cruel treatment of animals, using the
- 20:02same narrow logic as a theologian from the year
- 20:061391, from praising men's incomparable faculties
- 20:11to making plants into more than what they are.
- 20:15But there is something heartwarming about this
- 20:18whole exchange, and let me tell you what I mean.
- 20:23It seems like even during the Dark Ages, there
- 20:27were people who believed that animals have a
- 20:30soul. If not, then why would Manuel II Palaeologos
- 20:35feel compelled to bring up that topic and debate
- 20:39it? But yeah, if anything, this shows why we
- 20:43call the Middle Ages the Dark Ages. In any case,
- 20:47if you have any comments about this story, reach
- 20:51out theveganreport .gmail .com Thank you so much
- 20:56for tuning in every week. I appreciate you. Thank
- 21:00you so much for caring and see you soon.