Latest / MUBI Podcast / The Elgin and EL TOPO plunge NYC into "Midnite Madness"
Transcript
- 0:04Heads up. This episode includes explicit language descriptions of drug use.
- 0:07And one thing you might not be into: spoilers.
- 0:13Picture this, New York City November of last year.
- 0:17The perfect kind of crisp, sunny autumn afternoon you usually only find on movie posters for romcoms.
- 0:23And I'm standing beneath a sleek theater marquee in the Chelsea neighborhood, talking to a gray haired sage of a guy named Steven Gould.
- 0:31This theater was the last cinema built in New York City before World War Two.
- 0:36There was a moratorium.
- 0:38So this opened in December 1941.
- 0:41And it might be apocryphal, but rumor has it that the builders and the principles were getting crazy.
- 0:49They were in a meeting and they said, "Listen, I got to get home.
- 0:52My wife wants dinner, blah blah blah, What the hell is the name of this theater?" And one guy looked at his watch and it was an Elgin watch.
- 0:59And he says, "Here.
- 0:59That's the name Elgin."- It feels apocryphal, but let's keep it.
- 1:03- Yeah.
- 1:05Steven knows all about the Elgin Theater because in the seventies, he helped program the movies that screen there.
- 1:11Today, the place is a polished art deco dance theater called the Joyce.
- 1:14Stylish West Side types streaming all around us for a matinee performance.
- 1:18But Steve will tell you, it wasn't always like this.
- 1:21We were the poor kids on the block.
- 1:23The structure out here that we're under is the marquee, and it still is the dimensions of our marquee.
- 1:30But since we didn't have as much money, it was more beat up.
- 1:34And standing alone was a little kiosk.
- 1:37That was our box office.
- 1:38And it was about the size of maybe a large phone booth or something.
- 1:43Our cashiers freezing their ass off out here in the winter or sweating in the summer.
- 1:49You know, it was I don't know.
- 1:50There were sometimes where I thought it was a little like...
- 1:53There's a Peter Sellers movie called The Greatest Little Show on Earth.
- 1:57And he had this little dumpy theater, and the big chain opened a few blocks away and he started saying, "Well, you don't have to pay me.
- 2:06If you got something, you can bring it in.
- 2:08You know, so people were bringing in like chickens or sandwiches for him.
- 2:12And he was taking that because he just wanted to keep the place going.
- 2:16Look at it.You mean to tell me my uncle actually charged people to go in there?- That people actually paid?
- 2:21- Yes! Some... That movie's actually called The Smallest Show on Earth.
- 2:28But the Elgin made up for its small time, looks with a big screen, big sound and big ideas.
- 2:33And in the early seventies, one of those ideas turned the sidewalk under that beat up marquee into the place to be in New York.
- 2:40And changed how and especially when the world watches movies.
- 2:55I am Rico Gagliano, and from the streaming service MUBI welcome back to the MUBI podcast.
- 3:00MUBI's the best place outside of theater, to see beautiful, hand-picked cinema.
- 3:04On this show, we tell you the stories behind beautiful cinema.
- 3:07This is season two.
- 3:07We're calling it Only in Theaters.
- 3:10Every episode, we bring you the tale of a movie-house that made history.
- 3:13And the Elgin was definitely one of those.
- 3:17If you've ever gone to a late night screening of a cult film, you have this theater to thank, along with the maker of a movie called El Topo.
- 3:23Myself, I am not normal.
- 3:26I cannot make a normal scene because I am an artist.
- 3:29That is El Topo's director Alejandro Jodorowsky and I talked to him and many others about how the Elgin created a place and especially a time for proudly weird movies like his and their proudly weird audiences.
- 3:42So ticket, please.
- 3:42Enjoy the show.
- 3:56The story of the Elgin's rise begins in 1970.
- 3:59Which is a little surprising, 'cause that's also a time when movie theater attendance was falling right off a cliff.
- 4:05So I think 46, 1946, 100 million people went to the movies every week.
- 4:11That's what people did.
- 4:13And then in early 1970s, it was down to something like 17 million.
- 4:17You met Louis Menand in our last episode.
- 4:19He's a staff writer at The New Yorker.
- 4:20So there was a huge drop. Also...
- 4:23I have to say, in the UK, very similar.
- 4:25They had huge movie attendance in the forties.
- 4:27It really dropped off in the sixties.
- 4:30And nobody's ever actually been able to explain quite why people stopped going to the movies.
- 4:35I mean, one theory is baby boom, that people stayed home with their kids.
- 4:39Obviously, television was a factor, but it started before there was television.
- 4:42It started in the late 1940s.
- 4:44Well, Amy Nicholson has a theory.
- 4:46This is a time when American movies have been stale for most of your life.
- 4:51Like if you're 20 years old in 1970.
- 4:54Movies have been pretty boring.
- 4:55Amy writes about film for Variety and The New York Times.
- 4:58She also co-hosts the movie podcast Unspooled.
- 5:01And you should know her tastes tend towards the crazy.
- 5:04Yeah, my favorite type of movie is an ambitious failure.
- 5:08You know, a movie that really just shoots for it.
- 5:10Does everything, takes chances, is like pushing the boundaries of what cinema can do.
- 5:15And if they win, that's amazing.
- 5:15Amazing.
- 5:18But if they fail, my heart still goes out to them.
- 5:20And in 1970, she says, there were a lot of young people like her and not a lot of boundary pushing movies for them to see.
- 5:27At least not out of Hollywood.
- 5:29So, I mean, the major studios have been spending all of their time trying to compete with television.
- 5:33And their idea of how to do that is like big movies, four quadrant epics, musicals, you know, The Sound of Music and My Fair Lady, and Cleopatra.
- 5:41And you're feeling, you know, in your bones that things are going to be majorly shaken up.
- 5:46That we're poised for a shakeup.
- 5:48You know, if you were at the Oscars in March 1969, the movie that wins best picture is Oliver.
- 5:55You know, just the big old musical, Oliver.
- 5:57One year later, April 1970, the winner of this picture is the X-rated film Midnight Cowboy.
- 6:03Like, that is the most radical shift that has ever happened.
- 6:06And it's happening right in this moment.
- 6:08Well, the hero of our story sensed that shift and was going to capitalize on it.
- 6:13The Polish born manager of the Elgin Theater, a guy who's sadly no longer with us, name of Ben Barenholtz.
- 6:21I love that Ben Barenholtz himself was like the guy at the center of this because he's just a man of amazing taste, in my opinion.
- 6:29He survived the Nazi occupation when he was a boy.
- 6:31He comes to America in 1947.
- 6:34And he just has somehow amazing taste in the surreal and the absurd.
- 6:39Well he was tall, I guess dark haired, a thin mustache.
- 6:46That's Chuck Zlatkin.
- 6:47He'd eventually program movies at the Elgin, along with Steve Gould.
- 6:50But he started there as an usher, and his boss, Barenholtz, made an immediate impression.
- 6:55Intense eyes and always smoking cigarettes.
- 7:00Eventually he started using a cigarette holder which added to his image.
- 7:05And then after a while he stopped smoking cigarettes and just chewing on the cigarette holder.
- 7:12But he was enigmatic, I would say was hard to sometimes figure out what he was thinking about, what was on his mind.
- 7:20Well, clearly he spent a decent amount of time thinking about programing and marketing.
- 7:24The Elgin kept a tight budget.
- 7:26Vincent Canby of the New York Times once wrote the theater wouldn't spring for apostrophes for the marquee.
- 7:31But it did have a rep for deftly appealing to a lot of different audiences.
- 7:35It was a repertory theater, a revival theater, underground theater with classic films, foreign language films.
- 7:42And we found this huge CinemaScope screen that we were able to get into the theater.
- 7:47So we did a whole big CinemaScope film festival! But I think maybe the most poignant thing is that we decided at one point that we would charge senior citizens $0.25 at any time.
- 8:01So the seniors, they would be like making scarves and giving it to the staff.
- 8:05And of course, now I'm a senior citizen.
- 8:07Where can I find a theater that I can see a movie for $0.25?
- 8:11Please, somebody tell me that! Still, Barenholtz was pretty sure the new breed of young hipsters paying more than a quarter were his target demo.
- 8:21He started searching for a movie he could get as an exclusive that would blow the counterculture's collective mind.
- 8:27One day...
- 8:28it arrived.
- 8:31From exactly the kind of character you'd expect.
- 8:34Well, I am not sure if I was born one day. I am not sure who I am.
- 8:43But my ego is a long time in this moment, I am a cine-maker.
- 8:50But in another moment, I was a mime, I was a painter, I was a musician, I was a poet.
- 8:58I know only my name.
- 9:00Alejandro Jodorowsky Prullansky.
- 9:05Alejandro Jodorowsky is known for saying unusual things.
- 9:08But his CV checks out.
- 9:10He was born in Chile, where, as a teen, he started a marionette theater.
- 9:13Went to Paris, where he joined the troupe of mime superstar Marcel Marceau.
- 9:17Then it was off to Mexico to launch an experimental theater company, where he did everything.
- 9:22In this company of theater I started making music, costume, writing, directing actors.
- 9:30Ten years preparing me to make movies because my passion went to making movies.
- 9:36When I have all the techniques which I learned in ten years, I started the picture Fando and Lis.
- 9:48Right off the bat Fando and Lis established Jodorowsky's favorite tropes: mystical vision quests, psycho-sexuality, surreal symbolism, satire of authority, and religion, epic imagery, lots of blood.
- 10:06It was based on an avant garde play or... loosely based on it.
- 10:09I didn't shoot the theater play I shoot the ideas I have around the theater play.
- 10:16And I make this picture to create the greatest scandal in Mexico.
- 10:25There's no audio of the actual riot that broke out at the first screening of Fando and Lis.
- 10:32But I imagine it sounding something like this: What about the movie set the audience off?
- 10:35But I imagine it sounding something like this: Probably lots of stuff.
- 10:36But I imagine it sounding something like this: Oh, too violent.
- 10:38But I imagine it sounding something like this: There was nudity.
- 10:39But I imagine it sounding something like this: J. Hoberman was a film critic for the Village Voice, starting in the seventies.
- 10:43But I imagine it sounding something like this: He also co-wrote the book Midnight Movies.
- 10:45But I imagine it sounding something like this: I mean, you know, Mexico was kind of traumatized in the late sixties.
- 10:50But I imagine it sounding something like this: I don't know if you're aware of, you know, they had the Olympics there at the same time they, like, shot hundreds of students. Yeah.
- 10:56But I imagine it sounding something like this: So things were very tense there.
- 10:57But I imagine it sounding something like this: And, you know, it was Catholic and repressive and...
- 11:01But I imagine it sounding something like this: and this movie could be seen as anti-clerical.
- 11:04But I imagine it sounding something like this: I mean, there were a lot of things that they could object to.
- 11:06But I imagine it sounding something like this: The Mexican government quickly banned the film from being shown.
- 11:09But I imagine it sounding something like this: And in the U.S., it was just...
- 11:12But I imagine it sounding something like this: a flop.
- 11:13But I imagine it sounding something like this: When I made Fando and Lis a company in America buy the picture, cut the picture, and make another picture.
- 11:22But I imagine it sounding something like this: And was awful! Fando and Lis in the United States was awful! Was not my picture.
- 11:28But I imagine it sounding something like this: Was for me a big, a big failure.
- 11:31But I imagine it sounding something like this: So for his second film, Jodorowsky figured he'd try and play nice.
- 11:35But I imagine it sounding something like this: Because I was searching something commercial, something they know, I said"Well, I will make a cowboy picture, and then they will understand my picture." That is the way that El Topo was born a cowboy picture.
- 11:53But I imagine it sounding something like this: You thought, here's how audiences will understand me.
- 11:55But I imagine it sounding something like this: - I'll make a Western.
- 11:55But I imagine it sounding something like this: - Yes, yes.
- 11:57But I imagine it sounding something like this: And, but myself, I am not normal.
- 12:01But I imagine it sounding something like this: I cannot make a normal scene because I am an artist.
- 12:04But I imagine it sounding something like this: I am not a business man.
- 12:06But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then I make an artistical picture.
- 12:08But I imagine it sounding something like this: And the cowboy was not a normal cowboy.
- 12:13But I imagine it sounding something like this: There was a lot of things in El Topo who are not normal.
- 12:18But I imagine it sounding something like this: That is for sure.
- 12:20But I imagine it sounding something like this: El Topo is a mystical quest.
- 12:24But I imagine it sounding something like this: This guy rides out into the desert, you know, looking kind of like a Spaghetti Western villain or something.
- 12:31But I imagine it sounding something like this: All in black rides out into the desert with his young son behind him on the horse.
- 12:36But I imagine it sounding something like this: The hero, played by Jodorowsky, by the way, tells his naked son to bury a teddy bear and a picture of his mother in the sand.
- 12:49But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then they ride off into a series of ever stranger and bloodier adventures.
- 12:56But I imagine it sounding something like this: He picks up a woman.
- 12:57But I imagine it sounding something like this: She gives him this task to defeat the four masters of the desert.
- 13:02But I imagine it sounding something like this: Who are all very strange.
- 13:08But I imagine it sounding something like this: He does that.
- 13:14But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then somehow there's a second part of the movie where this town has grown up, it's completely corrupt.
- 13:22But I imagine it sounding something like this: He's very different.
- 13:23But I imagine it sounding something like this: He's kind of like a monk.
- 13:29But I imagine it sounding something like this: And this town is so awful.
- 13:31But I imagine it sounding something like this: He goes and he entertains with his...
- 13:32But I imagine it sounding something like this: He has a companion, a woman who is a dwarf.
- 13:37But I imagine it sounding something like this: And the town is so brutal, they humiliate them, you know, by making them have sex.
- 13:41But I imagine it sounding something like this: In public, as I recall.
- 13:49But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then he just, this town's awful, he just wreaks vengence on this town just slaughters them all.
- 14:01But I imagine it sounding something like this: Yeah, sometimes movies lose their impact over time.
- 14:04But I imagine it sounding something like this: El Topo...
- 14:06But I imagine it sounding something like this: is still eye popping, over-the-top violent and kind of addictively baffling.
- 14:15But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then it somehow, and then the cycle begins again or something like that.
- 14:18But I imagine it sounding something like this: Yeah, it's not. I mean, like, I can hear you struggling with the plot because it's not really about the plot.
- 14:23But I imagine it sounding something like this: No, it's not about the plot.
- 14:25But I imagine it sounding something like this: You know, there's this thing you learn about in cinema studies called the Cinema of Attractions, which is basically, you know, like the narrative is not as important as certain discrete elements of the movie.
- 14:35But I imagine it sounding something like this: I mean, stars would be the most important, but action scenes, special effects, all these other things.
- 14:41But I imagine it sounding something like this: That's true of El Topo.
- 14:43But I imagine it sounding something like this: Nobody would be following the story anyway.
- 14:45But I imagine it sounding something like this: They would be, you know, it would be like the trip. It was a trip.
- 14:51But I imagine it sounding something like this: Whatever it was.
- 14:51But I imagine it sounding something like this: Jodorowsky desperately needed to sell major studios on El Topo.
- 14:56But I imagine it sounding something like this: He says it'd cost $1,000,000 to make and he owed his investors big time.
- 15:01But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then we take the plane and we come to United States, to sell El Topo because if not we go to the jail.
- 15:08But I imagine it sounding something like this: And then we start to go to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Century-Fox, etc.
- 15:14But I imagine it sounding something like this: And they say, "Fantastic, but we need to show to our commercial sections." And then the commercial guys see the feature, they say "It's incredible, but we don't know how to show that.""We cannot show that because we know we don't know how." And then I went to another company the same thing, another company and the same thing.
- 15:36But I imagine it sounding something like this: Finally, a music producer named Alan Douglas arranged a screening at the Museum of Modern Art.
- 15:41But I imagine it sounding something like this: Some in the audience walked out.
- 15:43But I imagine it sounding something like this: Ben Barenholtz was there.
- 15:45But I imagine it sounding something like this: He didn't.
- 15:47But I imagine it sounding something like this: And the thing is that, you know, Ben Barenholtz saw it and immediately knew that this movie would be something.
- 15:56But I imagine it sounding something like this: Like, I have to program this movie.
- 15:58But I imagine it sounding something like this: He said that the first time he saw El Topo, he felt like he had seen a movie that felt like the present, you know, that finally felt like the future.
- 16:06But I imagine it sounding something like this: That half the audience walked out was kind of a point of pride.
- 16:10But I imagine it sounding something like this: He was like,"This is the movie of its time, you know, we're in a moment of change, and if everybody likes this change, then it's not even genuine change." It was violent, it was mystical.
- 16:20But I imagine it sounding something like this: It had all kinds of outlandish characters.
- 16:23But I imagine it sounding something like this: It was a lot like a Spaghetti Western, which, those were extremely popular, except it was a kind of a head movie.
- 16:31But I imagine it sounding something like this: I mean, you know, I can just imagine, you know, like Ben looking at it and going like "The hippes will love this shit," you know, it's like, it's all in there.
- 16:39But I imagine it sounding something like this: Chuck Zlatkin says there were just two challenges: marketing the movie to a counterculture that didn't like being marketed to and hiding the movie from critics.
- 16:47But I imagine it sounding something like this: Some of whom Barenholtz was pretty sure wouldn't love this shit.
- 16:51But I imagine it sounding something like this: And that's when the decision was made by Ben to present it at midnight, because he felt that it was a really special film and that he wanted to introduce it to the audiences that it would appeal to, primarily younger people.
- 17:07But I imagine it sounding something like this: And you wanted to keep it away from having a regular opening where critics would come and maybe kill the film.
- 17:14But I imagine it sounding something like this: And, you know, a very smart showman, he took out an ad,
- 17:20little ad in The Village Voice: "Coming soon, El Topo at midnight.
- 17:23little ad in The Village Voice: Too heavy to be shown any other way." And that's it. Was there a graphic or anything?
- 17:29little ad in The Village Voice: No, no! Nothing.
- 17:30little ad in The Village Voice: Turns out that was plenty.
- 17:33little ad in The Village Voice: The Elgin gives birth to midnight madness.
- 17:36little ad in The Village Voice: Coming up in just a minute, stay with us.
- 17:44little ad in The Village Voice: MUBI is a curated streaming service showing exceptional films from around the globe, all of them hand-picked by real people who really know movies.
- 17:52little ad in The Village Voice: And with a new film debuting on the platform every single day, there's always something new to discover.
- 17:58little ad in The Village Voice: So on this season of the podcast, you may have noticed we're talking about history making experiences that were only possible in movie theaters.
- 18:05little ad in The Village Voice: Hopefully it inspires you to love and support your local cinema that much more.
- 18:10little ad in The Village Voice: And we got a new thing going that can help you do exactly that.
- 18:13little ad in The Village Voice: It is called MUBI Go and when you sign up you get a free movie ticket every week to see a hand-selected film in theaters.
- 18:22little ad in The Village Voice: Previous picks include award winning films like Drive My Car, The Lost Daughter, Cha-Cha Real Smooth, and the Power of the Dog.
- 18:26little ad in The Village Voice: MUBI Go is now available in the UK, New York and Los Angeles, and it is coming to more U.S. cities soon.
- 18:34little ad in The Village Voice: To learn more, check out MUBI.com/go Also, one more thing.
- 18:39little ad in The Village Voice: After you finished listening, you can stream some of the films we have featured on the podcast this season.
- 18:44little ad in The Village Voice: All you got to do is subscribe to MUBI.com and look for the collection called "Featured on the MUBI Podcast." That is on the Now Showing page.
- 18:53little ad in The Village Voice: You can also find all the links we have mentioned in the show notes of this episode.
- 18:57little ad in The Village Voice: Speaking of which.
- 18:58little ad in The Village Voice: Back to it.
- 19:02little ad in The Village Voice: So it's December 1970, Ben Barenholtz' little ad has just hit the Village Voice announcing the Elgin's midnight screenings of El Topo and New York's counterculture is already pretty sure this might be a movie for them.
- 19:15little ad in The Village Voice: Because, according to J Hoberman, by 1970 a lot of cool stuff happened at midnight.
- 19:21little ad in The Village Voice: Oh, there were plenty of midnight screenings.
- 19:23little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, midnight screenings go back a long way.
- 19:25little ad in The Village Voice: And actually, there was a tradition, you know, in the whole underground scene of midnight movies and performances.
- 19:32little ad in The Village Voice: You know who The Fugs are?
- 19:33little ad in The Village Voice: Yeah, the Fugs, the counterculture band from New York.
- 19:36little ad in The Village Voice: Yeha, I mean, they used to perform at midnight all the time.
- 19:38little ad in The Village Voice: But if it was such a typical thing, what made this so special?
- 19:41little ad in The Village Voice: Well, he was going to, it was going to get a theatrical run at midnight.
- 19:45little ad in The Village Voice: It wasn't just a one time thing, like a special show at midnight.
- 19:48little ad in The Village Voice: It was going to be continuous.
- 19:49little ad in The Village Voice: And I think that, you know, when I say that it was not unusual, I mean that it was not unusual in the context of underground, experimental films or, you know, performances.
- 19:59little ad in The Village Voice: But this was, you know, like a commercial movie house that showed some far out stuff.
- 20:04little ad in The Village Voice: Meaning that maybe this kind of brought that tradition into the mainstream.
- 20:08little ad in The Village Voice: Completely established that tradition, completely.
- 20:11little ad in The Village Voice: It was the first, but it was a blockbuster.
- 20:13little ad in The Village Voice: It was the first midnight blockbuster.
- 20:15little ad in The Village Voice: And Chuck Zlatkin says that was clear right from opening night.
- 20:19little ad in The Village Voice: Okay, so it was like, it was, the theater was packed.
- 20:23little ad in The Village Voice: I think it was standing room only.
- 20:25little ad in The Village Voice: Maybe it was like 600 people in there.
- 20:28little ad in The Village Voice: And, you know, the film started.
- 20:37little ad in The Village Voice: In seconds there was silence.
- 20:46little ad in The Village Voice: And then when things, various things happen the audience would respond.
- 20:57little ad in The Village Voice: You could just, you could just feel it.
- 20:59little ad in The Village Voice: You talk about those thrilling moments when something really works.
- 21:02little ad in The Village Voice: Well, this really worked.
- 21:06little ad in The Village Voice: And when the film ended, the audience exploded.
- 21:13little ad in The Village Voice: It was like the lobby was filled with people talking about the movie.
- 21:18little ad in The Village Voice: So in the terminology of the times, it blew people's minds.
- 21:21little ad in The Village Voice: And it was obviously that they were going to go out and tell people to come see it.
- 21:25little ad in The Village Voice: And they did.
- 21:27little ad in The Village Voice: A lot of people.
- 21:31little ad in The Village Voice: Standing with me outside the former Elgin Theater Steven Gould remembers what it was like to host a blockbuster on a block that wasn't really used to busting.
- 21:41little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, this was a very Latinx area at the time.
- 21:44little ad in The Village Voice: You know, we had guys with little carriages and a block of ice coming here, shaving and pouring sirup on it and stuff.
- 21:51little ad in The Village Voice: - Selling shaved ice.
- 21:51little ad in The Village Voice: - Yeah. Yeah.
- 21:52little ad in The Village Voice: And then, you know, all the guys sitting out playing dominoes.
- 21:56little ad in The Village Voice: It was that kind of place.
- 21:57little ad in The Village Voice: And I think some of the older locals looked at us, you know, a little "loco" for you know, midnight going to a movie and stuff, but definitely crowded.
- 22:06little ad in The Village Voice: A lot of people, you know, bell-bottoms, beads, long hair, beards.
- 22:13little ad in The Village Voice: And then I know I can honestly say I don't really remember that many families coming in to see El Topo.
- 22:21little ad in The Village Voice: - I would hope not.
- 22:21little ad in The Village Voice: - Yeah.
- 22:23little ad in The Village Voice: I would hope you would turn away the little kids.
- 22:25little ad in The Village Voice: Yeah.
- 22:25little ad in The Village Voice: But any admissions the Elgin lost from the family audience they made up for with the celebrity audience.
- 22:31little ad in The Village Voice: Robert Redford showed up. Abbie Hoffman.
- 22:33little ad in The Village Voice: Know how years later, the discotheque Studio 54 became this crazy playground for coked up stars and hipsters?
- 22:40little ad in The Village Voice: Well, El Topo screenings were like the scruffy, more cosmic dress rehearsal for that.
- 22:43little ad in The Village Voice: With maybe slightly lower octane drugs.
- 22:47little ad in The Village Voice: See, smoking then was allowed in the balcony in the theater, and so people could smoke in the balcony.
- 22:52little ad in The Village Voice: That's the only thing we enforced.
- 22:54little ad in The Village Voice: No smoking in the orchestra, smoke in the balcony.
- 22:57little ad in The Village Voice: But we didn't enforce what you could smoke.
- 22:59little ad in The Village Voice: People were coming to see it, at least, you know, high on marijuana, many of them more than that.
- 23:06little ad in The Village Voice: And long before, you know, the Rocky Horror Show phenomenon took place, people were coming dressed in costumes for the people in El Topo.
- 23:15little ad in The Village Voice: And we'd also play, you know, rock music before our El Topo began and it got to the point where people would get up on stage and dance to the music.
- 23:25little ad in The Village Voice: It was such a scene, Jodorowsky says, it was even a little much for him.
- 23:28little ad in The Village Voice: They smoked marijuana.
- 23:30little ad in The Village Voice: Every time I went to the theater there was a lot of smoke of marijuana, and they was putting in my hand cigars of marijuana.
- 23:40little ad in The Village Voice: I never smoked marijuana, I was a virgin like that! I'd say "Thank you", I'd put it in the garbage.
- 23:46little ad in The Village Voice: In my life I never drink alcolhol neither.
- 23:49little ad in The Village Voice: Can I make sure that I'm understanding this?
- 23:51little ad in The Village Voice: You had never smoked marijuana, so you went to the theater and people were just putting joints in your hand and you- just, like, threw it away.
- 23:57little ad in The Village Voice: - Yes.
- 23:59little ad in The Village Voice: Yes, I you don't criticize that.
- 24:00little ad in The Village Voice: Everyone do what he want.
- 24:03little ad in The Village Voice: But it was not my world.
- 24:05little ad in The Village Voice: Jodorowsky might not have cared much for the weed, but he definitely appreciated the movie's notoriety.
- 24:11little ad in The Village Voice: Soon, the Elgin and El Topo weren't just the talk of the cool kids.
- 24:14little ad in The Village Voice: One day I take the taxi, a normal taxi who bring me to Elgin Theater.
- 24:21little ad in The Village Voice: And when they say"Elgin Theater" he say me"You will go see El Topo?" He know, the taxi driver know El Topo.
- 24:30little ad in The Village Voice: Big happiness for my part.
- 24:30little ad in The Village Voice: Big happiness.
- 24:34little ad in The Village Voice: Because even the driver of taxi know the El Topo.
- 24:37little ad in The Village Voice: And that's when movie critics took notice too.
- 24:40little ad in The Village Voice: Many were enthralled.
- 24:41little ad in The Village Voice: - But others...
- 24:41little ad in The Village Voice: - I remember 'cause I was handling press at that time for the theater.
- 24:47little ad in The Village Voice: Vincent Canby, this film reviewer for the New York Times, he wanted a special screening of El Topo for him, and I would say "I'm sorry, we don't do that, because the experience is seeing it at midnight with the audience and we're not having any screenings." And he was really taken aback.
- 25:06little ad in The Village Voice: "I'm from The New York Times! Do you know who I am?" I say, "Yes, I know who you are.
- 25:13little ad in The Village Voice: Just come any midnight, no problem. And we'll make sure you have seat." Yeah, it's kind of like, yeah, we know who you are.
- 25:19little ad in The Village Voice: In fact, we're showing this at midnight because, like, you're the enemy! So he eventually came and saw it.
- 25:26little ad in The Village Voice: That's the amazing, months later, he had to break down and come see it.
- 25:31little ad in The Village Voice: Do you remember the review?
- 25:31little ad in The Village Voice: What did he write?
- 25:32little ad in The Village Voice: I don't remember.
- 25:32little ad in The Village Voice: I should have looked at it beforehand to tell that story.
- 25:38little ad in The Village Voice: It's okay. Amy Nicholson looked it up.
- 25:40little ad in The Village Voice: He thought that what made it a success was just that it was being played so late at night that if people walked out of the movie at 3 A.M.
- 25:48little ad in The Village Voice: and didn't think it was that great, then they felt really dumb.
- 25:52little ad in The Village Voice: Like, "What have I done with my life?" You know? So they're surrounded by other people who are all nodding and being like, "Yes, it's a masterpiece." And you're like,"Yeah, yeah, it's a masterpiece." Just because you're exhausted and you don't want to feel like an idiot or risk being like the uncool person who sides with the squares and says they don't get it.
- 26:06little ad in The Village Voice: Oh, yeah.
- 26:07little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, some of the critics seem to have just thought that this movie was like Emperor's New Hollywood.
- 26:11little ad in The Village Voice: And to be fair, if you were a critic who felt like El Topo was a simple exploitation flick, or just the rantings of an oddball, Jodorowsky's interviews at the time might not have dispelled that idea.
- 26:22little ad in The Village Voice: When he does give interviews, they're like pretty much insane and incomprehensible, and he's talking about religion and sex, and then he's talking about how the Holy Spirit touched him in a very, very private place.
- 26:33little ad in The Village Voice: Like literally a private place that I don't want to say right here.
- 26:36little ad in The Village Voice: He is saying that he wants to build a cathedral for a piece of cheese.
- 26:39little ad in The Village Voice: He also infamously said a scene where his character sexually assaults his lover was a real assault.
- 26:42little ad in The Village Voice: Something he now says was just like a lot of stuff he told the press at the time.
- 26:49little ad in The Village Voice: An attention grabbing fiction.
- 26:51little ad in The Village Voice: Regardless, it's obviously pretty shocking.
- 26:55little ad in The Village Voice: But neither controversy nor critiques put a dent in El Topo's box office.
- 27:00little ad in The Village Voice: The movie played every weekday at midnight, 1 A.M. on weekends, month after month.
- 27:05little ad in The Village Voice: You know... In a sense, reviews were meaningless for that film.
- 27:10little ad in The Village Voice: What mattered were people's response to it.
- 27:13little ad in The Village Voice: And you know, the creator of the film put so much in there for people to see, so much symbolism for every different, you know, religious or belief or whatever.
- 27:24little ad in The Village Voice: And people would come and...
- 27:26little ad in The Village Voice: you know, it wasn't enough for them to see it once.
- 27:29little ad in The Village Voice: Y'know, some people would have to come back and see it five and ten times.
- 27:33little ad in The Village Voice: To the point that in some ways the screenings started to feel religious, too.
- 27:37little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, the Village Voice at the time, who like really hyped up El Topo, they called it a comedy that becomes a cult of salvation.
- 27:44little ad in The Village Voice: And they referred to going to go see El Topo at midnight as midnight mass.
- 27:49little ad in The Village Voice: All of these kind of quasi religious, spiritual things, coming about at a point where like the hippie dippyness of the sixties has been segueing into the darker, really just after post-Manson, kind of"What are we all doing?
- 28:03little ad in The Village Voice: What are we all believing in?" In other words, it's pretty clear midnight screenings at the Elgin didn't become a phenomenon just because of El Topo.
- 28:10little ad in The Village Voice: Any more than a church is inspiring just because there's a Bible in it.
- 28:14little ad in The Village Voice: They also caught on because it was a chance for people to come together again and again, at a special time and place to try and find meaning.
- 28:27little ad in The Village Voice: And the final chapter of the El Topo story proves just how important the time and place really was.
- 28:32little ad in The Village Voice: It started with a celebrity sighting.
- 28:34little ad in The Village Voice: John Lennon and Yoko Ono came to see it.
- 28:37little ad in The Village Voice: Actually a couple of times.
- 28:39little ad in The Village Voice: Now, in my experience working at the Elgin, we're talking you know, this is now 1971, and in my experience there, I've seen a lot of people of note, a lot of celebrities, famous people, whatever, and they just deal with it.
- 28:52little ad in The Village Voice: Somehow, when I saw John Lennon walk up to the box office, I had to remind myself to breathe.
- 29:00little ad in The Village Voice: Yes, he was here or whatever.
- 29:02little ad in The Village Voice: And then it was a question of letting them in for free or not.
- 29:05little ad in The Village Voice: And I said, "I think they can afford to pay." So we sold them tickets and then they walked into the theater.
- 29:13little ad in The Village Voice: And as they were walking in, John turned to Yoko and said,"Mummy, do I have time to get sweets?" And she looked and said, okay.
- 29:21little ad in The Village Voice: And he went to the concession stand and got some candy and they went in to see the film.
- 29:26little ad in The Village Voice: And what was the result?
- 29:26little ad in The Village Voice: What happened?
- 29:28little ad in The Village Voice: Well, they came back again and I think they actually ended up seeing it maybe three times.
- 29:34little ad in The Village Voice: And then they said to Allen Klein, "Buy the film!" Be prepared to live the most wonderful experience of your life.
- 29:43little ad in The Village Voice: Allen Klein was Lennon's business manager.
- 29:46little ad in The Village Voice: For a while he also managed a little act you may have heard of called The Rolling Stones.
- 29:50little ad in The Village Voice: J Hoberman says Klein's company bought the rights to El Topo, and...
- 29:53little ad in The Village Voice: They pulled it right out of the Elgin.
- 29:56little ad in The Village Voice: That was it. I mean, Allen Klein, you know, no more midnight screening.
- 29:59little ad in The Village Voice: He wanted to reopen it on Broadway, you know, like give it a proper opening.
- 30:04little ad in The Village Voice: The movie got this official trailer: Alejandro Jodorowsky's film classic El Topo.
- 30:09little ad in The Village Voice: And a giant ad in Times Square, the width of an entire building.
- 30:13little ad in The Village Voice: Which just shows, you know, like how totally he misunderstood, well, what the appeal was.
- 30:19little ad in The Village Voice: You know, I mean, in a sense, you have something this is this private thing that people are enjoying, you know, that that they feel very cool about.
- 30:28little ad in The Village Voice: You know, they're part of it.
- 30:30little ad in The Village Voice: This sect, this, you know, cult or whatever.
- 30:33little ad in The Village Voice: You know, it's not the same thing to, like, show it in the light of day, on Broadway! El Topo is more than spectacle.
- 30:41little ad in The Village Voice: It is an experience for all of your life.
- 30:44little ad in The Village Voice: And what happened to it?
- 30:44little ad in The Village Voice: What happened to the movie,- Once it got pulled?
- 30:45little ad in The Village Voice: - It bombed. It bombed.
- 30:48little ad in The Village Voice: It didn't you know, it didn't didn't do any business.
- 30:51little ad in The Village Voice: El Topo's run was over.
- 30:55little ad in The Village Voice: But meanwhile, Ben Barenholtz, the Elgin and its midnight screenings were just getting started.
- 31:03little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, after El Topo finishes its run, everything he programmes next is a banger.
- 31:08little ad in The Village Voice: He programs Pink Flamingos, which is like, "Ta da!" look at John Waters, everything he could do.
- 31:13little ad in The Village Voice: I mean, we have Hairspray because of his amazing taste.
- 31:16little ad in The Village Voice: Ben deputized Chuck Zlatkin and Steve Gould as programmers.
- 31:19little ad in The Village Voice: They brought in the reggae fueled Jamaican flick The Harder They Come.
- 31:23little ad in The Village Voice: It played the midnight slot for years.
- 31:26little ad in The Village Voice: Meanwhile, Ben focused on film distribution, and the hits kept coming.
- 31:30little ad in The Village Voice: He saw Eraserhead.
- 31:32little ad in The Village Voice: Halfway through Eraserhead, he already was like, "I'm going to buy this movie." And then he invited David Lynch to live with him while finishing the print and gave him money for food.
- 31:40little ad in The Village Voice: He just knew what talent was going to be.
- 31:43little ad in The Village Voice: All these movies were huge midnight sensations and not just at the Elgin.
- 31:48little ad in The Village Voice: Because of this trend, he started and the fact that he proved there was an audience, he claims that within two years, every city in the country had a midnight movie going.
- 31:57little ad in The Village Voice: And it was kind of him tipping over that domino.
- 32:00little ad in The Village Voice: Alas, no theater can survive on midnight box office alone.
- 32:04little ad in The Village Voice: The Elgin finally closed in the late 1970s.
- 32:06little ad in The Village Voice: Following the last showing, we invited back everybody, whoever, you know, worked at the theater there, and we had a big party.
- 32:14little ad in The Village Voice: Someone turned to me, it was, you know, March of 1977 and I said, "Well, I guess the sixties are finally over" Because the Elgin was closing.
- 32:24little ad in The Village Voice: After the party, they put one last movie title on the marquee, Gone with the Wind.
- 32:33little ad in The Village Voice: Except the Elgin wasn't gone.
- 32:35little ad in The Village Voice: Four years later, it was reborn as the Joyce.
- 32:38little ad in The Village Voice: And yeah, it's a dance theater now, so it's changed, but also stayed the same.
- 32:47little ad in The Village Voice: It's that perfect autumn afternoon last November again.
- 32:49little ad in The Village Voice: And I'm sitting inside the Joyce Theater, now in a balcony seat, along with Steven Gould, waiting for a swing dance performance to begin.
- 32:57little ad in The Village Voice: I feel so at home in the balcony.
- 32:59little ad in The Village Voice: All we need is a blunt and we're all set to go here! This is the first run of shows at the Joyce since New York's COVID lockdown.
- 33:07little ad in The Village Voice: People eagerly head to their seats while I take in the sleek art deco lines of the place.
- 33:12little ad in The Village Voice: The lush red velvet curtain and the cool exposed brick walls.
- 33:16little ad in The Village Voice: Definitely not like it was back in the Elgin days.
- 33:18little ad in The Village Voice: Well, the walls had plaster on them.
- 33:21little ad in The Village Voice: And the plaster had paint on them.
- 33:24little ad in The Village Voice: Some of the paint was peeling! Once in a while, some clanking of the old steam radiators.
- 33:30little ad in The Village Voice: And on the roof of the theater we got about 20 children's wading pools and put them on pallets and we planted things up there.
- 33:40little ad in The Village Voice: And there was one fall that we had such a bumper crop of tomatoes that when people were leaving the theater, they got a couple of tomatoes when they were going home.
- 33:50little ad in The Village Voice: That's beautiful. It sounds like that theater had a different vibe than now.
- 33:54little ad in The Village Voice: Well, I mean, people seem to be excited waiting to see the show.
- 34:00little ad in The Village Voice: And that's something that's really wonderful when you come into a theater, the excitement saying, "Oh, I'm going to see this and see that." And, you know, obviously because I was 40 years in the business, movies meant the most to me.
- 34:14little ad in The Village Voice: But it is so wonderful that this venue is still being used as a theater.
- 34:20little ad in The Village Voice: And I know with COVID, people were freaked out and everything, but I am so happy to see the audience here.
- 34:28little ad in The Village Voice: I can't see the smiles on their faces'cause we all have masks on, but I hope it's a smile.
- 34:33little ad in The Village Voice: Good afternoon, everyone.
- 34:35little ad in The Village Voice: May I have your attention, please?
- 34:37little ad in The Village Voice: We are excited to welcome you back to the Joyce Theater.
- 34:40little ad in The Village Voice: For everyone's safety...
- 34:43little ad in The Village Voice: The audience is so psyched they drown out the pre-show announcement.
- 34:49little ad in The Village Voice: It's a different kind of crowd than turned out for El Topo.
- 34:51little ad in The Village Voice: No one's in costume and it's way earlier.
- 34:54little ad in The Village Voice: But it's a crowd of people celebrating something they revere together.
- 34:58little ad in The Village Voice: After a long lockdown the feeling at the Elgin, excuse me, the Joyce is still a kind of mass.
- 35:16little ad in The Village Voice: And that's the MUBI podcast for this week.
- 35:18little ad in The Village Voice: Follow us to make sure you get a front row seat for more deep dives into great movie theaters.
- 35:22little ad in The Village Voice: Next week, the suburban Midwest theater that helped turn a box office disaster into one of the most beloved cult films of the 20th century.
- 35:29little ad in The Village Voice: At the 95th week, Harold and Maud beat the record for longest running movie in Minnesota.
- 35:34little ad in The Village Voice: Like in the history of the state?
- 35:34little ad in The Village Voice: What held the record before that?
- 35:37little ad in The Village Voice: It was The Sound of Music.
- 35:38little ad in The Village Voice: So Harold and Maud beat The Sound of Music.
- 35:41little ad in The Village Voice: Come on, how can you miss that?
- 35:42little ad in The Village Voice: Meanwhile, this episode was hosted, written and cut by me, Rico Gagliano.
- 35:46little ad in The Village Voice: Beth Schiff is our booking producer.
- 35:48little ad in The Village Voice: Stephen Colón mastered and engineered.
- 35:50little ad in The Village Voice: Martin Austwick composed, performed all the music.
- 35:53little ad in The Village Voice: A million thanks to everyone at the Joyce Theater.
- 35:56little ad in The Village Voice: The show is executive produced by me, along with Jon Barranchea, Efe Cakarel, Daniel Kasman and Michael Tacca for MUBI.
- 36:02little ad in The Village Voice: If you're digging this show, please leave us a five star review wherever you listen, it will make it easier for others to find and fall in love with us.
- 36:09little ad in The Village Voice: Also, if you've got questions, comments, if you want to share your favorite moviegoing memories with us or maybe you even saw El Topo at the Elgin back in the day, tell us about it.
- 36:18little ad in The Village Voice: If you weren't too baked to remember the details.
- 36:20little ad in The Village Voice: Our email is podcast@MUBI.com And of course to stream the best of cinema, including some of the films we talk about on this very podcast, simply head over to MUBI.com to start watching.
- 36:32little ad in The Village Voice: Till next week, large popcorn no butter for me please.