Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Objections vs. Instructions Not to Answer (or Depositions: Don’t Say Anything!)
Transcript
- 0:02I am Netta Sagafi. I am vice chair of the HBA's
- 0:07litigation section. And I am delighted to introduce
- 0:11our speaker, Tony Ross today. Tony Ross, Anthony
- 0:15Tony Ross became a lawyer because he has always
- 0:19had a strong sense of fairness and a desire to
- 0:22serve others. During law school, he was the assistant
- 0:26to the president of the American Civil Liberties
- 0:29Union, which gave him a front row seat in the
- 0:31fight to preserve and defend the civil liberties
- 0:34enshrined in the Constitution's Bill of Rights.
- 0:37Tony attended New York Law School and attended
- 0:40Rutgers University, where he received a BA in
- 0:44psychology and economics. After law school, Tony
- 0:47embarked on a successful career as an entrepreneur
- 0:51in the hospitality space, and he credits the
- 0:54success of his company to his ability to connect
- 0:57with people from diverse backgrounds. Tony focuses
- 1:00his practice on transportation and general liability
- 1:04matters. He has extensive experience in general
- 1:08liability, commercial litigation, personal injury,
- 1:12consumer protection, and business litigation
- 1:15matters. And now let's get started. So nice to
- 1:20have Tony with us today. Thank you. Thank you,
- 1:23Neda. Good morning, everyone. Welcome to this
- 1:27presentation on defending depositions, which
- 1:28I think is a good perspective. Often we look
- 1:32at depositions just from the perspective of taking
- 1:34them. So talking about defending them is important
- 1:37as well. I think I've done hundreds of depositions.
- 1:41I actually don't know how many I've done. But
- 1:45Defending is as important, times more important,
- 1:47but definitely as important as taking them. We
- 1:50can go to the next slide, please. And these are
- 1:53just the objectives of our talk today, preparing
- 1:57your client for deposition testimony, make sure
- 2:00you preserve your objections, your privileges,
- 2:05avoiding waiving the privileges and avoiding
- 2:07sanctions, which is important, and maintaining
- 2:10professionalism, very important. Next slide.
- 2:18So when you're preparing your client, there are
- 2:21some very key golden rules, we'll call them.
- 2:28First of all, you have to remember that your
- 2:30client most likely has never had their deposition
- 2:33taken before. So you'll have to manage some of
- 2:36the anxiety around the process. And different
- 2:41people obviously will have different ways of
- 2:43managing that anxiety. Sometimes they'll want
- 2:45to speed through the depositions. Sometimes they
- 2:48have seen television shows, which gives them
- 2:52a false sense of really what a deposition is.
- 2:54Because usually on television, there aren't depositions.
- 2:56They just talk about them, if at all. And so
- 3:00first thing you want to tell your client is that
- 3:01this is a marathon, not a sprint. So they should.
- 3:06before answering. Don't just run headlong into
- 3:09an answer. They often, your client might think
- 3:12that they can understand or they know where the
- 3:16attorney is going. So they try to help them out
- 3:18sometimes and answer the question quicker than
- 3:22is necessary. That often is not good for making
- 3:25a good record. So you wanna ask your clients
- 3:27to pause before answering. That gives you a chance
- 3:30to make any objections. Also gives your client
- 3:33a chance to kind of think about the answer to
- 3:35the question. And you want to make sure that
- 3:39they know that they can estimate an answer. Sometimes
- 3:42there'll be a question about distance or time
- 3:45or height or even a date. They can give an estimate,
- 3:49but they're not to guess. It's very important
- 3:51that they don't guess. And ATFQ is answer the
- 3:57freaking question. That's a really important
- 3:59part of depositions. One of the things that I
- 4:02start off with my clients is checking to see
- 4:05that they understand this point. One of the things
- 4:09I'll ask them as an example is, do you know what
- 4:12time it is? And often, more often than not, they
- 4:16will answer with the time. That is not the right
- 4:19answer. I ask them if they knew what time it
- 4:21is, not what time. Answering the question is
- 4:24important. So if I ask you, do you know what
- 4:26time it is? You can either say yes or no. If
- 4:29I ask you what time is it, then you'll tell me
- 4:32what time it is. That's an important distinction
- 4:35because that's how witnesses get tripped up in
- 4:40depositions by answering a question that they
- 4:42thought they understood. They didn't pay attention
- 4:45and they answered the wrong question. The other
- 4:48thing that you want to make sure your clients
- 4:49understand is to give short answers. The shorter
- 4:52the better. I tell clients that if I ask the
- 4:54question, remember, this is from the perspective
- 4:56of someone who's defending a deposition. As to
- 4:59the question of my witness, they can take as
- 5:01long as they want to give me a long answer because
- 5:03I pretty much know where I want them to go. More
- 5:06often than not, they're answering questions from
- 5:08opposing counsel. Their answers should be short.
- 5:10Yes or no would be great, but those aren't always
- 5:12possible. But the shorter, the better. Another
- 5:15guideline I tell my clients, if you are answering
- 5:17a question and you find yourself taking a breath
- 5:20so that you continue your answer, you're probably
- 5:22saying too much. Answers should be short because
- 5:25that allows you to limit The record, it also
- 5:29keeps them from answering a question that wasn't
- 5:32asked, for example. The other thing is to let
- 5:35them understand they can take a break if they
- 5:38need to. This goes back to the concept of, again,
- 5:40this being a marathon and not a sprint. Most
- 5:44depositions can take several hours. And you can
- 5:47take breaks during that time period as long as
- 5:50there's no question pending. And you can use
- 5:53those breaks strategically. You can talk to your
- 5:55client. Sometimes the client just needs a little
- 5:58moral support during a break. You're doing really
- 6:01well. You answer that question properly, that
- 6:05kind of thing. You can also, during breaks, your
- 6:08client, was there something, maybe you'll either
- 6:10recognize it or you'll ask your client, was there
- 6:11something that you thought you wanted to say
- 6:13and you didn't get to say it correctly? Maybe
- 6:16you'll recognize that a question threw them off,
- 6:18and you'll say, did you say that right? Or did
- 6:21you get the information that you wanted? Because
- 6:22you can come back from a break and redirect your
- 6:24client and get a better answer out of them if
- 6:27it wasn't the answer that you think you needed
- 6:30for that record during the deposition. So take
- 6:33breaks. Use them strategically. Also make sure
- 6:36your client understands that you can't coach
- 6:39them during the deposition. They don't often
- 6:42understand that. And they, you know, for the
- 6:45most part, you're really kind of a fly on the
- 6:46wall in many respects. As we go forward, you'll
- 6:49understand and you'll see what I mean by that.
- 6:51Next slide, please. And this is just, I put some
- 6:56slides in here just to kind of make some, you
- 6:58know, make points a little bit more understandable,
- 7:01at least more indelible. And this is one of those
- 7:03where, you know, this is what clients often do.
- 7:06They'll let me explain everything. No, you don't
- 7:07want them to explain everything. You want them
- 7:09to take the time. Answer questions quickly, or
- 7:12not quickly, answer questions as short as possible,
- 7:16understanding the question that was asked, and
- 7:18then we'll move on. Next slide. So again, answer
- 7:25only the question that was asked. Do not volunteer
- 7:27information. So you should make sure that your
- 7:30clients understand that the more they volunteer,
- 7:34the longer the deposition is going to be. answering
- 7:38with people's names. Now, sometimes you can't
- 7:41get away from this. If someone asks, you know,
- 7:43were there witnesses to the car accident, you
- 7:45have to answer truthfully and let them know that
- 7:48there were, if there were, and who they were.
- 7:50But in terms of just, you know, telling a story,
- 7:53so to speak, this is not the place for your client
- 7:56to tell their story. They should not forget that
- 7:59opposing counsel is not their friend. They're
- 8:01an adversary. One of the... You know, everyone
- 8:04has their different ways of... of deposing witnesses.
- 8:10And my style is that I'm conversational. And
- 8:13you will find that if you're conversational with
- 8:15witnesses, they forget that they're in a deposition
- 8:18if you do it right. And it just feels like a
- 8:20conversation to them. And so sometimes I will
- 8:23just pause after my question or after their answer,
- 8:26and I won't ask another question. And sometimes,
- 8:29often, because it feels like a conversation,
- 8:33they will add more information and answer a question
- 8:36that I may not have asked. So you want to make
- 8:39sure that they know this is not a chance to tell
- 8:41their story. They should not forget that opposing
- 8:44counsel is not their friend. And don't volunteer
- 8:48excess information. Do not give excess or unnecessary
- 8:53explanations. Really, if you've done it right,
- 8:57and you should probably be prepping your witness
- 8:59several times before the actual day of the deposition,
- 9:03They should have heard several different types
- 9:05of questions. And you should ask. Some of those
- 9:08questions should be hard. Some of them should
- 9:10be somewhat tricky so that they understand that
- 9:12they have to listen to the question asked. If
- 9:15you have a short answer, don't give unnecessary
- 9:20information. Don't volunteer anything. The thing
- 9:24that I often say to a witness is that opposing
- 9:28counsel is entitled to your best recollection
- 9:30and your best testimony. They are not entitled
- 9:33to the ruminations in your head. If you're not
- 9:37careful, your client will go, OK, well, OK, that
- 9:39was a Wednesday. And on that Wednesday, I had
- 9:41this for breakfast. And then I went to the gym.
- 9:42And then I did this. And then I did the other
- 9:44thing. And then I had the car accident. And then
- 9:46that is a lot of information that is not necessary.
- 9:50And a good opposing counsel will take that information
- 9:54and ask questions about it. It helps them to
- 9:58determine when a story is true. But it also helps
- 10:02them find out more information about the circumstance,
- 10:05issue, and the deposition. So again, it's very
- 10:08important that they don't guess, that they can
- 10:11give an estimate, not guess, and keep their answers
- 10:13short. Next slide, please. Guessing versus knowing.
- 10:21Really should say estimate, guessing versus estimating,
- 10:23but it's the same concept. So again, no guessing,
- 10:27just estimates. And I don't know is a perfectly
- 10:29good answer. to a question if it's true, of course.
- 10:34I don't recall or I don't know the way those
- 10:36mean two different things. I don't recall means
- 10:39that I did know, but I don't know right now.
- 10:42And I don't know means I never knew. I don't
- 10:45know. I have no idea. I don't know the answer
- 10:47to that question. Both of those are acceptable
- 10:48as long as they're true. So encourage your client
- 10:53if... They don't know something. There's no reason
- 10:55for them to make up an answer or to speculate.
- 10:58If you don't know, you don't know. If you don't
- 11:00remember, you don't remember, and that's fine.
- 11:05And again, answer the freaking question. So I
- 11:12put this slide in again because it's really important
- 11:14because in the moment, again, remember your client
- 11:19has never been deposed like we've never been
- 11:21deposed before. Even with good preparation, they
- 11:25may get a little nervous or anxious during the
- 11:30deposition. And again, they'll refer or it might
- 11:32be that your opposing counsel has a very conversational
- 11:37and your witness just starts talking even when
- 11:42there's no question pending. And that's, by the
- 11:44way, another way to interject is you can actually
- 11:47say to your client, okay, there's no question
- 11:50pending, which is a cue for them to stop talking.
- 11:53So just make sure the client knows that they
- 11:56answered the question. Only the question is asked.
- 11:59They don't have to give long explanations. Just
- 12:02answer the freaking question. So when defending
- 12:11depositions, it's not the same as when you're
- 12:16objecting in court. Most of the objections in
- 12:21a deposition are, you have to make the objection
- 12:25to preserve them, some of them, for later for
- 12:29the court in case something comes up where you
- 12:31definitely want to interject your objection.
- 12:34But during the deposition, almost everything
- 12:37is fair game. We'll get to the privileges shortly.
- 12:41But most questions, the standard is that to be
- 12:47reasonably likely to lead to admissible information.
- 12:52It doesn't have to be relevant in and of itself,
- 12:56but it could lead to something relevant. So relevancy
- 13:00objections cannot be an objection to form. So
- 13:05when you have objections to form, that's what
- 13:08you say. You couldn't say objection or objections
- 13:11to the form of the question. You don't have to
- 13:12go much further than that. And most, it's not.
- 13:16It's bad form to go much further than that. Sometimes
- 13:18people say objection relevancy or objection asked
- 13:21and answered. Again, those are form objections,
- 13:25and the proper way to do that is objection to
- 13:27form. And that's it. At that point, you're not
- 13:31instructing your client not to answer the question.
- 13:34That would get you sanctioned under those circumstances.
- 13:38If the question is asked and answered, OK. Been
- 13:42known to ask questions several times. from several
- 13:44different perspectives, because you want to test
- 13:46your witness. Sometimes you're testing to see
- 13:49if they're going to give you the same answer.
- 13:50Sometimes they give you a nuanced answer, or
- 13:52they'll give you more information if you ask
- 13:54the question slightly differently. So with objections
- 13:59to form, that's all you really get as the attorney
- 14:03defending the objection is objection to form.
- 14:07Now, when you get the privilege objections, those
- 14:11are different. Objections that are not stated
- 14:15on the record are waived. So that's why you're
- 14:18saying objection to form, because if it is a
- 14:20relevancy objection or some other type of form
- 14:23objection, you're saying objection to form so
- 14:25that if it comes up later before the judge, you
- 14:28can say, yes, I objected, and this is why. Well,
- 14:31with privilege, those objections to be on the
- 14:34record right away. Objection, attorney -client
- 14:37privilege, that you instruct your witness not
- 14:39to answer. that are privileged. Because if you
- 14:41answer, if your witness violates a privilege,
- 14:45then it's waived. So you don't want to have your
- 14:50client waiving objections. There are very few
- 14:54privileged objections. We'll get to what the
- 14:56rest of them are. But the most important one
- 14:58is, of course, attorney -client privilege, or
- 15:01maybe work product. It doesn't come up as much
- 15:03as attorney -client privilege. But you want to
- 15:05make sure that you tell your client, you know,
- 15:08You instruct your client, and again, this is
- 15:09done during your prep. Tell your client, if I
- 15:12say objection, attorney -client privilege, if
- 15:15I instruct you not to answer a question, I'd
- 15:18like you to, you know, under my instructions
- 15:21and don't answer the question. I often tell my
- 15:25client, it's unlikely that this will happen,
- 15:26but it may happen, and just prepare them. If
- 15:29I instruct you not to answer a question, do not
- 15:31answer the question. All the other objections,
- 15:35the client will be confused because he'll hear
- 15:37He or she will hear the objection, and they'll
- 15:39be wondering, can I answer? Yes, they can answer,
- 15:41and they should answer. But only if it's not
- 15:44an objection, a privileged objection, in which
- 15:46case you should instruct your client not to answer.
- 15:49And that is well within the rules. There's no
- 15:53judge that would fault you for that. Objections
- 15:56to form, if you're instructing your client not
- 15:57to answer those questions, you could get sanctioned
- 16:01pretty nastily off the judge. Next slide, please.
- 16:08So again, just don't waive privileges. Any client
- 16:12privilege, there's a patient privilege. There
- 16:19are certain things that are privileged that you
- 16:20will want to preserve on the record. Otherwise,
- 16:23it's waived. And here are your privilege objections.
- 16:32Your attorney client does work product privilege.
- 16:36Again, that doesn't come up that much in a deposition,
- 16:39but it is there. There's the medical privilege
- 16:41or a doctor -patient privilege. They may ask
- 16:43you, the injury or the issue may have been a
- 16:46car accident, which is why the client is being
- 16:49deposed. But the question may come from opposing
- 16:53counsel. When did you get pregnant? Not relevant,
- 16:58and that's a medical privilege that you might
- 17:00want to preserve for your client. I would instruct
- 17:02my client, of course, as long as that's not relevant.
- 17:05do the actual issue that they're further at the
- 17:09deposition. I would instruct my client from things
- 17:11that are medical not to answer those questions.
- 17:13And most times, most accounts will understand
- 17:16that. If it's very far afield, particularly if
- 17:20it's of a personal nature, medical privilege,
- 17:24I would object. You can also use the privacy
- 17:27objection for that as well. If the person may
- 17:29have mental health issues, but those are not
- 17:31at issue. you know, in the injury or the accident
- 17:34that you're being deposed for, you would raise
- 17:38a privacy privilege or a doctor -patient privilege
- 17:40under those circumstances. And again, most times,
- 17:45you know, a judge wouldn't sanction you for those
- 17:50type of objections, losses of privilege objection.
- 17:52You're pretty good to instruct your client not
- 17:55to answer. That doesn't happen on television.
- 17:57It does not happen that much in an actual deposition.
- 18:01Next slide. So, do you want to avoid frivolous
- 18:11objections? And, you know, again, frivolous objection
- 18:14is many of the objections we just talked about,
- 18:18relevancy, hearsay, as an answer to, again, objection
- 18:21to form. But frivolous objections, they harm
- 18:26your credibility because you look You don't look
- 18:30like a good attorney. You look like you're defensive
- 18:34when you don't have to be. Let the testimony
- 18:37stand for what it is. If it's a dumb question,
- 18:40OK, it's a dumb question. Just let it go. Don't
- 18:43object for reasons like that. You can get sanctioned
- 18:47for that. It makes the deposition take a lot
- 18:49longer. And it's unprofessional. So for the most
- 18:52part, you want to avoid any of those objections
- 18:55that would be considered frivolous. And again,
- 18:57you can get sanctioned for those. And it's just
- 18:59bad form. So a speaking objection is an objection
- 19:11where you're really explaining yourself. And
- 19:17oftentimes, they're considered to be coaching
- 19:20your witness, which you're not allowed to do
- 19:22during a deposition. So if. You know that the
- 19:27question, whatever the question is, you know
- 19:29it's kind of a trick question, and you really
- 19:31want your client to answer it one way or another.
- 19:34If you haven't prepped them for it, at least
- 19:36in the moment, you're out of luck. They're going
- 19:39to answer the way they're going to answer. You
- 19:40can't interrupt with an objection and try to
- 19:43coach them as to the best way to answer that
- 19:47question. That's really bad form. I wouldn't
- 19:49take it into that position. I would stop you
- 19:51and admonish you during the deposition. and stop
- 19:55the deposition if you continue to do it. Attorneys
- 19:58are a little bit more forgiving. It depends.
- 20:00But you don't want to do speaking objections
- 20:02where your objection, that's outside the scope
- 20:06and blah, blah, blah. But you don't want to go
- 20:07through an explanation you shouldn't have to
- 20:09explain. You object on form, which is mostly
- 20:12what you're going to do. And then if you've prepped
- 20:15your client properly, just let them answer the
- 20:18question. Remind you, as we said, about taking
- 20:21a break, right? If they answer the question and
- 20:23it really is a bad answer, when you take your
- 20:25break, you know, instruct your client, hey, remember
- 20:28we talked about this? You know, this is what
- 20:32you should have said when you were asked that
- 20:34question. You'll have an opportunity to ask questions
- 20:37at the end of the deposition, and you might tell
- 20:39them in advance, I'm going to ask you that again
- 20:41and see if we can get a better, you know, answer
- 20:42it the way we practiced it. You would cure an
- 20:48answer that you weren't. really happy about during
- 20:51the deposition, but you don't want to do a speaking
- 20:53objection. They're really kind of rude. They're
- 20:56annoying. So you're extending the length of the
- 21:00deposition. And it really just is bad form. Any
- 21:05way you cut it is bad form. So no speaking objections.
- 21:09Next slide, please. And that's just a slide to
- 21:15kind of bring the point home. Don't explain.
- 21:18Let's do objection to form. I might have put
- 21:21this in the slide as well, or it's in the presentation.
- 21:24From the other perspective, if someone's objecting
- 21:26to your questions, okay, just move forward. You
- 21:28don't have to respond to the other person. It's
- 21:31in council when they object. Move forward. But
- 21:34no speaking objections. Next slide, please. Another
- 21:42example of that. And again, just objection to
- 21:45form. Two words. It's very simple. Anything beyond
- 21:50that, it's kind of similar to what I was saying
- 21:52about if your client is himself taking a breath
- 21:54as they finished an answer, they're probably
- 21:56talking too long. Same for you. If you're defending
- 21:59your client and your objection is you're taking
- 22:03a breath to continue your objection, it's highly
- 22:05likely that you're doing a speaking objection
- 22:08and you really don't want to do that. So these
- 22:14are the objections to form There are probably
- 22:16some other ones, but these are the most common.
- 22:20So the leading question, objection to form, compound
- 22:23question. Those come up where someone has asked
- 22:27the question, but they're asking two or three
- 22:29different questions. Was it dark outside? And
- 22:32was there light on? That's a compound question,
- 22:35objection to form. If the question is vague and
- 22:38ambiguous, objection to form. The cause for speculation,
- 22:43objection to form. is argumentative, same thing,
- 22:46objection to form. Now, I will say that sometimes
- 22:48during prep, I will let my client understand
- 22:54or at least try to get them to understand certain
- 22:57objections, I am kind of signaling to them. It
- 23:01depends on the sophistication of the client,
- 23:03if they can grasp this sometimes and oftentimes
- 23:06they can. If I say objection, argumentative,
- 23:10That's kind of a clue to my client. Don't fall
- 23:12for that. Objection, vague and ambiguous. You're
- 23:17not going to do this a lot, but that's a cue
- 23:19that, OK, something's wrong with that question.
- 23:22If your attorney is not understanding it, maybe
- 23:25you need to think about it a little bit before
- 23:27you answer. So the objections to form, if you
- 23:32make them short enough, it's not a speaking objection
- 23:34if you do it properly. So you can use them strategically
- 23:39if your client is savvy enough to let them understand,
- 23:43hey, if that's culture speculation, that means,
- 23:45you know, think about how this question more
- 23:48carefully and a good witness, if you've prepped
- 23:51them properly, will understand, may hear those
- 23:54objections and say, okay, that takes it special
- 23:57a little bit more of my attention. Make sure
- 23:59I answer it properly. You should also during
- 24:02prep, make sure that your client understands.
- 24:04They can ask for a question to be restated. so
- 24:07that, you know, it's clearer, you know, sometimes,
- 24:12oftentimes, opposing counsel ask a bad question.
- 24:14I do it all the time. You ask the question, then
- 24:17you realize, oh, that wasn't the best question.
- 24:19But if your witness answers it, okay, it's kind
- 24:22of a freebie sometimes. So, you know, let the
- 24:25witness know as you prepare them for deposition
- 24:27that they can say, hey, could you, you know,
- 24:29restate the question or could you ask that differently?
- 24:31Or I don't understand because, you know, they'll
- 24:34learn, you'll prep them in this way, but also
- 24:37the admonitions at the beginning of the deposition,
- 24:40they're instructed to understand that if they
- 24:43answer the question, an answer is an assumption
- 24:47that you understood the question. So it's much
- 24:51more difficult to answer the question and then
- 24:53later on say you didn't understand it, as opposed
- 24:56to just during the deposition say, hey, could
- 24:59you restate that? Did you ask that question differently?
- 25:01I'm not sure I understand. much better way to
- 25:05go. Next slide. Oh, and this is my problem. I
- 25:13talk too fast. So the fast talking opposing counsel.
- 25:17This really can mess up your record. Same goes
- 25:22for the witness. Everyone has to learn to slow
- 25:25down. I constantly tell myself that. Slow down.
- 25:30The court reporter will thank you for that because
- 25:32the court reporter is taking down everything
- 25:34that is being said, everything that's being said
- 25:37during the deposition. And they can't take down
- 25:40everything when people are talking at the same
- 25:42time. There is a skill part art in depositions
- 25:50in the cadence and understanding when a person
- 25:55is finished with their answer or their question
- 25:57and when you can speak. And you will find that
- 26:01there are witnesses and opposing counsel who
- 26:04get that wrong all the time. They don't know
- 26:07when you're finished. They start talking before
- 26:09you finish. Those mess up the record. And so
- 26:13you don't want to talk fast. You wanna take your
- 26:16time, whether you're defending or taking the
- 26:19deposition. And you wanna instruct your witness
- 26:21that they should understand slowly, don't rush,
- 26:25be clear, and take your time. So that the record
- 26:29is very clear. Next slide. So the pace of the
- 26:38deposition. Watch for rapid fire questioning.
- 26:43So one of the techniques that works, at least
- 26:46works for me, is you get into a routine. So you
- 26:51might say, you know, some very short. questions
- 26:56at the beginning before you ask a question that
- 27:00would take some nuance to answer. But if your
- 27:02witness gets into a routine, into a rhythm with
- 27:06you, they will often answer questions quickly
- 27:11without thinking about them. And that can hurt
- 27:17you if you're defending the deposition. So you
- 27:20want to make sure that there's a very Low much
- 27:25low lower cadence to the deposition itself and
- 27:28you can be strategic with your objections in
- 27:30that respect as well and what I will do is if
- 27:33you know, I you know, there's Posing councils
- 27:36asking questions and your client is answering
- 27:38them almost rapid -fire I might let that go on
- 27:42for you know, one or two questions. Maybe three
- 27:44questions and then I'll object Just say objection
- 27:48to form real purpose though is to interrupt cadence
- 27:52is to interrupt the routine. Because again, witnesses
- 27:57handle depositions different ways. If they're
- 27:59nervous, they may just talk quickly. They may
- 28:02want to get finished with the deposition and
- 28:04assume, wrongly, often, that if they just answer
- 28:07quickly, then this will all be over. They can
- 28:10answer quickly and end up really doing some sabotage
- 28:13to the case because they're giving the wrong
- 28:16answer or an answer that's not as helpful. to
- 28:19your case. So you want to watch the cadence of
- 28:23the deposition. If it seems like it's going,
- 28:26you know, your witness is answering, you know,
- 28:29really rapid fire really easily. It looks like
- 28:31they're not paying attention to the actual question.
- 28:34Object. Again, you can't coach them during the
- 28:37actual deposition, but if you're strategic about
- 28:40your objections, sometimes it just slows everybody
- 28:42down. Then you might want to, you know, let them
- 28:45take, you know, answer the question. They'll
- 28:48have to, and then you might want to ask for a
- 28:49break at that point so that you can remind your
- 28:52client you need to slow down. You know, you're
- 28:55answering these questions too quickly and you're
- 28:56not paying attention. And that also ensures the
- 29:00clarity and accuracy of the record. It is not
- 29:04uncommon for an attorney to ask a question several
- 29:08times because they're looking for a certain type
- 29:10of answer that will help them. in their case.
- 29:15And there's nothing wrong with that. So if you
- 29:21instruct your client properly, they're not just
- 29:23shooting off answers very quickly without considering
- 29:27what that might do in terms of their credibility
- 29:30and clarity of the record. And they're not going
- 29:33to be able to understand some of this because
- 29:35they've never been deposed before. your job as
- 29:38the attorney to prep them as well as you can.
- 29:41But you're looking, as a person defending the
- 29:44deposition, your job is to pay attention to what
- 29:47the question was, how quickly it was answered,
- 29:50what the consequences of that question are. You
- 29:52should be taking either notes as to where you
- 29:56need to redirect your client, because the answer
- 29:58where you need to instruct your client to go
- 30:02back on the record and Clean up an answer that
- 30:06wasn't as clear as you need it to be. So you
- 30:09don't want to watch the pace of the deposition,
- 30:12slow everybody down, object strategically when
- 30:14you need to. So this is the hostile interrogator.
- 30:24These are the attorneys who think that their
- 30:29job is to be rude. Either to your client or to
- 30:33you. I always tell my client, don't take the
- 30:36bait. I always tell my client, don't take the
- 30:38bait. But I also tell my client, my job is to
- 30:43be, if I need to be, is to be the pit bull or
- 30:47to protect you and defend you during deposition.
- 30:51I instruct my clients to always be respectful,
- 30:53answer politely, even if they think that the
- 30:56opposing counsel is being a jerk. They are to
- 30:58answer with respect. it's my job or your job
- 31:03as your attorney defending to defend your client.
- 31:07And you can object under the circumstances when
- 31:13your client is being badgered. I think next slide.
- 31:19So if your client is being browbeaten, sometimes...
- 31:25Those accounts will ask questions quickly because
- 31:28they're they want to get through with the deposition
- 31:30for some reason or maybe that's their technique
- 31:32in their style You want to slow that down because
- 31:34it feels like to you. Maybe it feels like they're
- 31:37bullying your witness You don't want that and
- 31:40you can definitely, you know object based on
- 31:44on bullying your witness or or being Argumentative
- 31:47if they really are it has to be egregious. I
- 31:50mean, you know, of course litigation is adversarial,
- 31:53right? So Sometimes you or your client may not
- 31:55like the question that was asked. It doesn't
- 31:57mean it was an improper question. It doesn't
- 31:59mean it was bullying or harassing. So be strategic
- 32:02about this as well. But stand your ground. Make
- 32:05a clear record. If opposing counsel is unprofessional,
- 32:08you might want to say that on the record. Because
- 32:10remember, the transcript, there's no nuance in
- 32:13the transcript. You can't get necessarily you
- 32:15don't get total voice in the transcript, right?
- 32:19So you might want to say, you know, objection,
- 32:22please don't yell at the witness, because if
- 32:23you don't say that, there's no there's nothing
- 32:25in the record that would let someone know who's
- 32:27reading the transcript that the opposing counsel
- 32:29was raising their voice. So if that something
- 32:32like that happens that you want to make a record
- 32:34of that. You can seek court intervention, but
- 32:38that's really a last resort. If you if you don't
- 32:41know, you will learn that judges really hate
- 32:44of discovery, which includes deposition battles.
- 32:50So you don't want the judge involved unless there
- 32:52absolutely is no other way to do that. So there
- 32:58is probably, think of it in terms of tiers or
- 33:01stages if you're at this point in a deposition
- 33:04and opposing counsels being harassing or bullying
- 33:07or unprofessional. You might object first. Just
- 33:11say, objection to form. You might just start
- 33:13off objection to form. If it happens again, you
- 33:15might object, you know, please don't harass the
- 33:19witness or objection, you know, harassing the
- 33:21witness. Next time it happens again, objection,
- 33:26you know, please don't raise your voice at the
- 33:27witness. And then at that point, I might start
- 33:30instructing, informing opposing counsel of what's
- 33:33going to happen next. Objection. If you ask the
- 33:35question, you know, in the same manner again,
- 33:37I may, you know, suspend this deposition. may
- 33:40instruct my client not to answer because at some
- 33:43point you'll have to, you may have to take control
- 33:45if it's just getting out of hand. Again, these
- 33:47are not things that happen common, you know,
- 33:49that often. So you don't get this at every deposition.
- 33:54You don't get to just, oh, you're yelling at
- 33:55my witness. You know, I'm suspending this deposition.
- 33:57Please don't do that unless it's really important
- 33:59because you will look foolish and could be sanctioned
- 34:03by the judge. So you want to make sure you're
- 34:06careful about this, but you also stand your ground.
- 34:09Don't. You want to make sure you also don't look
- 34:14like you look unflappable. Don't let them see
- 34:17you sweat, I think is a common expression that
- 34:20people say. You want to just keep your cool the
- 34:23whole time, even if opposing counsel is unprofessional.
- 34:27Because it speaks highly of you as an attorney.
- 34:30It shows your confidence about your abilities
- 34:32and your confidence about the case. It makes
- 34:35your law firm look good. And then if you do end
- 34:38up before the judge in the discovery dispute,
- 34:41it's very clear to a judge if there's one party
- 34:44that's very calm and the other side is being
- 34:47ridiculous. You don't want to have both sides
- 34:50being ridiculous. Then the judge is really annoyed
- 34:52and may sanction both of you. So again, you will
- 34:55stand your ground, of course. Don't allow your
- 34:57client to be bullied. Make a clear record. Make
- 35:02it clear that opposing counsel You know, you
- 35:05can sit down counsel. There's no reason to stand
- 35:07during deposition. You know, things happen in
- 35:09depositions and there's no, especially if it's
- 35:11not being videotaped. And often, even if it is,
- 35:14because the videotape is on the witness, it's
- 35:16not on the attorney. So if you need to make something
- 35:19clear for the record, you can. You seek court
- 35:21intervention if you absolutely need to, but you
- 35:25don't want to use that unless it's absolutely,
- 35:26you know, you have no other option. Okay, move
- 35:31on. The improper catch -all question is what
- 35:37I was saying earlier about compound questions.
- 35:40These are objections to form. Sometimes the attorney,
- 35:44again, it's not always on purpose, but it could
- 35:46be on purpose or it could just be a bad question
- 35:48by accident. If it's a compound question, you
- 35:51don't want to let your client answer it because
- 35:53it's not clear on the record which question they're
- 35:55answering. So if they say, and these are often
- 35:59come up because they're written questions in
- 36:01discovery, that's fine to say state all facts
- 36:03regarding the issue. That's fine. Or all witnesses
- 36:08that saw, you know, whatever happened, in a written
- 36:13discovery, that's fine. And during a deposition,
- 36:16it's not fair, you know, the witness to state
- 36:19all facts and to remember, you know, all witnesses
- 36:21or, you know, identify all documents. Those are
- 36:23things that are unfair. It's a bad form to ask
- 36:27those a deposition. So it's okay to object, but
- 36:30you object on form. And that's really it. There's
- 36:33no continued objection. You don't speak during
- 36:34the, you know, during the speaking objection,
- 36:36it still would be bad form there as well. Slide.
- 36:45So, as I said, objections to form is fine. Often,
- 36:50when you start hearing about relevancy, hearsay,
- 36:53competence, these are, that's improper objection.
- 36:57People do it, but you want to be the attorney.
- 37:00who understands the code and how to defend depositions
- 37:05properly. You want to just say objection to form.
- 37:08If you're not used to that, maybe it feels like
- 37:10you're not saying anything, but opposing counsel
- 37:12understands. Now, they don't have to change the
- 37:15question necessarily, but just by saying objection
- 37:18to form, you preserved your objection. If they
- 37:20try to read that into the transcript later during
- 37:22trial, you have an ability to say there was an
- 37:27objection there and explain what it was. But
- 37:30again, even if it's a, you know, there's an objection
- 37:33on competency or if you're objecting based on
- 37:36hearsay or relevance, those are great at trial,
- 37:38but they don't help you during a deposition.
- 37:41So those are objections to form. That's all you
- 37:43need to say. And that's it. Next slide. So we
- 37:54can go to questions after this because we're
- 37:56pretty much done with bites. primary presentation,
- 38:00and I can provide anecdotes as well as answer
- 38:02questions, but key takeaways. Good preparation
- 38:07prevents deposition disasters. So you want to
- 38:11make sure that you've met with your client several
- 38:14times, that you've, you know, several different
- 38:19types of questions that you've, you know, tested
- 38:23them on. Make sure they understand how to answer
- 38:27a question properly, how to listen to the question
- 38:30that's asked and answer only the question that
- 38:32was asked. I'll take some time. How to give you
- 38:37short answers. Again, it should be as short as
- 38:40possible. Their answers should be as short as
- 38:43possible unless you ask them the question. It's
- 38:47safe for them to answer. give you a long form
- 38:50answer if you're asking the question, because
- 38:51you're going to ask them a question that would
- 38:53elicit a long form answer that's helpful to you.
- 38:56But you don't want that from the opposing counsel.
- 39:00Oh, you want to make sure that they are prepared.
- 39:03They give you short answers. You want to make
- 39:05sure you object early and that you protect your
- 39:08privileges. And you want to remain professional
- 39:10at all. These are not things, at the beginning,
- 39:14it's not intuitive. You have to remember a lot
- 39:18of these things at the beginning because they're
- 39:20not intuitive. You're remembering to listen to
- 39:23the question that's asked. Just like you asked
- 39:25your client, you have to listen to the question
- 39:27that's asked too, because you should know what
- 39:28the answer is, or at least what you want it to
- 39:31be, and then be able to redirect your client.
- 39:35You should make sure that the answers your witness
- 39:38is giving are short. And if they're not, you
- 39:41want to throw in your objection to kind of break
- 39:43it up, that cadence. is that conversational cadence
- 39:48in terms between the opposing counsel and your
- 39:51witness, you don't want that. You don't want
- 39:56them to be comfortable with opposing counsel.
- 39:58You want your witness to be somewhat circumspect.
- 40:00You want them to think that, oh, every question
- 40:02might be a trick question. So I need to think
- 40:04about the answer. Train your clients to understand
- 40:08that if you object and you say more than objection
- 40:11to form, there's probably a reason. that you're
- 40:13doing that so you can't say much but if you say
- 40:16object vague and ambiguous clue to your client
- 40:19I mean that was a trick question so key takeaways
- 40:24i'm trying to get you to think about is what
- 40:25you're doing if you're defending an objection
- 40:27if you're defending a deposition you want to
- 40:29make sure that you're you're very limited in
- 40:32what you can do you want to make sure that you
- 40:34use your tools properly use your preparation
- 40:37really strategically your client should have
- 40:40heard every type of question, and be prepared
- 40:42to answer every type of question, trick question
- 40:45or not trick question. They should understand
- 40:47that their answers should be short. They should
- 40:50understand when you object in a certain way that
- 40:55sounds different, they should go, OK, be careful
- 40:57about my answer to that. And you should be professional
- 40:59at all times. And then just a well -defendant
- 41:07deposition protects your client. It protects
- 41:10your credibility and it protects your case. Those
- 41:14are the things that you really want to focus
- 41:16on. There's nothing worse than spending five
- 41:18hours into the deposition and then realizing
- 41:20when you get the transcript that your client
- 41:22gave a lot of information that wasn't helpful.
- 41:25Your client ruined their credibility by answering
- 41:29argumentatively, for example, when they should
- 41:32have been answering respectfully. and it could
- 41:37ruin your case. So you wanna really be careful
- 41:39when you're defending depositions because again,
- 41:42most of our focus often is on taking the deposition,
- 41:44which is a whole different skill set. But if
- 41:47you're defending a deposition, it's equally important
- 41:50and often more important how you defend your
- 41:53client, protect them and protect your record
- 41:56and protect your case. Are there any questions?
- 42:03Hi Tony, so it looks like we actually have eight
- 42:05questions so far within the Q &A box. Starting
- 42:08off with one from Cedar asking, do any of these
- 42:11tips differ when you are defending an expert's
- 42:14deposition as opposed to a client's deposition?
- 42:17They do a lot different and that's a whole different
- 42:21skill set. Expert depositions are a skill set
- 42:25unto themselves. They're so different that we
- 42:29really can't get into them that much right here,
- 42:31but I will say that they are different in that
- 42:34experts are presumed to have a certain level
- 42:37of expertise. You don't protect them the same
- 42:41way that you protect a lay witness. So yes, they're
- 42:45very different the way you defend an expert than
- 42:48the way you defend a lay witness. Great. Thank
- 42:52you. I have another question from Richard asking,
- 42:55would a question that violates a protective order
- 42:57be considered a privacy privilege objection that
- 42:59you can instruct your client not to answer? Yes.
- 43:04I mean, it depends on what the question is, whether
- 43:06or not it's privacy. But if it violates a protective
- 43:10order, that's what your objection would be. That's
- 43:12outside the scope. It violates a protective order
- 43:14that's already been put in places on file with
- 43:18the you know with the with the court that's totally
- 43:21valid objection and would be expected that if
- 43:24the question violates the protective order you
- 43:26would object and instruct your client not to
- 43:28answer and again opposing counsel understand
- 43:31that sometimes they don't maybe the person taking
- 43:33the objection is not handling attorney and they
- 43:36may be prepared for the objection but i'm prepared
- 43:39for the deposition and not as as prepared as
- 43:42maybe the handling attorney but but doesn't matter
- 43:45if it's violating a protective order, yes, you
- 43:47would instruct them not to answer the question,
- 43:49but you'd also put on the record why you're instructing
- 43:52them not to answer and explain that there is
- 43:53a protective order around that subject that is
- 43:56being questioned. Great, thank you. And we have
- 44:01another one from Cedar asking, how do you want
- 44:04your clients and experts to dress? Looking innocent
- 44:07and truthful, conveying gravitas, or experience
- 44:10calming, confident, or something else? Good question,
- 44:14because it really depends. First of all, the
- 44:16general rule, I tell all my clients, dress as
- 44:19if you were either business professional or sometimes
- 44:22I say as if you were going to church. You want
- 44:26them to be dressed professionally, sure. If they're
- 44:31a military officer, maybe you want them in officer
- 44:35dress. It depends on the witness and what the
- 44:37issues are, but you want them to dress you know,
- 44:40well, you don't want you don't want them to be
- 44:42to look like they just, you know, walked in,
- 44:44you know, from the gym or something like that.
- 44:46But the reason it depends on the witness, though,
- 44:49is because, for example, what if your witness
- 44:52is a CEO of a large corporation and you want
- 44:56them to be convey that they're, you know, they
- 45:01have that they're humble and that they have empathy,
- 45:03you would maybe say to the witness, you know,
- 45:06don't wear a tie, you know, wear a dress shirt
- 45:08and maybe wear a jacket, but don't wear a tie.
- 45:09So it really depends on the witness and what
- 45:12the circumstances are of the deposition. But
- 45:15you at least want them to dress respectfully
- 45:18and be well dressed. Great, thank you. And I
- 45:24have another question from James. Can you point
- 45:27to authority that states that objection to form
- 45:30is permitted and you are not required to state
- 45:33any more than that? I was criticized recently
- 45:35by the court for objecting to form only and a
- 45:38new deposition and was compelled. That's interesting.
- 45:42I'm very curious as to what you did that. So
- 45:46you were criticized for objecting to form, but
- 45:51I'm trying to think of the statues. I'm actually
- 45:53looking to see what I have in terms of my notes
- 45:59here. So I may have to get back to you because
- 46:02I don't remember statues off the top of my head,
- 46:04but I may have to get back to you in email. By
- 46:07all means, you can email me at tony .rosswilsonelzer
- 46:12.com. Let's go to the next question. At the same
- 46:17time, I'm going to look to see if I can find
- 46:18the statute that helps you with that. Great.
- 46:21Thank you. And then I have someone asking if
- 46:26relevance is an improper objection. It's improper?
- 46:32Yes. The short answer is yes. But if it's so
- 46:35irrelevant, so far afield, it might end up being
- 46:38a privacy objection or a doctor -patient privilege
- 46:41objection. Relevance by itself is a bad objection.
- 46:45You can object to form, but that's all you get.
- 46:48But objections to form, remember, objections
- 46:50to form don't stop the deposition. They don't
- 46:52stop the client from answering the question.
- 46:54They just preserve the objection. So if it's
- 46:56a relevancy objection, you say objection to form,
- 46:58relevancy, or objection to form, that's fine.
- 47:02That's all you would get. You don't get to tell
- 47:05your client not to answer because it's not relevant
- 47:07unless it's way far afield. But those, again,
- 47:10those are rare. Thank you. Another question.
- 47:15What is the authority for only saying objection
- 47:18as to form rather than slightly more specific,
- 47:20such as objection compound or objection vague
- 47:23as to time? Again, objection to form is considered
- 47:28the cleanest and the most respectful way to do
- 47:31it. You can say those other things, and often
- 47:32people do. Sometimes you do that because you're
- 47:35also reminding yourself, even when you go back
- 47:36and look at the transcript, you want to remember
- 47:38why you objected. And sometimes you're signaling
- 47:42to opposing counsel. If you say objection to
- 47:46form, let's say opposing counsel is a relatively
- 47:51young attorney. you might say objection compound
- 47:55that's an instruction essentially you're letting
- 47:57them know there was more than one question in
- 48:00that in that in that question and that may help
- 48:04opposing counsel whether they listen to you or
- 48:06not is up to them so That's why you would say
- 48:10it. It really depends on, you know, maybe the
- 48:13sophistication of the opposing counsel, because
- 48:16objection to form, I will say objection to form,
- 48:18but I know the other side is very sophisticated,
- 48:20and there's no reason for me to get, you know,
- 48:22more granular than that. But sometimes you do
- 48:24want to say objection relevancy, objection, you
- 48:27know, compound, objection asked and answered.
- 48:29Again, you can do that. And for the question
- 48:32that was asking that, that's earlier about the
- 48:35authority, and he may have been saying, he said
- 48:36he was sanctioned because he only said objection
- 48:38to form. If there are only objections to form
- 48:41and there's never ever an explanation, it may
- 48:44look to a judge as though you're just, you know,
- 48:47you're obstructing the deposition. And so, again,
- 48:52some of this stuff is art versus skill, because
- 48:56I object to form all the time and I've never
- 48:58been sanctioned for it, but also I'm doing that
- 49:01based on the totality of the full deposition.
- 49:04Like I said, if it's a very sophisticated opposing
- 49:06counsel, I object to form and they understand.
- 49:09everybody moves on, they may restate the question
- 49:11in a better form. But if the question is compound,
- 49:16if the question is, let's say they say, tell
- 49:19me was the light red, and the car was coming,
- 49:23and the pedestrian was in the street, that's
- 49:25a very compound question. And they ask it several
- 49:28times, you might want to say objection, compound.
- 49:31You're asking three different questions within,
- 49:33that's not really speaking objection, it is,
- 49:36but you're trying now to be clear. to opposing
- 49:38counsel, why you may have to instruct your witness
- 49:41not to answer. Again, these are rare, but if
- 49:44you're saying objection to form and nothing changes,
- 49:49but the question is so bad that you really need
- 49:52to clear it up for the record, you may have to
- 49:54be a little bit more clear about what the form
- 49:58objection is. Again, it may be more art than
- 50:04skill sometimes in the objection, but But objection
- 50:07to form, generally speaking, is totally acceptable.
- 50:10You don't have to go much further than that,
- 50:12but sometimes you do. I have another question
- 50:17if you can elaborate a little on address preparation
- 50:24for video depositions. So the preparation for
- 50:29video depositions is almost the same. The difference
- 50:32is that you want to remind your client that they're
- 50:34on camera. facial expressions obviously come
- 50:40through on camera. If they're rolling their eyes,
- 50:43if they look bored, if they look mad, those are
- 50:48things that you definitely don't want during
- 50:51a video recording deposition because that could
- 50:55be used against you. This day and age, especially
- 50:59after COVID, it used to be that almost always,
- 51:03almost always depositions were in person. You
- 51:07know, you go to the office of the opposing counsel
- 51:09or they bring the witness to your office and
- 51:12everyone's in the same room. Even when they're
- 51:14videotaped, everybody's there. But when you went
- 51:17to trial, you can object. Often people would
- 51:21want to introduce the video of the deposition
- 51:23and you can object because, you know, the witness
- 51:25is available. The witness is here. Why use the
- 51:28videotape? Have them answer the question on the
- 51:31stand. not as common anymore. Oftentimes now,
- 51:35almost all of the witness testimony can come
- 51:40through during the deposition. And so if that's
- 51:44the only chance that the jury is going to see
- 51:47either your client or the witness, you definitely
- 51:49want to know that they are putting their best
- 51:52foot forward in a video deposition, because that
- 51:54may be the only way that the jury sees them.
- 51:58So you want to make sure they're dressed appropriately.
- 52:00You want to make sure that they're not not disrespectful,
- 52:03they don't get angry, they don't look bored.
- 52:07So, you know, there are all kinds of depositions
- 52:10available on the internet and I encourage people
- 52:12to go check them out because there are lots of
- 52:15depositions, videotape depositions that you can
- 52:17see online and you can see just by watching the
- 52:20video why there's a bad deposition. I don't know
- 52:23if you've ever seen some of Donald Trump's depositions.
- 52:26that have been videotaped, he can be really combative
- 52:29and answer questions really horribly. That wouldn't
- 52:34necessarily come across if it was just the transcript
- 52:37you were reading, but when you see his facial
- 52:38expression or hear his tone of voice, it looks
- 52:42bad. So you want to be careful with the videotape
- 52:46depositions, and most videotapes, the depositions
- 52:50are videotaped nowadays. Great, thank you. And
- 52:56I have someone who is asking, what if the questions
- 52:59go beyond what is alleged in the complaint? So
- 53:03that's a relevancy. Outside the scope also is
- 53:07how you would look at that. Again, remember,
- 53:13the standard is if it's to be reasonably likely
- 53:19to lead to admissible evidence or admissible
- 53:22information. So it can be outside the scope.
- 53:25and still be within the bounds of a deposition
- 53:30question. And almost all questions at deposition
- 53:33are fair game. That's why it's rare that you
- 53:35would be instructing your witness not to answer.
- 53:39So you'd have to kind of monitor it. Let's say
- 53:41the first question, I mean, it depends on how
- 53:42far afield, right? You could maybe let the question
- 53:44go if it's outside the scope, it's a little far
- 53:47afield, but it's no harm, no foul, right? But
- 53:51if it's really, you know, often did you beat
- 53:54your wife? and this is the question about a car
- 53:56accident, an issue about is the car accident
- 53:58why you're being deposed, that is so far outside
- 54:01the scope that you would object and say relevancy,
- 54:06privacy, harassing the witness, or you're negative,
- 54:10and I might instruct my client not to answer
- 54:12that question. Is there a reason why you're asking
- 54:15that question? You might ask the opposing counsel
- 54:17on the record why they're asking that question,
- 54:19if it's so far afield. And depending on the answer
- 54:21you get, you can make, You would say, I'm sorry,
- 54:25counsel, but I'm going to have to instruct my
- 54:27client to answer that. You want to be on solid
- 54:29ground if you do that because you'll get sanctioned
- 54:33or you could get sanctioned anyway. You're not
- 54:35right. But sometimes it's so far field that you
- 54:37have no choice. Thank you. And then I have a
- 54:42similar question. How do you address questions
- 54:44around a prior confidential global settlement
- 54:47agreement by the opposing attorney? So that's
- 54:51kind of similar to protective order. So there
- 54:54are different ways to do that. You might object
- 55:00on relevancy, or you might say there's a protective
- 55:03order. I mean, well, it's confidential. And you
- 55:07can say that on the record. Sometimes you might
- 55:10ask to go off the record and have a discussion
- 55:13with opposing counsel off the record about that
- 55:16question. Maybe they didn't remember. Maybe they
- 55:18did not know. they're not necessarily trying
- 55:21to get away with something, they just weren't,
- 55:24they didn't know that there was a protective
- 55:27order around the answer to that question. And
- 55:30so sometimes that's how you'd handle it, but
- 55:32you definitely wouldn't want, don't let your
- 55:33client answer it if it's something that's confidential.
- 55:40Thank you. And then let's see. We have a question
- 55:46from Brad. What if an attorney is being deposed
- 55:49in a civil claim that he is a plaintiff? How
- 55:52should he dress for deposition? Ask that question
- 55:57again, please. All right. What if an attorney
- 56:01is being deposed in a civil claim that he is
- 56:04a plaintiff? How should he dress for a deposition?
- 56:08I mean, again, they should always dress like
- 56:11they're business casual, or sometimes I say,
- 56:14like I said, as if they're going to church. It
- 56:17really wouldn't matter whether they're a plaintiff
- 56:19or just a witness. You don't want them to look
- 56:21sloppy. You want them to look credible. Consider
- 56:26how you would look at a person, whether you would
- 56:30find their answer to be credible, depending on
- 56:33how they dress. And so you want to have your
- 56:36client or portray themselves in a way that a
- 56:39jury would accept their answer and accept them
- 56:42as a credible historian as to what they're answering
- 56:46about. Great, thank you. So it looks like Rogelio
- 56:52Ruiz is asking, my understanding is that the
- 56:55grounds to justify leaving the deposition is
- 56:57narrow. What are the grounds to leave the deposition?
- 57:01Very, very narrow. So again, the grounds would
- 57:03be, you know, harassing, questions that are really
- 57:07far afield are really, again, egregious. If the
- 57:12opposing council is calling your witness names
- 57:14or calling you names, sustained yelling, God
- 57:21forbid, being profanity during the deposition
- 57:25questioning, it would have to be really egregious
- 57:29to suspend the deposition. It's very, very rare.
- 57:33I don't think I've ever. and remember ever suspending
- 57:36a deposition. Now you can threaten to suspend
- 57:37a deposition. Sometimes that's all you need to
- 57:39do. And again, sometimes you go off the record.
- 57:42Sometimes you can have a discussion with opposing
- 57:44counsel and maybe calm things down. I don't think
- 57:49I've ever suspended a deposition for real. I
- 57:53may have threatened it once or twice, but I've
- 57:54never really done it. It's real, really, really
- 57:57rare. Again, opposing counsel usually understands
- 58:01the consequences and circumstances as well. You
- 58:04don't want to be, and I definitely have seen
- 58:06this, I've been in depositions that were suspended
- 58:08improperly, not by me, but by another attorney.
- 58:11You don't want to be that guy or that gal. You
- 58:14don't want to be the person that suspends a deposition
- 58:16prematurely and then gets called on the carpet
- 58:18by the judge or by your partner at a firm. You
- 58:22get called on the carpet by your partner. You
- 58:25don't want to do it unless you absolutely have
- 58:27to do it. It has to be because attorney -client
- 58:30privilege is being insisted upon, badgering the
- 58:35witness, really unprofessional behavior. Those
- 58:39are usually the circumstances where you would
- 58:41suspend the deposition. Great. And it looks like
- 58:47we have just two questions left. First one. When
- 58:51there's a single question based on several facts,
- 58:54is objection compound improper? No, it's not
- 58:58improper and it's necessary. So it is an objection
- 59:03to form, but if you're really trying to signal
- 59:06opposing counsel because then maybe they don't
- 59:07realize the question is compound. If that's the
- 59:10case, no, it's definitely it's proper to object
- 59:13if the question is compound and you want to protect
- 59:15your witness because you don't want them to answer
- 59:17a compound question because then it's not clear
- 59:19what question they're answering. So it is proper
- 59:22and necessary to object. And again, if they do
- 59:25answer because the opposing counsel either doesn't
- 59:27get the memo, so to speak, then it is what it
- 59:30is. But you then take advantage of it later on.
- 59:34When opposing counsel tries to use that answer,
- 59:35you might point out, I objected. It's a compound
- 59:38question. And so I'm not sure that the answer
- 59:41is. you know means what the opposing counsel
- 59:43thinks it means and that would be the opposing
- 59:45counsel's fault for asking a bad question but
- 59:47you do want to object um if it's if it's compound
- 59:49yes great thank you and our last question from
- 59:53the honorable victoria cheney how do you handle
- 59:56uh the secret how do you handle secret coaching
- 1:00:00on video such as texting between the attorney
- 1:00:02and the witness good question and that's really
- 1:00:05important so a couple ways to handle this these
- 1:00:08kept this these issues came up because again
- 1:00:11pre -COVID, everybody was in the same room. And
- 1:00:14so you could usually see what was happening,
- 1:00:17even if someone, if opposing counsel is sitting
- 1:00:19next to their witness and passing notes back
- 1:00:24and forth, that's improper. If I see something
- 1:00:27like that, it depends on how egregious it is.
- 1:00:30So you might want to give a warning first on
- 1:00:33the record. Remind everyone that you can't coach
- 1:00:39a witness during a deposition. But one of the
- 1:00:42other things that you can use, and I have definitely
- 1:00:45used this, anything that a witness brings into
- 1:00:49the deposition is discoverable. So if a witness
- 1:00:55is looking at a cheat sheet, for example, that
- 1:00:58they either have in their pocket or they maybe
- 1:01:00have a legal pad in front of them that actually
- 1:01:02has some answers to questions that they anticipate,
- 1:01:05you can ask for a copy of what it is they're
- 1:01:07reading. and what it is they have on them. I
- 1:01:10instruct my clients, do not bring anything. I
- 1:01:12often tell them to leave their phone somewhere
- 1:01:14else if we're doing an in -person deposition.
- 1:01:16Because even if they bring their phone, you may
- 1:01:19be entitled to something that's on their phone,
- 1:01:22depending on the question and the circumstances.
- 1:01:25So one, you do a warning. I would do a warning
- 1:01:28on the record. Remind opposing counsel there's
- 1:01:30no coaching of witnesses. And you might want
- 1:01:33to do that once or twice. But you are entitled
- 1:01:36to anything that the witness is reading or referring
- 1:01:39to during a deposition. And I have insisted on
- 1:01:45what the witness was reading turned out to be
- 1:01:51instructions from opposing counsel that they
- 1:01:53should not have had. You're entitled to anything
- 1:01:56that a witness brings into a deposition, you're
- 1:01:58entitled to it. So that's sometimes how you have
- 1:02:01to. you have to go about getting to the bottom
- 1:02:05of coaching a witness. Great. So it looks like
- 1:02:11that's it for questions today, Tony. Do you have
- 1:02:13any other concluding remarks that you'd like
- 1:02:15to make? I don't think so. I mean, I would just
- 1:02:17remind everyone, depositions can be, I mean,
- 1:02:20they're a great tool to use to find out. You
- 1:02:25want to, you know, deposition definitely gives
- 1:02:28you information about the case, of course, obviously.
- 1:02:31It also gives you a lot of information about
- 1:02:32the witness. Is this a credible witness? Is this
- 1:02:34a witness that you can tell? Is this a witness
- 1:02:36that gives you really honest and clear and concise
- 1:02:39answers? Depending on what side of the V you're
- 1:02:41on, that may not be a witness you want. I mean,
- 1:02:44that can settle your case. If the star witness
- 1:02:49is clear and concise and dresses appropriately
- 1:02:53and answers your question, clearly, succinctly,
- 1:02:57and you can't trip them up, you might want to
- 1:02:59think about settling the case if that's one of
- 1:03:04the circumstances of what you were looking to
- 1:03:06determine during the deposition. So it's a good
- 1:03:10tool to have in your tool belt. You can learn
- 1:03:14a lot about your case. You can learn a lot about
- 1:03:15the witnesses. You learn a lot about if there
- 1:03:18are other issues involved. Maybe you didn't know
- 1:03:21that there were other witnesses or other injuries
- 1:03:23or prior similar acts by another party to the
- 1:03:30case. So you just want to go in, have fun with
- 1:03:33them. Like I said, art and the skill, and if
- 1:03:37you develop it properly, there are lots of attorneys
- 1:03:39who, I know lots of attorneys who almost their
- 1:03:42entire practice is to take depositions because
- 1:03:45they're so good at it. You can elicit a lot of
- 1:03:49information. And again, the depositions are different.
- 1:03:53And so that's a different skill set. And it's
- 1:03:56a lot of fun. And it then exercises the parts
- 1:04:00of the brain that a lot of us as attorneys really
- 1:04:02like to exercise because it's complex and can
- 1:04:06be interesting and can be fun and informative.
- 1:04:12Thank you, everybody, for listening to this presentation.
- 1:04:16And if you have any questions, feel free to email
- 1:04:19me. And thank you again. Thank you again. Thank
- 1:04:24you, Tony, for an excellent presentation. And
- 1:04:26thank you so much to our audience. Have a great
- 1:04:28day, everybody.