Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Bad Girl (1931)
Transcript
- 0:13Hey everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:16at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. And I'm a white guy with a podcast.
- 0:22This is true. Me too, dude. Oh wow! Isn't that
- 0:24wild? Another thing we have in common. Wild how
- 0:27many things there are that we have in common.
- 0:29I know. I'm Ryan, by the way. Did you say that?
- 0:31I think I said I'm a white guy with a podcast.
- 0:33Did I? Oh, you did. Excuse my memory. Just in
- 0:36case. If you didn't listen to the last episode,
- 0:38this all might... We might not be recording.
- 0:41This could be a fever dream of mine. I panic
- 0:43checked the recording. We are, in fact, recording.
- 0:45Okay, well, I just imagine waking up tomorrow
- 0:47and you're like, hey, buddy, sorry you didn't
- 0:49ever show up for recording. I'm like, I recorded
- 0:51two episodes. And I'm like, but it's fine. We
- 0:53got another random white guy that liked a podcast.
- 0:56And no one noticed the difference. We are talking
- 0:59about our second movie in the fifth Academy Award
- 1:02year, and that would be Frank Borsage's Bad Girl.
- 1:06So cool. First movie we covered for the Fifth
- 1:08Academy, we had The Return of Ernst Lubitsch.
- 1:10Yeah. Second film, The Return of original Best
- 1:14Director winner. Frank Borsage, famously of Seventh
- 1:18Heaven. Yes, and a cool little feat that he achieves
- 1:22here that we'll talk a little bit in comparison
- 1:24to Lewis Milestone, but there's a lot of cool
- 1:26little details behind Frank Borsage's second
- 1:29feature in the Academy Awards. So Bad Girls specifically
- 1:33had three nominations. It was nominated for Best
- 1:36Picture. This was on behalf of Fox. Nominated
- 1:38for Best Director, which was Frank Borsage, and
- 1:41Best Adapted Screenplay from Edwin J. Burke.
- 1:44But because it's adapted, So it is based on the
- 1:461928 novel written by Fina Del Mar. And there
- 1:49was a 1930 play, which was also written by Fina
- 1:51Del Mar, but also Brian Marlowe. So who is in
- 1:56Bad Girl, Kyle? In Bad Girl, you have James Dunn,
- 1:59Sally Eilers. I thought Ellers. Sally Ellers
- 2:03and Mina Gombel, excuse me. I also have William
- 2:07Pauly as Jim Haley. Is that the brother? That
- 2:11is the brother. That's the brother. Okay. But
- 2:12there's a little interesting detail about him
- 2:14too. Oh, okay. A little fun detail right off
- 2:16the bat here. Obviously, Sally Ellers plays Dorothy
- 2:19Haley and James Dunn plays Eddie Collins. But
- 2:21did you notice in the very end of this movie,
- 2:23the end credits, it lists Sally Ellers as the
- 2:26girl? Yes. And James Dunn as the boy. I really
- 2:28like that. I thought so too. It did kind of send
- 2:31me on an existential crisis a bit where I was
- 2:33like, I'm pretty sure I know their names. Right.
- 2:35People call them Dot and Eddie. You know, I want
- 2:38to come back to that boy and girl thing at the
- 2:41end because I think it is a very nice cherry
- 2:43on top for the movie as a whole. But yeah, bad
- 2:46girl. Interesting story in how it was made and
- 2:50like how we got the end product we did. Off and
- 2:53on screen. Exactly. This is a story that contains
- 2:57many taboos of the time. This is very pre -code
- 3:01Hollywood. You can feel that they've taken this
- 3:04story that has some... quote unquote, unsavory
- 3:08topics and really tweak them to fit the sensors
- 3:12and all of that. And I think they did so in a
- 3:15way that I would say was very successful. I would
- 3:18too. I think specifically to the opening sequence
- 3:21of Bad Girl shows us Sally Ehlers walking down
- 3:25the aisle. This is Dorothy. And you see her talking
- 3:27with someone else who's hemming her dress saying,
- 3:29hey, gets easier on the eighth or ninth time.
- 3:31And this is the satire of like, you know, getting
- 3:34married multiple times. But then it becomes clear
- 3:36that she is a runway or a wedding dress model.
- 3:39Yeah. And that she really isn't getting married.
- 3:42This then starts the story of how she does. talk
- 3:47with a lot of men she feels like she gets picked
- 3:49up all the time almost to a point where she and
- 3:51her friend kind of find different ways to annoy
- 3:53men which i gotta tell you this movie was is
- 3:56it edith it's it's dorothy and edith edna edna
- 4:00thank you so dorothy and edna if this movie was
- 4:02dorothy and edna finding different ways to like
- 4:04annoy men i'm just like what if i play my ukulele
- 4:07really loud next to you I think I would love
- 4:09this movie. Yeah. But in doing this, she meets
- 4:11Eddie Collins. She strikes up a conversation
- 4:13with him. And the crux of this movie is that
- 4:16she finds herself staying at Eddie Collins' place
- 4:18specifically until 4 a .m., which is taboo. Nothing
- 4:21is alluded to having happened, but she's there
- 4:23until 4 a .m. And in effort to not get in trouble
- 4:26with her brother, who among us can't relate to
- 4:28this, they got married to avoid any kind of controversy
- 4:32there. And I think that itself lends itself exactly
- 4:36to what you're saying. of how it tried to talk
- 4:39about the code, or it tried to get around what
- 4:42eventually became the code. And it had a very
- 4:44difficult time getting made because the source
- 4:47material of this does not shy away from what
- 4:51this movie alludes to. Right. The source material
- 4:54talks very clearly when Dorothy stays at Eddie's
- 4:58place. It blatantly says, like, they had a romantic
- 5:01evening. They had a fling. That's just alluded
- 5:04to here. And really, almost... in a way that
- 5:07you don't know if they did or didn't, but because
- 5:10her brother believes so, we'll just go with that.
- 5:13Sure, they did. There's a lot of stuff in here
- 5:15about visits to the doctors and things that are
- 5:19kind of left out of the movie or are played more
- 5:21for laughs. A lot of tweaks. When Fox, I believe,
- 5:25yeah, Fox wanted to have the movie made and they
- 5:28could not find a director to make this movie
- 5:30because everybody was like, I'm not touching
- 5:32that book. I'm going to have to twist it so much
- 5:35just to get, a film out and finally frank borsage
- 5:38was like fine i'll do it my contract's almost
- 5:42up or whatever so if it doesn't work out then
- 5:44we're whatever no harm it is interesting how
- 5:47it came to be because when i was reading about
- 5:48that you're right about everything you just said
- 5:51but it sounded a bit more like he was tasked
- 5:54with this right but the studio is more like hey
- 5:56your contract's almost up so you're gonna do
- 5:58a project he's like great and it's this one he's
- 6:01like yes come on But he rose to the occasion
- 6:04and made the version of this that he could at
- 6:06the time. And that's a version that, you know,
- 6:08we talked about Smiling Lieutenant last week
- 6:11or this last episode. Yeah. And that's a movie
- 6:14that kind of dances around the subject of sex
- 6:17and sexual relations in a very funny, like carefree
- 6:21way. And this handles it a bit more like a death
- 6:24sentence. Like it's a lot more serious with its
- 6:27tone. about how this is all handled. And that
- 6:30was a little confusing for me just because obviously
- 6:32this was very much a real thing in the 1930s
- 6:34of the way that we saw relations and the way
- 6:38that we viewed women, fairly or unfairly, of
- 6:41the way they'd be in relationships with men.
- 6:44And if you had any kind of premarital sex, that
- 6:46was a scarlet letter on you. So you had to get
- 6:49married immediately. And I understand that a
- 6:52bit. The plot device leaning on, well, hey, nothing
- 6:54may have happened there. Because again, the movie
- 6:57just kind of has them embracing and then they
- 7:00just kind of stay, maybe fall asleep. That's
- 7:02kind of what the movie proposes. It's like, maybe
- 7:04they just fall asleep. And she woke up at 4 a
- 7:06.m. and was like, oh man, I got to get out of
- 7:07here. And then that then is the crux of the movie
- 7:10of like, well, now I got to get married. Interesting
- 7:12that this is the second movie in a row that we're
- 7:15talking about a plot device that hinges on a
- 7:17forced marriage. Yeah. Not even forced, but like
- 7:20almost kind of an arranged marriage. Yeah. Like
- 7:23we've got to do this now for whatever reason.
- 7:26In order for this to work. Yeah. But also I say
- 7:29forced or arranged. Both of them are kind of
- 7:31like, I mean, Eddie is kind of like, I mean.
- 7:34It wouldn't be the worst thing in the world if
- 7:35you and I got together. And she's like, oh, you
- 7:37would never regret it, I swear. So they're both
- 7:39very willing. I also thought of this. It's funny
- 7:41that we mentioned Frank Borsage with Seventh
- 7:43Heaven and everything, because a lot of the relationship
- 7:45between Eddie and Dorothy here seemed kind of
- 7:49similar to Seventh Heaven. Yes. Like, especially
- 7:51him being like, you know, it's not the worst
- 7:53thing in the world if you and I got together.
- 7:54That is almost verbatim what Chico says in Seventh
- 7:58Heaven. He's very... hesitant to just straight
- 8:01up be romantic correct and and admit his feelings
- 8:04yeah and it does feel like he's even if this
- 8:07isn't the case he's proposing it as kind of a
- 8:10favor he's doing oh don't worry about it we can
- 8:12get married i'll do that for you so that your
- 8:14brother won't be mad at you that kind of thing
- 8:17when really he is like wow i kind of like this
- 8:20dame maybe we'll i'll keep her around it's it
- 8:24is and i think that speaks a lot to frank borsage
- 8:28When we talked about Seventh Heaven, we did say
- 8:30that this was kind of the genre that he found
- 8:33himself lingering in for a long time. He spends
- 8:36a lot of time in his movies with young love and
- 8:39kind of this, like we're saying, almost like
- 8:42a forced love that then blossoms into something
- 8:46that feels... less forced yeah absolutely i do
- 8:49before we get too far i want to say that the
- 8:52reason that i mentioned william paulie is jim
- 8:53haley uh you mentioned that jim is dorothy's
- 8:56brother that's 100 true the reason i want to
- 8:58make sure we mention him is that he actually
- 9:00appears as jim dorothy's brother on the move
- 9:03in the movie but also on the stage play for 1930
- 9:05okay so he's reprising his role here which i
- 9:08thought was interesting especially since he doesn't
- 9:10have a ton to do Kind of a weird returning character
- 9:13to have in this, but it's completely fine. I
- 9:16would tell you more about the plot, but essentially
- 9:18what we have told you is the crux of the story.
- 9:21And everything else that happens after that is
- 9:23the miscommunication and the... trials and tribulations
- 9:28of these two navigating a marriage and not even
- 9:31like in seventh heaven where it's kind of like
- 9:32a fake marriage it turns into a real one i think
- 9:35they put an earnest try into this marriage from
- 9:38the get -go yeah but it really does come down
- 9:40to eddie is so different and dorothy is so different
- 9:43which to be honest with you i didn't think they
- 9:45really were that their miscommunications created
- 9:49hijinks in their relationship. Right. Really
- 9:51misunderstandings of like, yeah, I'm going to
- 9:52be working late. And she's like, well, what if
- 9:54he's talking to someone? What if he's actually
- 9:56doing this? A lot of insecurities. Yeah. I think
- 9:58this is a good time to kind of start saying how
- 10:00we feel about the movie. I didn't really care
- 10:02for Bad Girl that much. The thing for me is that
- 10:05it does kind of hinge itself upon the idea of
- 10:08a miscommunication. And the entirety of the movie
- 10:11is this proposal that comes out of... preventing
- 10:15anyone from being in trouble and then their relationship
- 10:18because of it and that relationship is a series
- 10:21of i'm not properly communicating my feelings
- 10:23to you so you're taking this as an assumption
- 10:25and then i take this as an assumption and this
- 10:27spirals out of control and in a comedy That makes
- 10:30a good bit of sense. This, especially watching
- 10:33alongside The Smiling Lieutenant, does not scream
- 10:35comedy. There are comedic elements to it, but
- 10:37that's not the tone of the movie itself. Right.
- 10:39So I found myself kind of confused by the tone.
- 10:43This movie felt like it was at war with itself
- 10:45in its tone and themes. So I wasn't a big fan
- 10:48of it. I do want to shout out our friend of the
- 10:51pod, Bryce, who has a Letterboxd review of this
- 10:53movie. And the opening sentence of it, I think,
- 10:55is a just dead ringer for the plot of this. I
- 10:58don't know why this is called Bad Girl. Interesting,
- 11:01because Dorothy is not a bad girl. And like,
- 11:04you know, what you would consider a bad girl.
- 11:06But maybe it's the title. And I'm sure you're
- 11:09going to agree with this. Maybe it's the title
- 11:11that she's worried to not have because she stayed
- 11:13out till 4am. Sure. But because she avoided that,
- 11:17the whole idea of bad girl just seems kind of
- 11:19out of place. So with that said, I kind of want
- 11:22to turn it over to you because I know you and
- 11:23I don't have a similar opinion of this movie.
- 11:25Yeah. And I, you know, I don't want to come out
- 11:27like I love this movie or anything, but I do,
- 11:31I do think I enjoyed it a little bit more than
- 11:33you did. I agree with the tone kind of not being
- 11:36consistent throughout the whole movie. When this
- 11:39first started. I was very into Dorothy. I agree.
- 11:43This felt like a very progressive movie. Yeah.
- 11:46And a very like girl power kind of movie when
- 11:50it first takes off. Yeah. I love when she is
- 11:53walking down the aisle and there are men like
- 11:56flirting with her. And she has so many great
- 11:59lines, none of which I've written down. Fantastic.
- 12:02I looked at my notes. I will say that one line
- 12:05that specifically stuck out to me is after the
- 12:07bridal show that she did. She's leaving and there's
- 12:10a guy who's like, hey, you and I should get together.
- 12:12Yes. And she's like, yeah, you know, my boyfriend's
- 12:14actually a prize fighter. And he heard that someone
- 12:16was trying to hit on me. So he's actually walking
- 12:18around here trying to find the guy. Yes. I don't
- 12:20know if that's a good idea. Great bit. That's
- 12:22what it is. Yeah. And one of the guys, this is
- 12:24what it is. When she walks by him, he mentions
- 12:26going out after the fashion show. And she's like,
- 12:30sorry, I've got to drive my two pet goldfish
- 12:32around. But if you want, there's an extra seat
- 12:34available. And he's just like. Maybe you can
- 12:36join them. What? Yeah. And she's just that girl.
- 12:40She's like, I'm constantly getting hit on. Even
- 12:43when she makes a phone call, you can hear the
- 12:46operator, whoever she's calling, the guy she's
- 12:49got to talk to for two seconds at the store.
- 12:51She's like, he's hitting on me too. And she's
- 12:54just over it. And all of her little quips and
- 12:56stuff, we mentioned this in the Smiling Lieutenant
- 12:58episode, but just the writing in all of these
- 13:00movies and how they're not afraid to shy away
- 13:04from. I'm sorry, they're not shying away from
- 13:07like the slang and the dialogue of the time.
- 13:11And I think that made her and Edna, her best
- 13:14friend, so much fun. And I was having a blast.
- 13:17I thought this was very funny. I think once her
- 13:21and Eddie's relationship really started to develop,
- 13:24that's when I started to lose interest. Right.
- 13:27Just like you said, the plot is based on this.
- 13:29What if he's doing this? And then he retaliates
- 13:34with, well, what if she's feeling this way? And
- 13:37that just goes back and forth from the moment
- 13:39they meet to the moment they get married to him
- 13:42buying an apartment for her, thinking that's
- 13:44what she wants. But in reality, she's pregnant
- 13:47and stressed about that. And then it goes as
- 13:50far as, well, she doesn't want this kid. Well,
- 13:53he doesn't want this kid. And that's the whole
- 13:56movie. Right. And those things aren't true. It's
- 13:59not that he's concerned that she may not want
- 14:02the kid, but because she's concerned that he
- 14:05may not want them, then she's kind of like, well,
- 14:07maybe I don't if he doesn't either. So it really
- 14:10is hinged upon a miscommunication, just them
- 14:12not speaking to each other, much like getting
- 14:14an apartment. She mentions like, hey, what if
- 14:16we had more space? He's like, oh, she wants a
- 14:18bigger apartment. But in reality, she's thinking
- 14:19about having space for the baby. She talks about
- 14:21getting another job. He's like, well, why would
- 14:23you want another job that looks horrible on me,
- 14:25which was a thing at the time. And in reality,
- 14:28she's thinking about making more money so they
- 14:30can have more space for the baby. So there's
- 14:33just a series of like, you're thinking the right
- 14:35way. You're just not saying what you need to
- 14:37say to get this. Right. And I think my problem
- 14:39with what you're saying here, well, I mean, it
- 14:41sounds like we agree on the tone. But the main
- 14:43problem is that that introduction that we have
- 14:45to Dorothy, that character that she has is kind
- 14:47of gone. Yeah. We don't see her like now be the
- 14:50vocal stand up for herself and her rights to
- 14:54her husband. She kind of recoils a bit. And now
- 14:56she's recoiling and like not talking to him and
- 14:59standing up for herself. And I didn't see the
- 15:01connection of why she would do that. And it didn't
- 15:03make sense to me. So that was the tonal shift.
- 15:06And again, movies can have multiple tones. That's
- 15:08completely fine. I'm a big believer in like,
- 15:10you know, your more comedic movies having like
- 15:12a very hard hitting moment. But this one didn't
- 15:14make any sense to me in terms of why that tone
- 15:16would shift for those characters. Yeah. And to
- 15:20go back and answer your earlier question about
- 15:21the title Bad Girl and how she doesn't really
- 15:24represent that title at all. I think that early
- 15:27on. her actions from like a 1930s perspective,
- 15:31you can see that she, she's not the, you know,
- 15:34Oh, thank you so much for your compliment or,
- 15:37or this, that, and the other thing. She is kind
- 15:40of like crass. Yeah. But in, in a very charming
- 15:44and attractive way, which is probably the problem
- 15:47she has, like that just escalates the problem
- 15:50she has with men already. Right. But then that
- 15:53does go away. And I think it's one of those things
- 15:55where, okay, well, once a woman, finds her husband,
- 15:58she becomes that, you know, she is the wife and
- 16:02her personality kind of disappears. Just to be
- 16:04clear, I don't think that, but I think that is
- 16:06the way women are presented in these movies.
- 16:09Correct. And then the characters around them
- 16:12have that portrayal or that thought of them in
- 16:15that way. So you're right. It's of its time for
- 16:18sure. And that's why it's difficult to look at
- 16:20some of these movies and like fully rate it because
- 16:23there's an understanding, a social norm of the
- 16:26time that we don't have currently. But knowing
- 16:28what we know of the 1930s, we can kind of make
- 16:30some assumptions and draw some lines of what
- 16:32that assumption might be. And in this case, it
- 16:34very much is the idea of a bad girl being not
- 16:38prim and proper, not being very like acceptable
- 16:41or not accepting of these advances and like,
- 16:44well, thanks so much. Gee whiz. Is it be great
- 16:46for us to get together? Maybe, you know, more
- 16:48meeting them where they are and having that attitude
- 16:51back to them, which hilarious. That's a bad girl.
- 16:54When in reality, it's just standing up for yourself.
- 16:56But OK, that's that's the joke, I'm assuming.
- 16:59So what's interesting about this is that the
- 17:01whole reason that Dorothy is very interested
- 17:03in Eddie is that Eddie is not immediately trying
- 17:06to hit on her. Eddie is not like these other
- 17:09men that are just making advances after advances.
- 17:12He's letting it breathe a little bit. And she
- 17:14appreciates this, especially since she first
- 17:17met him trying to annoy him with a ukulele and
- 17:19playing next to him. So she then feels bad. Hey,
- 17:22he probably wasn't that kind of guy. So maybe
- 17:24I should go apologize to him. And then that kind
- 17:26of births this connection between them. Even
- 17:28before they start getting together, there's still
- 17:29that miscommunication of like, hey, you were
- 17:31supposed to meet me here. Oh, sorry, this happened.
- 17:34So from the get go, they're not really on the
- 17:36same page. But then that just continued escalating
- 17:39where they just continuously were on the same
- 17:41page. He's going to the doctor to try and like
- 17:43get a better doctor for her because she wants
- 17:45to feel really safe with the whole pregnancy,
- 17:47like going through it. And he finds that doctor,
- 17:50but he has to stay out late to do it. So then
- 17:52she starts judging why he's out so late. And
- 17:54it just feels like, just sit down and talk. As
- 17:57an audience member, you're just like, guys, just
- 17:59talk. What are we doing here? And that makes
- 18:01it a little frustrating. But that being said,
- 18:04it's not like this is a terrible movie. It's
- 18:06not a bad movie by any means. It's just difficult
- 18:09to get involved in this story emotionally and
- 18:12then have a lot of sympathy for what ends up
- 18:15happening to them. It's probably a good time
- 18:17to start mentioning where this actually goes.
- 18:18Once they both are aware, I shouldn't say they're
- 18:21both aware that they have a baby. She's aware
- 18:23from the get go. Once Eddie is aware that they're
- 18:25having a baby, you kind of see the wheels turning
- 18:29a little bit of like, okay, maybe this is the
- 18:31moment where the story kind of shifts back to
- 18:33the original tone. And now they're on the same
- 18:35page and they can get this done. But because
- 18:37she never got that job that she wanted, they
- 18:38are trying to like. balance the budget a bit
- 18:41differently and trying to pay off this doctor
- 18:43that she really wanted. And instead of having
- 18:46that conversation, this continues. And he ends
- 18:48up being a prize fighter, boxing, and trying
- 18:51to make $40 a fight. I want to stop here. Would
- 18:54you fight someone for $40? In 1931? Yeah. Yes.
- 18:58Yeah. That's good money. What would the rate
- 19:02be for that? The exchange rate? I have no idea.
- 19:05Should I look it up? It's a lot of money. Let's
- 19:07look it up. Let's look it up. All right. So $40.
- 19:12It was 40, right? Not 50? I believe so. In 19,
- 19:16let's say 31. Yeah? Yeah. Worth today. Okay.
- 19:19This would be the equivalent of $855 to $877
- 19:23today. So just under 900. Let's call it a cool
- 19:26900. Would you get in the ring and fight a guy
- 19:28for $900? If it was another guy like me, probably.
- 19:33Who was also trying to get $900? Right. Like,
- 19:35as long as it's not, hey, would you fight Tyson?
- 19:38You know? then maybe, but I would also have,
- 19:41there's an amount of money I would fight Tyson.
- 19:43No, no, that's, Hey, would you die for money?
- 19:46It's like, probably not. Um, thanks for asking.
- 19:49Yeah. I appreciate that. Yeah. I'd, I'd have
- 19:51to be in like a position where I'm like, I'm
- 19:54about to have a baby and I have no money. I should
- 19:57probably go fight someone who's not Mike Tyson
- 19:59and just see if I can do that. Yeah. And because
- 20:02he becomes a prize fighter in that sense, he's
- 20:04coming home and having bruises, but he's not
- 20:07telling Dorothy that he's becoming a prize fighter
- 20:09because how do you have that conversation? Yeah.
- 20:11So then she starts saying he's getting in fights,
- 20:13like at bars and stuff, and he's not really invested
- 20:16in the relationship. All of this kind of like
- 20:19spirals into, well, we have the baby, but are
- 20:22really interested in the baby. And they just
- 20:24have a come to Jesus moment. They just talk and
- 20:25they're like, hey, I want to be here. Hey, I
- 20:26want to be here too. Okay. Yeah. Be together.
- 20:29This felt very rushed to me, that conversation.
- 20:32Because it really is like, wait a minute. You
- 20:34do want to have a baby? Yeah. I didn't think
- 20:37you did. I do too. And the baby's right there
- 20:38while they're having this conversation. The baby's
- 20:40like, yeah, what gives? Yeah. Guys, what's going
- 20:42on? I want to come back to the scene about the
- 20:44baby. I've talked to you about this off pod.
- 20:45I want to come back to that scene specifically.
- 20:47Yeah. Because I think that's where the humor
- 20:48comes back a little bit more. There's little
- 20:50like peaks of humor in this that I really enjoyed.
- 20:53There's another one we'll talk about here in
- 20:54a second. But I want to get to the overarching
- 20:56story. And this ultimately results in both of
- 20:59them realizing, oh, hey, you do want to be here.
- 21:01And we do want to have this life together. So
- 21:03they are in the car, really happy, embracing
- 21:06each other, embracing the baby. The end. And
- 21:08I think ultimately my issue with the movie is
- 21:10that it just doesn't feel like. anything really
- 21:12happened in this. It was a series of miscommunication
- 21:15breakdowns and it could have been easily resolved.
- 21:18And the tone, that's all fine. I don't mind a
- 21:21minimal story, but the tone was so all over the
- 21:24place that it was difficult for me to feel super
- 21:26invested. So I think that's why I'm not as high
- 21:28on Bad Girl, but by no means am I saying it's
- 21:31a bad movie. It was just more difficult for me
- 21:33to captivate me. Yeah. This is one of those things
- 21:36where I sometimes wonder, should I watch all
- 21:39of these movies twice? Back to back. Interesting.
- 21:42It's a lot. Which up till now you have. That's
- 21:44true. That's true. It's been out multiple times.
- 21:46Yeah. Because I think you go in expecting something
- 21:50to happen. And that could be just the title of
- 21:54this movie alone is an example of that. Oh, a
- 21:57movie about a bad girl. And then you're kind
- 21:59of strung along at the beginning with the way
- 22:01that Dorothy behaves. And Edna. I want to talk
- 22:04about Edna for sure. then the movie has its twist
- 22:07and everything changes. And maybe a second viewing
- 22:12where I go through and I know what I'm getting,
- 22:14I'd be able to look at it in a more analytical
- 22:17way that doesn't feel full of surprise and shock.
- 22:21Sure. And I think one reason that it's difficult
- 22:24for me to kind of see the reason why it would
- 22:26be called Bad Girl, even like a satirical sense,
- 22:28is having just watched Smiling Lieutenant. Claudette
- 22:31Colbert is almost as much of a bad girl in that
- 22:34sense as Sally Ellers is in this. So it's difficult
- 22:37to kind of be as invested in that story when
- 22:40I feel like I'm not really aware of what's going
- 22:43on with the central theme of it. Now, I do think
- 22:46from what I read, the original novel was called
- 22:50Bad Girl as well. Correct. And again, that had
- 22:53all of these taboos and things and it went into
- 22:55detail. So I'm sure that the character in that
- 22:59story. is quote -unquote more of a bad girl.
- 23:03It does spend a lot more time with the pregnancy
- 23:05and kind of the, oh, I don't know if I feel comfortable
- 23:10having this baby because I don't know if Eddie
- 23:12really wants it. Those are things that are not
- 23:15going to show up in a 1931 pre -code film because
- 23:18you can't have a mother or an expecting mother
- 23:21say, I don't know if I want this baby. Right.
- 23:25That does not happen. I think that the title,
- 23:28they kept it to kind of draw in audiences because
- 23:31in 1931, what man doesn't want to see a film
- 23:35about a bad girl? This is like the It Girl with
- 23:38Clara Bow. But because they had to tweak the
- 23:41story so much for the censorship, you lost a
- 23:45lot of what made her the bad girl. Yeah, I think
- 23:49the way to kind of put it is like if Jurassic
- 23:51Park, the novel. the movie, they were like, hey,
- 23:53we can't put dinosaurs in this. And you still
- 23:55call it Jurassic Park, but it was just about
- 23:57a theme park. Yeah. Well, unfortunately, that's
- 23:59a misleading title because now we're like, well,
- 24:02where's the Jurassic Park of this play in? Exactly.
- 24:04So I wonder if, you know, I haven't seen the
- 24:06play and I haven't read the original novel, but
- 24:09I wonder if those advances that they have towards
- 24:12Dorothy in the first couple scenes are more accepted.
- 24:15And she's like, cool, yeah, I'm a good time girl
- 24:18and let's go and do it. That's the independence
- 24:19of that character. Sure. And that's where the
- 24:21bad girl comes from. I'm sure also that scene
- 24:24with Eddie when she stays in his apartment until
- 24:264 a .m., there's probably more scenes that are
- 24:29shown or alluded to than just, you know, it goes
- 24:31pitch black and then they wake up. Right, yeah.
- 24:33So I'm sure there's some things like that that'll
- 24:36lead to or allude to the bad sense of bad girl,
- 24:40but it's missing from the movie. So it just feels
- 24:42like kind of a misnomer. Yeah. And I think it
- 24:44does. Turn it into more of a comedy film with
- 24:47elements of drama sprinkled in. Yes. And that's
- 24:50what causes the tonal shift and tonal identity
- 24:54crisis in a way. I'd almost flip it. I think
- 24:57for me, it feels like a drama with moments of
- 24:59comedy. Really? And not a comedy with moments
- 25:01of drama. Because the drama to me felt more present
- 25:03than the comedy did. But it's funny because even,
- 25:07you mentioned Edna, even Edna is like, hey, why
- 25:10don't you just talk to your wife? She is the
- 25:13highlight of the movie for me. Yeah. Well, she's
- 25:15the voice of reason. She is. She is. But even
- 25:19besides that, her comedy in this cracks me up.
- 25:23Her relationship with Eddie. kills me yeah it's
- 25:26so funny god there's there's a part where he's
- 25:29leaving and he says goodbye to dorothy and when
- 25:31he says goodbye to edna he's like so long meddlesome
- 25:35yeah he calls her meddlesome it's so funny and
- 25:38she's just constantly busting his chops uh she
- 25:42comes home and he's doing the dishes and she
- 25:44critiques it and he's like why are you here yeah
- 25:48why are you saying anything to me at all and
- 25:51she's like oh come on like it's i love their
- 25:54relationship so much and i do love that eddie
- 25:57is a good husband throughout this whole movie
- 26:00he is he's faithful yes he has these moments
- 26:03of of hesitation and worry because he is young
- 26:07they're both young and he's very career focused
- 26:10as a character but he He knows what he's gotten
- 26:13into with Dorothy and he wants to move forward.
- 26:15He is in love with her. And it's just those miscommunications
- 26:19that really cause any type of tension or drama
- 26:21throughout the whole movie. But at no point does
- 26:23he leave her side or not do anything. Like everything
- 26:27he does is for her. Yes. And I do love that.
- 26:31Like they are cute together when they're not
- 26:34stirring up drama. Because of a spiraling miscommunication.
- 26:38Right. Well, and it's so easy to kind of draw
- 26:41Eddie as this character who is going to go to
- 26:43the bar and drink himself stupid because he's
- 26:46so upset at the situation. He doesn't do that.
- 26:48And it'd be very easy to draw Dorothy as like,
- 26:50you know, now you're this distant housewife who
- 26:53doesn't feel like she's connected to her husband.
- 26:55So now you're kind of a stereotype in that sense,
- 26:58too. It would be very easy for the movie to do
- 27:00that. And it doesn't. And I do appreciate that.
- 27:02But that makes it even more confusing when both
- 27:04of them kind of see each other as that. She sees
- 27:07him as like he's going to the bars and he's getting
- 27:08drunk and getting in fights. And he sees her
- 27:12as like, well, she's just not telling me what
- 27:14she wants. She's kind of vague about everything.
- 27:16So they see each other as these stereotypes that
- 27:18they aren't. Yeah. And that made it kind of more
- 27:21confusing because just talk. Just talk to each
- 27:24other, man. What are we doing? But I do want
- 27:26to say a couple things about the comedy that
- 27:28you talked about. The comedy in this is very
- 27:31much present, especially in the first like 15
- 27:33minutes of this movie. Sure. Kind of takes a
- 27:35backseat as things go on. But there are some
- 27:38lines that actually kind of knocked me out. We
- 27:40talked a bit off pod about how there's a scene
- 27:42in the hospital where there's a nurse who is
- 27:44trying to present a baby to these women who just
- 27:48gave birth. And she's like, have you seen this
- 27:50one? Look how cute they are. She's like, oh,
- 27:52can I hold it? She's like, no, you can't. And
- 27:54just pulls them away and walks away. She's like,
- 27:56this one's not yours. And she does this two times.
- 27:59Maybe even technically three. The third time
- 28:01she does it to Dorothy, she's like, aren't these
- 28:03the prettiest hands you've ever seen? And she's
- 28:04like, yeah, I guess the kids are, right? And
- 28:06she's like, well, it's yours. And I'm like, what
- 28:08are, this woman is terrorizing these like women
- 28:12who just went through childbirth. She's just
- 28:14there to punk every single new mother. That's
- 28:16a hundred percent what it is. She's punking these
- 28:19mothers. And I thought this was hysterical. I
- 28:22was like, I kind of want a movie about like the,
- 28:23this is the bad girl. Like this is the bad girl
- 28:26in the movie of just like, I'm a nurse at a hospital,
- 28:29but I like to have fun with it. Yeah. Cause later
- 28:31on there's the scene that causes Dorothy. to
- 28:34go into hysterics because she thinks something's
- 28:36wrong with her baby. And I feel like that was
- 28:38just the nurse being like, boy, I shouldn't have
- 28:41dropped that baby. And she's like, what? Oh,
- 28:44no! Yeah, and then she comes out and she's like,
- 28:47yeah, your baby's fine. What are you talking
- 28:48about? It's so weird. Yes, but the dialogue,
- 28:51and it's funny how many comedic scenes take place
- 28:54in this movie that don't involve any of our main
- 28:56characters. True. Because there's another moment
- 28:58in the hospital where a mother is holding her
- 29:01new baby and she says, I named her Shirley after
- 29:06my mother -in -law. Her name was Esther, but
- 29:08it's close enough. And it's like, what? Who is
- 29:11this woman? And then the camera just pans over
- 29:14to Dorothy and you're like, oh, that's not important.
- 29:17That was just a zinger. Yeah. I'm for it. I mean,
- 29:19I'm for it too. And if the movie did more of
- 29:21that, maybe like I would see that humor more
- 29:23present. But it really was few and far between
- 29:25for me. We talked last episode about how I want
- 29:28to be more present about the script or the screenplay
- 29:31of these movies because we are getting to more
- 29:34of like a wittier style of writing in the fifth
- 29:37year of the Academy Awards. And the one line
- 29:40that got me. Is there's a scene where Eddie finds
- 29:43out for the first time that Dorothy is pregnant.
- 29:46And they find out at a house party with all their
- 29:47friends there. And while he continues to be like,
- 29:51yep, we're getting a house because you want a
- 29:53bigger space. Because you want more space, right?
- 29:54Just space, that's it. And she breaks down and
- 29:56starts crying. And I believe it's Edna that actually
- 29:58has to tell him, hey, she's pregnant. You fool.
- 30:01Right. And he has to kind of combat this. And
- 30:04at one point he looks over to his friend. And
- 30:06I want to go ahead and say that I think that
- 30:07this friend appears in one scene and it's this
- 30:09scene. I don't think he appears in any other
- 30:11scene. And he's just standing there next to Eddie.
- 30:14And Eddie looks at him and he says, Sue told
- 30:18me, but I forgot. And he has his hands on his
- 30:20hips. And he delivers it like Skippy would in
- 30:23the movie Skippy. Where he's like, Sue told me,
- 30:25but I forgot. And you can hear almost the audience
- 30:28like, whoo! like clapping in the background and
- 30:31i was like what is going on to where like that's
- 30:33the one line this guy has he was like i'm gonna
- 30:36hit that line this is my one line i'm hitting
- 30:38it he did a great job i thought that was great
- 30:39and again that's another one where the delivery
- 30:41is just as important as you know it's everything
- 30:43else that you mentioned of like i named my daughter
- 30:46after my mother and it's a completely different
- 30:47name yeah like it's almost like irreverent and
- 30:49i i appreciate that but again that's the tonal
- 30:52shift of like the humor throughout the movie
- 30:53was not irreverent it was those two scenes for
- 30:56me And that's why those were a highlight to me
- 30:58specifically. That's so interesting. But you're
- 31:00right, because maybe now that I have an understanding
- 31:02of this movie, I go back and revisit it, I'm
- 31:04meeting it more on its level than trying to figure
- 31:06out what its level actually is. And that's what
- 31:09I feel like I spent the majority of my runtime
- 31:11of this doing, is trying to put my finger on
- 31:15what this was. I feel like you and me right now
- 31:18are both holding Reese's peanut butter cups,
- 31:20but you have too much peanut butter in yours.
- 31:23And you have too much chocolate. Yeah, and I'm
- 31:26saying, boy, this comedy had a little too much
- 31:29drama for me in the tone shift, and you're like,
- 31:31this drama was a little too silly at times, or
- 31:34not silly enough, rather. And yeah, that's so
- 31:37interesting, because I thought this was pretty
- 31:39funny throughout, except for these dramatic moments.
- 31:43I do want to point out, too, I said this in the
- 31:45last episode, I've been watching Friends lately.
- 31:47Yeah. And just like The Smiling Lieutenant, this
- 31:50does feel like an elongated episode of Friends.
- 31:53It does. This is classic Ross and Rachel. Yes,
- 31:56this is Ross leaving the list on Chandler's computer
- 32:00of what he doesn't like about Rachel, like the
- 32:02pros and cons list. Right. And just when you
- 32:05think these two are having like the most romantic
- 32:07moment, Dorothy and Eddie, boom. What do you
- 32:10mean I have chubby ankles or whatever it is Ross
- 32:14says about her? And I think that. Used to bother
- 32:18me a lot when an entire movie's plot was hinged
- 32:21on that one little moment of miscommunication.
- 32:25Did you watch House of Dragon? No. There's a
- 32:28moment in that where a main character is dying
- 32:31and he's kind of losing his mind. And his dying
- 32:34words are like, the leader of the kingdom should
- 32:38be. Yeah. Yeah. And then someone like twists
- 32:42what he says and says, oh, he said my name. I
- 32:45stopped watching after that moment because I
- 32:47was like, I cannot do this. I can't watch an
- 32:49entire war take place over this dumb miscommunication.
- 32:52Right. In a little goofy, silly comedy drama.
- 32:57I'm all for that. I love it in the 1930s. Interesting.
- 33:01I think I had the same. I held Bad Girl to the
- 33:04same standard that you held House of the Dragon
- 33:06to where I'm like, I cannot base all of my. emotional
- 33:10involvement in these two people who are just
- 33:12not talking to each other yeah and and we'll
- 33:14get there eventually but uh to the thing that
- 33:17reminded me the most of this but again it's not
- 33:20a bad movie it's not something that i really
- 33:23disenjoyed my or didn't enjoy my time with this
- 33:25it was just more so i had seen aerosmith i had
- 33:28seen the swine lieutenant and then i watched
- 33:29bad girl i was like okay cool I still enjoyed
- 33:33it more than like, you know, Cimarron or Traderhorn.
- 33:37Coming for Cimarron. Well, look, here's the thing.
- 33:39It deserves it. Yes, agreed. I'll say that. I
- 33:41think that's the safest thing to say. Traderhorn
- 33:43also deserves that a good bit. So in that sense,
- 33:46Bad Girl is still, you can see the vision, but
- 33:50it's clouded. And to me, I couldn't get behind
- 33:53it. that as much because of how cloudy it was.
- 33:56One thing I do want to talk about is some behind
- 33:58the scenes stuff with this. You mentioned that
- 34:00Frank Borsage was the director here. An interesting
- 34:02thing, and maybe we'll talk about this live.
- 34:05I wonder what the banner will be like for this.
- 34:07Frank Borsage was the first to win Best Director
- 34:09twice. Yes, he was. Isn't that cool? But was
- 34:12he? What's happening? I like how he kind of did
- 34:17that unsolved mysteries. I'm like, he was the
- 34:19first director to win. You're like, yeah, he
- 34:20was. I was like, when was he? And then it cuts
- 34:22to commercial. Yeah, exactly. Well, he was like
- 34:25in the technical sense that he was the first
- 34:28person to win best director twice. That is true.
- 34:31However, Lewis Milestone did win two Oscars for
- 34:34directing, but Two Arabian Nights was best comedy
- 34:38direction. Right. So technically that comedy
- 34:42direction category went to the wayside. And because
- 34:45that's not around anymore, we're talking about
- 34:47the best director or best directing. Sure. category
- 34:51so these two people kind of held that title at
- 34:55the same time lewis milestone having won two
- 34:57direction oscars but frank borzage is the first
- 35:00person to win best directing across the board
- 35:03right right you know i'm i like that though i'm
- 35:06a fan of the frank borzage movies we've seen
- 35:09yeah i like seventh heaven i like that style
- 35:12he does yeah that like young romance that we
- 35:15talked about 100 That's what you're going to
- 35:18get from Boursage. And we've talked about Lewis
- 35:21Milestone now many times, and we're huge fans
- 35:24of his work. Very cool that those two, who have
- 35:28been around since the first Academy year, I think
- 35:30that's what's coolest about it, is the first
- 35:33win in the directing categories for both of them
- 35:36came from the very first Academy year. Yes. I
- 35:38like that a lot. And again, it shows the evolution
- 35:41of these movies. Because you look at Seventh
- 35:44Heaven against Bad Girl. And you can see where
- 35:48they've grown, not just in technological achievements,
- 35:50I should say technical, technical achievements,
- 35:52but also in the way that he grew as a director.
- 35:55I think the same thing with Lewis Milestone.
- 35:57Now, I will say Lewis Milestone for me, probably
- 36:00more of my preferred director between these two,
- 36:03but it's really neat to see the style of them.
- 36:06I think something we talk about a lot now with
- 36:08directors is, you know, we have kind of like
- 36:10prestige filmmakers. Scorsese, you know what
- 36:14you're going to get from a Scorsese movie? Nolan.
- 36:16You know, you're going to get from that. They
- 36:17have tones. They have themes that they revisit.
- 36:19And it's interesting to see this with these directors,
- 36:22too. I think every director has a little bit
- 36:24of a theme, but, you know, some more than others.
- 36:26Others are like, well, this is my Western and
- 36:27this is this. And they're not really connected.
- 36:29It's just I made the movie. But Borsage and Milestone,
- 36:32you do see their style and you see that. I think
- 36:36Borsage is a little bit more the couple, like
- 36:39the two leads. Milestone's more of a company.
- 36:42And I like that aspect. Yeah. I think that Milestone
- 36:45as well isn't afraid to cross or go through genres.
- 36:51Sure. And he does have more of like a technical
- 36:54style. I think that Borsage very much sticks
- 36:57with themes more than like a visual style. True.
- 37:02With the young romance and all of that. Because
- 37:05Seventh Heaven did have some great camera work
- 37:08going from the bottom floor up to... chico's
- 37:12seventh floor apartment and that that very cool
- 37:15like almost elevator like shot yeah the escalation
- 37:18yeah there's nothing like that in bad girl and
- 37:21i think that frank borsage as he developed as
- 37:25a filmmaker he had the the opportunity to really
- 37:28find his niche and he did it from a storytelling
- 37:31point of view rather than like a visual because
- 37:34bad girl doesn't doesn't have that type of visual
- 37:37storytelling i don't think it doesn't the only
- 37:39thing that kind of stood out to me is really
- 37:41interesting was when it cut to eddie being a
- 37:43prize fighter i like that scene of him boxing
- 37:45in the ring because the camera's in there with
- 37:47him you see him and this other guy fighting but
- 37:50On top of that, you see the audience, you see
- 37:52the arena that they're in and fighting in. And
- 37:55I thought this was a nice bit of scale and scope
- 37:57that we didn't see in his other shots. And otherwise
- 37:59it really was just more like, well, I guess we
- 38:01put the camera here to get this conversation.
- 38:02You weren't getting a lot of emotion from it.
- 38:04I thought that shot had some emotion in it and
- 38:07I really appreciated it. Yeah. Boursage kind
- 38:09of has that filming a stage play kind of vibe.
- 38:12Totally. But he still uses a wide array of angles
- 38:16and things and he's making it. More interesting
- 38:19than things we've seen in the past, like Disraeli,
- 38:21for example. So I do like this film and Borsage.
- 38:26I do want to talk about its other nomination,
- 38:29the Best Adapted Screenplay. Yes. I think that
- 38:32that is a really prestigious nomination here
- 38:36because you had what I think you could consider
- 38:39an unadaptable story at the time. Yes. The fact
- 38:45that this studio was trying to have this novel
- 38:47made into a film, but everybody was saying, no,
- 38:51we're not doing that. I don't know. And Edwin
- 38:54J. Burke took the story and said, all right,
- 38:56I'm going to make it so that we can do this for
- 38:58the screen. And then worked with Frank Borsage
- 39:00to put together this film that, while I think
- 39:03we both agree the tone doesn't sit right throughout
- 39:05the whole thing, you did take this very taboo
- 39:09-filled novel and you made it something that
- 39:11could be seen by a large audience. Sure. in 1931.
- 39:15And that deserves, I think, the nomination for
- 39:17Best Adapted Screenplay. Yeah, I think so. You
- 39:20know, we're keeping ourselves accountable of
- 39:22not looking up who wins these awards. Again,
- 39:25I think I'm pretty familiar with who won Best
- 39:27Picture. I spoiled it for myself. Okay, well,
- 39:29there you go. But I don't know who won a Best
- 39:31Adapted Screenplay for this. Tell you what, do
- 39:33you want to know? Does the audience want to know?
- 39:35Probably. Sure, let's do it. It was this. I was
- 39:40about to say spoilers and you're like, that's
- 39:42this. That seems about right, right? I mean,
- 39:44like, with the, I don't want to say troubled,
- 39:47but the storied history of getting this onto
- 39:49paper, it makes sense that this would be nominated
- 39:52or win. I don't know that I'm going to say, like,
- 39:55yeah, this is one of my favorite, like, screenplays.
- 39:57Sure. I wouldn't say that. But I think the background
- 40:00of how it came to be a screenplay, it makes sense.
- 40:03It's funny. I feel like a lot of the movies that
- 40:06are nominated for screenplay, I don't always
- 40:09enjoy the plot. But I do notice a bump in dialogue.
- 40:14Yes, yeah. And we've talked about that now. In
- 40:17nauseam, that's the term I'm looking for. I was
- 40:21going to say, if you're looking for a count,
- 40:22I have nothing for you. Yeah, just with Edna's
- 40:26great little punchlines and Dorothy's punchlines.
- 40:29And really, something we haven't talked about
- 40:31with this movie, it takes place during the Depression
- 40:34era. And I think Eddie is a very interesting
- 40:37character. His kind of cynical look on the world,
- 40:40but still sprinkled with a bit of hope that he's
- 40:44going to open his own business and he's going
- 40:46to be successful. And he's not going to be one
- 40:49of those down and out guys that's down at the
- 40:51soup kitchen and not, you know, earning a wage.
- 40:54Right. He is going to continue to try. Yeah.
- 40:56I liked that element of Eddie. I think it added
- 41:00a lot of comedy. but also a lot of much needed
- 41:03personality. During this era, most of the men
- 41:06we see are kind of one note. And I think Eddie
- 41:09is pretty nuanced. Yeah, I think that's fair
- 41:14to say. The other men that we see, especially
- 41:16later towards the film, they have more comedic
- 41:18lines. You mentioned at the hospital, like some
- 41:21of the lines that they say there, specifically
- 41:22in the men's waiting room. There's one guy that's
- 41:26asked, how many kids do you have? And he said,
- 41:28six, maybe seven or eight. They're like, you
- 41:31don't know how many kids he has? He's like, it's
- 41:32at least six. Right. And I like the delivery
- 41:35of that line, too, of, you know, OK, hold on
- 41:38now. You're not going to catch me in this. It's
- 41:39at least six. So if they're not one note in the
- 41:43way that they hit on Dorothy, they're mostly
- 41:46just kind of comedic relief in those lines. So
- 41:49you're right. Yeah. And that's a testament to
- 41:52the adapted screenplay as well, because. I highly
- 41:56doubt all of those jokes were in the book verbatim.
- 41:58Right. So they were writing these for the big
- 42:00thing. That joke in the waiting room reminds
- 42:03me, I think it's Norm MacDonald. One time they
- 42:06asked him, well, how old is your oldest kid?
- 42:08And he goes... It's either 10 or 15. It's just
- 42:12like, okay, cool. There's also a line that I
- 42:15think it's Eddie has in that same scene where
- 42:18they're like, so how's this been for you? And
- 42:20he's like, well, I got to tell you, I'm never
- 42:21doing this again. And I think that it's, that's
- 42:24kind of hinting at the hopelessness of him that
- 42:26he doesn't have. Cause you're right. He's a very
- 42:28hopeful person. And even though all this happens,
- 42:30I think what you would kind of expect from this
- 42:33is a, it's a wonderful life. Like he kind of
- 42:35just gets involved in alcohol and he just kind
- 42:38of becomes sad. and depressed about this. But
- 42:40in reality, he's just more stressed. He's like,
- 42:42well, I got to do it because it's my family and
- 42:44that's my wife. But God, this is a little tough.
- 42:47Yeah. And that's why I like all of the characters
- 42:50in this. It's a shame that so much of the plot
- 42:52hinges on the miscommunication. But I think every
- 42:56character in this delivers at least 10 zingers.
- 42:59And it keeps me entertained. It keeps me happy.
- 43:03I love, oh man, there's the moment where Dorothy
- 43:07is talking to her brother once he finds out she
- 43:10spent the night at Eddie's and she's getting
- 43:12kicked out. And there's a moment where Edna's
- 43:14like, shameful, shame. I can't believe you. And
- 43:18her brother says something, basically calling
- 43:22her a tramp or whatever. And just as she's about
- 43:26to leave, Edna's like, all right. Let's go. Let's
- 43:29go, Dorothy. We're out of here. And he's like,
- 43:31where are you going? She's like, listen, I heard
- 43:33how you talked about her. And I know where I
- 43:35was last night at 4 a .m. So I can only imagine
- 43:38what you say about me. So have a nice life. See
- 43:41you in the cemetery. And it's like. Damn. Yeah.
- 43:45Get them. I agree with you. I think Edna is probably
- 43:47the best part of this movie. She's so good. I
- 43:49also really liked what you alluded to before
- 43:51is that we talked about how in Love Parade this
- 43:54would lead itself to sex comedies and what those
- 43:57looked like. Obviously, that did the same with
- 43:58Smiling Lieutenant. Even kind of here, too. I
- 44:01don't think I'd label it as a sex comedy, but
- 44:03obviously the plot of this revolves around the
- 44:05idea of whether sex happened or not and the shame
- 44:08that comes with that being premarital. But with
- 44:11that said... I think there are tropes that you
- 44:13see in romantic comedies, sex comedy or not,
- 44:15that Edna is a character. Edna is present in
- 44:19a lot of those more modern rom -coms. And it's
- 44:22excellent to see kind of the source code of like,
- 44:25oh, you were the beginning. And Edna is the beginning.
- 44:27So I agree with you on that. I think Edna is
- 44:29the highlight for me because you can see such
- 44:31a clear like, oh, you're the best friend. And
- 44:33you're the importance of a best friend character
- 44:35in these movies. Not just for the comedic relief,
- 44:38but more to be the anchor. for these people.
- 44:41She's like the Ethel to the Lucy. 100%. Yeah.
- 44:44The Edna to the Dorothy. Absolutely. I have a
- 44:47question for you. Okay. We talk about Frank Borsage
- 44:50doing Seventh Heaven and how that ending was
- 44:52kind of up to interpretation of the two of them.
- 44:56embracing each other in the sunlight. And whether
- 45:00that was they were actually together or just
- 45:02that's how she pictured being with Chico if he
- 45:05was still alive. Right. Kind of the open nature
- 45:07of it. This is what inspired Damien Chazelle
- 45:10to make his movies be open -ended as well. So
- 45:14for you, with La La Land specifically, for you,
- 45:17with Bad Girl, this is not an open -ended ending.
- 45:20No. This is pretty cut and dry. Do you think
- 45:23that this was intentionally... Well, hey, a lot
- 45:26of people had some questions about this, so I'm
- 45:27going to make it very clear what this ending
- 45:29is. Or did you think that wasn't even something
- 45:31that crossed his mind? Did it feel like an overcorrection
- 45:33to you or intentional? No, I think because it
- 45:37was adapted from a book, he was probably limited
- 45:39to how it ends. But even if that's not the case,
- 45:43I don't know that. In my mind, he had Seventh
- 45:46Heaven on his mind while he was making this.
- 45:48Sure. Or at least not to the extent of, how am
- 45:51I going to finish this movie? How will it end?
- 45:52Right. That ending is kind of cute, and it is
- 45:55a little too saccharine. And he's an insufferable
- 45:59dad to me. Yeah. Where he's like, this is the
- 46:01future president of the United States you got
- 46:03in the car here. Right. He's like, all right,
- 46:04man. I do like when the cabbie's like, that's
- 46:06what they all say. And he's like, all right,
- 46:07I'm about to knock this guy out. He does actually
- 46:09lift off his seat a little bit. He's like, why
- 46:11I ought to. Yeah. He's like, no, just calm down.
- 46:13But it is. ultimately like it's a cute ending
- 46:16they both are finally parents who both openly
- 46:20agree this is nice i'm happy to be with you i'm
- 46:23happy to have this kid i'm looking forward to
- 46:25the future with you something that bothers me
- 46:27in movies from this era are how the endings just
- 46:31kind of happen like yeah it it had a final line
- 46:35Where she goes to take the baby back from Eddie
- 46:37because she's like, oh, it's spitting up on you
- 46:41or something. He's like, spitting up? I'm soaked
- 46:43all the way through. The end. It reminded me
- 46:46of, was it The Divorcee? No, it was Broadway
- 46:50Melody. Okay. Broadway Melody had them driving
- 46:53away. And him making that kind of quip or one
- 46:56-liner and then just cuts. Yeah, he's got the
- 46:58stutter. Yeah, the stutter. It felt very much
- 47:00like that, where it's the, what is the sign -off
- 47:02for this? Right. And it's not even especially
- 47:04a great line. So when the movie ends, you're
- 47:06like, oh, okay. And it doesn't have that, like,
- 47:08da -da -da -da -da. Like, the music's not playing
- 47:12or anything. It's just the end. Correct. Then
- 47:14the music kicks in. I will say in that same sense,
- 47:17I thought the opening of this movie, the score
- 47:20that plays during the title of Bad Girl, I thought
- 47:23was great. Like it does kind of lead you to like,
- 47:25hey, enjoy this comedy, which is what made it
- 47:27even more kind of confusing when the middle half
- 47:29of this movie happens. And you're like, I thought
- 47:30the score led me to believe this was going to
- 47:33be a good time. What are we doing? Yes. It's
- 47:35interesting to kind of look at the ending of
- 47:37Bad Girl because I'm not going to be the guy
- 47:40who's like, oh, you know what? This actually
- 47:41inspired the ending of this movie. There's nothing
- 47:44reported of this. But it's hard not to see the
- 47:47comparisons in the last shot of this movie, Bad
- 47:50Girl, and look at something like The Graduate.
- 47:53The graduate has this incredible last shot of
- 47:55Dustin Hoffman finally being with Mrs. Robinson.
- 47:59And they're in the back of this bus and they're
- 48:01excited and they're happy. And then you see that
- 48:03fade from them as the bus is driving away. And
- 48:06this is a similar shot of they're in the car.
- 48:08And you can see the background moving with them.
- 48:12But this one chooses to be that saccharine ending
- 48:15of, no, they really are happy. And it's interesting
- 48:18to kind of talk about Frank Borsage doing Seventh
- 48:20Heaven in the upper interpretation ending. And
- 48:23now this one that is more cut and dry, very much
- 48:25what it is. I wonder if a movie that is hinged
- 48:29upon... Are they really happy together? Are they
- 48:32really going to be good parents together? If
- 48:34something like The Graduate or movies that did
- 48:36that kind of ending looked at something like
- 48:38that and said, well, is that truly how I think
- 48:40that story would end? Wouldn't it be more interesting
- 48:42if it ended with them in the car with the baby
- 48:44and then be a little more like, oh, is this what
- 48:46I want? I thought there's, and I want to be clear
- 48:49about this, zero evidence or proof to show that
- 48:52any of these are connected. But it did have me
- 48:54thinking about what this leads to, how movies
- 48:57can have that final shot. but also kind of raise
- 49:00some questions in the very last second of, is
- 49:02this a good ending? Yeah. Is this a happy ending?
- 49:05I do think that that's what The Graduate was
- 49:07doing. I don't know if it's a direct callback
- 49:09to this movie, but just to that, exactly what
- 49:11you're speaking on, like, yeah, they have their
- 49:13happy ending, but they also have the rest of
- 49:16their lives together. Yes. Yeah, I think The
- 49:18Graduate, that was like, they just let the camera
- 49:20roll. They did. Longer, and they were like, wow,
- 49:23actually, I really like this. I don't know that
- 49:25they... intended for it to turn into that yeah
- 49:27sure but it added so much like there's so much
- 49:30legacy behind that one shot alone it's the best
- 49:31part of that movie absolutely one thing that
- 49:34does happen in bad girl at the end that you brought
- 49:37up earlier is the starring the boy and the girl
- 49:40yes lists both of the actors uh james dunn and
- 49:43sally ellers thank you so much as the boy and
- 49:45the girl i think that that allows some type of
- 49:48like open -endedness to this not in their story
- 49:53but it does kind of present it as they are the
- 49:58boy and the girl this could be anybody's story
- 50:00this is such a common thing sure maybe this is
- 50:04you you know and your sweetheart kind of thing
- 50:06and i kind of like that and i i don't know if
- 50:09that was the intention there but it is something
- 50:11i walked away with where i'm like oh this is
- 50:13the classic tale of boy meets girl and boy has
- 50:18complex relationship with girl because he doesn't
- 50:20communicate the classic tale of getting married
- 50:23to avoid any kind of taboo nature of hanging
- 50:24out until 4 a .m and then becoming a prize fighter
- 50:26exactly tale is old it's it's so funny that you
- 50:33mentioned friends in that because you can almost
- 50:35hear eddie being like front and back about the
- 50:39letter that she'd write him so It does feel like
- 50:42a Ross and Rachel type situation, which obviously,
- 50:44you know, paved the way for those situational
- 50:47comedies, even the movie comedies and the way
- 50:49that we write them. So again, just from a historical
- 50:52lens of seeing how this paved the way for what
- 50:57we know is like romantic comedies or sex comedies
- 51:00is really interesting. And you're right, you
- 51:02know, this is really pushing the limit. I talked
- 51:05previously in our Smiling Lieutenant episode
- 51:07about the Hays Code. And while the Hays Code
- 51:10wasn't in place, Will H. Hays was still very
- 51:12much the president of the MPPDA at the time,
- 51:141942 to 1945. So even before the code was in
- 51:18place, he was very strict about what could or
- 51:20could not pass. And you alluded to this. This
- 51:23made a very difficult operation for the screenplay
- 51:26to be actually written and this movie be made.
- 51:30It is interesting from the perspective of the
- 51:33historical lens of how things like Love Parade,
- 51:36Bad Girl, Smiling Lieutenant, even front page
- 51:39to a certain degree in the way that it's written.
- 51:41The divorcee. The divorcee lend itself to what
- 51:44eventually would become the Hays Code. Right.
- 51:47So this is really, I do enjoy looking at this
- 51:51from that lens of not deserved, like, yeah, of
- 51:55course the code happened, but you can see. The
- 51:58lines they were walking between. Yeah. And you
- 52:00can kind of see or feel Will H. Hayes be like,
- 52:02nope, we need something more concrete, a set
- 52:05of guidelines for self -censorship. Yeah. So
- 52:09it's interesting. I don't want to say it's a
- 52:10good thing. It's obviously not to censor anything
- 52:12like that, but it does lend itself to what movies
- 52:15became in the 19, late 30s, early 40s. Yeah.
- 52:19So I'm interested to get to that point with you.
- 52:21And what they had to be during this time as well.
- 52:24Correct. Due to limitations. I think that's very
- 52:30interesting. What can you do between the limitations?
- 52:31Yes. For sure. That's very interesting to me.
- 52:33And it's part of the reason I've enjoyed this
- 52:35pre -code era so much. I think there's a difference
- 52:37between censorship of something that exists versus
- 52:40how can you make this in a world that is going
- 52:42to be censored. Yeah. Because then you have a
- 52:45product that is, well, this is what's allowed
- 52:46versus we went back and removed these things
- 52:49that we don't like. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Take note,
- 52:52George Lucas. So overall. I think we've got our
- 52:57views on Bad Girl. I know where you sit, but
- 53:01I'll save that for your announcement. I gave
- 53:03this movie three stars. Yes, you and Bryce both.
- 53:07Oh, Bryce gets a lot of air time. Everyone else
- 53:11who's on the Discord and talks with us, feel
- 53:12free to add me on Letterboxd so I can see your
- 53:14ratings of these movies. But we know Bryce is
- 53:16hitting the paint. He's watching these movies
- 53:19and reviewing them, so it pops up. That's kind
- 53:21of the thing. He's already seen all of them,
- 53:23so it's easy to be like, oh, look who saw this.
- 53:26Do you think Bryce is third chair? If there's
- 53:28a third chair of the pod, do you think it's Bryce?
- 53:30Listen, I won't lie. I've talked to him about
- 53:32guesting. Yeah? Bryce, call me. He didn't respond.
- 53:36That makes sense. He's watching movies. Do you
- 53:39want me to hit him up? Maybe he'll respond. Yeah,
- 53:41go for it. He's probably tired of me, so he's
- 53:44looking forward to talking to you. That's probably
- 53:45right. He's like, for you, Ryan, definitely.
- 53:48Anything bestie. He just doesn't address you
- 53:50when he's on the pod. Never. Yeah, that's probably
- 53:52what's going to happen. Yeah. What'd you give
- 53:54Bad Girl? I give Bad Girl two stars. Oh, okay.
- 53:57So you are correct in that the normal rating
- 54:01for, I should say the standard rating for this
- 54:03is three. Sitting at 3 .3, but three stars is
- 54:06the most stars that this is, not the most, the
- 54:10common rating. Of this movie. So you and Bryce
- 54:13are right there in with everyone else. Two stars
- 54:15is pretty far down the list here. Again, this
- 54:18is just a personal preference. Sure. For me and
- 54:20what I was able to ascertain from this, it just,
- 54:24it did not hit me the way that I thought it was
- 54:25going to, especially seeing this is from the
- 54:27guy who did seventh heaven. I thought that it
- 54:30would be a little more coherent than that. And
- 54:33not to say the movie is incoherent. I just inconsistent
- 54:35is the main thing for me. So two stars is the
- 54:38rating that I feel confident with. I think that's
- 54:40bad girl. I'm totally okay with that. And we're
- 54:43just right there in the middle with two and a
- 54:44half. I think that's what I gave zombie -vers,
- 54:46so that makes sense. Let's go down the list of
- 54:49what zombie -vers has. Teenagers in a cabin.
- 54:52Yeah. Check. Zombie beavers. Check. John Mayer.
- 54:56Check. This is true. Before the pod started,
- 54:59I introduced Kyle to what is probably one of
- 55:01my favorite jokes in that... John Mayer has a
- 55:03song called Something's Missing, where he very
- 55:05eloquently sings about what might be missing
- 55:07from his life. And you could take that as a metaphor.
- 55:09But instead, the final bridge or the outro of
- 55:12that song is him going down a list of things
- 55:14that he may be missing. But then so you don't
- 55:16think that he's missing those things. He says
- 55:19check after it. It's true. Including money, the
- 55:22opposite sex, guitar. He has all of these things,
- 55:27so don't worry about him. That's why I said check.
- 55:29He's doing okay. How many times do you think
- 55:32there's been a podcast that's reviewed Bad Girl
- 55:34but name -dropped Zombievers? This has got to
- 55:36be the first time. It's in the tens. Oh. Oh,
- 55:38you think so? You think it's that many times?
- 55:39Absolutely not. It's kind of like when you say
- 55:43a sentence out loud and you're like, I think
- 55:44that's the first time those words have been used
- 55:46in that way ever. That's one of my favorite trends
- 55:49on TikTok right now is when someone sees like,
- 55:53a robot freak out in a sushi restaurant and like
- 55:56flip a table. And they're just like, Billy Joel's
- 55:58playing in the background. Yeah. And they're
- 55:59like, I'm the first of my bloodline to see something
- 56:01like this. Yeah. Yeah. That's true. That's, that's
- 56:06the zombie, zombie verse reference on a bad girl,
- 56:09Frank Borsage episode. First of our bloodline.
- 56:11Do you think I should hang on to my Frank Borsage
- 56:13impression? You can, it's up to you. He's coming
- 56:15back. He is coming back. Farewell to Arms, eventually,
- 56:18we'll be covering. Maybe I should wait for Farewell
- 56:20to Arms to really complete, because I have two
- 56:22movies now for the impression. By the way, for
- 56:25anyone playing at home, I've never heard Frank
- 56:26Warzaj speak. But I'm just using his two movies
- 56:29that I've seen to kind of culminate an impression.
- 56:31Sure. So maybe I'll wait for that third movie.
- 56:34That'd be good, because I think that is the last
- 56:36time he'll be nominated. So it'll be a nice farewell
- 56:39to Frank. Yeah, I don't think Farewell to Arms
- 56:42is going to be as funny to say in my voice that
- 56:45I do. I'll mention Bad Girl a little bit more.
- 56:48Yeah, we'll have to do that. What did you pick
- 56:51as your double feature? So for my double feature,
- 56:53I went with the 2005 hit classic, Zombievers.
- 56:57No, actually, I picked something very depressing.
- 57:01I think something way more drama than this movie
- 57:04even pretends to lean towards. I went with Blue
- 57:09Valentine. Oh, my God. Well, I mean, when you
- 57:15compare the two, sure, it's a laugh -a -riot
- 57:16comedy. Yeah, yeah. Blue Valentine, of course.
- 57:19I think that the tense relationship is my comparison,
- 57:24and I don't know if it lines up. Well, there's
- 57:26a baby that's a very big part of the movie. There
- 57:28is. Yeah. There is. I think that there's a lot
- 57:31of romance in Blue Valentine, like very heated
- 57:34romance. Someone plays a ukulele for someone
- 57:36else. Oh, my goodness. Look at you. You're right.
- 57:38Although I don't know if he's trying to annoy
- 57:40her in the way that Dorothy's trying to annoy
- 57:41Eddie. I love that part where he plays the ukulele.
- 57:44I love that cover that he does. Yeah. Always
- 57:47Hurt the Ones You Love. Wow. Yeah. That was a
- 57:50vocal stem for a very long time between Taylor
- 57:52and I. I would always sing that. She's like,
- 57:53shut up. Yeah. I know Blue Valentine is like
- 57:56very heavy, very depressing. And I think that's
- 58:00kind of what it is for me where Bad Girl is for
- 58:04me, not you. A comedy that tiptoes around in
- 58:08some of the drama. Sure. And Blue Valentine is
- 58:12a very heavy drama that wants nothing to do with
- 58:15your comedy. Yes. It wants your tears. Exactly.
- 58:19They're the perfect double feature. Derek, Sean
- 58:21France, right? No idea, if I'm being honest.
- 58:24I'll say yes. I'm pretty sure it's Derek. I might
- 58:26be saying his name incorrectly. It might be Gianfrance,
- 58:29but it's Derek for sure. He went on to do Place
- 58:33Beyond the Pines with Ryan Gosling as well. So
- 58:35I'm pretty sure that's correct. And then he did
- 58:36Roofman. Oh, look at him go. There you go. You
- 58:39know, I've caught a couple strays on this episode
- 58:42about how I view this more as a drama with some
- 58:45comedy elements. But I do want you to know that
- 58:47the double feature that I picked for this...
- 58:49or the movie that I picked for this double feature
- 58:51is a movie that does kind of balance comedy and
- 58:54drama, but I think at its core is more of a comedy
- 58:56with dramatic moments. So maybe that's truly
- 58:58how I see. that girl but I picked and since if
- 59:03you were paying attention to before the pod when
- 59:04I mentioned this off recording directed by Danny
- 59:07DeVito it's the 1989 War of the Roses or oh the
- 59:11idea of this movie it kind of seems like the
- 59:14early stages of what's a realistic version of
- 59:17these two people who are miscommunicating and
- 59:19not talking to each other and i think the uh
- 59:22true answer is them essentially trying to ruin
- 59:25each other's lives or in the remake of this later
- 59:29in life called the roses from 2025 uh actually
- 59:32actively trying to kill each other um this was
- 59:35the closest that i felt like a tone In the movie.
- 59:38Okay. Because the middle of the movie did very
- 59:40much feel like, why am I not connecting with
- 59:43this person? What's preventing that? And while
- 59:45you, the audience, are screaming, it's this,
- 59:47I thought that the natural progression of their
- 59:50communication breakdown would have lended itself
- 59:53to more of a distancing themselves. Or even something
- 59:57above distancing themselves, because that's kind
- 59:59of what happens in the movie. I thought it'd
- 1:00:00be more like, well, I hold contentment for you.
- 1:00:02Well, I want to ruin your life. Maybe now I'm
- 1:00:05going to not have this baby to spite you. A couple
- 1:00:08of things, or not be responsible for this baby
- 1:00:10to spite you. I thought there might be some things
- 1:00:12like that. And that's where, at the end of the
- 1:00:14day, I looked at Batgirl and I was like, I think
- 1:00:16I'm thinking of it like War of the Roses. So
- 1:00:18that, to me, feels like the progression of the
- 1:00:21relationship between Eddie and Dorothy and what
- 1:00:23that looks like in 1989. That makes sense. I've
- 1:00:25never seen that movie, but the way you're setting
- 1:00:28it up, it makes sense to me. One, DeVito has
- 1:00:30a little bit of a sick sense of humor, so that
- 1:00:32kind of lends itself to how he views their relationship
- 1:00:35in that movie versus something like from 1931.
- 1:00:39DeVito probably sounds similar to Borsage. In
- 1:00:42my mind, they're similar. I don't appreciate
- 1:00:45you trying to give away my impression before
- 1:00:47I do it for the Farewell to Arms episode. But
- 1:00:51you're right. There's a little bit of similarity.
- 1:00:52Maybe a little bit more his penguin in Batman.
- 1:00:56But I love that the audience is probably trying
- 1:00:59to piece together in real time what this sounds
- 1:01:01like. The only thing I'll give away is that,
- 1:01:03and I guess I can't mention it for Farewell to
- 1:01:05Arms as much, he would definitely say bad girl,
- 1:01:07like bad Goyle. Yes, I do like that. He's like
- 1:01:10Meowth from Pokemon. Yeah, a little bit. Like
- 1:01:13a little bit of penguin, a little bit of DeVito,
- 1:01:15and a little bit of Meowth. I like this. Bad
- 1:01:18Goyle. Yeah, there you go. That's exactly what
- 1:01:21Meowth sounds like. That's so good. Thanks. I've
- 1:01:23been waiting for us to cover a Frank Porzage
- 1:01:25movie for me to do my Meowth. Guys, if you have
- 1:01:27any thoughts on Bad Girl or any of the other
- 1:01:30films we're covering for this, not season, year.
- 1:01:34No, how do I say this? Academy year of the podcast.
- 1:01:38Shoot us an email at outaopodcast at gmail .com.
- 1:01:42Next week, we will be covering Five Star Final
- 1:01:46and The Champ. So looking forward to that. If
- 1:01:50you'd like to support the show, check out patreon
- 1:01:53.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast for access to
- 1:01:56the community discord. Watch parties. We'll be
- 1:01:58doing another one of those at some point this
- 1:02:00month. More details coming soon. Access to the
- 1:02:03best picture poll and movie reviews. Yep. And
- 1:02:07who knows what I've seen recently and I'm posting
- 1:02:09on there because we are recording a little more
- 1:02:11in advance for that. It's true. It's April. There's
- 1:02:14some good stuff coming out. I'll post that. Yeah.
- 1:02:16Man, can you believe the review that I dropped
- 1:02:18for... I'm leaving a blank there. Every time
- 1:02:21you do that, it makes my life so much harder.
- 1:02:23I realize that and now I'm doing it intentionally
- 1:02:25because I know that you're editing out the silence
- 1:02:28there. So maybe I'll just create like in April,
- 1:02:31I'll create like a voice of me doing like, I
- 1:02:33don't know what comes out in April. Man, I really
- 1:02:36enjoyed writing a review for the Super Mario's
- 1:02:38Galaxy movie. Look forward to that. What I want
- 1:02:41to start doing is finding random people on the
- 1:02:43streets and just having them... record a line
- 1:02:45of dialogue so i can just put the most random
- 1:02:47stuff in there from the most random people i
- 1:02:50like that i also like the idea of them not cooperating
- 1:02:52yes and they would end up being i really enjoyed
- 1:02:55this review that i ended up writing for leave
- 1:02:57me alone back up back up right now it's a cop
- 1:03:01that i ask yeah it's just you being arrested
- 1:03:04oh i'm sorry i'm sorry i'm sorry can you publish
- 1:03:06this this is the deadline But yeah. The funniest
- 1:03:09thing about that is the idea of the episode still
- 1:03:11being edited after you've been detained. Someone
- 1:03:13will do it. You can take care of it. It's not
- 1:03:15going to be me. Well, all right. We'll find somebody.
- 1:03:18Oh, you know what? Bryce. Perfect. Third chair.
- 1:03:20Third chair. Thanks, man. Can always count on
- 1:03:21you. We appreciate you doing that, Bryce. Thank
- 1:03:23you. He's always there for us. I know he's having
- 1:03:25like internal panic right now listening to the
- 1:03:27episode. He's like. I think he's behind too.
- 1:03:29So he's going to listen to this episode in like
- 1:03:312027 and be like. What? Did I agree to that?
- 1:03:34I stopped talking to those guys years ago. What's
- 1:03:35really funny is the idea that he may do editing
- 1:03:39for us between when he listens to this and 2027.
- 1:03:42Who knows? So he's like, oh, they're right. I
- 1:03:44did. Yeah. Predicting the future. Who's to say?
- 1:03:47Who's to say? That's going to do it for this
- 1:03:49episode. As always, I'm your host, Kyle. I'm
- 1:03:52Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies.