Latest / NAUGHTY GYM SHOW - Building Stronger Non-Monogamous Relationships / Scott Debates Scott: Can Love & Commitment Survive Radical Freedom?
Transcript
- 0:00We are April and Scott, creators of naughty gym.com
- 0:04and this is the Naughty Gym Show. For years, we've been fitness
- 0:08and nutrition coaches to thousands of people through our commercial gyms and
- 0:11online platforms. We've also spent nearly a decade in an ever evolving
- 0:16open relationship. This show brings together two of our biggest passions,
- 0:20fitness and sex positivity. Our mission is
- 0:23to maximize the physical and mental health of anyone brave enough to explore
- 0:28relationship structures that run counter. To societal norms demolished
- 0:33our old ways of thinking about relationships, and from that rubble built a life
- 0:37full of happiness, adventure and vitality. And now we want to help you do the
- 0:41same. So hop on the treadmill, start the show, and let us teach you
- 0:45how to never stop playing.
- 0:49All right, welcome back to the Naughty Jim Show. This is a.
- 0:53A new thing, new type of show we've never
- 0:57done, and it's just me. April's not here today and I have a guest
- 1:01who is a him and his wife. Scott and Kim are
- 1:06personal training clients, my virtual training clients. And Scott
- 1:12is here today to say why he hates me.
- 1:16I hate you because you make me go to the gym and drink less alcohol.
- 1:20I'm not sure I'm accomplishing the less alcohol part,
- 1:24but no. So we.
- 1:28So Scott and I have had an exchange of emails
- 1:32lately and just discussions. It started about one thing
- 1:36and sort of shifted to another, even though they're kind of connected, but initially we
- 1:40were talking about, through an exchange of emails,
- 1:44aspect of wildlife theory. And Scott's at a bit of
- 1:48a disadvantage there because I haven't put the book out yet. So, I mean,
- 1:51it's hard for him to know everything, you know, that I think about wildlife
- 1:55theory. But he's done a great job of
- 1:59making me really think through some of my positions, which is why I
- 2:04had so much value in having those exchanges. And so I want
- 2:07to hear his perspective on these issues and then I will
- 2:11respond to him and we'll just have a back and forth discussion and because there
- 2:14may be people out there that really disagree with certain aspects of wildlife theory,
- 2:18but this is not a fight and not a bad nature
- 2:22thing. He and I may disagree strongly. I don't know about some of this stuff,
- 2:25but whatever you hear today, don't think that we're hanging up mad at each other,
- 2:28even though we're probably going to strongly defend our position. So anyway, that was a
- 2:32long intro. Scott, welcome to the show. Thank you very much. So,
- 2:36yeah, I appreciate the. The invite and continued dialogue on this
- 2:41topic. So commitment, marriage, that's something that I believe we both believe in,
- 2:44and there's a lot of things we're in a lot of alignment on. I don't.
- 2:47I don't know Wild Love Theory fully, but the parts I have heard about
- 2:51it, I love just that idea of encouraging your partner to
- 2:55grow and be them for their full selves. And that's
- 2:58where. That's where this discussion started. I actually don't even remember the impetus
- 3:02for the original discussion or the email, but tell
- 3:07me, as best you remember, what the original
- 3:11issue was that we started discussing via email prior
- 3:16to this podcast episode coming out. So I think I may have done a disservice
- 3:21in it trying to explain it in that very first email. But you
- 3:25were talking about Wild Love Theory and just the general premise, correct me if I'm
- 3:29wrong, that the idea is the more you support your partner's growth and
- 3:33the less rules you put around the relationship in the environment, the more they can
- 3:38flourish and the healthier things can be. Hearing that,
- 3:41I agree with it in principle. I have a
- 3:46different approach to marriage, more of a traditional approach to
- 3:50marriage. It is a lifetime commitment.
- 3:53And so with that lifetime commitment where you kind
- 3:57of put on the blinders and pretend divorce is never an option. It's not an
- 4:01option. I mean, you just state every day, not even going to consider
- 4:05it. It's not a word that can come into our vocabulary with
- 4:09that. We put boundaries, rules on
- 4:14each other that allow us to maintain that mental posture.
- 4:19And that's something that I see as lacking in the E
- 4:23M community. So as I heard more about Wild Love Theory, I wanted to
- 4:27see if that could be included in it or how.
- 4:32How that note was included in Wild Love Theory. Yeah,
- 4:36and that's. We. We all really. The conversation got interrupted because
- 4:41unfortunately your wife had a death in the family and. And it sort of put
- 4:45a. I felt bad about continuing the conversation, even though I know it was sort
- 4:49of maybe a potential dist. You. But yeah,
- 4:52we kind of didn't conclude that conversation before the podcast
- 4:56came out and sort of renewed another potential issue. But I think we said
- 5:00we were going to finish it face to face and it was just kind of
- 5:03getting like. I don't know, it's kind of be way easier with a bourbon in
- 5:06hand or. Yeah, yeah, that's right. We're drinking.
- 5:10We're drinking them. I'm gonna. I'm gonna get that drinking water.
- 5:13Oh, yeah. So, yeah, I know,
- 5:17I know this isn't. It's almost not a fair conversation in some sense because you
- 5:20hadn't gotten a chance to read the book. It's not out yet. That being said,
- 5:23I do want to start out by saying that Wild Love Theory. Yes, is.
- 5:27Is a theory that focuses on
- 5:31Max. The theory itself is seven words. It's maximal relational happiness
- 5:35requires maximal relational freedom. It doesn't say that
- 5:39relational happiness requires relational freedom. Like the
- 5:44second chapter of my book is a story about. And you may find this interesting,
- 5:47but my grandparents, my maternal grandparents. I went with
- 5:51my cousin who was in some. Doing some postdoctorate
- 5:55work in therapy, and he was interviewing
- 5:59a lot of people that had been married over 50 years. My grand.
- 6:02Our shared grandparents were one of those couples, and they had been married
- 6:0663 years, and they were still pretty spry and with
- 6:10it. And we met him at Captain D's to do an interview. He asked me
- 6:14to come along in case I could think of questions he didn't think to ask
- 6:17them. And as he was writing down some of their responses, I asked
- 6:21my grandfather what was the worst fight that they
- 6:25had ever gotten into. And he paused and
- 6:28looked really perplexed and just kind of shook his head and said,
- 6:32well, I don't remember us ever having a fight. Sure. Now, these are two
- 6:36of the American nuclear family grandparents. I mean, they've raised.
- 6:40They'd raised four kids, all successful people, all with families of their own, to my
- 6:44knowledge, from them down through their children and their grandchildren and
- 6:47great grandchildren. Not one arrest of anybody in that entire family.
- 6:51The very stable family. They were very kind, very funny,
- 6:55just gracious people. So I had no reason not to believe him other than,
- 6:59well, he was about 80 years old and maybe he had forgotten. So I asked
- 7:02my grandmother. I looked at her and said, all right.
- 7:06That Meemaw. Meemaw and Gandhi was their grandparents. That can't
- 7:09be true. I know you all had a fight. What's the word? What's he forgetting?
- 7:13What was the worst one? And she looked at him and looked back at me
- 7:17and thought. And she goes, well, I don't reckon we've ever had a fight.
- 7:20All right? So now everything stops. Me and my cousin are just,
- 7:24you know, peppering them with this essentially same question asked.
- 7:28It asked 40 different ways. Did you ever slam a
- 7:32door? Did you know any of that stuff? Nothing? Asked my mother,
- 7:36my cousin's father, which was their daughter and son, and then the two other
- 7:40children, my aunt and uncle, they all said the same thing. They seemed perplexed,
- 7:44like they had never thought about it before, and said, yeah, growing up,
- 7:47we've never seen them fight, never heard them yelling behind the Closed door.
- 7:51All evidence that we have points to a 63
- 7:55year marriage over 23,000 days. And none
- 7:59of them, as best we can tell, ever ended in a fight.
- 8:02Okay. I thought was incredible. And it kind of held this up as
- 8:06like this, you know, this talisman of what a
- 8:10relationship should be like. Because I was on my second marriage
- 8:14and we could, if we went a week without fighting, I was impressed,
- 8:18like we would bring it up. This has been a great week. When fault one
- 8:21and here they did it for 63 years. Well,
- 8:25and they were happy, sure. Now they did not implement
- 8:29wildlife theory in any sort of way that we
- 8:33might recognize. Like they didn't have an open relationship obviously.
- 8:36You know, he worked on the railroad and made all the money for
- 8:40the family. She stayed at home and took care of the kids in the home.
- 8:43It was a traditional setup, but they were extremely
- 8:47happy. So I make that point in the book to say this is not about
- 8:51being happy. It's about is there something more than
- 8:55the traditional happiness? Is there a level above that? Is there a
- 9:00black belt to their brown belt or something?
- 9:03So it's not about, it's not about happiness in general.
- 9:07It's about this next level happiness also.
- 9:10It's not anti commitment or anti boundary or rules, in other words.
- 9:14I do make the case that the goal should be,
- 9:18if you want to maximize your partner's happiness, is to get to
- 9:23the point where you don't have to put any imposed rules or boundaries on them
- 9:27that they wouldn't otherwise choose for themselves. So if it's something like, in other words,
- 9:30we've talked about monogamy for instance. Yeah, theory works
- 9:34fine in a monogamous relationship as long as both people genuinely want it.
- 9:38And it's not a situation where one partner wants monogamy
- 9:42and the other partner is agreeing to monogamy even though really
- 9:46they would like to explore non monogamy. That's not mutual agreement. That's one
- 9:51person setting a standard and the other person agreeing, agreeing to it in order
- 9:55to maintain, you know, the connection or whatever. That's,
- 9:59that's the type of boundaries where wildlife theory is fine with co agreed
- 10:03upon, mutually desired. Because those aren't really boundaries.
- 10:07You can call them boundaries and that's fine, but that's not the type we're talking
- 10:10about in the book. Like you're both going to eat. You don't have to put
- 10:13a boundary on each other forcing each other to eat because you both want to
- 10:17eat. So that's kind of the distinction that we make in the book. So we're
- 10:21not. It's not anti boundary, and it's not anti commitment. I couldn't. This is an
- 10:25idea that's been rumbling around in my brain for a couple of years, but I
- 10:29never really brought it up to April until I had gotten to the point where
- 10:32I felt like my level of confidence in the stability of
- 10:36our relationship was such that I didn't have any fears anymore
- 10:40of letting go of the few remaining rules that
- 10:44I asked her to abide by. Does that make sense?
- 10:47No. No. I mean, it makes sense. Yeah. I get it. And I think
- 10:51it's beautiful for you. I don't. It doesn't make sense for me.
- 10:56Right, right. Yeah. So, yeah, let me go back and say something about that,
- 11:00too. I'm not saying that this is something that I believe is an
- 11:04ethical imperative in the sense that any other relationship
- 11:08structure is ethically compromised.
- 11:12I'm making the case, though, that if
- 11:16you can get to that point, that you. You will be happier because you'll
- 11:20be able to fully express yourself exactly as you are and not limit
- 11:24yourself because of boundaries somebody's put on you to make them
- 11:28feel comfortable, essentially. Or there's so many things unpacked there,
- 11:32I don't even know where to start.
- 11:35Start with the one you hate the most. Well, no, I don't
- 11:39hate any of them because, as you said, it's not a. I'm not evaluating
- 11:43this for you or anybody else. I'm just evaluating it for
- 11:47me. Right. So hit me with the definition of wildlife
- 11:53theory, and let's just parse through that kind of phrase by phrase. It's.
- 11:57Maximal relational happiness requires maximal relational freedom.
- 12:01Okay. Maximal relational happiness, that's a
- 12:05statement of. Are you meaning that for all people, in all
- 12:09things, in all relationships. Are you meaning that for in this.
- 12:12In this space where you've adopted wild love theory?
- 12:15Well, I mean, that's a good question. And it's sort of both.
- 12:20Even though it sounds like it can't be both. It is.
- 12:23It's like an ideal that I think people should strive for,
- 12:27but I'm not. I'm not 100% sure any of
- 12:32us or many of us can actually get there. All right, so in other words,
- 12:35operational. Target for maximal relational
- 12:39happiness. And that's a result of the maximal relational
- 12:43freedom. Yeah. In essence, I think all other things mean
- 12:48equal. The fewer impositions you have on
- 12:52your partner, the happier they can be. Okay,
- 12:56I. So there's. We have this happiness and freedom balance
- 13:00that's going on that as we maximize freedom and
- 13:04somebody's free to become their true and genuine self. It increases happiness.
- 13:08And as a result of that increased happiness, it's a good day.
- 13:11And we're, we're kind of looking that as a. You said it's
- 13:15not an ethical imperative, but I had heard you earlier referring to it as a
- 13:18moral imperative and I don't know if that's a misfortune. Well,
- 13:22okay, so it's not an ethical imperative in the sense of an objective morality
- 13:26because first of all, I don't believe in objective morality from a philosophical standpoint.
- 13:30But if you adopt the idea, if you, if you accept
- 13:34that it is your obligation as a partner to try
- 13:38to maximal maximize your partner's happiness, then it becomes an
- 13:42ethical imperative. Now it's not objective in the sense that maybe a
- 13:46Christian would say a law from God is objective.
- 13:49Sure. But it's, it becomes objective relative
- 13:54to the stated goal. So if, if you think maximizing your partner's happiness
- 13:58is something you should do, then it would become an imperative at that. Okay,
- 14:01so where I struggle with this is I do not have full
- 14:06freedom to go do everything I want. Kim does not have
- 14:10full freedom to go do everything she wants. I can't imagine
- 14:14a life that I have more relational happiness or more happiness
- 14:19than the life I currently have. I may be like your 63 year old
- 14:23meemaw that has, or 63 year marriage meemaw that has the brown belt
- 14:27and may not be able to see the black belt. I don't
- 14:31think that's true. I think I may have cracked
- 14:36the code in a way that was based on giving up some
- 14:40of my freedom. Again, this is for me. So this is not a,
- 14:44I'm not going to make a ethical or moral statement on other
- 14:48people's views on how they run their relationships.
- 14:51For me, I've intentionally chosen to maintain the posture
- 14:56of marriage is a commitment forever. So when you say let's,
- 15:00hey, would you marry me? That means tell death do
- 15:04us part. To me, I know there's a lot of people who's like,
- 15:08until we grow apart or there's something else, but for
- 15:12me it is till death do us part. And that allows me a level of
- 15:17surety, commitment, comfort,
- 15:21contentment. And for me,
- 15:25contentment trumps happiness. So happiness
- 15:28is something that is a short term joy based feeling.
- 15:32Genuine contentment is something where I can
- 15:35experience happiness growing out of it. Well, let's, let's talk
- 15:39about that definition of happiness you just brought up because that's
- 15:43not the way I define happiness in the book. And that's again
- 15:47where you come in. And maybe
- 15:51we shouldn't dissect wild, I don't know wild love theory.
- 15:54I'm trying to express how I don't hear the
- 15:59type of relationship structure that I have represented in
- 16:03mainstream E M cultures, books,
- 16:06podcasts, therapy. I hear mostly progressive.
- 16:11Let's go from monogamy to non monogamy to polyamory
- 16:15and or let's go towards freedom and happiness.
- 16:20Let's. We're all risk if we're. If we're fucking other people. We are
- 16:24probably risk takers and open minded individuals in
- 16:30that space. We've kind of selected that being the norm group most of the podcast
- 16:33books therapists are advocating for that freedom
- 16:38dash explorative happiness
- 16:42derived culture where I love the
- 16:46fact that Kim and I have a open relationship, we have a
- 16:50lot of fun and it brings a lot of joy to us and happiness to
- 16:54us. But what I value more is the contentment
- 16:59and longevity of knowing that
- 17:04one of us is going to die first. But we're going to ride this
- 17:07whole thing till we're done and we're going to maintain that posture every day.
- 17:10And so we put boundaries in place with each other to limit
- 17:15ever getting into a position where we could ever risk that
- 17:20longevity. Yeah. Yeah. So I have a lot to ask about
- 17:24that, especially the last sentence you just said because
- 17:28probably of all the things we've disagreed on and of course I may
- 17:33not understand your claim there thoroughly, but that's the
- 17:36part I disagree the most on. Okay, not only disagree, but I think it's impossible.
- 17:40So. But, but that's probably because I'm misinterpreting it. So we'll come back to that
- 17:44in a second. I do want to just quickly say that when the way I
- 17:49define happiness in the book may actually resemble more the way
- 17:53you define commitment. I don't know. But in. In I don't.
- 17:57Happiness is not a fleeting thing, at least not all happiness.
- 18:01It's not a kind of a whimsical spur of the moment sort of happiness.
- 18:04Philosophers usually describe happiness in one of two ways. Kind of like love
- 18:08has different types of love, have different definitions agape or you types
- 18:13of familial love. Happiness is defined in one of two
- 18:17ways, both being essential to what we write about in Wild Love theory.
- 18:20One is the hedonistic happiness, which is more like what I think you're talking about,
- 18:24the sort of. The more immediate satisfaction and joy
- 18:28in a moment, that sort of thing. But one is the eudaimonic and I'm not
- 18:31Even sure I pronounced that word right. It was created, I think, by Plato,
- 18:35but it's more of the purpose driven life. A life built on meaning
- 18:39and commitment and purpose. And. And that happiness tends to come from
- 18:43one of those two places. And that in wildlife theory, we just
- 18:47merge them and call that one word of both types of happiness,
- 18:51happiness. Okay.
- 18:55You compared happiness to commitment. I was using the word contentment.
- 19:00Yeah, I'm sorry. I meant contentment. Okay, that's my fault. Yeah. And it may
- 19:04not be, but I just wanted to point out that happiness as we define
- 19:08it in wildlife theory is not just the hedonistic version, it's also
- 19:11the eudaimonic. And this is the way philosophers tend to talk about happiness too.
- 19:15Say they full happiness usually comes through one of two of those things.
- 19:20And the happier person is the person that seems to be able to maximize both.
- 19:24Okay, so if every time I hear you say the word happiness, I transpose that
- 19:27with the word contentment. That's good.
- 19:32Well, I think it sounds more like the way you sound.
- 19:35I don't know that it would be exactly equivalent to contentment, because I think
- 19:39contentment sometimes can inhibit growth.
- 19:44Yeah, it can. I'm definitely advocating inhibiting growth compared to what
- 19:48you're talking about. Yeah. So I. I just wanted to point that out. So it
- 19:52didn't. We didn't come have to come back to that version of happiness. But.
- 19:55So, yeah, I do want to ask. Happiness, meaning transient joy,
- 19:59excitement, flirtation, the spark, you know, the first, the new
- 20:03relationship, energy and contentment being kind of that enduring peace,
- 20:07security, stability, those sorts of things. But then we.
- 20:11And that may be more of the eudaimonic happiness.
- 20:15And again, we just try to merge those into one. I think you need both.
- 20:19And I think that based off the conversations you and I have had, you think
- 20:23we need both of those two. We may just. You may be defining contentment
- 20:28in the same way I'm defining that other type of happiness. I think it's that
- 20:33I can't get. I get to a greater level of happiness based
- 20:38on knowing that I have a commitment and contentment and a
- 20:42sense of. I don't have to fear saying anything
- 20:46to Kim. There's nothing I can tell her or ask
- 20:50her to do or explore with her where I have to worry about
- 20:56losing the relationship. Or. I mean, I may
- 20:59propose something that may cause harm, and she'll say, that's a dumb idea. Don't do
- 21:03that, you idiot. But there's. There's no
- 21:06worry of saying to her, this is what I would like
- 21:10to do or this, or her saying to me, this is who I would like
- 21:14to do. This is what I would like to do. Yeah. And April and I
- 21:17have the same thing. Right. So that feeling of exploration
- 21:22for me isn't the first thing, it's the second thing.
- 21:25For me it is having that commitment and contentment drives
- 21:30the safety to do the exploration versus encouraging
- 21:34the exploration to drive the happiness or content.
- 21:38Well, that's not. But I'm not making that claim. Give me the wildlife theory
- 21:42definition again. Because I think where I hear the wildlife definition, I think that's what
- 21:46the claim is. It says maximal relational happiness requires maximal relational
- 21:51freedom. But that's not an ordering. For instance,
- 21:54I believe that all. Well, I'm not going to say all.
- 21:58I don't want to use absolute statements like that. But I think most
- 22:02relationships require some scaffolding at first. And I refer to
- 22:06imposed boundaries in the book as relational scaffolding that
- 22:10you put those in place in order to over time build trust
- 22:14in the relationship and then you remove them as they no
- 22:18longer become necessary. There were limits, rules,
- 22:22boundaries that April and I have had in place. I mean, and most people that
- 22:25go into non monogamy have some version of this story that you had this laundry
- 22:29list of rules when you first started and that. And those rules have
- 22:33dropped and become increasingly less relevant or necessary the
- 22:37longer you've been in the relationship. I just take that to the extreme.
- 22:42I just think I have adopted the position
- 22:45in the book, adopts the position that there's no end in sight for that that
- 22:49is inherently necessary. Now there may be in specific relationships
- 22:54necessary to keep them. Yeah. So in. In if
- 22:57we were to go without just listening to the definition of wild love theory
- 23:01and start at the beginning of saying any relationship that is solid and
- 23:05in a relationship where there was scaffolding, maybe at some point in time, maybe you
- 23:08didn't need it, maybe that's not your relationship style. But if you
- 23:11are sure in the relationship then.
- 23:15And you're at the point where like we're at the point where we're
- 23:19at. I completely agree with Wild Love theory as applied to
- 23:23us. Right. Where they're. With the caveat of we
- 23:27put rules and boundaries on each other, we won't get into any spot
- 23:31where either of us could get into a spot to ever up
- 23:35the relationship long term. Okay. So that's what I'll come back to that. Because that's
- 23:39the part where I think we disagree the most. But yeah,
- 23:45I think that's pretty much. I don't think you're misrepresenting love
- 23:49Theory, but I just wanted to clear up that it wasn't something I don't think
- 23:53anybody should ever. When the book comes out, for instance, read the book
- 23:56and go, okay, spouse, no more rules for you. That is a
- 24:00recipe for. I wouldn't think you'd propose that. So. All right. So we.
- 24:04We went through this exchange of emails talking about this very thing. This was the
- 24:07thing those first emails were focused on. So I did want to read
- 24:11something. And if. I want to make sure I understood this right. If I'm
- 24:15not, I just want you to explain, you know, where I'm missing it, but I'll
- 24:19try to read. I'm going to blast through the first part because it's not as
- 24:22important. I don't want to just spend 20 minutes reading. But you said where
- 24:27we differ significantly. This is you talking to me. Where we differ significantly is
- 24:31in how we structure this freedom. I'll stop for a second. I think me and
- 24:35you both want freedom. I think we value commitment and, you know,
- 24:40trust that our relationship is going to be forever.
- 24:44It's how we frame or get to that position. Seems like where we
- 24:48disagree, but yes. All right. And that's what you
- 24:52said there. Essentially, it said, and this is brought up a personal
- 24:56thing that we had been going through with some friends. Doesn't really matter.
- 25:00But you said because of that, I tried to contemplate similarly
- 25:04extreme situations within my marriage, including if Kim,
- 25:08that's your wife, attempted to murder me.
- 25:12Attempted to murder me. Or even more incomprehensibly succeeded
- 25:17at it in intentionally murdering one of our kids. Yeah.
- 25:20Even in those horrific hypothetical scenarios,
- 25:23I genuinely can't envision divorce. Correct.
- 25:27So there's a
- 25:31part of me that wants to say that sounds noble, and then there's the other
- 25:34side of me that wants to say that sounds insane. So I thought before I.
- 25:38Can you try a third option on please? Okay. Yeah.
- 25:42So if, If. If I'm misunderstanding that. Explain. If there's nuance
- 25:46in there, explain what you meant. It's not a new. There's nuance.
- 25:50It's not. It's not noble. I don't believe it's insane. It's a posture
- 25:55of every day saying there's nothing that
- 25:59can happen that will allow me to contemplate getting divorced every
- 26:05day. I know she takes the posture of we're in this forever.
- 26:08We made a promise to each other that we're in this forever.
- 26:12She will always be my wife. There's nothing that can be done
- 26:16to remove that. I can't, I can't fathom that.
- 26:20And anytime I get close to allowing myself to fathom that,
- 26:24I look at it and go, is that that
- 26:28doubt? Is that insecurity? Is that, is that worth
- 26:32it? Is exploring that worth it?
- 26:35So we've been married over 30 years,
- 26:39and there have been plenty of times where we've been in. I mean, there have
- 26:43been years, decade. I mean, they're long times where
- 26:47we weren't getting along or things weren't going rosy. Right.
- 26:50Happens to be. Things are going pretty rosy right now. But during
- 26:54those times, anytime I would start
- 26:58even allowing the hint of doubt to move
- 27:02in, I could see how quickly that could fester. I could see how quickly that
- 27:06would allow me to move into a spot of doing things
- 27:10that would cause problems. So knowing
- 27:14that I maintain that posture in every moment of every day,
- 27:17that I won't allow the doubt to enter. Right.
- 27:21Allowed me to never, never get to the point where I had to doubt.
- 27:28So do you. But do you mean if she were to murder one of
- 27:32your. I know this is like, literally, if. She were to murder one of the
- 27:35kids. I don't. There's a, there's a.
- 27:39Oh, I said this to her once. This probably, probably not appropriate
- 27:43for the podcast. She'll kill me for saying that. I said, I can
- 27:47more easily imagine murdering you than I can divorcing you.
- 27:50What if, what do you think she should do if you
- 27:55routinely physically abused her? That's.
- 27:59I'm not going to routinely physically abuse her because that will put me in the
- 28:02posture of, yeah, it's not
- 28:06an option. Well, so. Oh, let's, let's talk
- 28:10about. I mean, so what you're asking for is that's
- 28:14like lumping all things together because of an extreme case. Let's just talk about real
- 28:18cases. Right. Wait a minute. Let me, Let me. Before you say any more,
- 28:22I want to say this, and maybe I'm not asking the question well,
- 28:25but I think unquestionably, in any situation,
- 28:29yours, my relationship, or anybody else's, if somebody
- 28:33is being routinely physically abused, it is imperative
- 28:37that they separate themselves from that relationship. It's.
- 28:40It's life threatening, potentially.
- 28:44So I. Let me respond to that one.
- 28:48So I have. I am not naive in the sense that divorce doesn't
- 28:51happen or it doesn't serve a purpose. Right. So I'm not a divorce.
- 28:56Divorces should never happen. I've advocated for friends to get divorced.
- 29:00So when they're in an abusive relationship or when they're in a relationship where
- 29:04at some point somebody let doubt get in. And then over time, they moved apart,
- 29:08they just grew apart. And over. They were
- 29:12just roommates for 20 years. And, you know, it's always with a heavy
- 29:16heart and tears in my eyes. Sure. So, yes, if you
- 29:21go to. I've advocated for friends to get abortions.
- 29:24It's the same way. It's always with a heavy heart and tears in my eyes.
- 29:28It's not something that I enter into lightly or ingest.
- 29:31And then anytime there is a extreme case.
- 29:35Yeah, absolutely. That is. That is, you know, those are warranted solutions.
- 29:39Okay, but then any. When we start talking about the
- 29:45normal cases, right? Not. Not abuse or those sorts of things, but just
- 29:49my marriage, right. The one I can talk about.
- 29:54It's not allowing that doubt to enter in.
- 29:58In a normal relationship just isn't. Well, I want to. I want
- 30:02to come back to the doubt part because that's also one of the things I
- 30:05don't think is. I will
- 30:09say that from a logic standpoint, it's possible for a human being to
- 30:13think there's no doubt. But I don't think that you.
- 30:17That that's actually. I didn't say it's never. I didn't
- 30:21say it's never entered in. I'm saying don't allow it to enter in.
- 30:25Right. So anytime it shows up, get rid of it. Anytime there
- 30:29is doubt, you have to go, why am I doing this? Right.
- 30:33So my brain, My brain processes just like your does. Anytime it's not getting what
- 30:37it wants, it wants to explore what it wants. And then it's like, okay,
- 30:39well, maybe I can find something better. There's. So I'm not getting what I want.
- 30:43Something's not fulfilling me. Right. What can
- 30:47I do about that? Right. Oh, maybe this marriage doesn't work.
- 30:50Well, Anytime that doubt enters in for just a fraction
- 30:54of a second, that's a normal thought, right? It's a. Is it.
- 30:58Is it normal or can you prevent it? Yeah, I don't think you can prevent
- 31:02doubts like that. I mean, those are. Those are just because that's what I'm asking.
- 31:05In the, in the email exchanges, it seems like you're suggesting I can prevent the
- 31:09doubt. So don't. No, no, no. I, I always try and say maintain the posture.
- 31:14Right. It's not a. Okay. Yeah. I guess I'm still not quite sure
- 31:18what the distinction there is. I understand what a posture towards not
- 31:22wanting doubt would be. I'm not sure what a posture
- 31:27of not allowing doubt would look like because I don't I'm not sure I buy
- 31:30that that's possible, but maybe that's still not what you're saying. No,
- 31:34it's. I think. I think is what I'm saying. I think just maybe a struggle
- 31:39to see it. And that's fine. We just have different relationship dynamics,
- 31:44different relationship focus. So when you say things like the
- 31:50even if she murdered my children, I.
- 31:54Even the. Even in these horrific hypothetical scenarios, I genuinely
- 31:58can't envision divorce.
- 32:01There's nothing I can't gathering that there's. A little hyperbole to that,
- 32:05or you mean that. That even if she murdered my children, I wouldn't.
- 32:08Well, I can't imagine her murdering my children. I can't imagine.
- 32:12Yeah. So we're taking it to extremes, right?
- 32:16I'm trying to come up with the most violent,
- 32:19disturbing thing that I could ever think of,
- 32:22apply it to Kim and then go. Even in that environment, can I
- 32:27see getting divorced? No. And it could be because I've
- 32:31had 30 years of practice of maintaining the posture of just anytime doubt
- 32:35enters in, get rid of it. It's not a helpful.
- 32:39It is a natural thing. But she's
- 32:43the most loving, caring, open minded,
- 32:46supportive person. So there's. Why would you doubt?
- 32:52There's no reason to doubt because I made
- 32:56a commitment till death do us part, and that's the only way I know how
- 32:59to do it. Right. If. If I allow doubt to fester, if I allow doubt
- 33:03to enter, then the till death
- 33:07do us part things like until I find something better or until you
- 33:11annoy me enough or it's not a. Do you think that's what is
- 33:16the cause of. So, like, roughly. And I don't think it's quite 50%
- 33:19yet, but, you know, roughly. So somewhere between 40 and 50% of
- 33:23all first marriages in America end in divorce. Do you think it's because primarily
- 33:28those people didn't commit in the same way you've committed?
- 33:31I don't know. I can't. I can't speak for them. But I do know that
- 33:35a lot of American cultures based on the let's be in
- 33:39this until we find something better or we grow apart or Kim and I can't
- 33:43grow apart. Right? There is. We will grow and we will each grow and
- 33:47annoy each other for certain seasons. I mean, there's a decade or
- 33:51two where we grew apart in the sense that we were just very different people
- 33:55needing very different things. But we knew we were in it forever, so we had
- 33:59to constantly work at constantly getting back to together because
- 34:04there wasn't an option to go, well, I've kind
- 34:08of grown apart and let's go do something else. Do you think that since that
- 34:11worked for you, that intentional posture, as you
- 34:15put it. Yeah. That it would therefore work for other people if they adopted
- 34:19that as well? I, I know other people who do this. I don't
- 34:23know many other people in the E M community that do this. And that's what
- 34:27I was trying to talk about was the podcast
- 34:31books and therapists that are E and M related. I don't know of any that
- 34:36are practicing and giving coaching advice for
- 34:41the lifestyle I practice. They, most of them are
- 34:45in the progressive monogamy terms to non monogamy terms to polyamory or they're
- 34:50in the progressive part. We, we love
- 34:54swinging, but it's a spice to our relationship. It is
- 34:57not. It won't get in the way of our relationship.
- 35:01Well, I'll come back to that too. I don't know that I would
- 35:05agree that most EM therapists view
- 35:10it as monogamy turns into non monogamy turns into polyamory
- 35:14or even advocate for that.
- 35:17But I do understand that some people perceive
- 35:21it as like this evolutionary, you know, line. I,
- 35:25we have preached against that. I think wherever you're at is where you're at and
- 35:28there's no better or worse. We've only had two therap, two couples therapists
- 35:32to help us through E and M stuff. And both of
- 35:36them were. They, they recommended books and
- 35:40things that were definitely on the continuum of I'm
- 35:43like, could you just give me one E and M book that doesn't have the
- 35:46word polyamory in it? And I, I don't want to sound
- 35:50like I'm anti poly or any of those things. I'm just saying my relationship is
- 35:55this way and I'd love it if it were represented in the.
- 35:58It's over represented in the mainstream therapy. I think we
- 36:02can agree on that. Yeah. I approach marriage is like you go talk to a
- 36:06church based marriage counselor,
- 36:10you're probably going to get something like mine. Other than when we say, well,
- 36:13we like other people, their head would pop off.
- 36:16He said our relationship with the NM partners are bounded for two reasons.
- 36:20Firstly, Kim and I aren't drawn to falling in love with or
- 36:24overly entangled with others. Neither of us is truly polyamorous
- 36:29by nature. This is more of a preference. Right. So this goes to what we
- 36:32were just talking about with polyamory. Secondly, we hold a firm boundary
- 36:36never to engage in anything that could disrupt or diminish
- 36:40our lifelong commitments. All right, now this is the part I have the
- 36:44biggest problem with. I think I would, I would. We, we maintain a boundary
- 36:48of never getting us into a position that would get us into a position to
- 36:52do that. I forgot it's important to say not just that we wouldn't do that.
- 36:55If we don't get into a position that would allow us to get into a
- 36:59position to do that. We'll go to the first part. First we said we're.
- 37:04We aren't drawn to falling in love with or overly entangled
- 37:09with others. Neither of us is truly polyamorous by nature. Sure. Then why
- 37:13the restriction? If it's not something you want anyway?
- 37:16Why would you put a restrict. Like in other words, Abel doesn't
- 37:20have to put a restriction on me not to eat licorice. Right. I don't want
- 37:24licorice. So. Right. We're not drawn to it,
- 37:27but we won't get anywhere close to getting close to it either.
- 37:31That was. I was saying the second one needed that modifier. The first one is
- 37:35we're not drawn. It's not something either of us are drawn to. Kim, I don't
- 37:38speak for her, but I'm less drawn to the idea of deep
- 37:43infatuation with somebody else or even mild infatuation with
- 37:47something else. I don't mind like the flirting and the spark and those sorts of
- 37:50things and I love the connection and
- 37:53the extra energy. But I'm not really drawn to
- 37:58having deep meaningful relationships with some.
- 38:02So you distinguish somewhere connection,
- 38:05energy and flirting so hard. It's so hard to get all,
- 38:09all the words around the word love. Because I love chocolate,
- 38:13I love my wife. There's. Yeah, it's too complicated. I agree. I,
- 38:16at least with the definitional thing is impossible to
- 38:21do. I mean, look, you go to 20 different dictionaries and look up the word
- 38:24love, you're going to get 20 different versions of the definition that
- 38:29spark flirtation and infatuation. We both love that. Right. But when we're.
- 38:34We're talking about the bonding energy that
- 38:38is persistent and can in persistent across years,
- 38:42that kind of bonding energy, we're not drawn to that with other people.
- 38:46Now there's couples that will date for as couples for
- 38:50extended period of time and we have genuine. We genuinely care for them as friends
- 38:54and sex is good, but it's not something that we're
- 38:58drawn to. I'm not drawn to her as somebody
- 39:02I want to bond with and get a mortgage with. Yeah, but those
- 39:06are two different things. Totally. I agree with the first one.
- 39:09I'm sorry. I agree with the second one, at least for our relationship.
- 39:12I'm not sure I even understand the first one.
- 39:16Okay. You say I'm not. It's not like you said, you've been date
- 39:19or have been open to or have dated people for an extended period of time.
- 39:23Sure. But. Yeah, right. You say not get bonded
- 39:26with. What do you mean specifically by that? That's super hard because
- 39:30it's into a spot where I could see a future with that person or
- 39:35see a. Not even. Not even see a person future with that person.
- 39:39Get into a spot where I could get close to seeing that.
- 39:43As soon as. If we get this far
- 39:48into a relationship with somebody else, we always have a. We try to have a
- 39:51conversation with all four of us where Kim and I need to be very
- 39:55clear with our expectation, our boundary there, which is if one
- 39:59of us ever catches feelings. Feelings for either one of you,
- 40:02we're going to call this off immediately. When you say catching feelings,
- 40:07what do you mean? Because I gave a speech about this once and I said
- 40:10I hate that phrase more than anything in non monogamy because I don't believe it's
- 40:13possible. I don't believe you can have sex without catching feelings of some sort.
- 40:17Now it may be the degree to which you're talking about catching feelings and
- 40:21that gets us into a gray area. This is back to that. I love chocolate,
- 40:25I love my wife. Right. It's. It's subjective and we know what it means.
- 40:29Right. We have a. So I can. I know what
- 40:33it feels like when it happens and I know what it. When it happens.
- 40:36How to say, hey, it's happening.
- 40:38I'm drawn to that person and there's something starting to go there.
- 40:42And I have that content commitment
- 40:46with Kim where I can tell her anything. And so we'll just kill the relationship
- 40:51at that point. Yeah, And I understand that. Like for instance, April and
- 40:54I have discussed, although we haven't really done it, the possibility of separate dating.
- 40:59And so I could imagine in a scenario like that she starts seeing a guy
- 41:03with some regularity. And. And I'm trying to get her to watch a movie
- 41:07with me at home one night and she's constantly texting. You know, I can imagine
- 41:11scenarios like that where it would be problematic. But I also can't imagine
- 41:15having sex with somebody that I. I can't
- 41:19even imagine having sex with somebody that I hadn't already caught feelings for. Depending on
- 41:23what you mean by catch feelings. Yeah. And that's where we're different feelings. If I
- 41:26didn't have feelings for the person I wouldn't have sex.
- 41:30Right. I'm sure I've had sex with somebody I didn't have feelings for.
- 41:33I'm not going to pretend that never happened. But we
- 41:38can have the whole take home for the team conversation at another point.
- 41:42But the feelings
- 41:46I'm talking about right now are that. That deep romantic thing,
- 41:50what you talked about there with the story with April is so love's unlimited.
- 41:54Right. So Polyperson will tell you, you know, why would you want to limit love?
- 41:57April can go love that other guy. He can love you. Love is
- 42:00an unlimited resource. I love both of my two kids the same amount. Right.
- 42:04It's not like just because I love my son, I don't also love my daughter
- 42:07an infinite amount. Right. Time and energy have
- 42:11finite resources. Yeah. When she's. So when April's
- 42:15texting that other guy and you're not getting the time and energy, that's where the
- 42:19conflict starts happening. And so we won't get into a spot
- 42:23where I am drawn to somebody where it could ever get to the spot where
- 42:27we take away time and energy that's around the loving
- 42:31nurturing of Kim. Well, I agree with that.
- 42:34But let's take that example, because this is a good one, I think. We'll see.
- 42:39Let's say April starts dating some guy. Let's say you and April. No, that was
- 42:42bad because you wouldn't do that. Yeah. Let's say she's dating some guy and we're
- 42:46trying. And I'm like, oh, I've been wanting to watch this movie. It's Wednesday night.
- 42:49We don't have anything going on on Thursday. Let's watch this movie. And we get
- 42:53in the middle of it, and 10 minutes into it, she's texting. Sure.
- 42:56The rock, right? Yeah. No, let's not do that, because I
- 43:00couldn't blame her for that one. Some guy, right? Yep.
- 43:05Here's. Here's where I struggle.
- 43:09I feel exactly the way you do about that, I think, for the most part.
- 43:13But I also feel like that's a shortcoming on my part that
- 43:18I pro. I hope to overcome one day, but I'm not sure I ever will
- 43:21be. I'm human. I have mistakes. But what I would not want
- 43:26to do is say, I love this woman unconditionally. I love her
- 43:29just the way she is. Yeah. I love everything about her. Her wants,
- 43:33her desires, her needs, her faults, her insecurity, all these things.
- 43:38But I want to change her this way. And that's. Don't text that guy while
- 43:42I'm watching a movie, right. So I struggle with that because I know that I
- 43:46would feel some sense of jealousy or whatever,
- 43:50not being her. Yeah. Look, I wanted this. I had this movie
- 43:54plan. I want to watch it with you. I would, I would get in my
- 43:56feels about that. Right. But I also feel
- 44:00like that if she stopped and
- 44:05actually wanted, would rather be texting during that moment while she's watching that movie with
- 44:09me, that if she stopped, I'm now in love with
- 44:14not quite the version of her who she truly is. Okay.
- 44:18Yes. So what are your thoughts about that? Yeah, there's a couple things to unpack
- 44:22there. So it's happened to Kim, right? We're. We. We sit down, we're going
- 44:26to watch a movie. I, I picked out the movie. I think this is going
- 44:30to be a nice evening where we're going to spend some time and energy together.
- 44:32And she gets on to one of the dating apps and starts chatting
- 44:36with somebody and I get jealous, right? And I get butthurt
- 44:40and sulky for a bit and then I tell her, stop, I don't like that.
- 44:44Supposed to watch a movie with me, I'm important, blah, blah, blah. Right.
- 44:48That was my jealousy that was happening there. It was
- 44:52also her failure to. I communicated
- 44:55up front that this was important to me and this was a time that I,
- 44:59I set aside for us to do something. So she was causing harm.
- 45:03So it was a jealousy thing. So can't,
- 45:07I can't negate the fact that I was being immature and jealous. I don't
- 45:11want to say jealousy is immature. Jealousy is a natural thing. Yeah, like being jealous.
- 45:15But that's my problem, not her problem. I shouldn't limit her behavior just as I'm
- 45:19being jealous. Right? The fact that she was causing harm, probably unintentionally
- 45:24because she forgot because I picked out a dumb movie that she doesn't like.
- 45:26She just lost track of what she, what she was doing. Right.
- 45:31That was a problem that she, she should own.
- 45:34Right. She. If I'd communicated up front,
- 45:37this is our time. This is something I want. It's important to me. And she
- 45:41chose to ignore that and cause harm. Don't do that.
- 45:45So our only sexual boundary with each other is be
- 45:49your full sexual self and don't cause harm. Be your full sexual
- 45:54self. I'm going to reword it a bit. Full sexual self.
- 45:57As long as it doesn't bother me. No, as long as it doesn't cause harm.
- 46:01Because if jealousy, jealousy bothers me, that's not her problem.
- 46:05That's my Problem. Right. In that scenario,
- 46:09there were two errors. My jealousy, which was my problem, not her problem.
- 46:13So I should just shut up about it and deal with it on my own.
- 46:14Or I should communicate it to her. But if I shouldn't interrupt her. The other
- 46:18problem was I communicated up front. This is our time. It's important to me.
- 46:21And she chose to ignore that and go do her own thing, causing harm.
- 46:25Okay, well, when you say harm. Yeah. So let's take
- 46:29the harm was the deprioritization. Jealousy is one thing, but she.
- 46:34She could do things that would cause other emotions as well. Yeah.
- 46:37So I will reword it and say, you're free to do whatever you want as
- 46:41long as it doesn't cause me discomfort. Nope, because discomfort's fine.
- 46:45Jealousy, insecurity, discomfort. Those are things that she
- 46:49can do. Those I prefer not to. And depending on the day,
- 46:53it may be harmful. But she
- 46:57should stop. She shouldn't intuit that it's harmful.
- 47:01Well, we need to have a conversation. So let's say a hall passes.
- 47:05Right. So there are days where hall passes are.
- 47:08Okay, that's in yalls relationship you're talking about. Yes, in our relationship.
- 47:12Yeah. There are days. What do you mean by all pass? Just curious. She can
- 47:16go have sex with. She can go have sex with somebody else. Okay. Right.
- 47:19So there are days where she has just like, go do.
- 47:23She's picked out some guy at Heedo. And I'm like,
- 47:27yeah, go for it. You got a hall pass. Just kind of go do whatever
- 47:31you want. Today I'm. I'm in. I'm in a good mental state today. We're in
- 47:34a healthy relationship spot. There's gonna be no harm done.
- 47:37Thanks for checking in. Have a blast.
- 47:40Right. There are other days where she's like, oh, did you see that guy
- 47:44at the pool? And I'm like, I got a headache. I don't wanna do anything
- 47:46tonight. She's like, well, what do you think about a hall pass? And I'd be
- 47:48like, we've been fighting for three days. We're in a bad spot
- 47:52in our relationship. You go do that right now. It's.
- 47:55It's gonna ins. It's gonna cause the jealousy or insecurity, and it's
- 47:59gonna cause some harm and stress. That's not warranted right now. If she
- 48:03chose to go do that anyway. Right. She would be being her full sexual
- 48:07self while causing harm.
- 48:11Well, I guess I struggle with the causing
- 48:18harm part. Are you saying that because her actions.
- 48:23Because of her actions, you got jealous, therefore she was causing
- 48:27Harm because of her actions. I got jealous either
- 48:32way. In an environment that gets caused harm or doesn't cause harm, Same scenario,
- 48:36Right? It's the environment. Is today a day that we are in
- 48:41a good relationship or in a bad relationship today?
- 48:44Right. So that's what caused the harm.
- 48:49I'm not sure I'm following. All right, so Sunday
- 48:54she was telling me about this guy that she really, really likes and
- 48:58got super excited about. See the smirk on her FL face and all
- 49:02that kind of stuff? And it was. Wait, is this a real scenario, by the
- 49:04way? It was a real scenario, yes. Sunday, she was excited. And I'm like,
- 49:08I'm like in, in that moment, if she'd said, hey,
- 49:12we're supposed to go to dinner with them, but something happened, I don't remember what
- 49:15it was. And if she said, hey, would you mind if I just
- 49:19call him in for a hall pass? You know, can I go have sex with
- 49:22him one on one or. He was married.
- 49:25He's married. And she, she has the opposite of. What's it called? When they're
- 49:29hot husbanding her. Yeah, yeah. Her partner's in
- 49:33the conversion around him going out. Okay. One on one play.
- 49:38I would have been 100%, babe, go have fun. Knock socks
- 49:41off. There's no arm. We're in a great phase in our relationship. No harm.
- 49:47Two, three weeks ago. Two weeks ago, her mom had passed.
- 49:51The week before, we'd been bickering with each other. We were supposed to
- 49:54be doing a kind of reconnect thing the day her
- 49:58mom passed. So we never even got to do our reconnect thing.
- 50:01She comes home from the funeral. We just dealt
- 50:05through the stress. We hadn't really done the reconnect thing. If she'd said on that
- 50:09day, hey, I want to go smash that guy, what do you think? Right.
- 50:14I, I would, that jealousy. I would add jealousy either way.
- 50:18Right. I, I, I get the jealousy insecurity thing. When she goes off and does
- 50:22her. Thing every time or almost everything every time.
- 50:25The, the story I use is, it's like getting locked in the basement in
- 50:29the dark. First time, it was terrifying. Each time after that, it's a little easier.
- 50:33And now it's like, okay, I've been in the basement before. It's fine.
- 50:37Right. That jealousy insecurity thing is.
- 50:40It's real. Yeah. So I would have had it either.
- 50:43Either way. Right. So my,
- 50:46my result in jealousy insecurity is going to happen.
- 50:49Right. Her behavior is going to happen in either one of these scenarios. But in
- 50:52one scenario, there Was harm caused in the other scenario? There was not harm caused.
- 50:55So if you're jealousy. So the jealousy isn't the harm?
- 50:59No. Then what was the harm? The harm is the
- 51:03stress in the relationship.
- 51:07The negative. So if I'm feeling jealous and she
- 51:10goes off and smashes a guy and we've been fighting all three of those things
- 51:15together is going to cause some more stress in our relationship. Going to harm the
- 51:18relationship. But the jealousy isn't the issue.
- 51:22I don't think you can get rid of jealousy. I think it's just going to
- 51:25naturally happen. Well, and the only reason I ask that is because you keep saying
- 51:28there's jealousy. Yeah, I was just trying. That's like the. That's like the lighter
- 51:32on, on the fire. Just the thing that happened.
- 51:36Okay, so you feel like in those
- 51:40situations, I'm assuming then that her actions would be unethical.
- 51:47Oh, she would not. In other words, if she wanted to do that, she would
- 51:50be being. This sounds. Yeah, she wouldn't. She wouldn't have my cons because
- 51:54our. Our boundary. Our. Our boundary that we've established
- 51:59and consented to is go be your full sexual self. Just don't cause
- 52:03harm. In that case, she'd be causing harm. So she'd be doing a boundary
- 52:07violation. And if she's doing a boundary violation intentionally, that would be unethical behavior.
- 52:11What if it was? What's that? What if it was accident? Not. What if it
- 52:15wasn't? Oh, it's accidental. It doesn't matter if it's just like, I thought you were
- 52:19in a good spot and I thought everything was all cool and I thought we
- 52:22were doing great and. What do you mean we're not doing great? When the situation
- 52:24just outlined. Yeah, I agree. If somebody does something
- 52:29intentionally to cause harm, I don't care what scenario you construct around it,
- 52:33I think that's unethical. Yeah, but you're saying if that scenario.
- 52:37She could do that, the scenario after the funeral and stuff?
- 52:41Yeah, as long as she didn't intend harm by it.
- 52:45Even if you got harmed by it, that's okay.
- 52:48It's not okay. I'd prefer not to do it, but it's not unethical.
- 52:52Right. They're still. I'm now hurt.
- 52:56Right. And then when she comes back from this date, and instead of the normal,
- 53:00hey, I just had a date and it was awesome, let me tell you about
- 53:03it. And we have great sex, she'd come back from the date and I'd be.
- 53:05What do you mean you. What do you mean? I'M all sad and blah,
- 53:08blah, blah. I can't imagine her doing this. She checks in,
- 53:11she's very, very cautious and safe because
- 53:15of that. Intentional don't do anything to up
- 53:19the long term relationship. Okay, well, let's get to that
- 53:23part then. The. Because. Here's the second part of
- 53:27what I had just read her, started to read a minute ago in that same
- 53:30email. Secondly, we hold a firm boundary never to engage in anything that
- 53:34could disrupt or diminish our lifelong commitment.
- 53:38Yeah, okay, I think in principle I agree
- 53:42with this, except this is where my autism potentially kicks in is I take the
- 53:46words at face value and I get very.
- 53:49I resist anytime. I see when you hear this in therapy a lot too,
- 53:52where it says, secondly, we hold a firm boundary never to
- 53:56engage in any thing that could disrupt or diminish
- 54:00our lifelong commitment. Now, yeah, that's the part I don't think is really possible.
- 54:04I don't think that that's possible. Even going to the grocery store. I mean,
- 54:09I think there's. I could envision a scenario where I'm willing to bet that
- 54:13she could go to the grocery store, calamity ensued, and you divorce her. Now,
- 54:17you may disagree with that, but I don't feel like we hold there's any such
- 54:21thing as certainty in relationship. We can feel close
- 54:24to certain. I think, I feel that I fully expect to die in
- 54:29a rocking chair on my porch with April. Okay. In fact, if I didn't,
- 54:33I would never have been able to feel
- 54:37at least moderately comfortable telling her, no more boundaries from
- 54:42me. And while I agree you shouldn't knowingly do things that are
- 54:46about to harm, harm your relationship, I don't believe that you can put boundaries in
- 54:50place that make that any sort of certainty. That may not be what you're saying.
- 54:54So I just want to get some clarity on that part of the email.
- 54:57Right. It's maintaining that mental posture of
- 55:01that, yes, there's always a scenario out there of.
- 55:06I can't come up with one off the top of my head, but there's always
- 55:09a scenario where something horrific happens or something,
- 55:14I don't know, magical happens and one of us decides,
- 55:18hey, this is dumb, we're done, or it's over.
- 55:21I don't entertain it, she doesn't entertain it.
- 55:26And we've had 30 years of practicing not allowing that to be something we
- 55:30entertain. So. Say that again. Sorry that I
- 55:34wasn't following. I thought I was following. And then you seem like you shifted gears
- 55:37at the end there. So we don't. We don't entertain that thought.
- 55:41What thought? The thought of what happens if she
- 55:45goes to the grocery store and runs into some really hot dude? Or what happens
- 55:49if I fall in love with the secretary at work or what?
- 55:53You know, all those different things that could happen. We don't
- 55:57entertain those thoughts, even when not the fantasy full
- 56:00ones. But the doubt that creeps in with.
- 56:05Okay, I'll share the story of the. The time I got closest to having genuine
- 56:10doubt. There was 10 years in our
- 56:14marriage where we had a severe libido mismatch.
- 56:17So she was doing menopause and brain fog and we
- 56:22had kids, and it just. There was a severe
- 56:26libido mismatch. I was also horny as all
- 56:30get out. I was probably in the best shape I've ever been in.
- 56:33And so the testosterone was through the roof. I could fuck
- 56:37anything, anytime I was horny. Right. And so 10 years
- 56:41of me constantly saying, I need sex got tiresome.
- 56:46It got frustratingly tiresome
- 56:50and painful to the point where I'm like, I can't
- 56:54imagine doing this for another. I don't know how long. We're 40 years.
- 56:58I can't imagine doing this for another 40 years. This is just painfully
- 57:02frustrating. Well, at some point, you won't be caring about sex anymore either,
- 57:07right? Yeah. When you're 95 or something. Hopefully.
- 57:11Hopefully there'll be, I don't know, pills when we're that old or, I don't know,
- 57:14something. Remind me at some point in time to tell you my longevity plan
- 57:18and why it's all focused around being able to fuck at 100. Okay.
- 57:24Just hoping I could carry on a competent sentence by the
- 57:27time I'm 100. I don't care if I can talk. I just want to fuck.
- 57:32All right, so it had been 10 years of decaying
- 57:37libido and increasing libido and just libido divergence. And I
- 57:42would say there's three things I need out of marriage. I need sex, I need
- 57:46you to talk to me, and I need you to see me. Right. And by
- 57:49talk to me, I mean share your most intimate thoughts. Not just who talked
- 57:54all the time, but. And by see me, I mean see the struggles I'm going
- 57:58through, see the changes that's happening in my life, those sorts of things.
- 58:02But number one was sex. I was in pain. It was that.
- 58:05That frustrating. So I, at that point, I had.
- 58:08I had doubt for the first time. I was like, I don't see how.
- 58:12It wasn't like, I don't see being married to her next year or anything like
- 58:15that. It was. I don't see how I last for another 40 years.
- 58:19It's been a 10 year divergence and it's gotten
- 58:23painful. And yeah, menopause sucks. The moment
- 58:28she found the hormone replacement and all that kind of stuff, it was like,
- 58:31oh, she's back. It was like between hot flashes, not sleeping,
- 58:35all the other nonsense that she's going through, it was, it was bad.
- 58:39Yeah. So I'm not saying you can't ever experience
- 58:43it, but the moment it happened, I told her right
- 58:48the moment. And it crushed her. She's like, what the are you talking about?
- 58:51It just. That was the most devastating conversation we ever had was the moment I
- 58:55said, no, I have doubt for the first time. And it took
- 58:59another five years to unring that bell. Right.
- 59:04Of going, okay, so once the libido came back and the
- 59:08last decade's been pretty awesome. But how you go through.
- 59:12No, we're in this for forever. Does that, does that answer
- 59:16your question? So I'm not blind in the sense that it can't happen.
- 59:19Doubt. I'm saying it's maintaining the posture of not allowing
- 59:23it to fester or get in. I mean, I don't know that I understand
- 59:26that completely. Here's the way I view doubt. I think doubt is
- 59:31not only inherently human and unavoidable, but I
- 59:35think it's also necessary. And this may be where we
- 59:39disagree a little bit. I don't think commitment
- 59:43means anything unless doubt is available. In the same way
- 59:47that I don't think courage means anything if you never face fear.
- 59:51Sure. You're a Tillich fan, huh?
- 59:55Theologian, philosopher, Tillich from Harvard. Yeah,
- 59:59well, I mean, but this is kind of the consensus in most philosophy is that
- 1:00:03suppressing doubt is going to lead to anxiety. Trying to control the
- 1:00:09uncontrollable is going to lead to anxiety. Doubt is just a
- 1:00:13natural part of life in the same way jealousy is. You can learn to doubt
- 1:00:17less, I believe, in the same way you, like you were talking about earlier,
- 1:00:20the first time, maybe she goes and has a hall pass riddled
- 1:00:24with jealousy. And then, you know, the 10th time, maybe you're just
- 1:00:28a little bit jealous. And maybe you can eventually get to the point where certain
- 1:00:31scenarios don't even cause jealousy in the same way that certain scenarios may not
- 1:00:36cause doubt anymore. But to completely remedy your relationship of
- 1:00:39doubt, I don't think is plausible. And worse. And worse,
- 1:00:44I think it's detrimental to the. Yeah, I don't. Well, if you
- 1:00:48can identify the doubt and find the thing that is causing the doubt. And then
- 1:00:51I, I do believe doubt is a natural byproduct of something.
- 1:00:54If you can find the thing that is causing the doubt and remedy that,
- 1:00:58it doesn't reoccur.
- 1:01:02Well, yeah, I guess in some sense I agree that you can eliminate
- 1:01:07some sources of doubt. I don't think you can eliminate all of them. I don't.
- 1:01:10I think to do. Be able to do that would require godlike. It's. It's.
- 1:01:14Again, it's not eliminating them, it's maintaining the posture to eliminate.
- 1:01:18It's. It's a. It's an unending. But I
- 1:01:22don't. I, I hear that, but I, I feel like that is. It's a.
- 1:01:26It's a gymnastics. It's a what? I feel like that's word
- 1:01:30gymnast. I feel like it's trying to say I don't have doubt without saying I
- 1:01:33don't have doubt.
- 1:01:37No, it's a mindfulness technique where you maintain
- 1:01:41a posture in your mind of when you. When you see a thought come
- 1:01:45through, you find the origin of the thought and then try
- 1:01:49and understand what the thoughts origin are and see if it is something worthwhile.
- 1:01:55I agree totally with that. So maintaining a posture in my mind
- 1:01:59of when I see a doubt. Right. Maintaining.
- 1:02:03Okay, what is the origin of that doubt? Why is it there? Is it a.
- 1:02:08Is it an irrational feeling or is it a logical thought? If it's
- 1:02:11a logical thought, what can I do to remedy the situation? If it
- 1:02:15is an irrational feeling, why am I having that irrational feeling right now?
- 1:02:19And can I identify it as an. Irrational feeling if
- 1:02:23there were some sense of a doubt and it was logical like you just said?
- 1:02:26Yep. Is your answer to. In order
- 1:02:30to remove those doubts is to impose a boundary on your spouse?
- 1:02:34That's maybe so. In the environment
- 1:02:38where it was logical, I was in pain because I.
- 1:02:42We had a libido mismatch and the doubt had started growing
- 1:02:46and I noticed it as a logical response to a
- 1:02:49painful environment. And I communicated to her this
- 1:02:54doubt and her response was, okay, we'll find we can have more sex. And that's
- 1:02:58not what I'm looking for. I'm looking for a connection as well.
- 1:03:03Is it a boundary? I guess, kind of, but it's more of
- 1:03:07a. I don't know. That's a hard question. Depends on each one. I doubt
- 1:03:12this is going to be. And I won't do it if you tell me it's
- 1:03:14not very helpful. But this is another one of those
- 1:03:18areas where in the emails I thought, I don't. I Don't see how he believes
- 1:03:22this. If I'm interpreting what he's writing is accurately is how he believes it.
- 1:03:26And I pulled up all of these quotes from philosophers about doubt
- 1:03:31is not only unavoidable, but it's actually necessary for
- 1:03:36faith and a commitment. Doubt that. Doubt that. Commitment in the
- 1:03:40face of no doubt is not really commitment. And I
- 1:03:44could read through a lot of these, but I'm not sure that even if I
- 1:03:47read through them, that would matter. So I'm just trying
- 1:03:52to really figure out what you mean by not having a posture towards doubt.
- 1:03:57In other words, I don't like having doubts. So in some sense, I guess I
- 1:04:01have a anti doubt posture. But I
- 1:04:05also strongly believe that doubts are unavoidable. Not in every case,
- 1:04:09but in general, as a flawed human,
- 1:04:13I can't help but sometimes have doubts. Sure I. I should.
- 1:04:17I think I already shared this with you. Yeah, I did.
- 1:04:21When I was training for the first Ironman and I
- 1:04:24got concerned about finishing it because of GI distress.
- 1:04:28Not because of endurance, but because I was afraid I was gonna shit my pants
- 1:04:31somewhere along the way and my insides are gonna explode because the goose I was
- 1:04:35taking, my coach yelled at me, don't ever let that cross your
- 1:04:39mind. Don't, don't allow. Maintain that posture of you
- 1:04:43can do this. It's not a.
- 1:04:47Did it cross my mind? Yeah, right.
- 1:04:50But it's the. As soon as it crosses my mind, as soon as I see
- 1:04:54that thought, taking the mindfulness and going, okay,
- 1:04:58that's just a thought. What is the cause of that doubt? Is it a
- 1:05:02rational, logical things that are causing it?
- 1:05:05Like I'm having GI distress and my guts are going to explode. Or is it
- 1:05:09just I'm having an emotional. I'm. My anxiety is high because I
- 1:05:13don't like doing this part of the course. Right.
- 1:05:17Getting rid of that doubt, maintaining the posture
- 1:05:20to look at the doubt and get rid of it. What would have.
- 1:05:24Would that. Would it have changed your outlook? Had on that race you had
- 1:05:29some. I don't know what GI distress looks like in its worst
- 1:05:33case, but if you'd had the worst imaginable case of it in the middle of
- 1:05:37that race, would your opinions about this matter have changed?
- 1:05:41So at mile 13 on the marathon,
- 1:05:44I had to shit like crazy. And I knew that we were going to run
- 1:05:47right past the swim exit and I knew there
- 1:05:51were a bunch of porta potties right at the swim exit. And as soon as
- 1:05:54we got there, I was all excited because I knew I could poop there.
- 1:05:58I get up to them, they're all zip tied. And I asked
- 1:06:02one of the sport people, what the. Why are these all zip tied? Well,
- 1:06:05they're all full. And so at that
- 1:06:09moment I had doubt. Right. I learned two things. One is
- 1:06:13when a porta potty is full, they're full. And the other one is I'm stronger
- 1:06:16than a zip top. Okay. Okay. So it wasn't a situation where that gi
- 1:06:20distress could have physically, regardless of willpower,
- 1:06:24prevented a person from finishing the race? No. Okay.
- 1:06:27No. I mean, I would have just shit on the side of the road.
- 1:06:31Yeah, but so I, I mean, I agree with that.
- 1:06:34I don't feel like that's what we're talking about. But again, that could just be
- 1:06:37because I'm misunderstanding what you mean by a posture of not allowing in doubt
- 1:06:42because are you saying that in that race, are you saying
- 1:06:45much or say that. Again, you do much mindfulness stuff,
- 1:06:49meditate much or anything like that? Not in the traditional sense. This is an
- 1:06:53embarrassing thing that I've told several people before, but my.
- 1:06:58Centering. Is to go sit in the bathtub for about three
- 1:07:02hours. Okay. Sounds crazy to people, but I actually do it in a way.
- 1:07:05I let the water. So once I get the water up where I want it,
- 1:07:08then I let it drip real slowly. And it's that constant sound of the dripping
- 1:07:12water, almost like sitting by a running river or something, zones me out.
- 1:07:16If I need to get, say, a project done right at limited
- 1:07:19time, I'll go into the bathtub because nothing focuses me more than
- 1:07:23that water. I call that meditation.
- 1:07:27I don't know if that, that's, that. That'S a good relaxation meditation.
- 1:07:31I'm talking about a, like a vipassana, where you were,
- 1:07:36you focused on your thoughts, you're. You're really focused on your breath.
- 1:07:39And that's only a distraction to try and get you
- 1:07:43not to see your thoughts, which causes you to actually see your thoughts. As soon
- 1:07:47as you're focused on something else, you can actually see these thoughts that are coming
- 1:07:49in. You develop the skills to go, I can see a thought as
- 1:07:53it is emerging. And so in that environment, when you see things like
- 1:07:57doubt, jealousy, insecurity, you can then explore them at
- 1:08:01a layer deeper and go, that's just not something I want to
- 1:08:05have in my life. And so when it emerges, you can see it
- 1:08:09and go, oh, I've dealt with this before,
- 1:08:13it's not helpful, or this is a new one. I haven't dealt with this version
- 1:08:17of doubt before. Right. You hit, hit cold over the side of the head
- 1:08:21with a new one. So go sit still for 15 minutes, meditate. Figure out what
- 1:08:24that doubt's caused by. But are you still saying that
- 1:08:28all doubt is unavoidable if handled
- 1:08:33in that way? No, no, no, no. I'm saying maintain a posture
- 1:08:37to identify it and understand it. And then as you identify it and
- 1:08:41understand it, it will have less power and go away.
- 1:08:44Eckhart Tolle talks about that sitting by the river and viewing
- 1:08:49your thoughts as the river going by. They don't mean anything unless you give them
- 1:08:52meaning. I. I guess my concern
- 1:08:56is that you know what happens when doubt
- 1:09:00does creep in. If you're saying that no doubt can creep in with me,
- 1:09:05I'm saying you don't. You maintain a posture that you don't allow it when
- 1:09:09it happens. You. You explore it and then get
- 1:09:13rid of it. Or you say don't allow it, but then it happens. You're not
- 1:09:17saying that, not allow. The posture of not allowing it doesn't prevent it from happening.
- 1:09:21No, there's a. So there's a. There's a
- 1:09:25point in time where the thought comes in and it hasn't been really well formed.
- 1:09:28Right? The thought of, I want to punch that guy in the face,
- 1:09:31right? He's. He's annoying me. Cutting line at the checkout, and I want
- 1:09:35to go punch him in the face. That's a thought that I probably shouldn't be
- 1:09:38having. And I probably should. I should probably explore and figure out why it happened.
- 1:09:42And I don't want to have that thought again. Right? I don't
- 1:09:46allow that type of thinking to happen in my mind. When it
- 1:09:50happens, it happens. Right? Okay. When you say don't allow it,
- 1:09:55you don't mean that you're perfectly accomplished at that.
- 1:09:58Correct? No. It's a posture. It's an intent of not
- 1:10:02allowing it. It's not a execution of.
- 1:10:05I'm not an enlightened individual who can keep all these errant
- 1:10:10thoughts from popping into my mind. Right. But as you. Do you not
- 1:10:14think that's what other people do, though, is where my confusion came
- 1:10:18in is I thought you were. The way it was written, you were saying,
- 1:10:21I don't. We don't have doubts. We don't do anything that could even possibly affect
- 1:10:25our relationship. And all of that I completely disagree with at face value.
- 1:10:28But then when you explain, explain the nuance, I'm like, I don't think
- 1:10:31that's what the word said. Yeah, that's what I was like. It'd be better to
- 1:10:34have this over with a conversation than over
- 1:10:38email. Because it really is the. It's the posture
- 1:10:43by which you're attacking doubt. Is this something that you're allowing to fester or is
- 1:10:47this something that is just an errand thought that's like pops through your mind.
- 1:10:50You're like, yeah, that's dumb. Yeah. Well, because you mentioned that
- 1:10:54cultures in like India and East Asia already adopt this sort of non divorce.
- 1:10:59Right. Divorce is not an option sort of thing. And while it's
- 1:11:03not technically illegal there. Right. But the culture does suppress it.
- 1:11:07Correct. Which was interesting to me. Of course, I've already knew
- 1:11:11that. You know, there's arranged marriages, there's cultures that don't accept divorce as
- 1:11:15readily as you do in America. So I started digging into the stat and
- 1:11:19it as everything I can find. It turns out that the relationship.
- 1:11:22Relationship satisfaction, that's what I'm looking for is lower in those countries than in America.
- 1:11:26America, Indian cult, Indian people that are married and they've been
- 1:11:30married and they'll be as married as long as we are and they seem to
- 1:11:33be happy. Well, yeah, so. And in particular it's suppressive to
- 1:11:37women in those countries, much more so than to men. Men don't
- 1:11:42face the social pressure or scrutiny or negative outlook
- 1:11:46is the women. Especially if the women is the one, the woman
- 1:11:49is the one that pursues. I was only sharing the India.
- 1:11:53I was trying to help you understand when you're saying this isn't possible.
- 1:11:57I was trying to help you understand there are environments where it is possible.
- 1:12:00I'm not talking about the. It is.
- 1:12:04The environment itself is conducive to gender equality or any
- 1:12:08of the other variables in it. I'm just trying. I was when I brought that
- 1:12:11up as an example of this type of behavior isn't something that only exists
- 1:12:16in Scott's world. It's no. Their entire culture.
- 1:12:20I wasn't saying it was impossible. I was saying my contention would
- 1:12:24be that it's impossible to be maximally happy.
- 1:12:27I'm pretty damn happy. No, no, I didn't. Well, you can be very
- 1:12:31happy. I think my grandparents were. Although I could make an argument that my grandparents
- 1:12:35were following wild love theory in a sense because I don't think either
- 1:12:39of them ever wanted to do anything that they didn't do. Right.
- 1:12:43Society and culture that they grew up in limited what
- 1:12:48they felt like was an awkward options. Like in other words, I don't
- 1:12:52know. My grandmother may have wanted to travel to Italy by herself, but felt like
- 1:12:56that was crazy to think that and never really Worried about it enough
- 1:13:00for it to be an issue. Were there things like that that they suppressed?
- 1:13:03I don't know. I can't, you know, I can't know that in hindsight. I guess
- 1:13:07my point here is that the whole focus of
- 1:13:11wildlife theory is to show that maximal happiness, not happiness, but maximal happiness
- 1:13:16requires maximal freedom. And nothing in the stats
- 1:13:20that I've been able to find about India or East Asia show that they're happier
- 1:13:24than America. Yeah, I probably shouldn't have brought that up because it seems to be
- 1:13:27distracted by. I was just using it as an example. It seemed to be a
- 1:13:31distracting point. Well, and I know that. I know that you
- 1:13:35have. You've got a five o' clock appointment and we're. Right. Yeah, five o'.
- 1:13:38Clock. Is there any last things you wanted to say? Any things that I've misunderstood
- 1:13:43or. I think we've talked a little bit about love
- 1:13:47theory. We've talked a little bit about my philosophy on long term committed relationships.
- 1:13:51What I was hoping at the very beginning when
- 1:13:55I brought it up around Wild Love Theory and then when I was brought up
- 1:13:58around your podcast, is a point that I don't think we've touched on yet.
- 1:14:01I wish there were more voices in the podcast books and therapy that focused on
- 1:14:05relationship structures that are in very committed relationships where they
- 1:14:09are not looking to enhance
- 1:14:14freedom, they're really looking to enhance their relationship
- 1:14:21secondary. You consider those separate
- 1:14:26things? Not at all. No. I think Kim and I are pretty free, pretty,
- 1:14:30pretty open. Whatever each other wants to do is pretty cool,
- 1:14:34as long as it doesn't cause harm. I just don't hear
- 1:14:38many podcast books or therapists talk about the struggles of maintaining the
- 1:14:42relationship they talk a lot about.
- 1:14:46So somebody just gave me the recommendation to listen to the
- 1:14:51monogamish marriage and I'm on podcast number three. Seems like a
- 1:14:55really smart couple, but so far it's
- 1:14:59not about how to maintain a relationship. It's about what it
- 1:15:03means to be bisexual or what it means to be hot wifing or
- 1:15:06all these other things that are how to push the bounds,
- 1:15:11not how do we deal with our relationship. How do we manage our relationship
- 1:15:15health while doing these things? Now, I'm hopeful that it
- 1:15:21may be in some of the future episodes because this person who recommended it,
- 1:15:23pretty knowledgeable. So if you recommended this one, he said this one will scratch it.
- 1:15:27You're looking for it. Found you a podcast that actually does this.
- 1:15:30Yeah, they're good friends of ours and they are both incredibly intelligent people.
- 1:15:34All right. But even, even this one, which was the one that was supposed to
- 1:15:38be the example of this is about how to have a committed,
- 1:15:41long term, lifetime commitment relationship.
- 1:15:45I'm on episode three and I. That's not been the topic so far. Is it
- 1:15:49possible that of course we have different vantage
- 1:15:54points that we approach this stuff from? But I don't listen to
- 1:15:58podcasts waiting for them to say that. I assume they already mean that.
- 1:16:01I assume that the majority of people that get into a marriage or a committed
- 1:16:06relationship mean to do it for the rest of their lives.
- 1:16:09I don't think though that they take the stance that no matter
- 1:16:14what, which was the wording that you used.
- 1:16:17So I'm not advocating that everybody takes that stance any more than I
- 1:16:21advocate for everybody to be poly or everybody be whatever. It's just
- 1:16:26that's the relationship structure we've chosen. I wish it were something that were
- 1:16:29represented in the E M community. I don't see it represented much
- 1:16:33as much in the in EM community as the more
- 1:16:38em typical relationship, which is let's grow until
- 1:16:41it doesn't fit. See, I don't think anybody says that, not really.
- 1:16:45But maybe again, I'm misunderstanding. I. I heard it. Maybe I misunderstood
- 1:16:50it on your guys's podcast in the last, last episode, which was
- 1:16:55April said it, which was. I mean that. Yeah, it was the,
- 1:16:58the advocacy for divorce. And at some point you grow apart.
- 1:17:02And at some point, I mean there's relationship. I think that was you saying it.
- 1:17:06Yeah, but that's not a wealthy person. You grow apart.
- 1:17:09That's not something we think is inherent to every relationship. But we do think because
- 1:17:14of where we've grown up, we've seen these relationships.
- 1:17:17Hell, my mom and dad had one. They stayed together longer than I think they
- 1:17:22should have. It was obvious that that relationship was dead. Now that
- 1:17:26is not the same as saying I think it was impossible to fix it.
- 1:17:29But what I don't think is something I would advocate
- 1:17:33for is try to fix it regardless.
- 1:17:37Okay, I'm of the advocate. Try to.
- 1:17:40Unless there's abuse or something toxic in it. If it's
- 1:17:44just like, oh, if we've been had a Libido mismatch
- 1:17:48for 10 years, I'd say try and fix it regardless. Well, yeah,
- 1:17:52I don't agree with the regardless thing, but because
- 1:17:56the fact that it worked in your case, I realize informs
- 1:18:02your perspective. There's no way around that. But for every case where
- 1:18:06you stuck it out and it worked out, I'm willing to bet there's
- 1:18:1010 cases where that didn't happen. I don't
- 1:18:14have I got a sample. Of n equals 1. All I'm saying. Me too.
- 1:18:17It's the relationship structure that has worked for me and I wish
- 1:18:21it were more represented in the E Mistake podcast blogs,
- 1:18:25books. The we hear a lot of.
- 1:18:29I mean, how many hot Wife episodes? Everybody. Every podcaster's got a hot wife episode,
- 1:18:34Every podcaster's got an ED episode, everybody. How many of them have a non violent
- 1:18:38communication episode or a attachment styles
- 1:18:43in a. Let's work on our marriage episode and let's
- 1:18:47work on making this thing work while we're also other people.
- 1:18:50Monogamous marriage definitely has all the attachment theory.
- 1:18:54Yeah. I can only get to episode three. So yeah,
- 1:18:59shout out to them. They. They do a pretty thorough job in one of their
- 1:19:02episodes talking about those things. I think that my perception is,
- 1:19:05is that most podcasters,
- 1:19:09first of all, I agree with you to some extent. I think. And maybe we
- 1:19:13should do a better episode even though we feel woefully unqualified to do it.
- 1:19:16How do you maintain a solid relationship while
- 1:19:21you're doing this non monogamy stuff? Although we sort of
- 1:19:25assume it, that's not probably a safe position. I assume that you
- 1:19:30can't be successful in non monogamy unless you have a solid relationship.
- 1:19:35And I think at least the experience I've had that bears that out pretty
- 1:19:39well. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't say we
- 1:19:43shouldn't talk about that subject. So I do appreciate that. Yeah,
- 1:19:47that was my, my note that I wanted to include in either Wild Love Theory
- 1:19:51or in the podcast was just the how do we be
- 1:19:55more inclusive around this other relationship style? While also how do
- 1:19:59we encourage the podcasters, therapists,
- 1:20:02books, whatever, to talk about relationships
- 1:20:06being the primary thing and then all these spicy things we can do with them
- 1:20:09as secondary things that. Well, yeah, now I.
- 1:20:13I feel like we do that to some extent because for us,
- 1:20:17sex has never been the primary driver of this. We are not in
- 1:20:21it for. We're not
- 1:20:26demeaning this, but we say it all the time. We're not in it for sport
- 1:20:28or transactional sex. And we're very,
- 1:20:32very selective. Not because we think we're better than anybody
- 1:20:36else, but because that's just what works for us. And, you know, we might
- 1:20:40have sex with two people in a year. I gotta
- 1:20:44talk about the other. I gotta talk about the benefits of the other end of
- 1:20:46that spectrum too. Well, we started that way. Yeah.
- 1:20:50Like, I know we had one trip in Antigua where I don't know how many
- 1:20:55different experiences we had that week. But it's
- 1:20:59never felt as good to us as the more deeply connected
- 1:21:03experience has. It's like, it's like steak, even a
- 1:21:07bad. Pretty good. But for us, when it's cooked well
- 1:21:11and marinated, over time, it seems to turn out better for us.
- 1:21:14But that's a taste difference. I'm not, I'm not saying one of those versions
- 1:21:18is better than the other, but we don't focus on our podcast
- 1:21:23on the sexual aspect of non monogamy. And that's one of the things.
- 1:21:26I've loved your guys's podcast. So since I think it's one of the most better
- 1:21:30research, you guys obviously come to it prepared to have the conversation. And it is
- 1:21:34a meaningful conversation around good topics.
- 1:21:39Yeah. So don't, don't take this as a. A damnation of everything.
- 1:21:43And it sounds like I gotta go, so. Well, listen, I appreciate the conversation.
- 1:21:48It's been really. It's really good for me to have this conversation with people that
- 1:21:52think this stuff through carefully because it makes me work harder to make
- 1:21:56sure I'm not selling bad information, you know? Well, I appreciate
- 1:22:00you putting it out there. It takes vulnerability and trust to even just throw it
- 1:22:03all out there, so. And I'm going to assume that you got to get off
- 1:22:05at least partially because you'll probably have another date tonight. No date. Noel? No,
- 1:22:09he's a friend who's a carpenter. He's helping us put two deadman walls up while
- 1:22:12we take the load bearing wall out of the kitchen. What about tomorrow night?
- 1:22:17Yeah, we have three this weekend.
- 1:22:23All right, well, listen, tell Kim.
- 1:22:27Tell. Kim I said dinner. All right.
- 1:22:32I appreciate it, Scott. Enjoyed it.