Latest / Deep Dive / Invisible Baggage: How Caste and Class Travel Across Borders
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this deep dive. For those of you joining us, our
- 0:03mission today is to explore the the really complex, often
- 0:08entirely hidden social hierarchies that literally
- 0:10travel across the world when people migrate.
- 0:13Right. And you know, specifically we
- 0:15are analyzing the South Asian diaspora in Australia today.
- 0:18Exactly. And to do this, we're drawing
- 0:20heavily from the academic work of Amit Sarwal, who he has this
- 0:25brilliantly synthesized research using short stories and
- 0:28sociological data. Yeah, it's a really fascinating
- 0:31mix of literature and hard data. He really is, and he uses it to
- 0:35map out how class, cast, and race all intersect in a new
- 0:39homeland. Because, you know, as someone
- 0:41who loves gaining knowledge and looking at multiple
- 0:44perspectives, you might assume that moving to an entirely new
- 0:46country gives you a blank slate. Right, like starting fresh.
- 0:49Right. Yeah, We often think of
- 0:51migrating as like the ultimate software update for your life.
- 0:54Yeah, you pack your bags, you cross an ocean, delete the old
- 0:56operating system, and assume you're getting a complete system
- 0:58reboot. Yeah, that's the dream, right?
- 1:01The geography changes, so the assumption is that the social
- 1:04reality simply must change with it.
- 1:06A new physical environment supposedly demands a new social
- 1:09environment. But today we're looking at the
- 1:12legacy code that secretly keeps running in the background
- 1:16because human nature is sticky. Oh, very sticky, yeah.
- 1:20It turns out we often unpack our absolute heaviest historical
- 1:24baggage. You know our oldest social
- 1:26hierarchies the exact moment we land in a new environment.
- 1:30And that legacy code of cast and class?
- 1:32It just keeps running. It shapes communities in ways
- 1:35the outside world rarely even sees.
- 1:37Totally. To really understand how those
- 1:39hidden realities operate in the diaspora, we have to start by
- 1:42looking at the shiny facade they project back home.
- 1:45The highlight reel exactly. And the external hostility that
- 1:48actually forces them to maintain that facade in the first place.
- 1:51Because back in the Indian subcontinent, the non resident
- 1:54Indian or the NRI is this deeply mythologized figure.
- 1:58Oh massive. I mean, popular culture,
- 2:00especially Bollywood films, has spent decades basically
- 2:04imagining the diaspora is exclusively super rich, highly
- 2:08westernized and just making the homeland proud on the global
- 2:12stage. Right, the ultimate success
- 2:13story. Yeah, and the source material
- 2:15actually quotes the legendary Bollywood director Yash Chopra
- 2:19on this. He spoke at the very first
- 2:21Patriot Indians Day back in 2003 and he openly stated that as a
- 2:26director, he felt a moral responsibility to depict India
- 2:30and its diaspora and its absolute best.
- 2:32Wow, moral responsibility. Yeah, he viewed cinema as a
- 2:36vehicle to project this flawless, triumphant image of
- 2:39the migrant back to the people who stayed behind.
- 2:42But I mean, you can imagine that creates A staggering burden of
- 2:45expectation for the actual migrants.
- 2:46Well, for sure. Sociologist Ghassan Haige offers
- 2:49a really crucial insight into the mechanics of this.
- 2:51He points out that the absolute last thing a migrant wants to
- 2:54share with their family back home is the reality of the
- 2:57racism. Yeah, the daily discrimination.
- 2:58Right. Or the systemic prejudice they
- 3:00face in their new country. Because the psychological
- 3:03mechanism there is pretty clear. They told the truth.
- 3:06Their families would just look at them and ask why did you
- 3:08uproot your entire life and move to the end of the world just to
- 3:12be demeaned and insulted? Exactly.
- 3:14The entire migratory enterprise has to legitimize itself
- 3:18somehow. The sacrifice of leaving home
- 3:20has to be worth something. So they hide it.
- 3:23Right. So in letters home, in phone
- 3:25calls, and in the literature produced by the community, the
- 3:29experience is just relentlessly portrayed as a triumph.
- 3:32OK, let's unpack this for a second.
- 3:34It operates exactly like a carefully curated social media
- 3:37feed. Migrants are only posting the
- 3:40highlight reel of their success to justify their massive life
- 3:43choice. Right, exactly.
- 3:44They are intentionally burying the bloopers, you know, the
- 3:47daily marginalization they face and the reality of that
- 3:51prejudice in Australia, particularly looking at the
- 3:53data, it's not subtle at. All.
- 3:55No, it's really not. The sources detail a period
- 3:57between 2007 and 2009 where there was a highly publicized
- 4:01string of violent, opportunistic attacks on Indian students.
- 4:05Yeah, the media often referred to it using the really
- 4:07derogatory term Curry bashing. Which is just awful.
- 4:11And beyond the physical violence, there was a much
- 4:14broader cultural stereotyping at play.
- 4:18The phrase dumb, drunken, racist actually gained a lot of
- 4:21traction in Indian media to describe Australia during this
- 4:25time. It became a huge label.
- 4:27It did. It became such a prominent label
- 4:30that Australian television later produced a documentary series
- 4:33with that exact title. They literally took Indian
- 4:36contestants around the country to see if Australia actually
- 4:40lived up to that terrible reputation.
- 4:42What we're looking at here is a fundamental clash over national
- 4:45space. Kasan Haig developed this
- 4:47concept of what he calls Spatial manager.
- 4:49Special Manager. Yeah, these are members of the
- 4:52dominant culture, in this specific context, Anglo
- 4:54Australians who feel naturally empowered to dictate who
- 4:57actually belongs in the national.
- 4:58Space like they own the room. Precisely, they feel it is their
- 5:02right to manage where minority should be placed, what jobs they
- 5:05are allowed to hold and ultimately who should be sent
- 5:07back to where they came from. Wow.
- 5:09And the mechanism of that spatial management, it isn't
- 5:12just violent attacks, right? It's the everyday
- 5:14microaggressions. Well, absolutely.
- 5:16It's the daily friction. It's the colleague asking where
- 5:19you are really from, or the landlord hesitating on an
- 5:22application. It's that constant grinding
- 5:25reminder from the dominant culture that you are merely a
- 5:29guest in their geography. And if we connect this to the
- 5:32bigger picture, when you are constantly being managed and
- 5:35questioned by spatial managers, it strips away your
- 5:38psychological security. It has to.
- 5:40It creates A profound existential vulnerability when
- 5:44the broader society aggressively excludes you or tells you that
- 5:48you are a second class citizen. The natural human response is
- 5:51not to keep fighting that brick wall, right?
- 5:54The response is to retreat and turn inward.
- 5:57You seek safety in the familiar. Which makes sense.
- 5:59Yeah, and for the South Asian diaspora, the most familiar
- 6:02structural safety Nets available are the traditional systems of
- 6:05class and caste. Which brings us perfectly to the
- 6:07concepts of blood and bread, because our sources cite
- 6:11Marianne Tolbert, who uses these two metaphors to describe this
- 6:15internal social architecture. O blood represents familial
- 6:19links, ancestry, and cast. And bread represents economic
- 6:23status. Right source of income and
- 6:25class. In the diaspora, these two
- 6:28concepts interlock to form a rigid hierarchy, but they
- 6:31actually operate through different mechanisms.
- 6:33How so? Well, class, your bread is
- 6:35mobile. It's tied to your education,
- 6:37your standard of living, your profession.
- 6:39You can, theoretically at least, earn more bread.
- 6:41OK, right. But cast your blood is based
- 6:43entirely on hereditary transmission.
- 6:46It's tied to ancient, deeply in green notions of purity and
- 6:49pollution. You are born into it and you
- 6:51cannot change it. Amartya Sen, the Nobel laureate,
- 6:55points out a really fascinating dynamic here regarding dual
- 6:58belonging. He notes that immigrants feel
- 7:01absolutely no contradiction in being fiercely loyal,
- 7:04politically integrated citizens of their new country.
- 7:06Cheering for the Australian cricket team.
- 7:08Exactly. Paying taxes, participating in
- 7:11democracy while simultaneously holding on with an iron grip to
- 7:15their old cultural and class identities.
- 7:18They seamlessly run the new software in public, but the
- 7:21legacy code completely dictates their private.
- 7:23Lives. It's a dual existence.
- 7:25But I have to push back on the logic of this though.
- 7:28If you are migrating to a society like Australia, which
- 7:31actively prides itself on egalitarianism and the whole
- 7:35fair go ethos, wouldn't you want to escape the rigid, oppressive
- 7:40class systems of the country you just left?
- 7:43You would think so, yeah. You literally just flew out of
- 7:45the cage. Why would you voluntarily
- 7:47rebuild the exact same cage the moment you land?
- 7:50It's a great question. Sociologist SL Sharma addresses
- 7:53that exact friction. He argues that rebuilding the
- 7:56cage is actually a compensatory defense mechanism.
- 7:59A defense mechanism, yeah. Think about it, when you are in
- 8:02an alien setting, facing racism, in a sudden loss of your broader
- 8:05social standing, you have to find a way to stabilize yourself
- 8:08worth. Right, because the outside world
- 8:10is telling you you're less than. Exactly when the white majority
- 8:13strips away your external status, being the big fish in
- 8:17your own smaller pond becomes a crucial survival tool.
- 8:21You re establish the hierarchy because in that specific
- 8:24hierarchy you get to be at the top.
- 8:26Oh wow. It's about regaining a sense of
- 8:28control over your environment. Precisely.
- 8:30There's a literary example of this in the sources from writer
- 8:33Vijay Mishra. In his story Dil Kusha, he
- 8:36describes an evening party in Sydney attended primarily by
- 8:39Indian migrants, and the entire scene is just dripping with
- 8:43conspicuous consumption. Oh yeah, the guests arrive in
- 8:46designer wear, and the dialogue is this highly calculated
- 8:50competitive display of status. Totally.
- 8:52They talk about their wealth, their cars, their houses.
- 8:54And they place a massive emphasis on their children's
- 8:57educational achievements. Yes, there's a specific line
- 9:00from the story that captures this perfectly.
- 9:02It says to be a doctor is a blessing, but to be a dentist
- 9:05divine. It's so hyper competitive.
- 9:07It is. It's so specific it honestly
- 9:10makes me think of a high school clique that graduates and moves
- 9:14to a completely new city together, but they fiercely
- 9:17enforce the exact same cafeteria seating chart.
- 9:21That's a great way to put it, right?
- 9:22They change the geography of their lives, but they absolutely
- 9:25refuse to change the geometry of their relationships.
- 9:28Because that geometry is vital to their psychological survival.
- 9:32That conspicuous consumption isn't just about warding off the
- 9:35loneliness of being an immigrant.
- 9:36It's deeper than that. It is an active, aggressive
- 9:39maintenance of their bread. They are signaling to each
- 9:42other. The outside world might treat us
- 9:44as less than, but within these walls, I outrank you.
- 9:47Wow, but that cafeteria seating chart has incredibly dark
- 9:52consequences behind closed doors.
- 9:54Very dark to see exactly how this rebuilt cage of blood and
- 9:57bread functions when no one else is looking.
- 10:00Amit Sarwall's research takes us into the visceral lived
- 10:03experiences captured in South Asian Australian fiction.
- 10:07This is where the micro politics of exploitation really come into
- 10:10focus. Yeah, so Jada Fernandez's short
- 10:12story A Pocket Full of Stories provides A harrowing look at
- 10:16this. The narrative centers on a young
- 10:18servant girl named Nandini. And the text purposefully
- 10:22describes her as small, skinny, black and from Mangalore, right?
- 10:26Yes, markers that immediately identify her as lower caste and
- 10:29lower class to the other characters.
- 10:32She is working in Sydney for an affluent, highly westernized
- 10:35Indian, specifically Goin family.
- 10:38And you look at this family on the surface, and they seem
- 10:41entirely modern. They're living the cosmopolitan
- 10:44Western dream. But inside their home, they're
- 10:47ruthlessly enforcing the traditional sociocultural
- 10:50prejudices of the subcontinent. It's incredibly oppressive.
- 10:54Mandini is sexually and domestically exploited by her
- 10:57employer. She is repeatedly raped, she
- 10:59becomes pregnant and the the family's response is to blame
- 11:02her for causing trouble and literally force her to leave
- 11:05Sydney. And the psychological dimension
- 11:06of Fernandez's story is what makes it so disturbing, because
- 11:09the reader naturally asks why Nandini doesn't go to the
- 11:12Australian authorities or fight back.
- 11:13Right. Why not just leave?
- 11:15The story illustrates that her silence is the result of deep
- 11:18rooted cast consciousness. She has been conditioned her
- 11:21entire life to be entirely submissive to the upper class,
- 11:24the people providing her bread. The sources actually quote Anon
- 11:28Garrett Haradas on this exact dynamic.
- 11:31He notes that in the subcontinent, servants are
- 11:34taught to see themselves not merely as situationally
- 11:36inferior, as in, you know, I just have less money right now,
- 11:40but as eternally, intrinsically inferior by blood.
- 11:44That psychological conditioning doesn't get flagged at customs,
- 11:47it flies right on the plane to Sydney with them and continues
- 11:50to dictate their reality. Which creates a massive paradox.
- 11:54The behavioral split in the oppressors here is wild.
- 11:57It really is. Because the very same affluent
- 11:59diaspora members who might publicly organize, protest and
- 12:02complain about being marginalized by white
- 12:05Australians about hitting a glass ceiling or facing systemic
- 12:08prejudice. They're doing that on the one
- 12:10hand. Exactly, but they are
- 12:11simultaneously acting as absolute tyrants to those lower
- 12:15than them on their internal social ladder.
- 12:17They are the oppressors on the street for the oppressor in the
- 12:19kitchen. That is the tragic irony.
- 12:22And that dynamic bleeds out of the kitchen and into broader
- 12:25social circles, too. Yeah, the the sources bring up
- 12:28Chitra Fernando's story The Chasm, which explores this
- 12:31within the Sri Lankan diaspora. We were introduced to two vastly
- 12:35different subjects. Right mantle and the tempos.
- 12:37Yeah, Mantle is a Sinhala woman who has only been in Australia
- 12:41for eight months and the tampos are this affluent, highly
- 12:45established Tamil doctor family. And it's worth noting Mantle is
- 12:48a trained nurse. Exactly.
- 12:50She's an educated professional in her own right, but the Tampos
- 12:55and their elite social circle treat her exactly like a
- 12:57servant. The text notes that the elite
- 13:00wife Nellen hates cooking and cleaning, and Mantle's arrival
- 13:04essentially saves her from having to do it.
- 13:06Mantle is literally described by this elite community as a common
- 13:10or garden weed that risks crushing the Lily of their high
- 13:13society. And the mechanism of their
- 13:15oppression is just a constant stream of microaggressions.
- 13:18They mock Mantle's accent relentlessly.
- 13:20Because English isn't her first language, so she mixes up her FS
- 13:23and F. Right.
- 13:24They view her convent school for an educated background as vastly
- 13:29inferior to their own cosmopolitan Polish.
- 13:32They are using language and refinement as a weapon to gate
- 13:35keep their bread. There was a devastating scene in
- 13:37the story. At a picnic, the community
- 13:39invites Mantle, but they don't invite her as an equal.
- 13:43They essentially put her on display as a comic spectacle.
- 13:46It's so cruel. It is.
- 13:48The wealthy guests give each other suppressed smiles and
- 13:50meaningful looks every time she speaks.
- 13:52They isolate her entirely and the ultimate exclusion happens
- 13:56when she isn't even allowed to eat the food with them.
- 13:58They force her into such a humiliating position that she
- 14:00just has to politely walk out, saying I think I'll leave your
- 14:04picnic now. The sociological mechanism at
- 14:06play at that picnic is a strategy of negation.
- 14:09By mocking Mantle and pushing her to the margins, the
- 14:12privileged class is maintaining A strict boundary.
- 14:15They are sending a really clear message.
- 14:17Just because we are all Sri Lankan migrants in Australia
- 14:19facing the same white spatial managers does not mean we are
- 14:23equals. Right.
- 14:24It is a fierce protection of their precarious status.
- 14:27They have to push someone else down to feel elevated.
- 14:29That precarious status is the key to all of this, because this
- 14:33rigid clinging to class, this desperate enforcement of the
- 14:36seating chart, it doesn't just happen because these people are
- 14:39inherently cruel. No, there's a reason.
- 14:41It happens because these migrants are often watching
- 14:44their own status completely evaporate in the professional
- 14:47world. The bread they thought they had
- 14:49secured is suddenly stripped away by systemic hurdles in the
- 14:52new country. Which brings us to the
- 14:54phenomenon of professional deskilling.
- 14:56It's a massive source of trauma for highly educated migrants.
- 15:00The research highlights a story by Sunil Govanage called
- 15:03Arrival. Yeah, the protagonist Jayadeva,
- 15:06right? He has just moved his family
- 15:08from war-torn Sri Lanka to Australia.
- 15:12Initially he is elated. He sees no soldiers at the
- 15:15airport. He believes he has arrived in a
- 15:17lucky, peaceful, meritocratic country.
- 15:19Then he gets into a taxi. Yeah.
- 15:22The driver is a migrant from Lebanon, but as they talk, Jai
- 15:25Dava learns that back in Lebanon, this driver was an ENT
- 15:28surgeon. An ear, nose and throat
- 15:30specialist. Reduced to driving a cab?
- 15:33Wait, really? An ENT surgeon driving a cab?
- 15:35Yeah. The driver explains the brutal
- 15:38systemic reality of the Australian Medical Council exam.
- 15:42He doesn't just describe it as a test of medical knowledge, he
- 15:45describes it as a hurdle built specifically to gatekeep Asians
- 15:49and non westerners. The story presents the idea that
- 15:52if you come from a predominantly white Western country, the
- 15:56professional doors are open, but for an educated Asian migrant,
- 16:00the exam functions as a closed door designed to protect local
- 16:03jobs and maintain a specific cultural dominance in the upper
- 16:07economic tiers. The driver bitterly calls
- 16:09Australia the clever country, doesn't he?
- 16:11Yeah, because it eagerly takes in highly educated professionals
- 16:14to boost its immigration metrics, but then deliberately
- 16:17treats them like primitives but refusing to recognize their
- 16:20credentials. You can feel the sheer rage and
- 16:22frustration in that cab ride. Oh.
- 16:24Absolutely. You uproot your life for a
- 16:26better future. You bring all this education,
- 16:28the tartar and bread, and the host country just structurally
- 16:30refuses to recognize. It it lowers your occupational
- 16:33status. And because class and cast are
- 16:36so intertwined, lowering your occupational status in Australia
- 16:40simultaneously destroys your social status back home.
- 16:43You are no longer the triumphant NRI, you are a surgeon driving a
- 16:48taxi. That devastating loss of status
- 16:50forces a profound reckoning, particularly for the next
- 16:53generation. Yeah, the central dilemma
- 16:55becomes how do you survive when the host country rejects your
- 16:58professional worth, while your own community remains
- 17:01obsessively divided by caste and class?
- 17:04You are literally trapped between two different systems of
- 17:06oppression. Here's where it gets really
- 17:08interesting, though. Christopher Cyril's
- 17:10autobiographical short story The Ganges and Its Tributaries
- 17:14offers a really radical vision for how the diaspora might
- 17:17navigate this. Tell me about it.
- 17:19The narrator is a second generation immigrant reflecting
- 17:22on his Anglo Indian father, and this father has been absolutely
- 17:26battered by the system. He migrated for economic
- 17:29betterment but realized his middle class ambitions were
- 17:32constantly thwarted. Because the systemic racism.
- 17:35Exactly. He experienced systemic racism
- 17:37in Australia, just as he had experienced rigid classism back
- 17:41in India. He is exhausted by the legacy
- 17:43code. So what's his solution?
- 17:45Total integration. He looks at his grandchildren
- 17:48and says the world is getting smaller.
- 17:51One race. Soon there will be only one
- 17:53race. He actively desires for his
- 17:56grandchildren to mix their genes.
- 17:58Oh wow. He uses this wonderful evocative
- 18:01culinary metaphor. He wants them to eat nons with
- 18:04spaghetti. Nons with spaghetti I love.
- 18:06That yeah, he wants the boundaries to dissolve entirely.
- 18:09But I mean, looking at the sociology we've just discussed,
- 18:12doesn't this father's dream represent the exact nightmare?
- 18:16The diaspora is terrified. Of this raises an important
- 18:18question, yes. Doesn't the Nyans with spaghetti
- 18:21approach risk completely erasing the very cultural heritage, the
- 18:25blood that the community initially used as a shield
- 18:29against the spatial managers? I mean, if you mix it all away,
- 18:32you lose your identity. That is the painful binary of
- 18:34the migrant experience. Total assimilation is terrifying
- 18:37because it does risk erasing cultural distinctiveness.
- 18:41But Cyril's father is looking at a moral Ledger.
- 18:44He realizes that maintaining that blood comes at an
- 18:46unbearable cost. Preserving their roots provides
- 18:50comfort and solidarity against white racism, but it
- 18:53simultaneously preserves the inherited prejudices.
- 18:55The castism. The internal exploitation of
- 18:57people like Nandini and Manel, for him, mixing total
- 19:01assimilation, is the only true escape from the twin burdens of
- 19:05external racism and internal classism.
- 19:08His theory is that once people are literally related by blood,
- 19:11the hatred will have to diminish.
- 19:13Because, as he says in the text, they cannot hate without hating
- 19:16themselves. Wow, so you either keep your
- 19:19distinct identity and keep the cage, or you dismantle the cage
- 19:22but lose your distinct identity in the process.
- 19:25There is no clean, easy software patch for this.
- 19:28Which perfectly encapsulates why migration is never just a
- 19:31physical journey across the map, it is a deeply complex multi
- 19:35layered psychological relocation.
- 19:37You cannot just leave your history at border control.
- 19:39No, you can't. That is the major take away for
- 19:42you listening to this. Whenever you look at a
- 19:44community, any community honestly, not just the South
- 19:47Asian diaspora, remember that it is rarely a monolith.
- 19:51Very true. From the outside, we tend to
- 19:53look at a group of migrants and just see a unified block, but we
- 19:56entirely miss the invisible fences of class, cast and race.
- 20:02That they are navigating every single day within their own
- 20:05ranks. Recognizing those invisible
- 20:07fences and understanding the mechanisms that keep them
- 20:10standing is really the only way we can actually grasp the true
- 20:13complexity of our globalized world.
- 20:16Old hierarchies do not vanish. When people move, they morph.
- 20:19They intertwine with new prejudices to create entirely
- 20:22new social labyrinths. The community adapts to the new
- 20:25environment, but the underlying human drive for status and
- 20:28hierarchy remains completely intact.
- 20:30Which leaves us with a final provocative of thought to Mull
- 20:33over. Throughout this deep dive, we've
- 20:35been talking about geographic migration, crossing physical
- 20:38borders, moving from the subcontinent to Australia,
- 20:41navigating physical national spaces.
- 20:43But as our world moves increasingly away from physical
- 20:46geography and into digital spaces, you know, into the
- 20:49virtual reality and massive online communities, what happens
- 20:53to blood and bread there? That's a fascinating point.
- 20:55Digital migration is the ultimate frontier.
- 20:58It is migration without bodies. Exactly.
- 21:02When we migrate into digital avatars, when we leave our
- 21:05physical forms and traditional geographies entirely behind,
- 21:08will we finally leave our historical baggage behind too?
- 21:12Will the digital realm be the ultimate blank slate we've
- 21:14always been looking for? Or will human nature find a way
- 21:18to secretly encode our oldest, deepest biases right into the
- 21:22newest matrix? Will that legacy code of cast
- 21:25class and hierarchy just keep running in the background no
- 21:27matter how many times we update the hardware?
- 21:29Something to think about.