Latest / Her Journey: Women, ambition, love & reinvention / The Guilt of Thriving While Your Best Friend Struggles | Her Journey
Transcript
- I watched her cry into her coffee and felt a hot, shameful spike of relief that my own life wasn’t on fire. I didn’t want to feel that way, but there it was, sitting in my chest like a stone. Let’s be real for a second. We tell ourselves that friendship is a zero-sum game where joy is finite, where if she wins, I lose, or worse, if I’m happy while she’s drowning, I’m somehow betraying her. But here’s the messy part: happiness isn’t scarce. It doesn’t run out just because someone else needs it more than you do right now. Yet, when your best friend is in the thick of a crisis—whether it’s a divorce, a job loss, a health scare, or just a profound, crushing loneliness—it is incredibly hard to sit with your own stability without feeling like a fraud. You start tiptoeing around your own life. You hide your promotions. You mute your good news. You become a curator of sadness, editing out any trace of light so as not to blind her in her darkness. And in doing so, you isolate yourself from the very thing that could actually help her: your genuine, unburdened joy. There’s another layer to this guilt, one we rarely admit out loud. When your friend is struggling, their pain can act as a mirror. If she is stuck, it might remind you of parts of yourself you’ve buried. If she is suffering unfairly, it reminds you of how fragile safety really is. That proximity to chaos triggers a primal fear in us. So, we pull away from our own success because it feels dangerous. We think, 'If I show too much enthusiasm for my new apartment, it highlights how bad her situation is.' Or worse, 'If I talk about my pregnancy, it makes her infertility pain visible.' We try to shrink our world to match hers, believing that empathy means shared misery. But let me tell you something I learned after spending my thirties climbing ladders only to realize they were leaning against the wrong wall: empathy does not require you to dim your light. In fact, staying bright is sometimes the only way to guide her back toward the shore. We live in a culture that equates fairness with equality of outcome. We think love looks like standing shoulder-to-shoulder in the rain. But real, adult friendship often looks like one person holding the umbrella while the other catches a cold. It’s uneven. It’s lopsided. It’s uncomfortable. I remember a time when my best friend went through a breakup that reshaped her entire identity. For six months, I was the therapist, the driver, the dinner provider. I was also terrified to mention my own engagement because I didn’t want to seem like I was celebrating while she was mourning. So I stayed quiet. I became a ghost in my own life. And do you know what happened? She didn’t feel closer to me. She felt guilty. She saw my silence and interpreted it as pity, or worse, judgment. My withholding of joy didn’t make us equals; it made me a caretaker and her a patient. And friendship is not a medical procedure. Here is the counter-intuitive truth: your thriving is not an insult to her struggle. It is evidence that survival is possible. When you are in the dark, you don’t need someone who sits in the dark with you telling you how cold it is. You need someone who has walked outside, seen the sun, and comes back to tell you what it feels like on your skin. Your happiness is data. It is proof of concept. When you share your small wins—the promotion, the nice date, the garden blooming—you aren’t bragging. You are offering hope. Of course, you have to deliver it with tenderness. You don’t drop your good news like a grenade in the middle of her therapy session. You weave it in gently. You say, 'I had a good day today, which reminded me of how strong you are because you’d handle this better than I would.' See the shift? Now your joy becomes a tribute to her strength, not a contrast to her weakness. You are validating her resilience by showing her what resilience looks like in motion. So, what now? How do you hold both truths at once? How do you honor her pain without abandoning your own life? The answer lies in boundaries built on love, not avoidance. You can listen to her vent for an hour without letting her despair consume your weekend. You can cry with her on Tuesday and laugh at a terrible movie on Thursday. You must allow yourself to be a whole person, not just a supporting character in her tragedy. This is where my old corporate brain used to fail me—I thought I had to fix everything. Now I know I just have to witness. Witnessing requires presence, not performance. It means being there when she calls at 2 a.m., but also having the courage to say, 'I’m so sorry you’re going through this, and I’m also going to go enjoy this sunset because I need to recharge so I can be here for you tomorrow.' She needs you present, Miriam-style, fully alive. She doesn’t need you hollowed out by guilt. She needs you real. Reinvention is a continuous practice, remember? And part of that practice is learning to carry your joy lightly. It’s okay to be grateful for your peace while your friend is in the storm. It’s okay to feel sad for her and happy for yourself simultaneously. Those emotions are not mutually exclusive; they are companions. They sit together in the room. You don’t have to choose one over the other. You can hold space for her grief and space for your gratitude in the same breath. This is the maturity of long-term friendship. It’s knowing that seasons change. Today, she is in the valley. Tomorrow, she might climb out. And when she does, she will look for you. Not the version of you who shrank herself to fit her shadow, but the version of you who kept walking, kept growing, and kept waiting for her with open arms and a full heart. You are not abandoning her by thriving. You are preserving the self that she loves and relies on. Be gentle with yourself today. Your joy is allowed. Her pain is valid. And your friendship is strong enough to hold both. Until next time, keep living loudly, even when it feels quiet. You are doing beautifully.