Convince me Catan is a Good Game
Catan has a weird superpower: it’s one of the most loved gateway board games and one of the most mocked “I’m too serious for this” targets. We lean into that tension and ask the honest question: is Settlers of Catan actually good, or are we just remembering 1995 with rose-colored glasses? Clay brings the frustration many hobby gamers feel, like three-hour runtimes, dead turns, and trading that drags. Sam joins us bright and early from New Zealand to make the case that the problem usually isn’t Catan, it’s how the table plays it.
We get tactical fast: why Catan is closer to an engine builder…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.