Latest / Keen On America / Your Data Will Be Used Against You: Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on Policing in the Age of Self-Surveillance
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, my name is Andrew Keen.
- 0:02Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Show about everything that matters with the
- 0:07world's leading commentators and thinkers.
- 0:30Hello everybody.
- 0:31It's Thursday, February the fifth, 2026.
- 0:34Yesterday we did a show, uh, with the journalist Christopher Mathias, uh, who
- 0:40has a new book out to catch a fascist, the fight to expose the Radical, right,
- 0:45that seemed to suggest that, uh, anti Antifa has a right to unmask neo-Nazis.
- 0:55And we had an interesting conversation about the.
- 0:59Unite the right rally in Charlottesville back in 2017 and whether one has
- 1:04the right or not to expose people who were involved in that rally.
- 1:08It's all of course about privacy and indeed shame.
- 1:12We are.
- 1:13Again, talking about privacy today, perhaps in a more legal
- 1:17way with my guest, Andrew Guthrie Ferguson, who has a new book out.
- 1:22"Your Data Will Be Used Against You: Policing in the Age of Self Surveillance."
- 1:29Uh, Andrew is joining us from Washington DC.
- 1:31He teaches, uh, law at, uh, GW Law School.
- 1:37Uh, Andrew, I know this is beyond perhaps the focus of your book, but when it comes
- 1:42to exposing what people are up to in their political lives, what is your take
- 1:49on on this extremely controversial issue?
- 1:53Controversial, of course, both on the left and the right.
- 1:57I think it points to a a point that is discussed in the book,
- 2:01although I don't obviously touch on that issue, which is that our data
- 2:04exposes us, it exposes everyone.
- 2:07Uh, whoever is communicating with some kind of, uh, digital device in
- 2:11their pocket, uh, is uh, uh, exposed.
- 2:15And it has a duality to it, right?
- 2:17Sometimes it's useful for law enforcement to find people.
- 2:20Sometimes, uh, people who are protesting and dissenting, uh, get exposed.
- 2:24And as you were just talking about, it can work the other way around.
- 2:27The point is, uh, uh, maybe it was in your earlier discussion that there
- 2:31really aren't really laws or rules or regulation or constitutional,
- 2:35uh, protections about this data.
- 2:38Uh, my focus on the book is about how.
- 2:40The police and prosecutors and the government can use data against us.
- 2:43Uh, but obviously this sort of exposure of data, uh, has a double edged.
- 2:48Yeah.
- 2:49And a very sharp double edge, unfortunately.
- 2:52Uh, Eric Schmidt fa, uh, when he was CEO of Google, back in,
- 2:55I think it was 2008 or oh nine, famously said about online privacy.
- 3:00Uh, you shouldn't be ashamed of anything you do, uh, or if
- 3:03you are ashamed, don't do it.
- 3:05How would you respond to that?
- 3:09At the point, at that point at least, was a fairly typical Silicon Valley.
- 3:14To the issue of privacy now, I think it's a little bit more nuanced.
- 3:18Well, I think the really hard questions about data privacy general and about
- 3:21what information Google could collect, uh, I think they're actually more
- 3:25narrow and tailored and perhaps solvable issues about controlling what the
- 3:29government can do with that information.
- 3:31So, for example, I do like the fact that I can Google in a
- 3:36search query whatever I'd like to.
- 3:38Uh, query.
- 3:39Uh, and I would wish that data could stay with between me and Google
- 3:44and not necessarily be turned into evidence against me in a court of law.
- 3:47And part of what the book does is, uh, rationalize or, or,
- 3:50or wrestle with that tension.
- 3:52There is a reason why we all have acceptance or the
- 3:55seduction of self surveillance.
- 3:56There's the reason why.
- 3:57We buy, you know, watches that monitor our heartbeat or buy cameras
- 4:01that we put on our front door.
- 4:02There's a reason for that.
- 4:04Um, but what I don't think we've really wrestled with is that that data that we
- 4:07create can be used against us in a court of law, uh, and has been and will be.
- 4:13And, um, that presents its own danger.
- 4:15So in the book, I actually proposed solutions not for Google,
- 4:18collecting our data or data privacy or data protection writ large,
- 4:23but more about how to regulate.
- 4:25Government use of it and prosecution use of it against individuals.
- 4:29Uh.
- 4:32Does it depend, of course on how one views government and
- 4:36its rights in terms of citizens?
- 4:38I mean, what rights should government have, uh, Andrew when
- 4:43it comes to what you call policing in the age of self surveillance?
- 4:49Well, I think there are certain things that, uh, we would like to eat product.
- 4:53Lemme give you a good example.
- 4:54So I think we can all agree that a digital.
- 4:58Pacemaker, something goes in your heart that keeps your heart
- 5:01beating and records, uh, your heart beat and gives it to your doctor.
- 5:06Is a a good, it's an objective.
- 5:08Good we, that is saving lives.
- 5:10It's important and it's something that we should be investing in for
- 5:14innovation and everything else.
- 5:16At the same time, we might also agree that that data about your smart heartbeat
- 5:20should not be available to detectives who can go to your doctor's door with a
- 5:24warrant and get it and use against you.
- 5:26And use it against you in a court of law.
- 5:28And that's happened in a case I discussed in the book.
- 5:31And I think that balance is there.
- 5:33The person being charged in that case was arguably committing a crime, but that's
- 5:38his heartbeat being used against him.
- 5:40And I think that we should be able to design laws that balance, that
- 5:45very good need for having digital conveniences and innovations that
- 5:49have changed our world for good.
- 5:50Uh, but at the same time controlling how that information can be used against us.
- 5:56Give me more details on that heartbeat case.
- 6:00Why did the police wanna use his heartbeat and what was the
- 6:03crime and what was the outcome?
- 6:06So there's this guy who basically was committing a insurance fraud using arson.
- 6:10Uh, he was burning down his house and, uh, he came up with his whole story about how
- 6:16he had rescued everything right in time.
- 6:18And he told us, you know, it's an elaborate lie, uh, about this in order
- 6:21to get the insurance, uh, uh, uh, uh.
- 6:25Money, uh, which again is a, is a crime.
- 6:27And so detectives wanted to disprove his story by showing that his
- 6:32heartbeat wasn't responding the way it would've been if you were running
- 6:35around in the middle of a fire, uh, trying to save all of your possession.
- 6:39So they went and they got, uh, the heartbeat and they used it against
- 6:42him, and he was sort of convicted, uh, based on his own heartbeat.
- 6:45And again, that's a hard story.
- 6:46Like this is.
- 6:47A crime.
- 6:48It's uh, uh, something that we, we don't want to support.
- 6:51At the same time, this is intimate data that really was sort of involuntary
- 6:56given, like, I mean, I guess it could have chosen not to have a pacemaker and
- 7:00not stay alive, but once you have that, it seems like we might be able to carve
- 7:03out protections about certain sensitive data, certain information that maybe
- 7:08we don't want the government to have.
- 7:11What's been the typical response, Andrew?
- 7:14Silicon Valley when it comes to this issue of self surveillance and the, the
- 7:18data that can be used by the police.
- 7:20I know Apple in particular, uh, have been quite resistant to giving
- 7:25to, to, to opening iPhones for the police for one reason or other.
- 7:29What it, it can, one, make some rules about Silicon Valley's
- 7:35commitment or lack of commitment to providing data for the police.
- 7:42I think the, the problem is that currently the only protections are really
- 7:47coming from the companies themselves.
- 7:48There really isn't a law that controls it.
- 7:50Even if you're thinking about, you know, uh, Google, which has been
- 7:54collecting sort of location data and came up with its own three part warrant.
- 8:00So law enforcement could get access to this or what they call the censor vault,
- 8:03basically all of our location data.
- 8:05But it was Google's lawyers who actually came up with the idea of
- 8:08having this three step process.
- 8:09It wasn't like a judge saying this what the fourth amendment holds, or this
- 8:13is, uh, a legislative determination.
- 8:15It was like Google's lawyers.
- 8:16Now that case is actually going before the Supreme Court, uh, just got granted
- 8:20certs going up to, to be decided.
- 8:22Um, but again, the point is the company's making these these calls, so Apple has
- 8:26seen that it's in their business interest.
- 8:28To be more privacy protective.
- 8:30Uh, Google has essentially said, go sold you a cheaper phone, but made
- 8:35the money back on the data that they were collecting from that phone.
- 8:38Uh, and unfortunately now of course, all of those tech companies are somewhat.
- 8:43Beholden to a, uh, governmental administration in the US that is,
- 8:48you know, playing pretty tough.
- 8:49And I, I, I think it'd be hard for, for companies to push back the
- 8:53same way, um, that they had when they have all these other large
- 8:57government contracts, uh, at issue.
- 9:00Apple is sort of in a different boat than, you know, Microsoft or Google or Amazon
- 9:05or any of those other big companies.
- 9:07What rights can and should we have when it comes to these issues?
- 9:11I know that you focus in your book on the fourth Amendment.
- 9:15You might explain, uh, what the Fourth Amendment is and how it connects.
- 9:19But if one is indeed guilty of a crime burning down the house in
- 9:23order to get insurance money, why shouldn't the government use any kind
- 9:26of data it can get access to, to make its case if indeed we are guilty?
- 9:32Well, that is actually the cur, almost the current law, right?
- 9:35That, uh, there if you create data, it can be used against you.
- 9:40In fact, you know, the truth of the matter is there is nothing.
- 9:44Too private, too secret that the government can't
- 9:47access, uh, with a warrant.
- 9:49So, you know, your digital diary, your period app, your health monitor,
- 9:54your smart bed, whatever it is, uh, if the government can get a warrant
- 9:58to get access to it, and sometimes they don't even need a warrant.
- 10:01Um, they can use it.
- 10:02And so that is the current default.
- 10:04I think that that default, uh, devalues sort of a sense of not just privacy, but
- 10:09also gives the government more control.
- 10:11I think that, uh, we've seen, uh, potential abuses of that
- 10:15technology, that sort of use of.
- 10:18Uh, surveillance technology, even in the last like month or two where
- 10:21we've seen a government that has seen, uh, a fit to go after journalists
- 10:26and podcasters and, uh, protesters who are out, uh, on the streets.
- 10:32Uh, and so I think that we might want to, uh, have a balance.
- 10:35I actually think it's a kind of a bipartisan issue because you
- 10:38never know who's gonna be in charge of, uh, the government, but we
- 10:41might wanna have a balance about.
- 10:43Should there be higher limits?
- 10:45You know, maybe something more than a warrant to be able to get access to this?
- 10:48Should there be particular areas that are just so private and so intimate
- 10:52that the police can't get it, uh, no matter what, uh, that might
- 10:56lie under like a Fourth Amendment understanding of like a reason why.
- 10:59Just
- 11:00explain, uh, sorry, Andrew, for, for our, our non-legal audience,
- 11:04what the Fourth Amendment is.
- 11:05Sure.
- 11:05So the Fourth Amendment comes from the United States Constitution that governs,
- 11:10uh, unreasonable searches and seizures.
- 11:12So taking things, but also taking data.
- 11:15Uh, the Supreme Court, uh, has said that the controlling standard is
- 11:19whether or not we all have a reasonable expectation of privacy in something,
- 11:24what that means in a digital age.
- 11:26It's honestly kind of an open question still being debated.
- 11:28The court has said in a case called Carpenter that your cell site location
- 11:32data, so the data that's revealed when you walk around, uh, the, uh, world, uh,
- 11:39requires a warrant to get access to it.
- 11:41Uh, but there have been many other pieces of information where the court
- 11:45has held that there is no, quote unquote, reasonable expectation of privacy.
- 11:49And police can get it for any reason or no reason, just because they want it.
- 11:54Um, so you could have a system where you could have a warrant.
- 11:57Or you could even, and this is some of the proposal in the book, go even beyond
- 12:00that to say maybe there's certain areas that should be essentially privileged.
- 12:04It's like when you're, when a client and a lawyer are talking, they're
- 12:06something called an attorney-client privilege, where those communications
- 12:10just can't be used in court.
- 12:11When two married people are speaking, that communication is privileged.
- 12:15Why?
- 12:15Because we.
- 12:16Value something else besides the ability to use data against someone in a court.
- 12:21We value the sanctity of marriage.
- 12:23We value the sanctity of an attorney-client privilege.
- 12:26And I think that there, there are some pieces of our digital world, uh, that
- 12:29also deserve that kind of privilege or, so I, I make the argument in the book,
- 12:34this isn't gonna make the police very happy is.
- 12:37No, no, it's not.
- 12:38Um, I, I think, you know, the police and, and honestly the tech companies
- 12:41sort of like the status quo, where there really isn't regulation.
- 12:46The Fourth Amendment is still debating things in kind of
- 12:48an analog pre-digital world.
- 12:51Uh, and that means the technology proceeds a pace.
- 12:55And sometimes, you know, the, the book is honestly filled with
- 12:57stories of, uh, uses that get a bad guy and, and, and lock 'em up.
- 13:03And I wrestle with that.
- 13:04Uh, honestly, I, I'm trying to show that there is a positive to it.
- 13:07Uh, but I also think the danger of that is that that same data can
- 13:10be used to, you know, track it.
- 13:12Police officers, ex-girlfriend, or as we're seeing in Minneapolis, like go
- 13:17after, uh, protestors or people who are, uh, using their First Amendment
- 13:21rights, uh, in ways that are deeply uncomfortable that the police, you know,
- 13:25without, uh, the proper requirements, even if you call something a crime,
- 13:29it, everything becomes available.
- 13:31Uh, that you can use the same power in a real authoritarian way.
- 13:36You used the Minnesota example, uh, the Minneapolis example, Andrew Bit.
- 13:43A lot of people would argue outside the law that the, the, the, the,
- 13:48the current regime and certainly the behavior of ice in Minneapolis is
- 13:54unconstitutional, perhaps even illegal.
- 13:56So, uh, can that example really be used?
- 14:02I mean, you can always find examples of the police or a state overstepping.
- 14:08The boundaries, but that in itself doesn't mean that there
- 14:15shouldn't be laws should there.
- 14:18I do think that there should be laws.
- 14:20In fact, the book is filled with suggestion suggestions that there
- 14:23should be laws, but there are not.
- 14:25And and what's really chilling is that the technologies that ICE and, and the
- 14:30Customs Border Patrol are using right now in Minneapolis can be used by local law
- 14:34enforcement or the FBI in the same way.
- 14:37And there isn't a clear, uh, sense that it is automatically unconstitutional.
- 14:41You have to wait for the Supreme Court to, to claim that it is or state that it is.
- 14:46Um, and the.
- 14:48That we are seeing, and this is what's interesting.
- 14:50We are seeing a very aggressive use of new technologies, new surveillance
- 14:54technologies as we've never seen before against, uh, otherwise, uh, relatively
- 15:00privileged, uh, population that was not normally the target of surveillance.
- 15:05And so like the aperture of surveillance ha has expanded to target people
- 15:07who weren't normally targeted and suddenly everyone's saying, wow,
- 15:10this feels a little too much.
- 15:12Whereas that same technology can be used against.
- 15:16Anyone, unless there was a countervailing law or a constitutional
- 15:21rule saying it can't be, and right now we don't really have that.
- 15:27How aggressive has the police become?
- 15:29I know that there are lots of cases in which.
- 15:32Seems as if local police forces are becoming increasingly greedy for data.
- 15:38And there's one, uh, example where the Texas State police has more
- 15:43than doubled their drone fleet.
- 15:45Um, are there great differences between state police forces and
- 15:51are there any guidelines on what the police can and can't do in
- 15:56terms of collecting data about us?
- 15:59There are no.
- 16:00Like external guidelines.
- 16:01Obviously police departments themselves might write the rules that limit
- 16:05themselves, but there's no federal law or state law that's going to control it.
- 16:09They're actually for drones as that example.
- 16:11There are a few like FAA laws that sort of control like safety issues
- 16:15around, you know, drones flying ahead.
- 16:18But in terms of like.
- 16:19We have many cities now that are adopting drones as first responders.
- 16:23So imagine a nine one one call goes out, a drone response before the police officer
- 16:27taking a video of what's happening there, which again, from a tactical strategy,
- 16:32uh, uh, perspective for the police is.
- 16:34Very helpful for them.
- 16:35They can, if you have a realtime crime center, uh, which again is a
- 16:39new sort of idea of like fusing all these video streams together, analysts
- 16:43at the realtime crime center can see what's going on with the drone.
- 16:46They can then go to the various cameras that are right around, uh, the area.
- 16:49They can even like go get access to like the police officer's body camera
- 16:53and be able to, to see what's going on.
- 16:55Incredibly powerful, uh, uh, change for police to get eyes on the ground quickly.
- 17:02There aren't real, uh, you know, like external rules about what
- 17:06they can do, uh, with that data.
- 17:08Um, sometimes it's helpful, sometimes it's not.
- 17:11Um, but it's definitely a change and it's a change that we haven't talked about
- 17:14part of the book, which is, you know, on the theme of self surveillance, it's sort
- 17:18of this democratic self surveillance.
- 17:19This is like a mediated democratic self surveillance where we have chosen to
- 17:24spend our tax dollars, uh, on these camera systems and these drones.
- 17:28And I think we should have a debate about whether we're okay with them.
- 17:32When it comes to these kinds of debates, do do American citizens
- 17:37tend to be somewhat paranoid?
- 17:39There's more and more fear of big tech on lots of different
- 17:42fronts, especially with ai.
- 17:43And I wanna talk about AI a little bit later in our conversation, but.
- 17:48Where do we get balance in terms of this conversation?
- 17:51On the one hand, we have legal scholars like yourself.
- 17:54On the other hand, we have sort of hardcore libertarians who don't
- 17:57believe that the government have any rights to any information about us.
- 18:01Where, where, what is the model for beginning to figure this stuff out?
- 18:06Is it back in the 19th century?
- 18:08The beginning of the print, uh, mass printing press.
- 18:11Well, I do think we are on like a, a moment of evolution, if not revolution,
- 18:16about, uh, the power of surveillance.
- 18:19And you can just look at China and see what happens when you have a,
- 18:23you know, city that is like just covered in cameras everywhere you go.
- 18:27And it's not just cameras, it's video analytics like baked into
- 18:30the camera so you can identify.
- 18:32Individuals and objects and where they've gone, whether they're
- 18:35doing anything right or wrong.
- 18:36Uh, and then connecting all those data sets to who they are and what
- 18:39they do and their social credit score.
- 18:40And the rest, like we actually have the technology in the world, in America.
- 18:44We're sort of developing it in our local way because policing is
- 18:47a very local, uh, uh, business.
- 18:49Uh, and so people aren't necess.
- 18:52Putting all the pieces together to see this kind of change in law.
- 18:57But I think when you have, I mean, there's a change in technology, but
- 18:59when you have that kind of change in technology and really change in power.
- 19:03We should have a corresponding change in law and have these
- 19:06debates about whether we are okay.
- 19:08And it is true that there will be people who are, uh, completely
- 19:12against any surveillance technology.
- 19:14And then there'll be people who are actually very, you know, pro technology
- 19:18because they sort of like the.
- 19:19You know, if we watch everything, nothing bad will happen.
- 19:22Uh, and then hopefully we can have a debate about how to give the data that we
- 19:27need, if we really need it in a particular case, but maybe protect other interests
- 19:31like First Amendment interests, religious interests, you know, medical interests.
- 19:34Like do you really need, uh, automated license plate camera outside the, you
- 19:38know, medical clinic or the, you know, AA meeting or any of those things.
- 19:42Like we could have that debate.
- 19:44It is hard, but it's doable.
- 19:47You bring up the China example and their notorious social credit system.
- 19:52There are lots of cameras around the world, not just in
- 19:54China and London, for example.
- 19:56I think there are more cameras in London than anywhere else, but, uh, the UK still
- 20:00has a constitutional system as opposed to the authoritarian system in China.
- 20:06Can one distinguish them between types of government?
- 20:10I, I think I've already asked this question, but.
- 20:13Some governments are more responsible in terms of how they use this data and
- 20:18how would you compare European models?
- 20:21Obviously you've, you've mentioned China with the us.
- 20:24Well, I think what's interesting is I think that the, the origin story of
- 20:28how we reach this point where we have essentially built a surveillance state.
- 20:34Almost where we can do this kind of tracking and um, uh, monitoring of
- 20:39people but haven't panicked yet is in part because up until right about
- 20:44this moment in American history, the people using the technology were.
- 20:49Somewhat moderated and even somewhat concerned, like the Biden administration,
- 20:53uh, was doing internal checks.
- 20:55They had, you know, an AI policy.
- 20:57They clearly were hearing voices of civil libertarians and activists
- 21:02who were against it, and there was a, a sense of restraint.
- 21:06I think what just has happened just in the last few months is that we've
- 21:10seen that there are no restraints.
- 21:13The norms are gone.
- 21:15There is no law or constitutional law to fill it.
- 21:18And so we're in a point here in America where the parallels to
- 21:22China are actually stronger than they were, you know, two years ago.
- 21:27And, uh, you know, and maybe you can look to other governments
- 21:31that would do it wisely.
- 21:32And again, the European, um, uh, many European cities have pretty elaborate
- 21:36surveillance systems and people don't seem quite as, uh, uh, uh, worried about it.
- 21:42Um, but.
- 21:44If an election can change that and we can see how, um, power can
- 21:48be used or misused, or how the, the people targeted can change.
- 21:54There's a huge debate, probably outside your sphere of interest,
- 21:57Andrew, about the crisis of democracy and the threat of authoritarianism.
- 22:02Do you think one reason why the American democracy seems to be in crisis and we
- 22:07have this shift towards authoritarianism, is this emerging panopticon?
- 22:13I mean, we can blame it all, of course, on.
- 22:16Trump or Stephen Miller or somebody within ice.
- 22:19But are there structural reasons why democracy seems to be increasingly in
- 22:24crisis in the digital age, where the government knows more and more about
- 22:29us through our self surveillance?
- 22:34I'm, I'm sure people have made that argument and can make that argument.
- 22:38I, I think that what's interesting now is that.
- 22:42The Trump administration has sort of seen the potential of this
- 22:47surveillance that has been there.
- 22:48I mean, again, the Biden administration was investing in a lot of this technology.
- 22:52They were building out the real time crime centers.
- 22:54They were, um, um, you know, fighting against, you know, Ron
- 22:58Widen, Senator Wen's, like the Fourth Amendment is not for sale.
- 23:01Act like there was like push, like the Biden administration was
- 23:04building this out, but I think they thought it, they were doing
- 23:06it, it wisely and it's only now.
- 23:08Where there's this like, aggressive use of technology that I think the Trump
- 23:12administration has realized, like, wow, if we keep, there's these companies
- 23:15that will sell us this data and we could track anyone we want right now.
- 23:19Maybe we're focused on, you know, undocumented people or
- 23:22people protesting, uh, ice, but we could use this for anything.
- 23:26And I think we're still, they, they may be waking up to this power and
- 23:30I think that this is a moment where.
- 23:33People who are now, the new targets of, uh, of, of this power
- 23:38are, are frightened about it.
- 23:40Um, but my point to them and even to the Trump administration
- 23:43is like, you know, president Trump's data was used against him.
- 23:46Like they actually went back and used his data, his texts, uh, and
- 23:50this is a bipartisan fear, like whoever's in power may well abuse
- 23:54this power, and thus we should have rules and regulations and limits.
- 23:58So we will prevent this foreseeable danger.
- 24:02When it comes to the, the right to privacy of the American.
- 24:06Founders, who do you think was the wisest?
- 24:09We began this conversation talking about Charlottesville, of course,
- 24:13the home of Thomas Jefferson.
- 24:14I'm guessing in terms of this conversation and the appearance of a, a panopticon
- 24:19like architecture in America be turning in his grave, but did some of
- 24:24the founders anticipate any of this?
- 24:28I think so.
- 24:28So at the end of the book, I, I talk about the tyrant test and I sort of use as a
- 24:32metaphor, but also a plan of action where.
- 24:36The tyrant test says we should imagine the worst.
- 24:39Imagine
- 24:40the tyrant.
- 24:41The tyrant test.
- 24:42Tyrant test.
- 24:42Yeah.
- 24:43So the, the, the, the solution, one of the solutions at the end of
- 24:45the book is called the Tyrant test.
- 24:47Uh, and it basically says we should imagine the worst.
- 24:49We should imagine the tyrant reading your most embarrassing Google queries, uh,
- 24:54and finding out everywhere you've gone.
- 24:57And then we should.
- 24:58Plan accordingly.
- 24:59So what would we do structurally?
- 25:00These are big questions that involve big answers.
- 25:03There have to be legislative changes, there have to be judicial changes.
- 25:06We need to have a division of power between federal and
- 25:08state and like community.
- 25:10Maybe even have things like juries and grand juries.
- 25:13Uh, and I say, you know, the model for this tyrant test is America, right?
- 25:17The founding fathers were concerned about the idea of a.
- 25:21Any entity having too much power.
- 25:23So they tried to split it apart, tried to have contested, uh, places of power,
- 25:27and we should do the same thing with, uh, data and, and digital surveillance.
- 25:32We should create checks, rights and remedies.
- 25:34We should have, uh, limits of, of juries and grand juries who could sort of vet
- 25:38whether we want this kind of surveillance technology in their community.
- 25:41And we have to have legislative protections and judicial, uh,
- 25:45acts like judges have to actually.
- 25:47Maybe act to protect, uh, individuals when the Fourth
- 25:50Amendment is, uh, you know, at issue.
- 25:52And if we do all of the above and I try to lay 'em out in a more
- 25:56sophisticated way that I'm saying here in the book, we we're moving forward.
- 26:00It's not gonna be a solution to every problem we have, but it's
- 26:03definitely better than what we have now, which is essentially nothing.
- 26:09We, what we have now, of course, is AI moving very fast.
- 26:13It was a recent, um, story about perplexity, public safety
- 26:19deal, alarming experts when it comes to policing the police.
- 26:23Ai.
- 26:23How does AI change all this?
- 26:26Andrew?
- 26:27So it's interesting, AI is changing surveillance 'cause
- 26:29it's kind of supercharging.
- 26:30So think about the cameras that we've had, uh, on our city streets for, for ages now.
- 26:35Like everyone's kind of familiar with these cameras, right?
- 26:38But now imagine 'em all going back to that real time crime center
- 26:40just de uh, described and then.
- 26:43Being able to track or identify any objects, so man, woman, child, bus, van
- 26:48blue, van Blue Subaru, Tesla, whatever it is, and be able to separate out all those
- 26:52objects and then track them back in time.
- 26:54It's like a time machine.
- 26:55And the way we do that is ai, right?
- 26:57We basically can train the AI to match like.
- 27:00This is what Tesla looks like.
- 27:01This is what a cyber truck looks like.
- 27:02This is what, uh, you know, a Ford looks like.
- 27:05And we have trained the video surveillance so that we have turned ordinary
- 27:09cameras into something wholly new, which is a system of tracking in major
- 27:14cities that have, you know, cameras like Chicago's over 32,000 cameras.
- 27:18Uh, like we are developing a, our own panopticon o of sorts in this way.
- 27:24And behind that is ai.
- 27:25We'll see other smaller pieces.
- 27:27I just read an article about AI assisted police reports, so it's not in the
- 27:30book, but it's the idea of you can take the audio from a pol a a, uh,
- 27:35body camera footage and turn it into a pre-printed chat GPT police report.
- 27:40That then becomes the basis of the arrest prosecution and the rest of, uh, the
- 27:45criminal justice system going forward.
- 27:47Fascinating new technology, changing the relationship between police
- 27:51and, and, uh, the community.
- 27:53We're just gonna see more of it.
- 27:57It was interesting in my conversation with, uh, Matts, we talked about the
- 28:01rights and wrongs of wearing masks.
- 28:04From his point of view, he thinks that the left or Antifa have a right to, uh,
- 28:10expose the identity of people on the far right and that they have no right and
- 28:15people working for ice to wear masks.
- 28:18What's your take on masks and anonymity in public?
- 28:24Well, I, I haven't read his book, so I, I apologize,
- 28:26but, um, yeah, and he's not, and to be fair, he, he's
- 28:28anything but a legal scholar.
- 28:30He's a polemicist, he's a guy on the left.
- 28:33So I'm not trying to compare, but I'm, I'm curious as to your thinking on our
- 28:38legal right to anonymity on the right, for example, to wear masks if we want to
- 28:44go to a a, a white supremacist rally or a Antifa rally, should we have that right?
- 28:53It's sort of outside my expertise, but just sort of, you know, spit balling here.
- 28:57Uh, I think that individuals should be able to choose whether to mask
- 29:02or not and thus keep a measure of anonymity when they protest.
- 29:04'cause it probably cuts both ways.
- 29:06I don't think law enforcement should, I think there's a real troubling, uh,
- 29:09reality that we're seeing masked law enforcement just because we really want
- 29:14a government, uh, and, and police power that's accountable like the whole.
- 29:18You know, sense of why we might trust giving over sort of this carceral power
- 29:25to someone else is because we should implicitly trust that they're following
- 29:30rules, that they understand what they're doing, and there's a transparent way
- 29:34to hold 'em accountable when they.
- 29:35Don't follow those rules.
- 29:37I think masking and not having badge numbers and not doing all the
- 29:40things that we normally have with local policing, uh, undermines that.
- 29:44Uh, but for ordinary citizens, like I, I understand why, you know, I
- 29:48think there's a value in anonymity.
- 29:50Um, uh, and, you know, and, and protests.
- 29:55All sorts of debates endlessly.
- 29:57Andrew, again, you don't need me to tell you this about the rise or fall of crime.
- 30:02Uh, every administration seems to be obsessed with Trump in.
- 30:06When, uh, Jeremy Bentham in the late nine, uh, 18th century came
- 30:10up with his idea of the panopticon where everything could be seen.
- 30:13It wasn't that people would actually, everything would be seen, but that
- 30:18people would fear they were being watched, which would enable them, or
- 30:22at least in Bentham's utilitarian.
- 30:25Mind to behave themselves, to obey the law, whether it was in
- 30:28prisons or schools or hospitals.
- 30:31Could one, make the argument perhaps in a, in a utilitarian sense that all these
- 30:37cameras are actually good because it means that people are breaking the law less?
- 30:44I think that's the rationale, the Chinese government for, for, uh,
- 30:47putting them on their streets.
- 30:48But I, I think there's a countervailing argument that, you
- 30:52know, the utilitarian argument.
- 30:54Necessarily suppresses the.
- 30:56Outlier, the dissenter, the voice that people don't want to hear or, or see.
- 31:00And that's pretty American.
- 31:02Um, the idea of being able to, uh, do what you want, even if it's
- 31:06uncomfortable to other people.
- 31:08Uh, and so I'm not sure we necessarily live in an, a utilitarian
- 31:13world in that, that sense.
- 31:15Um, I also, I'm not sure it necessarily works, like we've had lots of deterrents.
- 31:19So you have deterrence in, you know, cameras and, you know.
- 31:22Seven elevens that still get robbed, and it's not necessarily,
- 31:25it works in that same way.
- 31:27Um, but, uh, I also, I, I think it, it is an understandable argument
- 31:34and I think that it is an argument that needs to be pushed back again
- 31:39because we, I don't think we want.
- 31:41To live in a world where the government can see everything we do
- 31:46and thus judge us for us and possibly penalize us for us, uh, us for it.
- 31:51Um, especially if that data would then be used to prosecute you.
- 31:54Like it can be in China where if you jaywalk, uh, you can get your old face put
- 31:59up on the side and they ticket you for it.
- 32:02Um, certainly I don't think, uh, anyone watching is necessarily sympathetic
- 32:07to the Chinese state, but if we had technology, if we carry cameras or
- 32:13smartphones or AI devices around with us, which were increasingly doing, which
- 32:18will reveal everything we're doing, uh, and it did indeed radically reduce crime.
- 32:26What should a government do?
- 32:28Sh should a civilized government in a sense, in this context at least, uh,
- 32:34believe that a degree of crime isn't a bad thing when it comes to freedom.
- 32:41I, I think the danger in that sentence is the definition of crime, right?
- 32:45So if crime is seeking out an abortion for your daughter in Texas or Idaho,
- 32:49or a place that's criminal, no.
- 32:50No.
- 32:51Aren't
- 32:51you just questioning the nature of the law and saying that if you don't approve of
- 32:56the law, you have the right to break it?
- 32:59Well, I, I, well, I think that the danger is like when protest becomes criminalized.
- 33:06Criminalized, then it's all about who's defining the crime.
- 33:11Um, I think we could come to a compromise about saying, you know,
- 33:14there's certain crimes and certain times where some of this technology.
- 33:17It can be very useful, uh, and we should have rules about how you get
- 33:21access to it and when you can't get access to it and how you can't abuse it.
- 33:24But I think the one thing we do know is if you had that magical power where
- 33:28everyone was being watched and everything was being controlled by one person, it
- 33:31would most certainly be abused and it would be abused for political reasons, for
- 33:35personal reasons, for financial reasons.
- 33:37And I think I, I would rather live in a world where.
- 33:41We didn't have that.
- 33:42And we can deal with a, a little level of, of some crime that probably still
- 33:46gonna exist even when you over the cameras there, um, but isn't gonna be misused
- 33:51in that sort of tyrannical, uh, way.
- 33:53And I think that is what would happen.
- 33:56I, I, I would bet good money, that's what will happen.
- 33:59For better or worse, Andrew, we seem to be living in the future.
- 34:02There's a movie coming out this year called Mercy.
- 34:05Uh, about, uh, an AI world in which intentionality reveals whether or not
- 34:12one's guilty technology is moving so fast.
- 34:18H how is this gonna impact, um, criminality and indeed intentionality?
- 34:24Uh, can one be guilty?
- 34:28Intent, uh, of, of, of, of crimes.
- 34:30If, if, if one thinks in that way.
- 34:34So if you take criminal law, uh, you learn about how we as a society don't
- 34:39punish people based on thoughts alone.
- 34:43Um, you learn that we require some kind of act, and so I imagine that whatever,
- 34:49you know, AI Hollywood wants to create, whether it's Minority Report, you know,
- 34:54which is the earlier version of Mercy probably, although I haven't seen Yeah.
- 34:56Minority Report course covered,
- 34:58right?
- 34:58I mean, again, a, it will be wrong and b, it, it still hopefully will require
- 35:06people to do some, some kind of act.
- 35:08So it's not just in your head, but more so.
- 35:11If we have these changes, we should have corresponding legal responses that if
- 35:18we're gonna change the nature of power between police and prosecutors and
- 35:23ordinary people, we need to rebalance the protections for those, uh, people as well.
- 35:29Because if we just like, follow the technology, it's probably
- 35:32gonna have not be a happy ending, uh, to that, that that movie.
- 35:38Yeah, I'm not sure there is a very happy ending to that particular movie,
- 35:42Andrew, in our age of self surveillance, people are gonna be watching this and
- 35:47getting really, I think, very nervous, probably thinking to themselves,
- 35:50I've gotta give up my smartphone.
- 35:52I'm not gonna go out.
- 35:53I don't want to be seen by cameras.
- 35:55What's your advice to people when it comes to this avalanche of data, self
- 36:03surveillance, and otherwise should people.
- 36:05Consider turning their, their phones off.
- 36:10Most of the time, especially when they're doing something, shall
- 36:12we say, morally dubious, dubious if, if not breaking the law,
- 36:17I think as a general matter, like turning your back on new technology just isn't
- 36:22going to be a, a workable solution, right?
- 36:25We live by our smartphones and our smart cars.
- 36:29You can't even buy a car now that isn't tracking you with some,
- 36:32uh, device like that is the norm.
- 36:35We should have laws to protect it.
- 36:37Again, my argument in the book isn't that we need to have like data privacy laws,
- 36:42although we should, I hope someone, you know, does the hard job of figuring out
- 36:45the data privacy, data protection world.
- 36:47But this is like, should this data necessarily be used against
- 36:50us in a court of law and then.
- 36:53If so, what are the, the rules by which you would do it?
- 36:56Maybe the current like warrant system and, and you, for many of
- 37:00the data we're talking about, you don't even need a warrant, but the
- 37:02warrant system might be two weeks.
- 37:03So maybe you need something stronger and we could actually solve that problem.
- 37:07The bigger data protection problem of, than having to like, you know,
- 37:10hide your phone is gonna be difficult.
- 37:12But we could pass laws tomorrow saying, you know what?
- 37:15The government can't use this data against you in a court of law.
- 37:19Google can still use it to sell you products, but the government
- 37:22can't use it to, to prosecute you.
- 37:24We haven't had that world, that is sort of a revolutionary, counterintuitive
- 37:29world, but we could, we could have the best of both worlds if we wanted
- 37:32to make these difficult decisions.
- 37:36Well, I think the one thing we've learned from this conversation, Andrew, is
- 37:40that if you are planning to burn down your own house and claim the insurance
- 37:44money, don't use a heart monitor.
- 37:46Is that right?
- 37:47That is definitely a, a helpful tip about being careful that you
- 37:51know every smart device you own.
- 37:53It is a surveillance device.
- 37:56Well, on that helpful note for anyone planning to burn down your
- 37:59house, put your, put your phone away.
- 38:01Uh, although some people will be watching this on their phone, uh, very
- 38:05interesting and important new book, your data will be used against you
- 38:09policing in the Age of Self Surveillance.
- 38:12Uh, Andrew Guthrie Ferguson, thank you so much for a really
- 38:15interesting conversation.
- 38:17Thank you.
- 38:17It was a pleasure.