Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / It Reads Like Grisham And Clancy But Kenneth P Vogel Brings Truth In Devils Advocate
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Talk about being behind the curveball. All my podcasts are
- 0:02finally on one site, aero dot net, a r re
- 0:07dot net, seventeen different podcasts to choose from. Kenneth what
- 0:11a story, This is Grisham, this is Tom Clancy. But
- 0:14this is real life. And I think that's what I
- 0:16love about this is that I have to keep telling
- 0:18myself this is the way of the world, and even
- 0:21though I may not know what one hundred percent, My God,
- 0:24you are opening up my educational system.
- 0:27Speaker 2: Yeah, I appreciate it.
- 0:28Speaker 1: Arro.
- 0:28Speaker 2: You know, I think one of the conceits that I had,
- 0:31or one of the maybe misimpressions that I had going
- 0:34into this was that, you know, the way that politics
- 0:37works around the world, particularly in the developing country or
- 0:40the Middle East, the former Soviet world, the sort of
- 0:43pay to play system where people around the leaders are
- 0:47able to collect these huge sums of money in exchange
- 0:49for brokering access or influence to sometimes shadowy interests. Like
- 0:54things don't work that way in the US. We have
- 0:55all these laws that are intended to prevent that kind
- 0:58of thing, And as I dug into this book, I realized, no, actually,
- 1:02the things do work kind of similarly in the US.
- 1:05Speaker 1: I mean, it's like, you know, when I thought of
- 1:07Rudy Giuliani and and I guess I was blind to
- 1:10this because I'm so in love with, you know, supporting
- 1:13you know, the Associated Press, ABC, Fox, Seeing N and
- 1:16then all of a sudden, I come across this story
- 1:18about Rudy Giuliani as well as Hunt Hunter Biden, and
- 1:21I'm going, of course they had other things to do.
- 1:24What we were getting is what they wanted to share
- 1:26with us by way of propaganda, and now you're giving
- 1:29it to us in Devil's Advocate.
- 1:32Speaker 2: Yeah. I think the thing that was so interesting to
- 1:33me about Rudy and Hunter and the way that their
- 1:37stories kind of intertwine was you know that what we
- 1:42saw is particularly during the first impeachment of Trump, was
- 1:46Rudy Giuliani, you know, pressuring Trump to or urging Trump
- 1:50to pressure the Ukrainians to investigate Hunter Biden, to dig
- 1:53up dirt on Hunter Biden, and trying to expose Hunter
- 1:57Biden in the way that he had, you know, engaged
- 1:59in the kind of foreign influence peddling that sort of
- 2:03undermined Joe Biden's self image as this you know, this
- 2:08global statesman who had urge other countries to fight corruption
- 2:12and been a champion of democracy, and so, you know,
- 2:15it was a serious political liability and there were things there,
- 2:19you know that I think, did you know, call into
- 2:22question whether Joe Biden knew about what was going on.
- 2:25But the interesting thing is Rudy Giuliani was particularly well
- 2:28suited to be able to dig up that dirted to
- 2:31be able to prosecute that argument against Hunter Biden because
- 2:34he had engaged in exactly the same sort of activity
- 2:38in the foreign influence world, sometimes on behalf of some
- 2:41of the same people like they had both worked for.
- 2:45Tried to help this Romanian oligarch who was being prosecuted
- 2:48for corruption in regards to a land deal, and at
- 2:52one point Hunter Biden was brought in and Hunter Biden
- 2:54tried to get the guy out of trouble. At one point,
- 2:56Hunter Biden actually tried to do a deal for the
- 2:58land that was the subject of the prosecution with these
- 3:02Chinese interests that would have resulted in the Chinese paying
- 3:06five hundred million dollars for this land. That Hunter Bidy
- 3:08would then be a partner in the joint venture that
- 3:10would oversee the development of well Rudy Giuliani, just a
- 3:15year or two later, had tried to help that same
- 3:17Romanian Oligark get out of trouble. So, yeah, if you're
- 3:20looking for someone who can call out foreign influence pedaling,
- 3:24then it's good to have someone who has experienced in
- 3:27that world. But it also is quite hypocritical.
- 3:30Speaker 1: But you know what's really interesting about this book, Kenneth,
- 3:32is the fact that it really opens up our eyes
- 3:34to what is currently going on in Israel, not having
- 3:37ambassadors over there doing the negotiating, but basically businessman. It's
- 3:41the same thing you're telling us that, Hey, look before
- 3:44we are in this moment of now, we've got Hunter
- 3:47Biden and we've got Rudy Giuliani, and trust me, they
- 3:49were doing some big business deals behind the scenes.
- 3:54Speaker 2: Yeah, one hundred percent. I mean, the reference to the
- 3:57Middle East Piece deal is apt. Jared Cook and Steve Witkoff,
- 4:01who were like heavily involved in it, had extensive business
- 4:05interests with those countries. With some of the key countries,
- 4:08I mean Jared Kushner even before the first Trump administration,
- 4:12he had got a huge bail out from the Kataris,
- 4:14who again played a central role in this negotiation. Uh,
- 4:18and they had helped him essentially, like rescue this property
- 4:23that he had sixty sixty six Fifth Avenue, huge building
- 4:26in Manhattan that was really troubled financially. They bailed him
- 4:29out basically. So he gets into he gets into the
- 4:32White House in the first term, and he's working to
- 4:35help resolve this this blockade that the Emiadis and the
- 4:39Saudis had placed on the Kataris. And he's got deep
- 4:43business interest there and so you know, in some ways
- 4:46like that can be helpful, he said. Steve Witkoff and
- 4:49Kushner were asked about this and whether there was a
- 4:52conflict between their role and negotiating this current piece deal
- 4:55and their business interest in the region. They were asked
- 4:57about in sixty minutes and Jared Kushner said, no, Actually,
- 5:00that business experience is like a strength because now we
- 5:03have trust from these people, and like, you know, maybe
- 5:06there is something to that that like private diplomacy or
- 5:10diplomacy that sort of blurs the line between you know,
- 5:13official government to government interactions and private business can be useful,
- 5:18but at what costs, Like do we really want the
- 5:21specter of some of these decisions you know about us
- 5:24foreign policy being driven not by what's in the best
- 5:27interest to the United States of America or its taxpayers,
- 5:29but rather by some ulterior business motives to make nice with,
- 5:35you know, a sovereign wealth fund or a country that
- 5:37has a lot of money to throw around. Because let's
- 5:40not forget what Jared Kusher got out of the administration
- 5:42after the first Trump administration ended. He set up this
- 5:46this venture capital fund and got a two billion dollar
- 5:49investment from this out He's who he had just weeks
- 5:52earlier been dealing with as the Middle East peace negotiator
- 5:55negotiator for the first Trump administration. That's a conflict of interest,
- 5:59whether or not it also yields some benefit.
- 6:01Speaker 1: But is it a conflict of interest that will lead
- 6:04to an indictment, because it seems like we're in an
- 6:06indictment hell right now. It seems like everybody's going in
- 6:09for the count right now.
- 6:12Speaker 2: Yeah. I don't know. I mean, certainly at the top
- 6:15level with the president, it's unlikely that we would see
- 6:18any sort of a successful prosecution because of the Supreme
- 6:22Court decision on presidential immunity related to any official acts.
- 6:27And as far as like the people around him, I
- 6:30think it's also less likely that we'll see any sort
- 6:32of enforcement because Pam Bondy, as one of her first
- 6:36acts as Attorney General, decriminalized the enforcement of the Foreign
- 6:41Agents Registration Act, which is the main law that is
- 6:44used to oversee and regulate foreign lobbying. It's notable, by
- 6:48the way, Pam Bondi's background before she became Attorney General.
- 6:52She was a lobbyist and at least some of her
- 6:54clients were foreign countries, including, by the way, the state
- 6:57of Cutter which is you know, is the one who
- 7:01gave President Trump the two hundred million dollar playing too.
- 7:04So you know, it seems unlikely that there's a great
- 7:07appetite for prosecuting these types of cases.
- 7:10Speaker 1: Now, please do not move. There's more with Kenneth P.
- 7:13Vogel coming up next, the name of the book Devils Advocates.
- 7:19Oh what a shocker, an eye opener. We are back
- 7:24with Kenneth P. Vogel. This is so intriguing to me
- 7:27because this is the kind of stuff that I really
- 7:30it's like having I know what the tree looks like.
- 7:33The tree is the president, but we don't see the
- 7:35rooting system of the tree. And that's every bit of
- 7:37this that's going on. We see every little tentacle going
- 7:40out there to get what it is that's going to
- 7:42make this country even better through foreign policy. And when
- 7:44you've got somebody like Hunter Biden who comes along and
- 7:47undermines the US interests, Oh, the other side's going to
- 7:49get upset and that Do you think that's what's happening,
- 7:52is that he pissed him off?
- 7:55Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, it wasn't just the other side, by
- 7:57the way, like a sure this was this became a
- 8:00political cudgel that Republicans tried to use against the Bidens.
- 8:03But while it was actually happening, which is mostly during Biden,
- 8:07Joe Biden's vice presidency, they were like career civil servants, diplomats,
- 8:13foreign service officers in the State Department, in the White House,
- 8:16and the Energy Department who were raising concerns about this.
- 8:19So these are like natural allies of the Bidens who
- 8:22were saying, in some cases directly to Joe Biden, in
- 8:26other cases to his staff, hey, this is a problem
- 8:29that your son is working for these interests that are
- 8:32misaligned not just misaligned with US foreign policy that we
- 8:35as like the Vice President's office, were encouraging prosecutors in
- 8:40these respective countries to go after to bring anti corruption
- 8:44prosecutions against these oligarchs or these companies for theft of
- 8:49public resources. And your son is working for them, and
- 8:53they think that what they're getting out of this is
- 8:56is like influence or protection from the US against these
- 9:01prosecutions that the US is pushing. So at the very least,
- 9:04it's mixed signals that are being sent, you know, but
- 9:07I think more to the point, it is really undermining
- 9:11US foreign policy.
- 9:12Speaker 1: It's so interesting that when you say mixed singles signals,
- 9:15because I mean I really did smile and I got
- 9:18a little crazy smirk on my face when I learned
- 9:20that Giuliani played the president. I mean he did because
- 9:24he put him on his team in order to get
- 9:25where he needed to go in order to get his
- 9:27job done. And I just felt like, man, that's the
- 9:30way the power is, utilize each other's gifts and get
- 9:33the job done.
- 9:35Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, Rudi Giuliani is an interesting example. You know.
- 9:39Now he's become sort of a pathetic figure because of
- 9:43the controversy surrounding his work with Trump and the legal
- 9:47and financial repercussions of that. In terms of these big
- 9:50judgments against him for defamation related to his claims about
- 9:53the twenty twenty election. But you know, during the first term,
- 9:58he was quite influential in sort of creating this shadow
- 10:02foreign policy. People refer to him as like the shadow
- 10:05Secretary of State, where he was like traveling around the
- 10:08world meeting with world leaders. And even though he didn't
- 10:12have an official US government position, he was the private
- 10:15lawyer for the president, and he was seen as sort
- 10:18of like the bagman for President Trump during that first term,
- 10:22and he had business interests. It wasn't just that he
- 10:25was like going around the world, you know, trying to
- 10:28you know, negotiate peace deals or anything like that. He
- 10:31was courting business from some of these very deep pocketed
- 10:35you know, foreign government officials, foreign oligarchs, while at the
- 10:39same time whispering in Trump's ear about issues that affected
- 10:43these you know, his his clients or his business partners
- 10:46in far flung parts of the world. So that I
- 10:49think was in many ways like a test, like maybe
- 10:53a more modest version of what we're seeing now where
- 10:56there are many more people in similar positions, sometimes closer
- 10:59to Trump. Family men members, Steve Witcoff's family members, Howard
- 11:03Lutnix family members who were who were doing things similar
- 11:06to what Rudy did, and they're and they're getting less pushback.
- 11:10I think the public is just sort of like a
- 11:12nerd to this, because you know, we saw these scandals
- 11:15during the first Trump administration visa VI foreign influence, and
- 11:19they didn't really amount to that much. I mean, the
- 11:21Mother investigation obviously had some impact, put some people in jail,
- 11:25including Paul Manniford, who was quite close to Trump, but
- 11:29they all got pardon and their back out, and they're
- 11:31doing some of the same stuff right now. And I
- 11:33think part of that is because of the sort of
- 11:36precedent that was set during the first administration by folks
- 11:39like Ruy Giuliani and others that you could blur the
- 11:42line between US foreign policy and private business interest.
- 11:46Speaker 1: What's really interesting about this is that it's very creative.
- 11:49It does require an entire team, an invisible team. You
- 11:52weren't elected to do this job. Chances are it's just
- 11:55because you know the person and you've come with a
- 11:56pretty good looking resume. But this, to me is very
- 11:59intriguing because it is still serving our nation in ways
- 12:02that some people look away. Other people think it's wrong,
- 12:06but it's still it's developing that solid foundation. That's the
- 12:09way I look at it. Am I wrong?
- 12:12Speaker 2: No? I mean I think there is like with the
- 12:14with the Middle East peace deal, like that that was
- 12:17like you know, if you're to take the word of
- 12:20Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, like that was facilitated in
- 12:24part because they had these relationships, these business relationships that
- 12:27pre data and were outside of their work and government.
- 12:31And like that's a positive result obviously that that, like
- 12:34that they were able to negotiate this ceasefire. But is
- 12:38it worth the like conflicts of interest that like we
- 12:41don't necessarily see and we don't know, uh sort of
- 12:44whose interest is ultimately being served on some of these
- 12:48other deals. Uh, you know, that's an open question. And
- 12:50to your first point about the president or you know,
- 12:53people in the administrations having like people around them who
- 12:57were able to claim some connection and that becomes quite marketable.
- 13:02You know. I think we saw that most acutely during
- 13:04the first Trump administration because like you know, this is
- 13:07the way that Washington works. There are there's like a
- 13:09profess a permanent professional class of lobbying firms and political
- 13:13consultants who serve as gatekeepers, and they do it from
- 13:17one administration to the next, and sometimes are the same
- 13:19people doing in a democratic and Republican administrations, even as
- 13:22they you know, take a side during the campaign and
- 13:26cast themselves as you know, party loyalists on one side
- 13:28or the other. When it comes to when it comes
- 13:31to the business, they're willing to they're willing to work
- 13:34with both sides. But Trump, during the first administration came
- 13:37into Washington. He was truly an outsider and didn't have
- 13:41connections to this permanent professional class. So what that did
- 13:45was created opportunities for new people to come in who
- 13:48had some sometimes fleeting connections to him. There's a guy
- 13:52right about in the book, Robert Strick, who is a
- 13:54good example of this. He he, you know, had assisted
- 13:57the twenty sixteen campaign, but he was no one's idea
- 14:00of an insider. But when Trump came in, suddenly there
- 14:03were these foreign interests who were like, oh my goodness,
- 14:05we were planning for President Hillary Clinton, and now we're
- 14:09like at a loss as to how to navigate the
- 14:12new Washington under Trump. And so people like this Robert
- 14:15Strick character got huge sums of money from the Saudis,
- 14:18from you know, the Bahraineys, from the Congolese to help
- 14:23them navigate this. And then also Trump brought in people
- 14:27who were not political insiders, but were you know, his
- 14:30associates from real estate or from the business world and
- 14:34entrusted them to serve in this capacity. And so, like,
- 14:38you know, that created a lot of handwringing among Democrats
- 14:41and critics, including Republican critics of Trump that he was
- 14:44like empowering his business buddies. But like, I don't know,
- 14:48I mean, ultimately, if it was so different than empowering
- 14:52lobbyists who had been you know, who had been in
- 14:55Washington for decades and we're you know, outside of government
- 14:58and given this huge power to sort of determine who
- 15:01got access to the president just because they raise money.
- 15:04It's just a different kind of soft corruption.
- 15:06Speaker 1: Wow, softening up things just a little bit here. One
- 15:08of my favorite parts inside a book is the dedication
- 15:11who is daniel and why is daniel your everything? Because
- 15:14you put it on the page, so therefore I would
- 15:17like to know so that when I go to that page,
- 15:19I can give daniel just as much love and attention.
- 15:23Speaker 2: Yeah, Danielle is my wife, and she was quite patient
- 15:28during this process. And I think I, you know, probably
- 15:31would be institutionalized if for some you know, breakdown, were
- 15:36it not for her and instead her dealing with all
- 15:39my stress. Maybe she's about to be institutionalized for you know,
- 15:42I'm pushing her to the break but she was incredibly
- 15:45supported throughout this process.
- 15:47Speaker 1: Well, I'll tell you one thing about this book, Kenneth,
- 15:48is the fact that it has made me Google you
- 15:51and to go on to chat GPT because you've got
- 15:54my attention so much that it's like I want to
- 15:56go and I want to figure out not just what
- 15:58you've written in the past, but everything you're going to
- 15:59write in the future. It's because I trust you, and
- 16:03it's because you are giving us something that we should
- 16:06think we know, we don't know, but we need to know.
- 16:09Speaker 2: Yeah, that's kind of you to say, I and certainly
- 16:11that was the goal here. I mean this is you know,
- 16:14the my background is I write about money and politics
- 16:18and have done so for many years, you know, at
- 16:20Politico and now at The New York Times. And you
- 16:23know that what had that had traditionally meant covering domestic
- 16:26money and politics, as we discussed like campaign donations, you know,
- 16:30domestic lobbying, nonprofit advocacy and the like. But I just
- 16:34increasingly saw that there were there was a lot of
- 16:37you know, that there was an increasing amount of foreign
- 16:40money that was coming into the process, and it was
- 16:42like creating a disproportionate number of like the scandals that
- 16:47were gripping our politics. But I didn't really have a
- 16:50clear understanding of like what was going on. Why were
- 16:52all these foreign interests willing to pay so much money
- 16:55to try to influence American politics and government. And as
- 16:59I started to to peck away at this and do
- 17:01the reporting, I realized that it stems apart from this
- 17:05mindset that is, you know, quite prevalent in other parts
- 17:08of the world, you know, the former Soviet World, the
- 17:13Middle East, Africa, that like the way that you get
- 17:16what you want from government is you essentially pay people
- 17:18in government or you pay their families. And I thought,
- 17:21you know, that's not really how it works in the US,
- 17:24Like we're we're better than that, We're different than that.
- 17:27And the more I reported, the more I realized, no,
- 17:30it's we're pretty similar in a lot of ways.
- 17:33Speaker 1: Please come back to this show anytime in the future.
- 17:35The door is always going to be open for you.
- 17:38Speaker 2: Thanks Er, I appreciate it.
- 17:39Speaker 1: Will you be brilliant today?
- 17:40Speaker 2: Okay yes, thank you you too,