Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Are Underpaid Compared to a New Hire
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, here's a scenario I keep hearing about in my inbox. You've been at a company for three years, you're solid, you get good reviews, and then one day you find out that the new hire sitting two desks away—someone with less experience than you—is making more money than you. How does that even happen? Luna: It happens more than you'd think. And honestly, the first reaction is usually not a calm one. Lucas: Right. It's visceral. You feel undercut. And the instinct is to go straight to your manager and say, 'This isn't fair.' But that's the one thing you shouldn't do. Today we're going to talk about how to turn that frustration into a strategic conversation. Luna: So what's the smart first move? Do you confront the new hire? Do you go to HR? What actually works? Lucas: First, you need to understand what you're dealing with. This is a classic case of pay compression. That's when the salary for new hires gets pushed up by the market—especially in a hot hiring environment—while the salaries of existing employees stay flat. By 2026, with inflation having been sticky and the job market still pretty competitive for certain roles, this is happening a lot. Luna: And it's not necessarily that your company is trying to screw you over. Sometimes it's just a side effect of how budgets work. They have to pay market rate to attract talent, but they don't automatically adjust your salary. Lucas: Exactly. So the first step is to get the data. Not just the number you heard from a colleague, but actual market data. Look at salary surveys for your role, your industry, and your geographic area. Check the Bureau of Labor Statistics, but also sites like Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, or even job postings for similar roles at other companies. If you can see that the market rate for your position is twenty percent above what you're making, you have a strong case. Luna: But what if you can't find exact numbers? Some roles are pretty niche. Lucas: Then you get creative. Look at job postings for roles that are similar in title and responsibilities. Sometimes they'll include a salary range. You can also talk to recruiters—not to get an offer, but just to ask, 'Hey, what's the range for a role like this?' as part of your networking. And if you're in a state with pay transparency laws, you might even be able to find salary data on public job boards. Luna: So you've got your market data. What's next? Do you go straight to your manager, or do you need to do something else first? Lucas: Before you even schedule the meeting, you need to document your own contributions. Write down three or four specific achievements from the past year. Think about a project you led, a problem you solved, or a metric you improved. The point is to show that you're not just asking for a raise because someone else makes more—you're asking because your performance and your market value both justify it. Luna: That makes sense. You're building a case, not making a complaint. Lucas: Exactly. So when you do have the conversation, you want to frame it around internal equity and market value. Start by saying something like, 'I've really enjoyed my time here and I'm proud of what I've accomplished. I've also been doing some research on the market, and I'm finding that my current salary is significantly below the market rate for someone with my experience and performance. I'd like to talk about how we can bring my compensation in line.' Luna: That's a good script. But what if your manager says, 'Well, we don't have the budget for that right now'? That's a common response. Lucas: Then you need to be prepared for that. You can say, 'I understand there are constraints, but we're hiring aggressively in this market, and I think it's important that we maintain internal equity. Could we look at a salary review as part of the next budgeting cycle?' And you should ask for a specific timeline. If they say 'maybe in six months,' get that in writing—even if it's just a follow-up email. Luna: So you're not just asking for a raise, you're asking for a process. Lucas: Right. And sometimes the best approach is to go to HR and ask for a pay band review. Companies often have salary bands for each role. If you can show that your pay is below the band, they might be able to adjust it without needing a special budget. I've seen that work even for mid-level employees, not just executives. Luna: That's a good point. I remember a story from a friend who works in tech—she found out that a new college grad was offered ten thousand dollars more than her starting salary, and she'd been there for two years. She was furious, but instead of storming into her boss's office, she did exactly what you're saying. She gathered data, documented her contributions, and asked for a pay band review. It took a couple of months, but she got a raise that brought her to the midpoint of her band. Lucas: That's a great example. And it shows that this approach can work even in a big company with lots of bureaucracy. But there's another piece to this: the emotional side. It's really hard not to feel resentful. You can't let that seep into the conversation. If you go in angry, you'll come off as entitled or difficult, and that will hurt your case. Luna: Yeah, I think that's one of the hardest parts. How do you keep your cool when you feel so wronged? Lucas: You remind yourself that this is not personal. It's a business decision. And you're there to make a business case. So you practice your talking points out loud. You run them by a friend or a mentor. You also need to be ready for the possibility that they say no. And that's okay—it's information. If they say no and you're truly below market, then you have a choice to make. Do you stay and hope things change, or do you start looking elsewhere? And the act of looking can give you leverage, but also clarity. Luna: So speaking of leverage, what if you do get an offer from another company? Do you bring that to your current employer? Lucas: That's a delicate move. You can do it, but you have to be prepared to walk. If you bring an offer just as a bluff, it can backfire. Better to do the market research and the internal equity conversation first. If that doesn't work, and you get a real offer, then you can say, 'I've received an offer from another company for X. I'd love to stay because I love working here, but I need to make a decision that's best for my family.' And even then, you should be genuinely willing to leave. Otherwise, you're negotiating in bad faith. Luna: That's solid advice. And speaking of negotiations, there's a whole psychology behind how you frame your ask. Right, Lucas? Lucas: Absolutely. One key thing is to anchor high but reasonable. If you want a ten percent raise, ask for fifteen. That gives you room to compromise. And don't just talk about your current salary—talk about the value you bring. Connect your contributions to the company's goals. For example, if you led a project that saved the company fifty thousand dollars, mention that. It's not bragging; it's evidence. Luna: I like that. Evidence, not emotion. Let's take a quick break here, but when we come back, I want to talk about what to do if your manager says yes, but the raise is smaller than you hoped. Lucas: We'll get to that. And also, a note for our listeners: if today's episode helped you think through a career move, consider supporting the show. It's the smallest ask imaginable—if it was worth a coffee to you, that's the link. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every little bit helps keep us ad-free. Anyway, back to the topic. Luna: Right, and that support really does matter. So, Lucas, what about the counteroffer—when they come back with a raise that's less than you wanted? How do you handle that? Lucas: That's a good question. First, you need to know your minimum number—the salary you'd be satisfied with. If they come in below that, you can push back with a counter. But if they come in close, sometimes it's worth accepting and then setting a review date. Say, 'I appreciate this adjustment. I'd like to revisit this in six months, based on my continued performance.' That keeps the conversation open. Luna: That's smart. You're not closing the door. You're building a relationship. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing: don't forget to say thank you. Whether you get the raise or not, a gracious response goes a long way. If you do get it, send a follow-up email thanking your manager and summarizing the agreed-upon changes. If you don't get it, thank them for their time and ask for specific steps you can take to get there in the future. That way, you leave the door open. Luna: So to sum up: do your research, document your wins, frame it as a business case, stay calm, and be prepared for any answer. Sounds like a plan. Lucas: And remember, you can't control the outcome, but you can control how you approach the conversation. Even if you don't get the raise this time, you've positioned yourself as someone who knows their worth and is professional about it. That alone can pay off down the line. Luna: I think that's a great note to end on. Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll catch you in the next episode. Lucas: Until next time, keep asking the questions that matter.