Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / PRIMITIVE: Care, Cruelty, Religion, & Reason in the Human Animal (with Dr. Robert Sapolsky)
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Robert Sepalski
- 0:58got a degree in by iological anthropology from Harvard. This was back in the
- 1:03late seventies, lived in Kenya for a while to study non human primates.
- 1:08Earned his doctorate in neuro intracrinology, which is hard for what the world is
- 1:15that? Can you just flesh it out for the rest of us, Well,
- 1:17it's without an r after the d so endo neuroendo chronology. It's studying
- 1:23the effects of the brain on hormones in the body and the effects of hormones
- 1:26on the brain. And that could be about for my money, totally boring
- 1:33stuff like how much you're in. Your kidneys are making or it could be
- 1:37all about behavior and psychological states and actions and so yeah, the body brain
- 1:45looping influences there, so you're not a dualist. The brain is the mind,
- 1:51The mind is the brain, the brain is the body. It's all
- 1:53one, yep. And there's no little knee sitting inside the brain that's made
- 1:57out of stuff other than brain cells. I was taught to as I was
- 2:02a believer for decades, a devout Christian, and I was taught to be
- 2:07afraid of people like you. I don't listen because they think you're just a
- 2:13monkey, right, they want to make a monkey out of you, literally,
- 2:16And I spent so long not understanding, but more than that being afraid.
- 2:22I was afraid to be even around these ideas because I might become infected
- 2:25with evolution. Are some people, from your perspective, more genetically biologically wired
- 2:34to believe in gods and monsters? You think I might have been more primed
- 2:38genetically to be and stay religious. Well, unfortunately, my guess is a
- 2:45good clean experiment was not done on you, which is to control for the
- 2:51family you were raised in, so to clone you and dump one version of
- 2:55you in the middle of some other culture clone. Another version could have spent
- 3:00nine months in a different womb, having a fetal environment that it so,
- 3:04I don't know if it's genes. The thing we say in the business is
- 3:08it's gene environment interaction. It's every biological factor environment interaction. So you can't
- 3:16tease them apart. But it's not by chance that you wound up being who
- 3:22you are, and that each of us did. Is that essentially nature nurture?
- 3:27Is that what we're talking about. Naw, because you don't really have
- 3:30to choose anymore, because each is interacting with the other. You got genes
- 3:35that change how sensitive you are to nurture. You've got so that at some
- 3:39point it doesn't make any sense to say, what does this gene do?
- 3:45What does it do in a particular environment? What does this environment do?
- 3:50Depends on your genetic makeup. Doctor John Wathe is a friend of mine.
- 3:53He's a computational neuroscientist. He wrote a book called the Illusion of God's Presence.
- 3:59I'm not going to do him justice, but I'm going to try to
- 4:01distill his point that we are born helpless and we require parental other to provide
- 4:10for our every need. When we get older. According to doctor Wrothy,
- 4:15there are certain things I don't know, triggers that cause those same responses in
- 4:21us as adults. And this may explain our desire to look up to a
- 4:27parental other in the heavens or elsewhere. When you hear something like that,
- 4:31is there anything to it? What do you think? Well, I think
- 4:34there's a lot to it. I would frame it much more broadly. We
- 4:39like all sorts of other primates don't like risk a whole lot. We don't
- 4:44like ambiguity, we don't like a lack of clarity. We don't like the
- 4:47possibilities that something happens and we will never know why it did. And anxiety
- 4:55makes us more that way. And we have an incredibly powerful human tendency to
- 5:00fill explanatory vacuums with explanations, no matter how dubious. And I think a
- 5:09great example of this is studies. You take subjects and you sit them down
- 5:14and you say how important is religion in your life? And you get whatever
- 5:17answers you get. And in contrast, if for twenty minutes before these people
- 5:23had been sitting trying to solve some like seduku puzzle or something that was unsolvable,
- 5:30it didn't have a solution. It was frustrating. All of that On
- 5:34the average people afterward rate themselves as being more religious. Uncertainty, novelty,
- 5:43ambiguity brings out a very desperate need in us for explanation, no matter how
- 5:48implausible. The explanation is that we latch onto because it's comforting. I know
- 5:55you've debated the late philosopher Daniel Dennett. He had said something and I made
- 6:00this note because I really wanted your take. He was talking about religion coming
- 6:03out of an idea. So a lightning strike takes place and I'm in,
- 6:11I'm out on the African Savannah, and I say, well, it was
- 6:14the tree God that made the strike happen. And so I begin to make
- 6:18that claim. Even those who disagree are talking about it. It becomes part
- 6:21of the milieu, right, It becomes embedded in the cultural conversation, and
- 6:26before you know it, there are Shamans and a mom's or whoever, and
- 6:30they're all talking about maybe they're preaching about the magical tree, that kind of
- 6:34thing. But he said that religion exists only for itself, like the common
- 6:40cold might exist only for itself. And I tend to think that religion was
- 6:46actually a bonding agent, a tribal bonding agent between non kin, meaning that
- 6:50it grouped us together even if we weren't direct relatives. It solved problems,
- 6:57it answered questions, filled blanks, alleviated fears, There was more utility.
- 7:00It didn't just exist for itself. And it's kind of a broad question.
- 7:04Do you have any thoughts about that? Yeah, I completely agree with that
- 7:09interpretation, and religion is a great social glue. Stated in more evolutionary terms,
- 7:16we have evolved to want to pass on as many copies of our own
- 7:21changes as possible. Some of the time we do that by cooperating with kin.
- 7:28Some of the time we do that by cooperating with non kin under sort
- 7:31of controlled circumstances of reciprocity. All of that, what does religion do.
- 7:36It induces something people in the business call a sense of pseudo kinship. You
- 7:43feel more related to people than you actually are, and that fosters cooperation,
- 7:48that fosters unity. What that often fosters is the flip side pseudospeciation. The
- 7:57thems are so different from us they hardly even count as human. And that's
- 8:01a very effective thing, great evolutionary biologist David Sloane Wilson, who has pushed
- 8:07for a very modern view of evolution playing out on lots of different levels.
- 8:13And he's got this wonderful book, Darwin's Cathedral, where he analyzed the emergence
- 8:18of Calvinist belief in Switzerland and a whole bunch of little religions were popping up
- 8:24at the time, and analyzed why they happened to be in the right place
- 8:28at the right time and the right sort of belief system to promote pseudo kinship
- 8:33to a more effective and they're the ones who want out, and to use
- 8:39an evolutionary metaphor, they drove the neighboring competing new religions into extinction. So
- 8:46yeah, it is a fantastic sort of mechanism for getting people to feel more
- 8:52connected to each other. We've been talking a lot about how I don't think
- 8:56most people attend religious services or are part of a really logen itself for reasons
- 9:01of theology. I tend to think they are there for reasons of community.
- 9:05I mean, they own the Bible, but they don't know what's in it.
- 9:09They know it's true, but they don't know what it says. Kind
- 9:11of thing but I think beyond that, it's more of like, I want
- 9:13to belong, I need a group, I need a tribe totally agree,
- 9:18and something like that has an upside. There's a long literature showing that religiosity
- 9:28can have some health benefits, and it takes a lot of work to tease
- 9:31out the fact that religious people usually are less likely to be abusing substances.
- 9:39More importantly, religious people typically get a social community, and that in and
- 9:43of itself is a wonderful source of health protection. You see the same benefit
- 9:48for atheists who find humanist groups to feel so that can have a plus side,
- 9:54that can have a downside, which is all sorts of studies showing you
- 9:58look at somebody from a religion with some tradition of extremest violent fundamentalism, like
- 10:07show me a religion that doesn't, and you try to look for the predictors
- 10:13of it, and studies that have been done show ooh, how much do
- 10:16you believe in God? That's not a predictor of like you're willing to become
- 10:20violently fundamentalist. How often do you pray? That's not a predictor? How
- 10:26devoutly do you prayer? How often do you go pray with a bunchier co
- 10:31religionists. That's the predictor how often do you go to the church, the
- 10:37mosque, the synagogue, Because that's a surrogate measure of how often are you
- 10:43in an echo chamber of people who were saying, yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 10:48we're special, we're better. They're animals, they don't count. So
- 10:52that I think is enormously informative of the potential toxicity of religious social support that
- 11:01one gets by being religious in grouping and outgrouping. Ryan, I guess the
- 11:07classic dilemma which brings me to the useful fiction claim that well, you know,
- 11:11it's even if it's not true. It bonds people together, It gives
- 11:15them a sense of purpose and hope. I mean, if we're looking at
- 11:18the sort of the bumper sticker version of it, they say religion is good
- 11:22for us even if it's not true. And I really struggle with that because
- 11:26was it bertrand Russoli said if it's true, we should believe it, and
- 11:28if it's not true, we should not. How do you approach the useful
- 11:33fiction angle when it comes to the benefits of religion, well, useful fictions
- 11:37religiosity and to a lesser extent spirituality. Religiosity, for example, is great
- 11:46at reducing anxiety. It provides answers in the face of life's terrifying unknowns,
- 11:52and exactly as we were talking about, we yearn for attribution at that point.
- 11:58So you find out who there is a purpose, or even better,
- 12:01there is a purpose, and it has something to do with people like you
- 12:07being better and even best of all, you being better and going through all
- 12:11those versions of that. But then the big problem is what religion is best
- 12:16at when it comes to decreasing anxiety is decreasing anxieties that religion invented in the
- 12:24first place. And what you see in terms of the kindnesses, the potential
- 12:31upside of religiosity and the power of faith. For my money, there's nothing
- 12:37more destructive when it turns out that faith turns out to be displaced. Having
- 12:43the carpet pulled out from under your feet does not constitute psychological well being.
- 12:48So they tell me I'm sick and then sell me the cure. You came
- 12:52out of orthodox Judaism and busted out of that mindset pretty early. You're a
- 12:58teenager, is that correct? Yeah? I was fourteen when I had a
- 13:03tumultuous night of storm and drown and decided there's no God and there's no free
- 13:09will in the universe. It's this big, empty and different place. And
- 13:13it's been smooth sailing ever since then. So yeah, I dumped all of
- 13:18that when I was about fourteen. Well, at least you got through the
- 13:22bar Mitzva where you got the presence, you got all the good yes,
- 13:24and then you had your epiphany. So when you say Orthodox, please forgive
- 13:28the stereotype. But we've done some talking about like the ultra Orthodox were you
- 13:33was your family that family where they're swinging the copper roat chickens over their heads
- 13:37and not pushing elevator buttons on the Sabbath and shit like that. I mean,
- 13:41was that the temperature or what close approximation of we were what's called modern
- 13:48Orthodox, which nonetheless has a lot of that. We had two sinks in
- 13:54the kitchen, one for meat, one for dairy, to refrigerators. If
- 13:58you screwed up and like infected a utensil with the wrong kind, you buried
- 14:03it in the backyard for months so that it would be purified. You sure
- 14:07did not do all sorts of things on Saturday that could be mistaken for work,
- 14:15so that whole song of dance and a whole ideology slash theology that went
- 14:20along with that. It's interesting, though, to see so many secular Jews
- 14:26talking about religion. I don't even call it a useful fiction in this case,
- 14:30because an increasing number of people who are Jewish, traditional Jewish people or
- 14:35cultural Jews. Rather they say, well, they're either not sure about God
- 14:37or they just don't buy it, but they love the culture. And I
- 14:41totally think that's great. We're creatures of ritual, are we not. I
- 14:45mean the music and the clothing and the structure of it all. There's benefit
- 14:50to that, absolutely, and I deeply resent that circumstances of cultural evolution and
- 14:58society or prejudices and all of that meant that the Renaissance had a whole lot
- 15:03more really amazing Christian composers than there were Jewish ones, so they got the
- 15:07much better music. But yeah, culture, a sense of belonging is very
- 15:13very powerful and very galvanizing, and there's a double edged sword for better or
- 15:20worse. But yeah, cultural aspects are great to bring along as long as
- 15:26they are well selected. People are often surprised to hear that I say,
- 15:31I support like if you want to have a secular religion, I mean,
- 15:35knock yourself out if you want to frame community in that way. One thing
- 15:39about religions, they have had a long time to come up with pretty effective
- 15:43models or frameworks for community yep. And not only because they've had lots of
- 15:48adherents so you get that many more good innovators and because just sheer numbers.
- 15:54But there's an oomph, there's an emotional umph. You you make up some
- 16:00silly wedding vows where you're citing I don't know, Nelson Mandela and Taylor Swift
- 16:07or something, and like that's great. But there's a power knowing that you're
- 16:12doing a ritual that your parents and grandparents and great grandparents all the way back
- 16:18we're doing and maybe even died in some cases for the freedom to do that.
- 16:23All Yeah, time gets a big power to it. Next up,
- 16:30I want to talk about cruelty, and I'm going to ask nero biologist doctor
- 16:34Robert Sepalski if some of us or some of them are just more biologically wired
- 16:42to be saysiopathic, narcissistic, and cruel to other people. Stand by talking
- 16:57here with nero biologists and nero endocrinologist. Wow, I said the word,
- 17:03Doctor Robert Sepolski. This is a hot button. You don't have to answer.
- 17:10I'm just going to toss it up there, Okay. So I came
- 17:14out of a I mean, I used to be that guy. I was
- 17:17the Fox News Christian of band Culter reading Glenn Beck listening, you know,
- 17:22pro death penalty and suck it up, love it or leave it America kind
- 17:26of guy. You know, that's pray the gay away guy. I was
- 17:32essentially a Reagan Conservative, okay, even in my youth. And when I
- 17:36left Christianity, I went through a long reevaluation, Well what are my values?
- 17:41How do I feel about things like drugs and the death penalty and immigration
- 17:45and the rest of the world and American exceptionalism, etc. And I came
- 17:48out the other end, and I was struck by how cruel many of my
- 17:55previews, or at least myopic but inadvertently cruel sometimes positions were when I was
- 18:03a devout, hardcore right winger. So I myself see American conservatism, at
- 18:11least the frontline Republican Party right now, as kind of the culture of the
- 18:15cruel. You want to touch that at all, Doctor Sepalski. Yeah,
- 18:19the way I would reframe it is it's the culture of people who have gotten
- 18:26a certain type of shitty deal in life. I mean, there's among like
- 18:30snotty elitists, academic types who love evolution all that, there's like, ooh,
- 18:37look at the parts of the United States where people don't believe in evolution.
- 18:41It's the American South and fundamentalism and like yahooism and the temptation instead of
- 18:48saying cruel in this case, just not educated and not critical thinking all of
- 18:55that. And I think far more importantly, you look at that part of
- 18:59the United States, and that's the part that's been most screwed over in lots
- 19:03of ways, with the worst healthcare and the most toxic mining going on and
- 19:11the most That's a part of the country of people who have gotten a pretty
- 19:15crummy deal. And it's not surprising that an anger at them's is one consequence.
- 19:25Is not surprising that a totally distortive sense that things used to be better
- 19:30when we were the culture that dominated the country comes to the forefront. And
- 19:34it's not at all surprising that a pretty stoic, insular, unempathic version of
- 19:42explaining the unexplainables and life pops out the other side as well. Catherine Stewart,
- 19:48journalist and author friend of mine, calls it the knowledge economy. There
- 19:52are simply some people who have not benefited from the knowledge economy. Would you
- 19:59phrase it that way? Then they just simply haven't been given the resources and
- 20:03they were kind of given a raw deal. Yeah. All the above,
- 20:07horrible leadership and many circumstances, although I don't know a northern state like Illinois
- 20:15has a proud tradition of sending its governors to prison for horrible leadership. But
- 20:21nonetheless, the American South, the cultural things that got people there led to
- 20:26a certain elevated rate of violence that is endemic to the South. The culture
- 20:30of honor, where the people came from and what their backgrounds were in the
- 20:34British Isles when first being settled set things up for that. The fact that
- 20:41the South stumbled onto a collectivist type of crop, cotton, which instead of
- 20:48solving it with collectivism, they solved it with slavery has made that a world
- 20:53that is still trying to recover from its original sin and probably never will.
- 21:00Yeah, just all sorts of things that set things up so that certain types
- 21:06of explanations, even if they're nonsensical, and even if they are angry and
- 21:11exclusionary and vengeful, can provide comfort if you've been challenged in certain ways.
- 21:18Yeah, but not to be labor this speaking to primates. Isn't some of
- 21:23this just primitive. It's easier to hate than it is to love. It's
- 21:27easier to lash out and tear down than it is to build. This idea
- 21:32that I want the world to look like me because I'm a person of great
- 21:36insecurity and I need validation. There's a lot of stuff there that's just you
- 21:40know, I don't necessarily in my mind think, well you got the shaft.
- 21:44Sometimes I think you're just a terrible person. But maybe I'm not giving
- 21:49them enough credit, or at least giving the story of their lives, their
- 21:52backstory enough credence. I don't know. Well, my gut certainly pulls in
- 21:59that direction very readily. And I've got no shortage of people who challenge my
- 22:03personal rule that it makes no sense to hate anyone. But people become who
- 22:10they are for reasons of that. No one winds up being you know,
- 22:15mother Teresa, love her or not? By chance, nobody nobody winds up
- 22:21being Vladimir Putin by chance. There's no such thing as someone who is just
- 22:27happens to be a rotten, damaging human or one who just happens to be
- 22:32a wonderfully empathic, you know one. We're just the end products of circumstances
- 22:38that made us who we are. For those who are listening to the audio
- 22:42version, doctor Sapolski's dog, I'm a dog lover as well, and mind
- 22:47will bark in any moment whenever someone's outside. But if you hear the rattling
- 22:52of the leash, it is doctor Sepolski's not wearing chains or anything like that.
- 22:56I just know it sounds that way, just psychic ones. Let's talk
- 23:00about political party, since we're in this realm. Is it true that conservatives
- 23:07have a lower threshold for disgust? Is it true that those who are liberal
- 23:14are more empathetic? Or is that just a lie I tell myself because I
- 23:18want to feel superior. Oh, it's a mixture of both. The discussed
- 23:22threshold thing. I love that finding so first off, disgusting things, viscerally
- 23:30disgusting things discust us and make us recoil and make us overgeneralize what it is
- 23:40that's making us recoil. And fantastic study showing this. You sit somebody down
- 23:45and they fill out a whole questionnaire about their political views, their social politics,
- 23:49their geopolitical, they're economic, whatever, and you see on the average
- 23:55how people answer these questions. And if instead the person was sitting in a
- 23:59room boom were unbeknownst to them, there was a completely disgusting smell in the
- 24:04room. People become more socially conservative, does nothing to your economic views,
- 24:11nothing to your geopolitical people sit there and they become more likely to say,
- 24:18oh, when those people do something that's different, it's not just different,
- 24:23it's disgusting. It's wrong, wrong, wrong. And you find, for
- 24:29example, that across the political spectrum, when people are made disgusted by stuff,
- 24:34they become more hostile to immigration, or become more hostile to gay marriage.
- 24:41Back when these studies were being done, that sort of thing. So
- 24:44right off the bat, discust is this fabulous stepping stone from sensory disgust to
- 24:52moral disgusted, emotional discuss, economic, ideological, all of that. So
- 24:59that's sort of a backdrop with all of us. But what you see layered
- 25:03on top is on the average and these are just statistical blah blah blah.
- 25:07On the average, social conservatives have a lower threshold for disgust than do social
- 25:15progressives. What's this about? What's this about? Genes, environment, fetal
- 25:21whatever? You know, however you turned out to be. But show pictures
- 25:26to people of like festering wounds, crawling with maggots and things like that.
- 25:32On the average social conservatives stomachs lurch more than the average social progressive. On
- 25:40the average, social conservatives have more cleaning products in their home, are more
- 25:45averse to all sorts of churmish sort of things. And what's that about?
- 25:52Jonathan Height New York University has done some wonderful research on sort of the psychological
- 25:57structure of progressive versus conservative mindsets and purity, cleanliness, all of that is
- 26:07a much more emotionally salient thing in the lives of your average social conservatives and
- 26:14social progressives. Ha Did they become that way because of genes and hormones and
- 26:19environment and culture and all that sort of thing. But once you look at
- 26:23the world, and it is way easier to decide that there is disgusting stuff
- 26:29out there, It is way easier to decide that those people are disgusting when
- 26:33they do that, and in much the same way, for whatever genetic,
- 26:38environmental, cultural, et cetera reasons, you wind up being somebody for whom
- 26:45ambiguity is frightening. You wind up being a social conservative. If the future
- 26:52is an exciting place, that's one thing. If the future is terrifying because
- 26:56it's unknown, you spend a lot of time thinking about how wherever you are
- 27:02needs to be made great again because it used to be wonderful. And I
- 27:07think that's where the roots of it are. So yes, on the average,
- 27:11in the realm of social political issues, on the average, social conservatives
- 27:15are have a lower threshold for disgust than do social progresses. And I think
- 27:19that is so cool and interesting. I used to be that guy. I
- 27:26was proud of an accident of birth, and I'm proud to be American,
- 27:29even though it was really out of my hands and I hadn't even qualified it,
- 27:33Like where do we land in terms of cost of living, in crime
- 27:37rate and who's the most warlike and quality of our healthcare? And I actually
- 27:41wrote about this a few years ago. I was just so absolutely cocooned here
- 27:47in hashtag America. But as I spiraled out of right wing evangelicalism. I
- 27:52more and more saw myself as citizen of the world. I guess that's kind
- 27:56of common right as we see us all the human primates, across the color
- 28:02culture, across borders. That's common, correct, Yeah, And I think
- 28:06that provides one of the great sort of thought experiments for seeing or just the
- 28:12end product of stuff that came before that we had no control over. You
- 28:17look at first generation immigrants on one or you look at people who were just
- 28:22a couple of generations in my wife, and you see kind of where randomness
- 28:29came in her folks got off the boat at Ellis Island and they had enough
- 28:34money to get on a train that took them all the way out to Iowa
- 28:37until they ran out of money, and they became like commie leftist cattle ranchers.
- 28:44And if they had run out of money sooner, they would have wound
- 28:47up in Philadelphia, they would have wound up in the Lower East Side,
- 28:51and completely different cultures with that. With my parents and grandparents' generation. If
- 28:57it's some juncture or some border guard had demanded their identity papers which had been
- 29:04forged to get out of there, or something, they wouldn't have gotten and
- 29:08I could have spent my whole life instead growing up thinking that like Vladimir Putin
- 29:12was a cool guy, and those Ukrainians are all neo Nazis who were threatening.
- 29:18Just by the randomness of like who got on the boat, which boat
- 29:22didn't sink, who was granted asylum, who inherited the family's wealth, and
- 29:30who was the second son who decided to pick up and try the new world,
- 29:34you wind up having completely different views. If somebody had missed a train
- 29:38connection back when I would have been like a Putin enthusiast or who knows what.
- 29:45Yeah, you get something like that and you realize it's just the randomness
- 29:51of circumstance, environmental and biological. I'd read that travel is one of the
- 29:57great q for bigotry, meeting other people, integrating with other cultures, as
- 30:04long as you're not going there with the intent of missionizing them into being second
- 30:11class aversions of us. And doesn't take a whole lot of looking at the
- 30:15history of colonialism to see that that was one big thread of it. But
- 30:21yeah, the more different things you see in the world, the more you
- 30:25realize there's different ways of doing things, and the more you realize that nonetheless,
- 30:30like people in general love their kids and get googly eyed over puppies and
- 30:41like being tickled, and the commonalities. Their wonderful work by this historian of
- 30:45science, Frank Sulloway, looking at like the last five hundred years history of
- 30:49science, scientific controversies as the Earth around or not do the continents move?
- 30:57Is their evolutions for notology for real, and looking at all of the scientific
- 31:03players in it, doing lots of research on their family histories and stuff,
- 31:07trying to predict who were going to be the intellectual radicals who embraced this new
- 31:14whatever, and who would go to their graves saying this couldn't possibly be.
- 31:17And there were a bunch of predictors. If you hated your father, you
- 31:22were going to wind up being an intellectual radical. If you thought it was
- 31:26a great guy, much the opposite, if you were in first born,
- 31:30and all sorts of other predictors. And along with that was if you traveled
- 31:36a lot outside your culture while growing up, you were far more likely to
- 31:41wind up being one of the intellectual radicals. You could virtually divide the world
- 31:45of mid nineteenth century naturalists into the ones who had gone to someplace very exotic,
- 31:52versus the ones who left their office in Oxford to go look at the
- 31:56little birdies and the bushes outside and predict who embraced evolution and who didn't.
- 32:02So yeah, that's a big predictor. I was at a convention in Toronto
- 32:08years ago and there was a debate. It was the scientists and the philosophers.
- 32:14And before the first half hour was up, one of the scientists was
- 32:17so frustrated he crawled on top of the He crawled on top of the table
- 32:22and he was banging his fist at the philosopher. He was so angry.
- 32:28And it's interesting to see this tug of war. I don't know the answer
- 32:31to the are all questions scientific questions? Does philosophy is? It? Is
- 32:37philosophy science? And how do you even start that conversation? Oh good,
- 32:43I'm going to fall into terrible sort of hegemony here. Everything we do,
- 32:49from like our noses twitching, to the esthetics we invent in the cultures we're
- 32:55there, is the product of like the brains carry around and brains are made
- 33:01of biological yuck, and like, you know, no matter what type of
- 33:07philosophy you wind up espousing and the polls show about ninety percent of philosophers firmly
- 33:14believe in it's both the material world and somehow that's compatible with their being free
- 33:19will and holding people responsible for their actions for whatever reasons. That's the kind
- 33:24of brain you wound up having, and that's how you got there. So
- 33:30philosophy is yet another manifestation of our lives as biological organisms. You speak a
- 33:37little like a philosopher to me. You've got that kind of storytelling aspect of
- 33:42the philosopher. I'm not that's an insult or a compliment. Well, reading
- 33:49some of their stuff, I can only be deeply insulted. But I wish
- 33:52there had been more more anecdotes along the way there, you know it was.
- 33:58I mean, are all question scientific questions? Because I tend to lean
- 34:02that direction. Well, depends on what kind of science I was recently rereading.
- 34:09Stephen J. Gould had this essay gool was agnostic and left leaning and
- 34:16all of that palaeontologists and this famous essay that he called non Overlapping Magisteria,
- 34:24in which he made the argument that why can't we all just get along and
- 34:29like there's room for both science and religion because they're interested in non overlapping areas
- 34:37of inquiry, and that's totally wonderful if you're the type of scientist where what
- 34:43you care about is like the evolution of snail shells, which is a lot
- 34:46of what Gould did. On the other hand, if you're the kind of
- 34:50scientist who tries to understand the neural basis of violence, or the neural basis
- 34:57of mental illness, or the neural basis of kids getting brain cancers and any
- 35:02of those horrible those are not non overlapping areas of inquiry. What you're doing
- 35:09is like you were studying the science of why some awful, awful things happen
- 35:15and how insisting that it's a completely separate domain to say that there are transcendent
- 35:22forces who did that and for good reasons that we may not know. There's
- 35:27no room for both. So in those realms of science, if you study
- 35:31any of the awful areas that biology take you to, which is like saying
- 35:37the nature of life and Latin, you can't have that and room for religion
- 35:42as well, they're incompatible. In the last segment of our show, I've
- 35:46got a special surprise guest joining myself and doctor Robert Sepalski. I'm not going
- 35:53to tell you who it is, but she's a primatologist and these two have
- 35:59a lot in common. We'll do it next. I am so honored to
- 36:08be speaking this week with Stanford University professor and neurobiologist, doctor Robert Sepulski.
- 36:19Free will, Okay, fine, the philosophers say, I have agency,
- 36:24I can choose at some point, I can get involved, I can be
- 36:29an interventionist. And yet I also my brain is doing what it does at
- 36:36such a speed and in such a way that it's sort of predetermined. I'm
- 36:40just realizing what I'm doing. So can you sort of spell it out in
- 36:45small words, you know, with crayons and language that a guy like me
- 36:49can understand your approach to free will? Sir, Well, first off,
- 36:53there's a tiny subset of philosophers who are incompatibilists. They say, you can't
- 37:00have free will and our understanding of how the universe works. They don't go
- 37:04together. They're not compatible, but they are way out on the lunatic fringe,
- 37:08which is where I am as well. But yeah, the majority of
- 37:12philosophers say, yes, yes, yes, the world is made out of
- 37:15atoms and there's such a thing as biology. But somehow, somehow that's compatible
- 37:22with us being agents and masters of our own actions and thus appropriately held responsible
- 37:29for things. And I think that's gibberish, and it's gibberish. Well,
- 37:35so many people believe it because it's often a drag to think otherwise. But
- 37:39it's gibberish because people get pulled into looking in the wrong place for free will.
- 37:46You sit there and you got to make a decision what flavor ice cream
- 37:51are you going to get? Or a decision like are you going to pull
- 37:54this trigger or not? And you form an intent what you're going to do.
- 38:00You're conscious of what your intent is. You've got a pretty good guess
- 38:05what the consequence will be. Most importantly, you know you're not being forced
- 38:08to do this. There are alternatives available for you and for most people,
- 38:14and for our criminal justice system. That's necessary and sufficient to show there was
- 38:19free will. And there's a whole world of people who have been debating with
- 38:23really elegant experiments trying to locate when exactly does your brain form an intent and
- 38:30when are you consciously aware of it? And that's great, but none of
- 38:35that has to do with free will. Because as you sit there and you
- 38:40have this intent, and you know that you have it, and you know
- 38:44that you don't have to act on it, there's alternatives available to you.
- 38:47None of that asks the only question you can ask, which is, so,
- 38:52how did you turn out to be the sort of person who would have
- 38:57that intent in that place and time? And when you look at how you
- 39:00turned out to be that sort of person, your brain one second ago,
- 39:05your hormones this morning, your environment for decades, how you were raised,
- 39:09your fetal stressors, your genes, your call. When you look at that,
- 39:15none of us had any control over how we turned out to be the
- 39:19sort of person who would have the intents that we have, who would have
- 39:22the wishes that we have, who would have the extent of willpower. You
- 39:28can't will yourself to have more willpower, You can't successfully wish to wish for
- 39:34something different than what you wish for. And when you look at sort of
- 39:37the mechanics of how we become who we turned out to be, that's where
- 39:43you see there's no room for free will there. All we are is the
- 39:47end products of our biological histories interacting with our environmental histories, over which we
- 39:54had no control. Well, if that's the case, I'll play devil's advocate
- 40:00or apologist, often religious apologists. Then how could you ever chastise or punish
- 40:05the child for stealing the candy out of the store. How could you ever
- 40:08jail a murderer if it was never their choice? Well, miss, where
- 40:13we get into some really thin ice, because if you follow through the logical
- 40:17implications of this, blaming and punishing anybody ever as a virtue in and of
- 40:25itself, is not only intellectually insupportable, it's ethically insupportable. Likewise, praising
- 40:34and rewarding anybody because that's virtuous to do, that makes no sense either because
- 40:39nobody earned anything. None of us had any control over who we became.
- 40:45None of us are entitled to any more or less consideration than anybody else.
- 40:50And amid that, yeah, punishment and reward can be very good instrumental tools,
- 40:57and that could be very effective at shaping behavior now and then, And
- 41:00certainly some of that goes into child rearing, and some of that goes into
- 41:05every aspect of our behavior. But the notion that any sort of justice is
- 41:10being served when you punish someone for behaviors they had no control over or reward
- 41:15someone else for behaviors they had no control over. It is just the morally
- 41:20unacceptable world. Oh my god, people have conniptions at this point. You're
- 41:24just gonna have murderers running around on the streets. Obviously not. I mean
- 41:29that was my first I found myself literally sitting forward going, wait a minute,
- 41:34do we not imprison the person who is a murderer or potential or you
- 41:39know, who may murder again, or you know, for the protections of
- 41:43society. There's so many layers to that onion. But what someone hears on
- 41:46the surface is well, hey, it wasn't their fault, so eh,
- 41:51whatever, that's not what you're saying. No, you've got to protect people
- 41:58from damaging individuals, regardless of the fact that people become damaging because they were
- 42:04damaged. You've got to protect society from it. But you do it in
- 42:07a way where you subtract free will, you subtract blame, you subtract volition,
- 42:14you subtract rotten souls out of the whole equation. Oh my god,
- 42:19that's so difficult. You know, it's a quarantine model. Someone becomes dangerous,
- 42:25you quarantine them so they can't harm other people. You quarantine them the
- 42:30absolute minimum and not an inch more than that, and you don't moralize at
- 42:35them about how they're a bad person for needing to be quarantined, and you
- 42:37protect society from that. Whow that is like so impract We do it all
- 42:44the time. We do it. You got an airline pilot who has hay
- 42:47fever and they're taking antihistamines and as a result, they're drowsy, and the
- 42:52law is something like, if you're a pilot and you've taken antihistamines, you
- 42:58can't fly for three days because you're dangerous. You've got to protect people from
- 43:02drowsy pilots, not because they have rotten souls and want to hurt somebody.
- 43:07But you quarantine them. You can't fly, but you can do whatever else
- 43:13you want, and it's not your fault that you got sneezing in that.
- 43:17And we do that in all sorts of settings where we can't protect society from
- 43:22individuals who were capable of being damaging through no control of their own without invoking
- 43:30culpability. And here's one with a great historical precedent to it. You get
- 43:37some person, middle aged person driving along and from out of nowhere, with
- 43:43no prior history whatsoever. They have a grandma seizure and they lose control of
- 43:47the vehicle and they strike and kill someone in the process. And this is
- 43:52totally heartbreaking and tragic. But we do not sit there and say, oh,
- 43:59they evillly decided to have a seizure and lose control of the car.
- 44:02They could have prevented it. No, of course we don't say that.
- 44:07And people used to say that throughout all of European history, seizures were associated
- 44:13with demonic possession and people burned at the stake. No, we don't blame
- 44:17somebody. It's incredibly crappy luck that this person had a seizure from out of
- 44:22nowhere all. But we got to protect society. We use a quarantine model,
- 44:28and every state in the country has a law. They vary in terms
- 44:31of the length of how long do you need to be seizure free on the
- 44:36right meds in order to be able to drive again. Not because the person
- 44:39is sleeping with Satan, but they got like screwed up potassium channels in their
- 44:45head and it's not their fault, but we got to protect society from them,
- 44:50and we can do that now, And that would have been unthinkable to
- 44:53somebody four hundred years ago, where if somebody had a seizure and then the
- 44:58process like you know, flung their arms around and bopped you on the head,
- 45:02obviously they and their buddy Satan were working with intentionality. It would have
- 45:07been inconceivable then to have a mindset of saying, oh, it's a neurological
- 45:13disease. It isn't the person's fault. We need to do more research to
- 45:15know how to prevent it. But we got to make sure they're not driving
- 45:20if there was a chance of them having a seizure. And that's easy for
- 45:23us now. And all we have to do is extrapolate and know that there
- 45:29are things where we're sitting right now, and it's intuitively obvious that some people
- 45:34are rotten, mean people, and other people are kind and all of that,
- 45:38and like people can be who they want to be kind of stuff.
- 45:44To know that four hundred years from now or forty years from now or whatever
- 45:49will be looking back and saying, oh my god, I can't believe they
- 45:52used to think that one's capacity for empathy was a product of free will.
- 45:58Here's the biology of it, and we and our judgments will seem just as
- 46:02primitive as people who were saying epilepsy is a sign of demonic possession. And
- 46:07in those cases, yeah, there's no blame, there's no praise, there's
- 46:13no special treatment, there's no sense of entitlement, there's no such thing as
- 46:16justice being served. But nonetheless, you've got to have a society which dangerous
- 46:22people can't damage people, and where you foster people with the capacity to do
- 46:27tough, really useful things and motivate them to do it. All about your
- 46:30inbox is a fun place. Right now, there are people who've climbed on
- 46:36a table and they're banging their fists on the top toward you right now.
- 46:39I'm just going to let them and you have it out right now. Before
- 46:43I let you go, if I may, I want to bring in a
- 46:45friend of mine who is a palaeontologist. Her name is Erica. She runs
- 46:50the Gutsick Given Channel. She is one of the smartest people I've ever met,
- 46:53and she is a fan of yours, and so I wanted to just
- 46:57bring her in for a quick introduction and see if she had a question or
- 47:00comment for you. Erica, good to see you, Welcome, Hey Seth,
- 47:04Hi doctor Sapolski. It's a pleasure to be here. I'm sorry to
- 47:07kind of crash the interview, but gush. When I found out that Seth
- 47:10was interviewing you, I was like, oh my gosh. You know,
- 47:13you've been such a large inspiration to me for so long. I was like,
- 47:16I'm simply going to have to ask for just to drop in and pester
- 47:21you for a moment. So I'm coming at this more from the I'll give
- 47:25you my background, my master's degree I got in primatology out at Roehampton over
- 47:31there and in London, and I'm currently a third year PhD student in biological
- 47:37anthropology, so I'm on the morphology side of things. I study like Miocene
- 47:40apes and things of that nature, but I sort of come from the school
- 47:44of behavioral ecology and living primates, so you know, your work on the
- 47:47primatology side of things I found to be supremely inspiring and I really enjoyed.
- 47:52I actually I haven't read your book on I believe it's called Determined, but
- 47:57I've finished to behave this past Christmas, and I really enjoy So I'm going
- 48:00to sort of ask a question that might not be expected. That's a bit
- 48:05divergent from what you guys have been talking about with the free will stuff.
- 48:07And I'd just like to hear your favorite anecdote throughout the years of your studies
- 48:13regarding some of our closest living relatives. Well, let's see a number of
- 48:19them. A number were completely disastrous, Darty, he's attempting to anesthetize some
- 48:23of the baboons. Probably the most exquisite moment I ever had in my thirty
- 48:30three seasons of hanging out with these baboons was one with my wife who came
- 48:37out and studied the baboons, also did her thesis on them. And we
- 48:40had this incredibly ancient guy on the troop who was the last one for my
- 48:46original population in the late nineteen seventies. I'd always liked him. He was
- 48:52this gentle old guy. He was a gentle young guy back when he as
- 48:58far as we can tell, he was like probably half blind at that point.
- 49:01The kids, the infants hassled him because he was at the back of
- 49:06every progression. We were sure he was. He had picked off by hyenas,
- 49:09and like very very tentatively, we darted him. We anesthetized him,
- 49:15which is what some of the work was with all the babboons in the troop
- 49:20and did a work up on him to see how his body was doing.
- 49:22And when he woke up, you know, you put him in a holding
- 49:27cage and then you open up the door and every babboon on Earth runs out
- 49:30of there, barking and threatening and tear assing out of whatever this and we
- 49:37did it for him, and he walked out slowly, and he took a
- 49:40few steps and he sat down, and we did something that breaks all the
- 49:45rules of like field primatology. We sat down next to him and we all
- 49:51sat there for a while and we broke even more rules. We had these
- 49:55like little Kenya there called Malaika biscuits in Swahili Malika is angel, these little
- 50:02angel biscuits and which are like cookies, shortbread cookie, and we gave him
- 50:08a piece and we had some and just sitting there like watching the zebras and
- 50:15watching the clouds with this guy who had been around, you know, for
- 50:22twenty years from when things started with them. This was like a moment to
- 50:28die for, even though we were breaking all the Starship Enterprise rules of how
- 50:34you're supposed to be a primatologist. So that was just an exquisite moment,
- 50:39Doctor Sapalski, you did a lot of work with baboons living among them.
- 50:45When I say it that way, it sounds like you're like climbing in the
- 50:46tree and you're actually part of the you know, the troop. But can
- 50:51you just in just in a moment, tell everybody kind of what your background
- 50:54is in this area of your workplace. Yeah, I've kind of us laid
- 51:00back and forth between two fields as a lab neurobiologist to feel primatologist. The
- 51:05common theme has been understanding stress in the lab. What are the effects of
- 51:09stress on the brain, What do particular stress hormones do molecular biology of that,
- 51:15can you genetically engineer neurons to be more resistant to stress? Blah blah,
- 51:21all of that out With my baboons, it was looking at these socially
- 51:24complicated beasts with these really really challenging stressfully challenging societies and stuff, and figuring
- 51:34out whose bodies dealt better with stress than others, Who have the rotten choluster
- 51:38levels, who had the bad blood pressure, all of that, and what
- 51:42does that have to do with their social rank, their patterns of social affiliation,
- 51:47their personality, which is a totally legit term for other primates, and
- 51:53that's what the darting was about, monitoring their bodies. Wow, what's that?
- 52:00That is our national geographic clock. Each hour on the hour makes a
- 52:07different animal sound. Because I was like, wow, he brought one of
- 52:12them back right in Africa. Our kids grew up with that and it is
- 52:16as did our dogs. And it's amazing when we have like somebody over and
- 52:20we're all just sitting there and like suddenly they hear like some Hyaena cackle or
- 52:24something and we don't respond. The dogs don't look up. Did they just
- 52:30hallucinate that sound because we're habituated to it? So, yes, that's our
- 52:34national geographic I would think it'd be a social experiment. You're actually watching their
- 52:37reaction as if they're in the wild kind of thing. Yes, then we
- 52:40take urine samples. Erica, did you have anything else for doctor Sepalski before
- 52:45we call it? I just want to make sure you've got a few minutes
- 52:47with it. No, gosh, No, that was that was phenomenal to
- 52:51hear. I you know, I've done work in Kenya. I go every
- 52:53summer and do and collect fossils over there in West Kenya kind of off in
- 52:59the Coreer region, and then you know, it's interesting to hear the softer
- 53:01side of baboons because you know, for us out there, when the baboons
- 53:05crossed the hill and they're curious about you, it's quite intimidating to see,
- 53:07you know, a group of a large group of dozens of Bao boons,
- 53:10especially the males, hearing them coming with that barking sound. You know,
- 53:14I prefer the vervets because there's so much you know, more docile comparatively,
- 53:17although they're really naughty. Doctor Sipalski, though, wasn't there a story that
- 53:22you had told that you were studying a troop of baboons and they got tuberculosis
- 53:30and you disappeared and left that work for a decade, came back and there
- 53:34was a noticeable change and their behavior. They were more docile, more cooperative.
- 53:39Did I read that right? Yeah? It was a very rare,
- 53:45artificial, unlikely circumstance having to do with the presence of humans. Were a
- 53:52wound up. Half the males in the troop died of tuberculosis, and it
- 53:55wasn't random which half. It was. The males who were most aggressive and
- 54:00least socially affiliated. And this left you with a troop that was female dominated
- 54:07and much nicer. Male baboons left there and they developed and this is an
- 54:13okay word to use, they developed a social culture that had much less aggression,
- 54:19much more social affiliation. Males did not displace aggression onto females when they
- 54:22were in a bad mood. And the most amazing thing was, as you
- 54:27said, I gave up on that troop after that and didn't look at them
- 54:30for a decade. But coming back, yeah, they were still like that,
- 54:34but it was new males. By then. Male baboons grow up someplace
- 54:38else, leave their home troop at puberty, and transfer into this new one.
- 54:45And over this decade they were being repopulated by young, jerk male baboons
- 54:51who had grown up out into the big, bad, normal baboon world.
- 54:55And they showed up and somehow it took about six months for them to learn
- 55:00we don't do stuff like that here. And I did a ton of work
- 55:05trying to figure out what was the mechanism for the cultural transmission in them.
- 55:08So that said, nonetheless, they were still scary. I do not love
- 55:13baboons. They're skeevy, backstabbing guys, and that's why they're good for studying
- 55:19psychological stress. But this particular I was wonderful when I read the story.
- 55:24I must have read it wrong because I was thinking you had left and there
- 55:27hadn't been direct contact, and they all had done philosophy or something. They
- 55:31all sat around the base. They had a meeting and thought, well,
- 55:35let's become more civilized. It is time for us to evolve to a high
- 55:37irrationalon of Babboon. But that's not what happened. That was kind of a
- 55:42one off because of human intervention. Go ahead with Erica. I'm so curious
- 55:47because I remember that anecdote as well, and I thought that was so fascinating
- 55:51because you know, in paluinthropology there's this big question in parapharmatology as well,
- 55:54like was a common ancestor of humans in chipanzees more chimp like or more human
- 55:59like, and they have these disparate social systems, one being more female dominant
- 56:04or co dominant, and the other being more male dominated, and they're just
- 56:07separated by this one river. It makes you wonder. I remember reading that
- 56:09and thinking of myself, I wonder if something similar happened in the common ancestor
- 56:13of the Panins, where you got perhaps this more violent, more linear,
- 56:16dominance, hierarchy oriented group of Panin that for whatever reason, they see the
- 56:22more aggressive individuals kind of cult from the group, and then they end up
- 56:27with this sort of female structure to it, more co dominant structure. I
- 56:30guess I should say to it, but I think that's so fascinating. Dig
- 56:34just all over and it's speculative. Yeah. That or ecological models where you
- 56:38have very very dispersed resources, so you can't get big territorial troops, you
- 56:44can't get males dominating a whole bunch of females. Yeah, all stories of
- 56:49different routes by which you get that. I could just leave you too in
- 56:52a room and probably go on vacation, but I'm going to I'd hold him
- 56:57captive of conversation I've got so I could just ask him questions. You got
- 57:00to cout me off. I was thinking forty five minutes, but I've just
- 57:02I just can't couldn't let him go. So we've we hit the hour mark.
- 57:07By the way, we were talking about his dog. This is my
- 57:09This is Linus. He is a descendant of the wolf, and so he
- 57:15sits with me occasionally when we are doing the hard work of pointing and clicking
- 57:20here, but Eric is always good to see you, and doctor Sapalski,
- 57:22you are such a good educator and you're such a wonderful communicator storyteller. I've
- 57:27got your lectures up here this week as I was prepping for the interview listening
- 57:30again, and I'm just struck by how good a science communicator you are.
- 57:34You know, it's one thing to have the data, which I think there's
- 57:37so much good data, but to have somebody who communicates it in the way
- 57:40that you do, that's just rare, and it's it's really exceptional. So
- 57:44thank you for your work, and thanks for being here. Thank you,
- 57:46thanks for having me on. Follow The Thanking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for
- 57:52a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring
- 57:55the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on
- 58:01upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.