Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 246:7-16. Learning Torah: Unfit Student or Rabbi, Patience, Trick Questions, Asking Off Topic, Sleeping
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. We are in Hilsano Toyo Reshma
- 0:04involve him alarmed Ontario Talmud Shino Hogun.
- 0:09It's also to teach Tara to a Talmud who is not Hogan Ella
- 0:13Maxima is so Lamoto. First he has the maxim Lamoto
- 0:19shara and then teach him how to you know, go on the director
- 0:23shara. The boy came my sign and you
- 0:25check your then you bring him back to the base manager.
- 0:31Sorry, it's interesting. I mean, it could be that I mean
- 0:34that the exact McCoy. I'm wondering if it's from from
- 0:38the bar by Khazi and Prakia Prakia and and so they both gave
- 0:48Kumar says his Tom has tightness on Alicia and Shivam Prakhar.
- 0:51They're Dekha told me of which they are dying and they weren't
- 0:55and they didn't try to you know you know you know Makarov.
- 0:59They didn't try to be Makarov them, even though Shivam
- 1:02Prakhya, he'll be had a right for a certain and he decided to
- 1:06Makarov him, you know, but he you know, but he was a middle
- 1:09priest man. Because of that, he went off and
- 1:12created his own own new religion.
- 1:15So or because he says that he it says by Ghazi said he he was
- 1:21minded the eagle eagle Azov being Shamarian law Arbits who
- 1:25shameless whatever it's it's so that they're they're tie this.
- 1:29You know, they're right. Alicia and Truman Proctor
- 1:32shouldn't have taught taught them, but then they should have
- 1:36suppose, you know, there's a tie down there not to work harder.
- 1:38Gloria says to to bring them back to the motive.
- 1:43So whatever actually, it's how much you know and you know, it's
- 1:47also you know, you know, you know also people who who learn
- 1:54and they have I think I mean, I don't know, like like you have
- 1:57the last Sif about the teaching women, the kilo on the Tiphilis.
- 2:01I I looked up a little bit more at this different shouting, even
- 2:04the the the the the Chagranthos and Pierce Devara.
- 2:08But there's also just, I saw some sip shot in the Rambam.
- 2:11It's just the idea of just taking it out of context or out
- 2:14of this. And Thomas Shane Hogan also
- 2:17someone who has, you know, political motives or so your
- 2:19motives, you know, So then you also shouldn't teach them
- 2:23because they'll come out and use whatever they learn to, you
- 2:26know, for to say, you know, whatever, you know, to say it,
- 2:30to say whatever they want. Or or even Tomlin was, you know,
- 2:34Tomlin was sitting on a, you know, Tomlin and Yeshiva and
- 2:38like, you know, Yeshiva was sitting on a smartphone, you
- 2:40know, sitting on a phone or a computer doing things he
- 2:42shouldn't also like, OK, you know, I don't know if he
- 2:45shouldn't. OK, I'm just saying like Rebbe
- 2:49has to work to he shouldn't, you know, push him out, but he
- 2:52shouldn't, you know, he has to be he has to be very Nizar in
- 2:55these things, you know, whatever.
- 2:56But I think how good doesn't mean someone was tired of
- 2:59nowadays, I don't know. It's complicated to know, but if
- 3:03someone knows the guy is is you know, how good and he's really
- 3:09you know, he's he's he's like I said, ulterior motives involved
- 3:14in learning is what is what to talk about.
- 3:18Let's say the opposite. The Rav is not he's not doing
- 3:24you know, even if he is a Bucky and chasse and play scheme and
- 3:29everything whatever the whole I'm sweet him low right in the
- 3:33maybe me Mano Archiaso Lamotov. You can't learn from him until
- 3:39until they he he does Chuva. I mean, I guess exactly, but
- 3:43like but Acker right, so the mayor, so you know, the mayor
- 3:47learned from him and I know he's and then when Acker was running,
- 3:50you know, Dolly adore, but you know, he went off.
- 3:54So I actually saw somewhere that the IT says that I mean, I don't
- 3:59know to what extent into whatever, but in Shamay that
- 4:03Bushwur who didn't see over terror of a mayor because
- 4:05somebody came from Akhir. No, I heard I saw this
- 4:08somewhere. I get these things.
- 4:09They're not trying to keep shoot them and everything and whatever
- 4:12and says the mice said that that the real Kanan was, you know, I
- 4:16was able to patter to patter him from then.
- 4:19I don't know whatever about Uncle Pan him if if if if the
- 4:23rub is doing things which are which are are not the they're
- 4:28tova. So then it should people
- 4:30shouldn't go stop going to a sharing and stuff and whatever
- 4:33Tess Kate said Milandin, how does how does a rough?
- 4:38How do you teach teach Taya Haravyeshi Bharosh, you know the
- 4:42the row, the Maggie cheer sits in front altar medium Lafana.
- 4:45But coughing Katara. They should be sitting.
- 4:48No, they shouldn't just sitting like a straight row behind.
- 4:50They should be sitting, you know, around around them.
- 4:53Doesn't mean that this is certainly a circle.
- 4:55But like sit in a room. He can see everyone Kadeshu
- 4:58Kulav Rohima Sarov shamin Dvrov. Everyone can see him and listen
- 5:04and hear him. Well, Yeshuvarav al al al al al
- 5:06Key say the baggy chairs should not should not sit on a chair to
- 5:10meet him on the carcass, to meet him on the on the ground.
- 5:14Oh, oh, oh, how cool. How are it's?
- 5:17Well, call all Key sauce. Either they all should all sit
- 5:21on the ground or all sit on chairs.
- 5:25You know, what about the can Tamidim stand if the Maggie
- 5:29chair sitting? Can can the Maggie chair stand
- 5:31if everyone's sitting or the opposite can tell me he didn't
- 5:35stand if the Maggie cheer is sitting?
- 5:36It's a little bit unclear. Could be those.
- 5:38I heard you know, one when I get this year was was vodka that
- 5:42everyone should sit because he's sitting likely like you know,
- 5:45should be all the same level. There could be there's a time
- 5:47behind it and there's a lot making this year do stand during
- 5:51during, you know, giving cheer and whatever.
- 5:53But it could be. It's maybe the point is is that
- 5:56you know that sitting on the ground and sitting on whatever
- 5:59could be. That's that's a bit more that
- 6:01that that changes how they you know how the how they understand
- 6:04the sheer. I don't know how.
- 6:05Gabi, you're showing the daft picture.
- 6:06You love to medium. They're called smikha.
- 6:08This is only it's the to medium they call Smikha that you have
- 6:13to be back there, that there's that, you know, the same level.
- 6:17I guess we'll get to a certain point in learning.
- 6:18I don't know how how much this applies nowadays, Verav.
- 6:22Hello. It could be like in, in in
- 6:23trader, you know, younger boys. It could be the song.
- 6:26That's what up. Verav Alameda.
- 6:28Aye. David Torgaman, the Dean of this
- 6:31borrower's name, little customer Rankin.
- 6:33And the tour goes into all the Dean of the Torgaman.
- 6:38But they're not. Yeah.
- 6:39No one does, is not. No one does nowadays.
- 6:41So, you know, I guess someone have to translate it into
- 6:47Spanish or whatever. Someone just told me that by
- 6:51Stefanski that they used AI to go ahead and to make a few days
- 6:55ago they put out a the him speaking span.
- 6:57It's even this year in Spanish and mom, which looks real.
- 7:00So it's only they have within two days they have like 1000
- 7:02like viewers, whatever. So I don't know, maybe you go
- 7:06back to Maturagamani, the AII don't know.
- 7:08If you look at all else, you're Haram.
- 7:10She alleviated the lovely venue on some meeting La Yito Soleim
- 7:15Aravu teaches, you know, he's teaching and the you still don't
- 7:21understand what he's saying, though he shouldn't get upset.
- 7:25And the Shaina, the Fraser Hadova, he should, you know, go
- 7:30over it again, the Kamapalami Bacio Vino until they understand
- 7:35the, the, you know, they understand the, the, the depth
- 7:40of it. The Lo Yomar Hadami Devanti, on
- 7:43the other hand, the Ptolemy. And then of course, that is all
- 7:45Captain Lower, Captain Loimi and Michelin Novos.
- 7:49The captain can't be right, right, right, right, right,
- 7:55right. This is why it's well and my 400
- 7:57time that that the captain can't because it is.
- 8:05But we'll see you in a minute. But what about what about if he
- 8:07wants to Mahad at them and he wants to, you know, push them
- 8:10things? OK, there's there's different
- 8:12things, but you shouldn't get angry at them.
- 8:14You know, I told you 20 times I can't understand what's wrong
- 8:17with you. Whatever.
- 8:18That's not OK. And the Talmud shouldn't say
- 8:23this is the low bison Lloyd made right?
- 8:25Talmud shouldn't say I understood and he doesn't
- 8:28understand the show of the ways of a show.
- 8:30I mean, you should keep on asking and you could say love
- 8:33Robin, even if it's the revenue. Send him the rabbit.
- 8:37Sorry, I think Sarah, sorry. I just need to learn.
- 8:41And I think Sarah said, someone told me once he he wasn't sure
- 8:45he was getting, he was a sheer and, you know, as a Shiva sort
- 8:49of shot. And he said he he had that cash
- 8:51on it. And and he he, you know, stayed
- 8:55completely stubborn and, you know, he was like really
- 8:57stubborn. And she would start scaring.
- 8:58You're going to be the biggest arts in the world.
- 9:01Whatever. But that's part of learning.
- 9:03I don't know. Whatever.
- 9:04You didn't care. This is what you need to do.
- 9:06You know, Alec, although you hate Tommy Bush with Aveiro
- 9:10Shaloma Palmi Shaina or Shnea Vulalama Dafilo Eka Akhter
- 9:16common palming, I feel, I feel like so he shouldn't be, he
- 9:24shouldn't feel embarrassed if he has, you know, his rusa hopped
- 9:28everything or his friend. They hopped his, they hopped
- 9:31everything in the first time and he needed to put a lot of work
- 9:33into it. She in his vice with the reserve
- 9:36INSA Ninsa Nicknasi into the bits of Madras Mcclone.
- 9:40If he gets embarrassed, he's not holding on the level and the
- 9:43people who are smarter than him or quicker or quicker this or
- 9:46whatever then he's never got he's gonna just leave the base
- 9:49matter. She have you know, he'll give up
- 9:51you she can give up and and so he has to you have to keep on
- 9:54trying and he should just because he takes him 10.
- 9:57I think it you know, takes him 10 times takes him one time.
- 9:59It's not there's no you know, self self.
- 10:02There's not. They're both on the same level.
- 10:05Al Qaeda. I'm a law Baisha and llama law
- 10:07Captain Malama. Like I said, this is the chorus.
- 10:09The Baisha and the can't learn on Captain Malami bedroom.
- 10:16That's where the sheer was too deep.
- 10:18They couldn't understand him. I'm saying daitan she Kitsara or
- 10:22wasn't so deep. They just they you know, they
- 10:24just they he's in the it's harder for him to understand
- 10:29about him. Nicker Laura Shahemi sees that
- 10:32they're just being lazy or they're not putting this or
- 10:36you're not being lazy, but they're not putting as much
- 10:38effort in as they could with wrapping Molehem and they're you
- 10:42know, they're taking an easy bit If you know that's why they
- 10:45understand kind of literally Soleim not because he's angry
- 10:48that that you know what's wrong with you and understand it's
- 10:51that you got to give him a push. Lima bit very he's had it on and
- 10:56then yesterday, you know, sometimes, you know, be sharp
- 10:58with them and and whatever that's Munter because he's not a
- 11:02cop that he wants to push him to learn harder.
- 11:04But again, a ref should sometimes understand who who who
- 11:08he's talking to and sometimes can be too sharp with a with a
- 11:12Talman and and Talman has issues with it and whatever.
- 11:15So you know, my uncle Pani and that's you know, you know,
- 11:19that's you know, whatever about that.
- 11:22It was right moral to medium and this says that you should give
- 11:25and make it a little bit bitter for Tom medium.
- 11:27But if you have aim Roy Lerav Lino, Carlos Reich, if they tell
- 11:31medium it's also from this. The the the Rob shouldn't be no
- 11:36collus Reich feel in front of Tom medium, but at least like if
- 11:41Naham he shouldn't go out and you know and shoot some hoops
- 11:44with them or what I don't want to do in England.
- 11:48I don't know they don't do hoops.
- 11:49I don't know whatever whatever been some cricket, I don't know
- 11:53below that hole. I have no idea the level the
- 11:56leash noise in mind. They shouldn't eat and drink
- 11:58with that because they should say Muslim would tell us a lamb
- 12:01part of of Aima is not, you know, since by dying, it's not
- 12:05supposed to, you know, eat in public because person doesn't
- 12:08you know, he, he, he it's a certain separation creates aim
- 12:11out the laundry room. And if they if they see him as
- 12:14just the, you know, his their pal, they're not going to really
- 12:17be macabre from him. All right, You know, the, you
- 12:19know, often the the Rishi Shivas and things we'll eat in the
- 12:22dining room with yellow to meet him.
- 12:24But if they're a separate table, shouldn't just sit with the
- 12:26table with the bucker. I'm not talking about the, you
- 12:29know, the cure of yeshivas or this and the bucker needed and
- 12:31that's we're not talking about that, but talking about
- 12:34regularly yeshivas where where the you know, where there's
- 12:39certain amount of personal cover.
- 12:42The Arabic Maggie cheer or Shiva has to has to hold themselves to
- 12:48your base. Ain't Shirley Mesaraja Miyad
- 12:53shouldn't ask Shiloh's we shouldn't ask you know Kasha's
- 12:57and things. The second you know there was
- 12:59there was walking into the basement address, you know to
- 13:01him and speaking and learning. He actually he see Ashif Daito.
- 13:05I love until his you know he's focused, then you know he can
- 13:08able to sit down, put his briefcase down.
- 13:11I'll get a cup of coffee. I don't know whatever it is and
- 13:13the Tolman show you because she kind of actually see a shave the
- 13:17Anuar and nourish the Tolman ask until he he also has Yousif Das.
- 13:24They ain't sure Lim Shneim Kafka.
- 13:25They shouldn't have two people come up in the and ask together.
- 13:28Doesn't mean they should One shouldn't stand there and listen
- 13:31covers his ass. It means that they you know they
- 13:33can listen in just they shouldn't be asking the same
- 13:35time. They ain't sure Lim Sera, the
- 13:39Indian akher. And and again, I saw that
- 13:43there's a there's a there's an extra point here that you know,
- 13:46like you're talking about someone who's you know, who, who
- 13:49really who's really is holding. There are commonly to call me.
- 13:53There are, you know, big who you can ask in anything anywhere.
- 13:56And there are holdings. And then this doesn't really
- 13:58apply so much because even when they're walking in the street,
- 14:01even when whatever they they can answer, that's that's not that
- 14:04doesn't apply. It's not a very, you know, a
- 14:06regular market share. And surely Mr. Ralph Mignanath
- 14:09here should not start, you know, if they're in the middle of a
- 14:12Silgia, you shouldn't start asking about some other Silgia,
- 14:15at least not, you know, Bansa and the me OSU Indian Shimo skin
- 14:18boy. They should only he should only
- 14:20ask them from the things from they're dealing with all
- 14:22traditionally. It's viish.
- 14:25You shouldn't try, you know, because maybe I don't know.
- 14:27You know, there's some are Bunny you can you know, if they're if
- 14:30they're not holding this, you're not holding whatever, you know,
- 14:33they'll they they don't know. Again, there's some really like
- 14:36the cultural cools at the fingertips, but there's you
- 14:38know, you feed them, but but they're, you know, often they
- 14:41you know, they you don't start asking, you know, you know,
- 14:43they're in the middle of this. You start asking about what
- 14:45about monocles? Whatever they're not.
- 14:48You know, I don't know. It's it could be a you can
- 14:50embarrassing miation who have a hot face as a Tamidi Mache Lisov
- 14:55and the Raff should have, you know, should make say difficult,
- 14:57cautious in order to, you know, to and tricky questions in order
- 15:02for the Tamidi to think about things.
- 15:04I mean, even with the things he does, he he should do things
- 15:09which seem a little bit odd sometimes.
- 15:12So they could be they should ask and this and why did you do this
- 15:16or things like that? And also it's sort of a test to
- 15:24see if they what what they know. I don't know if it means they
- 15:29should get written tests. OK, I don't know.
- 15:30Some people really are really into written tests.
- 15:33Other people aren't the Anzac Lemisha and and and and then
- 15:41only to say that you need you don't need permission to ask
- 15:44them being you knocker can't ask the rob because maybe it's not
- 15:49covering, you know, whatever. But if they ask you, you know, I
- 15:52was sitting with the OR Shiva and someone came and say
- 15:55Shikhar, and he and he said, he said, what about the Gemara?
- 15:59You know, what about this Gemara?
- 16:01And he's like, well, didn't no one told me to look over there.
- 16:03And he's like, well, you missed the whole sliggy.
- 16:05Yeah, whatever. Like, hey, it's you gotta go.
- 16:08You know what, go look it up. Go this, you know, whatever you
- 16:11can start asking, you know, start asking different points
- 16:13and that's OK. You Gamo and Charlene Mahumad
- 16:19name is Shiva Mahumad. And you shouldn't ask Shiloh's
- 16:23standing and there there should the the the Maggie chair answer
- 16:27movement. I don't know how much the supply
- 16:29if he is be omitting this is just the course of this is in
- 16:32the round. This is all from the round on
- 16:34Nicholson Matura and the basis is that's a sefta.
- 16:38Sorry. I guess you know I don't know
- 16:39how much remarkably done this he's showing me or you go to a
- 16:43rub in the shul and you ask him a Shiloh.
- 16:44I don't know how much you know she shouldn't stand that I don't
- 16:48know the pan if you any of Aisha, I mean, she should hardly
- 16:51in double for her luck. It's our clown.
- 16:52But in some sense, when you when you ask a Shiloh, then you
- 16:56really should stand. When you ask a Shiloh, when
- 16:58you're asking, you know, a shot and something.
- 17:00So then it could be you should say it or it could be whatever,
- 17:03but asking a Shiloh should you should stand below Migvo, nor
- 17:09should he, you know, you know, stand.
- 17:11You know, he shouldn't like stand, stand taller than him
- 17:14along the rock, like shouldn't be from far away.
- 17:16Lo Mihori has a key name and nor should it should be behind like,
- 17:21you know, greater people out or whatever, but ain't surely Ella
- 17:24the union. And he should only ask, you
- 17:27know, he's giving a share on this.
- 17:29And then Rebbe, what about this, you know, or well, this halacha,
- 17:32you know, in the middle, you know, unfortunately it happens.
- 17:37You know, they just you know, I've been in sheer different,
- 17:42you know, from, you know, sheer kind of cheer him whatever.
- 17:45Like it. Suddenly some someone would just
- 17:46say what about this that we're talking about this and it just
- 17:49takes it just messes the whole the whole sheer up.
- 17:51Like it just takes it out of context and they and they get
- 17:54started. I want to know about this.
- 17:55What do you mean? You want to know about what's
- 17:57dealing with it? It's just it's very frustrating,
- 18:01but ain't sure I'm telling me you're up and you only ask out
- 18:05of year of low you shall be in your you should've asked more
- 18:09than three halachas at a time. You dial it if two people who
- 18:15asked two people asked one person asking you one person
- 18:21asked looking and not on something much a different
- 18:23topic. This cup game the Kenyan they
- 18:28should He answered the Shiloh the the answer the Shiloh the
- 18:32Shiloh Kenyan before he answers the one in low Canyon or doesn't
- 18:38even answer it Maisa. So Shaya Lamais of chain of
- 18:42Maisa, not shaya Lamaisa is cocky Lamaisa.
- 18:45You have to he should answer the one which is Lamaisa and not the
- 18:48one which is, you know, not lamaisa.
- 18:50Now halacha madrich. If he if someone asks for
- 18:54halacha or madrich is cocky and halacha, then you have to he has
- 18:58to, you know, if he only has time for one, you should answer
- 19:00the one about halacha Madricha Madrish.
- 19:06Madrish means, you know, I could be Russia is saying, you know,
- 19:11things like that Bhagatha and you're asking, you know, in your
- 19:14name or you know, you're asking the you know, ashkafa, things
- 19:18like that. So ashkafa's like the maisa.
- 19:20Now there's Kakin the Madrish if they right.
- 19:29So the what is the change over here?
- 19:32It's talking in the it's talking in the Madrid.
- 19:34The shark is it's in a gear. So aguada of a Kaba haimer
- 19:41there's cock in there's cock in La Hagada.
- 19:46Yeah. So he changes the Kabajan Xava
- 19:48between Kabajan and Xava. There's cock in the Kaba haima,
- 19:51Kaba haima. These are different, different,
- 19:56different. Yanim Tesvov, are you surely EE?
- 20:02The shoreline one's a ha ha, meaning one's greater than the
- 20:05other. And this she answered from the
- 20:08hakam first. Tom Hakamaritz and this Hakam,
- 20:13he should answer the Tom Hakam first.
- 20:18I mean, yeah, that's some of the reason why he had to answer the
- 20:23first. It was more than whatever.
- 20:29If that could be, if they have the same Shiloh, let's say
- 20:31whatever. Shneh hakamin shne tamidian,
- 20:35shneh amira shalu shneim bishtehalakos shalos.
- 20:40If everything is equal the past to Sifin, then he can just pick
- 20:47pick away who he wants. Mamta Tamakam, including the
- 20:51coin Amaris, Mishnah and and and any in any situation for Elias
- 20:58and for benching and all these things and moms with Tom and so
- 21:02some you know, it comes for Koi Namahara.
- 21:04It's or let's say nowadays on moms.
- 21:06I say it's about Chuva, you know, and about Chuvus with Tom.
- 21:09And the other guy is Yukos, you know, has Yukos and Shivas.
- 21:16It's the guy you know they should stocking to the to the to
- 21:19the to the you know to the Baal Chuva ain't ain't Shane named a
- 21:28base based on Madrid? She shouldn't she shouldn't
- 21:32sleep in the base of Madrid the home.
- 21:34It's not named a base of Madrid. Habaso Nas is Karoim.
- 21:37Anyone who sleeps in the falls asleep in the base of Madrid is
- 21:40torn up. She's now recovered Karoim Numa
- 21:44the in or Haim and she burbings down at the the someone who is
- 21:49the tomahawk or in the base of Madrid chimney.
- 21:51Whatever he is allowed for him to sleep there should because
- 21:54it's like it. That's like his house.
- 21:55That's where he sits and he learns all the time other
- 21:58people, you know, whatever, and this is Dafna like during the
- 22:01during during the Drusha things that everybody shouldn't sleep.
- 22:05It's it's important. It's it's you see, that's it's
- 22:09it has a time on him. I do think that a Rove he
- 22:13shouldn't be over listening either and give super boring
- 22:15drushas and other people shouldn't sleep, but that's I
- 22:17don't know if it's listening either, but uncle pane could be
- 22:20its anus. I don't know.
- 22:21Anyway, say that we'll stop here.