Latest / The CTO Podcast with Fexingo: Technical Leadership, Architecture, and Engineering Org / How Disposable Vapes Went from Boom to Bust
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, I was cleaning out my desk drawer over the weekend, and I found this old disposable vape from like 2022. And it got me thinking about how this tiny little product went from basically nowhere to a multi-billion dollar industry in what felt like months. Luna: And now it's basically banned. I mean, the FDA has been issuing denial orders left and right, and there's a federal ban set to take effect later this year. Lucas: Right. And it's such a wild story because it's not just about vaping or public health. It's a case study in how fast a product can explode when the supply chain and the distribution channels align perfectly. And then how quickly it can collapse when regulators step in. Luna: And honestly, if this kind of deep dive into a business story is useful to you in your own work, that's exactly why we make these episodes. And if it's worth a coffee to you, there's a link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just helps us keep this ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, that's a small ask. And it does go a long way. But back to the vapes. Let's start with the origin. The modern disposable vape really got its start with this company called Puff Bar, which was founded in California around 2019. They were essentially these small, $10 devices that came in flavors like mango and mint. Luna: And they didn't look like a cigarette at all. They looked like a flash drive or a highlight marker. That was kind of the point. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a big part of why they took off with younger users. But from a business perspective, what's fascinating is the economics. These things cost maybe two or three dollars to manufacture, and they sold at retail for ten to twelve. So the margins were enormous, and the unit economics just worked from day one. Luna: So it wasn't a hardware play that needed to sell subscriptions or refills. It was just pure volume. Lucas: Pure volume. And the volume got huge. By 2022, disposables accounted for over half of the US e-cigarette market, and that was up from essentially nothing two years earlier. I remember reading that sales went from around 14 million units in 2020 to over 300 million by 2022. That's not a gradual curve, that's a hockey stick. Luna: What drove that kind of growth? I mean, it wasn't just the flavors, right? Lucas: It was a few things. First, the product itself was just so simple. No buttons, no settings, no charging. You took it out of the package, you puffed on it, and when it died, you threw it away. That's a level of convenience that almost no other consumer product offers. But the second thing was distribution. These things were everywhere — convenience stores, gas stations, corner shops, online marketplaces. And because they were small and cheap, they were easy to ship and easy to stock. Luna: And I remember there were these weird social media marketing plays too. Some brands were essentially using TikTok and Instagram to build brand loyalty, even though the platforms had policies against it. Lucas: Right, and that's where the story gets murky from a regulatory standpoint. The FDA had been trying to regulate e-cigarettes as tobacco products since 2016, but the system was designed for big, established companies with the resources to file massive applications. The disposable vape brands were mostly startups, many of them operating in the gray market, and they just didn't play by those rules. Luna: So the FDA was essentially fighting a whack a mole game. They'd issue a warning letter to one company, and three more would pop up with a slightly different name. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the enforcement started to shift. Instead of targeting individual companies, the FDA began to target the products themselves. In 2020, they effectively banned flavored cartridges, but disposables were sort of in a gray area. And then in 2022, the FDA started issuing marketing denial orders for specific disposable products, saying they didn't meet the public health standard. Luna: And that's when the industry started to panic a bit. I mean, if your product can't be legally marketed, you can't sell it. But a lot of these companies just ignored the orders and kept selling anyway. Lucas: They did. And that's part of what led to the bigger crackdown. You had this period where the market was flooded with products that were technically illegal, and the FDA didn't have the resources to stop every shipment. So the sales kept climbing even as the legal risk was mounting. Luna: So what's the actual state now? I know there's a federal ban coming. Can you break down the timeline? Lucas: Sure. So, in late 2025, the FDA finalized a rule that bans all non-tobacco flavored e-cigarettes. That includes disposables, and it's set to take effect in September of this year. So within the next few weeks, it becomes illegal to manufacture, sell, or distribute flavored disposables nationwide. And on top of that, the FDA has issued denial orders for millions of products, so even some tobacco-flavored ones are getting pulled off the market. Luna: So the legal market for disposables is essentially going to zero. That's a massive shift for retailers and manufacturers. Lucas: It is. And the numbers back that up. Looking at 2025, sales of disposables were already down significantly from their peak. I think they dropped by almost half. And with the ban, the remaining legal market is just going to evaporate. But here's the thing — that doesn't mean the demand disappeared. It just means the demand is going to be met by the black market. Luna: And that's the twist. We've seen this with prohibition, with the war on drugs. When you ban something that people want, you create a black market. And that black market often has worse products, less regulation, and no age verification. Lucas: Exactly. And we're already seeing that. There are reports of counterfeit disposables that are being sold online and in some stores, and they're often made with lower-quality ingredients and potentially harmful substances. Plus, the black market is less likely to check IDs, so it might actually increase access for minors, which is the exact opposite of the goal. Luna: So what's the business lesson here? I mean, for a founder who's building a product in a regulated space, is there anything to take away from the vape industry's rise and fall? Lucas: I think the biggest lesson is that regulatory risk is a business risk, and it needs to be priced in from day one. A lot of these vape companies were operating with this sort of 'move fast and break things' mentality, and they didn't have a plan for what happens when the regulators catch up. And when they did catch up, the business model collapsed overnight. There were companies that had warehouses full of inventory that they couldn't sell, and they just went bankrupt. Luna: And a lot of them tried to pivot to other products, right? Like some started selling CBD vapes or nicotine pouches, but it's not easy to pivot when your whole supply chain and brand are built around a specific product. Lucas: Right. And that's a good lesson for any founder. The same goes for any product that relies on a legal gray area. You might have a great run, but if the rules change, you need to have a plan B. And ideally, plan B involves building a business that doesn't depend on the gray area in the first place. Luna: And I think there's also a lesson about the importance of understanding your customer. The vape companies didn't really care about building a sustainable brand. They were just focused on getting the product in front of as many people as possible. And that's a race to the bottom in a way, because you're not creating any long-term value. Lucas: Yeah. And that's why we're seeing some of the larger, more established vaping companies, like Juul, try to position themselves as the responsible players. They've been trying to get FDA authorization for their products, but even they've had a tough time. In 2022, the FDA actually ordered Juul to pull its products off the market, though that was later stayed on appeal. Luna: So even the big guys are in a precarious position. It's a tough industry to be in right now. Lucas: It is. And I think the final takeaway is about the pace of change. The disposable vape went from zero to billions in sales in under two years, and then to zero in under two more. That's an extreme example of how fast markets can change, and it's a reminder that no trend lasts forever. For founders, the key is to build something that can adapt, not just ride a wave. Luna: So as the ban goes into effect, what should we be watching for? I mean, is there any chance the black market doesn't actually materialize as strongly as we think? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. The demand for nicotine isn't going to disappear, and disposables have become a habit for a lot of people. So I'd expect the black market to be significant, but there's also a chance that some of those users just quit or switch to other products like nicotine gum or pouches. It's really hard to predict. But one thing I'm watching is how the enforcement is going to work. The FDA has limited resources, and it's going to be tough to stop the flow of products coming from overseas, especially from China where most of these devices are made. Luna: And that's another angle — the international dimension. The US is not the only market. These products are huge in the UK and other countries. So are the Chinese manufacturers just going to shift their focus to other markets? Lucas: Almost certainly. In fact, we've already seen some of the big players pivot to markets where the regulations are more lenient. There's also a thriving export market for these devices. So the global industry isn't going to collapse, it's just going to shift. And that's another lesson: when you're global, one market's loss is another market's gain. Luna: So what does the future hold for the legal vaping market in the US? Is it just going to be tobacco-flavored products, or is there any chance that some flavors get approved? Lucas: The FDA has said that they're open to reviewing applications for flavored products if the company can prove that it benefits public health, like if it helps smokers quit. But that's a high bar. So far, no flavored disposable has been approved. The only flavored products that have been granted marketing orders are some e-cigarettes that are sold by big tobacco companies, and even those are limited. So I think the legal market is going to be dominated by tobacco-flavored products, and the flavor ban is going to stay for a while. Luna: And that's a tough sell for a lot of adult vapers who switched to vaping to get away from the taste of tobacco. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the black market might be even more attractive. But at the end of the day, it's a prime example of how fast a business can go from boom to bust when the foundation isn't built to last. And I think that's the story that founders should pay attention to. Luna: Well, I'm going to throw away that old vape I found in my drawer. It's probably not even safe to use anymore, and now it's officially not legal to possess either. Lucas: Yeah, probably a good call. And if you're a founder thinking about your own product, just remember: the regulatory landscape is part of your total addressable market. And that's a wrap for today. Thanks for listening.