Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 10 Stocks Drove 60% of Gains: Is Your Index Fund Safe?
Transcript
- 0:00I was reading through the market analysis you brought in for us
- 0:02today and there's this quote from a 40 year market veteran
- 0:07that just completely stopped me in my tracks.
- 0:09Oh, the broken anchor quote. Yes.
- 0:11He's looking at the current financial landscape and he says
- 0:14I feel like I'm out in a big sea and the anchor broke.
- 0:17It is a profoundly unsettling image, isn't it?
- 0:20I mean, especially coming from someone who has
- 0:22tradedthroughthe.com burst the 2008 financial crisis, and, you
- 0:26know, the 2020 pandemic. Right, he's seen it all.
- 0:29Exactly. So to look at today's market and
- 0:31conclude that the anchor is completely gone, it really
- 0:35speaks to a fundamental shift in how the entire system is
- 0:38operating right now. And that is actually our mission
- 0:40for you today. On this deep dive, we are taking
- 0:43a stack of expert investing discussions, market mechanics
- 0:46and demographic data to try and answer one massive question.
- 0:50And it's a big one. It really is.
- 0:52Are we currently experiencing a permanent AI driven new reality
- 0:56in the stock market or are we sitting on a historic ticking
- 1:00time bomb? Because when you look at the
- 1:02sheer scale of the numbers in these sources, we need to figure
- 1:05out what is actually going on beneath the surface.
- 1:08Yeah. Our goal today is to cut through
- 1:10all that noise. We're going to look under the
- 1:11hood at the underlying mechanics of where the money is actually
- 1:14flowing structurally, not just emotionally, and figure out what
- 1:18this means for your own portfolio.
- 1:20Because the surface narrative of, you know, just continuous
- 1:23growth, it's hiding some unprecedented structural risks.
- 1:27It absolutely is. So let's unpack this broken
- 1:31anchor feeling. It seems to really come down to
- 1:33the sheer concentration of the market right now, specifically
- 1:36the S&P 500. We're always taught that an
- 1:41index fund is safe because it's diversified across hundreds of
- 1:44companies. Right.
- 1:45That's the traditional wisdom, yeah.
- 1:46But the sources point out that right now, just 10 stocks
- 1:49account for 60% of all market gains.
- 1:52Which is just staggering. 60%, I mean, to put that in
- 1:56perspective, in the 20 tens, the top 10 accounted for about 30%
- 2:01and before that it was closer to 20.
- 2:03Right. So that level of concentration
- 2:05completely shatters the traditional definition of
- 2:07diversification. But to truly understand why
- 2:10these seasoned investors are feeling unmoored, we have to
- 2:12look at the macro valuation metrics too.
- 2:15OK, like what? Well, the Shiller PE ratio,
- 2:18which is a cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio that
- 2:21smooths out volatility over 10 years.
- 2:23It's currently sitting at 42. And the Wilshire GDP ratio is at
- 2:27230%. OK, wait, let's ground those
- 2:31numbers for a second. The Wilshire GDP ratio that
- 2:34measures the total value of the stock market against the actual
- 2:38economic output of the entire country, right?
- 2:40Yes, exactly. So at 230%, the stock market is
- 2:44essentially priced at more than double the size of the entire
- 2:48U.S. economy. Yep, that seems completely
- 2:50disconnected from reality. And a normal Shiller PE is
- 2:54historically around 15 I think. So sitting at 42 isn't just
- 2:58high, it's screaming that things are dangerously overvalued.
- 3:02Historically speaking, it is flashing bright red.
- 3:06I mean, when the Shiller PE hits 30, that usually signals a
- 3:09market crash is imminent. When it hits 40, you are looking
- 3:13at a massive generational market crash.
- 3:16Wow. And we are at 42.
- 3:18The only other time we saw levels close to this was in
- 3:211999, right before the.com bubble burst.
- 3:24Which completely explains Warren Buffett's behavior right now.
- 3:28The sources note he is currently sitting on roughly 350 to $400
- 3:33billion in cash. Yeah, that is not the behavior
- 3:36of a man who thinks the market is offering fairly priced,
- 3:39rational deals. Not at all.
- 3:41Buffett is anchored to the idea that the market ultimately
- 3:44prices things at their intrinsic value, so his cash hoard is a
- 3:48glaring signal of severe hesitation.
- 3:51But then you know you have the opposing view.
- 3:53Right, the AI optimists. Exactly.
- 3:55Some argue that AI has permanently changed the rules
- 3:58that these asset light tech monopolies justify these crazy
- 4:02valuations. People look at Jeremy Siegel's
- 4:04famous 200 year chart of the stock market, which shows this
- 4:07beautiful continuous upward slope, and they just assume they
- 4:10need to stay in the market no matter what.
- 4:12But the sources bring in a pretty harsh reality check from
- 4:15investor Li Liu on that exact chart.
- 4:18Yes, over 200 years, the growth is real, but you aren't
- 4:21investing for 200 years. Right.
- 4:23You don't have that kind of time.
- 4:25If you buy the absolute peak of a cycle, you could easily face
- 4:2810 to 20 years of 0 growth. Just brutal sideways movement
- 4:33while the underlying businesses take decades to catch up to
- 4:36their inflated stock prices. The illusion of safety really
- 4:38traps people. When you buy into an index fund
- 4:41today, you think you're buying a tiny, safe piece of 500
- 4:45different companies. Right, like an analogy I thought
- 4:48of while reading this. If I go to a buffet I expect 500
- 4:52different dishes. But right now it feels like I
- 4:55paid for the whole buffet and when they hand me my plate, 50%
- 4:58of it is just taken up by 10 massive tech flavored desserts.
- 5:03That's exactly what it is. It's not true diversification
- 5:06anymore, it's just a concentrated bet on a few giant
- 5:09companies. You are essentially making a
- 5:11highly leveraged bet on a handful of hyperscalers.
- 5:14These are the massive cloud providers, you know, companies
- 5:16like Amazon, Google and Microsoft that operate all these
- 5:19global data centers. And this raises a really
- 5:22important question. Why are they getting so big in
- 5:24the first place? Exactly.
- 5:26Why are these top ten stocks getting so disproportionately
- 5:29massive? And the sources trace this back
- 5:31to the absolute dominance of passive investing combined with
- 5:35this sort of hidden demographic trigger.
- 5:38Yeah, we are living through a first of its kind financial
- 5:41experiment right now. In 1996, passive investing
- 5:44made-up just 6% of the market. By the end of 2024, that number
- 5:48is 60%. That is a massive shift.
- 5:52It is, and passive investing fundamentally changes how
- 5:56capital operates because it relies on market cap weighting.
- 5:59Let's breakdown the mechanics of that for a second.
- 6:01If I'm just a normal worker and I put $100 into my 4 O 1K index
- 6:05fund, the algorithm executing that trade doesn't look at
- 6:08valuations. Right.
- 6:09No, it doesn't care at all. It doesn't.
- 6:11Care if stock is fairly valued at $10 or insanely overvalued at
- 6:14$1000? It just automatically hands
- 6:17$7.00 of my money to Apple and $6 to Microsoft simply because
- 6:21they are already the biggest companies in the index.
- 6:23And that creates an automatic feedback loop with 0 price
- 6:26discovery. The passive machine blindly buys
- 6:29more of a company simply because it's already big.
- 6:32It's a self fulfilling prophecy. Exactly.
- 6:34And the bigger it gets, the more of the market's capital
- 6:37automatically funnels into it. Now add the demographic layer to
- 6:41this. The baby boomer generation
- 6:42controls roughly 30% of all the money in the stock market
- 6:46through pensions 401 KS and Iras.
- 6:48And here's where the time bomb actually sits.
- 6:52The government requires you to start pulling money out of these
- 6:54tax advantage accounts at a certain age and paying taxes on
- 6:57it. These are called required
- 6:59minimum distributions, or RMDS. Right?
- 7:02It used to be age 70 1/2, but Congress keeps actively delaying
- 7:07it. They pushed it to 72, then to 73
- 7:10and they are aiming for 75 by 2035.
- 7:13And by delaying those RMDS, Congress is artificially keeping
- 7:17the bid going in the market. They are basically preventing a
- 7:20massive outflow of cash. Currently, about $250 billion is
- 7:25forced out through RMDS annually.
- 7:27Which sounds like a lot, but. But the sources note that if
- 7:30Congress hadn't pushed the age to 73 / 1 trillion dollars would
- 7:34have been forcefully withdrawn and sold off this year alone.
- 7:38Wow, OK, I have to push back on the timeline here though.
- 7:42If Congress just keeps kicking the can down the road by raising
- 7:45the RMD age, couldn't this passive machine just keep
- 7:49running forever? Like if the money doesn't have
- 7:51to leave, what actually breaks the cycle?
- 7:54What breaks the cycle is an alternative that offers safety
- 7:56to a generation that desperately needs it.
- 7:59Baby boomers are in their late 60s and 70s.
- 8:01They cannot afford to suffer a 40% market crash and then wait
- 8:0515 years for it to recover. But they don't have the time
- 8:07horizon. Exactly.
- 8:09So the trigger scenario is interest rates.
- 8:12Oh, so if 10 year Treasury bonds hit, say 6 to 8%, or if
- 8:17annuities start offering really high guaranteed returns,
- 8:20suddenly that retiring class has a highly attractive risk free
- 8:24alternative? And if that 30% of market
- 8:27capital controlled by boomers gets nervous and mass rotates
- 8:30into bonds for safety, it triggers forced selling in those
- 8:34passive index funds. Here's the real danger of the
- 8:37passive machine. The selling will be as violent
- 8:40and indiscriminate as the buying was.
- 8:42The algorithms won't care about underlying value, they will just
- 8:45liquidate across the board. It could completely reset the
- 8:48mechanics of the equity market. That perfectly sets up the next
- 8:52piece of the puzzle, because right now all that passive money
- 8:55is flowing straight to the top of the index, which is entirely
- 8:58dominated by this AI build out. Right.
- 9:01The prevailing narrative is that AI demand is infinite, but
- 9:05looking at the supply chain dynamics, this feels less like a
- 9:08permanent new reality and more like a classic cyclical trap.
- 9:12It really does. The current AI build out
- 9:14strongly resembles a traditional semiconductor chip cycle.
- 9:17It's just operating on a much, much larger scale.
- 9:21And right now that cycle is being severely constrained by
- 9:23memory chips. This brings us to the Stargate
- 9:27incident detailed in the sources.
- 9:28I couldn't believe this part. In late 2025, Oracle and Open AI
- 9:33signed a deal where they requested 900,000 memory wafers
- 9:36a month. Yeah, to put that into context,
- 9:38that single order represented 40% of the entire world's memory
- 9:43supply. 40%. Prior to this, the largest
- 9:46single buyer in the world was Apple, taking up about 22% of
- 9:49the market. So an entity that previously
- 9:51bought basically 0 memory chips suddenly shows up and demands
- 9:5540% of global supply, and this sparked an absolute panic among
- 9:59the other hyperscalers. Oh, absolutely.
- 10:01Google, Amazon, Meta, they all look at this finite pie of
- 10:04memory wafers and realize they might get starved out, so they
- 10:07just start double ordering to secure their own supply.
- 10:10Which creates a massive surge of phantom demand.
- 10:13The factories get these orders and assume the baseline need for
- 10:15chips has doubled, but it actually hasn't.
- 10:17This sounds exactly like the toilet paper panic at 2021.
- 10:22Giant buyer clears the shelf and suddenly everyone else is double
- 10:25ordering just in case. Stuffing in their closets,
- 10:27creating this massive phantom demand signal.
- 10:30But when the music stops and everyone realizes their closets
- 10:34are completely full, who is left holding the bag?
- 10:37And that is the multi trillion dollar question right now.
- 10:40Plus the situation is further compounded by severe physical
- 10:43roadblocks. In the real world you can order
- 10:45all the chips you want, but building the data centers to
- 10:48actually house them takes two to three years and they are hitting
- 10:51intense power and water constraints.
- 10:54The sources site Northern Virginia, which is a major data
- 10:57center hub, facing massive social blowback over power grid
- 11:00strain and the millions of gallons of water required just
- 11:03to cool these facilities. Oracle even had to push back a
- 11:06massive 2026 build out to 2029 purely because of water access
- 11:11issues. So we have all these companies
- 11:13hoarding expensive chips, but they can't even plug them in
- 11:17yet. And the sources point out an
- 11:19unbelievable accounting nightmare hiding in plain sight
- 11:22here. Millions of these older AI chips
- 11:25are literally sitting uninstalled in warehouses.
- 11:28Right. And when a chip sits in a
- 11:30warehouse, it's categorized as an asset on the corporate
- 11:32balance sheet. But the moment it gets plugged
- 11:35into a server and put into service, accounting rules
- 11:37dictate that it must be depreciated over its useful
- 11:40life. Oh, wow.
- 11:41Yeah, that depreciation hits the income statement as a massive
- 11:44expense. Once those data centers finally
- 11:47come online, billions of dollars in depreciation expenses are
- 11:50going to suddenly hit these companies quarterly earnings,
- 11:53instantly making them look significantly less profitable.
- 11:56Meanwhile, the technology itself ages like milk.
- 11:59NVIDIA is already rolling out chips like the Vera Rubin, which
- 12:03is five times faster and uses 110th the energy of the chips
- 12:06currently sitting in those warehouses.
- 12:08Exactly. And those new hyper efficient
- 12:10chips require entirely new water cooled data centers anyway.
- 12:14They can't just be slotted into the old air cooled
- 12:16infrastructure. So you have a scenario where
- 12:19billions of dollars of older chips will be functionally
- 12:22obsolete before they are ever plugged in.
- 12:25The companies will eventually be forced by their accountants to
- 12:27take massive earnings write downs.
- 12:30The sources draw an amazing historical parallel here to a
- 12:331968 book called The Money Game. Back then, the narrative was
- 12:37that demand for mainframe computers was infinite, but IBM
- 12:42started releasing new systems like the 370 so fast that it
- 12:46obsoleted their own previous models way faster than the
- 12:49eight-year depreciation schedule allowed for.
- 12:51And the companies that had borrowed heavily to buy those
- 12:54older computers to lease them out saw their stock prices crash
- 12:58by 80%. 80%. The technology was real, the
- 13:02growth was real, but the capital cycle was just brutal.
- 13:06Today's businesses that buy GPU's with a debt just to rent
- 13:09them out face that exact same risk if supply suddenly catches
- 13:13up to demand and rental prices plummet.
- 13:15So if the AI vortex is sucking all the oxygen and all the
- 13:19passive capital out of the room, what is happening to the
- 13:22companies that actually make physical things?
- 13:25The sources mentioned that 79% of the companies in the S&P 500
- 13:29are currently underperforming the index.
- 13:32Yeah, money is fleeing traditional businesses to chase
- 13:35tech. This requires us to separate a
- 13:37fundamentally broken business from one that is just caught in
- 13:40a bad macroeconomic narrative. Because across the board, there
- 13:44is a broad consumer slowdown happening, right?
- 13:46Yes, Walmart, Target, Kroger, they are all lowering prices
- 13:51because the consumer is heavily squeezed by inflation and credit
- 13:53card debt. Let's look at Chipotle, for
- 13:55example. Their stock is down 40% from its
- 13:59highs. They are facing their first same
- 14:01store sales decline since 2016, and Wall Street is terrified
- 14:05about the impact of GLP 1 weight loss drugs reducing how much
- 14:09people eat right. The market is treating the stock
- 14:12like the business is permanently impaired.
- 14:14But if you look past the stock price and examine the underlying
- 14:17mechanics of the business, it remains a cash machine.
- 14:21They still boast a 21% return on invested capital.
- 14:25Meaning for every dollar they invest back into the business,
- 14:27like opening a new store, they generate 21 cents of profit
- 14:31every single year. Precisely.
- 14:34And they generate $1.5 billion in free cash flow, which is
- 14:37actual cash leftover after operating expenses that they can
- 14:41use to expand or weather economic storms.
- 14:44They have a massive economic Moat, a strong competitive
- 14:47advantage in the fast casual space that prevents rivals from
- 14:50easily stealing their market share.
- 14:52You know, I noticed a funny contradiction from the sources
- 14:54regarding Chipotle's struggles. Wall Street analysts are saying
- 14:58Chipotle's foot traffic is down because consumers are squeezed
- 15:01by the price of a $21.00 burrito.
- 15:03Yeah, but the sources note that when you actually order a bowl
- 15:08right now, it is so jam packed with food that it takes 2 entire
- 15:11meals to finish. Isn't giving away too much food
- 15:14an incredibly fixable margin issue rather than a sign that
- 15:18their economic mode is broken? It's an excellent observation if
- 15:21your portion sizes have drifted and you are giving away too much
- 15:24product. You can fix your profit margins
- 15:26tomorrow just by enforcing standard operational guidelines.
- 15:29Exactly. That is a temporary operational
- 15:31hiccup. Wall Street is punishing them
- 15:33for a short term macroeconomic dip in foot traffic, completely
- 15:38ignoring their long term cash generation and structural
- 15:40advantages. Now, the sources contrast
- 15:43Chipotle's macroeconomic struggles with companies like
- 15:45Nike and Lululemon, which are suffering from entirely
- 15:49self-inflicted wounds. Right, because bad management
- 15:52can destroy an economic Moat much faster than a tight
- 15:54consumer market. Lululemon is a prime example of
- 15:57this. They completely abandoned their
- 15:59core aspirational marketing. They used to market to the
- 16:02ideal, the elite Yogi, the mountain climber.
- 16:06Their founder, Chip Wilson, even warned that the board was losing
- 16:09its edge by drifting away from this identity.
- 16:11Instead, they pivoted to broad mass market appeals that
- 16:14completely missed their core audience.
- 16:16The sources point out a baffling incident where Lululemon
- 16:19sponsored a streamed yoga event on the Great Wall of China.
- 16:22Oh yeah, and decided to feature a Japanese drum performance.
- 16:26Which in the context of East Asian history is just a tone
- 16:29deaf unforced error. Because they lost their brand
- 16:32focus and alienated their base, they are losing massive ground
- 16:35to hungry competitors like Aloe. That is a fundamentally
- 16:39different risk profile, right? A company eroding its own brand
- 16:43identity is in far more danger than a company like Chipotle
- 16:46dealing with a temporary dip in consumer spending.
- 16:49It's basically the difference between a great runner pushing
- 16:51against a strong headwind versus a runner who just decided to tie
- 16:55their own shoelaces together that.
- 16:57Perfectly captures it, yeah. So if physical goods are
- 17:01struggling with consumers, what about the software side?
- 17:04The companies that don't make physical chips but rely entirely
- 17:07on corporate tech budgets? Let's talk about Salesforce.
- 17:10OK. If AI is the new king of the
- 17:13market, the fear is that a traditional enterprise software
- 17:16giant is about to be replaced. The sources show that
- 17:20Salesforce's stock has actually become a mirror image of AI
- 17:23stocks. When AI searches, Salesforce
- 17:25drops. Yeah, and the logic behind that
- 17:28fear is driven by a concept called agentic AI.
- 17:32Unlike a chat bot that just answers questions, agentic AI
- 17:36can autonomously execute tasks. The worry is that companies will
- 17:40soon be able to use this AI to simply vibe code their own
- 17:43custom databases and customer relationship management systems
- 17:47from scratch, allowing them to abandon Salesforce entirely.
- 17:50It's a direct threat to the traditional Software as a
- 17:53Service or SAS pricing model. Salesforce historically charges
- 17:58per seat, meaning per human user.
- 18:01If an agentic AI does the work of 10 humans, a company needs
- 18:05fewer human employees, which means they buy fewer software
- 18:08licenses from Salesforce. Exactly.
- 18:11But here is where Salesforce executed a brilliant pivot.
- 18:14Instead of fighting the AI Tran, they lean directly into the
- 18:18threat. Well, the gentic work units.
- 18:20Yes, they introduce what they call Agentic work units or AW.
- 18:25They are shifting their revenue model from charging per human
- 18:28seat to charging a micro fee per test completed autonomously by
- 18:33the AI within their ecosystem. I love the football analogy the
- 18:36sources used to explain this shift.
- 18:39Instead of paying a flat fee just to have a player on the
- 18:41roster, whether the player sit on the bench, Salesforce is now
- 18:45saying we'll charge you a tiny fee for every single snap the
- 18:49player actually takes on the field.
- 18:51It's a great way to put it. It aligns Alesforce's financial
- 18:54success directly with the customer's actual roductivity.
- 18:58And the adoption rate proves the pivot is working.
- 19:01They saw a 57% quarter over quarter increase in those
- 19:04agentic work units. But beyond the pricing pivot,
- 19:07the broader market is severely underestimating Salesforce's
- 19:10ultimate Moat, which is institutional risk aversion.
- 19:14Ah, the classic nobody gets fired for buying IBM mentality
- 19:18updated for 2026. Exactly.
- 19:20Nobody gets fired for buying Salesforce.
- 19:23If you are a chief financial officer at a Fortune 500
- 19:26company, your primary job is to mitigate risk.
- 19:29The idea of ripping out a secure, deeply integrated 20
- 19:33year old database system that touches every piece of your
- 19:35company's financial data just to replace it with a cheap open
- 19:38source AI alternative that your IT guy built over the weekend?
- 19:42Oh man, the risk is astronomical.
- 19:44The reward of saving a few $1,000,000 on software licenses
- 19:47doesn't even come close to justifying it.
- 19:49Because if that custom AI breaks and loses customer data or
- 19:52causes a massive security breach, that CFO is resigning in
- 19:56disgrace, right? So while the market treats
- 19:58Salesforce like a dinosaur waiting for the meteor, they are
- 20:01quietly generating massive free cash flow, growing their net
- 20:05income at double digits, and effectively integrating the
- 20:08meteor into their own business model.
- 20:10This brings us full circle to our primary mission today.
- 20:13The overarching narrative we are constantly fed is that you
- 20:15should just put your money in an index fund, close your eyes and
- 20:19let the magic of the market carry you to retirement.
- 20:22And based on the mechanics we've unpacked today, that traditional
- 20:25wisdom is incredibly dangerous right now, when 60% of the
- 20:29market's capital is flying blind without price discovery and 50%
- 20:33of your portfolio's weight is propped up by just 10 stocks
- 20:36entirely dependent on a fragile semiconductor supply chain, you
- 20:40aren't diversified. You are exposed.
- 20:43Right. So for you listening right now,
- 20:46the ultimate take away from these sources is that the lost
- 20:49art of stock picking is returning.
- 20:52Understanding the difference between the stock price and the
- 20:55fundamental value of a business is more crucial today than it
- 20:59has been in decades. Absolutely.
- 21:01You need to be able to identify the difference between a
- 21:04temporarily beaten down cash machine like Chipotle, company
- 21:08fundamentally stumbling like Lululemon and a highly
- 21:11entrenched adapter like Salesforce.
- 21:14Because when that broken anchor finally catches on something,
- 21:17whether it's interest rates rising, the boomers rotating to
- 21:20bonds, or the AI chip supply glutting the market, the passive
- 21:24index is going to field the full violence of that snap.
- 21:27But if you own businesses that generate real, sustainable cash
- 21:31flow and possess strong economic moats, you can weather the
- 21:34storm. Definitely.
- 21:36Before we wrap up, though, I want to leave you with a final
- 21:38thought to Mull over, drawing on a concept from economics
- 21:40mentioned in the sources, Jevin's Paradox.
- 21:43Oh, this is an interesting angle.
- 21:45We keep waiting for AI to cause mass corporate layoffs to
- 21:48justify the hundreds of billions of dollars being spent on this
- 21:51infrastructure. We assume efficiency
- 21:53automatically equals fewer workers, but so far, companies
- 21:57aren't firing people, right? Jevin's paradox suggests that as
- 22:01a resource becomes more efficient to use, demand for it
- 22:04actually increases. Companies are simply expecting
- 22:07exponentially more output from everyone.
- 22:09The goal posts for human productivity just keep moving
- 22:12further away. Exactly.
- 22:14So the provocative question is this.
- 22:16What if the real breaking point of this massive AI cycle isn't
- 22:19the failure of the technology or a glitch in the software or even
- 22:23a shortage of water for the data centers?
- 22:26What if the actual limit to this infinite growth narrative is the
- 22:30physical and psychological limit of human beings trying to keep
- 22:33pace with the infinite output of the machines we've built?
- 22:37Man, that, that is something to think about.
- 22:40Until next time, keep digging, keep questioning, and thanks for
- 22:43joining us on The Deep Dive.