Latest / KAJ Business & Money LIVE / How Organizations Can Recover From Toxic Leadership | Bryan Hughes
Transcript
- 0:34Speaker 1: Welcome to this very special edition of the kg A
- 0:37Masterclass Live, the show which ensures that you profit from
- 0:41your time spent year with experts, either through their industry,
- 0:45in sites information or simply learning from them. And today
- 0:50we have with us doctor Brian Youth is a leadership,
- 0:53an organizational health consultant, researcher. He has led organizations over
- 1:00four thousand people, and we'll learn from him, you know,
- 1:03about toxic leaderships and organizations, and how organizations can recover
- 1:09from toxic leadership and much more.
- 1:13Speaker 2: Welcome to the show, doctor Brian.
- 1:16Speaker 3: Thank you glad to be here.
- 1:19Speaker 1: You're welcome, Welcome to the show. Welcome to India in
- 1:22this online form, doctor Brian. And I'm sure not just
- 1:25in India, but a lot of people, a lot of
- 1:28organizations across the globe will benefit from what we are
- 1:31going to talk right now. We'll talk about organizations, will
- 1:35talk about toxic leadership in those organizations and much more.
- 1:40But before that, let's learn a bit about your journey,
- 1:43your background, so that the audience knows who they're listening to.
- 1:48Speaker 3: Sure, so, I you know, initially I went to university
- 1:52to be a music teacher, right, So that's kind of
- 1:54shaped my journey a little bit, and as I began
- 1:58working as a as a teacher, I realized that, you know,
- 2:02some of the bureaucracy would kill the joy. So I
- 2:05switched gears and I went into sales and then in
- 2:08the into management. Along the way, I went back and
- 2:11refreshed my my education, and you know, grew kind of
- 2:15simultaneously both professionally and academically too. As you had mentioned,
- 2:20you know, I've I've led organizations of uh nearly a
- 2:23billion dollars in in revenue and four thousand you know
- 2:26plus employees. But all along the way, also continued on to
- 2:30earn my MBA and then later my doctorate with a
- 2:32focus on organizational health and toxic leadership.
- 2:38Speaker 1: Absolutely, absolutely so in these times, you know, when there
- 2:43is so much a question about leadership, about you know,
- 2:47toxic leadership, about you know, about leadership in crisis, in
- 2:53the backdrop of the great resignation quite quitting.
- 2:57Speaker 2: Do you do you think you know?
- 2:59Speaker 1: UH organizations will learn, all leaders will learn, especially when
- 3:04people are thinking let's bring in AI, let's make them
- 3:08the leaders. In fact, they are performing better than any
- 3:11of these you know, corner room occupants. How would you
- 3:15like people to understand from that perspective, doctor Bryant, that's
- 3:21a that's.
- 3:21Speaker 3: A great question. So you know, there's a couple of
- 3:24layers to understand in there. You know, when we had
- 3:28the Great resignation and you know, quite quitting as as
- 3:33a byproduct of that, really wasn't a great resignation. It
- 3:37was more a great reevaluation. It was those individuals in
- 3:42employment roles. They didn't just reevaluate their jobs, they reevaluated
- 3:46their lives.
- 3:47Speaker 2: Right.
- 3:47Speaker 3: They begin asking deeper questions, is my work mattered the
- 3:50people I work with care about me? Am I? Am
- 3:52I valued? Or am I just a resource?
- 3:54Speaker 2: Right?
- 3:55Speaker 3: And then the flip side of that is organizations they
- 3:58responded the only way that they knew how. They measured more,
- 4:00you know, more dashboards, more productivity tracking, more analytics. But
- 4:04at the end of the day, you can't spreadsheet your
- 4:07way to human meaning. And this is where a lot
- 4:09of organizations miss the boat and where AI can actually
- 4:13become a challenge because the greatest risk of AI isn't
- 4:18machines acting like humans, it's humans acting like machines. Unfortunately,
- 4:24the business schools for a decade and a half, for
- 4:27maybe even two decades now have been so focused on
- 4:31metrics and KPIs, which are absolutely important. I never want
- 4:35to take anything away from that. Right, we have to
- 4:36measure our results. But the framework of what a quality
- 4:41leader has been coming out of the business schools is
- 4:48around metrical you know, quantitative performance rather than qualitative performance.
- 4:54So now what we're doing is we're dealing with a
- 4:58finite pie of perfor ormance and rather than being additive.
- 5:03And so when you talk about AI ai IS, it's
- 5:11it should be removing minutia. It should be removing tasks
- 5:18that don't require human talent to allow people to work
- 5:22in matters of collaboration and creativity and connection. And the
- 5:28biggest challenge is going to be leaders to reshift their
- 5:32focus from Okay, I have to manage so that my
- 5:36spreadsheet and my dashboard looks better. Instead they need to
- 5:40shift and say, okay, now that the dashboards in the
- 5:44minutia are taken care of, now what can myself and
- 5:47my team do to genuinely create value? Right, and so
- 5:52thinking qualitatively hopefully that answers that.
- 5:54Speaker 1: Question for you, absolutely absolutely, doctor, But let's understand it
- 6:00this way. Firstly, you know leaders themselves, when leaders whatever
- 6:08their trait is. When they talk about success, they meet
- 6:12those numbers. The same toxic traits become the parameters of success.
- 6:18This is what a strong leaders should be. This is
- 6:21how a leader should be. This is how a leader
- 6:24is leading from the front. But the same trait if
- 6:29someone down the line, you know, some junior employee shows,
- 6:33then he or they become toxic for the company. They
- 6:37may get fired. Leaders will get you know, better bonuses
- 6:40and all that stuff. So in this sense, how should
- 6:45we understand what is an organizational culture?
- 6:49Speaker 2: Here?
- 6:50Speaker 1: How should an employee understand what is the right thing
- 6:53to do? What is the wrong thing to do? And
- 6:56it is not about just now, even two years down
- 6:59the line. It will continue to be that because people
- 7:03understand the language of success better. Only when you know
- 7:08that starts creating problems, that they start raising questions till
- 7:13then the leader is a great leader. How do you
- 7:16want people to understand that part of toxicity in leadership
- 7:21as well as organizations?
- 7:24Speaker 3: Absolutely great question. So let me clarify a little bit
- 7:27here and put a definition around toxicity. So toxicity by
- 7:32definition isn't aggressive or abusive. Those those they can be together,
- 7:37but those are almost different leadership typologies. A toxic leader
- 7:42is someone that is self interested and not organizationally focused. Now,
- 7:47you can absolutely perform well at your you know, in
- 7:52your role and maximize your bonuses, but if you do
- 7:55that by by supporting the organization's outcomes, that's not toxicity.
- 8:01Where toxicity is Look, I'm going to be manipulative. I'm
- 8:04going to I don't really care if the company succeeds.
- 8:07It's just about me succeeding. And therefore maybe I will
- 8:10manipulate others or I will use people to get my benefits.
- 8:14And then when that spreads into an organization, it's because
- 8:18it the behaviors are seen by others as allowable and appropriate,
- 8:24and so then other people will duplicate those those behaviors
- 8:27and then it spreads. So for an organization, exactly what
- 8:31you said. Sometimes most executive leadership, they'll see somebody performing
- 8:37at a very high level, and they'll be just they'll
- 8:40be satisfied with that. They'll be satisfied, Okay, they're hitting
- 8:43their numbers, we're going to pay their bonuses, et cetera.
- 8:45But they're not looking again that qualitatively. They're not having
- 8:50the conversations closer to the field and saying, okay, well,
- 8:53how is this leader accomplishing what they're accomplishing, Because if
- 8:57they're accomplishing things through toxic behavior, then it may be
- 9:01okay for a while, it may produce the results you're
- 9:04seeking for a reasonable period of time, but eventually it
- 9:09will catch up and it you know, it depends on
- 9:11the type of organization and other factors, but usually you'll
- 9:15see things like staff attrition. You know, people will be leaving,
- 9:21and then customers will leave and then things collapse. But
- 9:25the executive leadership still looks at past performance, saying, hey,
- 9:28that that leader is a top performer, so now they'll
- 9:32listen to that leader. When the leader is deflecting, oh, well,
- 9:35these customers are leaving because of marketing conditions, or these
- 9:38these employees are leaving because of this factor or that factor,
- 9:43and they'll they'll deflect and I don't know, just defer
- 9:47the blame to others rather than taking personal accountability. So
- 9:52to avoid this, you know, there's types of behaviors that
- 9:56executive leadership should have to ensure that their leaders aren't
- 10:00leading inappropriately, leading into the toxicity that we're trying to
- 10:05avoid in the first place. And that's how you have
- 10:07high performance that is sustainable.
- 10:11Speaker 1: Absolutely, absolutely, doctor Bryant. Let's understand it and test it
- 10:15from this particular anger. Now, with artificial intelligence coming in
- 10:21in an organization, people many people have ethics, they can
- 10:27start questioning.
- 10:28Speaker 2: They will have you know, time, They can move on to.
- 10:31Speaker 1: Another organization and they can question from there or in
- 10:37public or in anywhere else, right to the board of directors,
- 10:41or do much more beyond that.
- 10:44Speaker 2: But with AI coming in, leaders have a lot of trials.
- 10:47Now they can remove more people. Bring in AI.
- 10:52Speaker 1: They will not question as the way humans do, and
- 10:56they will do as the leaders design them to do.
- 11:01Speaker 2: Should we understand that AI.
- 11:03Speaker 1: Is a better friend of toxic leadership or is it
- 11:07a better friend of an organization which values you know,
- 11:11good employees?
- 11:13Speaker 3: Hm, you know. Thinking through that, I think it could
- 11:19go either way.
- 11:20Speaker 2: Right.
- 11:20Speaker 3: AI is a tool, right, And if I use a
- 11:23hammer to build a home for somebody that doesn't have
- 11:26a home, then it then it becomes a good hammer, right,
- 11:29Or if I use it to injure somebody becomes a
- 11:32bad hammer, and it's never the hammer. The hammer is
- 11:34just the tool. AI could be used either of those ways.
- 11:38If we used AI again, as I mentioned earlier to
- 11:41remove the repetitive minutia, freeing people to think, you know,
- 11:49creatively and you know, actually have this level of true collaboration.
- 11:55It can become a powerful amplifier for things that we do.
- 12:00But the flip side of it is AI as a
- 12:03model is you know, whether it's genitive or you know,
- 12:06extending into even a gentave. AI is it's trained on
- 12:11past performance and past behavior. And so therefore if the
- 12:16information that is feeding into it is that from toxicity.
- 12:21There's an individual Dean Gray, and he talks about this
- 12:24idea of digital drift where truth is actually shifting a
- 12:29degree or so within AI, because AI also absorbs bad information,
- 12:36bad technique, bad concepts, and even if you have good
- 12:41outcomes but bad methodology to get there, AI doesn't know
- 12:46because AI, you know, it can optimize decisions, but it
- 12:49cannot determine what is right. And so there's no understanding
- 12:52of ethics in an AI model. And so you can
- 12:56get that digital drift that skews and then that then
- 12:59becomes a friend and of the toxic individuals that are
- 13:03you know, manipulating. So it could be used either way.
- 13:08It's about the.
- 13:08Speaker 4: Intentions, absolutely, absolutely, Doctor Bright now in terms of you know,
- 13:16identifying or you know, recovering your organization from such toxic leadership.
- 13:22Speaker 1: Whose job is to identify toxic leadership, especially when leadership
- 13:29is one of the top leaders or maybe the topmost leader.
- 13:34How will they do it? Who will create the rules
- 13:37to identify? How does it work in today's time?
- 13:42Speaker 2: Doctor Bright?
- 13:44Speaker 3: Let me start with the last part. You know, how
- 13:46it works, There has to be willingness because depending on
- 13:50the role, depending on the type of organization, you know,
- 13:55how it's discovered and how it's dealt with, you know
- 13:58will very but anyone involved has to be willing to
- 14:04take a step back and say, look, we can do better.
- 14:08Are you know? The humans that work for us and
- 14:11with us are not simply just you know, assets on
- 14:15a balance sheet that they're They're legitimately humans that have
- 14:18their own dreams and expectations and their own value and worth,
- 14:21and therefore we they deserve more, right, which isn't usually
- 14:25a conversation that happens at a board of directors level
- 14:27or even a c suite. Sometimes that's only relegated to
- 14:31you know, the human capital partners within the organization. It's
- 14:34not even out, it's even outside of operations. So, you know,
- 14:39board of directors absolutely should pay attention to people metrics,
- 14:45so exit survey, information, ethics, violation reporting, you know, just
- 14:52noticing trends in uh, you know, I would say, you know,
- 14:57not for cause, you know. So voluntary terminations when people
- 15:01leave the organization on their own accord, those absolutely should
- 15:05be a part of a boarder director's conversation as I,
- 15:08as I sit on boards, or as I counsel with
- 15:10board members as a consultant. Right, we have those conversations.
- 15:14The c suite should do that as well when it
- 15:17comes to helping an organization recover. Right, So, let's say
- 15:21you know a middle manager toxic leader. That middle manager
- 15:26is removed. What most often happens is maybe there's some
- 15:31anecdotal words or commentary around, Okay, this person didn't represent
- 15:36who we are. We're gonna move on now, and then
- 15:38it's more or less swept under the rug. When I
- 15:40did my research and tons and tons of interviews around
- 15:45individuals who felt the effects of toxic leadership, the most
- 15:49common phrase used was swept under the rug. That it
- 15:54was acknowledged, but it wasn't addressed, and because of that,
- 15:58they're that I know that next step of actually recovery
- 16:05of healing wasn't done, and therefore the individual it broke
- 16:11down trust and a level of accountability. Right, accountability needs
- 16:14to be mutual. If I, if I receive a paycheck
- 16:18from you, I'm just by nature accountable to you for
- 16:21my performance because you can terminate my role in my
- 16:23future and stuff at at any time. But when organizations
- 16:27feel a sense of accountability downwards towards the field line workers,
- 16:33that mutual accountability, that's where you start to get a
- 16:37conversation that is instead of hey, yeah, this person wasn't healthy,
- 16:42they're gone, and then we're never going to talk about
- 16:44it again. Instead we're saying, we want to make sure
- 16:47this doesn't happen again, So we want to empower you
- 16:49with some skills and some behaviors and some reporting and
- 16:52some other things to try to reverse that tide so
- 16:54that not only does it not happen again creating the
- 16:58effects on the business that's the business objective outcome, but
- 17:02also it re establishes accountability. And you can't have trust
- 17:05unless you have accountability.
- 17:09Speaker 1: Absolutely absolutely, let me understand this way for my audience,
- 17:13doctor Brian. Leaders Toxic leadership not only impacts the immediate
- 17:20aspect of any organization.
- 17:22Speaker 2: They also change the whole culture of.
- 17:26Speaker 1: The organization, and what may seem wrong to another organization
- 17:32seems almost a culture within that particular organization. A lot
- 17:38of things are left to ambiguity, which you know, helps
- 17:42such toxic.
- 17:44Speaker 2: Leaders amidst all these things.
- 17:47Speaker 1: How do you, then, ah, understand what is right and
- 17:52what is wrong? When everything is coming from the top,
- 17:56starts from the top, you know, and goes down to
- 18:00the bottom. It's not never the other way. How does
- 18:04that work? How do you whose job is it? Is
- 18:07it the authorities from outside?
- 18:10Speaker 2: Is it? Is it the legal authorities? How does that this?
- 18:14Speaker 1: Or it might take a long time, It may be
- 18:16many years before people come to know about it, or
- 18:20the organization itself is borne by then.
- 18:24Speaker 3: Yeah, no, you're absolutely right, you know. So culture by definition,
- 18:30in an organizational culture is the shared beliefs and practices
- 18:35of the of the group. So too many organizational leaders
- 18:40executives believe that culture shaping is you know, slogans or
- 18:46mottos on the wall, or things that are talked at
- 18:51the people. But the real culture is what people do
- 18:56on their own, what people do when nobody's looking what
- 18:58what is the natural reaction into X, Y or Z behaviors?
- 19:03And so if we're really going to understand and activate
- 19:08and function with a culture change, right is we need
- 19:13to approach that from both directions. So from the top
- 19:17down exactly as you said, right that that level of authority, Now,
- 19:21it can absolutely depend. I know you have a global audience,
- 19:23so you know outside authority and legislation, and you know
- 19:28regulation varies, you know, dramatically in different countries and continents.
- 19:34But as a as a rule, at the organizational level,
- 19:39top down, it's not just what you say, it's what
- 19:41you do. And I know that's very logical, but that's
- 19:44not what most people actually do in practice. So have
- 19:49the difficult conversations, have skip level interviews. Senior executives should
- 19:55spend time in the field to understand what is the
- 19:57lived experience of of the people on their team at
- 20:02all levels of the organization. Right, Yes, executives have jobs
- 20:07that only they can do, and where are they going
- 20:10to find the time they need to make the time.
- 20:12But when they spend time in the warehouses or in
- 20:15the fields, or in the sales process and they get
- 20:20to experience that, it gives them the context to then
- 20:25help validate or question the data that usually is driving
- 20:29their decisions. That's a culture shift from the top down,
- 20:34from the bottom up is we need to create communication methods,
- 20:38we need to empower, and we need to challenge assumptions.
- 20:41Right when a junior manager has it a I don't
- 20:47know whatever, a one on one or a performance conversation
- 20:49with that line level associate and the line level associate
- 20:53says no, everything's fine, that junior manager needs to say no,
- 20:57really tell me what it's like, tell me what's going
- 21:00on right, and and we need to have that. We
- 21:05need to build those patterns, you know, psychological safety as
- 21:09a term maybe that we would use in that environment,
- 21:12but where people feel like they can speak up, where
- 21:14they don't feel like there's you know, retaliation or retribution,
- 21:17they don't feel like their job is at risk. Because
- 21:20when when you have correct and accurate information going from
- 21:26the bottom up, and then you have modeled behaviors and
- 21:31not just slogans on the wall coming from the top down,
- 21:35that's how you take a culture shift. And yes, it
- 21:39will take time, you know, it's it's not quarter to
- 21:41quarter like you know, like our our board meetings are
- 21:44it's it's something that's probably you know, six, nine, twelve months,
- 21:48depending on where the starting point is in the organization
- 21:51to begin with.
- 21:54Speaker 1: Right, right, doctor Bright, you have something called, you know,
- 21:57the culture Recovery Framework, a tool behavioral modification tools that
- 22:04helps leaders recover from toxicity or mitigate its risk before
- 22:09it's spread.
- 22:11Speaker 2: So who is this tool for?
- 22:13Speaker 1: Is it after after the leader has been removed or
- 22:16somehow the leader has a change of art or mind
- 22:19and they want to change. How does this particular framework
- 22:23work and for whom does this framework work? Is it
- 22:27for the toxic leaders or is it from the employees side.
- 22:33Speaker 3: You know, zooming the lens out a little bit. It works,
- 22:35It applies across all organizations, so it was done not
- 22:39just for the for profit you know, companies and corporations.
- 22:43It also works for nonprofit organizations and ecclesiastical groups and
- 22:47maybe even to an extent, families. Right, there's some shared
- 22:51dynamics and all of those around the principles of accountability
- 22:54and trust. And so yeah, you could approach it from
- 22:58two directions. One is after you've removed a toxic leader,
- 23:03and whether that toxic leader is the person at the
- 23:05top or that toxic leader somewhere in between. Then you
- 23:08can go through this framework and work through these behaviors
- 23:12to first instill accountability where the individual feels that the
- 23:16organizational is accountable to them, and then the individual accountability
- 23:20where the individual feels that their manager, their supervisors accountable
- 23:26to them. And then we reverse that going through the
- 23:28trust cycle with a list of behaviors and activities and
- 23:31actions to actually walk people through this process. That's absolutely
- 23:37great if you've removed a toxic leader. If there isn't
- 23:40a toxic leader that is obvious or there isn't one
- 23:45in the moment, these behaviors create a certain level of
- 23:49resiliency because toxic leaders, as much as and I never
- 23:52want to fault the recruiters or talent acquisition, but toxic
- 23:57leaders are generally very high intelligence, and they know how
- 24:02to manipulate personality tests and interviews and other things, and
- 24:08so as much as we try to screen out these
- 24:10kinds of individuals in the hiring process, they work their
- 24:14way through. There's also a reality that if a toxic
- 24:17leader is removed but the organization is not healed, that
- 24:21other individuals who were previously not demonstrating toxic behaviors but
- 24:28they've seen other people get away with it, that they
- 24:30will evolve into a toxic leader from inside. And so
- 24:34we need to create cultures that are resilient against toxic leaders.
- 24:39And so by working through that framework right consistently, it's
- 24:43not a one and done so it's a set of
- 24:45behaviors that we instill and we start to expect as
- 24:49standard processes and behaviors within the organization. You move that
- 24:55process through. Now, when a toxic leader comes into the
- 24:58organization and gets through all of the best efforts we have,
- 25:01they will find that, look, they can't manipulate people, they
- 25:06don't have the same pull when they try to create
- 25:08triangulation and put this person against this person, they'll find
- 25:12that's just not accepted in that organization. And people at
- 25:15all levels of the organization speak out and call them
- 25:17out on those behaviors. They will self select out and
- 25:20leave the organization. And so, you know, sometimes i'll see
- 25:24within side healthy organizations is a certain number or group
- 25:29of people that will leave the organization at you know,
- 25:32manager or director levels, maybe you know, within that first
- 25:35three to six months. And that's actually a good sign
- 25:38in that particular case, because it means that they're they're
- 25:41creating an antagonistic environment that toxic leaders don't want to
- 25:45be a part of because they know that they're not
- 25:48going to be able to get their way.
- 25:51Speaker 1: Absolutely, absolutely, there's so much to learn about all this
- 25:55from you, doctor Brian, and I'm sure a lot of people,
- 25:58a lot of organizations would want to a lot of
- 26:00leaders whould want to connect with you and learn more
- 26:03about all this.
- 26:05Speaker 2: What's the best way for them to do so, you.
- 26:08Speaker 3: Know, a great way to start is to go to
- 26:10culturequiz dot clear day Strategies dot com, and by doing
- 26:15that they can get an idea of where their organizational
- 26:20culture and organizational health is from there. And then of
- 26:23course my contact information is on there and they can
- 26:25reach out to me directly. But it's always good to
- 26:29get a baseline of where you're at, right as long
- 26:32as people answer the questions. Honestly, it's a scientific tool
- 26:35that we've developed that will give them a understanding of
- 26:38where their real risk points are.
- 26:41Speaker 1: Wonderful, but this is set up on this very special
- 26:45edition of the Cage Masterclass.
- 26:47Speaker 2: Like, thank you so much indeed for joining us.