Latest / Reformed Thinking / Hope | C. S. Lewis
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to reformed Thinking.
- 0:01It's good to be back. We are jumping right in today.
- 0:05As the name of our show suggests, we like to take a
- 0:07substantial text, something with some real weight to it, and well
- 0:12see how it holds. Up.
- 0:13See how it aligns with Scripture, how it helps us make
- 0:16sense of things. Exactly.
- 0:17And today we're looking at maybe the most influential Christian
- 0:22apologist of the 20th century, CS Lewis.
- 0:25Specifically, his book Mere Christianity.
- 0:28But we're not trying to tackle the whole thing.
- 0:30That would be ambitious. We're zooming in on just one
- 0:33chapter. It's the chapter titled Hope.
- 0:35And this is a timely subject. I find that in our circles, you
- 0:39know, people who hold to the Westminster standards, people
- 0:41who love good solid theology, we can sometimes be a bit
- 0:45suspicious of the word oh. I know I am.
- 0:47When I hear hope used out in the world or even in some churches,
- 0:50it just sounds like optimism, right?
- 0:54Wishful thinking. Yeah, it sounds like a cat
- 0:55poster that says hang in there. Just feels a bit flimsy.
- 0:58We prefer terms like justification or sanctification,
- 1:02something you can really get your teeth into.
- 1:05But Lewis is so helpful here because he doesn't treat hope as
- 1:09a mood, he treats it as a virtue.
- 1:12A theological virtue, in fact. Right.
- 1:14It's right up there with faith and charity.
- 1:16Which means it's not optional. It's not something you just
- 1:19happen to have if you're a naturally sunny person.
- 1:22It's a discipline. It's a duty.
- 1:24Lewis argues, that this continual looking forward to the
- 1:28eternal world is not a form of escapism, which is what the
- 1:31critics always say. He says it's something a
- 1:33Christian is meant to do. It's part of the machinery of
- 1:36the Christian life. And that's our mission.
- 1:38For this deep dive, we're going to unpack why Lewis thinks
- 1:42aiming for heaven is the only practical way to live on Earth.
- 1:45We'll look at the three ways humans deal with their internal
- 1:48longing. And yes, we're going to try to
- 1:50make sense of the harps and crowns.
- 1:51The imagery of heaven is always a stumbling block, so we'll
- 1:54definitely need to spend some time there.
- 1:56OK, let's start with the paradox.
- 1:58Lewis opens this chapter with a historical observation that I
- 2:01think is just brilliant. He could completely flips the
- 2:05script on the idea that if you're thinking about the next
- 2:07World, you're useless in this one.
- 2:10That's the standard critique, isn't it?
- 2:11He's so heavenly minded. He's of no earthly good.
- 2:14You hear that all the time. All the time, yeah, But Lewis
- 2:17says the historical record proves the exact opposite.
- 2:20He does. He points right to the apostles.
- 2:22I mean, these were men who were arguably more focused on the
- 2:25return of Christ in the Kingdom of heaven than anyone who has
- 2:28ever lived. And yet, who did more to change
- 2:32the face of the ancient world? Nobody.
- 2:35They set the conversion of the Roman Empire in motion.
- 2:38They didn't just preach an idea. They fundamentally altered
- 2:41society's view on the value of human life.
- 2:44The whole social fabric changed. Then he points to the Middle
- 2:47Ages. The men who built that
- 2:48civilization, the ones who created the universities and the
- 2:51cathedrals, were men who believed firmly in a hierarchy
- 2:54of values that all pointed to God.
- 2:56And then his third example, which is maybe the most concrete
- 2:59one, the English evangelicals. This is a great one because it's
- 3:02so tangible. We're talking about men like
- 3:06William Wilberforce, men who abolished the slave trade.
- 3:10These were not secular humanists.
- 3:12They weren't driven by some modern idea of human rights.
- 3:16They were driven by a deep biblical conviction that every
- 3:19single human is made in the image of God and is an eternal
- 3:23being. Their focus on eternity is what
- 3:26gave them the stamina to fight the massive economic structures
- 3:29of their day. So the argument is that because
- 3:32their minds were anchored in the next World, they had a much
- 3:35longer lever to move this one. Correct.
- 3:37They left a permanent mark on earth because their minds were
- 3:40occupied with heaven. And Lewis twists the knife a bit
- 3:43here. He says that Christians, you
- 3:45know, in the modern world have largely ceased to be effective,
- 3:48and the reason isn't that we're too heavenly minded.
- 3:50It's that we aren't heavenly minded enough.
- 3:52Exactly. We've stopped thinking about the
- 3:54other world. We've become so desperate to be
- 3:56relevant here and now that we've lost the very thing that made us
- 3:59distinct, the very thing that gave us any power to change
- 4:02things in the first place. He boils this all down into a
- 4:05rule, and if you take one thing away from the chapter, I think
- 4:08this is it. I agree, He says aim at heaven
- 4:11and you will get earth thrown in.
- 4:14Aim at Earth and you will get neither.
- 4:16Aim at Earth and you will get neither that.
- 4:20That's a chilling thought. It implies this strange, almost
- 4:24backwards law of reality. It definitely can't get the
- 4:27secondary thing by making it the primary thing.
- 4:30It just doesn't work. It feels so counterintuitive
- 4:33though. If I want to fix society,
- 4:35shouldn't I focus 100% of my energy on fixing society?
- 4:38Logic would seem to say so, but Lewis uses an analogy that just
- 4:42clarifies it perfectly. He talks about health.
- 4:44Relate to this one we all want to be healthy of.
- 4:47Course, health is a blessing. It's a good gift.
- 4:50But the moment you make being healthy your primary direct goal
- 4:54in life, what happens? You become a hypochondriac.
- 4:57You're the person who's constantly measuring their food,
- 4:59checking their polls, worrying about every little ache and
- 5:01pain. You become a crank, as Lewis
- 5:03puts it. You become anxious, and
- 5:06ironically, that very anxiety is terrible for your health.
- 5:10So by trying to grab health too tightly, you end up strangling
- 5:13it. So how do you actually get
- 5:15health? You get it by aiming at
- 5:17something else. You aim at enjoying a good game,
- 5:19or taking a long walk, or doing a good day's work.
- 5:22You aim at the activity itself, the joy of it, the satisfaction
- 5:25of it. And the health gets thrown in as
- 5:28a sort of bonus. This applies to so many things.
- 5:30Happiness too. If you wake up and say today my
- 5:33goal is to be happy, you will almost certainly be miserable.
- 5:37But if you wake up and say today I'm going to build this
- 5:39bookshelf or I'm going to help my neighbor with their yard, you
- 5:42might just find yourself happy by lunchtime without even
- 5:45trying. And Lewis applies the same logic
- 5:47to civilization. We hear so much talk today about
- 5:50saving Western civilization. It's.
- 5:52A constant talking point. But Lewis warns us that we will
- 5:55never save civilization as long as civilization itself is our
- 5:58main object that's aiming at Earth.
- 6:00So what's the answer? We have to learn to want
- 6:03something else even more. We must want God.
- 6:06We must want the Kingdom of heaven.
- 6:08If we prioritize the eternal, the temporal civilization gets
- 6:12preserved almost as a byproduct. It's the logic of idolatry,
- 6:15isn't it? Right.
- 6:16When you put a created thing in the place of the creator, you
- 6:19don't just offend God, you end up ruining the very thing you
- 6:22were trying to worship. Corrupt it precisely.
- 6:25So, OK, if the rule is aim at heaven, why is that so difficult
- 6:31for us? Yeah.
- 6:32Lewis then shifts gears to talk about our internal wiring.
- 6:35He says most of us find it very hard to want heaven at all, You
- 6:39know, unless we're just thinking about seeing loved ones who've
- 6:41died again. He points out a couple of
- 6:43obstacles. The first one is just a lack of
- 6:45training. Our whole culture, our
- 6:47education, our entertainment, it fixes our minds on this world,
- 6:51right? We're trained to be practical
- 6:52materialists, even if we say we're Christians that.
- 6:54There's a more subtle reason, he gives It's not just that we're
- 6:57distracted, it's that we don't even recognize the desire for
- 7:00what it is when we feel. It this is where Lewis is at his
- 7:03absolute best. He's like a physician of the
- 7:05soul here. He says that if we really
- 7:07honestly look into our own hearts, we will find that we do
- 7:10want and want acutely something that cannot be had in this
- 7:15world. He talks about the false
- 7:16promises of the world, and he isn't necessarily talking about
- 7:19sin here. He's talking about good things.
- 7:21Right. He lists things like the first
- 7:23time you fall in love, or just thinking about a foreign country
- 7:26you've always wanted to visit, or taking up a new subject that
- 7:29just completely captivates your mind.
- 7:32We've all felt that, that initial spark, that feeling that
- 7:35says this is it, this is what I've been waiting for.
- 7:38But then what happens? You get married.
- 7:40You finally travel to that country.
- 7:42You master the subject. And it's it's not quite what you
- 7:44thought it would. Be and we have to be so careful
- 7:46here. Lewis is not saying these things
- 7:48are bad. He's not saying you have a bad
- 7:50marriage or you went on a bad vacation.
- 7:52That's such a critical distinction.
- 7:54He explicitly says he's talking about the best possible
- 7:57outcomes. The wife is wonderful.
- 7:59The hotel is excellent. The job is deeply rewarding.
- 8:03He's describing success. And yet, even in that success,
- 8:06something is missing. There was something in that
- 8:09first moment of longing, a kind of promise that the reality
- 8:13didn't quite keep. He says something has evaded us.
- 8:17It's like trying to catch a scent on the breeze.
- 8:19You know it's there, you run toward it, but you just can't
- 8:21hold it in your hand. He suggests that the object, the
- 8:25person, the place, the piece of music, it wasn't the thing
- 8:29itself, it was just a channel or minder.
- 8:32We caught a glimpse of something through that object, but when we
- 8:35tried to grab the object itself, we realized it was just a
- 8:37signpost. So we're left with this gap.
- 8:40We have a desire that seems infinite, but we live in a world
- 8:43of finite things, and Lewis says there are basically three ways
- 8:47people deal with this tension. The three archetypes of the
- 8:50human condition. I think every person listening
- 8:52can probably fit themselves or people they know into one of
- 8:55these categories. OK, let's start with the first
- 8:57one. He calls it the Fool's Way.
- 8:59The fool puts the blame on the things themselves.
- 9:01He feels that disappointment we were just talking about.
- 9:04He gets the new car and the thrill fades.
- 9:06He gets the promotion and the job becomes routine.
- 9:09But his diagnosis is simple, I just picked the wrong one.
- 9:14So his solution is just to swap it out for a new one.
- 9:16Exactly. If only I had a different wife.
- 9:19If only I had a bigger house. If only I'd gone to a different
- 9:23university. The Fool is convinced that the
- 9:25ultimate satisfaction is available here on Earth.
- 9:28He just missed the target this time around.
- 9:30So he spends his life. Lewis uses the word trotting.
- 9:34I love that word trotting. It's so descriptive.
- 9:36It's this restless, almost undignified movement.
- 9:39He trots from woman to woman, which leads to the divorce
- 9:42courts. He trots from continent to
- 9:43continent. He trots from hobby to hobby,
- 9:45always thinking that this latest thing is finally the real thing.
- 9:49And he's always disappointed. Always because he's trying to
- 9:52get infinite satisfaction out of a finite object.
- 9:55It's a basic mathematical error. You just can't fit the ocean
- 9:58into a bucket. And you see this everywhere in
- 10:01our consumer culture. The entire advertising industry
- 10:04is built on promoting the Fool's Way.
- 10:06You're unhappy? Well, it's because you don't
- 10:08have this product. It creates this endless cycle of
- 10:11hope and despair. OK, let's look at the second
- 10:13character, and I suspect this one is maybe more common among
- 10:18the kind of responsible people who might listen to a show like
- 10:21this. Lewis calls him the
- 10:23disillusioned, sensible man. This is the man who's decided
- 10:26that the whole business of longing was just, well, nonsense
- 10:30moonshine, as Lewis says. He looks back at his youth, at
- 10:34the poetry, the romanticism, all those intense desires, and he
- 10:37just says, well, that was just being young.
- 10:39He decides to grow up to lower his expectations.
- 10:42He represses that part of himself that used to cry for the
- 10:45moon. He decides that life is just
- 10:46about being comfortable paying your taxes, doing your duty and
- 10:49not making too much of a fuss. And Lewis is fair here.
- 10:53He admits that socially speaking, this is a much better
- 10:56way to live than the fool's way. Oh certainly this man is a much
- 11:00better neighbor. He pays his bills, he doesn't
- 11:02abandoned his family to go chase some fantasy.
- 11:05He isn't a nuisance. He is, as Lewis says, probably
- 11:08happier in a day-to-day sense. But.
- 11:10There's a huge cash. A massive flaw.
- 11:12This man tends to become a bit of a prig.
- 11:15He looks down on people who are still hopeful or idealistic.
- 11:18He calls them adolescents or dreamers.
- 11:21But the real danger isn't his social arrogance.
- 11:24The real danger is theological. What if the longing wasn't
- 11:27moonshine? What if the rainbow really does
- 11:29have a pot of gold at the end? That is the terrifying question
- 11:33Lewis asks, supposing infinite happiness really is there,
- 11:36waiting for us. If that's true, then the
- 11:38sensible man has done something absolutely tragic by cultivating
- 11:43the so-called common sense. By callousing his own heart to
- 11:46avoid disappointment, he has actually stifled the very
- 11:50faculty in himself that was designed to enjoy that
- 11:52happiness. He finds out too late, a moment
- 11:55after death, that his caution was actually a catastrophe.
- 11:58He killed the very hunger that was meant to lead him to the
- 12:00feast. He.
- 12:00Starved himself to death because he decided that food didn't
- 12:03exist. Which brings us finally to the
- 12:06third option, the Christian way. And this is where Lewis moves
- 12:10from just observation to apologetics.
- 12:12He uses what's often called the argument from desire.
- 12:16Walk us through the logic here. It all rests on this
- 12:18relationship between appetite and supply in the natural world.
- 12:22Lewis starts with a simple biological fact.
- 12:25Creatures are not born with desires unless satisfaction for
- 12:28those desires actually exists. Give us his examples.
- 12:31A baby feels hunger? Well, there is such a thing as
- 12:35food. That doesn't mean that specific
- 12:36baby will get food right then. But food is a real thing that
- 12:40exists in the universe. The hunger corresponds to a
- 12:42reality, right? A duckling wants to swim?
- 12:45Well, there's such a thing as water.
- 12:47Men feel sexual desire while there's such a thing as sex.
- 12:49So the existence of a natural innate desire is pretty strong
- 12:53evidence that a corresponding object exists somewhere.
- 12:56Correct. So the Christian looks at the
- 12:57data from his own heart. He says I find in myself the
- 13:00desire which no experience in this entire world can satisfy.
- 13:04The frill says I just need more stuff from this world.
- 13:08The sensible man says the desire is fake, but the Christian says.
- 13:12The Christian says the desire is real, but the object it's
- 13:15pointing to is not in this world.
- 13:19Therefore, the most probable explanation is that I was made
- 13:21for another world. That is such a relieving
- 13:24thought. It just reframes everything.
- 13:25It does. If these earthly pleasures don't
- 13:28satisfy the deepest longing, it doesn't prove that the universe
- 13:31is a cosmic fraud. It just proves that earthly
- 13:34pleasures were never meant to satisfy.
- 13:36It they were only meant to arouse it.
- 13:37Exactly To subject the real thing, Lewis calls them copies
- 13:41or echoes or mirages. It's like you're hiking and you
- 13:45see a beautiful mountain range in the distance.
- 13:47You enjoy the view, but you don't try to eat the mountain.
- 13:50You don't get angry that you can't put the mountain in your
- 13:52pocket. You appreciate it for what it
- 13:54is, a pointer to something vast and wonderful.
- 13:58And this leads to a very specific set of duties for the
- 14:00Christian because we still have to live here, we still have to
- 14:03deal with all these copies. We do, and Louis warns against
- 14:07two errors here. First, we must not despise
- 14:11earthly blessings. This is where some Christians
- 14:14can go wrong. You know, they become these grim
- 14:16ascetics who seem to hate the world.
- 14:18But the world is God's good creation.
- 14:21We should be deeply thankful for a good meal, a beautiful sunset,
- 14:24a loving family. But we must never, ever mistake
- 14:28them for the real thing. We can't try to turn the copy
- 14:31into the original. That is where all the heartbreak
- 14:33comes from. We have to keep the desire
- 14:35itself alive. That's the key.
- 14:37Lewis says we have to make it the main object of life to press
- 14:40on to that other country and to help others do the same.
- 14:43We have to make sure that our desire for our true home doesn't
- 14:45get snowed under by all the cares and distractions of this
- 14:49life. It's an act of discipline.
- 14:50Then you have to constantly remind yourself, this is good,
- 14:54but this isn't it. This is a very nice inn, but I'm
- 14:56still on the Road home. OK, so Speaking of this other
- 14:59country, we have to address the imagery because when we talk
- 15:02about heaven, people, even many Christians, get a bit
- 15:05uncomfortable. We have all these cartoons in
- 15:07our heads. Lewis calls them the facetious
- 15:09people, the ones who try to make the Christian hope sound
- 15:12ridiculous. They say things like, well, I
- 15:14don't want to spend eternity playing a harp.
- 15:16Or I don't want to sit on a damp cloud forever.
- 15:19It all just sounds incredibly boring.
- 15:21Lewis is quite sharp here. His response is basically, if
- 15:25you cannot understand books written for grown-ups, you
- 15:28shouldn't talk about them. He does not suffer fools gladly.
- 15:31No, he doesn't. He explains that all of the
- 15:34script imagery, the harps, the crowns, the gold, the jewels,
- 15:38it's all a symbolical attempt to express things that are, by
- 15:42their very nature, inexpressible.
- 15:44We're trying to describe a reality that exists outside of
- 15:47time and space, but we only have language that's stuck inside
- 15:50time and space. So we have to use analogies, we
- 15:52have to use symbols. OK, so let's decode them then.
- 15:55Why harps? Why is everyone in the Cosmic
- 15:57Orchestra? It's not about the instrument
- 15:59itself. Scripture uses musical
- 16:01instruments because for many people, music is the one thing
- 16:05in this life that most strongly suggests ecstasy and Infinity.
- 16:10It's the closest we get on Earth to a feeling of pure,
- 16:13unadulterated glory. So when the Bible says harps,
- 16:17it's really saying it will be like that feeling you get when
- 16:21the Symphony swells to its climax, but infinitely more and
- 16:24forever. Correct, it's just shorthand for
- 16:27ecstasy. OK, what about crowns?
- 16:30That sounds like we're all going to be kings, which seems like a
- 16:32logistical nightmare. I mean, who are we ruling over?
- 16:35It's not about bureaucracy or having political power over your
- 16:39neighbors. Crowns are mentioned to suggest
- 16:41that those who are united with God in eternity will share in
- 16:44His splendor, His power, and His joy.
- 16:47So it's about our status in the family of God.
- 16:49We're not just subjects. We become sons and heirs.
- 16:51It suggests the true elevation of the human spirit.
- 16:54We will finally become what we were always meant to be.
- 16:57And the gold streets of gold. Again, it's it's not about
- 17:01economics. It's not that heaven has a good
- 17:03stock market. Gold is used to suggest the
- 17:05timelessness of heaven. Gold's done at rust.
- 17:08It doesn't decay. It's immutable.
- 17:11So it suggests a kind of beauty that lasts, a value that never
- 17:15fades. Exactly.
- 17:16So when people take these symbols literally, they're just
- 17:18making a massive category error. Lewis ends this section with a
- 17:22very funny comparison. He says people who take these
- 17:25symbols literally might as well think that when Christ told us
- 17:28to be like doves, he meant that we were supposed to lay eggs.
- 17:32That really puts it in perspective.
- 17:34We're talking about spiritual realities, not poultry farming.
- 17:38And we have to remember that the spiritual reality is the solid
- 17:41thing. We tend to think of our material
- 17:43world as hard and real, and the spiritual world as something
- 17:48misty or ghostly. Lute suggests it's the other way
- 17:51around. Heaven is the ultimate solid
- 17:54reality. We're the shadows until we get
- 17:56there. Which lines up perfectly with so
- 17:59much of Reformed theology. The idea that God is the most
- 18:01real being the ends realism of everything else just derives its
- 18:05reality from Him. And if we are in Christ, we are
- 18:08moving toward that greater reality.
- 18:10We're actually becoming more real everyday.
- 18:12So. Let's try to bring this all
- 18:13together. We started with the idea that
- 18:15hope isn't a mood, it's a theological virtue.
- 18:20We established that strange rule.
- 18:22Aim at heaven and you get earth thrown in.
- 18:25Aim at earth and you get neither.
- 18:27And we saw the historical evidence that the most effective
- 18:30people in this world were those most oriented toward the next.
- 18:34Then we looked at the human condition, that persistent,
- 18:37nagging sense of dissatisfaction.
- 18:39Which is not a defect, it turns out.
- 18:40It's a feature. It's the signature of our
- 18:43design. And we looked at the three ways
- 18:45we can be the fool, constantly chasing new toys and blaming the
- 18:49old ones for not satisfying us. We could be the sensible man
- 18:52we're pressing our deepest joy just to stay comfortable.
- 18:55Or we can be the Christian. The Christian who recognizes the
- 18:59hunger as proof that the food exists, who follows the scent of
- 19:02the flower back to the hidden garden.
- 19:04The Christian way seems to be the only one that really honors
- 19:07both the desire we feel and the reality of the world we live in.
- 19:10It allows us to enjoy the world for what it is, a beautiful
- 19:13echo, without crushing it by demanding that it be the
- 19:15original voice. It's incredibly liberating.
- 19:18Think about the freedom in this view.
- 19:20If I know my true home is somewhere else, I can stop
- 19:23demanding that this world be perfect.
- 19:26I can forgive my spouse for not being God.
- 19:28I can forgive my job for not being heaven on earth.
- 19:32That takes a huge amount of pressure off of everything.
- 19:34It allows us to just enjoy things as created things without
- 19:38trying to wring every last drop of ultimate happiness out of
- 19:42them. We can just receive them with
- 19:44gratitude. I want to leave our listeners
- 19:45with a final thought to chew on. We usually treat disappointment
- 19:49as an enemy. When we feel that little bit of
- 19:52emptiness after a big achievement or after a really
- 19:55great vacation ends, we feel let down.
- 19:58We feel like something went wrong.
- 19:59We wonder if we made a mistake or if it just wasn't as good as
- 20:02we'd hoped. But based on what we've
- 20:04discussed today from Lewis, I want to challenge you to view
- 20:07that feeling differently. What if you saw that empty
- 20:10feeling not as a failure, but as a signal?
- 20:13A signpost. A signpost pointing you to your
- 20:15true country. If you can shift your
- 20:17perspective that way, then that moment of dissatisfaction
- 20:20becomes a moment of quiet assurance.
- 20:23It's your soul reminding you that you are not home yet, but
- 20:26that home is real and you're on your way there.
- 20:29That's the. Realism of looking forward.
- 20:31Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into CS Lewis.
- 20:35This has been reformed thinking. Until next time.