Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️112 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 12 Oct Air quality Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. It's kind of preposterous sitting through a public inquiry into a proposed gold mine in The Sperrins, listening to detailed arguments about how much toxic industrial dust might be acceptable, at the very same time that the Northern Ireland government is consulting on a new strategy to reduce air
- 1:16pollution. On one side of this extraordinary situation, we have the Department of Agriculture, Environment, and Rural Affairs telling us that cleaner air is essential for public health. And on the other, we have an application to introduce a substantial dirty industrial operation into one of the most
- 1:37beautiful and environmentally sensitive landscapes in the country, complete with the prospect of toxic fugitive dust emissions, fine particles potentially carrying heavy metals, escaping into the air and travelling beyond the boundaries of the mine site to settle on our land, our water,
- 1:58and ultimately find its way into our lungs. A landscape where the air is still clean enough to be taken for granted, where the wind moves over blanket bog, through the heather, and across the mountain slopes, carrying the smell of wet peat, grass, and rain. I know which of those two versions of the future I
- 2:21would prefer, but here we are. The proposed clean air strategy for Northern Ireland is currently out for consultation, with responses due later this month. Our chief medical officer, Professor Sir Michael Macbride, has described air pollution as a major environmental risk to human
- 2:42health, associated with respiratory and cardiovascular disease and lung cancer. He has also highlighted the disproportionate burden carried by vulnerable communities. Right now, there's a great deal of effort being devoted to improving the quality of the air we breathe, because prevention,
- 3:04as I understand it, is supposed to be preferable to spending the next several generations trying to repair the damage. And with our health service already on its knees and the enormous cost of treating illness, surely it makes more sense to tackle the causes than spend a fortune sticking plasters over the
- 3:24consequences, especially when some of that damage can never be undone. Today the inquiry was dealing with air quality, and we heard further submissions about dust, particulate matter, metals, monitoring, and the assumptions used to predict what might be released from the proposed mine. As usual, some of
- 3:51the discussion was highly technical. There were calculations, tables, modelling inputs, references to appendices, and the familiar chorus of assurances from the applicant, but occasionally a detail emerges that reveals a huge amount that perhaps the applicant would prefer us not to
- 4:11know about, much less understand the consequence of. One of those details today concerned density of dust particles. Doctor Thomas Cummins from University College Dublin School of Agriculture and Food Science had examined the applicant's air quality assessment and questioned the density values used in the
- 4:34modelling. The figure was 1.7 grammes per cubic centimetre. Doctor Cummins argued that this appeared to be a bulk density value, whereas the modelling required the density of the individual particles themselves. He pointed to values closer to 2.7 or three grammes per cubic centimetre, including. Specific
- 5:00gravity of 2.73 identified in the mine waste management documentation. In a topic such as today's clean air, it's hardly the type of detail you would want to get wrong. Bulk density takes account of the spaces between particles in a material. Particle density. concerns the solid material
- 5:25itself. A pile of dust contains air spaces. An individual mineral particle does not contain those same spaces. And when you are trying to calculate how particles travel through the air, how quickly they settle, and where potentially contaminated dust might be deposited. Getting the physical
- 5:50properties right is an essential part of the job. The applicant's rebuttal maintained that the value of 1.7 was appropriate and conservative for the assessment.
- 6:04There was also a substantial error pointed out in the unit measurement, as originally printed, which the applicant acknowledged as a typographical mistake. Doctor Cummins responded by returning to the distinction between bulk density and particle density. So we had two different positions on a
- 6:26modelling input that could influence the predicted movement and deposition of dust. I found myself thinking about the extraordinary confidence with which these assessments are asserted and then presented to the public as fait accompli, as though the calculations are beyond question, and the
- 6:47conclusions already settled. We are given the outputs of sophisticated computer models, with figures calculated to several decimal places, and encouraged to regard the resulting predictions as reassurance, but you know, rubbish in equals rubbish out. And here was a scientist
- 7:11questioning one of the most basic physical values fed into that process. The decimal places look very impressive. They become less comforting when the people examining the calculations cannot agree on what should have gone into them, and this was not the only detail Doctor Cummins challenged. He
- 7:31also identified inconsistencies in the presentation of the metals being assessed. The competent text referred to six metals, including lead and mercury, while a table only contained four. There was even a chemical symbol incorrectly assigned to tellium. Tallium is Tl, and Th is thorium. I
- 7:56appreciate this may sound like an obscure little er, but these are technical documents being used to support a proposal with environmental consequences extending far beyond the lifetime of the mine. We are entitled to expect precision, particularly when the subject is the possible deposition of
- 8:17airborne chemical and metal particles into landscape of rivers, peatlands, farm lands, homes, and the lungs of people. There was further disagreement about mercury in different mine waste streams. The applicant clarified that the scavenger tailings referred to in the discussion would not be placed
- 8:38in the dry stack facility and disputed the significance of the concern. Today's experience at the public inquiry really illustrates how difficult it has become for ordinary members of the public to follow the constantly shifting technical detail of this application, the type of waste, its composition,
- 8:59where it goes, how it is stored, what becomes airborne, and how that is calculated. Each part has its own collection of documents, explanations, and qualifications. And somehow, through all of this, we are expected to emerge feeling reassured. Dust suppression also featured in the discussion, the
- 9:22applicant's model assumes a 75% reduction in dust emissions through measures that include applying water. There were questions about how much water would be needed, how often it would be applied, and the difference between the area being actively worked and the much larger footprint of the
- 9:40proposed dry stack facility. It brought to mind that remarkable balancing act we have been hearing about throughout this inquiry. We need water to keep the dust down. We need careful manage we need careful management of water to prevent pollution. We need the waste sufficiently sufficient. Dry for
- 10:01the proposed storage system, while also preventing it from becoming dry enough to blow away. And we are assured that all these competing requirements can be managed. And then there is the matter of what we know, or don't know, about the air quality before any mining begins, the applicant has relied
- 10:24on baseline air quality information collected in earlier years, including monitoring undertaken around 2015 and 2016. The applicant considers that information suitable for the assessment, but concerns were raised about whether the existing monitoring gives an adequate representative picture
- 10:47of current conditions, like now, today, across communities and wider landscapes that could be affected. There is a difference between having some historic measurements and having sufficiently detailed record of the air people are breathing today, and that difference becomes enormously important
- 11:09once an industrial development begins operating and becomes a source of toxic emissions. Today's hearing also brought contributions from people who understand that air pollution is experienced by living bodies, and is much more than the average figures in a modelling table. Leona Quig spoke from her
- 11:30professional experience in paediatric neurology and neurodevelopment, raising concerns about children's vulnerability and the combined effects of pollutants. The applicant maintained that the assessment standards account for sensitive groups, and that the predicted effects would be
- 11:49negligible. Ah, yes, that old chestnut, negligible effects, a wonderful, convenient little phrase that has made so many appearances at this inquiry.
- 11:59It must surely qualify as the most memorable phrase of the inquiry. Tish McElwae spoke about the Green Castle community, including the Youth Club, and the long-established Boxing Day road run, which brings more than 1000 people out onto the roads. The applicant's response included the
- 12:17observation that runners would experience only transient exposure. Transient is one of those words that sounds wonderfully reassuring when delivered in the measured tones of a barrister. I presume the runners will be delighted to learn that their exposure is transient, especially those who
- 12:35have spent five miles inhaling great lungfuls of mountain air. The people of Greencastle have been running those roads long before Dalradian arrived with its plans, its consultants, and its productions, and the air they breathe belongs to their everyday lives. It's not an inconvenient variable to be
- 12:52accommodated in someone else's industrial calculations. There was another incident towards the end of the day involving Mary Brawley, our solicitor, who received a formal warning from the commission. My understanding of what happened is that the commission believed Mary was seeking to revisit a matter that
- 13:11had already been addressed. Mary challenged that assumption. She explained that she had intended to raise a completely different issue, denied deliberately disrupting the proceedings and asked for the warning to be withdrawn. The commission did not resolve the matter there and then and indicated that
- 13:29proceedings would resume tomorrow. But I will say that sitting through this inquiry, I have become increasingly conscious of the difficulty facing by those trying to challenge an application of this scale, the applicant has teams of specialists, legal representatives, and
- 13:45consultants, all operating within a process they understand intimately. Local people and those representing them are expected to navigate the same procedures, often while trying to bring forward concerns that have emerged from years of living in and caring for this place, and when there's a
- 14:05misunderstanding about what somebody is trying to say, the consequences can be unsettling to witness. A public inquiry ought to be a place where concerns can be properly heard and tested. That is especially important when the consequences of the decision may remain with a community for generations, the
- 14:26rest of the day unfolded with the familiar procession of predicted concentrations, acceptable limits, mitigation measures, and monitoring arrangements, all wheeled out alongside the assumptions on which these reassuring predictions depend. The applicant remained steadfast in
- 14:44its confidence that everything could be sufficiently controlled, while those challenging the application continued the exhausting business of trying to establish whether the evidence justified even a fraction of that confidence, and all the while. Beyond the walls of the hearing
- 15:01room, The Sperrins carried on being what they've always been-a living landscape with people on its valleys, farms scattered across its hillsides, birds crossing open mountains and rivers, carrying the waters of the peatlands down through the generations of communities who call this place home-and the air
- 15:20moves through all of it. There will be no convenient boundary at the edge of the mine site telling the wind where it is permitted to travel, nor will there be an opportunity once development has begun to return to this moment and to collect measurements of conditions that no longer exist, and that is the
- 15:41concern of Hugh McLeod, brought to the inquiry today. Hugh is a father from Mid Ulster, whose young child was diagnosed with leukaemia in 2023. His family's experience has given him a very personal understanding of what it means to search for answers about health and exposure, he has been careful not to
- 16:04attribute those cancers to the proposed mine or its exploration activities. His concern is that when families need answers, missing evidence cannot be recovered by reassurance. Hugh has very kindly recorded his reflections on today's hearing, the importance of proper air quality baseline surveys, and
- 16:25the responsibility to gather information while there's still an opportunity. I'm going to leave the final word with him.
- 16:32Hello, my name's Hugh McLoey, and I'm from Dripperstown, father of a young child who was diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia in 2023, and one thing I can say before talking about the inquiry is: once cancer comes through your front door, you learn very quickly that answers matter.
- 16:55What was checked? What wasn't? What do we know? And what are we still waiting to find out? And that's what brought me to the gold mine inquiry today. The minister cancer concern was previously described by the public health agency as an allegation in the inquiry. I corrected that today because it
- 17:17is actually ongoing monitoring, as stated by the health minister and also previous health minister, but that made me think about the inquiry. What has actually been said in there? What's been taken for Tris? It it baffles me. So I'm not saying that the proposal already in mine. or the aspiration caused
- 17:45those cancers. But in the same hand, if something caused those cancers, there's not enough data to root it out, along with other things. So I'm saying, in our experience here in Mador, should teach everyone a lesson, including the commissioners, about collecting evidence when you have the chance. Because
- 18:08when families ask questions, we don't have the data is a very different answer from we have investigated and ruled that out. You cannot turn a gap in your knowledge into reassurance for somebody else. Today I raised what people are breathing. My understanding is that if you follow the prevailing wind, the
- 18:31most common wind which runs from southwest to northeast from Oma or from the Dalriadian site, the wind travels over The Sperrin mountains, through Cookstown, Dribberstown, Mackelfeldt, Maharaja, on up the shoreline of Loch Ness, over through South Antrim, and it will take to Balamina until you find a
- 18:55monitoring station that is capable of picking up particulate matter, and that matters because it's too far away. I raise that gap because people live along that whole route, and their exposure, not just to the potential mine but to everything else, cannot simply be be read off a distant
- 19:17monitor. So how much fine particulate matter are are we breathing? What's in it? Where are the current representative measure measurements? If the authorities had those answers today, they didn't put them on the table, and they most certainly cannot show us the locations and dates of tests
- 19:40done or monitoring done, because it's a data black hole, central and middle ster right over The Sperrins. Think of it this way: before you hand over a house, you photograph its condition. You record the crack in the wall, the mark in the ceiling, or the state of a roof. You don't wait until the builders
- 20:02have finished, take your photograph, and then try to agree what damage was done there beforehand. Air quality baseline is that first photograph. Except, this is the air going into people's lungs. This is the air carrying particulate matter that can cross three placetas into unborn children. That's why
- 20:24I told the commission today: no application shall be approved until an adequate representative air quality baseline has been established. Get the monitors in, collect the samples, capture the seasons, the weather, and the changes in the wind. Establish how much particulate matter is there and what it
- 20:41contains. You have one chance to directly measure those conditions before development changes them. Now, later modelling may later modelling may help estimate the past, but it cannot go back in time and collect a sample nobody took. I also looked at what the applicant's documents say. The
- 21:03Enves air quality assessment in Appendix C 19 says in page 94 that deposited dust will be tested for a suite of metals, so they know that the dust that's going to be coming off the site is going to be full of contaminants. But the monitoring programme does Not show explicitly, nor identify, for
- 21:24example, lead two 1o or polonium 200 testing, radioactive products in the iridium and the radon decaygon. Measuring total lead or uranium mass does not by itself tell you the radioactive activity of those particular substances. Then you have the RPS Health Impact Assessment Appendix C 14 says in page 31
- 21:47that mining derived discharges will be minor. It points to a separate radon assessment. Well, we need to see better workings out for that. Where are the decay products assessed?
- 22:01Where do they travel to, where might they settle, what additional exposures predicted, and how will anyone check that prediction? Now, I'm not saying the presence of a radioactive system substance automatically means a harmful exposure. The amount and dose do matter, however, and that's precisely
- 22:22why the measurement and calculations matter. If the evidence answers those questions, produce it. If newer documents change the picture, identify them. If testing is considered unnecessary, explain the evidence behind that decision. My request to the applicant and dear is
- 22:40straightforward: establish the baseline before approval. Check the predictions, preserve the records, and publish the results. Families should never have to ask years down the line. Down the line, what were our children exposed to? Mums should never have to ask down the line. What was I exposed to when I was
- 22:57pregnant? And then to discover that the opportunity opportunity to collect the evidence was allowed to pass, we cannot promise that every future health question will have an answer, but we can collect the evidence now while we still have the chance. And today was very surreal because it fitted into
- 23:20what I was reading in the news and on the media, there seems to be an absolute absence of data that's been treated as a reason for no concern. The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and I hope the commissioners took that away with them today to think about.
- 23:44You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation are available in
- 24:02the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our
- 24:21voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.