Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Why We Pathologize Normal Behavior
Transcript
- 0:00I mean, imagine you're just like walking down
- 0:01the street, right? And you see someone meticulously
- 0:04avoiding every single crack on the sidewalk.
- 0:06Oh, yeah. Like they're tracing patterns in the
- 0:09air with their fingers, maybe whispering rapidly
- 0:11to themselves. Exactly. And your immediate instinctual
- 0:14thought is probably, well, you know, that's not
- 0:16normal. Right. But what actually makes you or
- 0:19me or anyone else normal? Like, are you just
- 0:22operating on a lucky genetic blueprint? Or, you
- 0:24know, are you the product of a perfectly balanced
- 0:27childhood? Or, and this is the big one, Are you
- 0:30just conforming to this completely arbitrary
- 0:33set of rules that society just collectively decided
- 0:35on yesterday? Yeah, because the moment you try
- 0:37to actually pin down an objective definition
- 0:39of normal, the entire concept just starts to
- 0:43disintegrate. Totally. Like we want this clear
- 0:45black and white boundary separating healthy from
- 0:47pathological, but human behavior just refuses
- 0:50to fit into neat little boxes. Welcome to the
- 0:53psychology undergrad. We are two passionate psychology
- 0:56students digging into the thick of our coursework
- 0:58for you. And today we are unpacking chapter 10
- 1:01of Ed Newgrug's 2022 textbook. Right, the chapter
- 1:04on abnormal development, diagnosis, and psychopharmacology.
- 1:08It's a heavy one. It really is. And as we wade
- 1:11through these massive concepts of how the mental
- 1:14health field defines and treats atypical behavior,
- 1:18we realize the line between what is considered
- 1:20a quirk and what is labeled a clinical disorder
- 1:23is incredibly blurry. It is. And the author actually
- 1:27shares this striking personal anecdote early
- 1:29in the chapter that perfectly captures that tension.
- 1:32Oh, right. About his early days as a therapist.
- 1:34Yeah. So when Newcrug first started, he actively
- 1:38resisted diagnosing his clients. He viewed labels
- 1:42as, you know, reductive, like something that
- 1:44boxed people in. Which makes sense. But out of
- 1:47pure professional necessity, he had to learn
- 1:50the diagnostic manual, the DSM. And he admits
- 1:53in the text, he says, It soon became my Bible.
- 1:57I love that quote. Calling the DSM a Bible is
- 2:00a brilliant lens for us to use today. It really
- 2:02is. Because it is essentially the ultimate sacred
- 2:05text of modern psychiatry. I mean, it dictates
- 2:07the rules, defines the suffering, and prescribes
- 2:10the rituals for healing. Exactly. So to keep
- 2:13all this dense textbook material grounded for
- 2:16you listening, we are going to lean into that
- 2:18spiritual framework. We'll use religious analogies
- 2:21to conceptualize how different schools of psychology
- 2:23view human suffering. Because before you can
- 2:25interpret a diagnostic Bible, you really have
- 2:27to understand the origin stories, right? You
- 2:30need to look at the different Genesis narratives
- 2:32that competing theories use to explain the creation
- 2:34of human behavior. Right, how the mind fractures
- 2:36in the first place. So let's open with the first
- 2:40Genesis story, the biological and genetic model.
- 2:43OK, so in our framework, this would be the predestination
- 2:46analogy. Yes, predestination. Historically, there
- 2:48was this very deterministic idea that if you
- 2:51carried a specific gene for say schizophrenia
- 2:54or depression, your fate was just sealed from
- 2:56birth. But modern biology completely rejects
- 2:59that kind of strict genetic fatalism. It is never
- 3:02just one single gene causing a complex psychological
- 3:06disorder. Right, it's highly polygenic. Exactly.
- 3:09Our genes provide a blueprint, like a biological
- 3:11predestination, but they do not dictate the final
- 3:14structure. The crucial mechanism here is epigenetics.
- 3:18Which is the interaction between your DNA and
- 3:20your environment. Yeah. I always picture epigenetics
- 3:22like a massive soundboard in a recording studio.
- 3:25Oh, that's a good way to look at it. Yeah, so
- 3:27you might be born with the anxiety slider pushed
- 3:29up slightly higher than someone else based on
- 3:32your genetics. But the environment, like prenatal
- 3:34nutrition, childhood trauma, chronic stress,
- 3:37or even poverty, that acts as the sound engineer.
- 3:40Right. The environment is what physically reaches
- 3:42out and pushes that genetic slider all the way
- 3:44to maximum volume or mutes it entirely. So the
- 3:47environment holds the pen, even if genetics bought
- 3:49the paper. That's a great way to put it. Now,
- 3:52moving from the physical brain to the invisible
- 3:54mind, we hit our second Genesis story, the psychoanalytic
- 3:58model. Born from the one and only Sigmund Freud.
- 4:01Yep. And if biology is predestination, psychoanalysis
- 4:05is spiritual warfare. Definitely. Freud argued
- 4:08we are thrust into the world driven by these
- 4:10dark, unconscious, sexual, and aggressive instincts.
- 4:14And the structural model of the mind he proposed
- 4:16is literally an internal moral battlefield. You
- 4:19have the id, which operates entirely on the pleasure
- 4:21principle. Those are your base animalistic temptations,
- 4:24just screaming for immediate gratification. Exactly.
- 4:27Then you have the superego, which is the internalized
- 4:30voice of societal commandments and moral judgment
- 4:33constantly inducing guilt. And trapped in the
- 4:36crossfire of all that is the ego, the rational
- 4:39self, just desperately trying to mediate this
- 4:41eternal spiritual warfare without suffering a
- 4:44complete psychological break. And that internal
- 4:46war is fought across specific psychosexual stages
- 4:50of childhood development, you know, oral, anal.
- 4:53phallic latency in general. Right. And Newcrook's
- 4:56text emphasizes that abnormal behavior in adulthood
- 4:59is the direct result of getting stuck or fixated
- 5:02in one of these early developmental battles,
- 5:04usually due to poor parenting. Yeah. And the
- 5:07textbook's breakdown of the anal stage, which
- 5:09happens around one and a half to three years
- 5:11old, is wild, but it illustrates this perfectly.
- 5:13It really does. The stage is all about potty
- 5:15training, which is fundamentally a child's first
- 5:18real negotiation with societal control. And Freud
- 5:20posited that if parents are excessively strict
- 5:23or punitive or shaming during this process, the
- 5:26child digs their heels in. The bathroom becomes
- 5:29a battleground for autonomy. And they might grow
- 5:31into an anal retentive adult. Someone who is
- 5:34rigidly over controlled, stubbornly obsessed
- 5:37with orderliness and like aggressively stingy.
- 5:41They are quite literally withholding themselves
- 5:44from the world. Conversely, if parents place
- 5:47far too much emphasis on the act of defecating.
- 5:49like praising it excessively. The child might
- 5:53feel a profound sense of loss once the waste
- 5:55is flushed away. Right, and to compensate for
- 5:58that internal void, they could develop anal expulsive
- 6:01traits. Yeah, becoming wildly disorganized, recklessly
- 6:05generous, or even hoarders in adulthood, constantly
- 6:08trying to hold onto objects to replace what they
- 6:10feel they've lost. Okay, but pulling back for
- 6:13a second, is this actually how modern clinicians
- 6:16view hoarding or OCD? Because attributing adult
- 6:19hoarding to childhood bathroom habits feels like,
- 6:22I don't know, historical baggage we just have
- 6:24to memorize for exams. That's a super fair pushback.
- 6:28Very few practicing psychologists today are drawing
- 6:31a direct line between a messy apartment and how
- 6:34someone was potty trained in 1995. Right. But
- 6:37the underlying mechanics of Freud's theory remain
- 6:40undeniably foundational to the field. How so?
- 6:43Well, the core premise that our adult defensive
- 6:46behaviors or unconscious mechanisms designed
- 6:49to protect us from unresolved childhood anxieties
- 6:52and relational wounds, that is still the bedrock
- 6:55of much of modern therapy. Oh, okay. So the specific
- 6:58stages might be outdated, but the concept of
- 7:01the unconscious driving the vehicle is permanent.
- 7:04Exactly. Though behaviorists looked at all that
- 7:07invisible, unmeditable, unconscious warfare and
- 7:10threw it entirely out the window. Which brings
- 7:12us to our third Genesis story, Learning Theory.
- 7:15which we can frame as the karma analogy. Right.
- 7:19Thinkers like B .F. Skinner argued we are basically
- 7:21born as blank slates. There's no id, no superego,
- 7:25no inner demons. To a strict behaviorist, your
- 7:28entire personality is simply an accumulation
- 7:30of reinforced behaviors. Every single action
- 7:33you take is shaped by operant conditioning in
- 7:35your environment. You are the sum total of your
- 7:39psychological karma. It's this continuous lifelong
- 7:43cycle of cause and effect. And as undergrads,
- 7:46we don't need to rehash the basic definitions
- 7:47of positive and negative reinforcement. But looking
- 7:50at how they physically construct a mental illness
- 7:52is terrifying. Oh, definitely. Like, we can see
- 7:57exactly how negative reinforcement builds a debilitating
- 8:00anxiety disorder like agoraphobia. Right. So
- 8:03if you have a panic attack in a grocery store,
- 8:06fleeing the store immediately removes the terrifying
- 8:09stimulus. And that relief powerfully, neurologically
- 8:13reinforces the behavior of fleeing. Yep. The
- 8:16next time you even think about the store, you
- 8:18feel anxious, so you stay home. The anxiety drops.
- 8:21You've just reinforced avoidance again. And through
- 8:25continuous negative reinforcement, the walls
- 8:27of your world just shrink until you cannot leave
- 8:30your house. You aren't fundamentally broken or
- 8:33fighting an unconscious war. Your environment
- 8:36has simply rewarded dysfunctional avoidant patterns
- 8:39so consistently that they became your reality.
- 8:42But the beauty of the karmic model is that if
- 8:44you change the reinforcements, you can extinguish
- 8:47the pathology. Which is super empowering, but
- 8:50it's also incredibly mechanical. Yeah, it treats
- 8:53humans like biological algorithms, which is why
- 8:56the fourth Genesis story, the humanistic approach,
- 8:58emerged as this massive rebellion. And this is
- 9:01our inner light analogy. Carl Rogers and Abraham
- 9:05Maslow rejected both the dark, instinctual pessimism
- 9:08of Freud and the robotic determinism of Skinner.
- 9:12Humanists argue we are born inherently good.
- 9:15We possess this natural upward drive toward self
- 9:18-actualization. But to reach that pinnacle, you
- 9:22have to navigate Maslow's hierarchy of needs,
- 9:24starting at the base with fundamental physiological
- 9:27survival. Moving up through physical safety.
- 9:30than the need for love and belonging followed
- 9:32by self -esteem. And only when those foundational
- 9:35needs are secure can a person truly self -actualize
- 9:38and fulfill their unique potential. The tragedy
- 9:41occurs when society, or parents, conditionally
- 9:45gatekeep that third tier, love and belonging.
- 9:49Rogers called these conditions of worth. Like
- 9:52when a parent subtly communicates, I will only
- 9:55love you and accept you if you pursue this career
- 9:58or act this way or suppress this part of your
- 10:01identity. Right. And to survive and secure that
- 10:05necessary love, the child dims their inner light.
- 10:09They create a false self that pleases the environment,
- 10:13which results in a state of incongruence. They
- 10:16are completely disconnected from their authentic
- 10:18experience. And to a humanist, abnormal behavior
- 10:21isn't a disease to be cured. It is the agonizing
- 10:24symptom of a soul that has been forced to abandon
- 10:27itself. And Newcrug includes the deeply unsettling
- 10:29case study of Ellen West to illustrate the lethal
- 10:32consequences of this dynamic. That story is heartbreaking.
- 10:37Ellen was a vibrant, ambitious woman whose parents
- 10:40placed immense conditions of worth on her. They
- 10:43explicitly forbade her from marrying the man
- 10:45she genuinely loved and pressured her into a
- 10:48marriage with a distant cousin just to maintain
- 10:50their social standing. She completely lost her
- 10:53autonomy and her inner light. And to exert some
- 10:56semblance of control and to numb the crushing
- 10:59despair of living a lie, she developed severe
- 11:02anorexia. She was bounced between prominent psychiatrists
- 11:05who viewed her not as a suffering human being,
- 11:08but as a fascinating cluster of symptoms. Yeah,
- 11:11they slapped varying diagnoses on her, treated
- 11:13her with cold clinical detachment, and entirely
- 11:17dehumanized her. Stripped of her authentic self
- 11:19and met with zero clinical empathy, she ultimately
- 11:22took her own life. The humanistic critique here
- 11:25is devastating. Ellen West wasn't killed by an
- 11:28intrinsic biological disease. She was killed
- 11:30by an environment that refused to offer her unconditional
- 11:33positive regard. She was pathologized by a medical
- 11:37establishment that completely ignored the very
- 11:39real societal cage she was trapped in. Which
- 11:42perfectly sets the stage for the most radical
- 11:44Genesis story, the postmodern and social constructionist
- 11:48approach. Right. So if the others are predestination,
- 11:52warfare, karma, and inner light, this is the
- 11:57myth analogy. So postmodernists argue that there
- 12:00is no objective underlying structure to personality.
- 12:03There is no measurable true self. They argue
- 12:07that what we consider reality is entirely constructed
- 12:10through language, primarily by those holding
- 12:12institutional power. The textbook uses a fantastic
- 12:15thought experiment called color therapy to break
- 12:17this down. I love this one. Yeah. So imagine
- 12:20a society where the leading psychiatric authorities
- 12:23establish a consensus that your favorite color
- 12:25dictates your mental stability. They decide that
- 12:28loving the color red indicates a robust, healthy
- 12:31psyche. While an affinity for the color blue
- 12:34is a symptom of a severe deteriorating mental
- 12:38illness. If you walk into a clinic in that society
- 12:40and admit your favorite color is blue, the clinician
- 12:43will immediately diagnose you, pathologize your
- 12:47preference, and perhaps even institutionalize
- 12:49or medicate you to force you to like red. The
- 12:53distress the blue lover feels when ostracized
- 12:55by society is very real, but the label of mental
- 12:58illness applied to them is entirely a social
- 13:01construct. Postmodernists argue our current diagnostic
- 13:04categories are largely myths we've agreed upon
- 13:07to categorize individuals whose behaviors disrupt
- 13:10the current social machinery. Wait, so are they
- 13:12saying mental illness doesn't objectively exist,
- 13:14like at all? Well, they clarify that they view
- 13:17abnormal behavior as a social construct rather
- 13:20than an inherent truth. We treat deviations from
- 13:24the societal norm as objective medical diseases.
- 13:27Okay. So to a postmodernist, an individual experiencing
- 13:31a hallucination isn't necessarily broken in an
- 13:34objective sense. They simply have a deeply atypical
- 13:37way of processing reality. Exactly. But because
- 13:41that behavior makes society deeply uncomfortable
- 13:43and disrupts capitalist productivity, the medical
- 13:47establishment brands it a pathology. So, we have
- 13:50these five radically different lenses for viewing
- 13:53human suffering. Yet, pragmatically, over one
- 13:56fifth of Americans will meet the criteria for
- 13:59a diagnosable mental disorder in any given year.
- 14:01And the mental health field requires a standardized
- 14:04language to process that sheer volume of distress.
- 14:07Which brings us to the actual mechanics of our
- 14:09diagnostic Bible, the DSM -5. The Diagnostic
- 14:13and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Tracking
- 14:16its evolution from the DSM -1, published in 1952,
- 14:19to the modern DSM -5 is fascinating. It really
- 14:23is. The first edition was essentially a psychoanalytic
- 14:26text, deeply concerned with neuroses and unconscious
- 14:29conflicts. But today, it strives for a highly
- 14:32objective, a -theoretical biological approach
- 14:35based purely on observable symptom clusters.
- 14:39One of the most critical structural changes moving
- 14:41from the old DSM -4 to the current DSM -5 was
- 14:45the total abandonment of the multi -axial system.
- 14:48Right. Previously, clinical disorders like major
- 14:50depression were on axis 1, but personality disorders
- 14:54and intellectual disabilities were banished to
- 14:56a separate axis, axis 2. And that separation
- 14:59carried immense stigmatizing weight. By isolating
- 15:03personality disorders on their own axis, the
- 15:06manual implicitly communicated to clinicians
- 15:08that these conditions were fundamental, intractable
- 15:13flaws in a person's character rather than treatable
- 15:16conditions. So collapsing everything into a single
- 15:19axis system in the DSM -5 was a deliberate move
- 15:23to reduce that stigma and unify our clinical
- 15:26approach to human suffering. And when you look
- 15:29under the hood of the text, it's not just a catalog
- 15:32of names. The mechanics of how clinicians use
- 15:35the DSM require extreme precision. You don't
- 15:39just receive a blanket diagnosis of PTSD. Clinicians
- 15:43use subtypes and specifiers. You might be diagnosed
- 15:47with PTSD with prominent dissociative symptoms,
- 15:51severe. They also utilize provisional diagnoses
- 15:54when the clinical picture is blurry. A clinician
- 15:57might write rule out bipolar 1, signaling that
- 16:01the symptoms heavily suggest it, but they need
- 16:03to observe the client longer before cementing
- 16:05the label. Or they might note traits, indicating
- 16:09someone exhibits narcissistic behaviors without
- 16:12crossing the threshold into a full -blown personality
- 16:15disorder. Most importantly, the DSM includes
- 16:18Z codes, which are used to document psychosocial
- 16:21and environmental stressors. Like extreme poverty,
- 16:24going through a brutal divorce, or experiencing
- 16:26homelessness. Z codes force the clinician to
- 16:30acknowledge that the patient is not just a walking
- 16:32brain chemistry set. They are a human being reacting
- 16:35to a potentially crushing environment. But if
- 16:38the DSM is a sacred text, we run into the classic
- 16:41problem of literal translation. Oh, definitely.
- 16:44If you apply the criteria rigidly without deeply
- 16:46understanding the cultural context of the patient,
- 16:49you risk doing massive harm. The DSM -5 attempts
- 16:52to mitigate this by including a cultural formulation
- 16:55interview, or CFI. The text highlights a specific
- 16:58cultural concept of distress known as ataca de
- 17:01nervios, which translates roughly to attack of
- 17:04nerves in Latin American cultures. It is a culturally
- 17:08recognized normal response to severe acute stress
- 17:11like a funeral or a family trauma. And the symptoms
- 17:14include intense trembling, uncontrollable tearfulness,
- 17:18dizziness, and a profound feeling of losing control
- 17:20over one's body. If a Western -trained clinician
- 17:23observes this and literally translates those
- 17:26symptoms strictly through a standard DSM lens,
- 17:29completely ignoring the cultural framework, it's
- 17:31going to be a disaster. Right. It's like trying
- 17:33to literally translate a sacred text without
- 17:36understanding the historical culture. You'll
- 17:39misdiagnose a recognized cultural expression
- 17:42of grief as a severe psychiatric break, a panic
- 17:45disorder, or even psychosis. You end up pathologizing
- 17:49a cultural difference, which is the exact danger
- 17:51the postmodernists warned us about, because the
- 17:54label dictates the treatment. Exactly. And once
- 17:57a biological diagnosis is locked in, the system
- 18:00moves to biological treatment. We enter the realm
- 18:04of psychopharmacology, the potent, sometimes
- 18:07miraculous, often controversial rituals of modern
- 18:10psychiatry. The text outlines five major classes
- 18:13of medication, and the mechanisms behind them
- 18:16are wild. First, the antipsychotics. When drugs
- 18:19like Thorazine were introduced in the 1950s,
- 18:22they literally emptied psychiatric asylums. By
- 18:25blocking dopamine receptors, they quieted the
- 18:27terrifying hallucinations of schizophrenia, allowing
- 18:30tens of thousands of institutionalized people
- 18:32to return to society. But the mechanism of heavily
- 18:35suppressing dopamine in the brain comes with
- 18:37a steep physical cost. The text emphasizes the
- 18:40severe risk of tardive dyskinesia. which is a
- 18:43neurological condition causing uncontrollable
- 18:46involuntary movements of the face, tongue, and
- 18:48limbs. And it can become permanent even after
- 18:51the drug is stopped. It's a brutal trade -off.
- 18:54Next, we have mood stabilizers, primarily for
- 18:57bipolar disorder. Lithium is the classic here,
- 19:00discovered in the 1800s. Yet its exact mechanism
- 19:03in stabilizing manic episodes is still not entirely
- 19:06understood, which is staggering given how widely
- 19:09it is used. Then we hit the antidepressants,
- 19:13and the historical trajectory here is incredibly
- 19:16bumpy. In the 1930s, the medical establishment
- 19:19literally prescribed amphetamines, straight speed,
- 19:23to cure depression. Which is shocking. Prescribing
- 19:26an intense stimulant to a depressed person just
- 19:29resulted in a brief high followed by a crushing
- 19:32crash and intense paranoia. We eventually evolved
- 19:35to the SSRIs. selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors,
- 19:39in the late 80s and 90s like Prozac. They were
- 19:42hailed as miracle drugs because of how they operate
- 19:45in the synaptic gap between neurons. Normally,
- 19:48after serotonin is released to transmit a signal
- 19:50of well -being, the brain has a reuptake pump
- 19:53that quickly vacuums it back up. And SSRIs physically
- 19:57block that pump, leaving more serotonin floating
- 20:00in the gap to continuously bind to receptors.
- 20:03effectively elevating mood with far fewer severe
- 20:06side effects than older drugs. Fourth are the
- 20:09anti -anxiety medications, primarily benzodiazepines
- 20:12like Xanax or Valium. They work by enhancing
- 20:16GABA, an inhibitory neurotransmitter, effectively
- 20:19putting the brakes on a hyperactive nervous system.
- 20:22They are incredibly, immediately effective at
- 20:25stopping panic, but the brain builds tolerance
- 20:28quickly, creating a high potential for severe
- 20:31addiction and life -threatening withdrawal. Finally,
- 20:33we have the stimulants used for ADHD like Ritalin
- 20:37or Adderall. This is where we see the fascinating
- 20:40paradoxical effect. Yeah, you would think giving
- 20:42a powerful stimulant to a child who is already
- 20:45hyperactive and bouncing off the walls would
- 20:47be a complete disaster. But you have to look
- 20:50at the mechanism. In ADHD, the prefrontal cortex,
- 20:53the executive part of the brain responsible for
- 20:56focus, planning, and impulse control, is actually
- 20:59under stimulated. It's asleep at the wheel. By
- 21:02introducing a stimulant, you wake up the prefrontal
- 21:04cortex. Once the executive function comes online,
- 21:07it can finally apply the brakes to the rest of
- 21:09the brain's hyperactivity, creating that paradoxical
- 21:11calm and intense focus. It is brilliant neurochemistry,
- 21:16but it forces us to confront the ethical rebellion
- 21:18within psychology. Because critics look at the
- 21:21sheer volume of pills we prescribe and ask, you
- 21:24know, are we just heavily medicating normal human
- 21:26reactions to a crazy world? Are these medications
- 21:28genuinely healing biological diseases or are
- 21:31they just chemical straight jackets used to make
- 21:34people quiet and compliant? The textbook introduces
- 21:37us to thinkers like Thomas Sasse and R .D. Lang
- 21:39who championed this exact critique. Sasse famously
- 21:43argued that mental illness is a complete myth.
- 21:46He asserted that what we call illness is usually
- 21:48just a person's entirely logical, albeit distressed
- 21:51response to deeply toxic cultural forces and
- 21:55societal pressures impinging on them. Lange went
- 21:57even further, suggesting that people should be
- 21:59allowed to fully experience and traverse their
- 22:01psychotic breaks without medication, viewing
- 22:04it as a natural mechanism for the mind to heal
- 22:07and reorganize itself. To understand the absolute
- 22:10terror of what happens when the medical establishment
- 22:12unquestioningly applies these labels, we have
- 22:15to look at the 1973 Rosenhan study detailed in
- 22:18the text. Oh man. On being sane in insane places.
- 22:23It remains one of the most chilling indictments
- 22:25of the diagnostic system ever published. David
- 22:28Rosenhaun and seven other perfectly sane individuals,
- 22:31including psychologists, a pediatrician, and
- 22:33a housewife, presented themselves at the admissions
- 22:36offices of 12 different psychiatric hospitals
- 22:39across the country. And they faked only one single
- 22:43symptom. They complained of hearing a vague voice
- 22:46repeating three words, empty, hollow, and thud.
- 22:51That was the entirety of the ruse. Based solely
- 22:55on those three words, all of them were immediately
- 22:58admitted to the psychiatric wards. And the moment
- 23:00they crossed the threshold into the hospital,
- 23:03they stopped faking entirely. They reverted to
- 23:05their normal personalities, spoke rationally
- 23:08with staff, and calmly stated they no longer
- 23:10heard voices. But it did not matter. The doctors
- 23:13diagnosed almost all of them with schizophrenia.
- 23:16Because the label of schizophrenic became incredibly
- 23:18sticky. It acted as an opaque lens. through which
- 23:22every single normal behavior was viewed as pathological.
- 23:26Right. When the pseudo -patients calmly took
- 23:28notes for the study in their journals, the nursing
- 23:30staff didn't ask what they were writing. They
- 23:32documented it in their charts as writing behavior,
- 23:35interpreting it as a compulsive symptom of their
- 23:38psychosis. The enteral patients on the ward figured
- 23:41out the researchers were faking almost immediately.
- 23:43But the highly trained medical staff were completely
- 23:46blind to their sanity. These perfectly normal
- 23:49individuals were locked in these institutions
- 23:51for up to 52 days, forced to agree they were
- 23:55insane and take powerful antipsychotics just
- 23:58to negotiate their release. It fundamentally
- 24:00exposed the terrifying unchecked power of the
- 24:03psychiatric label. And it highlights why the
- 24:05legal context surrounding mental health is so
- 24:08vital. The text notes the landmark 1975 Supreme
- 24:11Court case O 'Connor versus Donaldson. Prior
- 24:14to this ruling, If a psychiatrist slapped a label
- 24:17of schizophrenia on you, the state could lock
- 24:19you in a hospital indefinitely against your will
- 24:22simply for having the diagnosis. The Supreme
- 24:25Court ruled that a mental illness label alone
- 24:27is not enough to strip someone of their liberty.
- 24:29The state cannot involuntarily confine a non
- 24:32-dangerous individual capable of surviving safely
- 24:35in freedom. You must be an active danger to yourself
- 24:38or others. It was a monumental victory for civil
- 24:41liberties. pulling power back from the absolute
- 24:44authority of the diagnostic Bible. And it really
- 24:48synthesizes the entire mission of this deep dive.
- 24:51Exactly. Whether you were navigating your own
- 24:53complex mental health journey, trying to hold
- 24:56space for a struggling friend, or studying to
- 24:58become a counselor yourself, understanding the
- 25:00mechanics of how we categorize humans gives you
- 25:03immense perspective. When you understand the
- 25:06polygenetic predestination, the internal spiritual
- 25:09warfare of early childhood, the karmic cycles
- 25:12of behaviorism, the tragedy of losing your inner
- 25:15light, and the societal myth -making that decides
- 25:18what is normal, you stop seeing the label. You
- 25:22learn to see the deeply complex human being buried
- 25:24underneath it. We must utilize the DSM as a critical
- 25:28tool. a shared clinical language necessary to
- 25:31navigate insurance, organize treatment, and provide
- 25:34relief. But we can never allow it to become a
- 25:36weapon that flattens an individual's humanity.
- 25:40And on a highly practical note from the ethics
- 25:42section, never intentionally alter a client's
- 25:45diagnosis just to appease an insurance company.
- 25:48Yeah, that is textbook insurance fraud. It is
- 25:50profoundly unethical, and it will end your career.
- 25:53A vital warning to close out our reading, but
- 25:56we want to leave you pondering one final lingering
- 25:59thought grounded in that postmodern critique.
- 26:02We've established that our diagnostic Bible is
- 26:04a living document constantly revised as societal
- 26:07norms shift. What is considered a debilitating
- 26:10pathology today might just be a mismatch with
- 26:13modern society. So what behaviors or neurological
- 26:17traits that we casually label as disorders right
- 26:20now, traits we aggressively attempt to medicate
- 26:22away or correct in therapy, might actually be
- 26:25viewed as unique evolutionary advantages or brilliant
- 26:29creative strengths a hundred years from now when
- 26:31society's structure inevitably shifts again.
- 26:34Are we truly curing illnesses or are we just
- 26:37treating the symptoms of refusing to fit the
- 26:40mold? Keep that in mind the next time you see
- 26:42someone walking down the street meticulously
- 26:44avoiding the cracks.