Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP250: The Importance of Direct Mail In Ecommerce - Insights, Impact & Good Practice, with Fractional CMO Anna Wilson
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 0:10feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thoughtleys, and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ecom strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James of Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Today's episode is sponsored by Sentra and Shopline.
- 0:38So let me set the scene for our conversation today for and
- 0:41choose you to our wonderful guest.
- 0:42We're going to be talking about offline media and embracing
- 0:45offline media and e-commerce and things like direct mails,
- 0:47potential impact, good to practice, etcetera.
- 0:49A highly experienced guest today.
- 0:51So warm welcome to Anna Wilson. How are you, Anna?
- 0:54I'm good. Thank you.
- 0:55James. How are you?
- 0:56I'm good. Thanks.
- 0:57Yeah, it's Monday, it's fun. It's sunny.
- 0:59We we're both in a sunny area, so that's good.
- 1:02Before we get into all the questions, and this is going to
- 1:05be a really interesting topic today, do you want to give our
- 1:07listeners a bit of an instruction to you your
- 1:09background and and what is a fractional CMO?
- 1:13Yeah. So I'm Anna Wilson.
- 1:15So I've got just over 20 years experience in the industry.
- 1:20So I started off my career client side, headed up the UK
- 1:26marketing team for a company called Orvis.
- 1:30I then went into agency side over to the dark side so and had
- 1:36kind of various roles at a database marketing agency.
- 1:40I then about seven years ago decided that I didn't want to be
- 1:46agency full time and also I didn't want to be client side
- 1:49full time. But I, I felt there was a gap
- 1:52for in the middle working with brands, retailers mainly so but
- 1:58where I could help them kind of get the most out of their
- 2:02agencies and some of the partners that they worked with
- 2:06also. So over the kind of the last
- 2:09seven years, I've become this almost fractional CMO role for
- 2:13various brands. And in terms of what that means,
- 2:17so for quite a few of the brands I work with, they're not kind of
- 2:22big enough to justify a full time CMO.
- 2:27It's quite an expensive full time hire and and yes, it's not
- 2:32kind of needed in smaller retailers, but some of the
- 2:36skills are. So it's working together with
- 2:39brands on their kind of their marketing priorities, working
- 2:44with the organizational structure of the teens, working
- 2:47with who they pick for their agencies, how they optimize
- 2:51their agencies and just kind of leading the marketing function
- 2:56really. Cool.
- 2:57Yeah, I've definitely seen the rise of the fractional role in a
- 3:00few areas. A marketing and Chief digital
- 3:04officer one seems to be the the big areas.
- 3:06Interesting. So let's get in, let's talk
- 3:09about offline because I'm having now I'm the old man of
- 3:12e-commerce. I haven't been in for about 20
- 3:14odd years. The the kind of the enthusiasm
- 3:18with offline, it goes up and it goes down, it goes up and it's
- 3:21down. And it seems that the
- 3:22conversation around offline marketing, specifically within
- 3:25e-commerce is becoming stronger again.
- 3:28It's getting a lot more attention and love now.
- 3:30Why are you seeing that and and why do you think offline is
- 3:33suddenly more pressing to the? Yeah.
- 3:36So, so this year actually we've seen more brands talk about
- 3:42starting DM and coming into that space.
- 3:45So I think I, I've worked with brands for many years that have
- 3:49started off with the catalogue and actually the, the website
- 3:52was more the order form as opposed to the digital marketing
- 3:57channels driving people to the website.
- 3:59So it's, it's the well, the role of it is a change significantly.
- 4:04I think over the past 20 years, there's obviously a lot of
- 4:09brands that have come into the market and digital marketing has
- 4:13been, well, I wouldn't say easy, but it's been a channel where
- 4:16actually people have been able to kind of grow their grow their
- 4:19business with, with search, social, etcetera playing a huge
- 4:24part in that. As digital has got more
- 4:27expensive, it costs more to reach reach people.
- 4:33It actually is potentially less effective for some than it once
- 4:37was. People are kind of looking at
- 4:39other channels and in the crowded space, direct mail can
- 4:44can stand out. So you can easily miss advert on
- 4:49your Facebook feed, for example. You can't miss something that
- 4:53lands on your doormat. So it's a much kind of you, you
- 4:58have to do something to get it out of your life, so to speak.
- 5:03So if that, even if that involves going, picking it up
- 5:07and putting it in the recycling bin.
- 5:09Greb and create digital flagship stores for iconic brands of
- 5:12today and tomorrow. We are the number one Sentra
- 5:15agency in the world with more than 50 Sentra implementations
- 5:18to date. We are also e-commerce design
- 5:21specialists, platform and tech partner agnostic.
- 5:24Try our new e-commerce design subscription.
- 5:27Visit greben.com. I, I love that that positive
- 5:31view of, well, you've, you've actually got to take the effort
- 5:34to, to throw it. I, I do think it's interesting
- 5:36though, because I definitely feel saturated in terms of
- 5:39digital communication, whether it is on social media.
- 5:42I don't use social media in private life, but I use it for
- 5:44business. So LinkedIn, so much content,
- 5:47e-mail, so much content, SM, s s, so many people are doing SMS
- 5:50reminders, especially around people around like competitions,
- 5:53promotions, giveaways. But it does feel at time you're
- 5:56like, ah, Christ, not another. I just delete, delete.
- 5:59So I can totally see the appeal in an air, in a medium where
- 6:03fewer people are doing it consistently.
- 6:05It's trying to get a bit more headspace from people.
- 6:09Yeah. Also what you have to think
- 6:11about is when you've got a catalogue, especially like I'll,
- 6:14I'll talk mainly about catalogues at the moment.
- 6:17So, but you've got 3248, however many pages of products that
- 6:23you're putting in front of the customer, whereas all the
- 6:26potential customer, whereas with a even with an e-mail when and
- 6:30you potentially have a long e-mail, you only put in so much
- 6:34products in front of them. So it's all about kind of that,
- 6:38that guesswork of which products to put at the forefront where
- 6:41although you have to obviously think about what goes on the
- 6:44front cover, back cover of a catalogue, we've still got the
- 6:47whole rest of the kind of selling space.
- 6:50So it's harder. Well, it's, it's typically why
- 6:54with a catalogue there's higher average order values.
- 6:57So because they're seeing kind of more of the range where on on
- 7:01digital marketing, you just don't get that luxury.
- 7:05Yeah, interesting. And going to talk about
- 7:07misconceptions next, because I, I definitely have heard people
- 7:11say this, that that print isn't for the younger, younger
- 7:14audiences wants to be in social. We we all, you know, I think, I
- 7:17think a lot of people like lazy generalisms about what, what
- 7:20massive groups of people do. What's your take on the
- 7:23relevance of print formats for the, for different audiences,
- 7:26different demographics? And, and I guess the second part
- 7:29to that is how do you make it relevant and interest enough for
- 7:31younger audiences to take it seriously?
- 7:34Yeah, so everybody in the UK anyway has got somewhere their
- 7:40post goes. So the majority of people still
- 7:43have a hole in the door regardless of what age they are
- 7:47so and and still have still have that doormat space with the
- 7:54younger generation, most of their life is now digital.
- 7:58So they even kind of all their bills and other kind of means of
- 8:04contacts is, is through e-mail or through other digital
- 8:08channels. So those well, for that younger
- 8:11audience, they get less on their dormat.
- 8:13And actually it's, you think, you think back to your youth
- 8:18when you if you got a letter or you got something addressed to
- 8:21you. It's kind of that excitement
- 8:24level is, is probably more exciting for AI don't know
- 8:28someone in their early 20s getting something in the mail
- 8:31than it is a 5060 year old who's actually used to it.
- 8:36So in, in terms of the messaging, that's obviously
- 8:41product LED. So you wouldn't, you wouldn't, I
- 8:45don't know, send a, a Boden catalogue focusing on patterned
- 8:51dresses to a 20 year old. You would potentially send an 18
- 8:57year old a skate Hut catalogue or something that's actually
- 9:01more focused to what they're interested in.
- 9:04So it's think it's, it's also thinking about in digital, you
- 9:08wouldn't give exactly the same creative to the younger
- 9:12generation than you would the older.
- 9:14So it's just been smart about who your prospects are and
- 9:17getting the targeting right, really.
- 9:19And do you find the formats vary?
- 9:21Because I, I haven't done, I haven't done or run print
- 9:24campaigns for, for quite a while.
- 9:26But I remember doing a lot of this when I worked for a book
- 9:27club company and experimenting with different formats from
- 9:30short form like Flyers, leaflets and inserts to, you know, maybe
- 9:348 to 12 page castles, then to big full catalogue.
- 9:37So do you find for different, for different age ranges that
- 9:40different formats work? Or is it more the content and
- 9:43the messaging? It's more the content and the
- 9:45messaging. The the format actually is, is
- 9:50driven in many cases by Royal Mail and their pricing.
- 9:54So because what I would recommend is if you have got a
- 9:59large product range, regardless of the age that you're
- 10:02targeting, you want to be going for optimum, optimum cost
- 10:07effectiveness. So it actually can be about
- 10:11putting more in front of them to make use of the paper and the
- 10:13and the postage weight that you can have.
- 10:16I would say with the younger generation, they could be so
- 10:22different types of format in terms of being clever about it,
- 10:27making it kind of stand out. So, but quite often they don't
- 10:32increase them. They're either too expensive or
- 10:36they don't increase the response to kind of go outside the norm.
- 10:42Centre is the only commerce platform built exclusively for
- 10:44fashion brands. Over 300 fashion brands run on
- 10:46centre, including icons like Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie
- 10:49jeans. Centre sol's business logic
- 10:51challenges for fashion brands. I know other platform and they
- 10:53are on a mission to help you scale up rapidly globally across
- 10:56all online and offline channels. Take your fashion brand global
- 10:59faster, further, stronger today and let.
- 11:03Let's Let's move on to our acquisition and retention.
- 11:05So we'll start with acquisition because I think a lot of people
- 11:08who aren't used to offline and mixing it in with digital media,
- 11:12we think, OK, how do I use it for acquisition?
- 11:15Like what, what are the techniques, what works well and
- 11:17how important is this? Is it an acquisition tool?
- 11:20Is it a retention tool? And so where would you
- 11:23recommend, where does this sit in the marketing mix for
- 11:25acquisition and and how does it need to play with other media?
- 11:29Yeah. So for acquisition it's it's
- 11:32very important. So there are methods to to get
- 11:38in front of people that are similar to your own customers.
- 11:44So most of you listening will probably understand Meta and
- 11:51Facebook and the ads and how kind of some of the targeting of
- 11:54those works. So if you, if you think about
- 11:58how you can create look alike audiences in Meta, so, so for
- 12:03example, giving them your best customers and getting them to
- 12:08find people that are, that are similar, it works very much the
- 12:13same in the direct mail space. There's data cooperatives that
- 12:17you can join that do modelling and and get the best people to
- 12:21target. It is obviously more expensive
- 12:25than digital channels for acquisition.
- 12:27Response rates can range anything from half a percent to
- 12:322% of people that you target, and generally the cost to
- 12:38acquire someone through a catalogue can be more expensive
- 12:43than the cost to acquire through digital.
- 12:46However, average order values typically larger and the
- 12:51lifetime value of a customer also can be much higher.
- 12:55And I think some of that is because you've put the whole
- 12:58kind of a significant proportion of the range in front of people.
- 13:02You've been able to tell the brand story a little bit better.
- 13:06They're more loyal because they've kind of spent time
- 13:08digesting that catalogue and ignoring kind of everything in
- 13:13the online space more so in terms of where it sits with the
- 13:19digital space. So it's very important that if
- 13:23you are doing the catalogue for acquisition, you think about
- 13:27what happens when somebody then goes online as well.
- 13:32So you might want to follow it up with social ads, with display
- 13:37ads, with making sure that on Google you're supporting that
- 13:44catalogue landing because there will be extra visitors come in
- 13:47and searching for you. So but it's just kind of
- 13:50thinking about that whole the whole dynamic really.
- 13:53So and the fact that they don't come straight to the website and
- 13:55buy straight away, it is just kind of one touch point in many.
- 14:01I'm intrigued to know like, because obviously we're so used
- 14:04to like digital touch points for conversion now where it's like
- 14:08the medium, the call to action is to go online and, and, but,
- 14:12but how do you see many brands doing this now where they're,
- 14:14they're trying to, they're they're pushing people to
- 14:16contact centres as well for like phone ordering?
- 14:18Or is that just is everyone trying to use direct mail and
- 14:21offline to send people to websites?
- 14:25It's predominantly to send them to websites if, if it is a a
- 14:30product that requires kind of more help to purchase, it might
- 14:35be that there's more kind of direction to go to other
- 14:39channels as well. So, but in most, well with most
- 14:43brands that I work with that have catalogues, 90% of orders
- 14:49are coming through the website more than more than that.
- 14:53So there are telephone numbers on there.
- 14:56So which actually, even if you don't want people to call and
- 14:59place an order, a telephone number on a catalogue offers
- 15:01reassurance. So it's, it's definitely kind of
- 15:05worth having on there. Some of the older generation,
- 15:09there's still telephone calls that comes through an e-mail as
- 15:13well. So, so it's important that
- 15:15you've kind of got those, got those covered.
- 15:17But generally it is to get them to the website, which actually
- 15:23makes it even more key. You're thinking about people
- 15:26landing on that website, the fact that they potentially have
- 15:28got the catalogue in their hand. So data capture comes very, very
- 15:32important because you spent a lot of money to get them there
- 15:35and how you kind of follow on that journey as well.
- 15:38It's interesting that I remember the the good old days of doing
- 15:41direct mail when I when I first started working at the book club
- 15:44companies, when we people just started to build e-commerce
- 15:47websites and people just started to shop online.
- 15:49So it's early 2000s and some of the, well, some of the response
- 15:53mechanisms was people sending cheques in the post or per or
- 15:57yeah, it's yeah, it says proper old school.
- 16:00I think back then, 80% of the customers that I the brand I was
- 16:05working with would send the order form in.
- 16:09Yeah, exactly. I mean some even sent cash and I
- 16:11I imagine some people listening, we should be thinking what the
- 16:14hell used to happen. It's a crazy day.
- 16:16Let's talk about retention then. So what strategies were, because
- 16:21obviously at acquisition stage you can, you can get data sets
- 16:23out there to like model on look alike audiences, but you don't
- 16:26really yet know what people are buying and their behavioural
- 16:29stuff. Once you get into the retention
- 16:31line, you've got a bit of extra data.
- 16:32You know more about the customer.
- 16:34How should how should strategy shift?
- 16:35What is the role then in direct mail and how personalized can
- 16:38and should it be getting? So many brands still don't
- 16:43personalize at the retention level.
- 16:45Or if they they personalize, it's more so they will have.
- 16:52So for example, the beginning of the catalogue where there may be
- 16:55an intro for new customers, it may be a bit different for for
- 16:59retention audiences. It might be the like the founder
- 17:04of the brand talking to them as as if they're a friend.
- 17:08Also offers will be personalized.
- 17:11So quite often the people that haven't bought for a period of
- 17:16time with the lapse lapses, they, they will get a stronger
- 17:20offer, similar potentially to acquisition offers in terms of
- 17:26getting kind of more granular with what they've purchased.
- 17:30There are other kind of means out there now within the DM
- 17:35space. So one you've got just more kind
- 17:40of DMS you can do focused on different audiences.
- 17:44So it might be that some brands send a letter to their VIPs or
- 17:49whatever, but more so now there's, there's programmatic DM
- 17:54coming into into the space. So think, think about how you
- 18:01would do automated campaigns on e-mail.
- 18:04So you have your post purchase flows, your abandoned baskets,
- 18:08your win back campaigns. There's there's now the kind of
- 18:12the means to do that in Adm environment as well.
- 18:19Interested. Yeah, I've, I'm, I've already
- 18:22been intrigued by how personalized people are going to
- 18:23get because it, it feels like a law of diminishing returns when
- 18:26you try to get too hyper personalized in print.
- 18:29But then it's not my expertise. So let's talk about data.
- 18:34We always have to talk about data on this podcast and there
- 18:37will be some people who understand what good measurement
- 18:40of metrics look like in an offline model, knows you've not
- 18:42done it before, probably taken up, but how do you measure it?
- 18:45You know how different the KP is on offline versus digital.
- 18:48So what? What metrics matter and how do
- 18:51you use data to to measure the success of this?
- 18:54Yeah. So the good thing with DM is you
- 18:57have a physical name and address for everybody that you send a
- 19:02mailing to. So you know when you've sent it
- 19:06and then you can track. So people that respond to that
- 19:11catalogue, you know that they've received the catalogue.
- 19:14So a lot of people will know it as a match back analysis.
- 19:19So you match the responders back to the mailing file.
- 19:22So it's, it's easier than in the digital world where you're not
- 19:28100% sure in some cases what they saw when they saw it and
- 19:33how they reacted. So that's kind of the, the blunt
- 19:37measure they received it. Did they buy?
- 19:39Yes or did they not buy? And then obviously you will then
- 19:44have the other touch points that come into it.
- 19:47So you might be also doing retargeting, for example, in
- 19:52other channels. So, but it's hard to kind of
- 19:54bring that all that cost into it.
- 19:56So, so most brands, what they will do is they will just look
- 20:00at the the cost of the the catalogue.
- 20:03Or whatever the DM piece is, they'll look at the responders
- 20:07and they'll look at the profit that that catalogue brought to
- 20:12the business. Also, just to kind of understand
- 20:16the incremental uplift of it. The good thing with mailings is
- 20:21you can hold back kind of control cells.
- 20:25So especially with retention audiences, so you can, for
- 20:29example, not mail 10% or 20% of the audience and then actually
- 20:35see how differently they respond to the people that do get it.
- 20:39So it's kind of quite a is, is the, I would say the easiest
- 20:44channel to to measure out of all of them.
- 20:50Yeah, I like the the I like the hold out thing because that also
- 20:53gives you that that more accurate measure about whether
- 20:55the the sale because I know you do time based analysis of DMS,
- 21:00you know the pit window period after it being sent on those
- 21:03customer records. But obviously they see other
- 21:05stuff as well. So you get that really nice
- 21:08ability to measure incrementality by doing the
- 21:10whole of that piece, which is nice.
- 21:13Let's talk about programmatic. So not an area I know anything
- 21:19about. So I'm quite intrigued as well
- 21:21the role of programmatic in in DM and offline.
- 21:25But do you want to talk us through what, what is the role?
- 21:27You know where is this heading? Yeah.
- 21:31So, so the thing we've programmatic.
- 21:34So let's think e-mail for a moment because everyone kind of
- 21:38is familiar with that. So where you have automated
- 21:42flows, so where either purchase behaviour or behavioural data
- 21:51can trigger an action to to send an e-mail, if you have got a
- 21:57physical name and address for that contact, you also can have
- 22:03the ability to inject something into the post for them to
- 22:08receive on their doormat. So with e-mail open rate that,
- 22:15that, well there'll, there'll be a proportion of people that
- 22:17don't open. Even the best kind of automotive
- 22:19campaigns may only get 6070% open rate.
- 22:23And then you've, you've also got a crowded inbox that you've got
- 22:29to get kind of get to the top of and get noticed.
- 22:34Whereas back to the, the discussion about the catalogue
- 22:38earlier, it's on the doormat. So people have got to got to
- 22:42pick it up. So you can as well because
- 22:46obviously it's more expensive than with e-mail, much more
- 22:51expensive. So an e-mail might be a fraction
- 22:55of pennies to send, whereas a, a physical kind of mailing piece
- 23:00that's been triggered will be anywhere from between 45 and 85
- 23:05P So it does cost much more. So the key thing here is
- 23:09actually building it into your your overall strategy.
- 23:13So for example, if somebody goes on the website, abandons a
- 23:17basket today, you're not going to send them a a letter before
- 23:23you've had the opportunity to send them an e-mail.
- 23:25So it's more that you would actually probably send them,
- 23:28send them an e-mail within a couple of hours of abandoning,
- 23:32potentially send them an e-mail the next day.
- 23:33If they're not then responding, then actually follow up with
- 23:38with a mailing and abandoned basket is just one of many, many
- 23:43examples. So some brands are using it very
- 23:47successfully for kind of win back campaigns, birthday
- 23:51campaigns, So anniversary of purchase kind of all, all things
- 23:56really that can be triggered. I really like this.
- 24:00Do you know what? I hadn't twigged that basket
- 24:02abandonment would be in there. I was things like win back.
- 24:06They when when people are at the point of like churn and
- 24:10anniversary purchase, all those things I had in my head.
- 24:12But abandoned basket, I just haven't connected to that.
- 24:15And that makes a lot of sense actually, because abandoned
- 24:18basket rates are average like 6870% if you look at Baymont
- 24:22Institute's aggregate tracker. And there are so many reasons
- 24:26why people abandoned, but there is so much noise in people's
- 24:29inboxes and increasing and get like that way with SMS
- 24:32reminders. So I think that's a really nice
- 24:35thing where people could do you find, is that an area that
- 24:38people when they're starting to test out into into like offline
- 24:41and print, is that an area they test first or do do they go for
- 24:45other areas? Well, with programmatic, it'll
- 24:49be one of the areas that they that they test first.
- 24:53Especially I think sometimes it depends on the products you're
- 24:56selling. Because if you're selling
- 24:58something that's very much an impulse buy, you probably
- 25:01wouldn't do it as much because they've already probably bought
- 25:04from a competitor. Whereas if you are, I don't
- 25:08know, buying a bed is more of a considered purchase.
- 25:12So therefore, actually receiving something in the post a few days
- 25:16later with all kind of maybe customer reviews on their
- 25:20reassurance on their more advice on the help, the quality, all
- 25:25those aspects which you can have more kind of space to do it can
- 25:30help. So, but it's very much so
- 25:34because usually with the programmatic suppliers you're
- 25:37paying for kind of a number, you pay, you pay like a fixed fee
- 25:42per month and then you get a number of kind of sends for that
- 25:46price. And in order to kind of optimize
- 25:50that, you would look at it across various various triggers,
- 25:55so to speak. Yeah, I really like that idea of
- 25:58using it for more, more complex considered purchases, whether
- 26:02it's beds, other furniture, because the ability to better
- 26:04showcase the the value proposition of that product and
- 26:08and the reassurance and the persuasion messaging versus what
- 26:11you do in an e-mail. Because that's basically if you
- 26:13make an e-mail this long, no one's read it for an abandoned
- 26:15car. Absolutely.
- 26:18And quite often with certain, with certain brands, it might be
- 26:21that you've abandoned baskets with multiple brands and
- 26:25actually, well, how many times do you go to buy something and
- 26:29you've finally made the decision you've forgot which brand it
- 26:31was. So well, that might just be me,
- 26:34but I do that quite often where actually there's just because
- 26:38there's so much noise and then you get yourself to be all of a
- 26:41very similar brands and everything.
- 26:42So it's just getting that cut through.
- 26:44Yeah, it is. I, I, I quite like it as well
- 26:46because it's, it's, it's demonstrating a bit of extra, a
- 26:49bit of different thinking about how can I be useful for T rather
- 26:52than just I've set up a I was talking about doing abandonment
- 26:56marketing in the video, my newsletter last week.
- 26:59So wish I'd had this conversation with you first,
- 27:00because I hadn't thought about the bringing it into offline.
- 27:03I might have to do an update to that.
- 27:06You said about, you know, programmatic, you pay fixed fee
- 27:09per month because I think some, if you're not used to offline,
- 27:11it feels like price. This is going to be really
- 27:13expensive. How do I get a budget for this?
- 27:15What? How low can the starting budget
- 27:17be to test the water? So with programmatics, so
- 27:22there's, there's different spies out there that offer kind of
- 27:24different packages, but you've also got to think about actually
- 27:28if you're going to test it, you want to test it and understand
- 27:32the result of it to see whether it's worth kind of continuing.
- 27:34So you've got to kind of have sort of almost decent volume.
- 27:37So you wouldn't, I don't know if you're only if you've only got,
- 27:42I don't know 1000 customers, programmatic will be way, way
- 27:46too early in your journey. So, but I would, I would say the
- 27:50starting budget is, is probably so over a three month period for
- 27:56programmatic, you're probably talking about 15 K So and that
- 28:00would cover kind of the print, the posts and everything for an
- 28:04actual catalogue, which some of the smaller brands always can
- 28:08start off with. So because at that point they'll
- 28:11probably have less, fewer events and programmatic won't be the
- 28:14first step for them. You're talking about to, to get
- 28:19a decent reading of whether it will work.
- 28:21You're probably talking about a budget of about 20 K 25K.
- 28:26About 10, yeah, I do. So you're right, it suits.
- 28:29So programmatic suits as a larger audiences, but a small
- 28:32catalogue when you consider that some people are spending 3040 K
- 28:35plus a month on on digital media fees factoring that percentage
- 28:40of your annual budget as a test zone.
- 28:43OK, excellent. That's really useful.
- 28:45And what about gotchas? Because there's always gotchas,
- 28:49things, things are challenging, things are tricky and we're not
- 28:52in a, in a fixed world where things don't change.
- 28:55And I think you, when we were chatting prior to the podcast,
- 28:57you said about Royal Mail costs going up.
- 28:59So what are some of the gotchas that people need to think about
- 29:01in terms of when they're planning, budgeting and and
- 29:04executing these these programs? Yeah, so, so Royal Mail
- 29:08definitely is something to think about.
- 29:11So or something to think about. So they, although they're trying
- 29:16to encourage people to put things in the mail and, and get
- 29:21kind of more people using the system at the same time they're
- 29:25putting prices up. So in, in July the prices will
- 29:31be going up about another 10% for a lot of people sending
- 29:33catalogues. So you've therefore got, they've
- 29:36got to work harder for them to work.
- 29:39It's going to change formats because you can, you can
- 29:44actually get round some of the increases or reduce some of the
- 29:47increases with different formats in there.
- 29:50So, but it's it's definitely something to think about also.
- 29:56You've then got all the kind of print paper things to think
- 30:00about and you've always got there's always some paper mill
- 30:05or something going on strike or doing something that means that
- 30:09you've got to kind of be on the be on the ball.
- 30:12So, but, but I think just to kind of add to this, because I
- 30:18think some listeners might be thinking, oh God, it sounds
- 30:21complicated and it's not something we can do, we can do
- 30:25tomorrow. But there are there are agencies
- 30:29that kind of kind of hold your hand kind of through this, the
- 30:32programmatic, the cost for many, it kind of includes them doing
- 30:36it all kind of for you if you want you to want them to with
- 30:42the catalogue side of things. I'm non exec director a agency
- 30:47called Go direct Marketing and they can very much build the
- 30:53plan and do do everything apart from the creative and give
- 30:56guidance on the creative as well.
- 30:57So can kind of make it quite, quite easy for a new player kind
- 31:03of coming into, into the market. Yeah.
- 31:06So but and, and also thinking about, so for example, a day
- 31:12like today, the sun shining. So there's other distractions
- 31:15apart from people looking through their mails.
- 31:17So thinking about timing is kind of quite important as well.
- 31:22Yeah, very good advice. And I've got one final question,
- 31:26which is sustainability. We know it's hugely important
- 31:30and more and more shoppers are taking this seriously and
- 31:32they're it's impacting brand affinity and brand purchase
- 31:36decisions. Now, obviously print creates
- 31:38waste because as you said earlier, some people will just
- 31:41throw it away and they'll recycle it.
- 31:42And yes, it can be recycled, but there's still, there's all that
- 31:45effort and all that resource used to create it.
- 31:48How can brands who aren't delivered, who have same
- 31:50sustainability initiatives and at the core of their thinking,
- 31:54how can they push into DM without screwing up initiatives
- 31:57and thinking like, Christ, we're just, we're going away from what
- 31:59we're trying to achieve. What I would recommend here is
- 32:04so Market Reach who are kind of part of Royal Mail have done a
- 32:10lot of work on sustainability and measuring kind of the
- 32:15impacts of different mailing pieces.
- 32:18So there's lots of studies, lots of things that you can kind of
- 32:20look on there. So it actually, it's the same
- 32:24carbon impacts actually sending a postcard than it is to send an
- 32:29e-mail with a large attachment, for example.
- 32:32So it's actually a, a, a full mailing piece is actually
- 32:40similar to having a cup of coffee.
- 32:42So there's kind of some parable called parables that actually
- 32:46make it not sound as bad as you think it would be.
- 32:50So, and then also just things like there's different, there's
- 32:56different papers, there's different prints, ink, there's,
- 32:59there's all kind of different, the, the world of understanding.
- 33:03This is kind of coming up and actually, or it's been around
- 33:07for a while. And actually they're addressing
- 33:10it at every point. So I I would say in many cases
- 33:15digital's worse than you think rather than the post well DM
- 33:20being as bad as you think. Because in, in digital, you, you
- 33:25see people sign up to offset schemes wherever it's like
- 33:28planting. And I know there is cynicism
- 33:31around some offset schemes and, and quite rightly so, but I
- 33:34think there's a lot of people trying to do positive things,
- 33:38even if it's not maybe as good as, as we need to get to.
- 33:41Is it similar in, in print? Do you have print companies
- 33:44providing services who do offset schemes and that help mitigate
- 33:50the impact of doing campaigns? Or is is that industries not not
- 33:53caught up with that yet? No, they so they have and
- 33:57probably in some cases they were doing it earlier than this
- 34:00digital because it was very much kind of, it was always it, it
- 34:06was a barrier even when sustainability was kind of first
- 34:11been spoken about. So some of them have been kind
- 34:14of thinking about it for some time and you just need to kind
- 34:17of look into it to kind of get the details behind it.
- 34:21So, but, but there's also things like on a lot of catalogues
- 34:24there's there's sustainability kind of a lot of kind of the
- 34:28logo and the credentials and stuff for some of the the print
- 34:31and paper. So, yeah, so it's definitely,
- 34:35it's definitely out there. Thanks a lot, I've really
- 34:38enjoyed chatting about DM because it's nice to refresh
- 34:40myself on what was going on out there.
- 34:42And if anyone listening wants to talk to you about whether
- 34:45they're looking for advice or they're potentially looking to
- 34:48run campaigns, how do they reach AT?
- 34:51If you send me either an e-mail through Anna at Key Ascent, so
- 34:58that's KEYASC ent.com or look on LinkedIn.
- 35:06So Anna Wilson on there. And because Anna Wilson's quite
- 35:13a common name, I'm the one with the wing walking profile
- 35:16picture. Excellent.
- 35:18Now that's a brilliant differentiator.
- 35:22Exactly. Cool, Anna, I've really enjoyed
- 35:24talking to you. Thanks so much for coming on the
- 35:25podcast and thanks everyone for listening.
- 35:28As always. Hope you found it interesting,
- 35:30taking some good insights away. Hopefully it's kind of it's
- 35:34nudged you to think maybe a little bit more seriously about
- 35:37offline and DM if you're not already.
- 35:39And do reach out to Anna with any questions and make sure
- 35:42you're following inside comments on LinkedIn and a subscribe to
- 35:45our newsletter. Take care, everybody.
- 35:47Thank you, James. You're listening to the Inside
- 35:51Commerce podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 35:53consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 35:56Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 35:58feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 36:01industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 36:04explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 36:06and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 36:09really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 36:12help fine tune your E Comm strategy and tech.
- 36:15Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James of Paul if you'd
- 36:18like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 36:20We hope you enjoy the latest episode.