Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / God Likes to Watch: The Blaming and Shaming of Purity Culture
Transcript
- 0:05The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursulling knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking, feelself much more. Happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast, hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:52Man. If I had a dime for every time I've met somebody here,
- 1:00you know, had them call the podcast or they sent me an email
- 1:03talking about the damage that was done to them by the Puritans. These high
- 1:07control moralists sit around with their arms folded and say this is sinful and you
- 1:17are carnal. Therefore you must spend the rest of your life in denial of
- 1:22yourself because the self is wicked. I heard a whole bunch of that growing
- 1:30up, you know, and so I wanted to do a speech or a
- 1:34presentation about purity culture. And this was kind of a stretch for me.
- 1:40This was a liberation exercise. I was really trying to push myself because and
- 1:45a lot of people don't know this because I'm a blabbermouth, but I'm also
- 1:49very shy. I'm an introvert. Really, I'm selectively social. I love
- 1:53people, I go out and I really connect, but I'm also extremely private
- 1:59and loved to be, you know, kind of alone in a very very
- 2:01enclosed, quiet space. In fact, if you meet me on the road,
- 2:06you'll find that I'm engaging in all of these ways. And then whenever
- 2:10it's done, the battery's empty and I have to go plug into the wall
- 2:15and just recharge in a quiet place. And in a similar way, I
- 2:20am kind of an introvert and very shy when it comes to sexual stuff.
- 2:29So when I came out of the faith and I started to meet people like
- 2:31Daryl Ray and Aaron Lewis and others who were just front and center, you
- 2:37know, and they talk about it as it should be talked about, as
- 2:39a natural, healthy part of the human condition. I was blushing all the
- 2:44time, and I still do that. I am a blusher. I am
- 2:49just shy in that way. So as I wrote the speech, I was
- 2:53really trying to overcome that in some way, you know, just own it.
- 2:57Much of this stuff is the scars of at are left over from the
- 3:01damage that was done by the moralists, by the pulpit pounding shame brigade,
- 3:08and you need to just get over that. So just talk about it anyway.
- 3:14I'm going to play for you my speech as it was recorded just recently
- 3:17at the Blue Water Atheist Humanist Conference in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada. I've
- 3:23retired it from the road. It is now on YouTube, and the YouTube
- 3:28link is in the description box of the show in case you want to watch
- 3:31it, and you may want to, because there's a hundred high impact rapid
- 3:37fire visuals, you know. Me, I like to use a lot of
- 3:39slides for the audio version. Everything translates except for one clip about at the
- 3:50twenty minute mark or something like that. I talk about this church in Alabama
- 3:53and a guy on stage wielding his sword up the spirit and he's on stay,
- 4:00she's on the platform at this old Pentecostal church and he's literally wielding a
- 4:04sword. He's got a not a plastic or a foam sword. It's a
- 4:09sword, a big, heavy metal sword like a Highlanders sword, and this
- 4:15dude, big manly man with his jeans and his T shirt and his ball
- 4:17cap, and he's on stage and he's wielding the sword of the Spirit.
- 4:23And so when you hear that, there'll be a bunch of praise and worship
- 4:27music. I think they're speaking and tongues in the background. There's something picture
- 4:30that in your mind. I think that's really the only part that doesn't translate.
- 4:34Okay, but I hope this is a liberation exercise for you. If
- 4:40you know somebody harmed by purity culture, send them the links, because this
- 4:46is designed to be empowering and encouraging and a positive in people's lives. Now,
- 4:55because I don't want to interrupt a forty eight minute presentation midstream, let
- 4:59me take my break right now, and in just a second I will be
- 5:03right back in. We will kick the whole thing off. Hang on,
- 5:13all right. This is the audio of a presentation that I have been giving
- 5:17all around the country and in parts of Canada for the past several months.
- 5:21The speech is called God likes to Watch the blaming and shaming of Purity Culture.
- 5:30Enjoy. So I was back at my table earlier and somebody bought a
- 5:46book from me and I wasn't able to make change at the time. And
- 5:50I know this is a mistake with this audience, But who do I owe
- 5:55ten dollars to raise your head? Hey, it's an honor to be back.
- 6:02It's a real joy to be here. And I'm so glad that all
- 6:06of you were here. They stuck me right before dinner. So I'll give
- 6:09you the choice. We can do an abbreviated version and you can go eat,
- 6:13and we can go full Monty. What do you want? You didn't
- 6:16really have a choice. I'm giving you the illusion of control. But all
- 6:21right, how many of you remember your first kiss? I see some smiles,
- 6:33a few frowns, a couple of scowls. I remember my first kiss.
- 6:42I will never forget her name. Her name was Bellin. Now.
- 6:49I met Bilin in my hometown of Tulsa, Oklahoma. I was fourteen,
- 6:54and my mother thought it would be a good idea for my sister and I
- 6:57to get some real life work experience, even though we weren't sixteen of legal
- 7:02age. To get a job, we need to train up some work ethic
- 7:05in these two and so we signed up to be volunteers at a local hospital
- 7:12and think of candy striper two point zero. We ran errands and did that
- 7:17kind of thing, and all of the Junior Guild volunteers, the young people
- 7:24had to wear these green smocks, and oh lovely, Billeen rocked this smock.
- 7:34We were both assigned to the ninth floor Saint John Hospital, Tulsa,
- 7:39Oklahoma, and we did what gophers do. We delivered ivy bags and paperwork
- 7:45and ran errands for the various medical staff, and then between jobs we would
- 7:49just hang out and get to know each other. Now, Billeen was a
- 7:55vision. This is not Billieen. I didn't hang on to a freaking forty
- 8:00year old picture of Billeen and keep it with me. This is a stock
- 8:03image, but it captures a lot about what I remember about Billien, how
- 8:09she sort of appears in my mind and my heart, that light and lovely
- 8:13complexion surrounding those ocean blue eyes, blonde hair that she washed in lemon juice
- 8:22that she said gave it a luster and a texture, And she had a
- 8:24genetic hearing loss which sort of affected how she rounded out her consonants. I
- 8:30found that tremendously charming. Her teeth, oh, her teeth, much too
- 8:35perfect for a fifteen year old, and yes, since she was fifteen and
- 8:43I was fourteen, Billien was an older woman. Our job running errands,
- 8:52which meant we were always taking the elevator, and on one very special day
- 8:56that summer, I noticed she was close enough to me to almost touch me.
- 9:05I did not move away. Next Aaron, I stood a little closer
- 9:11to her, she did not move away. Next elevator ride, we were
- 9:18standing like this, and the time after that we kissed, and that moment
- 9:26was electric. I had no idea what I was doing, but I was
- 9:33doing it right. I was doing it a few seconds of passion before and
- 9:41the elevator door opened and we walked out and tried to look like nothing else
- 9:45had been going on. Of course, my next thought was we need to
- 9:50run more errands right oh the long hot summer. But sadly, when the
- 9:58summer ended, we both went on our separate ways and got on with our
- 10:01separate lives. Still, Billen will always be my first I was four decades
- 10:09ago. Fond memories for me, But I have not yet said anything about
- 10:16the dark side of young passions when you are brought up in a culture of
- 10:22shame in high control cultures, especially high control religion. Shame is constant.
- 10:28There you are, you are at puberty or beyond. You're a walking,
- 10:33talking, throbbing hormone. Right, you're supercharged with fantasies about physical touch,
- 10:41passionate touch, sensual touch. On one hand, it feels natural and right,
- 10:48and the other hand it feels carnal and sinful and wrong. And of
- 10:52course, in this hand they usually place a Bible. I was fourteen,
- 10:58I had all already looked at a woman lustfully in my heart. At fourteen,
- 11:03I was already an adulterer. I had felt desires in my youth.
- 11:09I had failed in righteousness. I was captivated by her eyes, her face,
- 11:16her voice, her shape, her laugh, her mind, her heart,
- 11:22her person. Hardline Christianity had taken my personal hetero attraction to females,
- 11:28and it had turned it into a minefield. I was going to say booby
- 11:33trapped, but that might be inappropriate. Purity culture breeds dysfunction. It takes
- 11:45creatures of innate desire and commands them not to desire. How do we do
- 11:52this? Well, we must desexualize them first stop, have them make a
- 11:58promise to God, and so often to God's proxy, which is your guardian,
- 12:03very often the male head of household, the father. By the way,
- 12:07it's no accident that I've used a girl in this slide. Abstinence programs
- 12:13like True Love Weights encourage young people to wear purity rings on their fingers.
- 12:18This one says waiting for the one. By the way, Isaiah forty thirty
- 12:22one talks about God renewing your strength. You feel carnal and weak. God
- 12:28will make you strong. There are purity balls ceremonies where young girls are actually
- 12:35dressed up in wedding gowns where they vow sexual chastity, specifically in front of
- 12:41the eyes of their father. Here is a young girl at a purity balls.
- 12:46He's actually signing a stay of virgin contract under the eyes of her Christian
- 12:52dad. Many Christian cultures actually call this dating your dad. Now, are
- 13:00you ready for the veins to pop out of your head? A few years
- 13:05ago, ABC Nightline did a whole feature on purity balls. Check this out.
- 13:11Meanwhile, Ron has a special gift for Caroline before they all head to
- 13:16the ball, all ready for you, Dear, you look lovely well.
- 13:26You are growing up before your daddy's eyes. One of the things that you
- 13:31were talking to Daddy about was when am I going to get my purity ring?
- 13:35And one of the things that I think is important for us to remember
- 13:39is this is your desire to do it the Lord's way to really save yourself
- 13:45from kissing lots of toads along the way, and wait for your prince charming
- 13:48to come along, and he's got to pass through your dad, and Dad's
- 13:52got to put the stamp of approval on him, because dad's are really smart
- 13:56and they can separate princess from toads. Really well. Let me show you
- 14:01the ring that I got for you here. When somebody comes along who is
- 14:05ready and has a proper character and will treat you like a queen, then
- 14:09that's the guy that passes the test. And until then, this is just
- 14:13a reminder keeping yourself pure is important, and so you keep that on your
- 14:18finger, and it's a daily reminder that you're at this point. You're married
- 14:20to the Lord, and your father is your boyfriend and we're gonna have fun
- 14:26together. Here's a creepy purity ball where they kneel in front of an actual
- 14:37cross with the guardians all gathered around. Next up, cover up that auto
- 14:46fix things. Notice how removing the fabric from the woman's shoulder automatically removes all
- 14:52inclination to lust and sin. It's really amazing. Okay, this is actually
- 14:56an illustration I grabbed off of the WICKI how page. How dress modestly?
- 15:01It's a prevention because women, of course, are the gatekeepers for preventing lust
- 15:07and sin. Right, the apostle Paul, not exactly an egalitarian, commanded
- 15:13women dress modestly with decency and propriety. When I was a kid in religious
- 15:20schools, I had a year in the ACE program Accelerated Christian Education. This
- 15:26was the kind of stuff that we were taught. This was an actual illustration
- 15:31from the ACE program. There's a little girl and she's looking in the mirror
- 15:35preparing for her day. She says, looks nice, looks good. Oh,
- 15:39some knees are showing too little to wear. I must look right always.
- 15:45Now, if I could distill this down to bullet points, here's the
- 15:48great wisdom that high control purity cultures have for people. Don't think like a
- 15:54slut, don't dress like a slut, don't be a slut, and don't
- 16:00be tempted by the sluts. And who's the target for most of these commands.
- 16:08Of course it's the female. The perception has long been that men,
- 16:15much more than women, are sexually activated visually, so we have to mute
- 16:21what men see. By the way, there are some neuroscientists who are challenging
- 16:25the claim that it's only men who are visual while women are not. The
- 16:30National Academy of Sciences published an article in twenty nineteen saying that both male and
- 16:37female brains respond in very similar ways to visual stimuli. Other research says,
- 16:42yes, male primates do more rely on visual stimuli visual cues. This leans
- 16:51into primate mate selection. There's a great book that gets into some of this.
- 16:56I narrated the audiobook by doctor Hector Garcia called Alpha God, where we
- 17:00get into some of this, including the key to some of this, which
- 17:03is male dominance behaviors in primates. But as self aware primates, as higher
- 17:11primates, we don't have to be slaves to the amygdala. David Michael Buss
- 17:17is an American evolutionary psychologist. He's an expert in human sex differences in mate
- 17:22selection, and he makes the necessary point a scientific description of evolved behaviors is
- 17:30not the same as a moral prescription for that behavior. Not every evolved trait
- 17:34is going to be a civilized or moral or pro social one, and we,
- 17:40as conscious beings higher primates, have evolved the ability to override old programming.
- 17:45In other words, we can experience and acknowledge the evolutionary triggers that draw
- 17:52our eyes toward a beautiful person while choosing not to entertain or engage in objective
- 17:59accre obsession, or predation. This stuff gets really, really complicated. It's
- 18:07a whole other speech. But I want us take a second and talk about
- 18:10the priming of young males, building on the evolution of some dominance behaviors.
- 18:17This model often sees the men excuse dominance behaviors expected, while females are subjugated,
- 18:25blamed, and shamed. Many times we see this in fundamentalist religions.
- 18:29Of course, we know this when we open our Bibles to the Book of
- 18:33Genesis. The story of Christianity starts with Eve, produced as a byproduct of
- 18:41Adam. She has created subordinate Eve tempted Adam to taste the forbidden fruit.
- 18:47And how did God punish Eve sexually Genesis three sixteen. I will surely expand
- 18:56your pain and your pregnancy in pain, you will bad children then against your
- 19:00husband will be your desire, but he should rule over you. Her punishment.
- 19:07This is called Eve's curse. Childbirth is going to hurt like a mother,
- 19:11and when you have sexual desire for your husband, it will be part
- 19:15of that curse. It's weird. It's almost as if the story was written
- 19:19by men. Okay, anybody here familiar with Lilith. Lilith she's only mentioned
- 19:27one time in the Bible, but ancient Babylonian tradition and some Christian traditions know
- 19:32her as the first wife of Adam, coming before Eve. If you'll pardon
- 19:37the expression, confident, A confident together, independent, sexually liberated female,
- 19:48not submissive. Oh, she's too independent for God and Adam. She was
- 19:55cast out as the demonic seducer to make way for the more submissive Eve.
- 20:00Also, when the Bible Delilah, she seduced and betrayed Samson. His life
- 20:06was destroyed when she cut off his hair and stole his divine strength. The
- 20:11alluring Jezebel convinced King Ahab to worship the false god bay All and kill the
- 20:17prophets of Yahweh. The Book of Revelation has a female destroyer. She is
- 20:25adorned in gold and pearls. She rides a scarlet beast holding a cup filled
- 20:30with what fornication? She is the mother of Harlot's The Horror of Babylon.
- 20:41Even the Christian Apocalypse Smith has an adorned female seductress bringing destruction. Oh you
- 20:49women, you're the sirens Sarchan. You beckon us men into calamity and sin.
- 20:56Oh I see you out there. Fundamentalist Islam, of course, has
- 21:02a ton of this kind of thing. The sexualize them so that they will
- 21:07not be abused. And by the way, I need to clarify something,
- 21:10I've used the word desexualize a few times. This is actually ironic because the
- 21:15effect is the opposite. The more you hyper target someone to try to desexualize
- 21:22them, you're actually over sexualizing them. You're treating them as a sexual creature
- 21:26first. So you are defeating your own purpose by targeting someone in that way.
- 21:33Okay, here is an alarming example look purity culture out of the Mormon
- 21:37Church. A few years ago, there was a video shown at something called
- 21:44the Youth Standards Night for the LDS Church, and they took the one direction
- 21:51song you don't Know You're Beautiful and they retooled it with a message for young
- 21:56women. Prepare yourself for cringe. Don't pick your men. We keep any
- 22:07virtuous baby dressing modest. We know it's rough when the world is making its
- 22:15suah, don't need short skirts or low cut shirts. Sout shirt in away
- 22:22that you are running everyone else, everyone else find you, baby. You
- 22:33lie the world like nobody else. By the way that you sneaking cat yourself,
- 22:40He'll say to tell he are hard to find these. You gotta know
- 22:47you are so beautiful boy. You for me and so I can see you
- 22:52understand why I need you honest? Sleep right now, I'm talking to you,
- 22:57and you mustily that's what make you do it? Okay, did you
- 23:15catch it? Did you catch it? You'd understand why I need your modesty?
- 23:23Does that line sound alarmingly rapey? Do anybody else cover up? I
- 23:32need you to cover up. You're the gatekeeper for how I think, how
- 23:36I feel, what I do. At the very least, it is saying
- 23:38that women are responsible for how men act and react in a sexual way.
- 23:48Purity cultures, obsession with females, primes males, and ways that they may
- 23:52not even realize and please understand I'm not generalizing all men or young men into
- 23:59a predator canny. We see it happen way too often, but males are
- 24:03often the victims of purity culture. I was a victim of purity culture.
- 24:10They tried to desexualize me and blame and shame me. I took a purity
- 24:14pledge. I didn't have a ring, but I did promise fidelity before Man
- 24:18and God to remain sexually pure, which kicked off years and years of struggle.
- 24:26Boys are often biblically brainwashed for dominion. Here is a parent training guide.
- 24:32This was produced by James Dobson's outfit in Colorado, focus on the family.
- 24:37Written by a minister, It's a guide book for fathers to raise a
- 24:41modern day Nights and of course, nights and God's army must wear armor.
- 24:48We've got the helmet of salvation, the breastplate of righteousness, the shield of
- 24:52faith, the belt of truth, the shoes of peace, and the sword
- 24:57of the Spirit. By the way, was sent a video clip of one
- 25:00Christian man literally wielding his sword of the Spirit. This is Storehouse Church and
- 25:10Jasper, Alabama. Okay, okay, Outside of the fact that he almost
- 25:30decapitated his own pastor. That's a penis, right, that's a penis.
- 25:42A projection of male fierceness and chest banging warrior strength dominating fundamentalist cultures once again.
- 25:52And we see this in Christianity. There's a lot of this type of
- 25:55language, rites of passage, there are tests of virtue, sacred oaths to
- 25:59go one holy missions or quests. You are a man crusading for God.
- 26:04When I was in Christian radio in the nineteen nineties, we saw the promise
- 26:08Keeper's movement. This was a revival specifically targeted to men. We saw tens
- 26:14of thousands of people at a time filling these massive football stadiums to commit themselves
- 26:18to godly manhood. And the model was this men of the final word sex
- 26:23only in marriage. And of course, as Yahweh is a heterosexual man's man,
- 26:30he wants the same attributes in boys, young men, husbands, fathers,
- 26:33etc. Be strong, be solid, be manly, be masculine.
- 26:40Of course, we're not talking about masculinity in the healthy sense, right.
- 26:45Natural masculinity is wonderful, but the hierarchy model in many fundamentalist purity cultures is
- 26:52one of toxic masculinity. Ask the women in this room about the man explainers,
- 27:03right, chauvinism, male chauvinism, kind of looking down at women.
- 27:07Let me show you how it's done, little lady. Everybody in this room's
- 27:11got a story. Trust me. How many boys and men have been terrified
- 27:15of being called what they have been taught is one of the ultimate insults.
- 27:21What are you queer? Gay? You fag? Gay? Men aren't true
- 27:26men. This thinking goes well beyond religion too. I have had this happen
- 27:32on my own pages. I post a podcast or a video or something,
- 27:36and someone will jump in and say something really nice. I love Seth's voice.
- 27:41Oh thank you, what a lovely sentiment, What a great compliment made
- 27:47my day. Thank you so much. But they can't leave it there.
- 27:49They have to follow up with no homeown. How insecure is Dad's statement because
- 28:03in that perception, non heterosexual men, well, they're not actual men.
- 28:08Nah. A lot of people like to talk about men back in the day
- 28:11primal man, masculine, manly man. Okay, great, these were the
- 28:18ones in charge, the manly man. And I always like to remind these
- 28:22people about some other manly men who lived in the halls of power, who
- 28:26looked like this in the United States, they're going after drag queens. And
- 28:33I'm like, have you read a fucking history book? Do you have any
- 28:37idea what you're physical response to emotional issues? We've all heard the men don't
- 28:49cry thing, right, confusing healthy human vulnerability with weakness. I'll give you
- 28:57something to cry about, strong, suck it up. We hear a lot
- 29:02of that and the grunting displays of noble aggression. Settle it with fists in
- 29:07the parking lot, lock and load. I'll show you who's the man.
- 29:11Male assertions of dominance and power, and these are very often sexual in nature,
- 29:15like the guy with the sword. We've got this, dude, How
- 29:18America is this? By the way, how United States is this? And
- 29:22I think it sums up twenty first century biblical manhood. You mark your territory,
- 29:27you puff out your chest, you give him the thousand yards stare,
- 29:30and then you extend your penis with a firearm. Right. Notice how the
- 29:37insults toward women are so often sexual in nature, and your mind make a
- 29:42list of the popular insults hurled at men and the popular insults hurled at women.
- 29:48The ratio is not even close. It's so telling to watch people especially
- 29:55women valued and or devalued sexually. First. Another example, of course,
- 30:00is one you're familiar with. A man with a lot of sex partners.
- 30:03He's a playboy, he's a ladiesman. A woman with a lot of sex
- 30:07partners, she's a whore and a slut and a bimbo and a tramp.
- 30:11And often religious culture, certainly purity cultures of all stripes, condition people to
- 30:18think like this. What about good people who struggle through the indoctrination of sexual
- 30:23stereotypes. They're overwhelmed by it, all the blaming and the shaming, this
- 30:29idea that they have to submit themselves in every way to God and by proxy,
- 30:33then the church body. Anybody here familiar with the concept of church discipline,
- 30:40this insidious scenario has people of all ages reporting their quote unquote moral failures
- 30:48to the pastor the church leadership and the entire congregation. If it is discovered
- 30:55you had sex outside of marriage, or you had an affair, or you
- 30:59watched point, or you were caught in a non hetero relationship or whatever,
- 31:04pastors and parents drag you before the entire church body, and you are then
- 31:10made to confess. You say a prayer of repentance, and you promise before
- 31:15your accountability partners that you will never do it again. You are being watched.
- 31:23Now this gets tricky because I'm not talking about accountability in the healthy sense.
- 31:29Let's say you're struggling with an issue like addiction, and you've got somebody
- 31:32that can work with you to navigate through difficult times. You're struggling with something
- 31:38you want to reach a goal, you have a weak moment, you call
- 31:41a friend. I don't call that accountability. I call that community. This
- 31:45version of accountability is much more orwellian. Someone else is made aware of your
- 31:51most private thoughts and struggles so that they can keep you on the straight and
- 31:56narrow, to help distract you, to pray away the weakness, and then
- 32:00intercede to God for your forgiveness, and to surveil and report. How far
- 32:10do some churches take this? Check out this example from my hometown. Buddy
- 32:15of mine, who is a former believer, went to this church and the
- 32:21pastor did a whole sermon on sexual purity, and he had a segment in
- 32:25the sermon about masturbation, and he directed that portion of the sermon specifically to
- 32:34males, because, of course, females never masturbate. Ye, okay,
- 32:45anyway, this pastor came up with a way to protect men from this particular
- 32:52sin. And I am not making this up. He assigned masturbation partners.
- 33:06By the way. By the way, this is why you should never pose
- 33:08for stock photos. Right here, These four guys have no idea what I
- 33:15have done to them on this day. No, I didn't do a casting
- 33:22call for masturbators. This is a stock am it. Okay, here's the
- 33:25deal. The idea is this. You are tempted to engage in the devil's
- 33:31handshake, okay, and you realize I am lusting. God is watching.
- 33:38I must resist these fantasies and this physical feeling of lust. So you call
- 33:44a buddy and you confess. And this is supposed to produce some kind of
- 33:47a cold shower effect. Right, you pray with a partner and it all
- 33:52goes away. Of course, this is insanity. It is also genius.
- 34:00It's genius. Control somebody's sexual identity. You got the whole person, who
- 34:07they are, what they think, how they live, who they love,
- 34:10if they self love. By the way, you have not lived until you
- 34:15have researched Victorian era masturbation preventions. Holy schneikes physicians at the time, we're
- 34:24warning the public masturbation would lead to all kinds of problems, mental illness,
- 34:30physical disease, of course, the sickness of sin, even death, physical
- 34:34death. So in the eighteen hundreds we saw doctors and clergy prescribing these penis
- 34:39torture chambers that were supposed to bend and grab and poke and spear men out
- 34:46of having a troublesome erection. There are tons of versions of these four women
- 34:51as well. It's crazy, all right. We've already established God likes to
- 34:58watch. We've already established biblical sex is always a threesome. We have established
- 35:06that how sadistic is the God model for sexuality. Let's say puberty hits at
- 35:15twelve years old. The median age for marriage in the United States is around
- 35:21thirty. That is eighteen years where any sex would be pre marital sex,
- 35:29eighteen years of in eight sexuality that people are told to suppress, almost two
- 35:35decades at war with a body that God intelligently designed to sexually activate early.
- 35:43But wait, there's a remedy for that. If you don't think you can
- 35:47wait, get married as soon as you can. First Corinthian says, but
- 35:53if they cannot control themselves, they should marry, for this is better to
- 35:58marry than to burn with passion. And how many very very young people jumped
- 36:05into the marriage bed because they were sold the lie that physical intimacy was not
- 36:10legitimate unless they picked somebody and signed the papers. For many people, I'll
- 36:16bet from many people in this room, the honeymoon night was a nightmare.
- 36:21Terrified. You've been taught nothing of value about yourself, certainly not your partner,
- 36:27if you'll, dirty and carnal. Even though this was supposed to be
- 36:30godly sex, an intimate moment that should have been exciting and amazing became scary
- 36:37and awkward and traumatizing and awful. Purity couples literally fumbling in the dark,
- 36:45sometimes realizing too late they're not even compatible. But now they're locked in,
- 36:51they're committed. They're trapped, disappointed and depressed and miserable. Let's say the
- 36:58legal age of marriage is eighteen. How much did you know about yourself when
- 37:04you were eighteen, barely out of high school. You haven't gone to college
- 37:09if that's what you want for yourself. You had a job, It certainly
- 37:14wasn't a career. You hadn't navigated any adult relationships. How could you know
- 37:19anybody else when you were still getting to know yourself. Gone is the chance
- 37:25to take your time and test the waters and figure things out beyond the cocoon
- 37:30of youth. Lost is the chance to learn and grow and mature through experience.
- 37:38The law said you were ready, the pre marriage counselors said you were
- 37:44ready. Your parents and pastors said you were ready, but you were not
- 37:47ready. And then comes the joy of Christian marriage counseling. Oh yeah,
- 37:54you know, it's a spiritual issue. Pray together, study of the Bible
- 38:00together, open up to each other more, submit more, including in the
- 38:05bedroom, try harder in the bedroom. All of this communicates the problem maybe
- 38:10you and many churches, divorce is treated with genuine compassion, but there's still
- 38:21a stigma. I mean, if you believe in a soulmate, how could
- 38:24you ever take a second spouse. So if your soulmate was your first spouse,
- 38:31then if you divorced, you're betraying them with your second. Or if
- 38:36the second spouse was the soulmate, that means you'd betrayed them with your first.
- 38:39It's a freaking mindfield. It's a joke. Even the most well meaning
- 38:44divorce recovery workshops usually frame it as a spiritual problem, when so often it's
- 38:50a compatibility problem, it's a maturity problem. Hell, sometimes it's a safety
- 38:54problem. I'm unsafe in this marriage, and and I can't get out because
- 39:02God. Perhaps most ironic, I think, is the reality that so many
- 39:09of the Holy Rollers that preach against unbiblical sex so often get caught with their
- 39:15own pants down. Have you noticed this? How many times have we seen
- 39:21it? I mean from the corner church to the megachurch. They preach from
- 39:24God's house, but their own house has a closet loaded with skeletons. And
- 39:30then we can just get ready because it here it comes. Oh Lord,
- 39:34Oh Lord, I've sinned against thee Oh. I was weak and in the
- 39:39flesh. They caught me with porn, they caught me in an affair.
- 39:43They caught me in a hotel with the same sex partner. I've been banging
- 39:47things that weren't in my Bible, and I'm so very sorry, Jesus.
- 39:52So how to sinned against thee? Oh? Oh? I'm reminded of this
- 39:58quote from the late Chris of her Hitchens. He wrote this in his book
- 40:01Hits twenty two, he said, whenever I hear some big mouth at Washington
- 40:05to the Christian heartland banging on about the evils of sodomy or whatever, and
- 40:09mentally enter his name in my notebook and contentedly set my watch sooner rather than
- 40:15later, he will be discovered down on his weary and well worn old knees
- 40:21and some dreary motel or latrine with an expired visa card, having tried to
- 40:27pay well over the odds to be peat upon by some apache transvestire's day.
- 40:36I've gotten to that point. If I see somebody who's at the podium preaching
- 40:39day day, day, day, night night night against a specific thing,
- 40:44I watch those preachers very closely, beyond the foked tongues of the do as
- 40:51I say, crowd. It is remarkable to think that whole generations are convinced
- 40:55to give somebody else the keys to their private thoughts and desires, attractions,
- 41:00choices, partners, relationships, families, their whole lives. So many of
- 41:07us, I mean, we were just conditioned. We bowed down and complied.
- 41:10We had no idea at the time that we had every right to square
- 41:14our shoulders and say this is none of your business, and a lot of
- 41:19people still struggle with this even today. It's understandable they've been primed after a
- 41:24lifetime of being told who they are and what to do by other people.
- 41:30Oh, if I could get in a time machine, my friends, I
- 41:32would have some advice for the young Seth Andrews, and some of this advice
- 41:38might resonate with you. So let's take that journey now. The first piece
- 41:43of advice I would give to my young self would be never take sex ed
- 41:47from clergy. Seth, you need to know that Christian purity culture is kidding
- 41:55itself. Abstinence only programs constantly fail. They constantly fail, and this has
- 42:05been studied. The Journal of Adolescent Health reported that simply telling kids to cross
- 42:09their legs and be pure does not delay sex. It does not reduce risky
- 42:15behaviors. It's a trespath on the individual. It fuels dangerous ignorance, It
- 42:22stigmatizes young people, it reinforces harmful gender stereotypes, and it makes the problems
- 42:29of unwanted pregnancies and STDs even worse. And the fact that many purity culture
- 42:35parents and pastors are sincere, and so many are they genuinely are trying to
- 42:40teach good and protect their kids from harm. Their sincerity does not mean they
- 42:46know what they're talking about. Often they're just downloading the same dysfunction into their
- 42:52children that was downloaded into them. I would tell myself that purity culture is
- 43:00so often about control. Christianity likes to say it's about freedom, but if
- 43:06you actually read the Bible, the fundamentals of the faith, Christianity is about
- 43:10surrender. What are we surrendering the self? He must increase, I must
- 43:20decrease. We've all heard the slogans die to ourselves, live for God,
- 43:25more of Jesus, less of me. I surrender all you think about,
- 43:31even baptism by immersion, what does that represent? Symbolically? I must die.
- 43:37I am dying to myself being risen essentially as someone else or with the
- 43:44identity of another, because I am not worthy. And unless you think the
- 43:49modern church is not still infected with this nonsense, allow me to introduce you
- 43:53to conservative influencer, podcaster, and minister on Instagram. Her name is Ali
- 44:00Stuckey, and she posted this little sermonette in March of twenty twenty two.
- 44:07Okay, I know I probably sound like a broken record to a lot of
- 44:09you. But because this is a message that keeps on showing up in Christian
- 44:15women's circles, I feel like I need to say it again. You are
- 44:17not enough. You're not enough. Nowhere does the Bible say that you are
- 44:22sufficient. Nowhere does the Bible say that you're perfect the way you are.
- 44:25And that is good news. It's actually great news. You know why,
- 44:29Because you're not enough. You never will be. But Jesus is Ali Stuckey
- 44:37has given herself permission to say this to people. Purity culture has given itself
- 44:43permission to say this to you. But they do not have permission unless we
- 44:49gifted to them. Next piece of advice, do some solo runs. Did
- 45:00you just raise your hand back there? Now is not the time. In
- 45:09the United States, ninety two percent of men, seventy six percent of women
- 45:15self pleasure. Now you're not ruining yourself or your partner or shredding the moral
- 45:20fabric of society. Jesus is not there taking polaroids for judgment Day. You're
- 45:25not going to go blind or grow hair on your palms. Did anyone ever
- 45:29hear that warning from people growing up? You're gonna go blind and have you
- 45:32hairy palms. It's your body, it's natural. It can relax you,
- 45:39it can build confidence. It's a great way to avoid pregnancy and STDs.
- 45:45Don't worry about it, don't be guilty about it. Next up, have
- 45:52fun with it. Now. I'm not an adventurous guy, but if you
- 45:54happen to be one of the more adventurous people, explore that space on your
- 46:00own terms. And if some clucking conservative church hen shows up and starts to
- 46:06judge you for role playing and costumes and kink and a closet full of sex
- 46:10toys, just to assure them that your trip to the adult store boost capitalism.
- 46:20Jesus loves capitalism. It's a great way to combat The next piece of
- 46:27advice I would give myself is something totally counter to what I was taught when
- 46:30I was a young believing Christian seth you should have pre marital sex. Sexual
- 46:39compatibility or incompatibility should not be a honeymoon's surprise. How in the world do
- 46:49you make a sexual commitment to someone without sexual experience? How could you pledge
- 46:54to a partner if you can't fully know your partner. Here's another tip that
- 47:00my Christian counselors would have hated live together. I am convinced you'll never know
- 47:08someone unless you live under the same roof with You've seen those couples, maybe
- 47:15you've been those couples when you're first together. Oh they're perfect, we never
- 47:20fight, what a wonderful person. Blah blah blah. And then they live
- 47:24under the same roof for six months and you're like, holy shit, live
- 47:36together. The chemical high of infatuation finally drops. It's no longer just harps
- 47:43and roses. You get a good long look at each other from behind closed
- 47:49doors. The veneer comes off. We are raw and unfiltered in that environment,
- 47:54sometimes for worse, very often for better. It's an amazing type of
- 48:00intimacy when you can be that type of vulnerable with someone. But if it's
- 48:05not going to work, if something is going to go a ride, that's
- 48:07information that you need. Knowledge is power, And contrary to what the church
- 48:14said, I would tell my young self, you don't have to have a
- 48:16piece of paper to be family. No document determines that, no religion has
- 48:23to sanction that, No father, mother, pastor, priest, politician,
- 48:29doctrine or authority with the capital a can invalidate it, and if anyone ever
- 48:35tries, just given this warning, access is denied to you. You are
- 48:42not the admin of my page. Took me a while to adjust my own
- 48:47perspective on this, to learn that I could draw boundaries. Once I learned
- 48:53that I could draw personal boundaries, it liberated me. And this permission sure
- 49:00can apply to our whole lives. You don't agree with what my interests.
- 49:05You know, like my clothing, my career choice, my sexual orientation.
- 49:10You don't like my friends or partners, lack of partners, the choice to
- 49:14get married or not get married, to have kids or not have kids,
- 49:17my politics, my philosophies, my religion, my rejection of religion that makes
- 49:23you uncomfortable. That's a problem for you. We'll let me call fine one
- 49:28one and we'll get the wambulance here and you can take a nice long ride.
- 49:35Sorry, I know I'm being snarky. I just always wanted to use
- 49:37the ambulance slide in a speech. And I know it's hard. It's really
- 49:42hard. It's a lot more complicated when it comes to loved ones, the
- 49:45people we care about. I would tell my young self to go out and
- 49:50get some actual science based sex, ad understand how the body is acting and
- 49:55reacting. What are the hormones doing in there? I want to learn about
- 50:00organs and orgasms, and forms of contraception and protecting against unwanted pregnancies and sexually
- 50:07transmitted diseases, setting and observing the boundaries of consent sex, and go out
- 50:15and learn about what is happening. I tell myself to embrace the human spectrum
- 50:22of legitimate love out there, far beyond that bubble. Cast off the judgment,
- 50:28seth cast it off. It'll open up your heart. Man, it'll
- 50:31open your mind, It'll open your whole world. I so wish I had
- 50:37gotten there sooner. I wasted decades and bigotry, small mindedness. Finally,
- 50:44I would tell myself that Bilien was a gift. Those precious, passionate seconds
- 50:49together in the elevator, nothing to be ashamed of. It was a gift.
- 50:55Cherish the memory, Embrace that memory, Enjoy that memory, lean into
- 51:00the moment, and savor it. It was perfectly normal, the beginning of
- 51:05a natural and wonderful journey, A big part of feeling truly alive. Now
- 51:13I know some people in this room can really relate to this story. Maybe
- 51:17purity culture has damaged you. Maybe you've got the scars, perhaps still open
- 51:22wounds, you still feel like damaged goods. Logically, in your brain you've
- 51:30overcome it, but in your gut and your heart it still stings. You
- 51:34still struggle. So let me leave you with this. No matter how much
- 51:38Bible the Puritans throw your way, just remember how wrong the Bible has been
- 51:45about everything else. Wrong about biology, cosmology, geology, meteorology, prophecy,
- 51:54history, morality, equality, humanity. Why in the world would we
- 52:00ever expect the Bible to be right about sex. Christian purity culture is built
- 52:07on a Bible written by anonymous primitive sexist men who probably couldn't find the clitterists
- 52:14with GPS. And the ultimate act of emancipation is to stare down this culture
- 52:23of control and say you do not have permission. Stop right there. This
- 52:30is my boundary line. You don't get to decide how I should feel,
- 52:37what I should think, where I should go, who I should choose,
- 52:40or how I should live. My sexuality, my identity, my person my
- 52:46choices, my relationships, my boundaries, my life, my future. These
- 52:51things belong to me. And if you ever bump into evangelist Ali stucky on
- 52:58the streets and she tries to sell you this claim that you are not enough,
- 53:04just educator, Just look her in the eye and smile and say,
- 53:07you know, Ali, you look tense. My advice to you would be
- 53:17to go home, turn down the lights, play some soft music, and
- 53:24go fuck yourself. Thank you for having me, for real honor to be
- 53:30here. Thank you. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a
- 53:39complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the
- 53:45Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming
- 53:50free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.