Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 264. Breast Implant Illness and Autoimmune...The Truth & the Lies with Robert Whitfield MD
Transcript
- 0:11A little bit controversial today. We're getting into some controversy with breast implant illness with my dear friend and colleague, Dr. Robert Whitfield. He is the top dog when it comes to breast explant surgery. But here's, let me give you a little backstory as to why we are almost 300 episodes in and why I have not talked about breast implant illness yet because, and I'm sure Dr. Rob will agree with me.
- 0:39Every person that I hear speak on this subject has one answer. Take your boobs out. And I don't feel like I need to or want to because I like the ones that I have and I don't have problems.
- 0:54So that's why I was always resistant to bring someone on because I don't want the message to be, if you have breast implants, ladies, get them out. If you have Hashimoto's and you have implants, get them out now. Drop that 2025G and get them out.
- 1:12when I don't think everybody does. So then Dr. Rob and I are talking at a conference and it turns out he doesn't think that either. So I'm like, all right then, now it's time to chat about this topic because I am gonna talk to Dr. Rob about a couple people, patients, friends of mine that I know that did not have a positive outcome from their breast explant surgery. So Dr. Rob, thank you so much for coming on. I can't wait for this conversation.
- 1:41Well, we had a few chats about this. And so from a background perspective, everybody needs to know how I got to where I am. So I'm a plastic surgeon, but my structure is based in oncologic reconstruction for breast cancer, head, neck cancer, and sarcoma.
- 1:58So I've always taken care of women with breast cancer. And that being said, I took care of them closely as you would for any patient. But a patient with cancer is screened heavily all the time and followed up carefully all the time. So I would see my patients so frequently. And I had no idea what breast implant illness was when it was first posed to me because I had never seen it in my practice. Yeah.
- 2:25I think the rigidity with which we followed both our surgical technique and care for our patients afterwards would limit the ability for that to happen. And then in cosmetic patients, I didn't have a separate system to take care of them.
- 2:42I cared for them the same way I took care of my cancer patients with extreme, I guess, for lack of a better word, a lot of follow up so that I always would know what was going on. You know, and I didn't see this in my cosmetic practice either. And fast forward to 2016, I had a breast cancer patient who relocated from.
- 3:03the Georgia, state of Georgia, to Austin to retire. And from time to time, I would be asked by breast cancer patients to just remove their reconstruction, not because of a specific problem, but because they were tired of having it. There's lots of emotional issues around that. So,
- 3:21Mine was not to talk someone in or out of that decision. That's the decision someone arrives at. And I listened to this patient very carefully, and her one complaint was fatigue.
- 3:34having cared for a lot of cancer patients of different varieties, many times you'll hear that complaint from them, either from problems with bone marrow suppression after chemotherapy or just fatigue from having to deal with cancer for such a long period of time, both emotional. Yeah. Yeah. So, of course, and, you know, my mother passed away from cancer. My sister had breast cancer. And so I, you know, try to take care of everybody like their family. So basically I took care of this gal and, you know,
- 4:03So we're in the operating room and, you know, she actually had a request for me. She said, can you do an M-block capsulectomy? And I was like, why would you even know that term? I mean, that's a pathology term. And, you know, I had done cancer care my entire career. Yeah.
- 4:18and had been trained, you know, by great surgeons. And I was like, well, yeah, I can do that. I mean, just a weird request. And I had no idea where it was coming from. Right. So I took her and I did the case and she had to be monitored overnight in the hospital for a cardiac condition. I saw her in follow up and she was doing really well. We reviewed her labs and I always checked every case for residual or recurrence in a cancer because you have to. It's a cancer case. Right.
- 4:47And I always, when I took out a set of devices and capsule and all the materials involved, all the scarring and everything, I would always check for any residual bacterial or fungal contamination. And this lady had an E. coli infection. Whoa. So that's not just in the gut. That can be anywhere in the body for those listening, right?
- 5:09Yeah, for your listeners, that's a bad problem. And on a CLIA-based lab system, so that everybody listening understands, there's two ways to do things. There's swabs that look like Q-tips that then you'll swab a space or a substance or a liquid or a fluid, whatever. And then you'll send that to the lab and they'll plate that. They'll put it on an auger plate and try to incubate it. That's the tradition. That hasn't changed in 100 years.
- 5:35Then there's PCR testing. And we'll talk about that later. So this was on a CLIA based hospital system test. And you know exactly how bad that has to be to get that result. So your audience listening, that has to be greater than 10 to the sixth. That's over a hundred thousand colonies of bacteria. And I was like, how did I miss this? How, I mean, I went back through all my notes and I'm,
- 6:01her pictures and I'm like, I was like, how on earth did I miss this? And, you know, magically all of her fatigue went away. Wow. She had a breast implant infection. And so it was still kind of beyond me, like how this had occurred. I couldn't, you know, find this. I was just like, none of her labs were wrong. You know, nothing was off. Just the fatigue thing. Okay. Okay.
- 6:27And so clearly, you know, this this woman was very sweet and she put me on some board on Facebook, I believe, and said I did explants and I would do an in block capsulectomy and just people started coming out of the woodwork to see me.
- 6:45And, you know, because I had missed that, I was very, you know, leery of missing things. I had always prided myself on never missing a cancer case. So this really bothered me. I was a cancer patient and I would be beside myself if someone had done that to my sister and missed something.
- 7:03I was like, well, if these folks have tons of fatigue and otherwise, you know, an exam is normal, I have this now case that didn't make sense to me. Okay. And so from time to time, people opt to have, you know, devices, you know, removed. But at that point, I was still placing devices for cancer reconstruction and for cosmetics.
- 7:28By devices, you mean implants, right? Yeah, I was still, you know, just performing my normal practice that I had done for years. And, you know, I'd have people come in. And so that everybody understands, like, from cancer training, I learned all these different, basically, methodologies and had more tools in the toolbox than most people about correcting problems. So I was a go-to person for implant-based capture contracture, malposition, malposition.
- 7:56you know, just revisions, like things that people didn't really as a community-based plastic surgeon who just did cosmetics would even have necessarily that much experience because in cancer cases, those problems exist all the time because those folks have so many different problems with surgeries being more aggressive and extensive due to cancer. So I learned all these things. So I was always a resource in any community I've ever been in to take care of problems. And so
- 8:26You know, I would see and take care of people. And then from time to time, I'd have somebody ask me for an explant. And it may have been somebody who had multiple revisions. And I will tell you, if you've had multiple procedures, you're set up for problems.
- 8:41Hold on to that. That's a little tease. We're going to come back to that for sure. Okay. Keep going. Yep. So not everybody needs or wants to have an explant. I'd have people come in and ask me, you know, very frequently, especially at that timeframe, like, what do you think about this? Should I get this done? Yeah.
- 8:59And all I had was that really limited experience. And I would say, you know, in this small sample I have, you know, I've had people have a couple problems with infections, but otherwise I don't have, you know, a big experience to, you know, tell you and give you perspective about it. You know, part of giving someone a informed consent in a surgery is knowing all those things. And now fast forward six years later, I can definitely tell you a lot. Right.
- 9:27Yeah, I was going to say, so somebody comes to you with that, but that's what I respect about you is that you're not saying literally every person that had an implant put in, which you obviously do for aesthetic purposes too. So you're not anti implants.
- 9:44You are basically saying it depends on the person. And that's why you're here talking because that is what I believe as well. I think it's individualized. So now you get that same question six years later. Now, how are you going to answer it?
- 9:59Yeah, and now, you know, I will say now in the last couple of years, I stopped my revision practice. And basically because eventually everybody will have a problem. And it doesn't matter how good I am at fixing their problems.
- 10:15So at this point, I don't do revisions or primaries anymore, but it's not because of so much a device issue. It's more of eventually, whether it's a hip, knee or breast implant, they're going to need to be replaced or revised. Something's going to happen.
- 10:30And at this point in my career, after 20 some years of doing that, I just don't want to do that. So like totally fine. Yeah. If you focus on the explant. So let's let's really go into, first of all, what makes someone a candidate for explant surgery?
- 10:59And kind of the steps that women should take, because here's the issue that I see. And I kind of hinted to it in the beginning. I see women in all these Facebook groups, like you were kind of thrust into, like here's what Robert does. But all these Facebook groups, and listen, I'm coming from the hypothyroid world. I see patients every day coming to me with the fatigue and the hair loss and the weight gain and all the things. And they're in the Facebook groups
- 11:27God, just tell me an answer. Give me something. Give me give me a direction as to why I feel like shit. Right. And they grab on to an answer. So I'm willing to bet that at least 10 percent of the people in the breast explant illness groups, Facebook groups are searching for that answer. Maybe it's the implants that will finally make me feel better. Right. So not everybody needs it. Let's go through who does and what you look for.
- 11:54Right. So, you know, we talked, I'm giving a talk at A4M this Sunday, and the headline of my talk is, what do I think breast implant illness is, right? And there is no medical diagnostic code for breast implant illness. So both you and I deal a lot with inflammation. You know, we experience and deal with inflammation individually in our lives and personally with our patients. And really, breast implant illness, to me, is just...
- 12:22inflammation. The medical device, the breast implant itself is only one potential driver of inflammation. So you, as well as I know that your immune system and how it functions dictates much of how we manage, deal with, and get rid of inflammation. And if your gut health sucks, if you didn't pick your parents right, if you don't take care of yourself, you're going to be a good one.
- 12:50If you got exposed to mold, heavy metals, phthalates, glyphosfates, all this stuff, then yeah, you're going to have breast implant illness. And there ain't a damn thing I can do about it other than take out those implants and get the rest of you sorted. Because as good a practitioner as you are, as good as I am, as good as our colleagues are,
- 13:10Once you've reached a certain amount of inflammation, you can take care of those clients as well as possible and still not really solve that problem. Because now it's not just that, you know, the gut's out of whack or thyroid's off or
- 13:26you know, their sex hormones are off or they eat like crap. But now they have a device that also contributes to a huge amount of inflammation, especially the texture devices. Those are extremely strong promoters of inflammation in what I've seen over 20 years. Is that just because of the texture on them itself and it irritates the tissue around it?
- 13:49Yeah, it's the increased contact because of the surface area and in particular, the devices that have been pulled from Allergan. I mean, their intent in those devices, because I was an oncologic reconstructive surgeon most of my career, those were really designed to help us take care of cancer patients.
- 14:07Because cancer patients don't have a lot of tissue left, right? Because the whole risk reduction is really to do a mastectomy and leave, you know, very little tissue. And so you need something that gives a woman the most shape, form possible at one time. Yeah.
- 14:24It was never my practice to use a lot of implants. I was a specialized type of oncologic reconstructive surgeon. I used your own tissue to make a breast. I would use the tummy tissue. I could use the thigh tissue. And I did that using microsurgical techniques. So that's really, I mean, that was my forte. I really didn't do a bunch of implants. I would honestly end up taking care of people who had implant problems and convert them to what's called an autologous reconstruction. So...
- 14:52You know, my experience is a little bit different. And I think now people want to use both programmatically what I've developed, my heart program for recovery. They kind of try to get advice from me on what to do, just like you're asking, like, well, what should I do about this? And you know, now I have this and will always have this huge interest in functional genomics. It's always been the most interesting thing to me. And it's where medicine should be, not where it is now.
- 15:20And when you look at their immune system pathways, their vitamin D metabolism, their methylation pathways, their antioxidant pathways, and how they manage and deal with glutathione metabolism, you can see who is the setup for this problem. And so when people ask me- Not necessarily autoimmune, right? It's not just- No. Yeah. Okay. I just want to clarify. Yeah. It is not an autoimmune disorder. No. Autoimmune means you're attacking your own body. Mm-hmm.
- 15:49This is not. This is, you know, how you manage inflammation. It's everybody comes to me because I want to look and feel better. Right. I'm the guy who actually does something about aging. Right. If we manage inflammation better, you're always going to look better. You're going to feel better. You're going to age better. Right.
- 16:07So, you know, now that we know more about functional genomics and instead of using a prescription, we can use a supplement, we can alter a diet, we can change a lifestyle issue. Like those are the most meaningful things for these patients, whether or not I do an explant for them. I try to get them all to understand and embrace the concept of managing their inflammation.
- 16:27Right. Right. That's beautiful. So, and I think that's part of the, the thought processes gone wrong around this is that people think, Oh, it must be,
- 16:39an autoimmune situation because I have Hashimoto's, I'm going to have breast implant illness. And you're literally saying, no, it's not even about that. It's literally about the inflammation in your body. So now how do you, and this is the other thing that I have mad respect for you for is that you actually take people through a, a functional program that,
- 17:00And you look at sex hormones, you look at thyroid, you look at markers of inflammation, insulin, all the things to see if there's something that we can do before we go into surgery. Right. Well, the most powerful thing is like who teaches you. And I happen to be taught by great, great just surgeons and just people. And every Saturday morning I would just get beat on on rounds about nutrition. Yeah.
- 17:28It's because the people who trained me were the people that came up with the concept of IV nutrition, their mentors basically had, it was that genre of surgeon and
- 17:39That's what kept little babies alive. That's what kept critically ill patients alive. And back, you know, when I trained, I'm basically old enough now. It's kind of funny. But we didn't have intensivists in the hospital. If you were a surgeon, you took care of your own patient from point A to point B, point C until they went home to discharge. Imagine that.
- 18:02There was no, no person you called. And my mentors would shame the death out of you if you did think you needed to call somebody because you weren't smart enough to figure it out. And so they made sure you were a very good doctor. The whole point was, before you were a good surgeon, you had to be a very good doctor. And so
- 18:24When someone asked me why do I even care about nutrition, they're like, well, my burn patients and my cancer patients probably cared that I knew a little bit about nutrition. Plastic surgeons where I trained, we ran the burn care for the entire state of Indiana. We were the tertiary referral center and the plastic surgeons were the primary physicians. We didn't have anybody do anything.
- 18:47We did all the surgery. We did all the critical care. I mean, it was just like... But that kind of experience is totally... It changed how I...
- 18:58learned everything. And then I never forgot that. I mean, we always used it. I just think now it's more of an expression of everything that I learned, but it's so much better now because now we add functional genomics to it, or we have functional medicine testing, or, you know, we do our own hormone balancing because I take a bunch of stick from people around here because they're like, why is Rob doing hormones? I'm like, well,
- 19:23So just so everybody understands, cancer patients and critically ill patients die if they don't get taken care of properly from a nutritional standpoint. And if their hormones are all out of whack, their cortisol is super high, and they don't have enough testosterone, they will not heal. So in order to get someone as lovely as Dr. Horniman in and out of surgery and recover really fast because she's a very busy woman, has a lot going on,
- 19:48I will always make sure hormones are balanced out because you'll stay swollen longer, you'll have less energy, you'll have more fatigue, your results will not be as good. So I always want my patients to have the best results. I mean, 60% of my patients fly in from out of state for a reason. So my program, HARP, is basically, it's my holistic accelerated recovery program, but it's just basically everything I've done in my career. I make sure that...
- 20:14The nutrition, you know, we have a nutritionist on staff now, but I make sure from a food sensitivity standpoint, we're controlling inflammation. And then I don't ever want to put anybody through surgery who's having problems with constipation like a lot of women do, either because of the gut microbiome. So we'll do a gut microbiome test or several tests.
- 20:36We just want to make sure that we get you on the right track before you ever have a treatment with us, because your results obviously are my my calling card. But you have to feel good in order to get a good result. And people who can't eat and digest their foods or get their nutrition.
- 20:54their nutrients from their foods, they always have a tougher time. They'll stay swollen longer. They'll produce more edema fluid if you want to think of it like that. Right. And, you know, we have a lymphatic massage therapist in my office full time, and we have a lymphatic massage balancer pro device. So I put everybody in those things because, you know, ice compression elevation, lymphatic massage, good nutrition, balanced hormones, knowing your genetics, supplementing them. According to that, those people have the best outcomes. Right.
- 21:23Right, right. And you even, you'll do testing even prior to them making that final decision to go through the surgery or not. Because what if you found something in testing like balancing hormones? What if you're like, well, maybe you're fatigued. You just need some more testosterone. And then you won't need the explant as much as I want to take your money, right? Like you might not need it. So let's try this before we move on. It's been very organic because now people are just seeking me out for that program. Yeah. Yeah.
- 21:54They're not really seeking me necessarily for surgery because it's hard to travel to Austin. But we run our program to care for people who want to feel better and not have an explant or people who want to feel better after they've had surgery with someone else, which is everybody's prerogative. Obviously, we just we want everybody to do better.
- 22:12Right. And have as much information to make an informed decision as possible. I think when you understand your genetics, your hormone levels, your nutritional status, how your gut works –
- 22:24your toxicity levels. I mean, I have so many people with mold. If you live on the coast of this country, I think you have mold and I won't operate on you. Have you found mold inside the capsule too? Because I had a patient literally it was, is myself and my health coach were on with her. And she's talking about like, she has implants and dah, dah, dah. And,
- 22:46And she's like, I have had them in for 25 years. And we both went, oh, you know, I mean, like if even if it's not BII, you have some mold growing in that capsule, right? I mean, old saline implants of 25 years. So we could talk about that. So I get asked those questions a lot. And so after 2008,
- 23:11And 16, when I did that case, and I found that E. coli infection on CLIA-based labs. So always remember that's a taking a swab and swab in a pocket or a surface and then growing it in an incubator.
- 23:24I had a nurse travel from out of state to visit me. Her sister lived in Austin and she had found me and wanted me to be her surgeon. And she came and I saw her and she was actually an ICU nurse. And I all I could think of was like all this stuff. This lady's been exposed to her whole career.
- 23:43has gotta be stuck on her implant somehow, like she got a cut or, you know, you get things by contamination at the time of surgery by the surgeon or the assistant, or you get, you know, a hepatogenous showering of that either through having a pneumonia or having a UTI or having a colonoscopy or whatever. There's all sorts of ways to get bacteria into your bloodstream.
- 24:07And I took her implants out and they were the grossest, slimiest things that weren't ruptured. They were completely intact, but they just had biofilm on them. And I came out to her husband. I said, man, she is going to get better. It's going to be, you know, these are infected. I guarantee it. And I did them the old way. I did all the samples and swabs and I sent them off and nothing, nothing came back. And I was like, wow.
- 24:36Oh my God. Now I look like an idiot because I know, I know this is what's going on. Right. But for the audience, that is an inferior technique that's been around a very, very long time. And biofilm is super difficult to both get off of implants.
- 24:54and to then declare what the actual offending organism is. Right. And there used to be studies done with this where they would vibrate vascular graphs to get the biofilm to come off. Because it was so adherent, you couldn't culture it, then you couldn't treat the patient, you couldn't help them. So at that point, I was probably vice president of the Research Foundation at that point.
- 25:17So we had been learning about ALCL, which is the anaplastic large cell lymphoma associated most closely with the textured implants. And there was a company, Microgen DX in Lubbock, Texas, that they'd used preliminarily for a lot of the early work with it. And then MD Anderson started doing their own work.
- 25:36And I basically got in touch with that company. And I said, look, can I send you my samples and you run them against your panel of bacterial and fungal DNA? And they're like, yeah. All right. I said, well, I need...
- 25:51one price and I'm going to send you all these. And so I did about between 300 and 400 CLIA-based samples before I switched to PCR. So PCR for everybody listening, all you need is one colony of DNA from a bacteria or fungus or mycobacterium for that matter to give you a positive. So you know, it's actually there.
- 26:15And so since then, I've done over 840 PCR tested samples. And as you would expect, there's a kind of wide variety of bacteria. But the most prominent, the number one bacteria is called Cutie bacterium acnes. And it's the in its highest concentration. It's on our face because it's part of acne. OK, our chest and our shoulders. OK.
- 26:43So is it just the fact that that's on the breast that gets into the nipple and goes down and contaminates the device? Is it the fact that somebody pops is it and, you know, gives them showers their bloodstream with, you know, this bacteria? Right. Is it someone scratching their chest because, you know, it itches and there's there's a acne? Whatever. I don't even it doesn't matter.
- 27:06Yeah. Right. This is what you find. This is reality. Right. And when someone gets on the Internet and writes some stupid stuff, I don't really care because I have objective evidence that shows you exactly what is there. When people say they have crazy mold growing in their implants, I'm like, OK, I mean, that sounds awesome. It should be on TMZ. But in reality, I only you know, if you're my patient, whoever's listening, it's all going to be very straightforward for you.
- 27:34I'm not cryptic at all. I do everything by the book every single time. I take everything out the same way. I sample it the same way. It's all sent off. Our testing is very organized. Our recovery program is excellent. Our pre-op medication program is set up for success to make you have the least amount of nausea. No nerve pain. I use nerve block on everybody.
- 27:56I mean, I can't stand variability. Like I want everything to be the best for everybody. So I work really hard to make sure that, you know, the, the, you know, the eyes are dotted and the T's are crossed. Well, and I like it too, that you, because I've heard you say this, that you acknowledge that this is an emotional procedure as well as a physical procedure and nurturing their emotions afterwards is just as important for healing, right?
- 28:24As are the hormones, which huge fan of testosterone for healing. We can get into that, but not right away because we have too many rabbit holes to go down. But no, I love that. I love that you approach it from that. You got to heal the woman too afterwards because this is a rough procedure. It's a big choice.
- 28:42It is. It's it's an early on. I didn't offer immediate fat transfers because I didn't kind of know the lay of the land. I didn't know what was completely going on. And actually, a patient got me to do theirs. And she just wouldn't she wouldn't let it go. She's like, I cannot have you take these out and not do a fat transfer. Something have something. Right. So there are answers for women, too.
- 29:04Right, and she knew one of my cancer patients, and she's like, I know you did this for Susie Smith. I know you did this. Yeah. I'm like, well, yeah, I've done over several thousand fat transfers for cancer patients because I used to do over 150 a year for over a decade, easy, for cancer patients because obviously when you do a cancer reconstruction based on the fact that they just had mastectomies, typically bilateral mastectomies, they're not even. Mm-hmm.
- 29:33Nobody's even. Nobody's even to begin with and nobody's even after that surgery. It's my job to make everybody even. That's what I do. So fat is the best filler always just for your patients to know. It's the original one and it works.
- 29:48Otherwise, nobody would get a Brazilian butt lift if anybody's been paying attention, right? No, you don't have one butt cheek bigger than the other. Typically, I mean, it all works. People are best, you know, obviously the breast itself is a very emotional topic for these cases where if I have a petite woman come in with a big implant and she is small and small framed, obviously those are the people with the most dicey outcomes. So if I can at all, I'm always trying to.
- 30:18Anytime you take out a breast implant, it changes the aesthetic and it's not going to be for the better in most instances. So I want to give back and provide volume, improve shape. You know, if I have to lift and do that, I can. I've got all sorts of proprietary things we've developed to help offset the, you know, what is a very emotional situation for the client, you know, first and foremost. Yeah.
- 30:44I've tried to get spouses and significant others really more involved so they can appreciate what's going on, you know, from both the physical but more the emotional, you know, standpoint. And I'm proud to say we've had some very good spouses of late. I've tried to make sure that, you know, as much as possible, they come to all the appointments they can. Sometimes it's obviously not practical for work and things like that, but...
- 31:07So they meet me and know what I'm talking about and conveying because I can give everybody a lot of information. I try to keep it as focused as possible. I've learned over six years a lot about this topic, and I have a lot of grasp of things that I can guarantee most providers have no idea about. Yeah. It's just...
- 31:29And that's fine. It's just the emotional part is harder if the spouse or significant other's not there. I have a patient advocate who's in my office basically full time for all the clients as a resource. And now we have a physician's assistant who's also had an explant and she's going to run my recovery program.
- 31:50So we're really trying to, and it's meaningful, right? They'll always ask a question to those women versus me because they want to know their experience. I can't give you that. Exactly. Yeah. I think that helps to have somebody that's gone before you and to know what to expect along the way from the person that's been there and done that. I think that's fantastic. Yeah.
- 32:13Now, Dr. Rob, I want to throw out the couple of things, the cases that we talked about before I talked about in the beginning here. So I have had I would I would say of my patients, I can think of a solid three.
- 32:30that had the explant surgery done did not get better. Like legit, they're like, no, now I got to look at putting them back in. My husband won't let me get them back in because it was expensive surgery, getting them out and this and that. And then one, now I've had, I'm not going to dismiss the grouping over here that I've had or probably five to 10.
- 32:49that I always ask, okay, you had the exploit. How'd you feel? Oh, tremendously changed my world, world of difference. I was felt like I was dying. So we have the people that a hundred percent made a huge difference. We have the three that I know that didn't. And of one of the three,
- 33:06She ended up, but it was a year after the explant, but so crazy. It had to have been connected somehow. Maybe you can clarify. Hives all over her body. I mean, prednisone in and out of the hospital for a year, multiple specialists testing, gut testing, histamine, allergy, did it all these specialists. And finally, she's on now an immunomodulator to keep everything calm. So she doesn't have to be on prednisone the rest of her life. Yeah.
- 33:36So I'll turn that over to you now. Yeah, I think she's somebody who would really benefit from functional genomic testing because she probably has a pathway that's turned on instead of turned down. And that's why...
- 33:49she's experiencing an increased immune response, not a decreased immune response. So she's a concerning patient. I just took care of a patient with whole body, rash, eczema, everything. And I've had several instances where...
- 34:06these patients arrive, they have tried everything under the sun with derms, and the derms are kind of at a loss. And then they're like, you know, maybe you should go see someone like, you know, Dr. Robb and see if he can, you know, provide some, you know, guidance about this. Maybe it is a device-related issue. Now, in those instances where they have the device, the breast implants in place, and they're having that like eczema or whole body rash thing,
- 34:34I feel like that's more of a, dare I say, almost like an allergic response. Like when you get a drug rash, it's all over the trunk. And then when you stop the drug, the rash goes away. I've taken out implants on table. And by the end of the case, many of those rashes are gone. Okay.
- 34:53So that's really more like a reaction. And I don't know what's mediating the reaction other than something with the device. Now, not all of those have biofilm either. But in her, I mean, she's got something probably in her methylation pathway that's completely amped up and that's why. In the other cases, so in those, so those are the reasons why my program exists, right? If you do the work upfront,
- 35:19You won't have that because if they're going through the program and they get better, then they're just mediating their inflammation and the medical device, the breast implant is not the big driver.
- 35:31So there are all sorts of drivers, as you know, and your clients know. But I think what your salient point is don't jump to the conclusion that it's this. Right. You know, so I took care of patients like we have talked about with different forms of cancer. And I had a dual appointment as a plastic surgeon and an orthopedic surgery appointment where I taught.
- 35:53And I would take care of sarcoma patients for the audience. Sarcoma patients, very rare cancer. It affects fat, muscle, bone. And so people would either get an amputation or a limb salvage procedure. And I was the guy who would help cover the prosthetic used to salvage the limb. So they would take out a portion of your femur or your tibia and they would replace it with a prosthetic. These are huge. I mean, these things are enormous. And the first time I ever saw one, I was really intimidated. I was like, wow.
- 36:19okay, I better figure out how to cover this up because this is a life over situation. These folks won't survive. They'll get an infection. They could die or need an amputation. In those situations, I got to learn a lot about the –
- 36:36orthopedic devices and how they cope with infections and problems. And nobody who operates and uses a device is immune from anything. Doesn't matter what type of device it is. Deep brain stimulators from neurosurgeons I took care of.
- 36:52defibrillators from cardiac people, infected sternums from cardiac surgeons with their plates and all their crazy junk, sternal wires, all sorts of crazy stuff I've taken care of, infected, you know, tibial prosthesis or femurs or hips or knees or whatever. Like nobody's immune to this stuff. Right. But I can tell you now, spending all this time looking at everybody's genetics, you can definitely figure out who's more susceptible to it.
- 37:18So in the four pathways, if you're missing or have problems in all four of them,
- 37:25Like everybody asks me, Rob, can you, is there a test? Do you have a test for this? Can you, can you tell if someone has breast implant illness? I'm like, well, no, but I can tell you who's more susceptible to develop it. I can, I can tell you that, you know, through genetics, I think that's my best like lens to look through and see like, based on their immune pathway function, who's more susceptible to this. And then.
- 37:50I think that's basically the take home message that I can share with you and your audience is like you can't outrun your genetics. Right. Right. You didn't pick your parents, but they definitely gave you your genetics. Yeah. So the more you learn about that, the better off you'll be. And, you know, maybe that's at the end game what all of this work is accomplished is that I feel better like myself.
- 38:15about that as an answer now. I've always been really reluctant. I don't like to go out there if I can't support what I'm saying with data. I don't feel like that's something we should ever do for patients. They put a lot of faith in us to give them the best answers. And I feel like I've answered a lot of the questions that I started with in 2016 after that case. So...
- 38:42Yeah. Well, no, we're happy you're doing what you're doing. Before I let you go, though, we have to talk about the revision issues because we've talked about, you know, some symptoms that people can have, how to check, you know, even just coming to you for that kind of rundown of their genetics, genomics to see if maybe they are susceptible to this.
- 39:04But now we have revisions. Now, when you said that, here's my mind peaking because I went from under to over, under the muscle to over the muscle, changed from saline to silicone. Once we figured out silicone is not so bad and has a much better shape, and then changed, actually went down in size. So I've had four now. So does that make me more prone to breast cancer? Yeah.
- 39:31or to even BII, but both, answer both of those. Or are you talking total revisions? Yeah.
- 39:37No, I think what I look at it is because I see so much biofilm, which for the audience, once again, is it a contaminant of bacteria or fungus? Predominantly, it's bacteria. So I didn't say it before, but I've only had four instances of fungus out of 1,100 samples, 1,100 explants that I've done. And so it's predominantly what I said. It's Cutie bacterium acnes, and that's from our skin of our face, neck, chest, shoulders.
- 40:07In revisions, because it's entering the space again, and I will say the same thing, it's always best to be first. Yeah. Because that's the best time to have the best result, right? The first time is the best time. If it's done properly, hand-in-glove fit, that's how I always was taught and that's how I always think about it. Each time you go back, there's scarring,
- 40:36The blood flow is not as good as the time before aging. There may have been pregnancy. There may have been weight loss, weight gain. There's just a lot of factors. And every time you open a surgical space where there's a breast implant, a hip implant, a knee implant,
- 40:52you have the opportunity to introduce bacteria into that environment. So I always worry about people becoming super symptomatic after they had an exchange, after they had some repair or revision, because I did so much of that work.
- 41:10I know what the issues are, but once again, it was a different type of work I did. And it was all more hospital mediated with very specific protocols in place for what we were doing, what techniques we were using, how like everything was always for me, like very rote and complicated.
- 41:31If this was your mom's breast implant for breast cancer, or this was your dad's knee implant for a knee cancer, it was always like that kind of pressure I put to each case. And I always tell everybody like, you know, it's easier to be a professional athlete. They only play the Super Bowl once a year. Yeah, that's true. Every time I operated on a woman for breast cancer, that was the Super Bowl. That was the Super Bowl. Yeah. So 95% of the time I was successful in the Super Bowl.
- 42:01Yeah, those are some good stats right there. I want you on my fantasy football team.
- 42:08I mean, those are the things that, you know, everybody wants to come see you for their thyroid. You want to see the best person to take care of you for that problem. That's the pressure we put on ourselves and our programs when we did those. So, I mean, it's no different now. I just feel like when I hear those things, my ears perk up. If someone tells me, like, they have my favorite, one of my favorite questions to ask people is,
- 42:34When you get in the car with your significant other or your kids, regardless of what decibel the stereo is on, do you turn it down? Do you turn down the car radio every single time you get in it? And 100% they're like, oh, yeah. I'm like, oh, okay. So you have sound sensitivity. Oh. And I'm like, do you have like light sensitivity as well? Does light bother you? Oh, yeah. A lady told me she had to wear headphones to do the dishes in her sink.
- 43:03Oh, okay. That is sound sensitivity. Dang. All right. And then if they have headache and it's kind of obvious, like who's got mold, right? They're anxious. They can be, you know, a little bit angry.
- 43:17Right. But then sometimes I'll go to, well, you don't have enough progesterone too. So I don't know. But in Texas, I think you all, everybody has mold until- Everybody's got mold in Texas. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. So I just, I like answers. I asked the question, I was like, where were you living? I'm like the home reno detective. I mean, did you renovate your house when you were living at it? Or did you move to a different one? And-
- 43:40There's so many old homes in Austin and old like condo buildings and apartment buildings. Like the kids who go to school here, they live in some really old places. And the moms will tell me, oh, you know, I went and visited my kid and there's mold in the in the vent. I'm like, oh, Lord. You know, and people who don't, you know, if their glutathione metabolism is poor, you know what's going to happen. Right.
- 44:05they're going to have a chronic mold exposure because they can't kick it out of their liver. And, you know, it becomes all like when you just listen to the patterns, it's everything you went through in school, like they're just different now. Now they're genomic patterns instead of the patterns we were taught about specific disease processes because nobody taught you about toxic mold exposures. I mean –
- 44:28No, no. That only happened to immunosuppress people. Right. Exactly. Now, this has been great. That's all just another example of how deep into each individual patient you go, really checking all of the boxes. And I mean all of the boxes. If we could clone you and then put you into endocrinology, rheumatology, that would be amazing.
- 44:55I actually had an OB send a patient to me. Hey, why not? I mean, listen, you do it all. What the hell? And you're going to do it better than the run-of-the-mill conventional OB. I'm going to tell you that. They got a lot. I mean, that's your primary care provider, and that's for a lot of women. That's, you know, it's just we all have to do better, basically. You just got to do better. Exactly. Exactly.
- 45:20So Dr. Rob, we will have obviously all of your contact information everywhere in the description, in the show notes, but are you taking new patients right now? Yes. I am. So you can contact us a couple of ways. I have two sites, my breast implant illness expert.com site and my dr robert whitfield.com sites.
- 45:45And those are the two fundamental ways. You can follow us on social, Dr. Robert Whitfield, on Instagram and TikTok. And my show, I hope to have you on soon, Holistic with Scientific. It's my podcast. Awesome. We'll put all the links in so people will be able to easily find you. But Dr. Carl, thank you so much for your time today. I greatly appreciate it. This was the message that I wanted to give my listeners. So thank you. Thank you for having me. Appreciate it.