Latest / Politics with Paul / Have We Strayed From the Federalist Papers' Vision? | Politics with Paul #99
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Rayner.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about whether the Federalist Papers hold up to today's politics.
- 0:15Core reading material for politics and political science includes a collection of 85
- 0:20papers called the Federalist Papers, written to promote and support the ratification of the US
- 0:26Constitution in 1787.
- 0:29The Federalists supported replacing the heavily flawed Articles of Confederation completely
- 0:36with this constitution, which was technically done illegally according to the law of the
- 0:41articles, but I digress on that point.
- 0:43The Federalist Papers laid out all the reasons why the constitution was crafted the way it was
- 0:50and why it was necessary for that time.
- 0:53And John Jay wrote a handful of them, James Madison wrote a significant number of them and
- 0:58Alexander Hamilton wrote the most and all of them were under the pseudonym Publius and while
- 1:04they are dense and archaically written, this is the late eighteenth century, they are key to
- 1:09fully understanding the constitution then and now in their entirety, but some of them are
- 1:15regarded either often or by consensus as the most essential of the papers, especially
- 1:22numbers ten and fifty one.
- 1:24And although The US constitution hasn't quite been around for two hundred fifty years, there
- 1:29is no better time than this semi quincentennial to revisit these vital documents and whether
- 1:35the arguments still hold up today and whether we follow the principles in them.
- 1:42So which Federalist papers are we looking at?
- 1:4585 papers is way too much to cover in one episode and you could probably, if you really
- 1:50tried to make an episode for every single paper.
- 1:53Of course, we're not gonna do that.
- 1:55But we're gonna look at six of the seminal most often studied papers.
- 2:00Number 10, on the dangers of factions and how to counteract them.
- 2:05Number 39, defines the system of government of The US constitution and explains the concept of
- 2:10federalism, although it doesn't actually use that word.
- 2:12Number 51, why checks and balances and the separation of powers is necessary to protect
- 2:18liberty.
- 2:19Number 70, the need for an energetic and singular executive.
- 2:23Number 78, necessity of an independent judiciary with lifetime terms.
- 2:28And number 84, which argues that a bill of rights isn't needed?
- 2:33Stick around for that one.
- 2:35But let's first get to Federalist paper number 10 about the dangers of factions and how to
- 2:42counteract them.
- 2:44And this is probably the most well regarded of the Federalist Papers.
- 2:49If you ask somebody to distill the ultimate the core of The US constitution and all the papers
- 2:57written in favor of it, they'd probably pick number 10 to be the ultimate figurehead for
- 3:03that, if you will.
- 3:05It was written by James Madison and it argues why the US constitution system would prevent
- 3:09any one group from accumulating too much power to trample over the other groups.
- 3:17Many of the founding fathers, not quite all of them even though some people kind of
- 3:21collectively say this is the case and probably be more accurate to say framers of the US
- 3:25constitution, were apprehensive about full direct democracy.
- 3:30They were concerned about this idea of mob rule and Shays' rebellion was the final straw for
- 3:37this, what they saw as democratic excess.
- 3:40And so the US constitution, there wasn't a lot of direct democracy in there.
- 3:45The US house was directly elected, and it was representative of the populations of the
- 3:52states, but the president was indirectly elected by the electoral college so technically
- 3:57the states in a way elect the president, although through the citizens instead of the
- 4:02actual state government.
- 4:03And then the US Senate was the one that was elected by state legislatures and amendments to
- 4:10the US Constitution had to be done through state legislatures and conventions, not voted
- 4:15on by the public even if the public could push for a lot of these amendments.
- 4:20So you saw a lot
- 4:21of provisions in the constitution that was against or at least not in support of full
- 4:30direct democracy.
- 4:32But one
- 4:32of the key points of Federalist number 10 is a word that's not actually used in the document.
- 4:41It describes the concept of pluralism, which is this idea that diverse groups can live
- 4:47peacefully within a society while maintaining their identities.
- 4:52And a word that actually is used in the document is faction, which just simply means a
- 5:00group of people with a common interest.
- 5:02And as James Madison astutely points out, factionalism is inherent to human nature.
- 5:07And so the cure to this factionalism is to control its effects, which is not possible in a
- 5:15pure democracy, but is possible in a republic.
- 5:19Pure democracy is this simply just majority rules.
- 5:24If you're
- 5:25in the minority, tough luck.
- 5:27Republic,
- 5:29we elect representatives to represent us.
- 5:33And so instead of these direct decisions on laws, we elect a small body of representatives
- 5:38to vote for laws instead.
- 5:40And so the idea was that this would result in laws of the interest of the community instead
- 5:45of being dictated by factions' self interest.
- 5:49Factions would, to some extent, have to
- 5:51work together to elect these people in this government.
- 5:55And it wouldn't just be that these office holders would just be at
- 6:00the beck and call of a particular singular faction.
- 6:03There were multiple factions trying to vie for that representative's attention.
- 6:10And it also argues in this paper that a large republic is better than a small one for these
- 6:17purposes because in a large republic, more people equals more factions, which equals fewer
- 6:23chances for a majority to take over the other.
- 6:25So it's protecting minority rights.
- 6:29And you have to remember back then, The United States information did not travel far at all or
- 6:37or or it took forever to travel far.
- 6:39One of the objections to the constitution was, well, this there's no way that this kind of
- 6:45thing can work because this country is just too big, it's too vast, you can't have an effective
- 6:50system or you can't have a system of government like this where the federal government is much
- 6:57more active in what the states are doing, you have to let the states do their mostly their
- 7:02own thing like they were doing under the articles of confederation because things are so
- 7:08vast and information and travel is just takes forever.
- 7:12So does federalist number 10 and its arguments still hold up in today's political climate.
- 7:19I think you see clearly that the need for pluralism is as necessary as ever because you
- 7:26can't just have one singular group run roughshod over everybody else, and we are a
- 7:33melting pot for all sorts of cultures and political views and religious creeds and so on.
- 7:40And although official political parties weren't around when the Federalist Papers were written,
- 7:46they didn't arrive much longer after the Federalist Papers and the US Constitution was
- 7:51ratified, but the parties are a clear example of factionalism themselves.
- 7:57And when one of them gains too much power, it tries to silence opposition and undo all the
- 8:02opposite party's policies.
- 8:05But the parties themselves are also a collection of factions competing for influence
- 8:11on the overall party.
- 8:13You see a tug of war between them a lot times.
- 8:15You see it a little bit more with the Democratic party because the Democratic party
- 8:18is a lot more coalition based than Republicans are, but they both still have coalitions where
- 8:27multiple factions are vying for influence over those parties.
- 8:32See far left and center left competing in the Democratic Party, far right and center right
- 8:39competing for influence in the Republican Party.
- 8:43Even that is a little bit reductionist because you're not there's all sorts of shades within
- 8:48those groups.
- 8:49And some people would argue today that we are in a hyper pluralist system, not just
- 8:55pluralist.
- 8:56So hyper pluralism is this theory that there are too many interest groups that are competing
- 9:02for influence.
- 9:03Like, yeah, we have a lot of groups and no single one of
- 9:06them is going to overtake all
- 9:08the others, but there's too many of them competing.
- 9:11There's too many that have cleared the barrier to entry, and so it leads to gridlock and
- 9:17contradictory and fragmented policies.
- 9:20And judicial overload is there's more interest that take their cases to court.
- 9:24People who argue that we're in a hyper pluralist society also argue that a society and
- 9:30policies have become ever more complex, the number of different interests has also
- 9:36increased.
- 9:37All these political issues that did not exist back in the days of the founding fathers, now
- 9:42they are here.
- 9:43Artificial intelligence is one of the latest ones to fit that bill.
- 9:48And in a sense, it's actually arguing that the minority has become tyrannical and how it is
- 9:55bogging down government just to get its way.
- 9:58It's that idea of that vocal minority that's having an outsized influence.
- 10:02And you even look at how people vote, most of the
- 10:08people that are voting or at least there's a high correlation between people who are much
- 10:13more partisan and ideological than people who are less so beholden to parties and ideologies
- 10:20even though there is a sizable number of people who don't affiliate with a party or they do
- 10:26affiliate with Republicans or Democrats, but they don't care about it as much or they just
- 10:32don't think in ideological terms.
- 10:34A lot of voters do not think in ideological terms.
- 10:37But this vocal minority, the ones who are the most active in politics, even though they're
- 10:45not that many, they are having an outsized influence on politics.
- 10:51So in a way there, it's the minority dictating the policies for everybody else.
- 10:59And if elected officials do respond mostly to the most well funded and most organized groups
- 11:07that there are, still even they do not win every time.
- 11:11And more and more people are aware of the influence of money in politics.
- 11:16You see just the exorbitant amounts of money spent on the biggest, most influential
- 11:22elections in the country.
- 11:25And yet in a lot
- 11:26of cases, the system of
- 11:28pluralism still works pretty well.
- 11:31Although many places in The US have started trending towards one party rule or they've been
- 11:37doing that for quite a long time, you can still find competitive races at the federal and state
- 11:43levels.
- 11:44You find seats that flip between the parties all the time.
- 11:47You find intra party squabbles.
- 11:49Just talked about how some how Republicans, center right and far right, can tussle over the
- 11:58future of the party and the shades in between, far left and center left, vie for control of
- 12:04the Democrats and shades in between.
- 12:08Although, you see it less in the Republican Party currently because for the most part, if
- 12:14you're not
- 12:14a supporter of Donald Trump, you're kind of
- 12:17an outcast.
- 12:18But it was a lot more of that intra party squabbling in the lead up to 2016 the twenty
- 12:26sixteen election before Donald Trump became the nominee for that party.
- 12:31So right now, you are seeing more of those intra party squabbles within the Democratic
- 12:36party.
- 12:36But when the Democratic party takes power, you'll see a lot less of that, and Republicans
- 12:41will start to have more infighting.
- 12:43It's kind of the way it works when power shifts back and forth.
- 12:47So you still see a lot of pluralism at work and there are still a lot of factions that aren't
- 12:57necessarily the most well known that could still have an influence and still have their
- 13:01interests heard and become reality.
- 13:06So that does it for Federalist number 10.
- 13:09Let's go on to Federalist number 39, which talks about the blend of federal and state
- 13:16power.
- 13:18And this one was written by James Madison.
- 13:20It lays out the concept of federalism.
- 13:22Again, federalism is not actually said specifically in this paper, but that's what the
- 13:28term is for what James Madison is talking about.
- 13:32The big thing is this separate spheres of influence and power between the federal and
- 13:38state governments.
- 13:39Federal government has its responsibilities.
- 13:41State government has its responsibilities.
- 13:44This is the concept that's called dual federalism, is sort of like a layer cake.
- 13:49One layer is the federal government, one layer is the state government, they have their own
- 13:54things that they do.
- 13:56And you think back to when the US constitution was being ratified and was trying to replace
- 14:02the articles of confederation, the articles gave too much power to the states.
- 14:07It made a weak central government, and this was one of the chief reasons the US constitution
- 14:12was created.
- 14:13It was to reinvigorate this federal government while still preserving some of the powers for
- 14:18the states.
- 14:19And for the anti federalists, they believed that The US constitution was going to kneecap
- 14:25state powers to bolster the federal government.
- 14:28They saw it as a repeat of the British monarchy.
- 14:31Think about the time, and it was not that long before that The US had officially become an
- 14:38independent nation and they didn't want anything that even resembled the British
- 14:43monarchy.
- 14:43That's why they made a national government that basically had no power except for what the
- 14:50states told it to do.
- 14:52And although the Federalist Papers were written before the Bill of Rights, which we'll talk
- 14:56about some more in a little bit, the tenth amendment to the constitution delegates any
- 15:01powers not expressed in the constitution to the states.
- 15:04So you see that as fulfilling James Madison's vision of federalism even more.
- 15:10And that was partly as a way to satisfy anti federalists.
- 15:14When James Madison was running for congress, he promised to introduce a bill to try to start
- 15:20the process for adding these amendments that eventually became the Bill of Rights, the first
- 15:2510 amendments to the US constitution, and that won a lot more anti federalist support for the
- 15:34constitution.
- 15:35But does Federalist number 30 nine's arguments hold up in today's political climate?
- 15:43In the time of the founding fathers, it was much more of a dual federalism, but since the
- 15:491930s with FDR and his New Deal, we've seen a lot more cooperative federalism, which is a
- 15:56marble cake kind of description.
- 16:00The federal and state governments collaborate and share responsibilities.
- 16:05Now, obviously, there's still some clear delineations where federal government still has
- 16:09certain powers.
- 16:10For example, they are the ones who get to regulate interstate commerce and state
- 16:15governments have other powers like they set their own government structure, but you still
- 16:20see a lot more where they're cooperating on things like law enforcement, for example,
- 16:25especially law enforcement that crosses state lines or crimes that cross state lines.
- 16:30However, has the federal government taken too much power at the expense of the states now or
- 16:37has federal governments taken too much power in general?
- 16:41There are certainly a lot of people that would argue that and countless policies have been
- 16:45debated over whether or not and how much should be in federal or state purviews.
- 16:51You talk about immigration, for example.
- 16:54A lot of people would say federal government has overstepped its bounds, other people would
- 16:58say federal government is just enforcing its laws and that state government should
- 17:03cooperate.
- 17:04You kind of
- 17:04see a little bit of a There's been a little
- 17:07bit more of a reversal in terms of support of state governments to some extent because
- 17:17typically, at least from what the parties typically say, states' rights is more of a
- 17:25Republican talking point and Democrats are less so keen on it.
- 17:30But in the context of the Donald Trump administration, you see Republican the
- 17:36Republican party argue for a lot more federal intervention, and Democrats are actually saying
- 17:43to scale it back.
- 17:45And so some of this debate over whether or not we still have that core sense of federalism is
- 17:54partly due to political party affiliations.
- 17:59But there's there's too many policies to talk about that that could fit that bill.
- 18:06There's so many that's people argue whether it's not just what we should do about those
- 18:12policies, but whether it's a federal jurisdiction or a state jurisdiction thing.
- 18:17So it really kind of depends on a case by case basis whether you think those individual
- 18:23policies, whether they still uphold the concept of federalism, at least dual federalism where
- 18:31federal and state have their own separate spheres since we are in more of a cooperative
- 18:36federalist system.
- 18:38Now let's move on to federalist number 51, which talks about checks and balances and the
- 18:43separation of powers.
- 18:45This one was written by either James Madison or Alexander Hamilton.
- 18:48There's some debate about that, but it discusses the relationship between the three
- 18:52branches of government and how that protects liberty.
- 18:56The Articles of Confederation, however, had no executive branch, zero.
- 19:01There was no president, there was no anything.
- 19:04And the courts, they existed, but they were severely limited in power.
- 19:08Almost all this national power was vested in the Continental Congress.
- 19:13So that sounds like the Continental Congress could easily abuse its power.
- 19:18Right?
- 19:18Well, no.
- 19:19Even them, they were mostly beholden to the state governments.
- 19:22Remember, state governments had just about all the power under the articles of confederation,
- 19:28and it's why a lot of things bogged down because a lot of these states had their own
- 19:31interests that they supported and oftentimes butted heads with other states, especially with
- 19:39North versus South.
- 19:41The US Constitution, however, created three branches, the executive, which enforces the
- 19:47laws, the legislative, which writes the laws, and the judicial branch, which interprets the
- 19:53laws.
- 19:54And each branch is independent in its own role, depends as little as possible on the other two,
- 19:59because if you had all these powers vested in the same branch, there's probably going to be
- 20:05an abuse of power.
- 20:06I mean, could you imagine if a president got to rule on whether the laws were constitutional or
- 20:13if the legislature got to do that or if judges were the ones who got to enforce their rulings
- 20:18or got to write laws.
- 20:20It's not hard to imagine all the things that could go wrong with that.
- 20:24But in this system under the US constitution, if any branch tries to take too much power, the
- 20:30other two will bring it back down by checking said power.
- 20:33And some of these examples that you see at work under the US constitution is the president
- 20:39appoints federal judges and can pass or veto legislative bills with his ultimate he can pass
- 20:45it with his ultimate signature or say, nope.
- 20:48That bill's not happening and veto it.
- 20:51The legislature confirms these federal judges, so the president appoints them, but the
- 20:57legislature still has to confirm it.
- 20:59And they can also override presidential vetoes if they have two thirds of each house.
- 21:04And judges can rule laws unconstitutional and they have lifetime tenure to avoid retribution
- 21:11from the other branches.
- 21:13So does Federalist number 50 one's arguments still hold up in today's political climate.
- 21:20Well, are a lot of questions about how much the separation of powers is holding up today,
- 21:24particularly between president and congress, because many people feel that congress has
- 21:29ceded a lot of its power to the president and that it follows the president's beck and call
- 21:34on everything instead of being more independent and a check on his power.
- 21:40And you see that a lot, especially with cases of war, like with LBJ, Lyndon Johnson, and
- 21:49Richard Nixon when it came to Vietnam, George Bush with the war on terror, Barack Obama with
- 21:55drone strikes, Donald Trump with Iran Iran, excuse me.
- 21:59Now I'm not saying that the president has or hasn't taken too much power in these scenarios,
- 22:06but a lot of people argue that that is the case because of in particular, because of the war
- 22:12powers that he has with how much power does he actually have in declaring war.
- 22:16There's a lot of debate about what the constitution allows for the president in that
- 22:21regard.
- 22:23So it's not just with war, it's just one of the main things you see where people feel that
- 22:32congress has given up too much power to the president.
- 22:36When we hold any presidential candidate or president in such regard that we basically
- 22:43worship them.
- 22:44Our support of them becomes our identity.
- 22:46We run the risk of deteriorating this separation of powers.
- 22:51We start to become unwilling to hold the president accountable for their actions as long
- 22:55as they have policies that we like.
- 22:56So even if they refuse to enforce judicial rulings or they to usurp more power to write
- 23:05laws from Congress and a lot of people would argue that executive orders basically do that,
- 23:12it risks further eroding the separation of powers that we have.
- 23:18And it's not just a problem in the case of Trump.
- 23:21A lot of people talk about it because it's it's the time that we're in right now, but it's the
- 23:27case for other presidents, this whole cult of personality problem that we have.
- 23:32And this will be even more of a problem in the future if toxicity and polarization continue to
- 23:38ramp up.
- 23:38We got to stop worshiping these people that are in office, especially when they're a singular
- 23:46person that has an inordinate amount of power.
- 23:51But in any case though, politics over two fifty years has repeatedly demonstrated the need for
- 23:56the separation of powers because these are all human beings that are operating and any one of
- 24:01us, if we're in a position to take too much power, whether any of us were presidents or any
- 24:08of us were in the legislative branch, any of
- 24:09us were in the judicial branch, trying to usurp any of
- 24:13the powers of the other branches, it is very easy for any one of us to become corrupted and
- 24:21trying to overstep our bounds and a lot of times trying to justify those things in our
- 24:27heads.
- 24:28And in a similar vein, let's talk about Federalist number 70, which is about an
- 24:33energetic and unified executive.
- 24:36And this one was written by Alexander Hamilton who discussed the need for a singular executive
- 24:42and especially why it wasn't like the British monarchy.
- 24:46One of the many debates in the constitutional convention was whether the executive branch
- 24:51should be one person or three persons or whether the president should have a counsel to
- 24:57advise him on all sorts of policy matters.
- 25:02This lack of a counsel to advise the president was a major anti federalist objection because
- 25:08they thought that he would just be ill ill informed, informed, excuse
- 25:12me, and would act very haphazardly.
- 25:18And the whole point of
- 25:19the American revolution was to resist an oppressive government, especially one from far
- 25:24away.
- 25:24It was across an entire ocean.
- 25:27The British monarch George the third was this symbol of all that was wrong with this kind of
- 25:32government, and so that was applied to the idea of any single executive.
- 25:36And so that's why the Articles of Confederation had such a well, not a weak executive.
- 25:42It had no executive to speak of.
- 25:44The head of the Continental Congress was the closest thing to a president, and even that was
- 25:50more of a ceremonial title.
- 25:53But given the many woes and shortcomings due to the articles of confederation, the
- 25:58constitutional convention eventually settled not only on the need for an executive branch,
- 26:03but
- 26:03a singular leader with robust responsibilities, at least robust compared to what Americans had
- 26:12been experiencing up to that
- 26:13point with the Articles of Confederation.
- 26:15And Hamilton argued that a unitary executive was the most efficient and accountable.
- 26:22And he cited the misconduct and disagreements amongst the council of Rome as a major factor
- 26:29in the decline of the Roman empire.
- 26:30So he saw it as, well, if we do the same thing with America, America is basically going to
- 26:36fail before it really gets its gets going.
- 26:40But does Federalist number 70 and its arguments hold up in today's political climate?
- 26:46Well, the chief executive is undoubtedly more powerful, much more powerful than in the time
- 26:53of the founding fathers, and presidential powers have expanded what the president can and
- 26:59can't do.
- 27:00There are many more executive agencies underneath him that he can shape, just a
- 27:05general expansion of the executive branch, not just executive agencies but people who aid the
- 27:11president.
- 27:12He's one of the most recognizable figures in the entire world and he can have a significant
- 27:16influence on other countries and how their politics are shaped, but has this energetic
- 27:24executive worked out in ways that Hamilton didn't foresee?
- 27:27Has it overstepped its bounds and acted like a monarch?
- 27:31Well, you certainly see a lot of people argue that.
- 27:34Usually it's from people who aren't of the same party as the current president, so you see a
- 27:40lot of democrats say Donald Trump acts like a king.
- 27:44Republicans said Joe Biden and Barack Obama acted like kings.
- 27:48Democrats said George Bush acted like a king.
- 27:51But while it's not a recent phenomenon to have people derive a president they don't like as
- 28:00acting like a monarch, it does call into question these this whole idea of whether the
- 28:08president is too energetic.
- 28:10Well, let's look at a couple of the things that Alexander Hamilton said to support a unitary
- 28:16executive.
- 28:17First of all, he argued it was more efficient, which I mean, it it that's that's pretty pretty
- 28:24clear.
- 28:25One person versus a three person council or a three person triumvirate or having a
- 28:32presidential council tell a president what they should and shouldn't do, it's it's inevitably
- 28:38going to be more efficient to have one person calling all the shots.
- 28:44Now you do see a lot more of like a basically a counsel to the president these days, and the
- 28:50cabinet can act sort of like a counsel, but there's no counsel that's specifically there's
- 28:57no council like the framers of the constitution and the anti federalists were thinking of at
- 29:05that point.
- 29:06But efficiency isn't always a good thing when it comes to politics, and one of an episode I
- 29:11did a while ago was about this tug and pull between whether to have an efficient government
- 29:18or a deliberative government.
- 29:20Efficient will make things happen much more quickly, it'll get things done much more
- 29:26quickly, but will it lead to haphazard policies and things that weren't thought out well at
- 29:35all.
- 29:36And then deliberative democracy will get a lot more information, but will it wait too long to
- 29:43respond to things that need a quick answer?
- 29:47And those have no easy questions.
- 29:49But undoubtedly, the presidency is much more energetic and efficient in a way than it used
- 29:56to be.
- 29:57But one of the interesting things to think about is whether that makes the presidents more
- 30:02accountable because the idea that not only was for for Alexander Hamilton, not only was a
- 30:10single president more efficient, you also knew where to put the blame.
- 30:16If something went wrong, it was that guy.
- 30:18But does it work that way now?
- 30:20In some ways, yes and in some ways, no.
- 30:23A lot of people just blame the president for things that go wrong even if it's not something
- 30:27that the president has control over, even if it's not something that the president can
- 30:31indirectly impact.
- 30:34And in the face of crises like some serious economic downturns or other major screw ups, he
- 30:40does get held responsible by more people and one of the ways you see that is through the
- 30:44presidential job approval ratings.
- 30:46But partisan affiliation and loyalty to political figures can still lead people to
- 30:52refusing to hold a president accountable at all and just constantly point the finger at someone
- 30:57else instead.
- 30:59Anytime a president in recent memory has entered office and something has gone wrong,
- 31:07they'll just say, well, it was the other guy or, well, it's this congress that's that's road
- 31:12blocking me.
- 31:13And you you see that kind of thing all the time.
- 31:17So I don't know if it necessarily makes a president more accountable.
- 31:21It depends on what Alexander Hamilton meant by a more accountable executive.
- 31:26But I guess you could also say that 2020 was a time where president was held accountable.
- 31:34And anytime that a president runs for reelection and doesn't win, it's demonstrating
- 31:39how much accountability there is in a singular president.
- 31:42So you can argue both ways in that regard, but there is a need for, to some extent, an
- 31:52energetic executive, a robust executive because there are a lot of things that the president
- 31:58has to respond to in a lot more complex situations, and there's no turning back now on
- 32:04how much power the president has now.
- 32:06We're not gonna be returning to those levels that you saw in the late eighteenth century,
- 32:12early nineteenth century.
- 32:14But there can be a point where a unified executive can very much act like a monarch if
- 32:21not enough people hold that person accountable.
- 32:26Let's move
- 32:26on to Federalist number 78, which is about an independent judiciary with life tenure.
- 32:33This was written by Alexander Hamilton, which also laid the foundation for judicial review.
- 32:38Chief Justice John Marshall was the one who affirmed judicial review in the Marbury versus
- 32:43Madison case in eighteen o three, and he's oftentimes given the credit for affirming
- 32:49judicial review, which he should get to some extent.
- 32:52But the idea was first laid out in Federalist paper number 78 by Hamilton.
- 32:58So it's looking at judicial review, why it's necessary, and why an independent judiciary
- 33:04with life tenure was actually necessary to protect the constitution.
- 33:08And in the paper, Alexander Hamilton argued that the judiciary is naturally the weakest of
- 33:14the three branches.
- 33:15It does not have the power of the sword, quote unquote, like the executive branch does because
- 33:21the executive branch enforces the laws.
- 33:24And it also does not have the quote unquote power of the purse like the legislative branch
- 33:29does because one of the things that the legislative branch does in regards to writing
- 33:34laws is determining budgets.
- 33:37The judiciary, however, has no equivalent to either one of those.
- 33:42Its only power is judgment.
- 33:45And so Hamilton dismissed the idea that this judiciary could become too powerful because of
- 33:51this ability to rule laws unconstitutional.
- 33:54He says that straight up that liberty cannot be endangered by this branch.
- 33:59It has to rely on the executive and legislative branches to uphold its rulings.
- 34:04It can't actually really do anything on its own.
- 34:08And so to put the courts at least somewhat on par with the other two branches, federal judges
- 34:13were given lifetime tenures because they if they had term limits, they could be a lot more
- 34:25beholden to political whims of the presidents and the legislature.
- 34:32But do Federalist paper or does Federalist paper number 70 eight's arguments hold up in
- 34:38today's political climate?
- 34:40Some people would argue that the judiciary isn't as independent as it should be even with
- 34:46lifetime terms.
- 34:48The process to confirm them has gotten ever more political, especially in the last few
- 34:53decades.
- 34:55You probably saw it starting in the seventies and eighties where these battles over
- 35:02confirmation would become much more protracted, much more based on partisan and ideological
- 35:08feelings and and beliefs.
- 35:12For example, Brett Kavanaugh a few years ago when he was confirmed by the US senate or
- 35:19Merrick Garland who wasn't even heard or his nomination wasn't even heard by the US Senate
- 35:27at that point.
- 35:29And those are just two examples of this highly charged judicial nominating and confirming
- 35:36process confirmation process.
- 35:38There's also the fact that some of these nominees are proposed to the president by
- 35:42highly partisan and ideological interest groups.
- 35:46They're ones that donate heavily to the president's campaign or the campaign of like
- 35:52minded members of his party in Congress and also many judges consistently rule
- 35:58in favor of one party.
- 36:00Now, in fairness, part of that is that Republicans tend to have a lot more narrow of a
- 36:09view of constitutional law and Democrats tend
- 36:13to have a more expansive view of constitutional law.
- 36:18And then also liberals tend to be democrat, conservatives tend to be republican, especially
- 36:24when there are people who are involved in politics.
- 36:27So even if judges aren't explicitly thinking, oh, I'm gonna vote in the republican way, I'm
- 36:32gonna vote in the Democratic way.
- 36:33And, of course, they're never gonna say that they're voting or ruling in favor of a party.
- 36:37They, in fact, very much push back on that idea.
- 36:39Now whether you believe that, that's that's for you to decide, but they don't explicitly go,
- 36:46They're gonna vote or they're gonna rule in favor of Republican or Democratic policies.
- 36:51But their philosophy on how to interpret the constitution tends to align a lot with one
- 36:57party or another as these parties have become more uniform in their thinking over time.
- 37:04And that's why you see some judges called conservative judges or liberal judges or they
- 37:09are Trump judges or Obama judges or anything along those lines.
- 37:16And also some people would argue that liberty can be endangered by the judiciary.
- 37:23Although there was a lot of backlash to recent court rulings like the overturning of Roe
- 37:28versus Wade in the Dobbs versus Jackson Women's Health Organization ruling or the ruling that
- 37:35majority minority districts are unconstitutional in the Louisiana versus Calais
- 37:40case.
- 37:41So some people will hold those as examples of how actually the judiciary can threaten
- 37:49liberty.
- 37:49I'm not saying one way or another what I think, but that is an argument that a lot of people
- 37:55would make.
- 37:57And so even though the judiciary doesn't have a lot of or really any ways to enforce its laws,
- 38:05it has to rely on the executive and legislative branches, even with a lot of the gripes that
- 38:12the executive and legislative branches have on rulings that go against what they think, they
- 38:19usually just respect the rulings anyways.
- 38:22Not always, but a lot of times they do respect the rulings anyways.
- 38:27There's still that legitimacy that the US Supreme Court has even though a lot of people
- 38:33have become increasingly negative about the Supreme Court.
- 38:38And then lastly, Federalist Paper number 84, which was also written by Alexander Hamilton,
- 38:45and this argued that the way the US constitution was written up meant that a bill
- 38:49of rights was not necessary.
- 38:52That seems very odd that a founding father, especially somebody like Alexander Hamilton,
- 38:59would say such a thing.
- 39:01Why would he say that?
- 39:02Well, he felt that the Constitution already explicitly enumerated and protected the rights
- 39:08of the people and he was writing the preamble.
- 39:10He showcases that the preamble says, We, the people of The United States, in order to form a
- 39:15more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common
- 39:20defense, promote the general welfare and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our
- 39:24posterity, do ordain and establish this constitution for The United States Of America.
- 39:30Well, I guess it's right in there.
- 39:33Says, We the people of The United States secure the blessings of liberty.
- 39:36So really for him, the US constitution was the bill of rights.
- 39:43You didn't need to tack on something else.
- 39:46But not only did Hamilton oppose a bill of rights being added to the US constitution, he
- 39:51actually thought that making one would be dangerous.
- 39:55He said it would, quote, would contain various exceptions to powers which are not granted, end
- 40:01quote, and allow people to, quote, claim more than were granted, end quote.
- 40:08So he's basically saying that it's a slippery slope to saying, Oh, well, what powers do we
- 40:14also or what rights do we give here?
- 40:17And, well, if this right is included, then what does that say about the power that the
- 40:21government has in this setting?
- 40:23And also he argued that it would give politicians a plausible excuse to claim power
- 40:28to supposedly uphold rights and say, Oh, you see, I'm doing this to actually uphold the
- 40:33freedom of speech, for example.
- 40:36Now does Federalist Paper number 80 four's arguments hold up
- 40:40in today's political climate?
- 40:42Well, the lack
- 40:43of a need for a bill of rights is obviously a moot point because only two years later the
- 40:48bill of rights was ratified and added to the US constitution because James Madison, also
- 40:54originally opposed to the idea of a bill of rights, promised in order to gain anti federal
- 41:00support for the constitution that he would bring up the issue in Congress.
- 41:04He would introduce bills that would get the process going.
- 41:08For all of Alexander Hamilton's brilliance, even the smartest people get things wrong.
- 41:13We all get things wrong.
- 41:15And Hamilton was certainly wrong about the lack of a need for a bill of rights because if a
- 41:19right isn't specified, the government's probably going to infringe upon it at some
- 41:24point, especially if you do not have the same political view as the prevailing power in
- 41:30government.
- 41:32But one point that Hamilton made that is worth discussing is can specifically enumerating
- 41:39rights cause issues that give politicians, quote, plausible pretense for claiming that
- 41:45power, end quote, to supposedly uphold rights.
- 41:49Because you have a litany of Supreme Court cases that have dealt with how to interpret
- 41:54various bill of rights provisions, especially the freedom of speech.
- 41:57And both parties have often claimed that they're upholding the freedom of speech of
- 42:02press and so on when they're not respecting it for the other side, if they're not outright
- 42:09trying to restrict said freedoms, and if we really care about the freedom of speech in this
- 42:16country, we shouldn't be so close minded to so much that we don't believe it, but there are so
- 42:22many ways that politicians paint themselves as some sort of heroes because really they're
- 42:29championing the rights of whatever particular group they support, but yet they do not extend
- 42:37that same helping hand to groups that don't support that politician.
- 42:42It happens all the time.
- 42:44And there's also the fact of the tenth amendment to the US constitution, says that any
- 42:50rights not expressly given to The US constitution are given to the, or excuse me, in
- 42:56The US constitution, any provisions that are not in The US constitution expressly given to
- 43:03the federal government belong to the states.
- 43:05Well, what are those powers?
- 43:08That's been a debate for over two centuries now, what powers fall into the purview of the
- 43:15federal government, which ones fall into the purview of the state government, and we still
- 43:20have those today.
- 43:22So Hamilton obviously got the idea wrong about whether we needed a bill of rights.
- 43:29We certainly needed one even though he didn't think we did and he thought that it was
- 43:33actually the wrong move to add one,
- 43:36But he may have had
- 43:38a point about how when you do enumerate these rights, then you have to then say all these
- 43:45various exceptions to the rule with freedom of speech.
- 43:48You talk about shouting fire in a crowded theater or certain forms of speech during
- 43:55wartime.
- 43:57Burning The US flag can be considered protected speech.
- 44:02All sorts of exceptions that have had
- 44:04to have been made over time or clarifications made over time and there's going to have to
- 44:11be more that are made in the future.
- 44:14So looking back at those six Federalist papers, should we say that we have lost our way from
- 44:21Federalist paper philosophy?
- 44:24Because these papers still have many applicable lessons for us today, not just about how to
- 44:28structure a government, but how human nature operates in these environments.
- 44:33And many of these underlying lessons and basic concepts are still around today.
- 44:38But just like anything else that's ever been written, they have flaws in logic and things
- 44:42they couldn't predict.
- 44:44Government has had to change over time regardless of how we feel about those things,
- 44:50regardless of how we feel about interpreting the US constitution.
- 44:53Lots of things have changed over time and even originalists have changed.
- 44:58A lot of them have changed to some extent with the times.
- 45:02So I guess it depends on how you see it as straying away from its philosophy because a lot
- 45:08of those core concepts like separation of powers still exist.
- 45:13Are they sort of fraying at the strings?
- 45:16Some people would argue yes, but in any case, these Federalist papers still hold a lot of
- 45:22incredibly valuable lessons today and we should be careful that we don't run the risk of
- 45:30forgetting these core tenants regardless of our political views.
- 45:35And I think part of
- 45:36it is because of them being in such inaccessible prose because they are very much
- 45:43written like late eighteenth century old white men would write.
- 45:49So there needs to be some sort of way to make these concepts and what they're saying much
- 45:58more accessible to the general public and also showcase why these concepts are so important.
- 46:07You don't have to get super involved in politics to understand why the Federalist
- 46:11Papers are still so important today, and it doesn't mean that they didn't get some things
- 46:17wrong.
- 46:18There's certainly the judiciary can certainly be political, for example.
- 46:22We do need a bill of rights and all sorts of other things that I'm not even thinking of
- 46:28right now.
- 46:30If you peruse all these documents enough, you're going to find flaws or things that are
- 46:36outdated, but we should still look to these papers for a lot of guidance as to how to
- 46:46preserve this system of government that we have now and hopefully turn back this tide of
- 46:53partisan and ideological and affective polarization, get back to the basics of what
- 46:58government is supposed to be, at least discuss the meaning of all these things
- 47:04in a serious actual come together conversation.
- 47:11But that's going do it for today's episode of the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 47:14As always, thank you so much.
- 47:16Please like, comment, share, subscribe to the podcast.
- 47:20Episode 100 is coming out next week.
- 47:23Boy, what a milestone.
- 47:25Thank you all for being part of the journey.
- 47:27Links to the show notes, my works like my five day educational email course about how to more
- 47:32effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization in politics, my book on political independence,
- 47:40my writings on medium.com and then my media, the Facebook page, LinkedIn profile, website,
- 47:50paulraider.org, and one other thing I'm forgetting.
- 47:55You'll see it in the show notes.
- 47:56I'm blanking on what it is right now.
- 47:58Oh, my email.
- 47:59PaulRayderWritesgmail dot com.
- 48:02So once again,
- 48:03thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.