Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Business Valuation in Family Law
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the nuts and bolts of business valuation
- 0:06in family law. I'm Dan Bemel and along with April
- 0:09Zana, some co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:12Association's family law section. Our section
- 0:15is sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Morsovsky,
- 0:18Luna & Hunt. White, Zuckerman, Morsovsky, Luna
- 0:21& Hunt provides a wide variety of resources to
- 0:24complete almost any project, large or small.
- 0:27They also provide traditional accounting and
- 0:29tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:32them to discuss your specific accounting needs
- 0:35and learn how they can be of service to you.
- 0:38We have so many great programs coming up, so
- 0:40please mark your calendars and register now if
- 0:42you haven't already. October 3rd, when bankruptcy
- 0:45is filed during divorce. October 14th, a fireside
- 0:49chat with Judge Kaufman and new family law judges.
- 0:53October 23rd, Parenting Pallant Land Assessments,
- 0:56a LA County Practice Overview, also with Judge
- 0:59Kaufman. November 1st is our annual Family Law
- 1:02Symposium. This year is called Order in the Court,
- 1:05Tactics for Addressing Bad Faith and Incivility.
- 1:08November 5th, we'll have State of Department
- 1:10II, one of our annual in -person flagship events.
- 1:15And November 13th, Spotting and Managing SLAP
- 1:18Issues in Family Law. Other exciting programs
- 1:21are on the calendar and in the works, and you're
- 1:23all welcome at our section meetings on the third
- 1:25Wednesday of the month. We plan events, hear
- 1:28directly from Judge Kaufman and other bench officers,
- 1:31brainstorm on cases, and have lots and lots of
- 1:34fun. Okay, so now let's get to the program. I'm
- 1:37delighted to introduce today's speakers. Katie
- 1:41Pandolfini is an associate at Blank Rome, LLP,
- 1:44focusing on matrimonial and family law. With
- 1:47a unique background in law and finance, she specializes
- 1:50in representing high net worth clients in complex
- 1:53matters involving asset tracing, business valuation,
- 1:57high -end lifestyle issues, and more. Katie is
- 2:00a certified divorce financial analyst and has
- 2:03completed training in mediation and collaborative
- 2:05law. John Del Grego is a managing director in
- 2:09the Valuation and Litigation Support Services
- 2:11Group at CBiz Inc. Mr. Del Grego specializes
- 2:15in valuations of closely held businesses and
- 2:17business interests for matrimonial litigation.
- 2:20collaborative and non -adversarial divorce, and
- 2:23estate and gift tax matters. He also performs
- 2:26valuation services for business damages by sell
- 2:29agreement, shareholder litigation, buying and
- 2:33selling businesses, and employee stock ownership
- 2:36plans. Thank you both for putting this together
- 2:39and spending time with us today. Really excited
- 2:42to watch the program and I'll turn it over to
- 2:45you. Thanks, Dan. Okay, so if we can get the
- 2:50slides up on the screen. Okay, John, so what
- 2:59are we doing today? So today we are talking about
- 3:04one of my favorite topics of all time is valuation.
- 3:07The other is music, but we're going to talk about
- 3:10valuation here today. So let's go to the next
- 3:14slide. I think we have a preview. Those are pretty
- 3:23mugs. Okay, there we go. Okay, so I think the
- 3:30top four takeaways that we're going to do today
- 3:32is help our audience understand the various standards
- 3:35of value, learn the basic principles of business
- 3:39valuation and the different approaches. recognize
- 3:42various financial statement adjustments, and
- 3:44identify common problems in valuation reports.
- 3:48And along the way, hopefully, it's going to be
- 3:50fun and very exciting, as John promised. Oh,
- 3:53it'll be fun. All right, next slide. OK, so these
- 4:01are the three different parts. We're going to
- 4:03start off with what is value. All right, next
- 4:05slide. Keep going. Next slide. There we go. Here
- 4:11we go. All right. Let me jump in. So we're talking
- 4:14about business valuation. So let's understand
- 4:17the concept of value first and foremost. So value
- 4:22is two things. Value is made up of the perception,
- 4:27and it's written here, but it's important. This
- 4:29is everything you want to know about valuation
- 4:32right in this slide. It's the perception of future
- 4:35benefits and the risk of receiving those benefits.
- 4:38So in a business valuation, those future benefits
- 4:41are cash flow. Basically, it's money. So value
- 4:45is two things. I'm going to keep hitting this
- 4:48because this is everything we want to know about
- 4:49valuation. It's two things. It's future benefits.
- 4:52How much money am I going to get from this business?
- 4:55And what are the risks of me getting those benefits?
- 4:59So that's what we do in evaluation. Figure out
- 5:03the future cash flow. Figure out the risks of
- 5:07of getting those cash flows. So cash flow and
- 5:11risk. Now, some of the things we have to consider
- 5:13in evaluation is sort of highlighted in these
- 5:17three little bullet points on the bottom. Value
- 5:18to whom? Value for what purpose? And value when?
- 5:23Because believe it or not, value changes depending
- 5:26on who's buying something, right? everybody's
- 5:30perception of future benefits could be different.
- 5:33And because that perception of future benefits
- 5:35is different, value could be different. So in
- 5:38evaluation, we want to identify its value to
- 5:41whom so we know how we're going to value this
- 5:43thing. What is the purpose? So we can have the
- 5:46same business. If we're valuing it for a state
- 5:48and gift purposes, or valuing it for a divorce,
- 5:51or valuing it for a sale, those could be three
- 5:54separate and different values. So we want to
- 5:57make sure we dial in on the purpose, who the
- 6:01buyer is, what is the purpose, and when. Because
- 6:04when is also, like you think about your stock
- 6:06portfolio, your stock prices change on a daily
- 6:09basis. Your business value also changes. on not
- 6:13so much it's not as volatile, but it does change
- 6:15on a regular basis as well. And so we want to
- 6:18know the valuation date. When are we valuing
- 6:20it? Who's buying it? And what is the purpose
- 6:22of the valuation? So those are the critical pieces
- 6:25of any business valuation. All right. Next slide.
- 6:31All right. So what we do, we kind of work, we
- 6:35work in this world of hypothetics, right? So
- 6:37if we're valuing a business that's actually being
- 6:39sold, we're going to let the market come to us.
- 6:42give us a price, pay the price, and then we know
- 6:44what the value is worth. We don't know what the
- 6:47business is worth. We don't do that here. So
- 6:49as valuation people, we have a lot of assumptions
- 6:51that we have to live off of. And the two most
- 6:57critical are this premise of value and the standard
- 7:00of value. So the premise, we can go to the next
- 7:02slide. The premise of value is will the business
- 7:06be sold or will the business be liquidated? So
- 7:09what we hear all the time in divorce cases is
- 7:13we go to value of the business. The business
- 7:15owner says, you know what, my business is not
- 7:16worth anything because I'm just going to shut
- 7:19it down and no longer work. Therefore it has
- 7:22no value. Yes, you could do that. But the assumption
- 7:25or the premise that we work under as valuation
- 7:28experts in a divorce is that it is a going concern.
- 7:32It will continue on into the future. That is
- 7:34the first premise. We could also assume it might
- 7:37be liquidated. That's a different value. That's
- 7:40a different premise. In divorce cases, it's typically
- 7:44this going concern premise that the business
- 7:47will continue on whether or not you decide you
- 7:50want to shut it down. I mean, that's your decision
- 7:52as part of the divorce, but the value of the
- 7:55business is under the assumption that it will
- 7:56be so. When are you going to use a liquidation
- 7:59value in a divorce case? We may use a liquidation
- 8:03value in situations when the the profits of the
- 8:08company or the cash flow of the company doesn't
- 8:12create value. In other words, the thing is worth
- 8:15more dead than alive. And that actually, some
- 8:18businesses are really just there to pay the owner
- 8:21a salary. And therefore, it doesn't have any
- 8:24really transactional value. It has enough to
- 8:27pay compensation. So therefore, it's only worth
- 8:29the value of its assets. So we may consider a
- 8:33liquidation value when the cash flow is not significant
- 8:36enough to use a going concern. But we go into
- 8:39a business saying, look, this business is going
- 8:42to continue on. OK. Let's go to the next slide.
- 8:48If Katie and I knew how to use technology, we'd
- 8:50be forwarding these ourselves. But we don't know
- 8:53what we're doing. We're just vamping here. So
- 8:56here is where we get really crazy. This standard
- 9:01of value is the hypothetical conditions that
- 9:05we operate under to value a business. So there
- 9:09are a lot of these different standards of value.
- 9:11We're going to get into it a little bit, but
- 9:12there's fair market value, fair value, investment
- 9:14value. All of these different standards of value
- 9:17tell us how we should value the business, what
- 9:20hypothetical assumptions we use to value the
- 9:23business. And each of these could come up again
- 9:26with a different value. Every state has a different
- 9:30standard of value. So let's go to the next slide.
- 9:33The most common standard of value is fair market
- 9:38value and all the other valuations, all the other
- 9:40values, all the other standards of value are
- 9:44kind of built off fair market value. So fair
- 9:47market value, here's the hypothetical assumption
- 9:52that we live off of. Under fair market value,
- 9:56we assume that there is a sale of the business
- 9:59between hypothetical willing buyers and hypothetical
- 10:02willing sellers, neither under a compulsion to
- 10:05do the transaction. Nobody's forcing anybody
- 10:07to sell. It's two hypothetical people going to
- 10:11the market, one to buy, one to sell. That's the
- 10:14assumption in fair market value. So, and hypothetical
- 10:18is important because If I, let me give you an
- 10:21example. So I do a lot of work in the music industry,
- 10:24music stores. So, and I'm a musician part -time.
- 10:28So I like music stores. I like guitars. I like
- 10:31drums. I may see a music store and say, I'm willing
- 10:35to pay a lot of money for this music store because
- 10:39I've always dreamed of owning a music store and
- 10:41I love all the inventory. So that's me as John
- 10:45Del Grego looking to pay a premium to buy a cool
- 10:49music store. I may have, that music store may
- 10:53have a competitor in the marketplace, guitar
- 10:56center by example, who says, you know what, you're
- 10:58a pain in the neck to me, I wanna buy you out
- 11:01of the market, and I'm gonna pay a lot of money
- 11:03to do so. So, different motivations create value.
- 11:09We as valuation people can't decide who those,
- 11:13We can't identify all those possible buyers of
- 11:17a business. There could be hundreds of them with
- 11:19hundreds of different values. We rely on this
- 11:22hypothetical willing buyer, willing seller, which
- 11:25essentially says, you got a business. It's going
- 11:28to operate essentially the way it's operating
- 11:30now, generating the similar amount of cash flow.
- 11:33What would an investor pay for it? That's fair
- 11:35market value. That's where most of Our valuation
- 11:40work hovers if we go to the next slide, we'll
- 11:43see some. We'll see you're just looking for,
- 11:46you know, a rational person, not the person who's
- 11:49going to pay a premium who is, you know, it's
- 11:52fact specific. That's exactly right. It's not
- 11:56fact -specific because everybody has their own
- 11:58motivation to buy. We don't identify those because
- 12:02we can't. It's exactly like you said. It's actually
- 12:05an investment buy. If an investor came in and
- 12:08said, I want this company, how much cash flow?
- 12:11What's my future benefit? How much cash flow
- 12:13is this company? as it's operating, going to
- 12:16put in my pocket. That's how we look at it. And
- 12:18these are some of the concepts I just sort of
- 12:21went through, the hypothetical willing buyer,
- 12:23willing seller, so forth. It's also a cash price.
- 12:26So we know from experience in buying and selling
- 12:29businesses in my world that it's not always a
- 12:32cash price in a transaction. Sometimes there's
- 12:35an earn out, right? So the value is, here's $1
- 12:38,000 and I'll pay you 25 % of revenues going
- 12:40forward. Again, that's kind of speculation. We
- 12:44have to zero this in on what is the cash price
- 12:48for this business. So that's kind of important
- 12:50as well. Let's go to the next slide. So here
- 12:54are some other standards of value, fair investment
- 12:57value to the holder. Let's talk about California
- 13:00because that's where we are, right? So California
- 13:03is a little bit tricky. California is almost
- 13:04all of these. So California is a fair value state,
- 13:09but they also use investment value. They also
- 13:11use marital value. I think they also use value
- 13:15to the holder. All meaning the same thing, essentially,
- 13:19though. And this is where it gets tricky because
- 13:21fair value in some states doesn't mean the same
- 13:23thing as it does in other states. But what fair
- 13:26value means is we're not considering discounts.
- 13:31We'll talk about discounts in a little bit. Discounts
- 13:34are tricky, but When I value a company in this
- 13:36hypothetical world, I know what we're assuming
- 13:41under fair market value is we're taking that
- 13:43interest, we're taking it to the marketplace,
- 13:46and the marketplace is going to look at it and
- 13:49say, well, I'm not going to pay you full value
- 13:51for this because you don't have control of the
- 13:54operations. If I want to sell it in a year, it's
- 13:57going to take me a long time to do it because
- 13:58it's a private company. And we see that in the
- 14:01marketplace. privately held companies and privately
- 14:04held interests are discounted, and sometimes
- 14:06they're discounted pretty heavily. We can use
- 14:09those discounts in fair market value. In fair
- 14:12value, we typically don't consider discounts.
- 14:15We basically just say, hey, this business is
- 14:18kicking out this amount of cash flow. What is
- 14:20that cash flow worth? So no discounts typically
- 14:24in fair value in California, although I think
- 14:28there's also times when fair market value is
- 14:31used. So California is a confusing state. They
- 14:34have a lot of a lot of synonymous terms, but
- 14:38traditionally it's a fair value investment, marital
- 14:41value, all meaning what's the cash flow to this
- 14:44individual business owner and what's it worth.
- 14:49So those are the standards. The standards of
- 14:51value are complicated, but it's really the hypothetical.
- 14:55It's the hypothetical. Assumptions that we we
- 14:59live on that says here's how we're going to value
- 15:02this. Some critical things here in a divorce
- 15:05situation. The valuation date. So I think I mentioned
- 15:09earlier value as of when is very important, right?
- 15:12So value changes on a not so much on a daily
- 15:15basis for a privately held company, but value
- 15:18does change on a regular basis so. In California,
- 15:23it's data trial. In a lot of states, it's data
- 15:25trial. New York is data separation. So we value
- 15:30a business based on the jurisdictional requirements.
- 15:35So we value it as here in California and Connecticut,
- 15:39where I'm sitting right now, it's data trial.
- 15:41And so we try to get a value as close to that
- 15:44date as possible. But it could also be an agreed
- 15:48upon date. But it gets tricky in valuation with
- 15:53a valuation date, especially if you have a agreed
- 15:58-upon valuation date. Let's say we've agreed
- 16:02that July 31, 2025 is our valuation date. That
- 16:07makes things easy for me because I know the valuation
- 16:09date. It's not a moving target for the date of
- 16:12trial, which may not have even been scheduled
- 16:13yet. Or it could be postponed. I got to continue
- 16:16to update valuations. We have an agreed upon
- 16:19date. July 31st. We're sitting here on October
- 16:221st. I can only rely on what's known or noble
- 16:25as of the valuation date in my valuation date.
- 16:28So in my valuation. So if there is a value, if
- 16:32I value this as of July 31st and something happened
- 16:35that materially affects the business in September.
- 16:39I have to go back to July for 31st and figure
- 16:42out. if that information was known or knowable,
- 16:45if it was known or knowable back in July, I could
- 16:49incorporate it into my valuation. If it's not
- 16:52known or knowable, I have to ignore it, even
- 16:55though it happened. So that agreed upon date
- 16:58in that set valuation date is sometimes easier,
- 17:01sometimes it's harder, and sometimes it brings
- 17:04in a lot of issues. But the valuation date is
- 17:07very important, and we can only consider what's
- 17:09known and knowable as of that date. So for valuations
- 17:14as of the date of trial, I mean, how often do
- 17:16you actually have statements up to the date of
- 17:19trial to actually perform your valuation? We
- 17:22know this takes a long time. Yeah. Great question.
- 17:25Never. I should say never. But what typically
- 17:30happens is there's a lag. There's a few months
- 17:34lag between the valuation and the trial. So if
- 17:39we're all working on the same page, There's always,
- 17:43not always, there's usually two experts in every
- 17:45engagement. Hopefully what we get to do is say,
- 17:48look, we got trial. It's coming in a certain
- 17:50date. Let's at least let the experts have. information
- 17:54through the same date, right? Because you want
- 17:56to compare apples and apples. So you got to pick
- 17:58a valuation date that's as close to trial as
- 18:01possible. Then from the time of your valuation
- 18:04to the data trial, the best we can do is see
- 18:07if anything has happened that would materially
- 18:10change our valuation, in which case we may have
- 18:12to update it the night of. But if nothing material
- 18:16has changed during that time period, we can usually
- 18:20testify that this is the value as of privately
- 18:24held companies aren't as volatile as publicly
- 18:26traded stocks. So if we're a few months out in
- 18:29our valuation date to trial, chances are that
- 18:32is a pretty good valuation. But yeah, it can
- 18:36get tricky. As you get postponements and deferrals,
- 18:40the further it gets out from the valuation date,
- 18:43the less reliable it becomes. And it gets expensive
- 18:46updating. So you kind of want to narrow that
- 18:49gap between valuation date and trial date. All
- 18:53right, let's move on. Next slide. Thanks. OK.
- 19:00So this is just an important concept. I'll tell
- 19:02you in a second why I put it here. Value is determined.
- 19:05That's what I do. I figure out the value of a
- 19:08company. Price is negotiated. And so price and
- 19:12value may be the same, but not necessarily. And
- 19:16this is an important concept. When I value a
- 19:20company, the case settles. And a year later,
- 19:23it sells for three times what I said it was worth.
- 19:25And then they come back and say, Del Greco, you
- 19:28screwed up. You were wrong. And I say, I'm never
- 19:30wrong. So price is negotiated. What typically
- 19:36happens in those types of situations is a buyer
- 19:42came in, a strategic buyer came in and paid a
- 19:45premium. We need to reconcile that. We will look
- 19:48at it and reconcile it, but we value it based
- 19:50on these hypothetical situations, which is mandated
- 19:53by fair market value standards, and then an investment
- 19:58buyer comes in or strategic buyer comes in and
- 20:00pays whatever the heck they want it to pay. So
- 20:03the price and the value don't always line up,
- 20:05and in most cases, they don't. So this is not
- 20:09This is not unusual for things like that to happen.
- 20:12But it's understand, and even when I'm valuing
- 20:15companies for the purpose of management planning,
- 20:17I'll tell the person I'm working with, like,
- 20:21Here's what this cash flow is worth to you. This
- 20:24is not what I'm telling you to sell the business
- 20:26for. This is what it's worth in your hands. But
- 20:29to sell a business, go out and get a premium
- 20:32for it and find the right buyer who's going to
- 20:34pay that premium. That's two different things.
- 20:37Value is value. Value is calculated. Price is
- 20:40negotiated. When are price and value the same?
- 20:44Well, They could be the same if we're using prices
- 20:49value, which happens, right? So sometimes we
- 20:51might go into a divorce where there's a letter
- 20:55of intent to sell the business, right? We work
- 20:58in this world of hypothetics based on the fact
- 21:00that we're not actually selling the business,
- 21:02but we want to know what it's worth. So we come
- 21:05up with a price. But if they've already in the
- 21:07negotiation of saying, we're selling the business,
- 21:10you know, we've got a letter of intent and we're
- 21:11negotiating. So price and value for purposes
- 21:14of the divorce could be the same if that's where
- 21:16they are in that particular stage. or if you're
- 21:20selling it to non -strategic buyers, right? So
- 21:23if I did a valuation and they used it for purposes
- 21:26of negotiating a settlement and they turned around,
- 21:29you know, I'm just going to sell it to my employees
- 21:30or sell it to somebody and there's no strategic
- 21:33anything, no strategy with that, value and price
- 21:37could be the same. Okay. All right. Next slide.
- 21:45All right. What is the business valuation? What
- 21:47do I do? For the next one. So when we look at
- 21:55a business valuation, we actually look at four
- 21:57things. I missed one here, but it's financial,
- 21:59operational, economics, and industry. Those are
- 22:03kind of the four things we look at. The financial
- 22:05side, why are we analyzing financial statements?
- 22:07Because we want to understand, we want to understand
- 22:10the cash flow, right? So value is cash flow and
- 22:14risk. I'm going to keep coming back to that concept.
- 22:17So the financials tell us what the cash flow
- 22:18of the business is. How do we measure risk? Economic.
- 22:23We look at the economy. How does the economy
- 22:24going to affect the business and the cash flow?
- 22:26We look at the industry. How does the industry
- 22:28affect the cash flow to the business? If we forget
- 22:33the industry, if we forget the economy and just
- 22:35focus on the cash flow, we've missed the risk,
- 22:39right? So, you know, I'll give you an example.
- 22:41We're valuing We're valuing a compact disc manufacturer
- 22:47in 1995 Banging out Spice Girls CDs, right? So
- 22:51they are making oodles of money banging out these
- 22:55compact discs music, right? So we if all we looked
- 22:58at is the financials and said, okay I'm gonna
- 23:02pay a lot of money for this manufacturing company
- 23:04because look how much money it's making if I
- 23:06forget the industry piece of that which says
- 23:09in 2000, you know Digital music is going to replace
- 23:14compact discs. I mean, I've completely overvalued
- 23:18the business. I've got to understand the risk.
- 23:21I've got to research the risk. So you could have
- 23:24profits that may not continue to the future.
- 23:28So it's cash flow and risk. So those are the
- 23:31things we really need to hone in on when we're
- 23:33doing evaluation. OK, next slide. All right,
- 23:39so here are the basic steps. This is like out
- 23:41of a textbook, but figure out what the engagement
- 23:43is. And I got to meet with the attorneys. What
- 23:45am I doing here for you? Am I doing an evaluation?
- 23:48Look, is it fair value? Is it fair market value?
- 23:51You know, I do a lot of work. I'm on the East
- 23:53Coast right now. I do a lot of work in Massachusetts,
- 23:55also a fair value state, but I'm quite often
- 24:01asked to do fair market value because it's not
- 24:05statutory. It's case driven. It's equitable distribution.
- 24:13So what makes the most sense in the engagement?
- 24:15So what am I doing? What standard of value am
- 24:17I applying? I'm gathering the data, analyzing
- 24:20it, getting my conclusion, writing a report maybe,
- 24:23or a disclosure. But those are the basic steps.
- 24:27So let's go to the next. We'll talk about the
- 24:29data that we rely upon. Before we get there.
- 24:32Yeah. Bird. Let's say that you are asked to do,
- 24:37you know, evaluation. When do you for the attorneys
- 24:41in the audience? When do you think that it's
- 24:44you're better off having a neutral? You're better
- 24:46off having your own expert. What's sort of your
- 24:48rules of thumb on that? It depends on the attorneys,
- 24:53so I do a lot of work as a neutral. And I explain
- 24:59the both sides that look. Whether I'm a neutral
- 25:02worker on one side or the other, I make a living
- 25:04being an independent valuation expert. It doesn't
- 25:08matter who hires me, right? So I'm getting hired
- 25:10for my independent opinion. So it doesn't matter
- 25:15what side I'm working for. As a neutral, I think
- 25:20I have a better chance of getting all the information
- 25:23I need, as opposed to working on one side or
- 25:26the other, where sometimes the information is
- 25:29limited. going through channels to get everything
- 25:35you need, having two experts, competing experts,
- 25:38and we can talk about why there's differentials,
- 25:41but when you have two experts, they're never
- 25:43gonna come up with the same answer. It doesn't
- 25:45mean one's right or one's wrong. It means they've
- 25:48had, if they're both qualified, it means that
- 25:50they're getting different information and interpreting
- 25:53it differently because they're only hearing maybe
- 25:56one side of the story. As a neutral, if you can
- 25:59get access to both sides, and get all the documents
- 26:02and do all the work you need to do, I think it's
- 26:04more efficient. But you've got to have the right
- 26:07set of attorneys that will agree to that because,
- 26:10you know, I do a lot of work in New York where
- 26:12the courts hire the neutral and both sides always
- 26:14hire their own. And there's always three experts
- 26:17in every case because nobody trusts anybody.
- 26:20So you've got to trust your expert and you've
- 26:22got to have the right set of attorneys. It's
- 26:23more efficient, but everybody's got to be on
- 26:25the same page with it. All right, let's keep
- 26:28going. All right, so let's go back one. Thanks.
- 26:35So when I started evaluation engagement, I sent
- 26:38out a two or three page request for what I need.
- 26:42I've been doing this for so long. You never use
- 26:45the word need because you guys will cross examine
- 26:46and say you needed that, you didn't get it, so
- 26:48therefore your opinion is not valid. You wanted
- 26:51it. I sent out a list of things that I want in
- 26:55evaluation. And it's 25, 30, 40 things. Of those,
- 27:01there's six things here that I will want to see
- 27:04in every valuation. And they're basic stuff.
- 27:07And I've got to tell you, I still get pushback
- 27:09on some of the basic stuff. And it costs a lot
- 27:11of time and money. And I will get these documents
- 27:14eventually. So because, anyway. The six things
- 27:19we're looking at are financial statements, tax
- 27:21returns, general ledgers, forecast employees.
- 27:23It's all right here. But why? So when we're doing
- 27:26evaluation, cash flow and risk. So I want to
- 27:30see the historical operations of the company
- 27:32to figure out what kind of profits and cash flow
- 27:35this thing is generating so I can figure out
- 27:37future cash flows. That's coming from the financial
- 27:39statements. It's coming from the tax returns.
- 27:41And the general ledgers are actually giving me
- 27:45a deep dive into the numbers on the financial
- 27:47statements and tax returns. So these are just
- 27:49the basic documents that I'm looking for. Forecasts
- 27:52are exactly that. If the company is preparing
- 27:56budgets and forecasting, they're predicting what
- 27:58their future cash flow is. I absolutely want
- 28:00to see that, so I don't have to spend as much
- 28:02time on it. I want to know what they think their
- 28:05cash flow is. Employee W -2s are important for
- 28:08a number of reasons, one of which is I want to
- 28:10see if there's anybody on the payroll that shouldn't
- 28:12be on the payroll. That's not working there.
- 28:14Family members, boyfriends, girlfriends, whatever
- 28:16it may be. I also want to know their pay structure,
- 28:20because we're going to talk about it a bit when
- 28:22we get to adjustments. When it gets to the point
- 28:27where I want to understand what the owner should
- 28:30be earning, I've got to see what everybody else
- 28:32is being paid in the organization, see what their
- 28:35pay structure is. I always get a lot of pushback
- 28:37on employee W -2s because they're not part of
- 28:40this litigation, they're not part of this whole
- 28:43thing, and we're not going to send them to you.
- 28:44But I don't care about names and social security
- 28:46numbers, but I want to see how top -level management
- 28:49people are being paid. And then we've got the
- 28:52bank statements and credit cards, which again,
- 28:54that's a forensic side of it. And there's forensics
- 28:57in most valuations. When I get a tax return,
- 29:02what's the motivation of a tax return? To not
- 29:04pay taxes, right? So very few tax returns are
- 29:08showing true profitability. Not that anybody's
- 29:10hiding things or doing anything that they're
- 29:12not supposed to be doing, but the tax laws allow
- 29:16you to take a lot of deductions that normally
- 29:18you wouldn't need or take. if you're just looking
- 29:21at true and optimal cash flow for evaluation
- 29:24purposes. But we also know that privately held
- 29:28companies, some owners use their privately held
- 29:30companies as a checkbook, as their own personal
- 29:33checkbook. So there is an element of forensics
- 29:35where we use the general ledgers, the bank statements,
- 29:37the credit card statements to kind of vet out
- 29:40things that are not necessary to the business
- 29:43operations. And so these are some critical documents
- 29:47that we rely upon. really should get on a regular
- 29:51basis. And your expert, when you're hired then,
- 29:53should get on a regular basis. And how far back
- 29:56do you usually request these records? So five
- 29:59years is the sort of rule of thumb that every
- 30:02valuation analyst will ask for. And is it written
- 30:07in stone? It's not written in stone. Sometimes
- 30:09we get two years, three years. But the reason
- 30:11we go, we want to go back as far as possible.
- 30:14And the reason is we're looking for two things.
- 30:16We're looking for trends over time. Like if a
- 30:19company is growing in the last two years, well,
- 30:25is that an anomaly or has that been growing for
- 30:27the last three or four or five years? So the
- 30:29further back we can go, the more we can look
- 30:34back, the better we can understand what's happening
- 30:36with the company. But five years seems to give
- 30:38us a long enough economic cycle where we can
- 30:41see the highs and the lows. That's really what
- 30:43we're trying to see. And if we have five years
- 30:45and everything is straight line, That gives us
- 30:47comfort that the company is kind of stabilized.
- 30:49If we see a lot of volatility, maybe we go back
- 30:52further. Don't know. But five years is sort of
- 30:55the norm, especially with one of those years
- 30:58right now being like 2020, 2021. So with COVID,
- 31:02which changed a lot of things for businesses,
- 31:04sometimes we go back even further. I might want
- 31:06to see 18, 19, throw out 2021. Look at 22, 23,
- 31:1124. But no rule of thumb. But you'll typically
- 31:14see five years for all of this stuff. All right,
- 31:19next slide. Just some additional stuff. I mean,
- 31:23the important thing here, you know, it's part
- 31:26of the valuation process. I said operational,
- 31:28we consider operations. We want to have a site
- 31:31visit and a management interview. Not always
- 31:33a site visit, you know, service business. I don't
- 31:35care. You're working out of your house. I don't
- 31:37need to come there. But we want to have a management
- 31:40interview and we're going to request it. Sometimes
- 31:44it's denied. It shouldn't be denied. Let your,
- 31:49if you've got the business owner, let your client
- 31:50talk to the evaluation expert. I mean, again,
- 31:53we're trying to get data. We're trying to learn
- 31:55as much as possible about a business. If all
- 31:57we are hearing is information from the outspouse,
- 32:01the non -working spouse, that information is
- 32:03going to be tainted. It's going to be tainted
- 32:04because maybe they don't have intimate knowledge
- 32:06of the operations. Or they're telling you one
- 32:10side of the story. I want to hear all sides of
- 32:13the story. I want to get to the right place.
- 32:15And the only way to do that is to talk to the
- 32:18people who actually run the business. I start
- 32:20with the business owner, but I may ask to talk
- 32:23to other people who are knowledgeable about the
- 32:26operations. I want to know what makes a tick.
- 32:28Again, how do they create revenue? And again,
- 32:34what are the risks? of continuing to generate
- 32:38that revenue. It's cash flow and risk. I'll continue
- 32:41to say it, but those are the two components of
- 32:43valuation. That's what we do. And what do you
- 32:46care about other employees' salaries if you only
- 32:49have a single business owner? I see that's on
- 32:52here. So if you've got a single business owner
- 32:56but employees, we'll talk about adjustments in
- 32:59a second, but business owners can take out whatever
- 33:04they want out of their business. So if they take
- 33:06all their profits out of the business and call
- 33:08it salary, then there's no cash left over. And
- 33:12in theory, there's no value. That's not necessarily
- 33:15true. What we do is we look at the business,
- 33:19we look at the business owner, we figure out
- 33:21the roles of the business owner, and then we
- 33:24say, okay, based on what this individual does,
- 33:27he should be paid X. Now, what's that X? How
- 33:30do we figure out that X? Well, We go to compensation
- 33:33experts, we go to benchmarking databases, or
- 33:41we look at people within the organization. So
- 33:43if I know that the president of the company is
- 33:45making a certain dollar amount and this owner
- 33:49is acting as the CEO, I'm going to assume, well,
- 33:52he's got to be making at least more than his
- 33:54president because he's doing more than his president.
- 33:56So I can use those individuals as a benchmark
- 33:59to figure out what the owner should be making.
- 34:04All right, next slide. All right, data. This
- 34:11is where we get, this is where we spend a lot
- 34:14of time. So when I asked for financial statements
- 34:16and tax returns, if all I get are tax returns,
- 34:19and I said this earlier, tax returns have a specific
- 34:22motivation of not paying taxes. So what I'm looking
- 34:25for as a valuation person is how much can an
- 34:28investor, me as an investor, I put myself in
- 34:31investor's shoes. How much can I expect to get
- 34:34out of this business? What kind of cash flow
- 34:37is it generating on kind of this optimal basis,
- 34:40right? If I stripped out all the nonsense, if
- 34:42all I have is the tax return, I've got to do
- 34:45some work to get to the true cash flows of the
- 34:47business. But there's also financial statements
- 34:50that I get. Are those more reliable? Maybe. You
- 34:54have this issue of cash. basis tax returns versus
- 34:57accrual basis. I won't get into the accounting
- 34:58nonsense, but there's different accounting for
- 35:01different types of financial documents. So typically
- 35:05we see on the financial statement side, a financial
- 35:08statement is something that shows your total
- 35:11revenue and your expenses to get to your profit.
- 35:13That's a typical financial statement. There's
- 35:15really four kinds. There's the kind that are
- 35:17produced internally, which we've got to spend
- 35:20a whole bunch of time on to figure out if they're
- 35:22accurate. Then there's the kind we get from the
- 35:24company's accountants, and they're either compiled,
- 35:27reviewed, or audited. And compiled is nothing
- 35:30more than taking the internals, doing no work
- 35:33to them, and just sorting them, and putting in
- 35:36a pretty little format, and handing them back,
- 35:38right? So you see a compiled financial statement
- 35:41from an accountant. You don't put a lot of...
- 35:45credibility into it. There hasn't been a whole
- 35:48lot of oversight to it. Reviewed and audited,
- 35:51the accountants actually come in and they do
- 35:53some analytical work to say, are the numbers
- 35:57that the company has given me, are they accurate?
- 36:01And the audit is the highest level. You get an
- 36:03audited financial statement. these auditors have
- 36:05spent a lot of time vetting these numbers to
- 36:08make sure they're right. So less forensics is
- 36:11necessary typically, and I say typically, on
- 36:14audited financial statements than in -house,
- 36:17you know, internally prepared. So it's the level
- 36:20of work based on the type of financial information
- 36:23that we're relying upon. Okay, so compiled, we
- 36:27should be a little bit wary, but audited a little
- 36:29bit less. Correct. Yeah, compiled is nothing
- 36:31more than they took the internal financial statements
- 36:35and pretty them up basically. Okay. Next slide.
- 36:41All right. Here is where all of the fun begins.
- 36:48So we have all these financial statements, tax
- 36:50returns, and we lay them all out over five years
- 36:53or three years or however long we have them.
- 36:55And now we've got to figure out, is the cash
- 36:57flow I'm looking at the real cash flow of the
- 37:00business? And there's three categories that we
- 37:04look for when we're doing this analysis. The
- 37:07first is, are there any expenses or even income
- 37:10items, are there any items in this financial
- 37:13statements that I'm looking for that will not
- 37:16recur? Are there one -time expenses? Is there
- 37:24a one -time income influx? The reason I want
- 37:27to know that is because during the valuation
- 37:30process, I'm using these historical financial
- 37:33statements and historical results as a proxy.
- 37:36for that future cash flow benefit we were talking
- 37:40about. So it's future income and risk. That future
- 37:42income is based, in some instances, off historical
- 37:46performances. So I want to make sure that historical
- 37:49results are properly stated, meaning I'm cleaning
- 37:54up those results for things that I don't expect
- 37:57will recur into the future. I want a clean set
- 38:00of historical adjusted financial statements.
- 38:02So the first is these non -recurring items. The
- 38:05second, I'm looking for assets and liabilities
- 38:08that are not business related. When I value a
- 38:11business, the value is the value of all the company's
- 38:14assets and liabilities, unless they're not contributing
- 38:18to the revenues of the company. Like I've got
- 38:22an airplane, a luxury. vehicle or boat. I've
- 38:25got some investment land. I've got some things
- 38:28that aren't necessarily part of business operations.
- 38:32They're just dumped into the company. I want
- 38:34to identify those, strip those out, value them
- 38:37separately. And then the last one's the most
- 38:39fun, discretionary expenses. We call them discretionary
- 38:44because we don't want anybody to think that there's
- 38:47tax fraud or anything, they're discretionary.
- 38:50They're expenses that a hypothetical investor
- 38:53or buyer may not have to incur to still generate
- 38:57the same level of revenues and profits. So discretionary.
- 39:02These are your perks? Perks, or beyond perks.
- 39:08So I think I'll lay out a couple of them if we
- 39:10go to the next slide. All right, let's go to
- 39:12the next slide. So these are the non -recurring,
- 39:14just some examples, right? So if you had some
- 39:16major improvements in a year, that's going to
- 39:19reduce cash flow. But let's clean that crap out.
- 39:22So these are just some examples of non -recurring.
- 39:25We can go to the next slide, which is probably
- 39:27some non -operating. There's your autos and whatnot.
- 39:30So go to the next one. Thanks. So discretionary.
- 39:36So these are the ones that you have the most
- 39:38fun in cross -examination. And these are the
- 39:40ones where When we talk about two experts valuing
- 39:44a company, it's like, wow, you're so far apart.
- 39:48How is that possible? And there's a bunch of
- 39:51reasons for that. But one of the reasons you're
- 39:54so far apart is owner's compensation. So when
- 39:57I own a business, I can pay myself whatever the
- 39:59heck I want. And if I can pay myself whatever
- 40:02the heck I want, then I may show very little
- 40:05profitability and very little value. So value
- 40:08is based on cash flow. If I have very few profits,
- 40:11very little profits in the business, then it's
- 40:14not really worth anything. What we do is we come
- 40:19in, and I think I mentioned this earlier, we
- 40:21look at the owner's comp, we look at their roles,
- 40:24we see how much control they have and how they
- 40:26pay themselves, and then we make an adjustment.
- 40:29You know, if this person's making a million dollars
- 40:31a year, but the market says they should only
- 40:33be making $200 ,000 a year, We adjust their compensation
- 40:37to $200 ,000 a year. That gives us another $800
- 40:41,000 a year to put to the bottom line. That creates
- 40:44value. So the higher the officer comp that's
- 40:49adjusted in evaluation, the lower the cash flow,
- 40:52the lower the value. When two experts come in
- 40:56to a valuation, One expert may think this person
- 41:00is so important that they have to make $800 ,000
- 41:02a year, or the other expert says, you know what,
- 41:04they're not important at all. They only have
- 41:05to make $200 ,000 a year. That's a subjective
- 41:07adjustment that has a tremendous impact on value.
- 41:13So owner's comp is one of the biggest adjustments
- 41:15you're going to see us make. you know these other
- 41:24areas where people always that run businesses
- 41:27take some liberties right it's travel it's entertainment
- 41:30it's it's gas for the car insurance you know
- 41:33all the perks right but then they got to measure
- 41:35are those with those perks still be available
- 41:39to a high level executive in a business right
- 41:42we got to be careful not all country club dues
- 41:44and in auto leases or automatic ad backs Unless
- 41:49you've captured in the in the total office or
- 41:52compensation, but there's a lot of non owner
- 41:54executives that have those perks. So you've got
- 41:58to figure out. You've got to figure out in the
- 42:01context of the company you're valuing if those
- 42:04perks makes sense for the business for the owner
- 42:08of the company to pay to a not to a business
- 42:11to an executive, right? So so we've got to take
- 42:14a hard look at at. all of these things, but the
- 42:17forensic side of it is digging through the general
- 42:19ledgers, the bank statements and credit cards
- 42:21to find the travel, to find all these other expenses.
- 42:26And that's where we see the biggest discrepancies.
- 42:28You know, if I've got the business owner and
- 42:30I'm seeing a lot of travel and entertainment
- 42:32and I have a conversation to tell me how important
- 42:34it is that they do this and entertain your clients
- 42:36and go on these extravagant vacations and all
- 42:39this other kind of stuff, I leave it in. I don't
- 42:41make an adjustment for it, whereas Whereas the
- 42:44other side here is, you know, I don't believe
- 42:46you need all that I'm hearing from the outspouse
- 42:49not owner spouse that you know He or she tags
- 42:51along and it has nothing to do with business
- 42:54and there's just conflicting information that
- 42:57brings you to conflicting valuation results,
- 42:59but Rents another one. It's not it's very common
- 43:03that when you own a business you own You own
- 43:07the business. I'm sorry. You own the facility
- 43:10for which you operate from in a separate entity
- 43:12And that allows me as the business owner to pay
- 43:15above market rent or below market rent. But if
- 43:19I were to buy that business as an investor, I'm
- 43:22going to pay market rent. So we'll make an adjustment
- 43:24to market rent, which means if there's a piece
- 43:29of real estate owned either by the business or
- 43:32by the business owners, it has to be It has to
- 43:36be appraised because we as valuation experts
- 43:39want that fair market rent number. We want to
- 43:41know what number to dump in there in our valuation.
- 43:46So it seems like there's a lot of subjectivity
- 43:48as to these adjustments, and that's where the
- 43:50two experts can really differ. Yeah, I mean,
- 43:53so this is where you spend most of your time
- 43:55on cross examination. It's you know, what are
- 43:58the assumptions that went into these? that went
- 44:02into these adjustments, right? So whenever you're
- 44:05cross -examining an expert, you want to key in
- 44:08on those assumptions. And better, you know, the
- 44:11technique in a cross is not so much saying, hey,
- 44:15Del Greco, you're wrong, because you don't know
- 44:18if I'm right or wrong, because this is my lane
- 44:20you're in. But it's more like, had you... use
- 44:26this instead of that, what effect does it have
- 44:29on the result, right? So put it in the judge's
- 44:31mind that you could have gone in either direction.
- 44:34You went in this direction and it had this result.
- 44:37That's kind of how you want to approach the expert
- 44:39because yes, these are subjective. And if an
- 44:42expert says, you know, it's this and only this,
- 44:47you know, that's problematic. It's never black
- 44:50and white. It's In my opinion, based on what
- 44:52I've learned from my conversations with, this
- 44:55is what I believe this number should be. But
- 44:58this is where it gets, yeah, it's subjective
- 45:01and it's tricky. Next. All right. Next slide.
- 45:08All right. How do we do all this? So next slide.
- 45:12So here we go. So we've done all this work so
- 45:15far, right? So we know conceptually, we know
- 45:18our standard of value. We know we've looked at
- 45:21the financial statements. We're trying to predict
- 45:23future cash flow. We've made all our adjustments.
- 45:25Now we've got this clean set of whatever. We've
- 45:28got the profits of the business. We've got the
- 45:30earnings of the business owner. Now we're here.
- 45:32What do we do with it? So there are three approaches
- 45:35to value. And when you're talking to your appraiser
- 45:40or you're cross -examining the other appraiser,
- 45:44you need to consider all three of these in every
- 45:47valuation. Do they all apply in every valuation?
- 45:50No, no, we don't use all of them all the time,
- 45:53but we have to consider all of these. So these
- 45:55three approaches is an income approach, a market
- 45:57approach, and an asset approach. The income approach
- 46:00is simply figure out the cash flow of the business
- 46:03and use that, you know, the technical way of
- 46:10doing it is you take the cash flow, you divide
- 46:11it by a rate of return, you come up with value.
- 46:13We don't have to get involved with the math of
- 46:15it, but it's cash flow divided by a rate of return,
- 46:19get value. The market approach, very, very similar
- 46:22to, you know, you're selling your house, right?
- 46:24What is my four bedroom colonial on a cul -de
- 46:27-sac in Poughkeepsie, New York worth, right?
- 46:29So I would go to town hall and I'd find other
- 46:32four bedroom colonials and I'd see what they
- 46:34were. what they were sold for, and I would use
- 46:37that as a proxy for the value of my house. And
- 46:42same thing with a business. If I can find comparable
- 46:45companies that were sold, I would use those sales
- 46:49prices to figure out the price of mine. And then
- 46:52the last approach we have is the asset approach.
- 46:55And the asset approach is simply similar to that
- 46:58liquidation method we were talking about early.
- 47:00The asset approach is the value of your business
- 47:03is worth the value of its assets, assets being
- 47:06cash, inventory, machinery, less its liabilities.
- 47:10That's the asset approach. It's a simple approach.
- 47:14We don't use it as a primary approach very often,
- 47:19but we consider it, right? Because we think a
- 47:23business should not be worth less. then it's
- 47:26assets. In other words, if I value a business
- 47:29and I come up with a thousand bucks for the value
- 47:31of the business, but I look at the value of its
- 47:34cash on the books and its inventory and subtract
- 47:37out its liabilities, and it's $5 ,000 worth of
- 47:41assets, and I only have $1 ,000 of value using
- 47:43my other approaches, well then maybe it is worth
- 47:46the value of the assets. So we do consider the
- 47:48asset approach, but it's not used all that often
- 47:52as a primary approach in evaluation. But your
- 47:56pleasure should always. Oh, I'm sorry. Do you
- 48:00look at each approach when you're valuing a business?
- 48:04Yes. So. So let's let's go to the next slide.
- 48:07Let's talk about a little more in depth and I'll
- 48:09tell you when and how. Well, let me just let
- 48:11me just. I always get this question after I value
- 48:14a company is like, OK, you value the company.
- 48:16You came up with a number. And you know, it's
- 48:19a million bucks for the value of the business,
- 48:21but. They've got $200 ,000 of inventory, and
- 48:24I know they have at least $100 ,000 of machinery.
- 48:30So do we add that to the value? No. When we value
- 48:33a business, the value includes all of the assets,
- 48:38tangible and intangible assets, that contribute
- 48:42to the revenues of the company. In other words,
- 48:46that value includes all of that inventory, all
- 48:48of the machines. It includes all of these things,
- 48:52tangible and intangible. And an intangible asset
- 48:54is something you can't touch or feel like cash
- 48:58and products. You can see all that. But intangible
- 49:02is like, I have a convenience store on a corner
- 49:07of a busy intersection that, because of my location,
- 49:12I make a lot of money with people walking in
- 49:14and out. So the intangible asset is location,
- 49:18or maybe it's trade name, or maybe it's reputation,
- 49:20right? So all of those things are captured in
- 49:23the value, all -inclusive. What's not captured
- 49:26in the value are those non -operating assets
- 49:29we talked about a little while ago, like the
- 49:32luxury boat or the land or things that don't
- 49:36contribute to the operations of the company are
- 49:39not included, but the value includes all of the
- 49:41assets of the company. So let's go to the next
- 49:44slide and talk a little bit more about the income.
- 49:49So let's go to the next one. Under the income
- 49:52approach, you're going to see one of two methods
- 49:54most commonly. You're going to see the capitalization
- 49:57method or you're going to see the discounting
- 49:58method. All you need to know about these two
- 50:00methods are the capitalization method takes the
- 50:03historical financial statements, uses that as
- 50:06a proxy of future benefit. Again, it's future
- 50:09benefit and risk. So we use the historical We
- 50:12come up with some kind of, we use an analysis
- 50:15and we say these historical results should repeat
- 50:18into the future and we come up with a value.
- 50:21Discounting, we project future cash flow. We
- 50:25ignore the, we don't ignore technically, but
- 50:28we don't use historical results. We actually
- 50:32use a projection. Next year, they're going to
- 50:34do X, the year after that, they're going to do
- 50:35Y, the year after that, they're going to do something.
- 50:37So we use a projection. A little harder to use.
- 50:41A lot of people stay away from the discounting
- 50:43method, especially in litigation, because it's
- 50:46a little more speculative with the crystal ball.
- 50:49I think I'm going to do this in 26. I'm going
- 50:51to do that in 27. It's hard to project future
- 50:55income. A lot of people rely on this capitalization
- 50:58method, which says, look, based on the last five
- 51:00years, here's the average cash flow over the
- 51:02last five years. Let's just say that's going
- 51:04to happen into the future. So two different methods.
- 51:08those are the most common ones you'll see. When
- 51:11are you going to see the discounting method?
- 51:12Like what's an example of a business where that
- 51:14would be important? So the discounting method
- 51:18you would want to use where you have a business
- 51:21that's either a startup business where it has
- 51:24no history and you can't use the other method
- 51:26or something significantly is expected to change.
- 51:31So if we've got a situation where, hey, I actually
- 51:35just had this in evaluation where they value
- 51:37the company And then a specific event happened.
- 51:41They valued it as of April, but then a specific
- 51:43event happened in March that dramatically changed
- 51:48the revenues of this business. It increased it.
- 51:51They had a positive review. It was a restaurant.
- 51:54They had a positive review that kicked them to
- 51:59another level. So the capitalization method,
- 52:02the historical meant nothing because this put
- 52:04them in another plane. So we actually had to
- 52:06create projections to capture that positive review
- 52:09that stemmed a whole lot of growth. So when we
- 52:12expect something to be dramatically different,
- 52:14we go to this discounting method. OK. Next slide.
- 52:24Pros and cons we use this in every we use this
- 52:27in almost every single engagement because it
- 52:30is company specific Here are the cash flows of
- 52:32the business and based on the cash flow of the
- 52:34business. Here's what it's worth So that's really
- 52:36the advantage of this approach So let's go to
- 52:39the next one, which will be the market approach
- 52:41Love the concept of the market approach. Hey
- 52:44My four -bedroom colonial on the end of the cul
- 52:47-de -sac sold for half a million bucks. So That
- 52:50means other four -bedroom Colonials on the street
- 52:53are also worth half a million bucks. Easy. Not
- 52:56so easy in the valuation world. I've got an engineering
- 53:01firm in New Haven, Connecticut, and what's it
- 53:06worth? Okay, let me go find another engineering
- 53:09firm in New Haven, Connecticut that sold recently.
- 53:11Guess what? I'm probably not going to find it.
- 53:13So let me expand that engineering firm outside
- 53:16of New Haven into New England. and I still don't
- 53:20have enough transactions. So let me expand it
- 53:22nationally. Cool. Now I got a bunch of stuff,
- 53:26but I don't, they're all different sizes. They're
- 53:29all different. And remember what I said earlier,
- 53:32these are actual sales of businesses. What happens
- 53:35in actual sales of businesses? You have different
- 53:37motivations, different people. So people are
- 53:40buying certain businesses for a particular reason.
- 53:43So you've got multiples and values all over the
- 53:46place that you've got to kind of dissect. So
- 53:49the market approach is very tricky. Conceptually,
- 53:52it's very easy, but it's very tricky to implement.
- 53:57So great area of cross -examination if your expert
- 54:01or the opposing expert has used the market approach.
- 54:04Because let's go to the next slide because there's
- 54:05two. So there's public company and merger and
- 54:10acquisition. So if I'm using a market approach,
- 54:12I could actually find, I don't know if I can,
- 54:15but. If there's publicly traded companies in
- 54:19the same industry as my company, I could see
- 54:21what they're trading for because it's available
- 54:24data, right? I can go to Yahoo and I could see
- 54:26what the price is. The problem is those are billion
- 54:29dollar companies. And a lot of those billion
- 54:32dollar companies have multiple arms of operations.
- 54:35So unless you have a really, really, really large
- 54:38company you're valuing, we don't typically see
- 54:43the use of the guideline public company. What
- 54:46we see more often is this merger and acquisition
- 54:48method, which is exactly what I was talking about
- 54:50before. We find sales of comparable businesses
- 54:53in the same industry, hopefully with the same
- 54:56level of revenues in the same geographic location
- 54:59and try to match it up. It's very hard to do.
- 55:04So if an expert is using this, you got to kind
- 55:08of dive into the details of, all right, you've
- 55:11used these dozen transactions. Your business
- 55:14is a million -dollar business, but one of the
- 55:16transactions is a 10 -million -dollar business.
- 55:18How is that comparable? Like, dig in. You got
- 55:20to dig into where's the comparability of these
- 55:24transactions to your subject company to see if
- 55:27it's really a match, you know? So it's a hard
- 55:33method to use. I use it as a test of reasonableness.
- 55:39I use it when I have a volume of data. Like if
- 55:43I went to a database and had 75 transactions
- 55:54and they all hovered around one times revenue,
- 55:57meaning the revenues were a million dollars and
- 55:59it sold for a million dollars, I could say, okay,
- 56:01these things trade in a million dollars, but
- 56:04you don't see that too often. And then last we
- 56:08got the asset approach, which is. Go to the next
- 56:12slide. Yeah, the next slide is simply the asset
- 56:15approach. Talked about the pros and cons. We
- 56:20can keep going. And the asset approach is basic,
- 56:26right? This is the floor value of any business.
- 56:28It's its assets minus its liabilities. And if
- 56:31we can't get value using the other two, then
- 56:33it's worth at least this. So kind of a simple
- 56:36approach. Rules of thumb. You love rules of thumb.
- 56:45Yeah, right. Everybody loves rules of thumb.
- 56:48I get called on it all the time. Hey, what do
- 56:50accounting firms trade at? OK, I can give you
- 56:54a range, but let's not lock into it, right? So
- 56:57rules of thumb are exactly that. They're like,
- 56:59you know what? These businesses try to sell for
- 57:03five times cash flow. OK, so I'm going to put
- 57:06five times cash flow. Now I have an idea what
- 57:08this thing is worth. Can I testify to it as an
- 57:11expert? No, I'm not testifying to a rule of thumb.
- 57:14I could give you some ideas based on all the
- 57:17data I've ever seen. This is the range of value,
- 57:22but you never want to rely on a rule of thumb.
- 57:24It gives you a ballpark and only a ballpark.
- 57:28John, we have a question from the audience. Good.
- 57:31Not to interrupt you, but let's do it. How do
- 57:34you treat retained earnings and valuing a business?
- 57:37Yeah, good question. So retained earnings is
- 57:40Really the sum or the or the product of the product.
- 57:44I've been so long since I've been in math class
- 57:47It's your assets minus your liabilities is your
- 57:50rate turner. So it's your net assets So the retained
- 57:54earnings of a business is really the minimum
- 57:58that it's worth So it retained earnings is really
- 58:02everything that you've left in the business,
- 58:04which is all the assets minus its liability so
- 58:07it's retained earnings is a net asset of a company
- 58:10the net asset of the company is looked at as
- 58:12the floor value for the business it's essentially
- 58:15essentially how we look at it all right slide
- 58:22trigger the next one yeah bona fide offers to
- 58:28buy these are fun so you know we always ask when
- 58:31we're valuing a company interviewing management
- 58:34Like I said earlier, we're working in this world
- 58:36of hypothetics. What is this thing worth if it
- 58:39were to be sold? But I will ask, have you ever
- 58:44had any offers? Because I want to know, especially
- 58:49now, if I'm valuing a company as of today and
- 58:51you've got an offer on the table, well, that's
- 58:54value, right? You asked earlier, Katie, when
- 58:58is value and price the same? It could be the
- 59:01same. If you've got an offer on the table, somebody's
- 59:03going to buy your actual business that we're
- 59:05trying to value, well, that's the value. The
- 59:07reason we're in this world of hypothetics is
- 59:09because you don't have anybody buying the business.
- 59:11So we have to fall in line with these assumptions.
- 59:14But if you've got somebody who wants to buy your
- 59:15business, this could be the value of the business.
- 59:18If it's a true offer, there's a lot of moving
- 59:22parts to it. We want to absolutely know if there
- 59:26has been any offers or there are any offers on
- 59:29the table. We need to consider those if they
- 59:31exist. I see we're running out of time. So or
- 59:35actually we're even out of time. So let's go
- 59:37to the next slide. Let's try to wrap up. Yeah,
- 59:40so discounts. All we need to know about for discounts
- 59:43is fair market value uses discounts. I value
- 59:47a business. It's a million bucks. You own 10
- 59:49% of that million. dollar value, so that's $100
- 59:54,000. Is that your value? Not necessarily. Under
- 59:57fair market value, we assume that 10 % interest
- 1:00:00is going to be taken to the market. The market's
- 1:00:02going to say, I ain't paying you $100 ,000 off
- 1:00:05a million dollar value because I can't control
- 1:00:08the cash flow. I can't do anything with this.
- 1:00:10I can't sell it. It's going to take me forever
- 1:00:12to find a buyer. I'm going to discount this 20,
- 1:00:1530, 40%. Those are discounts, lacking control,
- 1:00:18marketability, and they... I don't want to say
- 1:00:21arbitrarily, but a lot of states don't love them
- 1:00:24because they reduce value even though you're
- 1:00:28going to get all of the cash flow as the business
- 1:00:29owner. So it's this concept of if I were to take
- 1:00:34it to the market, how would the market treat
- 1:00:38it? But you're not actually taking it to market.
- 1:00:41So that's what the discount situation is. And
- 1:00:44fair value doesn't really consider the discounts.
- 1:00:47And we kind of mentioned that before under those
- 1:00:49standards. We've got another question. Yeah.
- 1:00:52All right. So how is the add back percentage
- 1:00:55for Perkwizards determined? Is there a standard
- 1:00:57percentage or does it vary based on each case?
- 1:00:59Yeah, it varies. So it'd be nice if we used a
- 1:01:02percentage like, hey, 50 % of T &E is going to
- 1:01:04add back. And look, we might do that. But it's
- 1:01:07really fact specific. I mean, if it's like I
- 1:01:10like to go into a case and say, tell me how much
- 1:01:14personal spending is in this because I don't
- 1:01:16want to have this Spend all this time on the
- 1:01:18forensics, right? So maybe we come to an agreement
- 1:01:19on it, but in other cases we may do a full spending
- 1:01:23analysis, a full forensic analysis, lay it all
- 1:01:26out, figure it out for ourselves, and then maybe
- 1:01:29through deposition say, tell me about all of
- 1:01:31these expenses and what they were for. We try
- 1:01:34to do it quantitatively so we get the actual
- 1:01:36right answer as. you know, opposed to a percentage.
- 1:01:40I might use a percentage if it's a small case.
- 1:01:42We're just trying to settle it. We want to come
- 1:01:43up with a number. Everybody says, yeah, you know,
- 1:01:45I do have some entertainment. We may use a percentage,
- 1:01:49but it's really, really fact and case specific.
- 1:01:53Okay. Let's go to the next slide. This is the
- 1:02:00discount. We can skip over that. Yeah. There's
- 1:02:03a lot of good stuff in there. That's just the
- 1:02:05math of it. You guys don't want to do math. All
- 1:02:08right, last is like they are even the last slide.
- 1:02:10So we couldn't bang this thing out. So, so here's
- 1:02:13where we have problems with in a valuation report,
- 1:02:16what we typically look for, not understanding
- 1:02:18the business or the industry, right? So we talked
- 1:02:20about either compact disk manufacturer and, and
- 1:02:24it's 2000 and you're going to be replaced by
- 1:02:26digital downloads, right? If your valuation analyst
- 1:02:28hasn't figured out the risks. that are presented
- 1:02:31this business, they haven't done their job, right?
- 1:02:33So we want to understand the business, we want
- 1:02:35to understand the industry, we want to figure
- 1:02:38out the risks. The normalization entries are
- 1:02:41huge, right? You want to make sure that that's
- 1:02:44the area of cross -examination and critique that
- 1:02:46you're going to spend your most time on. What
- 1:02:49normalization, what adjusting entries have been
- 1:02:52made? And if you miss them, you put in the wrong
- 1:02:54officer's comp, you miss some perks that you
- 1:02:56haven't taken out, you're going to come up with
- 1:02:57the wrong value. Roles of owners, same thing.
- 1:03:01If I don't know what the person does, I may not
- 1:03:03assign the right compensation to them, which
- 1:03:05means I've overvalued or undervalued the business.
- 1:03:09Personal goodwill is a whole valuation presentation
- 1:03:12all of itself, but personal goodwill is I need
- 1:03:15to understand how much of the cash flow is generated
- 1:03:20by the personal knowledge and reputation of the
- 1:03:22individual so I can assign the right compensation
- 1:03:25to that person. and there's a few other here,
- 1:03:28but I know we're running out of time. Before
- 1:03:31we end, give the audience a couple of tips for
- 1:03:35cross -examining a business valuation expert.
- 1:03:39Yeah. Let me think about this. I don't want you
- 1:03:46to cross -examine me, so I don't want to answer
- 1:03:47quickly. Okay. No, I'm just kidding. Credibility
- 1:03:52is where you gain all your advantage, right?
- 1:03:55So if you can impeach credibility, and it doesn't
- 1:03:57even mean that they're not qualified, or they
- 1:04:00might not be, right? So you want to know the
- 1:04:01qualifications of the expert. You get some experts
- 1:04:03that are forensic experts that try to do evaluation.
- 1:04:06You know, you can impeach credibility just from
- 1:04:08their expertise. But in evaluation, it's challenging
- 1:04:12the assumptions. And there are quite a few assumptions
- 1:04:14that we're making in these valuations. So you
- 1:04:16want to challenge the assumptions, but you want
- 1:04:19to keep it to a point Challenge the assumptions,
- 1:04:22but only the assumptions that materially affect
- 1:04:25the value. Like I've been cross -examined on
- 1:04:27like a dozen things, most of which are irrelevant.
- 1:04:30And it just gets too much and it becomes a waste
- 1:04:33of time. Find the one or two things that really
- 1:04:36are going to adversely affect the result and
- 1:04:39hone in on that. And also focus on things that
- 1:04:42the valuation expert may have missed or not done.
- 1:04:45That's where I find I get I get the best cross
- 1:04:48against me, even though I shouldn't have done
- 1:04:51something, but it's like, hey, did you do A,
- 1:04:53B, C, D, and E? No, I did not. Okay. End it there.
- 1:04:58If I don't have a good redirect who says, you
- 1:05:01answer you didn't do A, B, C, D, and E, but did
- 1:05:03you have to do D, C, and E? No, I didn't have
- 1:05:06to, and here's why. But focusing on the things
- 1:05:09that were not done, like... You didn't use a
- 1:05:12market approach in this, and you didn't tell
- 1:05:13me why. So there's three approaches. You only
- 1:05:16used two. Focus on the things that were missed.
- 1:05:19Focus on the things that are critical to the
- 1:05:22end result. And stay with those two things, and
- 1:05:25I think you'll be successful. OK. We are severely
- 1:05:29out of time. So thank you all for listening,
- 1:05:32and I hope you learned something. Yeah, thank
- 1:05:35you. Bye, everyone.