Latest / The Feminine Manifesto / #19 What If the Patriarchy Isn’t the Problem and Masculinity is Not Toxic? with Andrew Gray.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Is masculinity toxic?
- 0:05Is the patriarchy biblical and necessary?
- 0:07Today, we're going to get into all of that and much more. And to help us think
- 0:11through this and understand this biblically, I've asked Andrew Gray to come on the podcast.
- 0:16So, Andrew comes with years of pastoral experience, is the host of The Man Show,
- 0:21where he explores conversations around masculinity, faith, leadership,
- 0:25family, and personal responsibility.
- 0:27Welcome to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. I'm your host, Heather,
- 0:32wife, mother, and founder of the Feminine Manifesto.
- 0:35For too long, our culture has embraced and believed the lies of feminism,
- 0:39distorting God's design for women and leaving us burdened and unsatisfied.
- 0:44This podcast exists to confront the lies shaping our culture and boldly proclaim the truth of the gospel.
- 0:50True freedom is only found in Christ. So join us as we bring the truth of the
- 0:54gospel to light in our culture.
- 0:57Andrew, welcome to the Feminine Manifesto podcast. Thanks very much.
- 1:00Great to be here. Looking forward to our chat.
- 1:02I met you briefly at the Church and State Conference earlier this year in Brisbane,
- 1:07and I heard you speak on the topic of biblical patriarchy.
- 1:11This is a very relevant topic to my focus on this podcast, which is dealing
- 1:16with feminism, and as the feminists hate the patriarchy and actively seek to
- 1:21dismantle it, or in their words, smash the patriarchy.
- 1:25I was really interested when you were talking about this topic and really encouraged
- 1:28and enlightened too. And so, I really wanted to dive deeper into exploring this
- 1:32and particularly from a biblical lens.
- 1:35Sure. So, you've researched this topic a bit and it's obviously of interest to you.
- 1:40How did you become to be interested and start your own show to really challenge and encourage men here?
- 1:46Yeah, great question. Well, for me, it's been a long journey really that started
- 1:51out, as you mentioned, as a young man, getting involved in a pastoral ministry in my local church.
- 1:57I became a youth pastor, did that for close to a decade, and then eventually
- 2:01went on to run not-for-profit boards and was a senior pastor of a large multi-site church.
- 2:07And I guess all of my observations during that period of time,
- 2:10combined with my own upbringing and my own family life, has led me to be
- 2:15convinced and persuaded beyond turning that God's original design for family
- 2:20and for how we relate to one another is still undefeated.
- 2:23And what I mean by that is there's evidence all around us every day that there
- 2:29is a place for not only gender roles, but how we relate to one another.
- 2:34I've watched, as you have, and pretty well all of us have, we've watched the
- 2:38emergence of a new breed of,
- 2:41angry and traumatized feminism sweeping the earth.
- 2:45One of the things that challenges me greatly about that is, and it's unspoken
- 2:49a lot of the time, sadly, but the incredible damage and destruction that that
- 2:55movement and that wave is actually doing to women.
- 2:58And so there's a very sad irony in there that this supposed movement that is
- 3:04there to champion the values and the rights of women.
- 3:07And I go to great lengths on my podcast all the time to talk about the fact
- 3:11that as a God-fearing, God-believing family man, I want women to have all of
- 3:17the rights that they should have. I want them to do well.
- 3:20Being pro-male is not anti-female, but I am very, very saddened and troubled by the fact that,
- 3:27this new wave of feminism that supposedly is pro-women's rights is actually
- 3:32becoming the greatest force in the earth to damage what God always designed for women.
- 3:37It's really sad to see. So for me, I come from this position of when men follow
- 3:43God and they seek to be changed more and more into the character they should
- 3:48have, there's nothing for women to fear.
- 3:50And actually, when we relate to one another in that way, we see the most fruitful
- 3:54families and lives that come about. So it really starts for me from my pastoral
- 3:59days and watching the obvious that happens in family life. Hmm.
- 4:04I think some would argue that in defense of feminism, that in the past,
- 4:09women have been abused en masse by men.
- 4:13And what feminism did was gave them options to be able to divorce their husbands
- 4:17or be able to get out from underneath abuse.
- 4:21So, why do you see it's important to encourage masculinity in men?
- 4:26Yeah, great question. Again, look, from my perspective, I come at this word
- 4:30masculinity and the definition of it and the redefinition of it in a unique
- 4:37way, which used to be the common way.
- 4:39And what I mean by that is when I use the phrase masculinity, I regard it as a.
- 4:46Existential finished concept designed by God.
- 4:51We do hear often in today's world this phrasing of toxic masculinity and things like this.
- 4:57Interestingly and ironically, we never hear the phrase toxic femininity.
- 5:02Now, that always intrigued me and it's why I have tried to deliberately
- 5:07push the pendulum way back the other way in order to try and redress the imbalance
- 5:12and to say to people, there is no such thing as toxic masculinity because masculinity
- 5:18as a concept and by design is a closed loop
- 5:22finished as it was meant to be. Now, I'll unpack that in a moment.
- 5:25I think what we have is toxic humanity, which is actually the brokenness of
- 5:30humanity through the advent of sin and turning our backs on God and being in
- 5:36rebellion to how he wants us to live.
- 5:38But when I talk about masculinity, I'm referring to the original masculinity,
- 5:44the design of God, that men were put in their place in the world for three chief
- 5:49pillars and expressions.
- 5:51And I describe those as protection, provision, empowerment.
- 5:55Now, that does not mean that women can't do elements of that as well. They can and they do.
- 6:01I'm simply speaking to and about the men we were put here chiefly to do those three things.
- 6:07And you don't have to search too far and too wide to see what happens when men
- 6:11abdicate their role as protectors, providers, and empowerers.
- 6:15And maybe later in our conversation, we can break that down. I don't know.
- 6:19But when they abdicate that and they allow the brokenness of sin and corruption
- 6:24to run through their soul,
- 6:26that's when we actually see what you're referring to, which is the abuse or
- 6:30the suppression, I would say of others, not just of women, because it's women and children.
- 6:36And And it's even other men who get suppressed by broken men.
- 6:40And so really what we want to see is a renaissance of original true masculinity
- 6:47where more and more men get inspired to.
- 6:50Pick back up their cross, so to speak, and be a protector of those they love,
- 6:56a provider of those that they care for, and an empowerer of everyone they come in contact with.
- 7:01And my thing, Heather, would be that every single man that lives that way,
- 7:06I have never seen him have a challenge with the women in his life and vice versa,
- 7:10that when we actually live according to our design, things go well.
- 7:14And I really think that's where the core and the heart of the conversation is
- 7:18at when it comes to women who might be on a feministic tirade, so to speak.
- 7:24I feel sorry for those women, actually. I don't have a vendetta against them.
- 7:28I actually feel deeply sorry for them because in every one of my experiences
- 7:33and encounters, and I'm yet to see a contrary perspective on this,
- 7:38generally women who end up in that state have experienced
- 7:42some kind of abuse or mistreatment or abandonment or rejection from a man who
- 7:48was in a broken state himself.
- 7:50Now, the way we fix that in the world is not by throwing out men.
- 7:53The way we fix that in the world is by building better men, and that can only
- 7:57happen when we cleave to God's design.
- 7:59100%. And I mean, all through this whole topic of men and women and how it's
- 8:04affecting our society and the distortion of the roles that we currently have,
- 8:07it really is a simple answer of just returning to God's design.
- 8:12And when we do that, we flourish, our families flourish, our society flourishes. And it's so simple.
- 8:19I've talked a lot about in the past men being protectors and providers.
- 8:23And I remember seeing this. I did a video on it briefly.
- 8:26We were down at the beach and we saw some swans and there was this mother swan
- 8:31on her nest and the male swan was around the nest just being that protector.
- 8:37And you see it playing out naturally in the animal kingdom and how beautiful it is there. Yes.
- 8:42Yet when it comes to humans, we push back and say, no, I don't want that.
- 8:47That's right. Where is the biblical basis for men being the protector and the provider for women?
- 8:54Yeah, absolutely. Look, I think a more detailed and granular phrasing for us
- 8:59to use is to talk about not just roles, but to talk about primary roles.
- 9:04So, there are many things that I can do secondarily as a man.
- 9:09And I can and I should, but it doesn't mean that they are my best expressions
- 9:12or my primary expression.
- 9:14So when I talk about men having the expression of protecting,
- 9:17providing, empowering, it doesn't therefore prohibit women from having
- 9:21similar versions of that expression, but for men, it must be their primary role.
- 9:26In the scriptures we see in Genesis, we see God giving the role of caretaker
- 9:32to Adam, the man, and giving him responsibility.
- 9:35And with that comes the pressure of being a wise decision maker and being someone
- 9:39who's willing to make choices
- 9:42and decisions that benefit others before himself, you know, and not often talked
- 9:47about passage in regard to this conversation is found in Ephesians 5, which is where
- 9:52I have built the cornerstone of all of my pre-marriage counseling over decades.
- 9:56And you read through that passage, which famously starts out in verse one,
- 10:00it says, wives submit to your husbands.
- 10:03And occasionally I've read that out at wedding ceremonies that I've officiated.
- 10:07And when you have a mixed group of people in the room, I've often even heard
- 10:10people gasping at the dare suggestion that I should even read it out.
- 10:15But To read it in isolation doesn't help us because the full context is what's required because.
- 10:22Further along in the passage, it says, husbands, love your wives as Christ has
- 10:27loved the church, as he gave himself for her and laid down his life for her.
- 10:32And so, I talk about this in pre-marriage counseling, which I don't do a lot
- 10:35of anymore these days, but I used to do a lot of it.
- 10:38And I used to talk to the young men and say, guys, here's what this means.
- 10:41This means that you get to die first. And they would look at me with a strange
- 10:46look and I'd say, I'm mostly talking metaphorically here, but if it came to
- 10:50it, I'm actually talking literally as well.
- 10:52That if there's a need for protection of your household, God requires you as
- 10:57a man to be the first line of sacrifice. You're made for it, you're built for it.
- 11:02Or I break it down into more realistic and simple terms. I say,
- 11:06if you guys start to struggle as a family financially and there's not enough
- 11:10food to put on the table. Well, guess who's fasting that night?
- 11:13You are. That's your role. That's your calling as a man to put yourself second.
- 11:19So, not often understood,
- 11:21Rarely talked about, but a huge part of the biblical role of a man's life is
- 11:27that his going first and being primary is actually a call to put himself second.
- 11:33Yeah. And that's very interesting. And it's very interesting seeing people's
- 11:38reactions to the word submission because in any healthy relationship or dynamic,
- 11:43even in society, and I think this was interesting through COVID,
- 11:47is that a lot of the.
- 11:51Well, generalizing here, but there was a large majority of the feminist left
- 11:55woke sort of movement who was pushing for this submission to government at all costs.
- 12:01And, you know, without getting into the whole COVID debate, that is needed in
- 12:05a society for the people to submit to their government at some level.
- 12:09You know, there's levels when you resist and so forth.
- 12:12But in any healthy dynamic or in an employee-employer relationship,
- 12:16there needs to be some submission, whether we call it something else in that scenario.
- 12:20In any healthy relationship, there needs to be a leader and there needs to be followers.
- 12:24And yet, when it comes to husbands and wives, the feminists get so angry at
- 12:28this, or we naturally get so angry at this.
- 12:31And it's obvious that this is obviously Satan's attack here,
- 12:35because why would this be such an issue in one relationship,
- 12:39yet in the rest of society we say, yes, this makes sense here.
- 12:42Yeah, absolutely. It's a brilliant and correct observation. You are spot on that.
- 12:47You can't apply the standard protocols of a rule in one context and not have
- 12:53that applying in others.
- 12:54But people, as we know, they do tend to cherry pick what they want to hear in
- 12:59order to buffer their premeditated narratives.
- 13:03I mean, if a person took time to read scripture properly, they'd also discover
- 13:06that submission is talked about in many other places and in many other ways,
- 13:10including husbands and wives submit to one another as is right in the Lord.
- 13:16And the plumb line there, as always, is what is right in the Lord?
- 13:21As we let God be the leader of our lives, what has he set as the boundaries
- 13:27for our healthy existence?
- 13:28And so you then come across into your example of what you said about COVID, which was
- 13:33fiercely ironic that in one instance, we had often women, but not only women,
- 13:37but often women at the microphone in front of the press gallery saying that
- 13:41we must all submit to everything that's being said instantly.
- 13:45And yet they were some of the great champions of not wanting to live under any
- 13:48kind of submission. And so we look at that and we go, well, where are the boundary markers here?
- 13:53How do we actually live with this? And something that we've tried to live by
- 13:57in my family, and I've even tried to encourage my children in this,
- 14:01is I've given them this illiterated guideline where I've said rules without
- 14:06good rationale should be reasoned with.
- 14:09In other words, you don't just submit to every single rule that gets thrown
- 14:14at you in life just because it's a rule.
- 14:16Because the truth of the matter is there are some rules that get invented that
- 14:20are bad for people. And for us to not reason the rationale of that rule makes
- 14:26us lemmings and robots without brains, and that's not what God designed us for.
- 14:30However, stemming from scripture and spreading out from there,
- 14:35we do see great rules with excellent rationale that are for our health and our
- 14:40protection and our favor.
- 14:42And so, it helps people to use these kind of guidelines when they understand,
- 14:46yeah, sure, not all rules are actually good for us because a lot of them are
- 14:50invented by people with impure motives.
- 14:53And coming back to that thing you said, turning back to God,
- 14:56trusting God, if we believe in the character of God that he always,
- 15:01on every occasion, wants for our best, then we can trust what he's got to say to us. And so.
- 15:07I think it's a fascinating observation that you've pointed out there,
- 15:09this idea of submission or whatever substitute word people want to use.
- 15:14It's commonplace everywhere and it's necessary in balance and in health,
- 15:20lest we have anarchy. Yeah, 100%.
- 15:23So, on that note of the different roles of men and women in society and how
- 15:28God has designed us, the other issue that people tend to get their backs up
- 15:32on is the problem of the patriarchy.
- 15:35Yes. And there's a real pushback against this idea, like, you know,
- 15:38let's smash the patriarchy. It's a real anger.
- 15:41Yes. So, can you explain what do we mean when we refer to biblical patriarchy?
- 15:47Yeah, sure. Look, there's a couple of ways for us to come at this.
- 15:50And I'm a bit of a nerd when it comes to being a wordsmith.
- 15:54I care a lot about choice of words and structure of sentences.
- 15:58And we live in an age, sadly, where language has been so abused and so mutilated,
- 16:02you're not even sure what people are saying even when they speak the same language
- 16:06as you, but let's come up the language of this for a moment.
- 16:10I do hold the view that in our English language, the word patriarchy has become
- 16:15an unfortunate placeholder.
- 16:18And what I mean by that is it's been so bullied and so misappropriated that
- 16:23it's almost impossible to use that word now without there being a mixed response.
- 16:27But if we were to try and wind the time machine back a bit and take a look at
- 16:32what that actually means, it comes back to what we were talking about before, this idea
- 16:37that men have a place in God's design to stand in gaps, to be on front lines, to do dangerous work.
- 16:45We look throughout history, and I'm certainly not an advocate for war,
- 16:49but when you look at the history of war, 99.9% of the frontline deaths are men because it's.
- 16:59Stand in the way of threat for other people's benefits. So, I think the language
- 17:04of patriarchy has become a little bit unfortunate.
- 17:08But again, this would be my thing. When it comes to this, as you've said,
- 17:12this intense hatred that goes on when people hear that language and hear that phrasing,
- 17:17very sadly, and most often, it comes as a result of people having experienced
- 17:24either damage or abuse or neglect
- 17:27or abandonment or misuse or rejection or something destructive to the soul
- 17:33at the hands of a man.
- 17:36And I've often, not often, I've occasionally been yelled down by others to,
- 17:41because I have chosen to hold this line, which became a famous hashtag a few
- 17:47years ago, when angry feminists were telling all the men to stop saying not all men.
- 17:55And you might remember that, but I refused to curtsy to that.
- 17:58I was saying no, but the truth of the matter is it's not all men.
- 18:02Now, I think the not all men thing grew momentum because in feminist quarters,
- 18:08it was useful to lay a charge of either abusive or potentially abusive at the
- 18:15feet of every single man.
- 18:16Because if you can allege wrong on behalf of the entire agenda,
- 18:21you can bring a penalty against the entire agenda and you'll have no resistance
- 18:25to your own agenda. And that's what the whole not all men thing was about.
- 18:29But for me, I was passionate about holding the line for the very large majority
- 18:35and the millions and millions of actually good men who are out there every day
- 18:41fighting their hardest to be good family men, to be providers,
- 18:45to love their wives and children, to do no harm to society.
- 18:49And the way that we fix and deal with the bad actors, the bad apples,
- 18:54is we have appropriate justice.
- 18:57But on the other side, we stick to the positive. When we do something about
- 19:01speaking to and for the good young men, the good middle-aged men,
- 19:06the good senior men who've held the line for decades.
- 19:10Because if we throw those good men into the same bucket of vinegar with the
- 19:15bad actors, we run the risk of the good men tapping out and saying,
- 19:19well, forget it. What's the point?
- 19:20I do my best and they still try to stick labels on me. I'll go hide in my cave
- 19:26in my corner somewhere and just wait my time out.
- 19:28That would be the worst result our world could have. Yeah.
- 19:32100%. So, with the idea of the patriarchy or even the wording shifting,
- 19:37do you think it's important or why do you think it's important that we get this
- 19:42right in society to have a good patriarchal model?
- 19:46Yeah. Look, if we don't, we will lose all the benefits of the God design. Like I just said.
- 19:54The deliberate confusion of language, if we allow the lazy redefinition of terms
- 20:01and concepts, then there is a group of people who,
- 20:04do have an angry agenda who will win, but they won't win because of the contest
- 20:10of ideas and intellectual argument.
- 20:13They'll win by default because those who've already got enough on their plate
- 20:18trying to fight for good will just disappear from the public discourse.
- 20:22And that's the worst thing that could happen to us. We're seeing this happen
- 20:25on a different front all across the Western world right now where.
- 20:29Well-intentioned, hardworking people are vacating public debate on super important
- 20:35matters like free speech because their lives are so pressured and so stressed
- 20:38already that they think, do I really need that on my plate as well?
- 20:42And every time I pop my head up, someone throws something at me.
- 20:45Well, I can certainly vouch for a lot of particularly middle-aged men right
- 20:49now who sadly are growing towards that position where they're thinking, what's the point?
- 20:55Why would I bother participating in this if I work hard, do the best I can,
- 20:59do the right things and they still throw stones at me?
- 21:02Forget it. Leave me alone. That would be hugely problematic if we can't find
- 21:07out the kinks in this language confusion and the mutilation of concepts and terms.
- 21:14And my thing, Heather, would be I'm certain it's a deliberate strategy.
- 21:19It's not happening organically or accidentally.
- 21:22It's happening on purpose because if you remove the protective layer of good
- 21:28sacrificial men from society, you're cooked.
- 21:32It's over. I mean, I can just testify to that in my own life.
- 21:36I'm obviously someone who's very keen to keep up to date with what's going on
- 21:40and in providing a counter voice to what is being told to us,
- 21:44like the whole reason I started this podcast was because of that.
- 21:47And it's exhausting. It's exhausting being that voice and constantly getting the pushback.
- 21:53And when that pushback comes within your own family and friends,
- 21:56that's when it's the most exhausting and discouraging.
- 21:59Yes. But it's been so encouraging, particularly this year in the political realm,
- 22:04to see men standing up in the political.
- 22:08Discourse, with the likes of Karl Stefanovic starting his podcast and having
- 22:13conversations about topics.
- 22:15Not that he's a Christian, but he's having conversations on topics that is about truth, actually.
- 22:20Yes. Seeing Matt Canavan speak up and these guys push back against these policies
- 22:25that have been shoved down our throats for years. And I think exactly like what
- 22:28you've been saying is people just became exhausted and just there was no hope.
- 22:33And there's a glimmer of hope now in our political realm of men starting to speak up.
- 22:39And whilst I'm a Christian, I rest in God's sovereignty that no matter what
- 22:44happens in life, he is sovereign. But when I see these men standing up,
- 22:48it actually takes a burden off me thinking, I don't have to be this person.
- 22:53Like the men are speaking up and I can focus on my role as a wife and a mother
- 22:58and building a healthy family because when men are faithful in their role of
- 23:02leadership, it actually allows women to flourish and kids to flourish
- 23:07and therefore society to flourish.
- 23:09And the knock-on effect is tremendous. And I think that's why there's been such
- 23:13a deliberate attack and a satanic attack on men, because you cut them out and
- 23:19everything else crumbles. Yes.
- 23:21No, you're absolutely right. You're spot on. And I think what we're starting
- 23:25to see, thankfully, is the early green shoots of a tide reversal.
- 23:30You know, when you mentioned some of these politicians or these...
- 23:33Media voices that are starting to speak out and speak up. It is a great thing.
- 23:37And I think a lot of it, Heather, actually is coming from the very simple result
- 23:42that people are starting to realize, even non-Christian people, right?
- 23:46But lots of people are starting to realize if woke was so wonderful,
- 23:51why has the world gotten worse? And that simple conclusion is growing in its
- 23:56momentum and it's the right conclusion.
- 23:59If all this nonsense that we were almost forced to choke down in the last 10 years that.
- 24:06A good thing for our communities would be to have men dress up as women and
- 24:11come to our schools and read stories to our children.
- 24:14If that was a great idea, why is the world worse?
- 24:17If it was a great idea to have 120 kilo men with still covered in hair in their
- 24:23body, go and play a women's sport and beat the living snot out of dainty, petite women.
- 24:29How is that better? People are starting to realize, thankfully,
- 24:33thank God it's finally happening. People are starting to realize,
- 24:36hang on, if we're saying one plus one is seven, I can't get on board with that.
- 24:41And I didn't say anything, this is not me, this is the collective voice.
- 24:46People are starting to say, 10 years ago.
- 24:49Didn't quite know what to do with this irrational nonsense because when I even
- 24:54thought about speaking up, I got called names and bullied and told to shut up and sit in my corner.
- 25:00And this is my theory, Heather. I believe we went through a period extending
- 25:04from just before COVID to about 18 months ago when people were in a shock bubble.
- 25:11The assault on truth, the assault on common sense, the assault on things that
- 25:16have worked and produced good results for millennia was so aggressively and hatefully
- 25:23vilified in an irrational way that I think the bulk of the world and common
- 25:29sense people were in a shock bubble.
- 25:30Like, I don't know what to do with this because there was no arguing intellectually
- 25:36and intelligently with these people.
- 25:38These people were like out of control, feral, tired toddlers who were screaming
- 25:45at the world saying, I just want what I want.
- 25:48And the rest of us didn't know what to do with it. But I think we've had a couple
- 25:52of waking up moments in the last little while. One of them was the assassination
- 25:56of Charlie Kirk. That rocked the world.
- 25:59Whether people liked him or hated him, the fact that he could be shot dead in
- 26:03broad daylight, and I'm not getting into the whole conspiracy thing with Candace
- 26:08Owens and all the rest of them, but the fact the man
- 26:10was killed essentially for the fact that he was willing to be courageous and hold his line
- 26:17standing for the truth and for his speech.
- 26:19That woke the world up. And particularly the biggest, here's the interesting
- 26:25thing. It's ironic and it's positive.
- 26:27The biggest demographic by Miles who were woken up by that
- 26:32were young men all across the world. There is a massive, massive turning of
- 26:37the tide of young men, 18 to 25, and
- 26:40I'd stretch that and even say 18 to 30, who are turning away from woke and turning
- 26:46to God and saying, this is broken.
- 26:48This isn't working. We need to go another way.
- 26:51And here in Australia, I think the big wake-up call was the Bondi massacre.
- 26:54100%, yeah. And it's shockingly tragic that those people had to pay that price.
- 26:59But wherever you stand on the political scale, wherever people might stand on
- 27:04pro-Israel or anti-Israel,
- 27:06common sense Australians were woken up by shock when they thought to themselves,
- 27:11how in the world could this happen in our country.
- 27:16Where when we were growing up, you wouldn't have even allowed this thought to cross into your mind.
- 27:20And so, thankfully, and thank God, there is a stirring going on and good people,
- 27:26good men, this is my challenge to men.
- 27:29Thankfully, good men are starting to realize, right, this is not just a phase.
- 27:33This is not going to go away by itself. Yeah.
- 27:36If we don't fight this, if we don't stand up and get a little courageous and
- 27:41find the extra bandwidth, however, wherever, our children are not going to have a world to live in.
- 27:47And that sounds overly fanatical, but it's actually true.
- 27:50And so, I'm in this space with you all the time as well.
- 27:54And my mission, if I can use that language, is I want to
- 27:59be involved in strengthening men, call to their masculine design that is godly,
- 28:05and calling on them to stand up and use their voice in their own family,
- 28:08in their community, because empowering men.
- 28:11The good men, and redeeming broken men from their space and bringing them into
- 28:16a godly good space. That's the only way we win this war.
- 28:19100%. Yeah, and there's often times still that I'm just so heartbroken about
- 28:24losing Charlie's voice in this world, even as you're speaking,
- 28:28just getting teary about it.
- 28:30But I'm also just reminded every time I get down about it that the amount of
- 28:35good that has been, that God has used, like, you know, they meant it for evil,
- 28:39but God has meant it for good.
- 28:40And we see that playing out so much and just how much the gospel was and still is proclaimed.
- 28:46I remember looking at the Google results last year, the most common question
- 28:51was who is Charlie Kirk in Australia?
- 28:53And you just think, wow, like, yeah, we lost his voice and he is such a great
- 28:57man, but he's in heaven with our savior now and he's run his race well and he was faithful to the end.
- 29:03And just what the encouragement that that is to men, but also to women.
- 29:08It's given me such a, I guess, a fire to continue and to run the race well to.
- 29:13Fight the good fight while we're here, because we're only here for a certain
- 29:16amount of time. That's right.
- 29:18Yeah. And I think one of the things that Charlie was so vocal about was the,
- 29:23universities and how unnecessary they are becoming in our culture now because of how woke they are.
- 29:30And I know you've talked about this as well, about how academia is constantly
- 29:34coming out with studies that men are the issue for everything in life.
- 29:39Why do you think that is? Well, again, we come back to this same thing.
- 29:43There is a hate-filled agenda that drives that.
- 29:47The fact of the matter is we have seen over the last five to seven years particularly,
- 29:51but even longer than that, we have seen the mass feminization of our institutions and.
- 29:57And I'm not for a moment suggesting that women shouldn't have roles. They should have roles.
- 30:01And there's many women who are extremely capable of holding leadership positions.
- 30:06However, what we haven't really unpacked properly in our world is the motive
- 30:11behind position pursuit.
- 30:13When women pursue positions because they believe on merit, they are the best
- 30:17person for the job, my view would be have at it, chase after it with all your heart.
- 30:22But what cannot be avoided is that there are many people
- 30:26in politics, in education, even in places like sport and even in religion,
- 30:31where there has been a pursuit of position because there are people who are
- 30:35cunning enough to realize that if they hold the power
- 30:38and hold the position, they get to control the narrative.
- 30:42And broken, unhealed, unwhole people cannot be trusted in positions of power.
- 30:48Now, that's men and women.
- 30:50That's every pillar of society, religion, education, sport, business,
- 30:55politics, arts and entertainment, literature. Every pillar cannot be trusted
- 31:00to people who are broken and have premeditated revenge agendas.
- 31:04And so, we have seen almost frightening acceleration of the feminization of our institutions and.
- 31:14We have removed a lot of the merit-based approach And we saw it happening years
- 31:19ago with the pursuit of quotas, one of the most dangerous and destructive things
- 31:22we've seen happen in politics and business and all kinds of other places.
- 31:26And here's the problem, in my opinion. It's a reaction to...
- 31:30To both the good and the bad in the masculine world.
- 31:34Have there been men who were misogynistic and sexist and held women out of places
- 31:40that they rightly deserve? 100% they have.
- 31:44But our response to that ought not to be, right, men are bad,
- 31:49full stop. Let's kick them out. No.
- 31:52The answer is realize where does bad come from and how do we turn the tide to increase the good?
- 31:58You don't improve performance in positions by removing a merit-based approach.
- 32:03You improve it by empowering all individuals.
- 32:06And so, we've still got this thing going on where there is an agenda that I
- 32:12believe is the unhealed, unresolved reaction to hurt and damage.
- 32:20And I would even say, Heather, this is an important part of the whole conversation
- 32:25where churches and pastors and leaders have got a huge, vital role to play.
- 32:30And we don't win this by ignoring the realities of feminist women.
- 32:36We actually need to be big enough and wise enough and mature enough to acknowledge
- 32:42there is a degree of damage.
- 32:44There is a degree of hurt. There is a degree of abuse. And we need men who will
- 32:50say things like what I'm about to say, which is we are compassionate and empathetic
- 32:56towards that pain because we are.
- 32:59I mean, I'm a dad. I've got a 19-year-old daughter. I'm ready to be protective
- 33:03and defensive over that girl with all my life, literally, if someone mistreats her.
- 33:09And the same expression that comes out of my manhood when I describe that is
- 33:13the same empathy I have for
- 33:15any and all women who've experienced neglect, abuse, abandonment,
- 33:20damage at the hands of a broken man or broken men.
- 33:25But the way we fix the byproduct of that in our world is not by eradicating
- 33:31men and giving the world to women to run.
- 33:35That would be one of the worst overreactions we could try to correct.
- 33:39The answer is, there is a healer in heaven whose name is God.
- 33:44Turn to him for the rebuilding and the making whole of your soul.
- 33:50And then we speak with louder and further reaching voices to,
- 33:54the already good men who are doing their best, and especially to our young men,
- 33:59to call them away from patterns and principles that will only destroy them and
- 34:04have them become destroyers of others.
- 34:07We call to the God design in their young masculinity
- 34:11to bring them onto the correct path, the narrow path, to choose the kind of
- 34:15life where they become a good husband, a good father, a good employer,
- 34:20employer, a good contributor to society.
- 34:22And so I think a huge part of what we've got to be doing in our conversations,
- 34:26as I said, is we've got to acknowledge there is hurt, there is damage.
- 34:31We've got to be clear about where it came from and where it did not come from.
- 34:35And most of all, we've got to be clear in our response plan.
- 34:39A defunct and deficient response plan would be kick masculinity out of the world
- 34:45and let the Women run the joint.
- 34:47No, let the women have the space they need for healing and wholeness when they
- 34:51actually have been damaged and do everything we can from our young boys right.
- 34:57Through to our senior men to call to the inner design of their God-created masculinity
- 35:03to bring them into the place they should live in.
- 35:05That's how we win this thing. Yeah, that's really helpful and just helpful to
- 35:09see that the women coming into these institutions and pushing for the leadership
- 35:15roles because they're reacting to what's happened to them,
- 35:18it's coming from a broken place. Yes.
- 35:21And so anyone in that position is not going to be in a good headspace.
- 35:25Correct. Man as well. Yeah.
- 35:28So that's a really helpful thing to point out there.
- 35:32And definitely, I remember chatting to a girl on the street about feminism,
- 35:37trying to engage with different people.
- 35:39And she looked, she must have been in her early, late 20s-ish,
- 35:43and she was looking generally surprised when I said there are good men out there.
- 35:47I could tell there had been some deep hurt and something in her heart,
- 35:51and it was heartbreaking to see.
- 35:53But like you're saying, the solution is not to just throw out men altogether,
- 35:58but to actually provide space for that healing.
- 36:02And as you say, the only solution for this is coming to our creator who knows
- 36:08us and designed us and loves us and coming to him both for healing and for repentance
- 36:15against our own sin against him.
- 36:16So, yeah, thank you for that. Yeah, absolutely.
- 36:20I really think that the approach that we need more and more of, which in its language is,
- 36:26probably difficult for some people to digest when I say what the world needs
- 36:31right now is the true heart of a father.
- 36:34Which comes from God the Father, because a true heart of a father actually can
- 36:39approach both sides of this conversation with the right response.
- 36:43So, as I said before, I am a father, I have two children.
- 36:47And when I think about this conversation in our world, My first responses are
- 36:51to the men who have inflicted or are inflicting damage, my response is not do away with them.
- 36:58My response is discover those who are willing to go on a journey of change because
- 37:04they have a backstory to their pain and their brokenness as well.
- 37:08And I would almost guarantee that most of them, that the worst offenders have
- 37:12got fatherlessness in their own history.
- 37:14We attend to their healing needs, to those men who are not yet willing to go
- 37:19on a journey of change, well, they are going to have to walk a road of paying for their crimes.
- 37:24There's no other way. There has to be justice served for how they've behaved, right?
- 37:30But the heart of a father is redemptive. The heart of a father says.
- 37:33How did this once innocent young boy turn into such a horrible monster of a man.
- 37:40I need to know the moments in his life where probably he was wronged and let
- 37:47down or abandoned or abused or mistreated.
- 37:51Because until we heal that in his soul, he will not have what it takes to become
- 37:55the good man he was designed to be. And so, a father's heart is redemptive.
- 38:00But again, on the female side, particularly towards the feminist agenda.
- 38:04It's not satisfactory for men to be utterly dismissive of that and just brand
- 38:09it as a nothing that must be eradicated either.
- 38:12A redemptive heart of a father says, no, hang on a minute.
- 38:15These women got here somehow. None of these women sat in a kindergarten classroom
- 38:20as a five-year-old one day and said, when I grow up, I want to be an angry feminist.
- 38:23There was a journey here.
- 38:25There were moments, there were this story in this lady's life of how she concluded that
- 38:31this was the best way to express her journey. And if we're not empathetic towards
- 38:35that, we make no space for her healing either.
- 38:37And so the central idea here is God is not just a good father,
- 38:42he is the perfect father, which many people sadly, as we know,
- 38:46have not experienced or know anything about.
- 38:49But when men take their cue in the world from the ultimate father and make the
- 38:54choice that they are going to be.
- 38:57The benefactor of others by also possessing that father's heart,
- 39:01we can see the broken and the wounded on the male and the female side of this
- 39:06equation becoming healed and whole and returning to their original design.
- 39:12And then the entire tide of how we actually connect in this world can be shifted and turned.
- 39:17But it starts one man at a time, one woman at a time, turning to God for their
- 39:22needs and their healing, and then a deep, deep commitment in the soul to live
- 39:26according to his ordinance. Yep.
- 39:29And I think it's helpful to distinguish there that in the whole feminist agenda,
- 39:34that there are those women who are coming from a broken perspective. 100%.
- 39:39But also, there are women who are coming from just an angry,
- 39:44sinful rebellion against God.
- 39:46I mean, We all have rebelled against God and we all constantly do.
- 39:50And that is our natural inclination, but for the grace of God saving us out of that.
- 39:55And, you know, coming back to the fall, that's the curse that we have to suffer
- 40:00as women alongside pain and childbirth. It's to that natural rebellion against
- 40:04our husband or to rule over men. Yes.
- 40:07And that's what we've seen play out since, you know, the last 60 to 100 years.
- 40:11And the result has been just utter destruction. Catastrophic.
- 40:15Yeah. And as we've talked about, the result for a lot of men is for them to
- 40:20become reclusive, to not lead and to just put their hands up in submission almost to that.
- 40:27So, in trying to combat that and turning this around, what encouragement and
- 40:32practical advice can you give to women to try and encourage that faithful leadership
- 40:36to the men around them, whether it be their husbands or their colleagues or
- 40:40friends? What can women do?
- 40:41Yeah, great question. I love that question. There's a lot of things that the women can do, actually.
- 40:48Not all women, young or old or middle-aged, not all women actually understand
- 40:53how powerful their voice already is.
- 40:57Even those who are clamoring to acquire a powerful voice, they need to understand
- 41:03they've already got one.
- 41:04And so the first thing that a woman can do is to speak well to their husband,
- 41:08speak well to their sons, speak well,
- 41:12and find specific, customized language
- 41:17to say, to those men in your life, especially if ladies, if you're surrounded
- 41:21by men who are trying their hardest to be good men, especially to those men,
- 41:26find ways to say to them, you are a good man. We need more of you.
- 41:31To hear that language for every man, and I'll put myself in the same category,
- 41:36for every man to hear that language from the people that he cares about and
- 41:41wants to protect the most is just about all the petrol in his tank he needs.
- 41:46If you tell a good man that you appreciate him, that you see what he does,
- 41:50and now again, depending on our posture, there could be women listening to this
- 41:54going, well, who's going to tell the women they're doing a good job?
- 41:56It's like, hang on a moment. Slow it down. Cool your jets. We will come to the
- 42:01ladies in due course as well, but just in this moment, we're talking about the men.
- 42:06Just cool your jets for a minute, ladies. To those men, if you say to him,
- 42:11you're doing well, I appreciate your sacrifice. Don't give up.
- 42:15Don't quit. we need you, that puts so much fuel in the soul of a man because
- 42:22he realizes what I do is seen. I don't need a whole lot more.
- 42:27Thank you to most men is like a cherry on the cake, to be seen and acknowledged.
- 42:31So, that would be the first thing.
- 42:32The second thing, which is probably a little more layered and a far more difficult
- 42:37task, the ladies in our world who do believe in the importance of having good,
- 42:42strong, masculine men, we need you.
- 42:46To be active in playing the biblical role of mentoring and training our young women.
- 42:52Now, here's a word to the middle-aged and older women who are biblically responsible
- 42:57for helping to raise our younger women.
- 42:59Eradicate all angry feminism from your,
- 43:03posture and your language and your preparation of them into the world.
- 43:07For example, to our young women, they have been told, generally speaking by
- 43:13other feminists and particularly mainstream media they have been told and they
- 43:18have been trained that every single male that they pass
- 43:23at every moment of every day when they look at her he's undressing her with
- 43:27his eyes and he wants to take sexual advantage of her
- 43:30now if that were true which it's not but if that were true and if you believed
- 43:35that wouldn't you go out the house paranoid every second of the day?
- 43:39Of course you would. And wouldn't you be angry and upset about that,
- 43:43that you live in this world that is constructed by men that just want to take
- 43:47advantage of you left, right and center? Well, like I said earlier,
- 43:50are there men who are doing that? Yes, but not all.
- 43:54Ladies, you've got to speak to the young women and say, listen,
- 43:57there are good men out there.
- 43:59There are fatherly men out there. There are men who want to be protective big brothers.
- 44:04They are not all evil. We have to help our young women jettison this narrative.
- 44:11All men are predators. It's so far from the truth and horrendously destructive.
- 44:17And we're seeing it play out in the lives of young adults right now,
- 44:20particularly non-Christian young adults, but even the Christian young adults are confused.
- 44:26They have returned to the old school battle of the sexes where their entire
- 44:31perspective has become transactional.
- 44:34I'll give you a little bit of what you want from me, but here is the list of
- 44:39the things I want from you.
- 44:41It's so anti-biblical. Any wonder our young people don't know how to find a
- 44:45partner and get married and raise a family because they're only viewing the
- 44:49other participant based on what needs and check boxes they can tick.
- 44:54And that's the only evaluation. When actually, again, all the way back to Ephesians
- 44:585, like we talked about before, the only successful relationships between men
- 45:02and women have to be symbiotic.
- 45:05What do I bring to you is my responsibility. What you bring to me is your responsibility.
- 45:10But we see our young adults being raised in a world where it's so transactional
- 45:15and the question they have is, what can I get from you and what am I willing to let go in return?
- 45:22Any wonder we're failing at relationships at that level. And they would be the
- 45:26two big things I'd say for how can women help these men. Number one,
- 45:30choose your words wisely.
- 45:32Speak him up. Even if he's not a great man yet, find some things and speak him up. He needs it.
- 45:37And secondly, to our young women, be very, very careful that we're not training
- 45:42them the same way the secular mainstream media world is training them,
- 45:46that all men are evil, all men are predators.
- 45:49If you train a girl that, she's never going to find a good one. Yeah. Thanks for that.
- 45:54I think that's really helpful and helpful to see that, you know,
- 45:57it's been through the use of words and damaging words that have torn down men
- 46:02and torn down our society. And it's that same voice that we can use to build
- 46:06it up again and to build up men.
- 46:08So, yeah, thank you for that insight. And thank you for coming on the podcast
- 46:11and having a chat about this. This has been really helpful.
- 46:14Yeah, really great to just talk about these issues. Yeah, my pleasure.