Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says I Need to Check With My Manager
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, we've hit episode one fifty of Manager Mondays. And I was thinking about the patterns we've covered—the 'it's not my job' crowd, the perpetual procrastinators, the perfectionists. But there's one archetype we haven't really touched. Luna: Which one is that? The employee who just can't make a move without checking with you first? Lucas: Exactly. The 'let me check with my manager' employee. Except you are the manager. And they're still asking you. I had a conversation last week with a client, a team lead at a mid-sized SaaS company, and she was pulling her hair out over this customer support rep. The rep had a clear policy: refunds up to fifty dollars, she could approve those on her own. Anything above that, escalate. But every single refund request, even the five-dollar ones, this rep would email her: 'Should I approve this?' Luna: That is exhausting. And it's not just inefficient—it's like a slow leak of your own time as a manager. Lucas: Right. And the thing is, the rep was competent. She knew the policy. She just wouldn't trust her own judgment. So we had to figure out why, and then how to break the habit. Luna: So what did you find? Was it a confidence issue or something else? Lucas: It was a mix. First, her previous manager had been a micromanager who would publicly chew her out if she made a call he didn't like. So she learned that the safest move was to defer. Second, the current manager, my client, had never made the decision rights explicit. She assumed the policy doc was enough, but the rep had internalized 'when in doubt, ask.' And third—this is sneaky—the rep had discovered that asking was less work than deciding. Luna: Less work? How so? Lucas: Because if she decided and got it wrong, she'd own it. If she asked, the manager owned it. So she shifted the risk upward. It's a form of learned helplessness, except it's strategic. She's not helpless—she's just figured out that compliance is safer than judgment. Luna: That makes total sense. So how do you break that cycle? You can't just say 'stop asking me'—that would probably make her feel more anxious. Lucas: Exactly. So we designed a three-step approach. Step one: make decision rights explicit in writing, not just in a policy doc, but in a one-on-one conversation. My client sat down with the rep and listed the exact situations where the rep had full authority—'refunds up to fifty dollars, exchanges for a different plan, extending a trial by three days.' And then they talked through examples until the rep could repeat them back. Luna: So basically a mini training on what she's allowed to decide. Makes sense. Lucas: Step two is the part most managers skip: role-play low-stakes scenarios. Not in a formal workshop, but in the weekly one-on-one. My client would say, 'Okay, a customer is angry because their invoice doubled. What do you do?' And the rep would start to say 'I'll check with you,' and my client would gently push: 'No, you have the authority here. What would you do if you had to decide right now?' Luna: That's like building a muscle. You have to practice using it before you can lift heavy weights. Lucas: Exactly. And step three is the crucial piece: after the rep makes a decision, you do a post-decision review. Not to second-guess, but to acknowledge the judgment. So when the rep approved a forty-dollar refund on her own, my client would say, 'Great call. Tell me why you went that route.' And then she'd reinforce it: 'That's exactly the kind of judgment I want to see.' Over time, the rep started to trust that her manager would have her back, not just in words but in behavior. Luna: I love that. And it's so easy to fall into the trap of only praising outcomes, not the decision process. If the outcome happens to be bad, you still want to praise the judgment if it was sound. Lucas: Yes. And that's a key distinction. You're rewarding the act of deciding, not just the result. Which brings me to something I've been thinking about as we hit this milestone. We've done a hundred and fifty episodes of this show, and the through-line is really about treating people like adults, not machines that need constant supervision. Luna: And that's exactly why we keep this show ad-free. We don't want to sell you anything or push some sponsor's agenda. We just want to have honest conversations about management. If those conversations have helped you, and you'd like to support that, you can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that keeps us independent. Lucas: Yeah, and it genuinely helps. A lot of listeners have written in saying they've tried these tactics with their teams, and that's the best feedback we could get. So if you've gotten value out of a hundred and fifty episodes, consider it. And now, back to the rep. After three weeks of this, she was making about eighty percent of her decisions on her own. The other twenty percent, she'd group her questions and bring them to the weekly meeting instead of emailing every time. Luna: That's a huge shift. So what was the turning point for her? Lucas: I think it was when she realized that her manager trusted her, and that she would be evaluated on her judgment, not on being right all the time. Once she made a decision that didn't go perfectly—she approved a refund that turned out to be a fraudulent claim—and her manager handled it constructively, not punitively. They reviewed what happened, what signals she might look for next time, and moved on. Luna: That's the moment trust becomes real. It's easy to say 'I trust you' when things go well, but it's when you don't get blamed for a mistake that you actually believe it. Lucas: And that's the deeper lesson for any manager listening. If you have an employee who keeps checking with you, look at what happens when they do make a call and it goes sideways. Do you react with blame or with coaching? That's the real signal you're sending. Luna: Also, I want to add a small tip: praise the decision, not just the outcome. You said that earlier, but it's worth repeating because it's so counterintuitive. We're wired to celebrate results, but if you only celebrate good outcomes, you're teaching your team to avoid risk. Instead, celebrate the act of making a call, even if it doesn't pan out perfectly. Lucas: Yeah, and that's how you build judgment. Judgment isn't about being right every time—it's about making good decisions with the information you have, and then learning. So if you're a manager, and you have this 'let me check' employee, try the three steps. But also ask yourself: have I created an environment where it's safe to decide? Luna: And if you haven't, that's on you, not on them. That's a hard truth, but it's the one that'll make you a better leader. Lucas: So to recap: write down exactly what they can decide, practice it with them in low-stakes scenarios, and then review their decisions in a way that reinforces judgment over compliance. And do it consistently for a few weeks. It's not a one-and-done conversation. Luna: And for the employee, I'd say: if you're the one always asking, try to catch yourself. Before you hit send on that 'should I?' email, ask yourself, 'Do I have the authority? Do I have the information? What would I do if I had to decide?' If you can answer those, make the call. Your manager will respect you more for it. Lucas: That's a great note to end on. Thanks for listening, and here's to the next hundred and fifty episodes. We'll be back next Monday with another real management challenge.