Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Main Signs of an Attachment Disturbance
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:27This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:29It's Thursday, November 7th, 2024 at 7:36 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:36Time. And I thought that what I would
- 0:39talk about tonight is how do you know it's an attachment
- 0:45disturbance and not something else that's causing havoc in
- 0:49your life? And one of the things that
- 0:55begins to come up when you think about it in that way is the the
- 0:59patterns that tend to repeat. I think one of the interesting
- 1:03things about attachment conditioning is that the
- 1:09patterns are so stark in comparison to things that are
- 1:13different than that. I like to say it isn't actually
- 1:18rocket science. It's attachment theory and what
- 1:22we see, and this is thanks to Mary Ainsworth, going into the
- 1:27different homes of people that they tested with a strange
- 1:30situation and recording 10s of thousands of hours of
- 1:35interaction between caregiver and child.
- 1:39To begin to see that particular patterns of care that children
- 1:43receive tend to produce different attachment strategies
- 1:48in the way that they operate in relationships.
- 1:51And then that tends to, to lead to patterns in the way that
- 1:57children explore the world. So what you really look for in
- 2:02identifying attachment patterning is the way that
- 2:06people operate in relationships, but also the way in which they
- 2:11explore or don't explore the world.
- 2:14And then that results in actually how people do in the
- 2:18world is one of the ways that we tend to think about it.
- 2:22How functional are you? How, how do you get by in the
- 2:25world? And how is that reflective of
- 2:28this? So in some sense, that's good
- 2:32news. But you could also look at it
- 2:33from the other side, which is that the things that happened to
- 2:37you in in early childhood shape the way that you are.
- 2:41And then they unfold over the course of your lifetime in these
- 2:45very predictable patterns, which I would say is different than
- 2:50the luck of the experiences of your life as they unfold.
- 2:59You might say, how lucky are you when you when you're four or
- 3:03five years old and you show up on the playground?
- 3:09Is the way that you are and the way that you see the world and
- 3:12the way that you operate something that finds an audience
- 3:16that's appreciative of that, who's engaged by it, who
- 3:20includes you in in the social hierarchy that operates even on
- 3:27playgrounds? Or is that not something that
- 3:32that you find happens to you or the circumstances that can
- 3:38change quite a bit depending on the circumstances of the family
- 3:43beyond your control. So we see in the interaction
- 3:53between caregiver and infant the way that the caregiver shows up
- 3:58for the infant, creates in the infant and the young child
- 4:04expectations of how the world will go for them.
- 4:09And those expectations then shape the way that we form a
- 4:14sense of reality. I'm always talking about this in
- 4:20a Buddhist frame of, of how we create the experience of
- 4:24reality. So we have the capacity to sense
- 4:27the object that had to be sensed.
- 4:29When there's contact, the consciousness of the sensing
- 4:32experience arises. So this is undifferentiated,
- 4:37unfixated, unattached in the Buddhist sense of the word
- 4:43attached. What we really are talking about
- 4:46is fixating a meaning on to the sensing experience that you're
- 4:51having, different from what we mean by attachment theory.
- 4:58Once you've collected the data. And we don't do a universal
- 5:03survey of everything that's in front of us and then construct a
- 5:06version of reality that matches that.
- 5:11We take a highly curated selection of the things that
- 5:15already have meaning to us and select them from the environment
- 5:19and put together an experience of the environment that's based
- 5:23on that. So that if you find yourself in
- 5:26an environment that is rich with the things that you find
- 5:30interesting, the things that matter to you, you form a very
- 5:33different perception of what's happening.
- 5:36Then if you find yourself in an environment where very few of
- 5:40the things that you have already assigned meaning to and value to
- 5:45our present for you to select from, is that making sense?
- 5:53Once you've gathered that collection of mind moments you
- 5:59evaluated for urgency. And this is really a low level
- 6:02brain function, like the brain, some in the nervous system
- 6:06evaluating whether something needs urgent attention or not
- 6:11doesn't matter whether we ever get to it.
- 6:13And is there time for a pleasant experience.
- 6:17More important, for instance, to evaluate that a Saber toothed
- 6:21tiger is jumping out of a Bush than it is that you can see a
- 6:25rainbow in the distance so that you need to respond to the
- 6:30urgent things and they always jump to the head of the queue.
- 6:34And then, and all of this is unconscious in the sense that
- 6:37it's pre the self witnessing experience.
- 6:42Then if there's a match in the perceptual database of
- 6:52previously defined sense moments, then that whole thread
- 6:57attaches to the present moment and it rolls from ultimate
- 7:01reality into conceptual reality. And you would inhabit this, a
- 7:05version of what's happening which has been created in the
- 7:09mind. How do you tell the difference
- 7:12between the tableau of conceptual reality and a sensing
- 7:17experience? The easiest, if you're a sighted
- 7:21person, is to look around the room.
- 7:22And if you see everything in sharp detail and focus and that
- 7:27it's a smooth sort of flow of visual imagery, then you're in
- 7:33the mind and not actually in the sensing experience because the
- 7:37eyes doesn't see that that's created in the mind.
- 7:44So having that awareness, this is the sense gathering that I
- 7:48do. This is the meaning that I've
- 7:50assigned to it. Some of these meaning threads
- 7:53are long, some of them are not. If you started a particular
- 8:06thread of meaning in childhood, then that thread of meaning will
- 8:10will extend all the way from childhood into the present
- 8:13moment. And that richness, that
- 8:18variation of that, those, that history of meaning will then
- 8:22inform the way that you experience the present moment.
- 8:27And can you track that that in addition to the experience of
- 8:32the present moment that you've created, is all of the meaning
- 8:37from the past repetitions of this kind of experience, the way
- 8:42that you've classified. And then the self, of course,
- 8:47the self good missing experience has that sense of richness and
- 8:54meaning, which is one of the ways that we we decide what's
- 8:59valuable to us and what isn't valuable to us.
- 9:03But in that creation of reality, we also create an expectation of
- 9:10what's going to happen. And if you don't have good
- 9:14differentiation between the sense of reality, you don't, You
- 9:20may lose track of the idea that what you're anticipating
- 9:24happening is not necessarily what's happening.
- 9:30But if you lose track of that, then you can anticipate what's
- 9:33happening. And the only version of of what
- 9:36happens that you will really accept is the one that you've
- 9:40anticipated, which informs your response to the intention and
- 9:46then the response that you take. You know, certain kinds of
- 9:50attachment conditioning will make you sensitive to the
- 9:53interpretation of anticipating rejection.
- 9:58And once you get into the mind state of anticipating rejection,
- 10:03you'll interpret whatever happens is rejecting.
- 10:07And then your response will be informed by the meaning that
- 10:11you're being rejected. And you will take an action that
- 10:15is in fact informed on that meaning and not what's actually
- 10:18happening. And then the person that you are
- 10:22responding to will be confronted with all of this meaning around
- 10:27you being rejected, which they may have trouble puzzling how
- 10:35that ended up in the exchange that you're just having with
- 10:39them if they're able to interpret it.
- 10:44But if they're not able to interpret it, they'll respond to
- 10:48you as if your version of it is actually what's happening.
- 10:55And you, you'll notice that it's fairly easy to spiral into these
- 10:59arguments that don't make a lot of sense between people, mainly
- 11:04because you've lost track of what's happening and you're just
- 11:06operating from these long threads of meaning come when
- 11:15you're about 10 months old or maybe a year old.
- 11:19You already have a functioning attachment system and that
- 11:25functioning attachment system expresses itself in the way that
- 11:29you interpret what world that you're you're living in.
- 11:36This is long before the self experience, long before the
- 11:40cognitive mind comes online. This is really that underlying
- 11:45procedural piece of meaning where that lands and you drive a
- 11:55car or could you ride a bike? Remember what it was like
- 11:59learning to ride a bike if you if you did or you remember
- 12:05learning to walk, what what was that like?
- 12:11Wasn't cognitive, was it? It was a process of, of partly
- 12:17the instinct of us. And then hopefully that you had
- 12:22a caregiver that was supportive and encouraging you of doing
- 12:27that. Lot of balance issues, a lot of
- 12:32falling down, a lot of moments of seeking reassurance from your
- 12:38caregiver as you as you land in them.
- 12:42The rush of sensation that is in the, the turning to look to the
- 12:47caregiver. And then are they immediately
- 12:49comforting and encouraging you to keep going?
- 12:52Are they alarmed and frightened that you're hurt?
- 12:58And do they then move into interfere with that process?
- 13:03So they frighten you by the way that they respond.
- 13:10That's how we begin to understand ourselves and our
- 13:16capacities and our capabilities. In the beginning, of course, the
- 13:35entire perception of the world, the entire perception of who we
- 13:42are in the world, the entire perception of our capacities are
- 13:47all coming from that reflection of the caregiver.
- 13:52And so we learn from them in a way the orientation to the world
- 13:58that they have, and there's no real contrast to understand it
- 14:05in a different way. And we learn who we are and that
- 14:09their expression of the experience of us.
- 14:16So if you luck out, that is to say you have a caregiver who's
- 14:21sensitively attuned you, delights in you, who, who is
- 14:26able to interpret and respond to your needs 30% of the time or
- 14:31more. That core sense of self that
- 14:35develops is one of somebody who's confident and capable of
- 14:41getting their needs, but who's capable of engaging in the world
- 14:46and and getting a positive response.
- 14:48Who's the light just in your beingness?
- 14:54This is the origin of that attachment condition.
- 14:59So we begin to examine the way that we meet the experience of
- 15:04other people, the way that we meet the experience of the
- 15:07world. In Buddhism, of course, the
- 15:10world is other people. So if you look at the
- 15:14descriptions in the refrain of the Sati Pattana Sutra, which is
- 15:19the the main instruction for meditation and Theravada
- 15:23Buddhism, 17 times in the refrain, it's repeated
- 15:27mindfulness of inside, mindfulness of outside,
- 15:30mindfulness of inside and outside.
- 15:33So an awareness of your own experience, an awareness of
- 15:39somebody else's separate and what their experience is, and
- 15:43then an awareness of the of the interactivity of your beingness
- 15:51in somebody else's being is this is basic, the basic mentalizing
- 15:57frame. Can you recognize yourself?
- 16:00Can you recognize the other person?
- 16:02Can you track the effect that the other person has on you?
- 16:10That all making sense in a bit. So George, the affect that you
- 16:19see in others or me picking other people's affect is through
- 16:27my own conditioning. Right.
- 16:30But if I know now knowingly that that I have an attachment
- 16:34disturbance, isn't that affect wrong in the sense that you know
- 16:39that what you're seeing is not right because of the
- 16:44conditioning that happened? That's certainly the beginning
- 16:48of it. So you recognize that you have
- 16:51an attachment conditioning and then you begin to mentalize when
- 16:54it's present and when it isn't present.
- 16:58And when it is present, it has a lot of effects on your ability
- 17:02to discern things. And when it isn't present, that
- 17:06tends to open up a whole capacity of mentalizing that is
- 17:11not available When when the attachment system is active.
- 17:16So you might say when the attachment system is active, it
- 17:19is causing you to pursue contact for safety and reassurance.
- 17:27And when the exploration system is active, that opens up that
- 17:32whole skill set to explore things.
- 17:35So you might also say that the cognitive mind is available when
- 17:39the exploration system is up and the IT is not available when the
- 17:45attachment system is up. Is that making sense?
- 17:51So then as you begin to track this, what you realize is that
- 17:55you have these assets and deficits in terms of your
- 17:58capacity to mentalize. And so as you begin to recognize
- 18:05that your particular attachment system activates.
- 18:09But what you also notice is that your capacities for mentalizing
- 18:16will be impaired or not impaired, but they're also not a
- 18:20complete set if you're not in the secure range of attachment.
- 18:24And So what we understand from that is that to come out of
- 18:29that, we then need to undertake training of the the deficits in
- 18:37our mentalizing capacity and to reframe the a mentalizing
- 18:42capacities that we have so that they're more in balance with the
- 18:48the wider perspective of them that making sense.
- 18:52We're too general. So, so you're technically when
- 18:57the attachment system is off, you're saying you're in the
- 19:00Green Zone, you don't have to worry about.
- 19:03But I was going to argue that the the belief systems are still
- 19:07there and how you see others that.
- 19:10Yes, that's what I'm saying. So it isn't enough to know that
- 19:14what you then have to undertake is the training of the
- 19:17mentalizing skills that you don't have developed
- 19:20sufficiently that you can create a different understanding of
- 19:24what's happening. So for instance, the the
- 19:36capacity of if we look at the the that Fonicky Bateman frame
- 19:42of early mentalizing capacities, spontaneity versus monitoring,
- 19:47self versus other, internal versus external and cognitive
- 19:51versus effective in the dismissing pattern very over
- 19:56monitoring. It's not just monitoring, it's
- 19:59over monitoring, and the over monitoring is what interferes
- 20:03with the spontaneity experience. In order to come out of the that
- 20:12imbalance, you have to stop over monitoring and you have to allow
- 20:17the spontaneity. The other aspect of that
- 20:22dismissing pattern is very self oriented and not particularly
- 20:26other oriented. In order to become other
- 20:30oriented you have to become empathetic.
- 20:32One of the things that dismissing people do is suppress
- 20:36awareness of their emotional experience, which is at the same
- 20:40time suppressing their empathetic experience.
- 20:43Which means in order to turn the empathy back on, you have to
- 20:47turn on a conscious awareness of your emotional experience moment
- 20:52by moment. And that then opens up the
- 20:56pathway where you can actually gather information about other
- 21:00people that would be meaningful for you to then see them as
- 21:04distinct from yourself, because your capacity for self is over
- 21:09developed. And it encompasses everything
- 21:14that making sense. So it's it's always a process of
- 21:18developing the skills that you don't have and and relaxing the
- 21:23skills that are over developed so that you can come more into a
- 21:27balance. Really what we want to do is
- 21:31coming to this place where we see ourselves clearly, we see
- 21:35the other clearly, and we can track the effect that we have on
- 21:39each other without it tipping us into a place where our cognitive
- 21:44mind goes offline and we're simply back into the habitual
- 21:50responses of the procedural mind.
- 21:55But in order for that process to become automatic and for our
- 21:59responses to be spontaneous and in a more secure range, we then
- 22:05have to also attend to the perceptual database and begin to
- 22:11layer in alternatives. So that when the the body mind
- 22:17moves from the undifferentiated, unfixated, unattached, pure
- 22:23sensing experience and assigns meaning to it, there's
- 22:27alternatives in the, the way that we represent experience so
- 22:34that we can form a different kind of reality than the one
- 22:38that we're habitually charged with creating.
- 22:45You know, you go to the database over and over again and pull
- 22:49the, the experiences that you have to define the, the
- 22:52experience of the present moment.
- 22:54So the present moment plus the whole past is attaching to it,
- 22:58which is why we over and over again form the same meaning
- 23:03experience in the present moment.
- 23:06And it isn't enough cognitively to understand this.
- 23:10And then after you've formed reality, and often after you've
- 23:13taken the action, recognize it and then attempt to repair it
- 23:19because there's a limit to the number of times people will
- 23:23allow something to be repaired. It's hard to you give up hope
- 23:29after a while, but that it can be an environment that would be
- 23:35meaningful, yeah. So I was going to ask, so the
- 23:42the boundary when the cognitive system goes down, I mean, I feel
- 23:47that even the procedural has some form of cognition, but is
- 23:51it like just saying it has a sense of just fight, flight or
- 23:55freeze kind of? No, it it.
- 23:58It totally assigns meaning, but what it probably doesn't have is
- 24:02a capacity to evaluate the accuracy of the meaning that
- 24:06it's a sign is. There an example.
- 24:14The example the Buddha gave was that the the farmer went into
- 24:17the Hut, it was at dusk and he saw in the corner a snake ready
- 24:22to strike, and he chopped it up with his machete.
- 24:26And then he lit a candle and he realized that it was actually a
- 24:29coil of rope that he chopped up in the moment.
- 24:36There was no reflection of, oh, is this really a snake?
- 24:40This, this might be a coil of rope.
- 24:43Because the fearfulness of the, of the experience of a snake
- 24:49shut down that whole process. And it was just the immediate
- 24:52response that comes from the perceptual database.
- 24:58So it is true to say that fear will almost all majority of the
- 25:03times will be there. Any intense emotional experience
- 25:08that exceeds the window of tolerance can cause the
- 25:11cognitive mind to collapse, and it can be really fast.
- 25:17And then you're just responding from the perceptual database,
- 25:21that procedural memory response. Then the body mind catches it.
- 25:32the IT takes about 3/8 of a second to respond to something
- 25:36that's urgent, and it takes a half a second to form a
- 25:40conscious experience of that. So there's a little lag time.
- 25:45Shinzen used to say it takes 3/8 of a second for the terrorists
- 25:51to take over the body before you're actually compelled into
- 25:55action. And what that self experience
- 25:58is, of course, is, is this a good idea that we're just about
- 26:02to completely implement or can we stop it?
- 26:06You ever started a sentence and stopped it when you recognized
- 26:10that if you actually completed the sentence, it would be a
- 26:13social disaster? So you know, the whole beingness
- 26:22of you, the whole muditness of you is operating.
- 26:27It's not the self experience, right?
- 26:30That's that's the audience that's also got the veto button
- 26:34to stop boneheaded ideas from actually being manifested as
- 26:39actions and creating of karmic threads.
- 26:45But what you'll notice when you actually begin to address the
- 26:50the procedural memory that that perceptual memory is that you
- 26:58don't need the self experience to over and over prevent you
- 27:02from doing something. You just don't do them anymore
- 27:05because you change the the meaning.
- 27:10The meaning engine you will the way that you define things so
- 27:16that you don't perceive the experience of the other person
- 27:21as expressed as rejecting. You experience it with curiosity
- 27:25and interest. It doesn't feel threatening.
- 27:29It doesn't activate the attachment system any longer.
- 27:34You have a sense of security in in attachment.
- 27:38You have a sense of confidence in yourself that is different
- 27:44than what the original conditioning provided you.
- 27:49And it happens automatically in the, in the creation of reality,
- 27:53which the self experience then recognizes.
- 27:58But the the experience of the self is, is very similar to what
- 28:02it's always been, is this thing that watches what happens.
- 28:06It's just what's happening is different without any conscious
- 28:10explanation or conscious decision of making it different.
- 28:15Is that making sense? No.
- 28:19I. Was going to ask the
- 28:22spontaneous, you know, imagine you being completely spontaneous
- 28:27in that sense that that aspect also tends to go away if you're
- 28:32fully in something positive, let's say.
- 28:37Well. How do I know what I, my friend
- 28:44Jimmy used to say? How do I know what I think until
- 28:46I hear what I say? That's totally spontaneous,
- 28:50right? When you really get going in a
- 28:53conversation with somebody else, you actually can be in a
- 28:56position of hearing what you're saying at the same time they're
- 29:01hearing it because the witnessing function in both
- 29:04people is 1/2 a second behind. Can you feel safe enough and
- 29:08confident enough and lively enough that you can just be
- 29:12expressive, but at the same time monitoring so that if it doesn't
- 29:16land in the way that you thought it would land to the with the
- 29:19other person, you can immediately inquire as to why it
- 29:23didn't land the way that you thought it would?
- 29:26How did they hear it rather than the way that you expressed it?
- 29:31Or maybe they do understand what you mean and they're reacting
- 29:35differently than you thought they might.
- 29:37All of those things can come when the balance of spontaneity
- 29:43and monitor. So you're completely spontaneous
- 29:46in your expressions with that mentalizing frame that you're
- 29:50intending to be commutative of something that you want to
- 29:54communicate. And then you track whether or
- 29:57not they've understood you. And then you track their
- 30:00response to the communication and modify your understanding of
- 30:05the relationship between you, which is that that intimate
- 30:09exchange. All of that happens pretty
- 30:13quick. And so you have to be able to
- 30:16mentalize pretty quick in order to be able to to pick up on it.
- 30:21And if you can't, then you have to begin to develop those
- 30:27skills. So for instance, if you were on
- 30:29the over monitoring side, everything would have to be run
- 30:32through self before you expressed it, which would mean
- 30:36everything would have to be delayed by 1/2 a second.
- 30:40Which would mean that somebody who was listening to you would
- 30:44notice the lag time over and over again in in your
- 30:49communication to them. And it would seem to lack
- 30:53spontaneity and often can see can seem rehearsed or prepared.
- 31:01But your experience, of course, is it's happening immediately
- 31:08that making sense so that if you're particularly if you're
- 31:14you've been in the habit of always rehearsing you, you have
- 31:21in some sense the illusion within yourself that nobody can
- 31:26tell that that's what's actually happening.
- 31:28But people are used to spontaneous conversations are
- 31:33constantly experiencing a lag in in your response.
- 31:38That makes sense, Christian. This is a weird question, but do
- 31:44you you wouldn't say that the goal for someone that's coming
- 31:48from an avoidance strategy would be to completely do away with
- 31:52rehearsing? Like, do you think that there's
- 31:53still kind of A use for it in conversation?
- 31:59In a moment of intimacy where you feel safe and secure and the
- 32:05conversation is rolling. Yeah.
- 32:07There's no real place for rehearsing in a fraught and
- 32:13difficult conversation with somebody where you have to be
- 32:16extremely sensitive and you have to really make sure that you're
- 32:22expressing what you mean in a way that they they can
- 32:24understand it. And it would make sense to to
- 32:29review the languaging of it, but it would also make sense to say,
- 32:35give me a minute or I need to really think about what I want
- 32:38to say so that I I'm communicating effectively rather
- 32:44than something that might be received as manipulative.
- 32:50So it's still an authentic expression even though it's not
- 32:54spontaneous. Kind of empathetic.
- 33:03It's kind of compassionate because you're not saying what
- 33:05do you sometimes want to say and which might hurt the other
- 33:07person. Right.
- 33:09But that, that in, in some sense, when you talk about the,
- 33:13the way to relate in a, in a compassionate way, you
- 33:18understand what experience you've made.
- 33:21You also understand it's the experience you've made and it's
- 33:24not a universal experience. And everybody has a different
- 33:26point of view. This is your point of view.
- 33:29What about your point of view do you want to express and then you
- 33:34move into the second pieces. How do I express it so that the
- 33:38other person will understand what I mean?
- 33:43And that means flipping it into their terms, not insisting that
- 33:50they understand your terms and be sure that they will.
- 33:56The more you know somebody, the more you understand their terms.
- 33:59In some sense, that's one of the the ways that relationships
- 34:03really become solid. I'll give you an example of
- 34:09this. One Thanksgiving, we were
- 34:12playing charades. And my, my friend Jimmy and
- 34:16Vincent have been together for since College in the early 60s.
- 34:21It's a long time. You do not want to play charades
- 34:24against them. Because Jimmy would walk up
- 34:28there and strike a pose and Vincent would give the answer.
- 34:31They were almost not even reading the question.
- 34:33The, the, the, the, the, the vocabulary of each other that
- 34:39they each have. Or they would give two or three
- 34:43words and the other person would know the answer.
- 34:46You know what I mean? So that they really know each
- 34:51other. They know each other for decades
- 34:52so that they have this a language for each other.
- 34:56So they know how to say something to to the other person
- 35:00so that it lands. They also know how to say it so
- 35:02it it it's upsetting, if that makes sense.
- 35:06But you probably do too in in different relational experiences
- 35:12era. So actually, the the closer you
- 35:19are with someone, right, like A1, like a dyadic relationship
- 35:23or maybe three people, right, that mean as far as already this
- 35:28is right now, let's add a community.
- 35:32You've entered into a community of people internally.
- 35:36I have the world of view that I'm being, you know, I'm will
- 35:39likely be rejected in some way or and it's already so the
- 35:44pressure of what is going on. I might not be in reality, I
- 35:49could be in reality, It's certainly possible someone could
- 35:52be rejecting me, but who knows? Let me just get out of here and
- 35:59let the whole thing go. So like we're applying these,
- 36:04you know, like with in terms of, of mindfulness in these ideas
- 36:09like, well, we actually need to go into community and we have
- 36:12attachment disturbances. What do we do when there's
- 36:15multiple people that we need to engage with and a lot of people
- 36:18are not actually asking you what's going on?
- 36:21How are you today? So in in the beginning, of
- 36:26course, it's the internal representation of your own
- 36:29experience and to recognize the attachments experience is
- 36:33constantly active under the perception of threat.
- 36:38And can you recognize the view of your attachment strategy as
- 36:42it arises when I don't, you know, attachment disturbances?
- 36:54It is an interesting phraseology because we all developed the
- 37:00attachment strategy that perfectly matches the
- 37:03environment that we grow up in. So if you grow up in a chaotic,
- 37:11insecure environment, you tend to be aware your caregiver is
- 37:15involved and you tend to go preoccupied if you're neglected
- 37:18and there isn't enough care. And it's consistent.
- 37:22You tend to become avoidant or dismissing it as an adult.
- 37:29If there's abuse or some kind of trauma, you tend to go into a
- 37:35disorganized state where we, which is a not only appropriate
- 37:43response, but a very predictable response.
- 37:48You see those kinds of conditions and you would
- 37:50anticipate that a child who grew up in that environment would
- 37:54manifest a particular type of attachment because of it.
- 38:00Where, where it becomes a disturbance is when you move out
- 38:05of that original family system and you attempt to negotiate in
- 38:12the wider world with adults who came out of different systems.
- 38:18And you're really trying to navigate the integration of your
- 38:21attachment strategy with their attachment strategy and how that
- 38:29affects the capacity of the relationship to function.
- 38:33So that if you come out of a childhood as a preoccupied
- 38:37person, and what you'll notice is just in the way that nature
- 38:43selects these things is that the, the person who's able to
- 38:47tolerate the presentation of your attachment system is
- 38:50largely going to be on the dismissing side of things.
- 38:55And the reason for that is because the chaotic internal
- 38:59emotional experience that a preoccupied person has or a
- 39:03secure person is very hard to manage because they're very
- 39:07empathetic. But this missing person is not
- 39:11empathetic. So they're not disturbed by the
- 39:14chaotic internal emotional system so that they don't
- 39:19inhibit the the relationship from forming.
- 39:23And so you begin to notice how these things match.
- 39:28But what you also notice is that organized, insecure attachment
- 39:37relationships tend to be transactional.
- 39:39They don't tend to be intimate. So that you can also find
- 39:43yourself longing for intimate connection where you really feel
- 39:47seen and known and appreciated and understood by someone else,
- 39:52and not be able to get that to happen in a transactional
- 39:56relationship. And so you're constantly in a
- 40:00state of longing for this intimacy that the structure of
- 40:03the relationship prevents from happening.
- 40:07And then people who are in disorganized attachment tend to
- 40:16trauma bond. And So what happens there is
- 40:18that in dissociative states, they slip out of an awareness of
- 40:23the present moment into the mind and they, they slip out of
- 40:28relationship with another person and they, they relate to the
- 40:34person often as an avatar, an abuser in the mind.
- 40:38So they're not actually in relationship with another
- 40:41person. They're in the relationship with
- 40:42the perpetrator in their mind acting out with the other
- 40:48person. And so the reason that we might
- 40:51call that a disturbance is because it is inhibiting the
- 40:57collaborative intimate relationship that security
- 41:01provides for people. And and as a result of that you
- 41:05have these deficits of experience.
- 41:08Is that making sense? And so when you recognize that
- 41:13I'm not an intimate relationship, I'm in a role
- 41:16based transactional relationship, but I long for
- 41:20intimacy, then you begin to explore what it is that that is
- 41:24necessary for me to then be able to do that.
- 41:29And as you undertake doing that work, of course, you hope that
- 41:32if you're already in a relationship with somebody that
- 41:35they might also see the the value of doing that and move
- 41:40toward doing that. But that isn't always the case.
- 41:43A lot of the time, the person that's being cared for in a way
- 41:47that is important to them is content in the relationship.
- 41:52And it's the person who's providing the care that's not
- 41:54receiving a reciprocal care that feels disadvantaged.
- 42:03And then in disorganized relationships, because the
- 42:07relationships are so chaotic and so unreliable, there isn't much
- 42:12sense of support really there. So there's more to do in that,
- 42:23but did that. But those representations are
- 42:26quite distinct from, you know, you're you're in your space suit
- 42:31your your body, and you have the capacities of the body and the
- 42:35talents of the body of the, you know, the things that lead you
- 42:41into your explorations. What has meaning to you?
- 42:45And we can look at the way that attachment conditioning effects
- 42:50that. But then there's also this whole
- 42:53cultural container that we we find ourselves in and how that
- 43:00limits your or, you know, advances your exploration in a
- 43:06way. Where did the resources go out?
- 43:13How much power do you have in in being able to gather them, which
- 43:18is beyond the individual control and into the, the societal
- 43:26control of that. That's a separate thing.
- 43:35Of course. Your attach, your underlying
- 43:38attachment conditioning is going to really inform how you're able
- 43:41to show up for that and and how you're able to navigate that and
- 43:47be effective in that. One of the things about security
- 43:52that's is that exploration really is central in secure
- 44:01functioning, whereas in insecure and disorganized relationships,
- 44:06often the the survival part, the secondary exploration part is so
- 44:10hard to do. There isn't resources left for
- 44:14the primary exploration. It does produce that sense of
- 44:18deficit in in life, but it doesn't matter because the
- 44:22resource collection, it takes so much energy because of the of
- 44:30the the reactivity that often comes with the insecure and
- 44:37disorganized strategy. So you might reflect on that
- 44:41also as a disturbance or difficulty in security.
- 44:47Of course, you set up the secure base that you need to explore
- 44:51from. And then you have the resiliency
- 44:54of this routine daily exploration, this routine
- 44:58pursuit of the things that have meaning.
- 45:00And So what you find is that these these long arcs of
- 45:06exploration, these long arcs of meaning that are very rewarding,
- 45:13but in insecure and disorganized attachment systems, often
- 45:18there's spurts or short periods of exploration.
- 45:23But because the navigation of of the pursuit of just time, energy
- 45:30and resources is harder that long, those long arcs of
- 45:38pursuing meaning don't happen so much, particularly in
- 45:42disorganized people. They don't happen.
- 45:44So that'll make sense. The I think it's it's a a.
- 45:55So what's immediately coming to mind is I was walking down the
- 46:04street and I was no. And I just failed again in a in
- 46:08a in a way that was really displeasing me.
- 46:13I'm trying to go after something that I really wanted and just
- 46:18couldn't manage it. And it dawned on me that
- 46:26actually the failure wasn't a problem for me.
- 46:29I was so used to failing. It happened routinely with
- 46:32everything that I tried. The problem I had is the
- 46:35success. That was what was really
- 46:39frightening to me and that the closer I got to success, the
- 46:43greater the anxiety. And at a certain point I
- 46:46couldn't bear the any anxiety anymore.
- 46:48So I would just fuck things up and that would relieve the
- 46:53anxiety. And I was familiar with the
- 46:57feeling of failure. So it wasn't, it was terrible,
- 47:01but it wasn't life threatening in its intensity.
- 47:06That makes sense. And that was a revelation.
- 47:10But then I I actually was curious about that and, and that
- 47:14really was my first foray into trying to overcome that
- 47:20conditioning. That would have been the early
- 47:2880s. So it's a lot.
- 47:29It's a long and a long walk. Figure that out.
- 47:36It did. So you're why the success and
- 47:39anxiety correlation was it? Well, the explanation that
- 47:44finally cracked it for me was the attachment explanation.
- 47:48But in early childhood, when your caregivers interfere with
- 47:55your, the development of your exploration and it's associated
- 48:00with the withdrawal of affection, So what you begin to
- 48:07associate is that if I succeed, I'll lose the affection and
- 48:11attention of my caregiver. And so in childhood, of course,
- 48:17that's completely catastrophic, even life threatening.
- 48:21But if you have that strong association, as you begin to
- 48:24move toward the things that you want, it creates the anxiety
- 48:28that you'll, you'll make yourself unlovable.
- 48:33And that's unbearable. How is that possible?
- 48:37What? How is that possible?
- 48:39If a kid exploration is Hanford in the middle, what what's
- 48:45happening? Is it the caregiver not that?
- 48:56Let's say you you crawl to the edge of the room and look back
- 49:02and the caregiver is there, and then you crawl out the doorway
- 49:07and then you crawl back in and the caregiver is gone.
- 49:15What do you make? How do you make sense of that?
- 49:21And then what happens, Of course, your attachment system
- 49:23activates and you become panicked and are seeking
- 49:27immediate proximity to a caregiver.
- 49:30But what you learn in that is you can't crawl past the doorway
- 49:34because if you do, you can't rely on whether the caregiver
- 49:37will be there or not. And then another way that it can
- 49:48happen is that you find something really fascinating and
- 49:51you want to pursue it. There's no support in pursuing
- 49:55that, and you're directed to pursue something else.
- 49:58So you pursue something else and you get all of your rewards, the
- 50:01caregivers response, but it doesn't have any meaning to you.
- 50:05But as soon as you turn back to the thing that actually means
- 50:08something to you, they withdraw the support.
- 50:11So that you learn that when you pursue the things that really
- 50:15matter to me matter to you, you risk the loss of interest and
- 50:21affection. Because they're not reacting.
- 50:27Because they've withdrawn from you, your action has caused them
- 50:31to withdraw disorganizing. Physically or just not reacting?
- 50:37Let's say if you make something and I don't react to it.
- 50:41All of the all of the above. No resources, no attention, no
- 50:47interest, condemnation, all of those.
- 50:56Sorry one one question is can can kids pick up on caregivers
- 51:00pretense of positive emotions? Sure they can, Unless in
- 51:14transactional relationships that part doesn't matter so much.
- 51:21So fake excitement. The kid.
- 51:23The kid doesn't know, right? Well, they understand that
- 51:27they're eliciting the excitement by the thing, the thing that
- 51:30they're doing. Oh, not not in their being, but
- 51:37in the thing that they're doing. Right, I do this and you give me
- 51:45the excitement transaction. All right, what do you say we do
- 51:56a little meditation practice after this topic?
- 52:01Let's do loving kindness for self.
- 52:10So go ahead and take your meditation posture.
- 52:13All right, let go of the meditation.
- 52:23How's that? Who did did?
- 52:30Anybody ask the question why should I be peaceful?
- 52:41What's the alternative? May I be angry?
- 52:47May I be angry? May I be angry?
- 52:53You know, there are longer phrases.
- 52:59Can anyone remember the Salzburg phrases Be peaceful, May I be
- 53:07free from harm, free from danger?
- 53:13And some people get quite elaborate.
- 53:16The reason that the phrases in this particular way of doing it
- 53:22are so concise is that you don't want to have to effort at all to
- 53:26repeat the phrase. It needs to be something you
- 53:29just grab on to it. For instance, if we contrast it
- 53:33to the equanimity phrase for for the long form of the phrases.
- 53:43For any harm I may have caused knowingly, unknowingly through
- 53:46my thoughts, words, and actions. I ask for forgiveness For any
- 53:51harm others have caused me, knowingly or unknowingly through
- 53:55their thoughts, words, and actions.
- 53:57Ioffer my forgiveness as best as it I am able.
- 53:59For any harm I may have caused myself, knowingly or unknowingly
- 54:03through my thoughts, words, and actions, Ioffer my forgiveness
- 54:06as best as I am able. For the concise version, which
- 54:10is forgive me, I forgive you, I forgive myself.
- 54:16But it's easier to fill the the space up without the effort of
- 54:21trying to get the phrase right that you don't have to
- 54:24concentrate on that. That's mainly what it is.
- 54:29The goal is not to feel peaceful.
- 54:31I mean, the goal is not to feel whatever the.
- 54:36It's important to attend the meaning of the phrase, but it is
- 54:38not the phrase is not driving the experience.
- 54:42The object of meditation is not the phrase, it's the mind state.
- 54:48Why is it important to discover the mind state?
- 54:51Because it's one of the aspects of mentalizing that's essential
- 54:55into in being able to understand your experience of the present
- 54:59moment and and the accuracy of your interpretation of what's
- 55:03happening. Without the accuracy, you don't
- 55:07know what's really what's happening.
- 55:10You are, or whether your responses to what's happening
- 55:14are appropriate or not, or even in scale, right, Which is if you
- 55:21reply it to an attachment line said, how do you know that
- 55:25you're, that you're not being rejected or that you are being
- 55:27rejected even though you, you've just created the reality that
- 55:32you are being rejected, which would be the, the Taja panati.
- 55:36They're reflecting back on the the way that you've defined it
- 55:41to see whether or not that's what's happening.
- 55:44And then coming into that sense of security of, wow, I'm
- 55:48experiencing this as rejecting. Is that what you mean?
- 55:51So that you you're coming from that place of confidence and
- 55:55ensuring that you understand what your experiences as opposed
- 55:59to just assuming that it's your version is true and reacting
- 56:04that this is really an essential training and why we focus on it
- 56:08the way that we do. Thank you so much.
- 56:14Yeah, I was just kind of getting planned towards that way.
- 56:16I just want to feel good and nothing else.
- 56:18I was kind of getting saturated. Yes, why not?
- 56:26No. The full range of everything you
- 56:28want to feel. No idealization here.
- 56:32Yeah, but not just to feel, but to to do what you just said.
- 56:37Yeah. Perfect.
- 56:40Thank you so much, Christian. Moody, I don't know if you find
- 56:46this helpful, but there's been times where may I be peaceful
- 56:50felt a little inert for me. So I've used like may I be
- 56:53joyful and that kind of has a little bit more action movement
- 56:57to it. But I also sometimes check in
- 57:02and kind of interrogate like, oh, do I have, you know, the way
- 57:06I interpret it? Do I have like a friendly, am I
- 57:09intending a friendly attitude towards myself and kind of see
- 57:12if I can intend that and if something shifts for me and the
- 57:15mindset kind of comes up or like a curious open attitude towards
- 57:19myself. And so I'll do little check
- 57:21insurance here and there, but I, I, I mess with the phrase
- 57:25sometimes if it's not vibing. Yeah.
- 57:29Thank you so much. Yeah.
- 57:29And, and realizing the motivation is very, very
- 57:31important. Before it was just about feeling
- 57:35good, but now it's about motivation.
- 57:37Yeah, and you have to be careful not to generate heat from the
- 57:41phrase. Oh, I see.
- 57:45Was that that that would not be the mindset of love and
- 57:48kindness. Unless you live in a place where
- 57:54your your heater is. Off and then you probably want
- 57:57to do. That it was 71 today and we were
- 58:04feeling the cold. So we have 1/2 day workshop
- 58:17called Family Archaeology coming up on the 16th, I think, which
- 58:21is really about going home for the holidays or interacting with
- 58:24the family, which happens quite a bit over the holidays and and
- 58:28you know, prepping yourself so that you can really use it to
- 58:32understand the family dynamics rather than simply be reactive
- 58:36to them. So that you can have a deeper
- 58:41understanding and develop your mid range mentalizing skills,
- 58:47which is to be able to watch the system that's happening and then
- 58:53understand your place in the system.
- 58:55I think that's a good thing to do.
- 58:56And so we'll talk about that and then I'm going to do we had a
- 59:02couple of requests from the last exploration thing, if I would
- 59:07just talk about my work. So in December, we're going to
- 59:12do a little bit shorter half day where I'm really just going to
- 59:19talk about the the the process of my exploration of photography
- 59:25and how that's come about. So they'll be a little bit of
- 59:30practice, but it'll be mostly a conversation about the work,
- 59:36which I, I hope will be of interest.
- 59:40Ioffer the teaching freely. I'm happy that you come in
- 59:43practice, but if you're resourced and you can make a
- 59:47donation to Medigroup, it helps me and also the work that we're
- 59:51doing, we really appreciate it. There's a link on the website
- 59:55for that. Thank you for your practice and
- 59:58we will see you soon. Bye.