Latest / The Vegan Report / How to be a Sneaky Vegan | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, I have a big announcement to
- 0:03make. In addition to the usual Tuesday episodes,
- 0:06I invite you to tune in every Wednesday for a
- 0:10special episode about the science of activism.
- 0:14Every Wednesday, I will give the microphone to
- 0:17world -class researchers who study the effectiveness
- 0:20of animal advocacy and vegan activism. Learn
- 0:25from them what are the best and worst ways to
- 0:29make a positive difference in the world. Since
- 0:33starting this podcast, I have come across strong,
- 0:37some would even say stubborn opinions on what
- 0:41the way forward looks like. I even developed
- 0:45my own strong opinions. But this is our reality
- 0:50check, a way to verify if our beliefs are backed
- 0:55by evidence and check if our perception of reality
- 0:59is not distorted. So connect every Wednesday
- 1:03and become the most informed and effective activist
- 1:07out there. Thank you. Today, I'm going to talk
- 1:14to you about the behavioral science of our food
- 1:17service institutions, how we can shape it to
- 1:20make people choose less meat, and why an all
- 1:23-vegan restaurant might not be as effective as
- 1:26you think. My name is Bjorn Olufsen. I'm a researcher
- 1:30and writer who is obsessed with the questions
- 1:32relating to meat production, animal welfare,
- 1:35and veganism worldwide. If you want to catch
- 1:37up with my work, you can follow my sub -step,
- 1:40more than meets the eye. meats spelled M -E -A
- 1:44-T -S. You can also follow me on LinkedIn, bjornioonolefsen,
- 1:48or go to my personal website bjornioon .com.
- 1:51If you're curious about more of the science of
- 1:54activism, you can share this episode of The Vegan
- 1:56Report with your friends or whoever would benefit
- 1:58from it, and we encourage you to take a listen
- 2:01every single Wednesday to learn more about this
- 2:03important research. So, last month, I took a
- 2:07plane to the Avisun. That's the Animal and Vegan
- 2:10Advocacy Summit in Nairobi, Kenya. The summit
- 2:13was great. That's not the important part. But
- 2:15I had to take an extremely long plane ride from
- 2:18Barcelona to Nairobi. It was over eight hours
- 2:21in length. And if any of you are vegan, you know
- 2:25that it can be quite difficult to eat vegan food
- 2:28on an airplane. So I had to do this very annoying
- 2:31thing that I'm sure most of you can relate to.
- 2:34I had to buy my ticket. Then afterwards I had
- 2:37to log into the airline manage my booking section
- 2:40and then scroll and scroll and scroll and find
- 2:43this tiny little option where I could change
- 2:45my my meal service from a default meal to a vegan
- 2:49option You know at the end of the day it took
- 2:52me 15 minutes But it was kind of annoying tasks
- 2:55that I didn't really want to go through and it
- 2:57just is a bit a bit Annoying every single time
- 3:01I have to fly And then if I forget to do it,
- 3:04which does happen once in a while, I'm sitting
- 3:06on the airplane and I'm trying to talk to the
- 3:08flight attendant, trying to see if there's any
- 3:10vegan food they have in the back. One time, I
- 3:13remember a few years ago, I had forgotten to
- 3:16do this and they had brought me every single
- 3:19piece of fruit they could find in Brooklyn, because
- 3:20that was the only vegan food they had. So I was
- 3:23sitting there with my tray table and they had
- 3:24like four apples and two bananas and like a pear
- 3:27in front of me. You know, better than nothing.
- 3:31but not exactly the vegan meal I had been hoping
- 3:33for. So why am I telling you this? This is because
- 3:38airplanes operate on a meat default. If you do
- 3:43nothing, they will serve you a meat option by
- 3:46default. Occasionally there's a vegetarian default,
- 3:49but basically no airline in the world has a vegan
- 3:52default. If they were to have a vegan default,
- 3:56all the food they would serve would be vegan.
- 3:58But if you wanted to eat meat, or eggs, or dairy,
- 4:03you would have to log in to the airline's website,
- 4:06manage your booking, figure out how to add the
- 4:08meat and dairy to your meal. But the thing is,
- 4:11most people wouldn't go through that trouble,
- 4:14because it is kind of an annoying task. This
- 4:17is a central concept called a food default. We
- 4:21can have a plant -based default, a meat default,
- 4:23or various versions of it. How are we presenting
- 4:26these types of food to consumers? Right now,
- 4:31in the vast majority of the world, the food is
- 4:33presented with meat and dairy as the default
- 4:36options. I, as a vegan, and I'm sure many people
- 4:40listening to this, have to put an extra effort
- 4:43if we want to eat vegan food. This is true in
- 4:47cafeterias, in restaurants, in bars, on airplanes,
- 4:51in corporate offices, workplaces, catering events,
- 4:54anything you can really think of where you eat
- 4:55food. We have to put an extra effort. But what
- 5:00if we could flip it? Now let's talk about behavioral
- 5:04science of food, specifically something called
- 5:06a nudge. A nudge you've probably heard of. It
- 5:10was first popularized in a 2008 book called Nudge
- 5:14by Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein. Right now
- 5:18I'm working with the Better Food Foundation as
- 5:20a research specialist on a series of projects
- 5:23all related to food -based nudges. The idea is
- 5:28simple. What if we could change the way our food
- 5:30systems are presenting the options to the consumers
- 5:33without actually removing the choice at all?
- 5:37That's what a nudge is. A change of the options,
- 5:41not the removal of them. If I were to walk into
- 5:43a vegan restaurant, none of the food would be
- 5:46nudged to me because there is no option to eat
- 5:50meat or dairy if I wanted to. I don't want to.
- 5:53I'm vegan. But let's say I've brought some of
- 5:55my friends' family to a vegan restaurant. they
- 5:57would essentially have to eat vegan as long as
- 5:59they stay within the restaurant premises. But
- 6:03a nudge is a way to position the option in such
- 6:07a way that people are more likely to choose it.
- 6:10There's a million different types of nudges.
- 6:13And we're going to talk about several of them
- 6:14today. First, I want to talk about plant -based
- 6:17defaults. In a plant -based default, a vegan
- 6:22option is presented to the consumer as the default
- 6:26option. So let's say you're signing up for a
- 6:30conference. You'd have to log in and put extra
- 6:33effort if you wanted the meat option. The same
- 6:35example with an airline. In a cafeteria, maybe
- 6:40all of the vegan food is visible to the consumer,
- 6:43and they'd have to ask a staff member to go to
- 6:47the back and bring the meat option out, which
- 6:49might take a little extra time, maybe five or
- 6:51six minutes. In a restaurant, All the items on
- 6:55the menu could be vegan, but the consumer would
- 6:58have to add meat or dairy options for an extra
- 7:00cost. For example, think of a vegan burrito that
- 7:05was given to the consumer, but they could add
- 7:08chicken for an extra $3 or 3 euros. In a vegan
- 7:14default, a plant -based default, we can see huge
- 7:17changes. So last year, I did a review. a literature
- 7:22review of all the studies on plant -based defaults.
- 7:26And I found that when we had a meat default,
- 7:29the vegan option was chosen on average 16 .4
- 7:32% of the time. But in a plant -based default,
- 7:37the vegan option was chosen 73 .8 % of the time.
- 7:42That's pretty amazing, right? That's over a three
- 7:45-fold increase. We're going from a less than
- 7:4920 % vegan to around three and four options being
- 7:52entirely vegan. And here's what's the crucial
- 7:55thing. The meat eaters who were able to eat meat
- 8:00aren't going to complain. That's the problem
- 8:03that we've seen with many other... restaurants
- 8:06or Meatless Mondays or Veganuary or vegan restaurants
- 8:10or something where the choice is essentially
- 8:13removed from the consumer. Sometimes, not all
- 8:17the time, but sometimes there's backlash. For
- 8:20whatever reason, a lot of people seem to really
- 8:22really like their meat and when they feel as
- 8:24if it's been taken away from them, they might
- 8:27react in a negative way or stop supporting that
- 8:30business or something like that. which has caused
- 8:33a lot of those initiatives to fail. Not all,
- 8:36but enough that we should be concerned about
- 8:38it. The benefit of a plant -based default is
- 8:42that everybody is happy. Most people are eating
- 8:45vegan. The people who really, really crave the
- 8:48meat are still going to eat the meat, but they're
- 8:50not likely to complain about it. This is the
- 8:53central advantage, in my opinion. We're able
- 8:55to work with food service institutions that might
- 8:59not be willing to work with us otherwise because
- 9:01we are giving them something that's not going
- 9:04to give them backlash or harm the consumer in
- 9:07any way. There is one thing we should keep in
- 9:10mind with plant -based defaults is that maybe
- 9:13the people who eat vegan might eat more meat
- 9:15later in the day. We only found one study that
- 9:19measured this and they did find that they're
- 9:21likely to eat more meat later in the day but
- 9:23that that amount was less than the amount of
- 9:25meat saved by the default. So It still works,
- 9:29but it is a cause for concern that we have to
- 9:32make sure that the food is filling enough that
- 9:34people are less likely to eat it later in the
- 9:36day. On the flip side, there's another type of
- 9:39behavior change that might be very positive,
- 9:42which is by having people eat vegan, perhaps
- 9:45even accidentally, for a long period of time,
- 9:48they might be more willing to go vegan later
- 9:50in their life or to reduce their meat consumption.
- 9:54I haven't been able to find a study that relates
- 9:57to this question specifically, but I think it's
- 9:59really worth considering. In my opinion, I think
- 10:02it's likely that when a plant -based default
- 10:05has some sort of messaging or narrative or framing
- 10:08campaign behind it to explain to people exactly
- 10:11why this is valuable and why it's meaningful,
- 10:14it might be more likely to change people's minds
- 10:16about veganism as a diet and as an identity.
- 10:19For example, in New York City hospitals, They
- 10:22gave people a plant -based default, and then
- 10:24after they left, they gave them an informational
- 10:26packet about why this was important and why this
- 10:28was implemented. I think this is very exciting.
- 10:32If we can pair plant -based defaults with other
- 10:34forms of media and messaging campaigns, we might
- 10:37be able to use it as a way to shift social norms,
- 10:41which is crucial for making the world a more
- 10:44vegan -friendly and less hostile to animals.
- 10:48So... A plant -based default is super exciting.
- 10:52And I think it's most exciting in universities
- 10:54because students are going to be more willing
- 10:56to be flexible, to experiment, and hopefully
- 10:59to consider the climate and animal welfare implications
- 11:02of what they're eating. So that's why I'm working
- 11:05with the Better Food Foundation. The Better Food
- 11:07Foundation is working with university students
- 11:09to implement these plant -based defaults across
- 11:13the United States and other places in the world.
- 11:15I'm excited to see this spread. I think not much
- 11:18effort has been put into this as an intervention
- 11:20historically, but with a lot more time and resources
- 11:24behind it, I do think that this could take off
- 11:26because of the benefits I mentioned earlier.
- 11:29There's not going to be a backlash. We're going
- 11:31to see huge changes in consumption, and it might
- 11:34even change social norms. But defaults aren't
- 11:38the only way to nudge consumers into choosing
- 11:42vegan. So let's talk about menus. On a menu,
- 11:48there are a million different ways we can reshape
- 11:51them to be more inclusive of the vegan food.
- 11:55And the first thing we need to keep in mind is
- 11:57that we probably shouldn't even be using the
- 11:59word vegan at all. I think a lot of people are
- 12:02hip to this nowadays, right? Plant -based is
- 12:04the new term. We should all be using plant -based.
- 12:07But plant -based is not that much better than
- 12:10vegan. It's better, but not that much. Instead,
- 12:14we need to be using terms that appeal to things
- 12:17like health, the origin of the food, the taste
- 12:20of the food. So instead of saying vegan burger,
- 12:24we should use something like umami burger or
- 12:29spicy chipotle burger or Mediterranean bowl as
- 12:37opposed to a vegan bowl or something like that.
- 12:40We're basically trying to give all these other
- 12:42indicators about what's going to be in the food.
- 12:45Because the word vegan and the word plant -based,
- 12:47like it or not, often make people think about
- 12:50what the food doesn't have. It doesn't have meat.
- 12:54It doesn't have dairy. And for many people, they
- 12:56assume that means it doesn't have flavor. I mean,
- 13:01obviously, I disagree with that. I think vegan
- 13:03food is great, but not everybody thinks that
- 13:05way, right? So instead, we need to be framing
- 13:08these foods in a way that is exciting and appealing
- 13:11and engaging for people, right? What would you
- 13:13rather eat? A vegan burger or a spicy umami burger
- 13:19with sauteed mushrooms on top? Something like
- 13:21that. Doesn't that sound better? Unless you don't
- 13:23like mushrooms. In that case, I don't know what
- 13:25to tell you. Mushrooms are great. So if we're
- 13:29going to be reshaping the titles of the food
- 13:32options, We can also be reshaping the way that
- 13:36the menu itself is structured. Something that
- 13:39I really like as a consumer, because I'm a vegan,
- 13:43I like it when I look at a menu and everything
- 13:45is extremely well -legal. Maybe there's a section
- 13:48or a box in the corner that says vegan options
- 13:51in big, bright, green, bold letters. To me, that's
- 13:55great because I know exactly what I could order.
- 13:57But that's actually not great for flexitarians
- 14:00or reducitarians or people who might want to
- 14:02eat vegan every once in a while because they're
- 14:04not going to look at that section because they
- 14:06don't think it's for them. Instead, not only
- 14:10do we need to integrate the vegan options with
- 14:12the entire menu, it's actually best to start
- 14:15with or end with the vegan options. So the plant
- 14:18-based food should be at the top of the menu
- 14:20right where people can see it. A small change
- 14:22of reordering and reintegrating the menu but
- 14:26it can increase the amount of their order by
- 14:28up to 56%. So, we should avoid calling them vegan.
- 14:33We should make sure that they're blended into
- 14:36the entire menu. Of course... For vegan consumers,
- 14:40it's always good for us to know what we can and
- 14:41can't eat. So you can include a small leaf symbol
- 14:44by the menu option or some small symbol that's
- 14:47going to be ignored by most people to indicate
- 14:49that it is in fact fully vegan, but it shouldn't
- 14:52be the main selling point. It shouldn't be in
- 14:54the title of the menu option, for example. Okay,
- 14:58something else to keep in mind is that the food
- 15:00has to be good. That's just an underlying principle
- 15:03for all forms of vegan outreach, but the food
- 15:05has to be good, it needs to be culturally appropriate,
- 15:08it needs to be diverse, it needs to be filling,
- 15:11and it needs to be tasty. Also, we need to make
- 15:14sure that the staff members who are distributing
- 15:16this food understand why they should be using
- 15:20vegan or plant -based nudges and meatballs. If
- 15:23they're not bought into the idea, they're not
- 15:25really going to be likely to implement it correctly.
- 15:29So staff training is one of those underrated
- 15:32aspects here. If you're trying to implement this
- 15:35in your community, you really need to have a
- 15:37conversation with all of these staff members
- 15:39or else it's probably not going to work out for
- 15:41a long period of time. Okay, so that's why it's
- 15:44important to frame the way that we're selling
- 15:46vegan items to people. When people think of veganism,
- 15:50they often have negative associations in mind.
- 15:52So by avoiding that label and by presenting the
- 15:56food in a much more inclusive and exciting way,
- 15:59people are far more likely to choose it. So how
- 16:04is this actually being implemented? Well, there
- 16:07are plenty of groups that are working hard on
- 16:10implementing these types of nudges. Greener by
- 16:13default and the Better Food Foundation are two
- 16:15of them. If you're interested, you can collaborate
- 16:18with these organizations by reaching out. I can
- 16:21put a link in the show notes. If you're a student
- 16:24in university, I recommend you reach out to the
- 16:26Better Food Foundation. If you're working in
- 16:28a corporation or a hospital or any sort of other
- 16:31institution, I recommend reaching out to Greener
- 16:34by default. And you can even email me at bjorn
- 16:37at betterfoodfoundation .org if you have questions
- 16:40about this. If you're working for a nonprofit
- 16:43that's working on nudges, you can join the NGO
- 16:46Working Group by Better Food Foundation. You
- 16:49can reach out to me by email if you want to be
- 16:51added. But even if you don't want to work on
- 16:54this professionally, you can still do local activism
- 16:56to get your institutions to frame the food in
- 16:59a better way. Something to keep in mind is that
- 17:02when you're talking to somebody about why this
- 17:04is important, you want to appeal to their motivations.
- 17:08I'm sure many people listening to this are super
- 17:10concerned about animal welfare and animal rights.
- 17:13And I get that. I am as well. But the reality
- 17:17is a lot of the a lot of other people in the
- 17:19world have different motivations. They might
- 17:21want to, for example, reduce the climate emissions
- 17:24of the food that they're serving. They might
- 17:27want to make their food more inclusive to people
- 17:29who have dietary restrictions or allergies or
- 17:33maybe their kosher or halal or they can't digest
- 17:35dairy, things like that. Or maybe they have a
- 17:40climate commitment that they're trying to live
- 17:41up to and the food service is a good way for
- 17:44them to reach that goal. So try to understand
- 17:47what the person you're talking to is motivated
- 17:50by. And then you can try to talk to them and
- 17:54advocate why a plant -based default or better
- 17:57plant -based nudges are going to help them reach
- 17:59their goal. For example, if they're concerned
- 18:02about climate and sustainability, you could talk
- 18:04about all of the climate effects of animal -based
- 18:07foods, especially beef and pork, but make sure
- 18:11that they don't replace the beef and pork with
- 18:13chicken or fish because that could actually result
- 18:15in more animals being harmed and eaten because
- 18:18they're the small body problem in which smaller
- 18:21animals need to be killed in greater quantities
- 18:24to create the same amount of meat. So if you
- 18:28have questions about this, I strongly recommend
- 18:30you reach out to the Better Food Foundation.
- 18:34But I am excited about the concept of plant -based
- 18:37nudges. To me, this is a way to reshape the way
- 18:42that we are presenting food to the world. It
- 18:45works. People are more likely to eat vegan when
- 18:48they don't really know the way it's presented
- 18:50to them. Because when they walk into a restaurant,
- 18:53they might not even know that the restaurant
- 18:55has been nudging them to select certain options
- 18:58this entire time. I hope that this intervention
- 19:02is going to do a lot of positive impact for the
- 19:05world going forward, and let me know if you have
- 19:08any questions. As always, thank you so much for
- 19:11listening. I am really grateful that people are
- 19:14excited about the research behind vegan activism,
- 19:17because if we're not looking at the research,
- 19:19if we're not thinking about what's impactful,
- 19:21what is evidence -based, what's going to work
- 19:23going forward, Our activism and our advocacy
- 19:26is always going to be stagnant. That's what's
- 19:29exciting about thinking about the data and the
- 19:31impact. We're going to keep getting better every
- 19:34single day and making sure we're making the world
- 19:38a better place for animals. Thank you so much
- 19:40for listening.