Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Basic Mentalizing
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is May 5th. 2022. It 7:30, 6 p.m.
- 0:25Pacific Daylight time, and we've spent the last week's talking
- 0:30about Advanced mentalizing. So I thought it was only fair
- 0:32that we flip it. And talk about basic mentalizing
- 0:37skills and this set of six, which is awareness of the State
- 0:45of Mind of self and other, if you look at the Sati putana suta
- 0:49and the refrain it says, mindfulness of inside
- 0:53mindfulness of outside mindfulness of inside and
- 0:55outside. So that's what we're really
- 0:58talking about here, awareness of your own state of mind and the
- 1:02weariness of another state of mind.
- 1:08Then the second one is monitoring the accuracy of a
- 1:11state of mind. The Pali word for that is Tha
- 1:15Japan naughty, which means constantly comparing the the
- 1:21Ultimate Reality experience to the conceptual reality that you
- 1:25create Tasha means, constantly, comparing pranati means
- 1:32conceptual reality. So the constant, I really think
- 1:35of it almost as a rocking back and forth.
- 1:38This is what I'm sensing. This is what I've made, this is
- 1:41what I'm sensing. This is what I've made.
- 1:42This is what I'm sensing. This is what I've made so that
- 1:46you can begin to reveal in that motion back and forth.
- 1:50Whether there's a mind state or a view, that's inhabiting the
- 1:55transition from Ultimate sensing experience into what you create.
- 2:00The Buddha talked about this in terms of the five, hindrances
- 2:06lost her craving. A version soften torpor,
- 2:11restlessness and agitation and skeptical doubt.
- 2:15When we begin our meditation, practice, the first piece of the
- 2:20development of the practice is to, in the at least in the Tera
- 2:26vaada path, a commitment to an ethical stance in life.
- 2:32So that's the opening to The Path.
- 2:35You you commit to trainings that will allow you to engage in the
- 2:42world and with yourself in an ethical way.
- 2:45A and then the the ethics that the Buddha was talking about is
- 2:50defined as the precepts in the vijnana.
- 2:57The monks have a certain number of precepts, the nuns have a
- 3:02certain number of precepts and then householders have
- 3:07essentially the five basic precepts.
- 3:10And then in Myanmar when we were on the street it was a setup.
- 3:15Of eight precepts for householders on Retreat, which
- 3:20added a few things. So I like the way that technicon
- 3:30language is this and I'm paraphrasing, which is undertake
- 3:34the training to refrain from killing and He widens that
- 3:43beyond the traditional theravada Buddhist view in the traditional
- 3:50terabyte is the traditional Tera vaada Buddhist views.
- 3:54Only human beings are sentient. So when it says to refrain from
- 3:58killing sentient beings, he's only were referring to that.
- 4:04Whereas if you extend that to what we now know, through our
- 4:08science view, there's a lot of sentience.
- 4:11Throughout different species in the world. the second is to, I
- 4:22always mix this up, it's peach or stealing, let's go as
- 4:27stealing to refrain from taking what is not freely offered to.
- 4:34So the practice of abstaining from taking what is not freely
- 4:39offered to. So that includes any kind of
- 4:42coercion that you might be able to use or manipulation that you
- 4:45might be able to use to get what you want, and only take the
- 4:48things that are explicitly and clearly.
- 4:51I offered to you. The third is to refrain from the
- 5:00engage engagement of the expression of your sexuality in
- 5:04a way that would be harming to you or others.
- 5:09We would have to include a prostitution in this or
- 5:15pornography. I think in the way that he
- 5:18frames it, The fourth is to refrain from harm that could be
- 5:27caused by harsh speech. And then the fifth is to refrain
- 5:38from intoxicating yourself and he includes in this media and
- 5:47all forms of the intake of information. and then, in the
- 6:00eight or nine, To refrain from wearing perfumes or makeup to
- 6:12refrain from dancing to refrain from sleeping on thick
- 6:17mattresses and to practice meta in every breath that would be
- 6:27the complete set that we commit to and we're on retreat.
- 6:36Then when we enter into the path, the first thing that we
- 6:41need to begin to develop is concentration.
- 6:44Access concentration is to be able to place your attention on
- 6:49an object and sustained awareness of it without
- 6:52interruption. And the reason it's called
- 6:55access concentration is that you can access Jonna or you can
- 6:59access the passenger inside practice from that level of
- 7:02concentration. That if you don't spend the time
- 7:06to develop that level of concentration.
- 7:11Then you don't aren't necessarily able to get the
- 7:17fruits from the practice that you do and it can lead to the
- 7:21delusion that the practice is actually not that helpful.
- 7:25And I think that one of the things that happens early on to
- 7:29people who are meditating is that they don't really
- 7:31concentrate well enough to do some of the techniques that are
- 7:34offered to them and because they're not actually able to do
- 7:38them, you know, most of the Their experience of meditation
- 7:42is not being able to do the technique very well and not
- 7:45getting much out of it. So it is useful to consider
- 7:49doing the pulmonary practices. We're of course, in the west,
- 7:54particularly in America, I think vastly overestimate our
- 7:59capacities and think that why should I who him?
- 8:03So special need to do preliminary practices and so we
- 8:07skip them and go on to the next part.
- 8:11But then we don't get the fruits of the practice and and it leads
- 8:14us to move from practice to practice to practice
- 8:18continuously seeking for the thing that we want.
- 8:22Even though the reason why we're not finding it is because we're
- 8:25not actually able to engage in the practice at a level.
- 8:28That would produce the result that we're looking for.
- 8:35Some of us get a through the different experiences of
- 8:38Education that we've had or through Sports practices or
- 8:42something like that. Do develop a level of
- 8:44concentration, but many of us don't.
- 8:47And so we begin that. Now in the west that tradition
- 8:52of preliminary practice has not been embraced and I think that
- 8:57that's largely because in the initial instruction of
- 9:01meditation going back. To the late 50s and 60s.
- 9:07It was largely done on Retreat and so you don't necessarily
- 9:11need to spend householder time during preliminary practices
- 9:16when you're in Retreat. Because if you're sitting for
- 9:18long periods of time, over an extended period of time, the
- 9:22concentration naturally develops from doing that, but if you're
- 9:28largely a householder practice and you don't go on Retreat,
- 9:32then I think it is. Imperative that you do.
- 9:35Some preliminary practices, which would I, which I would
- 9:40suggest is concentration. We met a group in the way that
- 9:46we tend to teach beginning meditation is to start with a
- 9:51simple breath, counting strategy, and then to go into a
- 9:57meta practice. But as oriented toward a
- 10:00concentration practice, rather than as a As a practice intended
- 10:06to produce positive States. So we use wet and dry for that.
- 10:12A dry for positive practice, would be a practice where
- 10:16concentration is not intentionally.
- 10:18Cultivated first, the wet for positive practice would be where
- 10:22concentration is intentionally developed first and then once
- 10:25you have access contras, duration, you move into the
- 10:29pasta and it's the opposite in meta a dry. meta, practice is
- 10:36concentration oriented in a wet bed, two processes where you're
- 10:41cultivating positive States would not cultivating
- 10:46necessarily Concentration, when you do a dry meant to practice
- 10:53or a dry loving-kindness practice.
- 10:56The blissfulness comes from the byproduct of the high
- 11:01concentration States and can be intensely Blissful which comes
- 11:06from any or can come from any of the Jean except states, you have
- 11:13met dijanna and also for possum in China we tend to teach meant
- 11:17of Asana. So there are these integrated
- 11:20hard practices and insight practices.
- 11:23So in the beginning of the development of your meta
- 11:27practice of your often using the positive strategies to set up
- 11:32the technique. And then once you've made the
- 11:36discoveries that you need to using inside practices, you
- 11:40abandon the inside practices and abide in the loving, kindness
- 11:45practices. So, mainly what we're trying to
- 11:47identify Defy in The Meta, John and practices, the Mind state of
- 11:54loving-kindness and then to make that the object of
- 11:57concentration. So it's a one pointed
- 11:59concentration practice on a mind State because a lot of the work
- 12:04that we do at meta group is focused on attachment and
- 12:08Detachment repair, really developing capacity to track
- 12:12mind. States is an important skill
- 12:17that you need to. Have in order to maintain secure
- 12:20functioning and so we'd like to start at the very beginning of
- 12:24practice with that and then when we come to the experience of
- 12:34this early basic metacognitive skill awareness of the State of
- 12:38Mind of self and others. If you're not able to track your
- 12:41own mind State, you're not going to be able to track the mindset
- 12:45of someone else and you may not even be able to tell the
- 12:47difference. Between your own mind, Satan.
- 12:50Somebody else's mind state. So the pulmonary practices that
- 12:54lead to this basic level of metacognitive, skill is actually
- 13:00developing the concentration to be able to be aware of your own
- 13:04mind State, and also somebody else's mind, Satan to
- 13:08differentiate them. And then the second one, of
- 13:13course, is the monitoring of the accuracy of it.
- 13:16Did you generate a version of conceptual reality that matches
- 13:21to what's actually coming in, or has that been distorted by a
- 13:27mind State and you're able to track that?
- 13:35If you had sensitive enough, attuned caregivers and then you
- 13:41would already be able to do this.
- 13:44It's only when you don't have that early training that it
- 13:47could be an issue. And so, when we look at that
- 13:51early experience of the infant in the dyadic relationship with
- 13:54their caregiver, the, those spontaneous uninhibited
- 13:59expression of the child. Hopefully is met by an attentive
- 14:04caregiver. Who would poo?
- 14:05Means whoever theoretically connects is able to understand
- 14:10what that expression means and then mirror it back.
- 14:15That's this is the development of that experience of
- 14:21understanding who we are in the reflection of someone else.
- 14:26If we don't have the reflection of somebody else to compare to
- 14:30our own internal experience, we don't develop that capacity of
- 14:35understanding other people's expression and how that reflects
- 14:41what our experience is. If that's always the condition
- 14:47that you experienced as a child, then you've always been able to
- 14:51do it and it's one of those automatic Gatherings of
- 14:55information that you do and then you become sensitive to your
- 15:02expression and then the experience that other people
- 15:05have of your expression and whether it matches what you
- 15:09thought should should happen. Which opens up to the third
- 15:15basic metacognitive skill, which is the awareness of One's Own
- 15:18influence on another state or behavior and vice versa?
- 15:24So, when you're mentalizing at that level, you understand what
- 15:28your experience is. And that's been Divine defined
- 15:33in reflection to your early experiences with a caregiver.
- 15:38So you'll notice in people with secure functioning that they
- 15:41experience on. Cells is capable and competent,
- 15:45and they experienced other people as receptive to their
- 15:50expressions. If there's enough Delight that
- 15:53comes back at them from their caregivers in that early dyadic
- 15:57experience, their expectation actually, is that those
- 16:00spontaneous authentic Expressions, will met be met by
- 16:04Delight in the other person. And then also that
- 16:12back-and-forth child expresses anger.
- 16:15They can experience the effect of that anger has in the
- 16:20expression of the caregiver and then how the caregiver responds
- 16:23that and in fact, care is consistently positive.
- 16:27And there's a problem with the expression of anger because your
- 16:29expectation, is that it won't affect the basis of the
- 16:32relationship, or the basis of delight.
- 16:36The caregiver has in you have you seen I suppose the mother or
- 16:41father respond to a very fussy child with the lightheartedness
- 16:46and the sense of delight. And you've probably also seen a
- 16:50caregiver that's overwhelmed by that experience and reacts
- 16:54harshly to the the child and each of those Reflections we use
- 17:02to create the experience of ourselves.
- 17:07And also the way that we anticipate or create the working
- 17:13model of other people. Stop making sense so far.
- 17:20So when we're talking about meditation and as an old student
- 17:24of shenzhen's, I really like to see her field technique for that
- 17:28because it's dividing up the experience of sensory experience
- 17:34into these easily trackable. Domains of sensory experience.
- 17:39and so you have the, the Perception of the world.
- 17:48And then when you add the focus in Focus out strategies, you
- 17:53begin to develop the sensitivity to self.
- 17:56And other other being the focus out, space and self being the
- 18:02focus in space. When you then add other people
- 18:12as objects of meditation and you're engaged in the experience
- 18:16of them, you begin to track the empathetic experience.
- 18:20So, we often talk about four basic kinds of emotional
- 18:25experience that you need to be able to track.
- 18:28And when you use these simple deposit and techniques to divide
- 18:32up experience, you can develop really Stark sensory clear
- 18:38Around these four basic kinds of emotional experience.
- 18:43The first is the emotional response that happens to the
- 18:47experience of the present moment.
- 18:50So you have the capacity to send something the object that can be
- 18:53sense. When there's contact,
- 18:55consciousness of that sensing experience arises, it's then
- 18:59compare its then evaluated for processing, speed on electrical
- 19:05and beta is the Pali word. Plus it on Pleasant or neutral,
- 19:09I think, urgent attention. Does it really matter whether we
- 19:13get to it and pleasant if there's time, is a better way to
- 19:16think about that. And then it's compared to the
- 19:19perceptual database. And if there's an entry in the
- 19:22perceptual database, that's close enough to the
- 19:25undifferentiated, sensing experience than conceptual.
- 19:29The process of conceptual reality happens in the
- 19:32undifferentiated. Sensing experience becomes
- 19:35conceptual reality based on what Means to you, not necessarily
- 19:41based on what's happening because we're referencing the
- 19:46perceptual database to create an understanding of what the
- 19:50sensing experience. Is, it really isn't about what's
- 19:57happening as much as it is, as it is about what it means to us.
- 20:03Now, there is always the possibility that it's a unique
- 20:08or novel situation that you're in, and then the imagination
- 20:11kicks in and creates a meaning that's associated with the sons,
- 20:15he experienced on, that becomes the reality.
- 20:18But when you begin to explore this deeply, what you'll see is
- 20:22that you could really create almost anything and it will take
- 20:26on the appearance of solid and real.
- 20:31And if you're not in this, Movement back and forth to
- 20:35compare what you've made with, what do you created, or what
- 20:41you've sensed? Then you can slip out of
- 20:48mentalizing and think that the experience that you're having is
- 20:51actually what's happening and that it's a universal experience
- 20:55and that everybody's happening. Having it is, this was not
- 20:59mentalizing mode which we would call psychic equivalence where
- 21:02you Think your experiences an accurate representation of
- 21:06what's actually happening and not a representation of what's
- 21:11happening. In that moment means to you.
- 21:14This that constant movement back and forth that understanding is
- 21:24I am creating reality based on what it means to be in this
- 21:27present moment and I'm not even obligated to other moments that
- 21:30I've had in creating this. Really that you're also doing
- 21:35that opens up this investigation of actively mentalizing what the
- 21:40other person's state is. If you're just relying on the
- 21:44fact that That everyone has the same experience as you.
- 21:47There's no investigation in all of what the other person's
- 21:51experience might be. So you're not engaged in that
- 21:54basic level of awareness of the state of your own mind in
- 21:59somebody else's and then in exploring whether there's a
- 22:03mindset present or not and a distortion present or not.
- 22:10You can evaluate whether you're seeing things clearly, and you
- 22:13can also begin to sense in the other person, whether they're
- 22:17seeing it clearly, whether they're in a Quantum estate, or
- 22:20they're actually in a view that's distorting and so that
- 22:25when you engage in the communication, you can express
- 22:28this, the better you know, people in the more you negotiate
- 22:33these agreements, the easier it is to have these kinds of
- 22:37dialogues. Now one of the things about
- 22:43Consciousness is that it's delayed by about a half a
- 22:47second, so that most of the time, the entire process that
- 22:51I've just described has already happened as it enters into
- 22:55Consciousness. It's unusual to see the process
- 22:58of the Mind forming conceptual reality.
- 23:01Most of the time of just enters completely formed and so we're
- 23:05engaged often in this reverse engineering.
- 23:09This is what I've made. What did I make it out of rather
- 23:13than this is what I'm sensing? This is what I make.
- 23:16This is what I've made. What did I make it out of?
- 23:18This is what I've made. What did I make it out of?
- 23:21So that you can begin to have a dynamic relationship to that?
- 23:32The better you are at doing that.
- 23:34Of course, the you move into the next level of mentalizing, which
- 23:38is becoming aware of one's State of Mind, in such a way that it
- 23:41has a regulatory effect on that stage.
- 23:45So we develop through experience strategies, for regulating
- 23:50different states of mind, or changing different states of
- 23:53mind. When you move into the meta
- 23:55practice, I think I didn't list the Types of meditation
- 24:02emotional states. Let me do that now.
- 24:04I'll reference them soon. The first one is the reaction to
- 24:07the emotional reaction to the present moment, plays out in the
- 24:11surface of the body. The second is the emotion that's
- 24:15generated by thinking. So you think a thought and part
- 24:18of that thought is the feel in that aspect, the emotional
- 24:22aspect to have auditory Visual and emotion that creates really
- 24:29Substantial conceptual reality experience.
- 24:33The third is the empathetic experience of someone else,
- 24:36which you develop in response to them.
- 24:39So when your mentalizing and you're aware of their state is
- 24:43separate the new words, then you begin to open to the empathetic
- 24:47experience of what they feel like and you can hold your own
- 24:51emotional experiences separate from that and keep them
- 24:54distinct. And then the fourth one is the
- 24:57somatic sized emotional. And so, old Holdings of
- 25:02emotionally overwhelming experience that are in the body.
- 25:05Usually, you notice them as energy centers that that release
- 25:10emotion. Let me begin to do.
- 25:15When we do also learn this in the dyadic relationship with our
- 25:18caregivers, very young is the the way that one can regulate
- 25:26the experience of one State of Mind.
- 25:29Usually, this is a, we learn through observation of how the
- 25:35caregiver responds to us to comfort in soothe us.
- 25:38If they do that, we may be asking for Comfort.
- 25:42We may be Scheme for soothing and they may not actually
- 25:45provide comfort and soothing but they do provide some way of
- 25:51regulating it. So I see her sad here.
- 25:56Let me give you some affection. Let me reassure you that it's
- 25:59going to be okay or a wipe that sad expression off your face or
- 26:04I'll give you something to be sad about another strategy.
- 26:08For regularly, with that really leads to the suppression the
- 26:11conscious of pressure. Manhattan and expression of
- 26:14emotion rather than a comfort in soothing, but it does lead to
- 26:21the development of a self-regulation strategy.
- 26:25So, we become aware that one state of mind in such a way that
- 26:29it has a regular ettore effect. So this is also the beginning of
- 26:33the self-generated emotion, where we think, of thought, and
- 26:36response to something that's distressing in the present
- 26:39moment, in a way of in an attempt to comfort and Do that
- 26:43ourselves. We want to use meditation as a
- 26:49way of evaluating how we do that.
- 26:53So we begin to learn to monitor auditory thinking visual
- 26:57thinking and the emotion. That is part of that consolation
- 27:02of thought and then pay attention to whether we use
- 27:09repetitive thought patterns as a way of regulating our
- 27:12experience, What you'll notice is that most adults use
- 27:18repetitive thoughts as a way of regulating their emotional
- 27:22experience and that children, observe adults using repetitive
- 27:27thought processes and to develop a version of that themselves.
- 27:32So, we learn from our caregivers, the strategies that
- 27:38our family systems used to regulate emotional experience,
- 27:51Through observation. But also from being soothed by
- 27:55our caregivers, what is it? They say to us that soothing Or
- 28:02has a regulatory effect. So, what we do is we anchor our
- 28:24tension in auditory or visual thinking depending on, which is
- 28:27our primary thought process, and then we track one of our
- 28:32thoughts from repeating thoughts and then we monitor the
- 28:35repeating thoughts until we learn the content of them.
- 28:40And then we evaluate whether they're beneficial thought,
- 28:43processes, or Afflicted, thought processes, we suppress the
- 28:47afflictive, thought processes, and develop, beneficial thought
- 28:51processes. To regulate.
- 28:59I'm my voice is failing, but I'll go on for a few more
- 29:02minutes and then we can meditate Once we develop beneficials of
- 29:11thought processes, then the we can move into a place of what we
- 29:17would call Self Mastery. In terms of emotional regulation
- 29:20that we developed these emotional regulation strategies
- 29:23and we develop enough of them that are beneficial That we have
- 29:30some, some opportunity of regulation in most situations
- 29:36that we're facing to that really Fosters our capacity to explore
- 29:41because we can explore individually and take risks and
- 29:46regulate and go deeper into the expiration.
- 29:50But it also understand that we are collaborative.
- 29:55We're meant to live in. Social groups.
- 29:57And so it's also being able to create a supportive social
- 30:01network that will be able to help you regulate if you get so
- 30:04dysregulated that your capacity to regulate yourself is not
- 30:10working in all situations. So in that development we all
- 30:17start off his Auto Regulators. This is from the attachment View
- 30:21and that it's a caregiver comes reliably enough that we reorient
- 30:26to externally regulating and if that caregiver comes reliably
- 30:31enough, we will move into a collaborative relationship with
- 30:34them where we really rely on them to regulate it, regulate
- 30:39us. So that we're willing then to
- 30:41take these big risks in our Exploration of life because we
- 30:46know if we need somebody, they'll be there to regulate us
- 30:50down in a secure person who had that dyadic experience their
- 30:54expectation, is that they will be able to find those people and
- 30:57have them around them. So they're much Freer and being
- 31:00able to explore, the people who have the view that, there aren't
- 31:03people like that around. And so, I have to, I have to
- 31:06monitor how much this regulation I allow by modifying or
- 31:12curtailing my Shouldn't so I don't get so dysregulated that I
- 31:16don't have somebody who will help me and if your expectation
- 31:19is that they're not plentiful and they're not available, you
- 31:23really do begin to limit your exploration.
- 31:30The fifth and is the awareness of One's Own and another's
- 31:33action, plans, or gold directedness that you learn
- 31:38that. You have your own agenda, that
- 31:41really your brain is developed enough to do that at about 18
- 31:45months and then you seek your own autonomy.
- 31:49It's also about the time that you really can move around on
- 31:55your own. And You Begin if your
- 32:01collaborative to collaborate with other people's agendas, and
- 32:05if you don't develop that capacity for collaboration,
- 32:08you're in conflict with other people's agendas for themselves
- 32:13were not being sufficiently supportive of your own agenda,
- 32:18but an example of that would be the child.
- 32:21Says, I'm hungry and the the caregiver says, okay, let me
- 32:25make you something to eat. I eat and then the child sees
- 32:29that the caregiver needs to make them something to eat.
- 32:32And so they settle waiting for the caregiver to make something
- 32:37to eat for them without constantly hectoring them,
- 32:41they're hungry because they can see that there's a process
- 32:43involved. They can collaborate with that
- 32:47or the caregiver can say we're not eating now we're eating in
- 32:50an hour, which a child won't understand, because they don't
- 32:53understand time, but I wouldn't give you a snack now and then
- 32:56you're going to You let me finish what I need to do and
- 32:59then we'll have dinner. And if that's consistent enough
- 33:01for that, the child has the expectation.
- 33:04At the end of that the dinner will be there then they can
- 33:06settle into playing and exploring while waiting for
- 33:10dinner in a way that if they're uncertain about it that they
- 33:13would be too anxious to be able to do it.
- 33:17And then the sixth one is meaning making Meaning, making
- 33:22is really where you understand that some activities are
- 33:24satisfying for you and some activities are not satisfying
- 33:27for you and being able to understand in activities,
- 33:31whether that quality of satisfaction is present or not.
- 33:36And then understanding why it has residents for you why it's
- 33:43meaningful to you. And then you can then organize
- 33:46your agenda in a way that you're pursuing things that are more
- 33:50meaningful. That'll making sense that basic
- 33:55set. So one of the things I think
- 34:02that's useful about using these kinds of maps to discuss this is
- 34:06that you can begin to do an evaluation of where your own
- 34:09mentalizing capacities are. And then you can begin to focus
- 34:14in on the things that you need to develop in order to increase
- 34:19your capacity for mentalizing and so, What I would like to do
- 34:28is just do some basic, see hear feel and then some focus in
- 34:32Focus out. So that, that really basic.
- 34:37The possum is Skillet. Developing mentalizing is
- 34:43something that you can practice. We divide the sensory experience
- 34:47individual experience auditory experience and the felt sense of
- 34:50the body which includes emotion. And then they come together, of
- 34:56course, to form conceptual reality.
- 34:58So we're pulling these individual threads of data and
- 35:03then combining the threads in order to create conceptual
- 35:06reality, the computer monitor a metaphor, I think it's quite
- 35:10helpful. If you look at your computer
- 35:12screen, you can see things that you've made into meaning, right?
- 35:17People in your listing to an auditory stream, which is
- 35:21language, which are Singing into words and meaning.
- 35:26But if you zoomed really tightly and on the video screen that
- 35:30you're looking at, it would be diodes of red green and blue,
- 35:34there would be no meaning beyond that in each of the individual
- 35:40red green and blue. They're either on or they're off
- 35:44bright or less bright that making sense.
- 35:48So that process of meaning making takes, we take all of
- 35:51that data in and we form conceptual reality and we assign
- 35:55a meaning. To it, that is not intrinsically
- 35:58there in the individual data stream.
- 36:01So what we want to do is move beyond the conceptual reality
- 36:05into the sensory experience, the streams of data that we then use
- 36:11to formulate conceptual reality. So in this process of dividing
- 36:16things into see, hear feel we're not looking at the content
- 36:20merely whether the sense gate itself is active or not.
- 36:24So is it odd Is it off? Then we'll divide into this 6
- 36:33will divide visual experience into external site space,
- 36:36internal visual thinking, internal visual thinking tends
- 36:39to be mental screen centered at the eyes where you see imagery
- 36:43associated with thinking, but not everybody's a strong visual
- 36:46thinker. So you may or may not have much
- 36:48awareness of that. There are other aspects of that,
- 36:51but that's the primary one. In order to re-experience its
- 36:56external site, space sound space and internal auditory thinking.
- 37:01So for most people, that's inside the head between the ears
- 37:04at the opening of the years, you have clear talk there.
- 37:08So words, you can understand the meaning of it.
- 37:10And some people have an awareness of a vibratory energy,
- 37:14which is also there, and then in the body initially, it's all
- 37:18Sensations in the body and then we divide emotional Sensations,
- 37:22which is Real. And from all of the other
- 37:25Sensations in the body, which is peel out.
- 37:29And then I think what we'll do is begin with the few minutes of
- 37:33concentration practice that we can settle in.
- 37:49So, how did that go? I can share.
- 37:57Okay, yeah, I just have to say that I felt like I was totally
- 38:06lost and maybe this is an advanced group and I didn't get
- 38:09the instructions because I didn't really didn't know what
- 38:14to do with the instructions. So I instead, I said, I will I'm
- 38:20watching my mind and trying different things out for a
- 38:24person who doesn't Know what to do, or what to feel?
- 38:28What the sense. Like, maybe this is are above me
- 38:31and it just went over my head. Yeah.
- 38:34What did you do? So what I did is I try I will.
- 38:39First of all, I would just get distracted into, you know,
- 38:42mind-wandering. Then I then I'd say, well, I
- 38:44better just kind of focus on something.
- 38:46So I don't get so frustrated. And then I went into, this is
- 38:51sort of like, somebody asking you to draw an apple and you're
- 38:56blind, and you've never felt one and no one's ever told you going
- 39:00to Apples. Like and then I'm like, oh no.
- 39:04Just like somebody giving instructions on ice skating and
- 39:09all this stuff and they're, you know, they've never given you
- 39:12ice skates, so you don't know the experience, but you know,
- 39:18and then I went from an Apple to another object and I'm like,
- 39:21wow, when you don't know what's just supposed to do or feel or
- 39:25experience, what do you do with your mind and so yeah, did you
- 39:31notice the apple and visual experience?
- 39:34Auditory experience are the felt sense of the body.
- 39:38So when I said well, the Apple would, if I was blind and
- 39:43somebody asked me to draw an apple and I never felt one.
- 39:47Nobody describes me. I'd be like, how did you know
- 39:50that? How did I know to draw the
- 39:55question? Auditory thought a visual
- 39:58thought or felt sense in the body?
- 40:03How would I determine the difference?
- 40:05That was the problem. I couldn't figure out what each
- 40:08one was, so in reflecting back on it.
- 40:11You described it to us as an auditory thought, but if I were
- 40:15a blind person and had never seen an apple, so, those were
- 40:21words, is that how you knew that you were thinking that?
- 40:28Yeah, I guess so. Okay, and where did you hear
- 40:32those words? I guess in my head, where else
- 40:36do here? Exactly, but we're in your head
- 40:41in my mind. So with the instructions of the
- 40:46explanation was auditory thinking space, which is inside
- 40:50the head or at the ears, did you notice that?
- 40:54Well I didn't catch that inside the head or in the ears at the
- 40:58opening of the ears is typically where you hear auditory thought.
- 41:03Well, I don't know, but I'm sort of leaning towards saying,
- 41:07internal and mind, okay? And then with internal visual
- 41:11thinking, it's typically a mental screen that Entered at
- 41:14the eyes. So when you close your eyes, do
- 41:17you ever see visual imagery? Happens.
- 41:25I think that my usual thing and is it where's that located?
- 41:31Well, I don't, I didn't know there was a location for these
- 41:35things, but I guess it would be in the front of the head, right?
- 41:42And then where do you feel emotion?
- 41:51In the throat or the core of the body.
- 41:55So along the surface of the body throat.
- 41:59Yeah. In the mostly in the front or
- 42:02sometimes. Yeah, I guess mostly in the
- 42:06fraud. So now what we've described is
- 42:11internal, visual thinking internal, auditory thinking, and
- 42:16the felt the emotion, and the body, that's the focus in space.
- 42:22Then the focus out space is where do you see visual image
- 42:25when the eyes are open? Oh, was instruction Open the
- 42:31Eyes for that part. No, but I'm just asking you,
- 42:35I've been trying to walk you through the spaces that you're
- 42:38monitoring. Okay.
- 42:40So what's the question, if your eyes are open, where do you see
- 42:44the visual space? Here and here.
- 42:52So out out in front. As far as I can see out with, I
- 42:58mean, I can't see knows me as far as I can see.
- 43:05And then when you hear the external soundscape of the
- 43:08world, where do you hear it? I guess through the years, And
- 43:16then, when you feel the body, where do you feel the body?
- 43:21They're the core front of the body or it could be us would be
- 43:26the footer the towel or what. So, the fuel out part is
- 43:30different than the feel in part. Oh, so I just described feel in
- 43:37you describe the contrast between feel it, and feel out.
- 43:41What's what did I say? Was feeling the front of the
- 43:46body, the core of the body in the throat.
- 43:49Okay, that's how you feel emotion and then peel out spaces
- 43:53that were other spaces like you could feel your foot use that.
- 43:58Deal out is feeling the when you think about touching something
- 44:04out of yourself. Well, no, it's an arbitrary
- 44:08designation but it's the Corporal Des, the physicalness
- 44:11of the body. So you've actually been able to
- 44:16Define all of the six bases that we were tracking and hear what
- 44:19you just want to do is let your attention to be drawn to
- 44:23whatever is sensing experience is happening and then know that
- 44:27it's one of those. Six paces.
- 44:31And try and Define it or recognize them, okay?
- 44:36You just have to recognize that it's active.
- 44:38You don't have to do anything else about it.
- 44:44All right, and I'll tell you make some good.
- 44:50Yeah and it's just goes over my head and I'm like I'm not sure.
- 44:54I got a garden here in level 2 class and all the basics are in
- 45:00that 84 meditations that you have.
- 45:03So if you go through those you'll get the basic
- 45:07instruction. That's the development of
- 45:10sensory Clarity that we need. So it does develop over time.
- 45:14I'm no you don't know the heck's going on and beginning, right?
- 45:20Like all that Equanimity with confusion, Okay.
- 45:24Yeah, the most important thing to me in that whole process was
- 45:29that I was able to not get too frustrated and angry good.
- 45:35I had a little bit of it but then I thought, well, just do
- 45:39whatever, you know, an apple fiorina.
- 45:42Like normally I would get really frustrated.
- 45:45Like I don't understand the instructions, why am I here?
- 45:48All right, I I managed to just say, oh well whatever.
- 45:54Yeah good. Yeah, that's good.
- 45:56Emily. Yeah.
- 45:58Eyes down is oh well, whatever it is.
- 46:18Else. Joan.
- 46:25I noticed that I was challenged in just being with a feeling and
- 46:32not a signing and emotion. I realized that that apparently
- 46:39is a pattern. I feel a feeling in them.
- 46:42I assign or think of. What does that mean, right?
- 46:49Good. So, thank you all for coming and
- 46:54practicing. Was that good enough?
- 46:58Joan? Or did you have more?
- 47:01Thank you. We're going to we have posted
- 47:10the new level 1 in the new level 2 on the website.
- 47:12If you want to take a look at that and I think it's End of
- 47:21June into July. Not sure.
- 47:26And then we have our Retreat coming up in October and the new
- 47:33thing that's on the horizon is that we're trying to put
- 47:36together a trip to Thailand in January and February the kind of
- 47:42echoed tourism trip will go to Chiang, Mai and then we'll,
- 47:47we'll hike through the mountains to the Monastery.
- 47:51Don't worry. I'm turning 70 this year.
- 47:54The idea of two days of hiking through the mountains of
- 47:56Thailand made, me think, we need to have cars on the available,
- 48:02so we'll have cars available. You need to, then we'll go and
- 48:06do a course at a high Forest Monastery.
- 48:13And then take a couple more days to do some more travel around
- 48:17Thailand, and come back. It's an 18 day trip.
- 48:19All together. So that the thing that we're
- 48:23trying to figure out but all that eventually lined up in the
- 48:26website I offer the teaching freely but I do hope that you'll
- 48:32make a donation. There's a link to do that on the
- 48:33website. Any amount is helpful and help
- 48:36support me and also the work medic group is doing thanks.
- 48:40Thank you for coming and we'll see you next time.
- 48:43Bye now.