Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Public Education Legislation
Transcript
- 0:08Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:09Shaw, and we thank you so much
- 0:11for joining us this evening.
- 0:12Our topic tonight, public
- 0:14education legislation. State
- 0:16lawmakers are considering
- 0:17several education related
- 0:19measures that examine school
- 0:21governance, financial
- 0:23transparency, administrator
- 0:24compensation increases, teacher
- 0:26recruitment, leadership
- 0:27development, accountability and
- 0:29assessment, and more. Most are
- 0:31high ranking policy priorities
- 0:33of the Republican supermajority.
- 0:35Meanwhile, early childhood
- 0:36education is top of mind for
- 0:38the minority party. In separate
- 0:40news conferences today, House
- 0:41and Senate Democrats announced
- 0:43another push to expand access
- 0:45to pre-K. We'll break it all
- 0:47down with our four guests and
- 0:49our Lexington studio tonight.
- 0:50State Senator Stephen West, a
- 0:52Republican from Paris and chair
- 0:54of the Senate Education
- 0:55Committee. State Senator
- 0:57Reginald Thomas, a Democrat
- 0:58from Lexington, Senate Minority
- 1:00Caucus chair and member of the
- 1:02Senate Education Committee.
- 1:04State Representative Scott
- 1:06Lewis, a Republican from
- 1:07Hartford and chair of the House
- 1:09Primary and Secondary Education
- 1:11Committee. And state
- 1:14Representative. Tina Bojanowski,
- 1:15a Democrat from Louisville and
- 1:17ranking minority member of the
- 1:18House Primary and Secondary
- 1:20Education Committee. We
- 1:22certainly want to hear from you
- 1:23tonight. You can send us your
- 1:24questions and comments by X.
- 1:26Formerly known as Twitter at
- 1:29Pub Affairs KET. Send an email
- 1:30to KY Tonight at Keturah or use
- 1:34the web form at Keturah KY
- 1:37tonight. Or you can simply give
- 1:38us a call at one 800 494 7605.
- 1:43Welcome, guests. We appreciate
- 1:44you all being here. A late
- 1:45start for you all today. And an
- 1:47early morning in the morning.
- 1:48Those 8:00 meetings I know talk
- 1:50to you all about that right.
- 1:52Let's start with some Senate
- 1:54measures and a priority measure,
- 1:56Senate Bill one. And we know
- 1:57that any time the lower the
- 1:59number the higher priority. Is
- 2:00that right, Mr. Chairman?
- 2:02That's absolutely right. Senate
- 2:03Bill one transfers some of the
- 2:05power of the elected school
- 2:07board to the superintendent and
- 2:09Jefferson County Public Schools.
- 2:10And there was some interesting
- 2:11testimony a couple of weeks ago
- 2:13from the current superintendent,
- 2:14Doctor Brian Yearwood, who said,
- 2:16you want to give me this
- 2:18authority, this expanded
- 2:19authority, but I shouldn't have
- 2:21it. So why should he have it?
- 2:24>> The reason he should have it
- 2:25is JCPS is a totally unique
- 2:28entity in the state of Kentucky.
- 2:30It states right in I think it's
- 2:33section six of the bill. It
- 2:35just describes how large JCPS
- 2:38is. JCPS has 95,000 students.
- 2:43Their budget is about $1.9
- 2:46billion. And so as as JCPS goes,
- 2:50so, so goes our state as far as
- 2:53especially scores and those
- 2:54sorts of things. And also we're
- 2:57really honed in on achievement
- 2:59and making sure it's not just
- 3:01about the statistics and about
- 3:03the scores. It's about are the
- 3:05kids getting the quality of
- 3:07education that they deserve?
- 3:08>> Superintendent Yearwood had
- 3:10testified a couple of weeks ago
- 3:11that he didn't see this as
- 3:13being a bill about student
- 3:14achievement and student success
- 3:16outcomes. What do you say to
- 3:18his criticism there?
- 3:19>> Well, you know, there's a
- 3:22lot of politics and Frankfort,
- 3:24but there's a lot of politics
- 3:25in Jefferson County school
- 3:27system as well. And, you know,
- 3:29when you have your employer
- 3:31sitting next to you in the
- 3:32committee meeting, the vice
- 3:33chair of the board, you know,
- 3:35maybe your answers are a little
- 3:37different than maybe you think
- 3:39behind closed doors. So he has
- 3:42a line to to walk, a tightrope
- 3:45to walk in his position. I will
- 3:48say I've been very pleased with
- 3:49Doctor Yearwood. He's saying
- 3:52all the right things. He's made
- 3:54some very difficult decisions
- 3:56early on, trying to right the
- 3:58ship and get their budget in
- 3:59order. So so we're very pleased
- 4:02with what he's done so far. And,
- 4:05you know, it's hard to believe
- 4:06that that we're trying to tell
- 4:08him, hey, we're trying to give
- 4:09you more power to do all the
- 4:11good things you say you want to.
- 4:13>> Do, right?
- 4:14>> But he does have a political
- 4:15tightrope to walk.
- 4:16>> Well, Senator Thomas, I want
- 4:18to come to you because your
- 4:19colleague, the minority Leader,
- 4:20Gerald Neal, said during that
- 4:21committee that we should just
- 4:23give Doctor Yearwood more time
- 4:24to settle in right before
- 4:26giving him perhaps more power.
- 4:28How do you see Senate Bill one?
- 4:29And do you think that it should
- 4:31take away power from an elected
- 4:33school board and give it to an
- 4:36appointed or selected
- 4:38superintendent?
- 4:38>> Well, Renee, my biggest
- 4:41concern about Senate Bill one
- 4:43is that, you know, there are no
- 4:46justifications for doing what
- 4:47they did. They have all these
- 4:49findings, Renee. But but where
- 4:51do they come from? You know,
- 4:52other than maybe, you know,
- 4:56looking at some reports or, you
- 4:58know, reading the newspapers,
- 5:00there was there's there's
- 5:01really been no thorough,
- 5:03detailed investigation as to
- 5:07what's causing these problems
- 5:08with JCPS. Now, as you recall
- 5:10from that meeting, I asked
- 5:12doctor, I asked him a question.
- 5:13Doctor, would you would you
- 5:15believe these problems are
- 5:16being caused by the structural
- 5:18governance of JCPS? Because
- 5:20that's what one of the findings
- 5:22said. He said there's nothing
- 5:23about the structural governance
- 5:25that's creating these problems.
- 5:26These problems do exist. He
- 5:27didn't deny that. He said
- 5:28they're very real, but it's not
- 5:30because of the way the
- 5:31structural governance is
- 5:32created. What they're proposing
- 5:33to do is two things, Renee,
- 5:35that I think really harm the
- 5:37city of Louisville. One,
- 5:39they're cutting back on how the
- 5:40board can meet. The board can
- 5:42only meet once a month, which
- 5:43means if there's a need for an
- 5:45emergency meeting, a school
- 5:46shooting, Renee, or or a sudden
- 5:49decline in the budget, they
- 5:50can't meet, you know, that
- 5:52really handicaps the board
- 5:54significantly in terms of
- 5:55operating. Secondly, Renee,
- 5:57they're giving Doctor Yearwood,
- 5:58and I want your viewers to
- 6:00understand this. They're giving
- 6:01him a $250,000 blank check to
- 6:05write for expenses any time
- 6:06they want.
- 6:07>> And what do you mean by that?
- 6:09Giving him a $50,000 blank
- 6:10check.
- 6:10>> I mean, he can he can write
- 6:12a check. If you read the
- 6:14legislation, he can write a
- 6:15check. Renee, for $250,000, a
- 6:17quarter of $1 million without
- 6:19consulting the board at all. I
- 6:21mean, we've been talking about
- 6:22financial accountability. I
- 6:23mean, that that's that's really
- 6:25shaky grounds when you talk
- 6:27about being accountable to to
- 6:30for a person, be accountable
- 6:32when they can just sign their
- 6:33name for $250,000 and.
- 6:35>> Say, do they have to comply
- 6:36with the transparent financial
- 6:38transparency rules that are
- 6:40embodied in Senate Bill three?
- 6:42That's a separate measure. What
- 6:43he also have to post all of
- 6:44those itemized expenses up to a
- 6:46quarter million dollars.
- 6:47>> Of course he would. But
- 6:49that's after the fact, Renee.
- 6:50That's after the fact, you know,
- 6:53now, generally before a
- 6:55superintendent can can write a
- 6:57check, he's got to get board
- 6:58approval. I want to come to you.
- 7:00This is going to cost $200,000.
- 7:02I want your approval to do that.
- 7:04That's what that's the way it
- 7:05is in Fayette County and the
- 7:07board.
- 7:07>> Is there any monetary
- 7:08threshold? What is the monetary
- 7:09threshold right now.
- 7:10>> In Fayette County?
- 7:11>> In Fayette County?
- 7:12>> I don't I don't know that
- 7:14there's any I don't know, I
- 7:15mean, I think even $400, I mean,
- 7:17maybe that can go on a credit
- 7:19card somewhere. But, but, but
- 7:20but again, that would require
- 7:21some kind of, you know, board
- 7:23okay on that. But but that's a
- 7:25significant difference here.
- 7:26You know, Renee, I don't want
- 7:28to take up too much time. But
- 7:29there was never a question
- 7:31asked the Doctor Yearwood in
- 7:32that presentation about doctor,
- 7:33what's your strategic plan now?
- 7:35What are you going to do? Give
- 7:36us your roadmap for success.
- 7:38You're going to give the
- 7:39superintendent all this
- 7:40authority and not question, you
- 7:42know, how he's going to
- 7:43implement it. Now, that's very
- 7:44telling.
- 7:45>> I want to go to Chairman
- 7:46West again before I get to
- 7:49Representative Tina Bojanowski,
- 7:49because she is in the Jefferson
- 7:50County school system, so she
- 7:51knows the issues surrounding
- 7:53the district very well. But
- 7:55respond to Senator Thomas.
- 7:57>> Yeah, this the general idea
- 8:00and I said this on the floor is
- 8:02we don't have to guess about
- 8:04what's happened to JCPS. I've
- 8:06been in this position ten years.
- 8:09Center Givens, who's the
- 8:10sponsor of this bill, has been
- 8:11in the Senate a lot longer than
- 8:13that. And we've heard the same
- 8:17thing year after year after
- 8:19year. Give us more time and
- 8:22give us more money. And to this
- 8:25point, the results aren't where
- 8:28they need to be on performance.
- 8:29And so I stated this on the
- 8:32floor. Whatever you say about
- 8:34this, this bill, SB1, it at
- 8:36least does something different.
- 8:38It changes the way that they do
- 8:40business. And and very simply
- 8:42it it clarifies who sets the
- 8:45strategy, which is the board.
- 8:46The elected board is still in
- 8:47place. It clarifies who runs
- 8:50the day to day operations,
- 8:51which is the superintendent,
- 8:54and it creates accountability.
- 8:56Senate Bill three also creates
- 8:58accountability clearly and
- 8:59would apply to Jefferson County
- 9:00if passed. And so it's it's a
- 9:03new it's a new pathway that
- 9:06that puts down some barriers.
- 9:08It does give the superintendent
- 9:09more power. But as you see with
- 9:12large entities, let's take
- 9:14apply it to business, a large
- 9:16corporation, a lot of times a
- 9:17large entity, you know that
- 9:21that power in the hands of a
- 9:22CEO or professional can really
- 9:25help move things, move things
- 9:27in the right direction. And the
- 9:29whole idea is, is this the
- 9:30perfect bill and is it going to
- 9:32do everything right? No. But is
- 9:33it a change from from previous
- 9:37past? Yes.
- 9:38>> Some people would question
- 9:39the wisdom in giving the
- 9:41superintendent a quarter
- 9:42million dollar petty cash fund,
- 9:43though. Explain the rationale
- 9:45for that.
- 9:46>> Well, there's always
- 9:48accountability. SB three would
- 9:49would they would have to show
- 9:50what you're spending it on and
- 9:52let's, you know.
- 9:54>> The board.
- 9:54>> The board is still in
- 9:56control of that superintendent.
- 9:58So they're the ones that have
- 10:00the four year contracts. They
- 10:02approve the four year, three,
- 10:03four year contracts of the of
- 10:05the superintendent. And so if a
- 10:07superintendent is writing to
- 10:08many of these $250,000 checks,
- 10:11he's a he or she is accountable
- 10:12to the board and they can non
- 10:14renew the contract. And so
- 10:18there's one thing to have a
- 10:20$250,000 check for a county and
- 10:23rural Kentucky, but Jefferson
- 10:25County school system this this
- 10:28is going to give the
- 10:30superintendent more flexibility
- 10:31with spending. And maybe they
- 10:33need maybe they need that.
- 10:34Maybe that's something new that
- 10:36they haven't had that they can
- 10:37use.
- 10:37>> Well, the $188 million
- 10:39deficit, though many people
- 10:40would question Representative
- 10:42Bozinovski the wisdom and
- 10:43giving the superintendent
- 10:45broader authority to write such
- 10:46a substantial amount of
- 10:48expenses without having
- 10:50advanced approval. First, is
- 10:51that one of the flaws you see
- 10:52with this bill, and what are
- 10:54the others?
- 10:54>> I think that the first thing
- 10:56that jumps out at me in this
- 10:58bill is thinking about our
- 10:59district. So Jefferson County
- 11:00Public Schools has the most
- 11:02public school choice in our
- 11:04state. We've got magnet schools,
- 11:06academies. We've got zones
- 11:07where children can pick where
- 11:08they go to school. With that,
- 11:11we have three of the top ten
- 11:12high schools in the state. So
- 11:14we're doing a lot of really
- 11:15good things in Kentucky in
- 11:18Jefferson County. But if you
- 11:20take these kids, I had a
- 11:22principal tell me once and she
- 11:24was just a not a magnet
- 11:26principal. She said by the time
- 11:27kids get to her, they've been
- 11:29sifted out seven times. So like
- 11:31they've had opportunities to be
- 11:32the more advanced students have
- 11:34had opportunities to go to
- 11:35different schools. So then you
- 11:37end up with select schools that
- 11:39have more concentrated poverty
- 11:42and more likelihood of becoming
- 11:45CSI schools. So which.
- 11:46>> Are comprehensive.
- 11:48>> Comprehensive support.
- 11:49>> Improvement, improvement.
- 11:51>> Right. So Jefferson County
- 11:52as a whole is in the orange
- 11:55category. But as you know, we
- 11:57have the most CSI schools
- 11:58that's brought up. We don't
- 12:00discuss how we have the best
- 12:01high school in the state.
- 12:02That's not brought up very
- 12:04often. But do we you know, so
- 12:06one of my thoughts is if if
- 12:08what we're trying to mitigate
- 12:09is how many CSI schools do we
- 12:11have? We have do we then stop
- 12:15having our school choice
- 12:17programing and send everyone
- 12:18back to their neighborhood
- 12:20schools? Because it's just it's
- 12:21a numbers game, right? If you
- 12:23have the more advanced kids
- 12:25going back to neighborhood
- 12:26schools, those scores will go
- 12:28up. Is that, you know, the
- 12:30solution? No, that doesn't make
- 12:31any sense at all. So we have to
- 12:33look at why the kids who are in
- 12:36these lower performing schools
- 12:38are lower performing. Is it
- 12:40because we have 139 different
- 12:42languages in the district,
- 12:44higher concentrated poverty,
- 12:46lots of kids with trauma and
- 12:48and behavioral issues that are
- 12:52interrupting their learning.
- 12:55That's where we need to focus
- 12:56is how to support those
- 12:58children.
- 12:59>> Can I comment on that real
- 13:00quick? Renee. Representative
- 13:03Bogdanovski brings up an
- 13:04excellent point. And ultimately,
- 13:05at the end of the day, that's
- 13:07why we're here with SB one.
- 13:08Jefferson County has 41 of the
- 13:1255 CSI schools in Kentucky. So
- 13:15for the people out there
- 13:16watching a CSI school is
- 13:21comprehensive support and
- 13:21improvement. That's the lower
- 13:235% of schools in in the
- 13:25Commonwealth, and they're
- 13:27performing at lowest level. And
- 13:29in Jefferson County has 41 out
- 13:31of those 55 across the state.
- 13:34And so those are the kids that
- 13:37we want to try to help. And
- 13:41it's been that way for about
- 13:44two decades. And so this this
- 13:46bill is aimed to change things
- 13:48to, to maybe this mixes up the
- 13:51system, maybe it and maybe
- 13:53there's some unintended
- 13:55consequences, things of that
- 13:56nature, as Senator Schickel was
- 13:58always good about saying, we'll
- 13:59be back here in nine months.
- 14:00We'll be back in session in
- 14:02nine months. So any unintended
- 14:03consequences we can try to fix.
- 14:06>> But this measure alone isn't.
- 14:08The structural governance piece
- 14:10is not meant to totally rectify
- 14:14the issues of Jefferson County
- 14:15public schools, right? There
- 14:16are other issues that we'll
- 14:18talk about that we'll do that.
- 14:19>> There's not any. You know
- 14:21how education is. There's no
- 14:22silver bullet to these
- 14:23questions, but maybe it's a
- 14:25component.
- 14:25>> Chairman Lewis, this this
- 14:27ball is in your court right now.
- 14:29When can we expect a hearing on
- 14:31SB one and House Primary and
- 14:33Secondary Education Committee.
- 14:34>> Right now obviously we're
- 14:35focused on House bills. So we
- 14:37we've not really went through
- 14:38all of the Senate bills, just
- 14:41from what I know on this bill
- 14:43and hearing, hearing discussion
- 14:44on it, we have passed in the
- 14:46last five years, probably
- 14:48superintendent now is in
- 14:50overall control of the
- 14:51curriculum. And number two is
- 14:52we put the superintendent on
- 14:54the site based councils when
- 14:55they hire principals. So we've
- 14:57we've made some corrections
- 15:00along the way to give
- 15:01superintendents a little more
- 15:02power and a little more
- 15:03authority. You know, some some
- 15:06of the issues about it's
- 15:09$250,000. Every district right
- 15:11now probably has a set figure.
- 15:13I think mine was $7,500 when I
- 15:15was a superintendent. I didn't
- 15:16have to get approval of the
- 15:18board to. It's a large district,
- 15:21$250,000, still a lot of money.
- 15:23So that might be something that
- 15:25needs to be looked at. But
- 15:26again, you know, I think all of
- 15:29us want the same goal. And that
- 15:31is to improve Jefferson County
- 15:32and all all schools in the
- 15:33state of Kentucky. It's just
- 15:35how are we going to get there?
- 15:36So, you know, at some point the
- 15:38bill will have a hearing and
- 15:40maybe there will be some ideas
- 15:41that we can all agree on and
- 15:43and help shape that bill. For
- 15:44for the best of everyone.
- 15:46>> I'm going to go out of
- 15:47numerical order because kind of
- 15:49related to this topic is Senate
- 15:50Bill 114, which would change
- 15:51the way school boards in
- 15:53Jefferson and Fayette County,
- 15:54Fayette County being the second
- 15:56largest school district in the
- 15:57state. The how those are
- 16:00appointed rather the school
- 16:01boards rather than elected. So
- 16:04and we've heard a lot of
- 16:05interesting commentary and
- 16:06testimony about lack of
- 16:09democratization of this very
- 16:11local decision making body.
- 16:14Explain the rationale for this.
- 16:17>> Senate bill. 114 kind of
- 16:21goes along with Senate Bill one,
- 16:24the same kind of general idea.
- 16:26Let's let's do something
- 16:28different. Let's let's change
- 16:29things up. What in essence,
- 16:31what it does. The gist of the
- 16:33bill is, is there are seven
- 16:35geographic divisions within
- 16:38within the county. Let's let's
- 16:39take JCPS as an example. And
- 16:43each each one of those
- 16:44districts gets a board member.
- 16:47And then there's four members
- 16:50at large okay. So we are adding
- 16:53member. We would be adding if
- 16:55Senate Bill 114 were to get a
- 16:57hearing and were to pass, then
- 17:00we would be adding members to
- 17:01the school board. And so that
- 17:05the key component that I'm sure
- 17:07these guys will want to talk
- 17:08about is the mayor. You know,
- 17:09the mayor would have would have
- 17:11appointment powers. Those of
- 17:14those school board members to
- 17:16be confirmed by the city
- 17:19council. So that's how.
- 17:20>> Does it make it more
- 17:22Partizan or less Partizan.
- 17:23>> More Partizan.
- 17:25>> To be specific to represent
- 17:27Bujnowski. I'm going to try to
- 17:29take the words out of her mouth.
- 17:31So so there's political
- 17:33proportionality in the bill.
- 17:34And so you have to have the
- 17:35Republican Democrat
- 17:38representation similar to what
- 17:39we do with college boards, the
- 17:43Kentucky, the school board. And
- 17:46there is precedent that we do
- 17:48this in other places.
- 17:49>> So if there's precedent,
- 17:50what's wrong with this
- 17:51representative?
- 17:51>> Well, number one, it's
- 17:52special legislation. Was it
- 17:55only I mean, our Constitution,
- 17:56section 53 of our Constitution
- 17:59says we're not to have special
- 18:00legislation. So we're not doing
- 18:01this. This is not every school
- 18:03board. This is only JCPS and
- 18:05Fayette County Public Schools.
- 18:07Secondly, it takes away the
- 18:10ability for constituents within
- 18:13the district to elect their
- 18:15school board members. And then
- 18:17thirdly, it adds a partizan
- 18:19nature. So we're kind of
- 18:21flipping around on what is and
- 18:22isn't Partizan. So within the
- 18:25last year or two, we changed
- 18:26the mayoral and Metro Council
- 18:29elections to be nonpartisan. So
- 18:31now a nonpartisan mayor has to
- 18:35select school board members who
- 18:36won't get to be voted on in a
- 18:39partizan nature. They have to
- 18:41pick Democrats and Republicans.
- 18:43And then the nonpartisan Metro
- 18:45Council would confirm those
- 18:48Partizan individuals. I think,
- 18:50number one, I think our school
- 18:52board should be elected. And
- 18:54number two, I think that school
- 18:57board members should be
- 18:59pro-public education. I don't
- 19:00think you need a D or an R next
- 19:02to your name to signify that
- 19:04you support public education.
- 19:06>> How do you see it? Senator
- 19:08Thomas.
- 19:08>> Central West said this is
- 19:09being done elsewhere, and I
- 19:11want to know elsewhere. You
- 19:13heard me talk on the Senate
- 19:14floor, and I used cities such
- 19:16as Atlanta, Tampa, Nashville,
- 19:19southern cities, not cities,
- 19:21not necessarily in size and
- 19:22scope to Lexington. But again,
- 19:24you know, cities that urban
- 19:25urban cities, okay, none of
- 19:27them. Not one of them, Renee,
- 19:31you know, have an appointed
- 19:32school board member. In fact,
- 19:34they have nine school board
- 19:36members, all of them that are
- 19:37elected by the general public.
- 19:39Okay. And so that's what
- 19:41they're doing and doing very
- 19:43well. I think Representative
- 19:46Bogdanovsky summed up the way I
- 19:48feel about this. We're going
- 19:49from a school board
- 19:51historically that that is
- 19:53nonpartisan nature across the
- 19:54state. And now we're injecting
- 19:56politics in our school board.
- 19:57And that's a that's a dangerous
- 19:58route to go down. Renee, when
- 20:00you talk about education, to
- 20:01insert politics in, in terms of
- 20:03what you should teach, who
- 20:04should teach, how should be
- 20:06taught, you know, we don't we
- 20:08don't want that in our schools.
- 20:10Now, again, Atlanta, Tampa,
- 20:13Charlotte they don't do that.
- 20:15And so I just think 114 is
- 20:18really taking us down a path
- 20:19that's that's really going to
- 20:21impact public education in a
- 20:23very negative way.
- 20:24>> Chairman West, I want to go
- 20:26to a point that I think
- 20:27Representative Bozinovski was
- 20:28getting at was about
- 20:29constitutionality of Senate
- 20:30Bill 114, because Senate Bill
- 20:31one, when it came about in 2022,
- 20:34was struck down by the Supreme
- 20:35Court. We know there was a
- 20:37reversal last year and because
- 20:38of it was considered
- 20:41unreasonably unreasonable, but
- 20:43also because it was special
- 20:45legislation. How is this bill
- 20:47not special legislation like
- 20:48the previous version was of
- 20:51Senate Bill one.
- 20:51>> So let's start. Let's start
- 20:53with Senate Bill one. Senate
- 20:55Bill one was not struck down
- 20:56because it was special
- 20:58legislation. The court struck
- 21:01it down. But what's unusual
- 21:03about the case is the court
- 21:05gave a clear road for policy.
- 21:08It says we don't know what the
- 21:10policy is. If you'll do these
- 21:13things, we can get to the point
- 21:16where it is we consider it
- 21:18constitutional. And they were
- 21:19very clear about how they laid
- 21:20it, laid that that out. It is
- 21:22important to note the way
- 21:23Senate Bill one was handled by
- 21:25the court. So the Supreme Court
- 21:27found that it was
- 21:29constitutional. And then we had
- 21:30a judge's race for Supreme
- 21:33Court Justice Goodwin was put
- 21:35on the court and with a very
- 21:38unique procedural motion and
- 21:41manner, they pulled the case
- 21:43back for review and passed it.
- 21:46Having said that, they still
- 21:48did put in there. You know,
- 21:49here's a here's a roadmap for
- 21:51success, basically. And that's
- 21:53what Senate Bill one has done.
- 21:55They said, give us some policy
- 21:56reasons for doing this and
- 21:57we'll consider it. Senator
- 21:59Givens, I believe, laid out 43
- 22:01policy sections.
- 22:03>> Pages.
- 22:04>> Yes, eight pages. Very
- 22:06voluminous, going to 114. Talk
- 22:09about 114. This in my opinion,
- 22:12this is not special legislation.
- 22:14And the reason for that is the
- 22:18General Assembly itself sets
- 22:20out the rules and regulations
- 22:22as to how Jefferson County was
- 22:25formed and how it currently
- 22:27operates as a city. Okay, so
- 22:29it's a unique operational
- 22:32system in Jefferson County. We
- 22:36the legislature passed a law
- 22:38that allows that Jefferson
- 22:39County is the only city in the
- 22:41state of Kentucky that operates
- 22:42the way it does. Kind of the
- 22:44same thing with Fayette County,
- 22:45UK that is a unique governance
- 22:48structure under under under our
- 22:51law. And so if Senate Bill 114
- 22:54is considered special, special
- 22:56legislation, then necessarily
- 22:58the way Jefferson County was
- 22:59formed and the way Fayette
- 23:00County was formed has to be
- 23:02special legislation, because
- 23:03it's you. We set them up in
- 23:05unique ways. And so that way,
- 23:07you know, the Lord giveth, the
- 23:09Lord taketh away. Urinea, you
- 23:11know. And so if the if the
- 23:12legislature is able to set up a
- 23:14city a certain way, unique way,
- 23:16then it can also pass laws that
- 23:18affect it in a unique way.
- 23:19>> Any more further comment on
- 23:20that?
- 23:21>> Well, I just don't think
- 23:22that that defends taking the
- 23:24right of the constituency to
- 23:27elect their school board.
- 23:28>> But if I may comment on that
- 23:29for a minute. Renee, what the
- 23:32state has not done is set up
- 23:34school boards in a separate way
- 23:36based upon their population. I
- 23:37mean, the Jefferson County
- 23:38School Board, the Fayette
- 23:40County School Board, have
- 23:41operated consistent with all
- 23:42other school boards in this
- 23:45state, all hundred and 71 of
- 23:47them for well over a century.
- 23:49The school board's governance
- 23:50has not changed. Now, all of a
- 23:53sudden, we want in Senate Bill
- 23:54one and Senate Bill 114 to
- 23:56change the governance of these
- 23:57two special schools. I think
- 23:59that absolutely, there is an
- 24:02argument that could be made
- 24:03under section 59 and 60 of the
- 24:06Kentucky Constitution that this
- 24:07special legislation.
- 24:09>> School board could make a
- 24:10quick comment on something
- 24:11Senator Thomas said earlier. I
- 24:13disagree. We can agree or
- 24:15disagree, but the idea of we're
- 24:18starting to inject politics
- 24:20into school boards. Have you
- 24:23ever been to a school board
- 24:24meeting? I think there's been
- 24:26politics in school board
- 24:26meetings for a long time and
- 24:28will continue to be. It's it's
- 24:29one of the most political
- 24:32dynamics you can get into if
- 24:33you're a politician. So
- 24:36politics is involved in all
- 24:37this stuff. And it just this
- 24:38would just change the dynamic,
- 24:40dynamic dynamic of those
- 24:42politics.
- 24:42>> But Renee, no school board
- 24:44member right now has a D or an
- 24:47R behind their name like we do
- 24:48in the state Senate. We have a
- 24:50DNR behind our name. We don't
- 24:51have a school board in this
- 24:53state as of today that has that.
- 24:55>> I'm I'm waiting for the
- 24:57General Assembly to go
- 24:58nonpartisan.
- 24:59>> Oh goodness. Who's going to
- 25:01file that bill? But is there
- 25:03not Senator Thomas, to your
- 25:05point, is there not already
- 25:06some presumption on where a
- 25:09particular candidate for school
- 25:10board would lean based on their
- 25:13platform that they present to
- 25:14voters to consider?
- 25:16>> Well, Renee, I think you can
- 25:18make that argument about anyone
- 25:19who comes, you know, comes
- 25:21before a body and talks a
- 25:24certain way about what
- 25:25positions they take. I mean, we
- 25:26live in a highly charged
- 25:28political environment. I agree
- 25:29with you on that point. But
- 25:31still, nonetheless, we don't
- 25:33vote for school board members.
- 25:34I haven't haven't since the
- 25:37adoption of the Constitution in
- 25:381891, based upon their their
- 25:40Partizan affiliation. And I
- 25:41think that's a good thing in
- 25:42education. I think we've done
- 25:44that because we try as hard as
- 25:46we can to keep politics out of
- 25:49curriculum and who's teaching
- 25:50students and how they're being
- 25:51taught. We try to do that.
- 25:52Renee.
- 25:53>> Is this a constitutional
- 25:54amendment and should it be and
- 25:55will it have to be eventually?
- 25:57Senate Bill 114.
- 25:58>> No, this is not a
- 25:59constitutional amendment. This
- 26:00this will be just straight
- 26:02legislation that would have to
- 26:03pass both chambers and be
- 26:06signed by the governor or the
- 26:07veto over it.
- 26:08>> Okay, Chairman Lewis, and
- 26:10I'm going to start with you
- 26:11next time on the next question
- 26:12to get you in the game here.
- 26:14I'm so sorry, sir, but your
- 26:16thoughts on Senate Bill 114 and
- 26:17particularly how it's connected
- 26:18to Senate Bill one?
- 26:19>> Well, Senate Bill 114, from
- 26:21what I know of and again, we
- 26:23really haven't, you know, dug
- 26:24deep into those bills yet
- 26:26because like I said, we're
- 26:27still working on House bills,
- 26:28but I certainly wouldn't be
- 26:30opposed to adding more board
- 26:33members to our bigger districts.
- 26:35I'm not a fan of the mayor's,
- 26:38you know, appointing the board
- 26:40members. I just I know in other
- 26:42areas I've seen that done some
- 26:45of our bigger cities, and I'm
- 26:47just not sure if I'm supportive
- 26:49of that. And there may be more
- 26:52to it for me to look into. But
- 26:54I do think that there's maybe
- 26:55some merit for our bigger
- 26:58districts. Maybe if they wanted
- 26:59to add a few more members.
- 27:01>> Yeah. Okay, now it's your
- 27:02turn, chairman. Okay. House
- 27:04Bill 257 and this is one of the
- 27:07accountability measures that
- 27:08would create a new state
- 27:09accountability system
- 27:10permitting local districts to
- 27:11develop their own systems. So
- 27:13talk us through this.
- 27:14>> Well, house Bill 257 was
- 27:17filed by representative JT pain.
- 27:20And we feel like it's a good
- 27:22bill. It does several different
- 27:23things. Number one, it moves us
- 27:25to a growth model instead of a
- 27:27change model. And that's
- 27:29important for a few reasons.
- 27:30But number one is it measures
- 27:33the growth of the kid from year
- 27:35to year and individual kids.
- 27:37Right. And not a group one year
- 27:38to the next. So, you know, we
- 27:40think that's a positive change.
- 27:42But what that also does if
- 27:43you're a change model, you
- 27:46can't get an ESL waiver that
- 27:48extends one more year, which
- 27:50means.
- 27:50>> A second language.
- 27:52>> Yes, English is second
- 27:53language. And as you know, our
- 27:56ESL population has doubled in
- 27:57the last ten years and a lot of
- 27:59our districts have 120
- 28:02different languages. Jefferson
- 28:04County, including those. So,
- 28:06you know, it's hard for us to
- 28:08be held accountable and hard
- 28:09for the student to be held
- 28:11accountable when they can't
- 28:12even speak our English. But yet
- 28:13they're accountable on our
- 28:14testing system. So it helps
- 28:17that the local piece would
- 28:20encourage districts to have
- 28:23more engagement in the
- 28:24community and let the
- 28:25communities decide what those
- 28:27pieces look like, whether
- 28:29they're a heavy industrial
- 28:31maintenance district, or they
- 28:32want to be more focused on the
- 28:35arts. So it would give skin in
- 28:37the game for our local
- 28:39communities and give feedback
- 28:40to our school districts. So we
- 28:42think it's a good starting
- 28:45point on maybe doing some
- 28:46things different in our
- 28:48accountability system. And I
- 28:50really I do like this bill. I
- 28:52think it's a good bill.
- 28:53>> So for those who would say,
- 28:55well, what does this mean for
- 28:56kids who are not just going to
- 28:58be competing with other kids in
- 28:59their district, but across the
- 29:01county and state lines and
- 29:02globally, what does it do to
- 29:03prepare them for that?
- 29:04>> You still measure that. And,
- 29:06you know, the big test that
- 29:07we've got. This brings me into
- 29:09something that I want to
- 29:10mention. You know, every state
- 29:12has a different test, so it's
- 29:13hard to know how you really
- 29:14compare. But we take a Nape
- 29:16test every year. That is that
- 29:18is all the states. So you know,
- 29:20and a lot of people don't even
- 29:22realize this. Our latest scores
- 29:24for Kentucky, we were 10th and
- 29:26fourth grade reading. We were
- 29:2920th in fourth grade math. We
- 29:30were 21st in eighth grade
- 29:34reading, and we were 27th in
- 29:36eighth grade math. So we're
- 29:38making gains from bills that we
- 29:41passed in previous sessions
- 29:43with Senator West and
- 29:46Representative Tipton's reading
- 29:46bill, numeracy bill that was
- 29:49passed. We passed some bills
- 29:51the last couple sessions. We
- 29:52passed first grade kindergarten
- 29:55type deal where we see kids
- 29:56that are behind. We give them
- 29:58immediate feedback and help
- 30:00right then and then. Hopefully
- 30:01by third grade we have them
- 30:03reading on grade level. So I
- 30:05think we made some progress.
- 30:07And and I would like to see us
- 30:09do more with the early grades,
- 30:11because that's where you can
- 30:12make the most progress. If you
- 30:14can teach a kid to read by
- 30:15third grade, our upper scores
- 30:17are going to be fine. And we're
- 30:18already doing some really great
- 30:20things in our upper level. But
- 30:21but that goes back to some of
- 30:23the things we're talking about
- 30:24for Jefferson County. Maybe we
- 30:25take the CSI schools and
- 30:27they're not all Jefferson
- 30:29County. A majority are, but
- 30:30maybe we have some different
- 30:31ways to deal with those.
- 30:34Jefferson County's got some
- 30:35great schools, but like I said,
- 30:37they've also got a pod of
- 30:38schools that we deal with every
- 30:40year that we're having a hard
- 30:41time putting, putting our hand
- 30:43on. Maybe we gave
- 30:45Superintendent Yearwood more
- 30:49freedom there where he can pick
- 30:50the principals of those
- 30:51buildings and be able to sort
- 30:53of pick his leadership team and
- 30:56maybe some incentive pay for
- 30:58teachers that that would, you
- 31:00know, go to that area if
- 31:01they're the best teachers in
- 31:02the district. So I think if we
- 31:04focused a lot of resources
- 31:06there, and maybe we wouldn't
- 31:09need as much as this overall
- 31:12governance or change in
- 31:13governance. So, you know,
- 31:15that's just a couple of things.
- 31:16A couple thoughts I have.
- 31:18>> I think I think this is a
- 31:20fabulous bill and it's a great
- 31:22first step. It's a really big
- 31:24change. So in addition to
- 31:25changing from change to growth,
- 31:27the assessment. So we have to
- 31:29follow the federal requirements
- 31:31of what we test as a state. And
- 31:35writing is not on the federal
- 31:37requirement. So in this bill we
- 31:40propose to no longer require
- 31:42from the state level the on
- 31:44demand writing and the editing
- 31:45mechanics test. And if you
- 31:47think about it, what students
- 31:49do is they sit down and they
- 31:50have 90 minutes to draft and
- 31:54rewrite and write an essay. And
- 31:56is that truly what kind of
- 31:58writing we use today? Right. So
- 32:02the on demand writing and the
- 32:04editing and mechanics would not
- 32:06be expected in elementary,
- 32:08middle or high school, and it
- 32:10could shift into a local
- 32:12accountability measure. And I
- 32:13think as a teacher, as we sit
- 32:15there and give these kids these
- 32:16tests that last 4 or 5 days to
- 32:19be able to decrease how much
- 32:21testing we're having, but then
- 32:24still get enough information
- 32:25that we can know how our
- 32:27students are doing, is
- 32:28definitely a win.
- 32:29>> When you just said something,
- 32:30I know that lots of parents are
- 32:31probably thinking, is this
- 32:32going to mean less testing time?
- 32:34>> It would be less testing
- 32:35time. That's correct. And I did
- 32:38have a post in a teachers group
- 32:40and there was lots of panic.
- 32:42You know, if you take away the
- 32:44writing test, is writing not
- 32:46going to be emphasized? And
- 32:48that couldn't be further from
- 32:50the truth. I mean, to say to an
- 32:52educator that we don't think
- 32:53you're going to teach writing
- 32:54because it's not on the test is
- 32:56not reasonable.
- 32:57>> So how would you assess how
- 32:58well a child can write? Because
- 33:00that is an important
- 33:01communication tool.
- 33:02>> So the district, each
- 33:03district would be able to
- 33:04figure out their own way, and
- 33:06it could be something that is
- 33:08done over the, you know,
- 33:09multiple times during the year.
- 33:11So each district would be able
- 33:13to decide, but.
- 33:15>> They would still have to
- 33:16follow the standards.
- 33:17>> They. Would still have to
- 33:18follow the standards. And I
- 33:19think that the biggest concern
- 33:21from the feedback that I got is
- 33:23that we're in a place with
- 33:24testing, that if it's not
- 33:25tested, people think it doesn't
- 33:27matter. And there are so many
- 33:28things that matter in school
- 33:30that whether or not they're
- 33:33tested, they matter, right? We
- 33:35don't test basic reading on our
- 33:36reading test. We don't test the
- 33:38ability to just pull the words
- 33:40off the page. But that's the
- 33:41most important thing that kids
- 33:43can do before they learn, you
- 33:45know, to have comprehension. So
- 33:47I think this is a great bill.
- 33:49It's the product of a couple of
- 33:51years of really hard work of
- 33:52Commissioner Fletcher in the
- 33:54Kentucky United we learned
- 33:56council. There are some other
- 33:57pieces that they came up with
- 33:59that hopefully we can work in
- 34:02there either this year or in
- 34:04the future. But I think, you
- 34:07know, one of the reasons I ran
- 34:08for office is because of how
- 34:10concerned I was about our
- 34:11testing and accountability
- 34:13system, so I'm all for it.
- 34:14>> Okay. Chairman West, when
- 34:16this gets to you, what are you
- 34:18going to say or do?
- 34:19>> What am I going to do?
- 34:22>> What pieces are you going to
- 34:23add to it? Right.
- 34:24>> Right.
- 34:25>> Right, or take away.
- 34:26>> We this may be an area where
- 34:28we have some common ground.
- 34:30We're going to sift through the
- 34:31bill like we do any other bill.
- 34:33Right. But this is not a new
- 34:36thing that the KDE they've been
- 34:38working on this three, 4 or 5
- 34:39years, something like that. So
- 34:41it's well vetted. We've heard
- 34:44multiple interim committee
- 34:45meetings about this. I like the
- 34:50part that you're that represent
- 34:53Representative Bujnowski is
- 34:54specifically talking about
- 34:56where we look more at growth of
- 34:59the student. I can tell you the
- 35:01Senate perspective is probably
- 35:04we're fine with it, as long as
- 35:06we don't get away from basic
- 35:08accountability. Right? You know,
- 35:09we don't want to stray too far
- 35:11away from making sure districts
- 35:13are accountable for the basics,
- 35:16right? Make sure. And to her
- 35:18point, we are required by the
- 35:20feds to measure that. But I'm
- 35:25hopeful.
- 35:25>> Yeah. You hopeful, Senator
- 35:27Thomas?
- 35:27>> First of all, I had to laugh
- 35:29when you interjected quickly.
- 35:30What? They have to learn how to
- 35:32write, I said, Renee sound like
- 35:34a true journalist, when she
- 35:36makes that point, right? You're
- 35:37like a true journalist. But,
- 35:38you know, it does sound like a
- 35:40good bill. I mean, this is
- 35:42going to be more labor
- 35:43intensive, I got to tell you,
- 35:44that represents Lewis, because
- 35:45when you start looking at the
- 35:47individual child, as opposed as
- 35:48opposed to collective class or
- 35:51collective school, you know,
- 35:52that's really getting down into
- 35:53the details. But that's a good
- 35:55thing. That's a good thing.
- 35:56Because ultimately, what a
- 35:58parent really cares about is,
- 35:59how is my child doing in school?
- 36:02So I applaud you for for doing
- 36:04just that. I applaud you for
- 36:06doing that.
- 36:07>> But that to your point
- 36:08though, that does mean that KDE
- 36:10or whomever is going to have to
- 36:11have some robust metrics in
- 36:14place, and it's going to be
- 36:15very granular to get to the
- 36:16point of measuring the growth
- 36:18of the.
- 36:18>> Individual change. We had
- 36:19growth, so they've already had
- 36:22experience with this. Now, the
- 36:23commissioner.
- 36:24>> What's the difference
- 36:24between change and growth for
- 36:26the average viewer?
- 36:26>> Correct me if I'm wrong.
- 36:28Change would be one group of
- 36:29third graders compared to a
- 36:31different third grade group,
- 36:34and growth is one group of
- 36:36third graders. How do those
- 36:38individual third graders grow
- 36:39into fourth grade? And I
- 36:42believe in the previous
- 36:44regulations, when we had growth,
- 36:45it didn't count as growth
- 36:47unless they bumped up higher
- 36:48than the level they were. And
- 36:51what I want to see is if a
- 36:54third grader scores proficient
- 36:56in third grade and then scores
- 36:59proficient in fourth grade,
- 37:00they have grown because they're
- 37:01scoring proficient on more
- 37:04difficult content. So that's
- 37:06the the commissioner affirmed
- 37:09that that was the intent. And
- 37:10so I look for that to happen.
- 37:12Another piece that's on this
- 37:14bill that has driven some
- 37:16discussion is that the survey
- 37:18that we did would be replaced
- 37:20with a measure of chronic
- 37:22absenteeism.
- 37:23>> And chronic absenteeism is
- 37:25defined as.
- 37:27>> Missing 10% or more, and
- 37:30then it's listed in the bill as
- 37:32excused or unexcused absences.
- 37:34So, you know, we we do have to
- 37:36get our kids in the schools. We
- 37:38have to. But I did have one
- 37:41educator reach out to me and
- 37:42said, we're trying to get them
- 37:44in the schools. We have to go
- 37:45to the courts and get them in
- 37:47the schools. If the courts
- 37:48can't get them in the schools,
- 37:50how are we going to? So there's
- 37:52some concern among educators
- 37:53about that measure. I think we
- 37:56need to get them in the schools.
- 37:58I think it's important, and it
- 38:01looks like it might be about a
- 38:034% portion of the
- 38:05accountability score, like the
- 38:06survey was in the past. So it
- 38:08would be a small amount. So
- 38:10we'll just see what the Senate
- 38:12thinks once we get it through
- 38:13the House.
- 38:14>> I want to revisit a topic we
- 38:16just talked about because this
- 38:17question or comment came in
- 38:18from Warren County, quote,
- 38:19inflicting more politics into
- 38:21educational leadership is
- 38:22simply unnecessary and has
- 38:24dangerous potential to have the
- 38:25Chamber of Commerce involved in
- 38:28superintendent, quote unquote,
- 38:29training or mayor's appointing
- 38:30board members has no merit. It
- 38:32simply makes educational
- 38:34leadership more partizan. I
- 38:35don't see any benefit to
- 38:37students.
- 38:39>> Part of that is is incorrect.
- 38:41Actually, I think what they're
- 38:42referring to is a bill we
- 38:44passed off the floor today,
- 38:45Senate bill. Before I know it's
- 38:47my bill that we passed. It's on
- 38:50principle leadership training.
- 38:52So the chamber already does a
- 38:54program in conjunction with
- 38:56Truist that helps train our
- 38:57principals. So that's what I
- 39:00think the question is with
- 39:01reference to the chamber, with
- 39:03the bill that passed off the
- 39:05floor would be somewhat
- 39:06involved in principle training,
- 39:07not superintendent training.
- 39:08>> Right? Right. Thank you.
- 39:09>> For clarifying. The first
- 39:10part of the question was again.
- 39:12>> That was about that. And
- 39:13then they went on to say
- 39:15training or mayor's appointing
- 39:16boards has no merit. Appointing
- 39:19mayors, appointing board
- 39:20members has no merit.
- 39:21>> I'll just go back to my my
- 39:23comment of earlier. The idea
- 39:25that 114 is the is the first
- 39:28thing that would inject
- 39:29politics into school boards is
- 39:31is not quite accurate. There's
- 39:33there's always going to be a
- 39:35certain level of politics there.
- 39:37And this this just changes the
- 39:39structure of that. Now the, the
- 39:43person who texted in or chimed
- 39:45in, we can disagree. They can
- 39:47say it's a bad policy and I we
- 39:49can disagree on that. And I
- 39:51understand that. But the idea
- 39:53that this is a new political
- 39:55there's no politics involved in
- 39:56school boards.
- 39:58>> Might be able to.
- 39:59>> Agree on accurate.
- 40:00>> Might be able to agree on
- 40:02that point. Maybe, perhaps.
- 40:03Okay. From Martin rivers in
- 40:04Lexington with the line of
- 40:05reasoning to put CEO like power
- 40:07into superintendents hands, why
- 40:09not take this to the state
- 40:11level and give the governor
- 40:12that same authority over the
- 40:14legislature, concentrate
- 40:15spending power with the
- 40:16executive? The Jefferson School
- 40:18District is large. State of
- 40:20Kentucky is larger. Does this
- 40:21make sense? Does it make sense?
- 40:24>> Well, it would probably
- 40:25probably be unconstitutional
- 40:27for us to do that. So no, I
- 40:29don't think it makes sense. And
- 40:31the governor, frankly has
- 40:34executive power. He has a lot
- 40:36of executive power.
- 40:37>> Perhaps a little bit more
- 40:39diminished than when he started.
- 40:40>> It is it is much diminished
- 40:42from when he started. However,
- 40:44with power comes responsibility.
- 40:46And I think we've seen with
- 40:47this governor, he's responsible
- 40:49for running all of our cabinets
- 40:52properly, making sure those
- 40:53happen. And frankly, my
- 40:54experience has been very poor
- 40:55with how many of our cabinets
- 40:57are being operated and the laws
- 40:59are being executed. And so, you
- 41:02know, with power comes
- 41:04responsibility. And so the
- 41:06reason we're here is, is, is
- 41:08this past track record. And
- 41:11we're trying to to change the
- 41:14do you know, it's crazy to do
- 41:17the same thing over and over
- 41:18again. Expect the same result.
- 41:19Right. I think Einstein or
- 41:21someone said that. So so this
- 41:22is an effort by Senator Givens
- 41:25to, to to change change the
- 41:26political dynamic. Important to
- 41:29point out this is Senator
- 41:31Givens bill that's been filed
- 41:33in the Senate. Right. He's one
- 41:37legislator that is allowed to
- 41:38file a bill. It hasn't gone
- 41:40anywhere.
- 41:41>> It's still sitting in the
- 41:42Committee on committees.
- 41:43>> It has not been assigned to
- 41:44a committee Committee. So it's
- 41:47it's there. So, so just there's
- 41:49a lot of bills that have been
- 41:50filed and just sitting there.
- 41:52>> Right.
- 41:52>> Well, you know, I'm going to
- 41:54say something in support of the
- 41:55governor. I'll just say it
- 41:56quickly. Clearly, this governor
- 41:58has done a lot of right things.
- 41:59He got reelected a couple of
- 42:02years ago, and that says a lot
- 42:03about what the people thought
- 42:05about his first term. He's
- 42:06getting a lot of good national
- 42:07press for his record here in
- 42:09Kentucky, particularly in the
- 42:10area of economic development
- 42:11and business. So so he's done a
- 42:13lot of right things, even
- 42:14though, as Senator West
- 42:16admitted, this legislature, the
- 42:18legislature over the past six
- 42:19years have diminished his
- 42:20authority. They've tried to
- 42:21weaken him, and yet he's still
- 42:23coming out strong and and being
- 42:27applauded by the people of
- 42:29Kentucky and now being
- 42:29applauded by the people across
- 42:31this entire country.
- 42:32>> We'll talk a little bit more
- 42:34about one of his major
- 42:35initiatives, which is universal
- 42:37pre-K that House and Senate
- 42:38Democrats announced today. Some
- 42:40takes on what to do there. But
- 42:41I do want to get to one more
- 42:43bill, perhaps about educator
- 42:45compensation. And this is about
- 42:47school administrators and
- 42:50superintendents not getting pay
- 42:51increases that outpace that of
- 42:53classroom teachers. And this
- 42:55may seem like a no brainer for
- 42:56many folks, but I guess the
- 42:58question is, is there not a cap
- 43:01that Senate Republicans would
- 43:02say a superintendent should
- 43:04make? Period.
- 43:07>> We we could do that.
- 43:09>> Or administrators.
- 43:10>> Administrators,
- 43:11administrators.
- 43:12>> Has that been discussed? Is
- 43:15there a concern that Yearwood
- 43:17or Doctor Demetrus Liggins with
- 43:18Fayette County make too much
- 43:20money?
- 43:22>> There's been talk of that.
- 43:24You know, some if you look at
- 43:26some of these compensation
- 43:28packages, especially the fringe,
- 43:30the fringe parts, there has
- 43:32been a lot of discussion of of
- 43:34how rich that is and what, you
- 43:37know, especially after they
- 43:38leave office or leave leave
- 43:41superintendent status that
- 43:42would it cost the pension
- 43:43system to pay them for the rest
- 43:45of their life? There's always
- 43:47talk about those type of things.
- 43:48I haven't really gotten
- 43:50personally too excited about
- 43:51these things. These people hold
- 43:55positions of power and
- 43:56authority, great responsibility,
- 43:58great responsibility, and so.
- 44:00>> And answerable to hundreds.
- 44:02>> Answerable to a lot of
- 44:03people. And their their
- 44:04contracts aren't always for
- 44:07long periods of time. Right. So
- 44:08a lot of times the lifespan of
- 44:10a superintendent isn't isn't
- 44:12always a long period of time.
- 44:13So I don't get too excited
- 44:14about that. But I think this is
- 44:16center Julie Raque Adams bill
- 44:18that we're talking about,
- 44:19Senate Bill two. And the idea
- 44:22is not maybe not necessarily
- 44:24always superintendents, but
- 44:26that that that central office
- 44:30part of the equation seems to
- 44:31have grown in a lot of
- 44:33districts, kind of maybe beyond
- 44:35where it should be. And so it's
- 44:37aimed at central office
- 44:39administrators, which would
- 44:40include superintendents. But I
- 44:43think that's what it's aimed at
- 44:45is if, let's the money that's
- 44:47going into these districts,
- 44:48either through SEEK or other
- 44:50other, other forms, let's,
- 44:52let's try to funnel more of
- 44:54that down to your front line
- 44:56teacher, the one that's really
- 44:58going to make the difference
- 44:59and move, move kids forward.
- 45:01>> I so I just have a thought
- 45:03listening because we've talked
- 45:04about Senate Bill one and
- 45:06giving more authority to the
- 45:08superintendent as chief
- 45:09executive officer of the
- 45:10district with a 1.5 billion
- 45:13budget, I'd like to see what a
- 45:15private sector CEO earns and
- 45:19compare that to what our
- 45:21superintendents are paid. I'd
- 45:23much rather have a study that
- 45:24gives them a market rate for
- 45:27their position. It's hard to
- 45:28find a superintendent. I think
- 45:32Representative Willner was on a
- 45:33superintendent search committee
- 45:34when she was on the JCPS school
- 45:35board, and we need to pay
- 45:40people what we need to pay,
- 45:41just like the private sector,
- 45:42in order to keep good people in
- 45:44the position. So I would like
- 45:46to see something where it's
- 45:47more of a study and how how
- 45:49does how do these
- 45:51responsibilities compare to
- 45:52private sector, and how is the
- 45:54pay balanced between those
- 45:56averages?
- 45:56>> 3.5 years, I think, unless
- 45:58the superintendent.
- 45:59>> Yeah, yeah.
- 46:00>> And then also I may add to
- 46:02that I'll have to look at the
- 46:04bill. But districts are paid
- 46:05off of a salary schedule. So
- 46:07you can't if you give a pay
- 46:09raise of say, 3%, that has to
- 46:12go to every single employee.
- 46:14And same thing with classified.
- 46:15If you get a 3% classified
- 46:18employees, it goes to every
- 46:19single one. So the
- 46:20superintendent might be the
- 46:21only one that's really outside
- 46:22of that with the contract and
- 46:26to Representative Sinofsky's
- 46:29thought there on pay, you know,
- 46:31we probably need to look and
- 46:32see what a similar size
- 46:34district in another state pays
- 46:36and see if it's in the ballpark.
- 46:37That's what I would do if I was
- 46:39a board member.
- 46:40>> That's who they're competing
- 46:41against.
- 46:42>> Yeah, because you are you're
- 46:43competing in a market that has
- 46:45gotten a lot smaller in the
- 46:47last ten years for principals,
- 46:49for teachers, for
- 46:50superintendents. So it's not
- 46:52just the administrators, it's
- 46:54teachers too. If we don't if we
- 46:55don't match what a private pays
- 46:57for a teacher, sometimes we
- 47:00don't get them either. So just
- 47:02a couple of thoughts.
- 47:03>> To be clear, Renee, for the
- 47:05audience out there, all this is
- 47:06handled currently by school
- 47:07boards. And so the legislature
- 47:09does not set pay rates for
- 47:12superintendents. Those are all
- 47:13individual decisions by the
- 47:16various districts. And so if
- 47:17they can, they can form their
- 47:19own search committees and they
- 47:20can look and they can use some
- 47:22of what representative is
- 47:23talking about currently. They
- 47:25can make their own decisions,
- 47:26pretty much pay whatever they
- 47:27want to pay.
- 47:28>> And there are some
- 47:29exceptions in the bill to allow
- 47:31a superintendent or
- 47:32administrator to make hire get
- 47:34a higher increase than what is
- 47:36being given to classroom
- 47:37teachers. In a certain.
- 47:38>> Way, the bill is drafted. If
- 47:39a district feels like, you know,
- 47:41this is the person we have to
- 47:43have and it's essential for our
- 47:44district, all they have to do
- 47:46is apply to the school board
- 47:47for a waiver, and most likely
- 47:50that will be granted.
- 47:51>> As I read the bill, it
- 47:53doesn't limit an initial salary.
- 47:55What it does is it limits
- 47:57percentage pay increases, right?
- 47:59>> Right, right.
- 48:00>> So if you have to pay X
- 48:02number of dollars to hire
- 48:04someone, it wouldn't limit from
- 48:05my reading of the bill you from
- 48:06doing that.
- 48:07>> Right. Right. Just their
- 48:08increase. They just couldn't
- 48:09get a 20% if the others are
- 48:11getting 3% right. That's true.
- 48:13So let's talk about in the time
- 48:14we have remaining Parikh
- 48:16getting back to perhaps the
- 48:17governor's, one of his main
- 48:19initiatives since he has taken
- 48:20office and and today Senate
- 48:23Democrats and House Democrats.
- 48:24And I'll defer to
- 48:26Representative Bujnowski first.
- 48:27What's the plan? What are you
- 48:28proposing this time? And do you
- 48:30think it's more palatable than
- 48:31what's been proposed by the
- 48:32governor?
- 48:33>> Well, so we have filed two
- 48:35different bills, and I filed HB
- 48:38572 and Rep Don worth filed HB
- 48:42574. And they are both to
- 48:45increase the number of children
- 48:46who have access to early
- 48:48childhood preschool education.
- 48:50My bill expands a program we
- 48:54currently have where children
- 48:55can have their household income
- 48:58can be up to 160% of the
- 49:00federal poverty rate, and it
- 49:02increases that to 250%. So it's
- 49:05just an expansion. Don Wirth's
- 49:09bill would be universal pre-K,
- 49:11so it would offer pre-K to all
- 49:13four year olds.
- 49:14>> Who want it, whose parents
- 49:16want it. It's not mandatory.
- 49:18>> Mandatory. It would be an
- 49:19opt in. I think one thing
- 49:21that's really interesting about
- 49:22these bills is that they both
- 49:23have what's called a teaming
- 49:25partner, and that is
- 49:27effectively a public private
- 49:29partnership where schools can
- 49:31subcontract with child care
- 49:33providers. So if I'm a parent
- 49:35and I'm working full time, I
- 49:37might not have the time to drop
- 49:39my child to preschool and pick
- 49:40them up from preschool. They
- 49:42may need all day. Child care,
- 49:43and child care centers can
- 49:46contract if the district
- 49:47chooses to, with local
- 49:49districts, and can run part of
- 49:52these programs through those
- 49:54programs. The other piece is
- 49:55that my bill has a six year
- 49:59time in between when we file,
- 50:03when we would pass the bill,
- 50:05and when this would have to
- 50:06take effect. So if you have a
- 50:10district where you might need
- 50:12to increase capacity to be able
- 50:14to house the classrooms, you
- 50:17have plenty of time to work
- 50:20that all out before before your.
- 50:25Required six years, right? So
- 50:30there has been an appetite in
- 50:31this body for an increase to
- 50:34200%. There has been a bill
- 50:36filed by a Republican in our
- 50:38chamber to increase that. In
- 50:422016. We had a bill that passed
- 50:44both chambers before I was
- 50:45there, president Stivers
- 50:47Speaker Osborne voted for it to
- 50:49increase to 200%. And then
- 50:51Governor Matt Bevin, Line-item
- 50:53vetoed it. So, you know, the
- 50:58research is there, that early
- 50:59childhood education is where
- 51:01we're going to get the most
- 51:02bang for our buck. And one of
- 51:04the conversations we had this
- 51:05afternoon was just how many
- 51:06children come into school who
- 51:07aren't potty trained, who are
- 51:10not potty trained, who come to
- 51:12kindergarten, and they're not
- 51:13special education students, but
- 51:15they don't they haven't learned
- 51:16toileting yet. And so that's
- 51:18just an example of how we
- 51:20really need to better prepare
- 51:22our preschool students for K
- 51:24through 12 education.
- 51:26>> So before I hear from what
- 51:28the Senate Democrats are
- 51:30proposing, this question
- 51:32response from Richmond. Given
- 51:34the widespread poverty and poor
- 51:35educational outcomes across the
- 51:37Commonwealth, high quality
- 51:38universal pre-K education
- 51:39taught by all Caps certified
- 51:42teachers and operated by school
- 51:44districts in parentheses, Knott
- 51:46private daycare would be the
- 51:47single most effective approach
- 51:48to improving education
- 51:49throughout the Commonwealth.
- 51:50Why has this not been adopted
- 51:52immediately? Why is this in any
- 51:54way controversial? Can you
- 51:55answer that with what the
- 51:57Senate Democrats are proposing?
- 51:58>> Well, we're proposing the
- 52:01same kind of two part strategy
- 52:03that Representative Bogdanovsky
- 52:05took place. And I want to go
- 52:07back to something
- 52:08Representative Lewis said,
- 52:08because I think I think he said
- 52:10it better than than I could say
- 52:12it when we were talking earlier
- 52:13and we were talking about, I
- 52:15think House Bill 257
- 52:18Representative Lewis said. And
- 52:18I'm quoting here, I would like
- 52:20to see us do more with our
- 52:21early grades. And this is what
- 52:23Governor Beshear has been
- 52:24pushing since he came into
- 52:25office back in 2019, that we
- 52:27need we need universal pre-K.
- 52:30He's been saying that, and we
- 52:32do Renee as we sit now and and
- 52:35represent Bozinovski laid out
- 52:36all the reasons why, as we sit
- 52:37here now, the majority of
- 52:40states in this country have
- 52:41some form of universal pre-K.
- 52:43We do not. Five of the seven
- 52:46states that are contiguous to
- 52:47us have universal pre-K, but we
- 52:49do not. Why do we have to lag
- 52:51behind? Our children lag behind
- 52:53in trying to do the best we can
- 52:55to see them do more? In the
- 52:57early grades? It's way past
- 53:00time, Renee, that we move this
- 53:02forward. I again, I fully agree
- 53:05with that. With that listener
- 53:07said that we've got to do this
- 53:09if we really want to see our
- 53:11children compete, not just here
- 53:12in Kentucky, not just here in
- 53:14America, but across the world,
- 53:15we've got to get them to school.
- 53:17Earlier.
- 53:17>> Chairman West, as as
- 53:19Representative Borowski pointed
- 53:20out, in 2016, a measure to
- 53:22expand pre-K was passed by
- 53:25Republicans. Then they voted
- 53:26for that. Why not now?
- 53:30>> I think I want to
- 53:31differentiate. There's two
- 53:32distinct differences here. So
- 53:34there's a difference between
- 53:37gently expanding the poverty
- 53:39level for existing pre-K funds.
- 53:44But there's a huge difference
- 53:45between that and universal
- 53:47pre-K. Okay. So we're talking
- 53:48apples and oranges and two two
- 53:50distinct differences. And so I
- 53:52cannot explain what the
- 53:53reasoning was of Governor Bevin
- 53:55at the time except to say, well,
- 53:58I can add one thing. Our budget
- 54:00was in dire straits in 2016. We
- 54:03had huge investments we need to
- 54:05make make in Kentucky Teachers
- 54:06Retirement System, which we did.
- 54:09Our credit rating had been
- 54:11dropping. And so he didn't just
- 54:15veto that. We had significant
- 54:17cuts to other budget areas,
- 54:19post-secondary, for instance.
- 54:20And so it was a different time
- 54:22as far as the budget goes, if
- 54:25we go into universal pre-K, the
- 54:28person who emailed in, I can
- 54:29answer that question
- 54:31specifically. It's it's money,
- 54:33like a funds to do that. I've,
- 54:36I personally spoke with the
- 54:38governor's people on you know
- 54:39we see your proposal. Where's
- 54:41the money coming from. Where is
- 54:43the money coming from for your
- 54:45proposal. And they told me it
- 54:48was coming from the sports
- 54:49gaming funds and the lottery
- 54:51funds. Okay. There's two
- 54:52problems with that. The sports
- 54:54gaming funds are currently in
- 54:56the permanent pension fund. And
- 54:58so those funds are earmarked to
- 55:00go to pay for pension debt. And
- 55:03so do you want to pay for this
- 55:05through pension funds? That's
- 55:07kind of what you're going to
- 55:08have to answer there. Secondly,
- 55:09the lottery funds, all the
- 55:11lottery funds are already
- 55:13delineated for different budget
- 55:14items, mainly education related
- 55:16items like scholarship,
- 55:19post-secondary scholarships and
- 55:20those things. So we haven't had
- 55:22an answer on where the money's
- 55:23coming from. The governor's
- 55:25office has told us we think it
- 55:26will cost $120 million for
- 55:29universal pre-K. I don't think
- 55:31that even begins to touch it. I
- 55:33think, personally, I think that
- 55:34you're more in the 4 to $500
- 55:37million range.
- 55:38>> And real quickly,
- 55:39representative Bozinovski, how
- 55:39much would your plan cost? Do
- 55:41you know, just a.
- 55:42>> Few estimate for 572 is 10
- 55:44million in the first year to
- 55:45set up a computer database
- 55:48system so we can track how the
- 55:50program is working. And then
- 55:5440.5 million in recurring funds
- 55:56to provide access for 9683
- 56:00children.
- 56:00>> Okay. Well, this is an issue
- 56:02we're going to have to take up
- 56:03again at another time. So we
- 56:04didn't get to a lot of issues,
- 56:07but I think education is really
- 56:08going to dominate. So there'll
- 56:09be plenty of opportunities for
- 56:10us to talk about these issues
- 56:12and much more. And our coverage
- 56:14of the 2026 Kentucky General
- 56:15Assembly is on every weeknight
- 56:16at 630 eastern, 530 Central on
- 56:19Kentucky edition. We break it
- 56:20all down for you. And then, of
- 56:22course, Bill Bryant. A team of
- 56:23journalists are here on Friday
- 56:24nights to walk you through it
- 56:26all. Again, thanks for watching
- 56:27tonight. I'm Renee Shaw and
- 56:28I'll see you tomorrow night.