Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Alibi (1929)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:43nominee from 1927 to today. I'm your host, Kyle.
- 0:47And I'm Ryan, and we crushed it. It was so good.
- 0:50I got chills. I feel so good. I don't want to
- 0:54start off on a bad note, but I do want to make
- 0:56sure that we go ahead and get this right out
- 0:57of the gate. Kyle, where were you the night of
- 1:021929? The hit film, Alibi, starring Chester Morris,
- 1:10Harry Stubbs, Mae Bush, and Eleanor Griffith.
- 1:13Does the person that you're with have the perfect
- 1:17excuse and proof of two ticket stubs to that
- 1:21showing? I went alone, so I feel like I'm in
- 1:24danger. Not a good look. Nobody wanted to go
- 1:28see this movie with me? It's not my fault, man.
- 1:31Well, you know what? This is why you always need
- 1:34an alibi. You're right. And I'll have one for
- 1:37next time. We have one today. We do. We had to
- 1:40watch this movie because it's the movie we're
- 1:43talking about. This is our third. No, fourth.
- 1:47Our fourth. We'll get there. Our fourth nominee
- 1:51that we've talked about for this year's Academy
- 1:53Awards for the 1930 Academy Award ceremony. So,
- 1:58Alibi. Yeah. Alibi was an interesting one. You
- 2:01know, we've had our, well, the Patriot that we
- 2:04couldn't watch famously. Talked about Lost Media.
- 2:06We had In Old Arizona, our Western that was truly
- 2:10set outdoors and filmed outdoors. Yeehaw. Yeehaw,
- 2:13indeed. And then we had our musical, our first
- 2:17talking musical in the Broadway melody that we
- 2:20talked about. We'll do one, only one this time.
- 2:22It says you. It says me. And now we have The
- 2:25Racket 2. Yeah, yeah. I mean, we've got a gangster
- 2:29movie for sure. Yeah. Although, as I say that...
- 2:32I almost want to call it a crime movie instead.
- 2:36I don't know if there's a huge distinction, but
- 2:39it didn't feel like your typical like Muggsy,
- 2:44as we said earlier with the racket, that type
- 2:47of gangster movie. Well, it was missing the Nick
- 2:50Scarcy of it all, right? From the racket, like
- 2:53that was a movie that was really hinging on the
- 2:55performance of that Nick Scarcy character. And
- 2:58this is more just crime in general. There's not
- 3:01really one like, figurehead of the of the crime
- 3:04that's happening it's more just a criminal in
- 3:07place of it yeah and that criminal being the
- 3:10closest thing to the head at least who you're
- 3:13following doesn't have anywhere near the same
- 3:15charisma no that lewis wolheim presented to nick
- 3:19scarcy correct but we're kind of getting right
- 3:22into the nitty -gritty with this one well Let's
- 3:24go back a little bit. Let's talk about the movie
- 3:27itself. So, Alibi had a couple names that it
- 3:29was known by, right? The Perfect Alibi or Nightstick,
- 3:31but most commonly it's known as Alibi. It was
- 3:35directed by Roland West. 1929, it is, to your
- 3:39earlier point, a crime film, and it was starring
- 3:42Chester Morris and Mae Bush. Mae Bush being a
- 3:46huge silent film star. Really? Yes. I have not
- 3:50seen her in anything, but she was, like, She
- 3:54was a big, big name. So was this one of the first
- 3:57examples of someone coming and transitioning
- 4:00from silent film to talkie specifically? Like
- 4:03a well -known actor of the time? It might be
- 4:07as far as like a silent star name that would
- 4:12bring in the crowds. Yes. Could very well be.
- 4:15Interesting. Yeah. That being said, she's not
- 4:18really a highlight in this movie. She's not.
- 4:20A name you... I didn't bring up either in our
- 4:24little gag at the beginning, is Regis Toomey.
- 4:27The only reason I had silence is I was going
- 4:29to make a joke about Regis Toomey. Oh, okay.
- 4:32But yeah, that's fine. Go ahead. We locked eyes
- 4:34like we were both waiting for the other one.
- 4:37So there's a couple people, right? The main cast
- 4:39here being Chester Morris, Eleanor Griffith is
- 4:42a very big part of it, Regis Toomey, to your
- 4:44point, and Mae Bush. And Harry Stubbs. And Harry
- 4:47Stubbs. Yes. Great name. I like it. Yeah. Very
- 4:51descriptive. Yeah. All of these names. I mean,
- 4:55really the big names on the poster and everything
- 4:58are going to be Chester Morris as your lead villain
- 5:01gangster and May Bush. That being said, Regis
- 5:05Toomey really is kind of the highlight of this
- 5:10movie, I think. Whether you like his performance
- 5:13or not, he's putting on the biggest spectacle.
- 5:17And let's get into the characters. So in our
- 5:20cast, we have Chester Morris, who does play Chick
- 5:22Williams, the titular criminal that you mentioned
- 5:25earlier. Eleanor Griffith is his love interest.
- 5:27She's very much head over heels when we first
- 5:29meet her, and she's very excited to marry him,
- 5:32much to the displeasure of her father, the police
- 5:35sergeant Pete Manning, played by Pernell Pratt.
- 5:38Mae Bush is in it as well as Daisy Thomas, and
- 5:41you mentioned Regis Toomey, who does play Danny
- 5:44McGann, but also Billy Morgan. There's a reason
- 5:47for that name difference there that we'll get
- 5:50into in a little bit here. So the main play characters
- 5:53that we need to know about is Chick Williams.
- 5:55We see his relationship with Joan, and we see
- 5:59that much to the displeasure of her father, who
- 6:03is very much adamant at proving that this is
- 6:04a bad idea, right? Police sergeant. He knows
- 6:08that Chick, I mean, very beginning of the movie,
- 6:10Chick is coming out of prison. And like, this
- 6:13is like, hey, he's different. He's fine now.
- 6:15Don't worry about it. And the police sergeant,
- 6:17her father, is just like, this is just not going
- 6:19to happen. But guess what? It happens. And movie
- 6:23begins. And that's the movie from there. The
- 6:25central plot of this movie is that there is a
- 6:28murder that happens of a police officer, right?
- 6:31There's a robbery that's happening of seemingly
- 6:33fur coats. Yes. Right. So fur coats are being
- 6:37stolen. A police officer stops it. There's a
- 6:40scene that I actually really like that. I don't
- 6:43think they invented this. I think this is just
- 6:44what they did back then. Everyone had the billy
- 6:47clubs, and they would start banging it on the
- 6:49loudest thing they could find and using that
- 6:51as essentially a police siren to notify other
- 6:54police officers that something was happening.
- 6:56So I kind of liked that scene a lot of how he
- 6:58started notifying people and he had them cornered.
- 7:00But then someone... Just you see a hand come
- 7:03out and shoot the police officer. He dies and
- 7:06then everyone gets away and they find this police
- 7:08officer. Chick Williams is the first person that
- 7:11they come to and say, well, hey, we need to know
- 7:13where you were because we suspect that you were
- 7:15the one to kill this man. And he says the very
- 7:18beginning, actually a little suspiciously close
- 7:20to what you said at the beginning of the episode
- 7:21of where you were, that he was at the theater
- 7:23with Joan. So he couldn't have done it. And Joan
- 7:26even has the ticket stubs to prove, yeah, this
- 7:28is where we were. So this is his. alibi so to
- 7:32speak right and that's the central part of this
- 7:34point of this movie is he has the proof of why
- 7:37he wasn't there so how could it be him right
- 7:40and the movie continues with you wondering well
- 7:43then who really did this how could this have
- 7:44happened if he really was at that location so
- 7:47before we get any further i want to point out
- 7:50something that happens in the very beginning
- 7:52of the movie there's an opening sequence and
- 7:54i remember i texted you this and i i can't remember
- 7:57the exact phrase that i said but there is something
- 7:59about how haunting the opening sequences. Right,
- 8:03yeah. And not just one shot, but, you know, we're
- 8:05in the prison, and after the title card shows
- 8:08up, there's a guard who's standing outside of
- 8:10these prison cells, and he, I think, blows a
- 8:13whistle, and then these doors open, and all you
- 8:16see is the doors. And then the doors, almost
- 8:18not even closed, retract. And as they retract,
- 8:22it shows all of the prisoners standing there.
- 8:24And it just feels very, like, scary and haunting
- 8:28and dark. And then... Once all the prisoners
- 8:30are walking, one of the guards pulls Chick aside
- 8:34and tells him to, like, go to, like, the mail
- 8:36room to pick something up. So then we cut to
- 8:38Chick in the mail room, and it's this extremely
- 8:41wide shot, right? It's a large room, almost like
- 8:45a warehouse that's just for the mail room. And
- 8:49it's Chick talking to someone else. You can barely
- 8:51hear what he's actually saying. And they're exchanging,
- 8:54you know, a package. There's like a change of
- 8:56clothes and a card and everything. And that opening
- 8:58sequence of that hallway and then that large
- 9:01room, I remember telling you, like, this is like
- 9:04horror movie stuff. Like, it's very disarming.
- 9:09is how it feels. And there's no music to accompany
- 9:11it that makes it feel kind of like, you know,
- 9:13hey, this is a little brighter than you think
- 9:14it is right now. And we're playing this a little
- 9:16more mysterious and mischievously. Yeah. No,
- 9:18it's just like kind of just haunting. It's just
- 9:21that image. You hear the clacking, you hear people
- 9:23moving, like it's a decision to be made, which
- 9:27is interesting because the rest of this movie
- 9:28is a thriller, but isn't really that scary or
- 9:32like that haunting. And I just, I can't stop
- 9:35thinking about that opening image. Like that
- 9:37to me was the best part of the movie because
- 9:40it felt audacious and something they didn't have
- 9:42to do. How did it affect you? So it's really
- 9:45interesting. It did feel a lot like a horror
- 9:48movie. Like you said, it felt very reminiscent
- 9:51of something like Nosferatu or The Cabinet of
- 9:54Dr. Caligari. There's a lot of German expressionism
- 9:57in this with really harsh angles and things and
- 10:01wide open spaces. A lot of playing with shadows
- 10:04and light. which is so cool to see in a black
- 10:07and white film. We talked about it last episode,
- 10:10the unique uses of sound other than just speech
- 10:13and dialogue, banging on the prison cells and
- 10:17things, and the ticking of the clock and all
- 10:19of that, and the lack of music in what should
- 10:22easily be a, oh, we'll just throw in music because
- 10:25now we can do that. But choosing to use sound
- 10:27effects adds to just that really harsh atmosphere
- 10:31that's created in the opening of the movie. The
- 10:35opening of this movie might be my favorite thing
- 10:38that we'll watch all this Academy season. I mean,
- 10:41I only have one more to go, right? Yeah. But
- 10:44like, it's easily the highlight of mine. I think
- 10:46that we have existed in a time period of this
- 10:50year where we're watching a lot of, you know,
- 10:53we're trying to figure this out. right yeah we
- 10:56got this new technology bear with us we're figuring
- 10:58it out and we're kind of giving like kudos to
- 11:00it right i think there's to your point some great
- 11:02shots in old arizona of like them running there
- 11:05isn't a shot specifically but it's just like
- 11:06the idea of being able to capture this that looks
- 11:09great so imagine my surprise when alibi comes
- 11:13around and they're not even experimenting with
- 11:15something they're just kind of like going for
- 11:17it right right like two shots like back to back
- 11:20and those shots really aren't seen You might
- 11:23be able to make the argument that the robbery
- 11:25scene where the police officer is shot. There's
- 11:28some in that, but I think it's more the way they
- 11:30play with shadow. And I really liked the way
- 11:32they play with shadow, but just that opening
- 11:34sequence to me, you hit it like nail in the head,
- 11:39like with the, um, The German expressionist side.
- 11:42Like, it's just, it's very, like, there's a lot
- 11:44of space. We want you to look around. We don't
- 11:47want you to just be focused on one thing. The
- 11:48black and white element lends itself to it very
- 11:51heavily because it adds that level of darkness,
- 11:55quite literally, in the shadows. So it just,
- 11:57it prepared me for something that I was just
- 12:00not ready for. Yeah. And I don't think it's a
- 12:03spoiler to say that it doesn't really continue
- 12:06beyond that. The tone of the movie itself doesn't
- 12:10really lend itself to those opening shots, in
- 12:13my opinion. That's true. The way it does feel
- 12:16oppressive and like a horror movie, even though
- 12:18it's so spacious in those opening shots, that
- 12:22tone kind of goes away. But I don't think that
- 12:25the blocking and your angles and things disappear
- 12:29completely. True. It's just presenting a different
- 12:32atmosphere later on. Yes. I think that... Whoever
- 12:37was doing set design for the prison popped off.
- 12:40Oh, let's talk about that real quick. Yeah. The
- 12:43nominations for this movie, of course, it has
- 12:45Outstanding Picture, Best Actor for Chester Morris,
- 12:48which we'll talk about in a moment. But the art
- 12:50direction, the nominee there is William Cameron
- 12:53Menzies. My guy, Menzies. That is a name that's
- 12:56going to pop up many, many times as we cover.
- 12:59Menzies, Menzies time. Exactly. I like it. That's
- 13:02good. He was nominated for six Academy Awards
- 13:05throughout the course of his career. Spoiler
- 13:07alert, he receives an honorary Oscar for his
- 13:10work on Gone with the Wind eventually. So, I
- 13:12mean, this is arguably one of the biggest names
- 13:16that we will talk about up to this point on the
- 13:19show. And like you're saying, the prison scene
- 13:23and everything as far as the set designs and
- 13:26not just like your practical sets that appear
- 13:29later on in like the club scenes and things.
- 13:33The end of this movie, when you're on the rooftops
- 13:35and the paintings of the skyline in the background,
- 13:39they don't look real per se, but they're done
- 13:43in a way that I think adds to this overall feel
- 13:47of the film. There's a scene right after that,
- 13:50too, at the very end where someone's jumping
- 13:53a building, right? And then you see in between
- 13:56the buildings, we're kind of in an overhead shot,
- 13:57and you see between the two buildings, and it's
- 14:00clearly a painting. right something they've drawn
- 14:02and you're right you can depict that like you
- 14:05can detect that it is not uh actually between
- 14:08two buildings but there is still that little
- 14:10bit of you that kind of like your breath is taken
- 14:12away just a little bit when someone like slips
- 14:13right where it's like oh you're gonna fall down
- 14:15there so i agree the art direction was like doing
- 14:18some incredible work on this so all credit to
- 14:21menzies for that it's very exciting to kind of
- 14:23like be able to identify these scenarios where
- 14:27the camera the cinematography and the art design
- 14:29work so well together and then find out well
- 14:32there's icons yeah these are icons in the beginning
- 14:35i think it's really cool too that the director
- 14:39roland west wasn't nominated for this and while
- 14:42obviously he's doing some great work and saying
- 14:45you know this is the shot i want here and this
- 14:47is the shot i want there you could not capture
- 14:50more than half of these shots if it wasn't for
- 14:53the art decoration and the set designs. 100%.
- 14:56So I think it is very, very accurate that the
- 14:59Academy would nominate William Cameron Menzies
- 15:02and maybe not Roland West. And that might have
- 15:05to do with, I don't know, the overall plot line.
- 15:08Well, no. The plot's not bad in this movie and
- 15:11the performances aren't bad. I just really like
- 15:14the art direction. Yeah. There's a lot of good
- 15:18in it, right? I think that it set me up for...
- 15:23The word I'm looking for, false expectations
- 15:25of what to expect from a movie when that's the
- 15:28opening. Yeah. Right. So what continues is the
- 15:31story that we mentioned. We'll pick back up with
- 15:34Chick being accused of this crime and him having
- 15:39the alibi of why he couldn't be there. What's
- 15:42done shortly after is they want to make sure
- 15:44they have an informant in on Chick's side. So
- 15:48they bring in a specific officer of theirs that's
- 15:51going to be Danny McGann. I believe Danny McGann
- 15:54is actually his name to Chick and Billy Morgan
- 15:57is his name to the police department. Police.
- 16:01Because we hear Danny McGann way more than we
- 16:03hear Billy Morgan. Yeah. Yeah. So Danny is actually
- 16:08a pretty great bit of casting because Regis Toomey
- 16:10plays Danny as this alcoholic. Like he's just
- 16:15kind of there. He just happens to be here. In
- 16:17the very beginning, he has a moment with Joan
- 16:20where he tries to like talk to her about a magic
- 16:23trick. And the magic trick is that he just happens
- 16:25to get her address. And now he knows where she
- 16:28resides. Right. Which you're arrested. Like in
- 16:322025, if you try that, you're under arrest. Right.
- 16:35insane thing that happened and the police sergeant
- 16:38that was one of my favorite scenes when the he
- 16:40says that and he's like just wanted to see where
- 16:42you reside the police sergeant's almost kind
- 16:44of like got her right it's like do something
- 16:48like what is what anyways so he kind of like
- 16:53makes himself the fool and he very much is playing
- 16:55the fool and finds himself into chick's group
- 17:01And maybe Chick feels bad for him, we don't fully
- 17:03know, but he just lets him in there because he's
- 17:04so unassuming. Yeah. And that's the perfect bit
- 17:08of casting for me, or at least the best role
- 17:11that I saw, was the duality that Regis got to
- 17:14play as Danny. And the other character's name
- 17:17I already forgot. Morgan? Billy? Billy. So Billy
- 17:20and... Danny. Danny. I already can't... I got
- 17:24one name at a time and that's it. So Billy and
- 17:26Danny... And the duality of those two characters
- 17:28I thought was really, really well done. Yes.
- 17:31And I loved that. In a movie that otherwise was
- 17:34kind of filled with the, even if it's not technically
- 17:37a gangster movie, the mob mentality of like,
- 17:40you know, listen here, see, like that caricature
- 17:44of it. Yep. Danny was a nice bit of like a bright
- 17:48spot of, hey, there are plenty of alcoholics
- 17:51in this, but I know what you're doing. And I
- 17:53see what you're doing. I thought he played that
- 17:55really well. It's such a unique performance that
- 17:58not just like that character and like playing
- 18:02a drunk we haven't seen before, but a really...
- 18:06The duality of it. The duality, yeah. Complex
- 18:09performance is what I'm thinking. Because the
- 18:13only other kind of drunk performance we've had
- 18:18was in Wings. Oh, yeah. That turned into a whole
- 18:21Bubbles thing. Yeah. Which is, you know, played
- 18:26for laughs and very funny. And because this is
- 18:29a talking picture, you go from a silent film
- 18:32portraying a drunk kind of stumbling every once
- 18:36in a while and probably like hiccuping in an
- 18:39intertitle card. And there's none of that with
- 18:42Regis Toomey's performance. He is slurring his
- 18:45words in a way that's, you almost get like a
- 18:49little annoyed because you're like, man, he is
- 18:51hamming it up. Yeah. But I think. He's so smarmy
- 18:56and slimy as this drunk gangster that when he
- 19:02does shift back into Billy, it catches you off
- 19:07guard and you're like, oh, wow, that's fantastic
- 19:10the way he's doing both. Yeah. It's great, too,
- 19:13because I think you kind of have to have that
- 19:15little bit of sliminess because Chick isn't the
- 19:18dumb criminal. Yes. Right? He wants to make sure
- 19:22that whoever he's bringing in isn't just some
- 19:24like, you know, liability, but he is actually
- 19:26kind of like a sleazy guy. So when Danny plays
- 19:29himself as like, you know, yeah, I'm drunk and
- 19:31I don't know any better, but also I'm kind of
- 19:33a little bit sleazy here on how I got phone numbers
- 19:35and stuff. Yeah. That makes Chick feel like he
- 19:37can trust him a little bit more. So all of that
- 19:39is done very well. I gotta say that's probably
- 19:43where the most of my praise ends. Of the movie.
- 19:45Okay. To me, it feels like it just, it goes on
- 19:48a little long. The relationship between Joan
- 19:52and Chick feels very depending on the scene.
- 19:56Like Chick's advance, not advances, but like
- 19:59feelings towards Joan really does depend on the
- 20:02scene itself. This is also an example where in
- 20:06the same year where I feel like Broadway Melody
- 20:08did a pretty great job of having, you know, a
- 20:10microphone that was going to be pretty central.
- 20:14to where everyone could be in one room and speak
- 20:16and hear pretty well, there's a number of occasions
- 20:19where people are standing just off -center of
- 20:23where the microphone should be, and you really
- 20:25can't hear them. And thank God for closed captionings.
- 20:29But in this case, that wasn't really a thing
- 20:31back then. And when YouTube is trying to put
- 20:33closed captions on it now, it can only use captionings
- 20:36based on what it hears. And it doesn't hear that
- 20:39well because it's not captured that well on microphone.
- 20:41Yeah. To a point where it's almost like there's
- 20:43points that aren't even on microphone where people
- 20:46are speaking. So it's difficult because this
- 20:50is a movie where you need to know everyone and
- 20:51what they're saying. And it's lost. So I didn't
- 20:54have a great experience with the rest of it,
- 20:56which was a shame because it looked incredible.
- 20:59Yes. And to your point. When they're inside buildings,
- 21:03they're finding the best angles of those. But
- 21:05it's really when the art direction is allowed
- 21:07to go off, the set direction is allowed to really
- 21:09go and explore and have these scenarios like
- 21:11these outdoor robberies at night or these prisons.
- 21:17I still don't understand why the mailroom is
- 21:19that big. But a mailroom that's the size of a
- 21:21Costco. That is when the movie really excelled
- 21:25to me. But I will say that there is a scene later
- 21:27on towards the end where the confrontation between
- 21:29Danny and Chick that I thought was pretty harrowing
- 21:34and thrilling that really got me back into it.
- 21:36So overall, we'll get more into the movie, but
- 21:39overall, how did you feel about your return visit
- 21:42to Alibi? It's so funny. I mentioned Broadway
- 21:45Melody and how I liked it so much less on a rewatch
- 21:49this time. I felt the exact opposite on my rewatch
- 21:52of Alibi. It's gorgeous. It's the best looking
- 21:56movie that we've watched maybe up to this point
- 22:00in the show. Roland West is doing stuff. And
- 22:04again, credit to William Cameron Menzies. They're
- 22:07just getting creative behind the camera. And
- 22:09it's so effective. And I love all of that. And
- 22:13I think that the story itself is engaging enough.
- 22:16Again, it is hard to tell what's going on at
- 22:18times. So I can't discredit that complaint. But
- 22:22I had a lot of fun watching this. Yeah, I don't
- 22:25know. It kept me engaged in a way that I don't
- 22:27think it did the first time. So, overall, I'm
- 22:30a fan of Alibi. I think I am, too. I mean, we
- 22:34talked about this on the last episode, but for
- 22:36me, it's less so, is this movie trying to insult
- 22:41my intelligence, and more, did I have a good
- 22:42time? Right. Right? So, I'm not going to rate
- 22:45it like, hey, I thought it was kind of boring.
- 22:47There's one star. Like, I'm going to give it
- 22:49its credit where it's due. For sure. But this
- 22:52one specifically just did not sit with me as
- 22:54well as the others have. Yeah. Despite me liking
- 22:57some aspects of it better than the other movies.
- 23:00It felt like it didn't fully handle the Chick
- 23:05and Joan of it all. I would have wanted to see
- 23:07a little bit more of them proper to feel like
- 23:10that's actually a thing. Because the way we're
- 23:12introduced to them is like Chick is out of prison
- 23:14and Joan is just like, yeah, that's my guy. Like,
- 23:17well, hold on. Like, how did he become your guy?
- 23:19Like, why is he your guy? Show me like you guys
- 23:21out on the town, like something that establishes
- 23:23you too. So I can fall back on this and not just
- 23:27the whole daddy doesn't want me to like be with
- 23:29you thing. Yeah. It's, it's really interesting
- 23:31too, because at any point, were you under the
- 23:35impression that, oh, Chick, Chick is actually
- 23:38a good guy. Maybe he was wrongfully in prison
- 23:40kind of thing, or right from the get go, was
- 23:43your impression of Chick that he is a bad? guy
- 23:46uh it was kind of half and half half and half
- 23:49in the sense that my impression from the get
- 23:51-go with that opening scene and the guard pulling
- 23:54him in and then him going to that large room
- 23:56putting on a suit and everything i was like okay
- 23:58well he was in prison like i need to know a little
- 24:01bit more about why he was in prison before i
- 24:03started doing this but then the movie wants you
- 24:05to think that he's okay yes the movie wants you
- 24:07to think that he is capable of change and things
- 24:10can get better but i never was fully convinced
- 24:12of that Because I was always remembering maybe
- 24:15because that shot was so like captivating and
- 24:18haunting that I'm not like if it was shot differently
- 24:21and we're like more close ups on him looking
- 24:23like mournful and like, you know, remorseful
- 24:25that he was in this situation. Maybe we'd be
- 24:29able to piece together like, OK, well, he didn't
- 24:31want to be here like he's a good guy. But because
- 24:34that shot specifically of him picking up his
- 24:36belongings was so haunting. You're uneasy. So
- 24:40then anything involving that actor who was in
- 24:42that scene makes you feel uneasy. So for the
- 24:45whole time, I was just like, no, there's something
- 24:48up with you, dog. And I think that's almost perfect.
- 24:51That's what the movie is kind of pushing you
- 24:54to feel. Because while he does seem like a nice
- 24:58guy when you're first introduced to him and Joan,
- 25:00he does have this complete character shift, almost.
- 25:04on the same level, at least from a character
- 25:07standpoint, as Regis Toomey's character, just
- 25:09not as showboaty in a way. Yeah. Let's talk about
- 25:13Chester Morris in general. Yeah. Because he was
- 25:16nominated for Best Actor in this movie, and do
- 25:19you personally feel like his performance was
- 25:22deserving of that nomination? I thought he was
- 25:25capital F fine. Yes. Not bad, but he was certainly
- 25:29there. Yeah. He goes on in his career to kind
- 25:34of live in this gangster role. And I think he
- 25:38plays it well. And this might be me looking back
- 25:41from 2025 and all of that. It's such a stereotypical
- 25:46character. You get into that, oh, well, we've
- 25:49seen it before. We've seen a better kind of thing.
- 25:51So while he does a good job having Regis Toomey's
- 25:55performance in this, it's hard to sing praises
- 25:59for Chester. He's a good gangster. He's just
- 26:01not my favorite gangster. Yeah. I mean, I think
- 26:05that he is extremely handsome, and I think he
- 26:07plays that part very well. That's why you can't
- 26:10really blame Joan too much when she's like, no,
- 26:11that's my guy. It's like, I get it. A dude named
- 26:14Chick, though, to me, that's like Cars. I forget
- 26:18the Cars character's name is Chick, but I'm just
- 26:21going to always think of that character, and
- 26:23I just don't really think of that as an attractive
- 26:26character to me. So hearing his name is Chick,
- 26:29I was just like, that's... Because this is like
- 26:31seemingly set around Chicago, right? So like
- 26:34Chick to me sounds like a very Southern name.
- 26:37So I'm just, I have questions for Chick, the
- 26:40character. Now, why don't you have a problem
- 26:42with Chico? I think I did have a problem with
- 26:46Chico. Did you? Oh, never mind. So I think at
- 26:50the time I was like, oh, that's interesting.
- 26:51Let's get back to that. And then he just kept
- 26:52talking about being a remarkable fellow. And
- 26:55I was like, okay, yeah. Chico, I'm going to keep
- 26:58you to the sideline right now. You tried to get
- 27:01me. You're not going to get me on that one. Oops.
- 27:03You'll get me on something else. Don't worry.
- 27:04Yeah. I was just always kind of under the impression
- 27:08that he was not a great guy, whether he was trying
- 27:12to do better or not. That was the question. But
- 27:16I thought that he did really well in that role
- 27:19specifically. I thought that Chester Morris was
- 27:21adequate. And that's nothing bad. But I think
- 27:25it's just in a movie where... Sorry, in a style
- 27:29of movie where you really need to be making a
- 27:31splash, I felt like no one really was doing that
- 27:34except for Regis Toomey. I thought Regis Toomey
- 27:37was kind of like the y 'all mind if I go a little
- 27:39ham on this one. Right, right. As far as the
- 27:41best moment for Chester Morris, I think that
- 27:45other than, again, these are scenes that aren't
- 27:49super exciting because of our year 2025, but
- 27:54his gangster... dialogue and monologues and things
- 27:57towards the end of the film when they've got
- 27:59him in a room and they're like okay this is it
- 28:02you're done and he's kind of panicking and freaking
- 28:05out and begging for his life that's definitely
- 28:07a highlight for me of his performance that is
- 28:09for me too Because you're watching the entire
- 28:11time. You're watching him being cold and calculated
- 28:13and in control. So one of my favorite reveals
- 28:16is that when you find someone, this is the difference
- 28:18of Nick Scarcy, right? Like Nick Scarcy and the
- 28:20racket. When he was not in control, he was just
- 28:23kind of like, all right, you know what? I guess
- 28:24I'll just get out of here. And like makes a plan
- 28:26to get out of there. But this time when Chick
- 28:29is cornered and told, well, hey, you have nowhere
- 28:31else to go. You start seeing like an actual like
- 28:34weasel. Yes. Like he just he starts like weaseling
- 28:37around like, well, how can I get out of here?
- 28:39And what can I do? And can I use her to my advantage?
- 28:41And like, can I like get other people hurt in
- 28:44order to do this? Like you see him just thinking
- 28:46of like he's in desperation mode. Right. And
- 28:49that's something you haven't seen from him before.
- 28:51So I thought that was great because it was completely
- 28:52like the 180 of how he's playing this guy. But
- 28:56it shows it doesn't feel like, you know, I did
- 28:58it just to do it. it felt like, well, hey, this
- 29:01guy who likes to be in control and everything,
- 29:03he needs that. Because without that, he's flailing.
- 29:06Right. So I loved that scene. Yeah, it's cool,
- 29:08too, because you have Chick with Joan at the
- 29:11beginning, where he's genuinely a nice guy, so
- 29:15he seems. Then you have his gangster version,
- 29:17and then you've got he is a scared animal backed
- 29:20into a corner. Yep, 100%. So it is impressive,
- 29:24his performance. the amount of different feelings
- 29:28he's able to evoke in the audience. It's just,
- 29:33again, interesting. Regis Toomey in this movie
- 29:36not getting nominated. But I don't think that
- 29:39there was a best supporting category yet. Not
- 29:42to that point. And I think that they recognized
- 29:45that enough actors were doing that, where it's
- 29:47like, hey, maybe you weren't lead, but you were
- 29:49really doing your best work there. And that's
- 29:51when supporting came to be. Yeah. You know, I
- 29:54also just realized that the Cars character who
- 29:57I was thinking of is named Chick Hicks. Oh. So.
- 30:00That definitely skews it Southern. Yeah, skews
- 30:02it very Southern for me. Just don't hear of many
- 30:05Chick names in Chicago. No. So I agree with you.
- 30:09I think that he does do a really good job. And
- 30:11it's specifically that ending is my favorite
- 30:13or that ending sequence is my favorite scene
- 30:17of Chick. of him just like desperation mode you
- 30:21nailed it like just animalistic like just survival
- 30:24like how do i get out of this yeah and not even
- 30:27like him thinking uh to himself he's almost thinking
- 30:30out loud of just like reaching for things and
- 30:32like his body is just moving in different directions
- 30:34yeah so and i love how you can kind of follow
- 30:37his eyes to see the light switch and like know
- 30:40as soon as someone's distracted i can hit that
- 30:42light switch and i think that sequence that's
- 30:44filmed in the dark is incredible as well because
- 30:47it could have just been gunshot noises like pitch
- 30:50black and you have to assume what's happening
- 30:52but you're watching it happen and it's filmed
- 30:54by moonlight of like them trying to scour and
- 30:58like capture him and everything he even throws
- 31:00a i'm not sure what it is he throws up like a
- 31:03pot or something out the window to break the
- 31:05glass so they all start shooting out the window
- 31:07which i thought was just classic 1920 that's
- 31:11yeah That's an interesting moment, too, though,
- 31:13as far as the character development of Joan,
- 31:16because I believe she's the one that tells them,
- 31:20oh, he's gone out the window. And she provides
- 31:23his escape because they all go to shoot out the
- 31:25window. Am I wrong in that? You are misremembering
- 31:27just a little bit. I thought she was going to
- 31:30do that. But at this point, she's seen his true
- 31:32character. Sure. So she's back on the side of
- 31:35like, my dad was right. So he throws the pot
- 31:37at the window and all the guys are like, okay,
- 31:39it's time to go. But as he throws the pot at
- 31:41the window, he goes out the door. And she said
- 31:43he went out the door. Oh, okay. So then they
- 31:46go after him and chase him up. staircase to the
- 31:50roof of the building so she does kind of like
- 31:54she does she does try to keep an eye on him but
- 31:56it's just kind of happenstance where she notices
- 31:58that the door flies open and she's like oh he
- 31:59went out the door so i thought the same thing
- 32:01that she was going to like defend him because
- 32:03she kind of spends the whole movie defending
- 32:05him right yeah but i think truly seeing him in
- 32:08that animalistic nature of like what do i do
- 32:10that's true colors yeah and for her i think that
- 32:13was like you know okay i i know where my allegiance
- 32:16lies here now Yeah, that definitely would have
- 32:19been a moment in modern version of this where
- 32:22great character development for Joan of, oh,
- 32:25do I give them half a second to get away or do
- 32:28I tell them they went out the window? Maybe I
- 32:31was reaching for that. And inadvertently, she
- 32:33kind of does give him half a second. Yeah. Just
- 32:35because, again, they're shooting out the window.
- 32:37Again, I don't know who you think you're getting,
- 32:40but they're shooting out the window, and she's
- 32:41like, he's out the door. And they're like, oh,
- 32:44okay, cool. And she inadvertently gives him half
- 32:46a second, but still. Which then leads to the
- 32:50scene that I was referring to earlier, where
- 32:51Chick is escaping and he's running on top of
- 32:54the buildings. And he jumps from one building
- 32:56to the other. And we watch him jump from a building
- 32:58with a horizontal angle. And then as he jumps
- 33:01on that building, we now have a vertical angle
- 33:03of that same building. But now you see in between
- 33:06the buildings he's jumping between. And you see,
- 33:10you know, I think the entire time it's art. It
- 33:14is artwork in between. But as he lands on the
- 33:18second building, he loses his footing and then
- 33:20falls. And there's a slight cut, and then it's
- 33:23what must be a dummy just falling down that wall.
- 33:27And I thought that was a pretty dark scene. Like,
- 33:30we hadn't really seen a gruesome death like that
- 33:34depicted. Granted, of a character who deserved
- 33:36it, right? A criminal. nonetheless like i thought
- 33:39that was very like dark unexpected scene that
- 33:42kind of was a nice bookend to the beginning of
- 33:44like you know the emptiness of this room and
- 33:47like how alone you are you are there and like
- 33:49how you're just like kind of like rank and file
- 33:51and the routine of you following this um pattern
- 33:54and then at the end it's just you alone and just
- 33:57falling so i thought that was a really nice bookend
- 34:01that that movie did. I'm growing more kind of
- 34:04it, or more fond of it, the more that I discuss
- 34:06it in its cinematography. But it's really the
- 34:10beginning and the end that I think it really
- 34:12shines. And the middle, to me, just kind of is
- 34:15Regis Toomey's movie. Right, yeah. And although
- 34:19he wasn't nominated, I do want to talk specifically
- 34:21about his performance, towards the end of his
- 34:24character's performance, I guess. He... Has this
- 34:28big reveal where finally the gangsters are all
- 34:30on to him. And they call him out. They're getting
- 34:33ready to execute him. And Chester Morris calls
- 34:36him a copper. And Regis Toomey has this great
- 34:39moment where he's still playing this drunk and
- 34:44just being real slick and sly about it. As they
- 34:47all get closer to him. Right. And as one person
- 34:50gets a little too close, he grabs him, swings
- 34:52him around, his gun goes off, steals his gun.
- 34:55And now he's pointing. a gun at all the gangsters
- 34:58just commanding them to all drop their guns and
- 35:02his that shift even though you'd seen him play
- 35:05like the straight cop character for a while now
- 35:07that shift in his voice and everything i was
- 35:10just like man he means business this is cool
- 35:12yep it's he plays it so well too where like he
- 35:16just switches it immediately and just plays a
- 35:18different character yeah so great but it's ultimately
- 35:20jones involvement that is the end of uh of his
- 35:24uh success there Oh, it wasn't Joan. It was just
- 35:28some other... Oh, that was Daisy. Yeah. Okay.
- 35:30So that's where a girl comes in, Mae. Yeah. So
- 35:34she comes in, distracts him just ever so slightly,
- 35:38and Chick takes the shot from his jacket pocket.
- 35:41Yes. So I agree. I think that he really was the
- 35:44appeal to me, Regis, to me. Was so, so, so good
- 35:48in that role as Danny McGann. I wish I liked
- 35:51the Chick performance a bit more. Yeah. I mean,
- 35:54it's good, and Chester Morris did well, but I
- 35:57think you're just kind of being out -acted up
- 35:59until that final scene of just, okay, it's time
- 36:02to lose my mind, because now I'm not getting
- 36:04my way. Yeah, which is good that after you lose
- 36:08Regis Toomey, you do have that to keep the movie
- 36:11going. And, you know, the more I talked about
- 36:14Chester Morris' performance and the three different
- 36:17types of his character that he's playing, I'm
- 36:18like, oh, actually, this was good. It really
- 36:20just needs a supporting actor category. It does.
- 36:23That's... what we're boiling this down to. That's
- 36:25what we're missing. Can we talk about Toomey's
- 36:27death scene, though? Yeah, absolutely. How did
- 36:31you feel about the length of it? I thought that
- 36:35it was very reminiscent of Seventh Heaven and
- 36:38how it felt like the lighting was trying to tell
- 36:41you what was happening versus you depicting it
- 36:43yourself. He has this moment where he's just
- 36:46talking with two other individuals about how...
- 36:49He's going to miss people. I can't remember exactly
- 36:51what he was saying, but it's just a very long
- 36:52monologue that isn't really filled with anything.
- 36:55And then he's just kind of slowly, slowly going
- 36:57out. The thing that I thought was interesting
- 36:59about it was, and maybe this is completely by
- 37:01accident, is that the whiteness in the faces
- 37:04of the two people that he's talking to, there's
- 37:06one that's left and one that's right, and then
- 37:08Tomi's in the center, the whiteness on them starts
- 37:11to dim, and it becomes a little more black. And
- 37:14I thought that that was signifying the idea of
- 37:16him kind of blacking out. yeah and like him like
- 37:20seeing the light in just himself and like it's
- 37:22blacking out and the fading on him and if it
- 37:25led to basically a black circle around his face
- 37:28and then just like fading out or cutting to black
- 37:30i'm totally a fan yeah but because it didn't
- 37:33do that and it might just be a technical error
- 37:36or just they half committed to the bit it goes
- 37:38on way too long yeah but it does feel to your
- 37:41point they're like we're losing the best guy
- 37:43in this movie right now we need to act Act right
- 37:46now and hold on to him for as long as you can.
- 37:49It does feel just a little too long. Again, great
- 37:53performance. But I feel like he looks at the
- 37:57one guy and he's like, goodbye, Harry. And then
- 38:00you assume he dies. And 20 seconds later, he
- 38:05looks to his right and he's like, goodbye, Jake.
- 38:08It's almost the exact opposite of The Wizard
- 38:11of Oz. Yeah. When she's like, and you were there.
- 38:14And you. And you can kind of feel Toomey doing
- 38:17that a little bit here where he's like, goodbye,
- 38:19chair. Yeah. Okay, wrap it up, buddy. Who else
- 38:23is here while I still can see anything? It's
- 38:27really funny. I found this interesting piece
- 38:29of trivia about Regis Toomey. He, for a long
- 38:32time, held the record for the longest on -screen
- 38:34kiss. Really? So I think that was just his goal.
- 38:38He was like, look. I'm a supporting character.
- 38:41I don't really play the leads. So when I get
- 38:44my opportunity, I am milking it for all it's
- 38:46worth. My death scene is going to be great. It
- 38:48was so long. This kiss was something like three
- 38:51minutes and eight seconds. He might beat it with
- 38:54his death scene. It's a long time to be smooching
- 38:58and dying. It's not very elaborate. That's a
- 39:00great album name, by the way. Smooching and dying.
- 39:04Watch out. For me, I think it goes on too long.
- 39:11That's obvious. Didn't really understand why.
- 39:13I think I was looking for the cinematography
- 39:16and art direction to come back. So when I saw
- 39:18the fading of their faces, I was like, is that
- 39:21what we're doing? And they're like, no, just
- 39:22the camera's acting up. Sorry, man. And I think
- 39:24it's them trying to pull in a lot of sympathy
- 39:27for this character and make you feel really connected
- 39:29to him. And while he has been fun to watch, just
- 39:33the overall... I don't know, writing of movies
- 39:36from this era, I think you're limited to how
- 39:39much you can really connect to any particular
- 39:41character unless you're really, really doing
- 39:44wonders, you know, in the script. So they're
- 39:47pulling for it, and they're like, Toomey's good
- 39:50enough to pull off the acting. Let's just go
- 39:52for it. For me, too long. Too long. Not just
- 39:55for you. It's too long in general. I mean, so
- 39:57let's talk a little bit about something that
- 39:58we talked about with the racket, and that was
- 40:00how this movie was received, right? So... It
- 40:03was received pretty well. Like you mentioned,
- 40:05the nominations came forth. Reviews are very
- 40:07positive for it. The best gangster film, even
- 40:10by today's standards, fun to watch. So the censorship,
- 40:14though, is that this faced a very similar situation
- 40:17that the racket did, where it was actually flagged
- 40:20by the Chicago Board of Censors, and they banned
- 40:23it, specifically citing its immorality, depravity,
- 40:27the criminal nature of it. And there was appeals.
- 40:31To have that, you know, removed to where it wasn't
- 40:34a censor that could stop people from seeing it.
- 40:36And it wasn't until ultimately a judge by the
- 40:38name of Harry Fisher actually watched the movie.
- 40:41Crazy idea. Let's just watch the movie and see
- 40:44if this actually holds weight. Right. And Judge
- 40:47Harry Fisher did exactly that. And they determined
- 40:50that, you know, censorship is a form of tyranny
- 40:53at its best, is what he said. And a warrant to
- 40:56the ideals of American people. And then an injunction
- 41:00was issued to remove that so then everyone could
- 41:02see this movie. Yeah. And I think that's smart
- 41:04because, you know, at least in the racket, there
- 41:07is the idea of like corruption within the police
- 41:09force. Right. And with Alibi, it is quite literally
- 41:13just the criminality, right? And that the police
- 41:16force is ultimately good there. If anything,
- 41:18the police force was highlighted in an extremely
- 41:21positive way. So it's surprising that they would
- 41:23try and like keep the idea of crime out of Hollywood.
- 41:27Yeah. I think it is because, at least at some
- 41:31point in the movie, you are rooting for Chick
- 41:34until you see his true colors, that is. So it
- 41:38does kind of... Well, I'd say you're rooting
- 41:41for Chick when you think he could be innocent.
- 41:42Right, yeah. So you're not rooting for the criminal.
- 41:45You're rooting for the innocent man, and then
- 41:47when he reveals to you that he is the criminal,
- 41:49it's very obvious, okay, well, I actually don't
- 41:51care for that guy anymore. So it seems like the
- 41:53movie's morals are in the right place. Sure.
- 41:55Which is why it kind of feels like the Chicago
- 41:57board was just like, you know what? We were here
- 42:00last year. We saw what happened. Yeah. Let's
- 42:02not do it again. Because it was Chicago, right?
- 42:04Yes. That had the issue with the racket. Correct.
- 42:06So that might just be their thing. Chicago, yeah.
- 42:11At the time, yeah, they wouldn't have liked Mortal
- 42:13Kombat, probably. They probably had an issue
- 42:15with that. Boston can have some problems with
- 42:19that. That's okay. Boston has plenty of movies
- 42:21where things like that happen. The town especially.
- 42:23I'd hate to see that. Interesting. Interesting
- 42:26that it's happening and interesting that even
- 42:28in 1929, I mean 1927 as well with the racket,
- 42:32that it was happening at that point in time where
- 42:35censorship was still very much a thing. Interesting
- 42:38to see pre -code censorship and then see what
- 42:42happens once code becomes code, so to speak,
- 42:46and becomes a standard if those censorships tend
- 42:50to stay or how many more censorships we're going
- 42:53to see before the code is enacted. Have you ever
- 42:55looked at the commandments, if you will, the
- 42:58don'ts of the Hollywood code? I haven't. So that's
- 43:02what's interesting to me. We talk about, you
- 43:04know, the cops are shown in a good light, a positive
- 43:08light in this, and it's mostly just the criminals
- 43:10that are the problem. Why would they want to
- 43:12censor this? But if you look at the don'ts of
- 43:16the Hollywood Code and what it eventually became
- 43:18to be, it's really just like any involvement
- 43:22of these particular things is a problem. So to
- 43:26run through them real quick, you had profanity,
- 43:29suggestive nudity, illegal traffic and drugs,
- 43:33any inference of sex perversion, white slavery,
- 43:37miscegenation, sex hygiene and venereal disease.
- 43:41That's very... Specific. Okay. Scenes of actual
- 43:45childbirth, sexualization of children, ridicule
- 43:48of the clergy, and willful offense to any nation,
- 43:51race, or creed. But you did have a lot of be
- 43:54carefuls, and some of that just involved, like,
- 43:58robbery, theft, criminal intent, and all of that.
- 44:01So you had, like, your hard, hey, you can't do
- 44:04any of this. And I think some of that pops up
- 44:07in things like Broadway Melody, where we're talking
- 44:09about... Quote, unquote, the scantily clad leads.
- 44:13But even in this, the illegal traffic and drugs,
- 44:16while that's not exactly what happens in this
- 44:18movie, I did see someone mention that early on
- 44:22you see one of the gangsters. It's implied that
- 44:24he's smoking marijuana because it was legal at
- 44:28the time. So there is that. But they're stealing
- 44:31coats, like we said. That's theft. Eventually
- 44:34you get to the Hollywood Code. That doesn't allow
- 44:36any of that. Even if it's showing the bad guy
- 44:39doing it, you can't show it on screen. So those
- 44:42reasons kind of allow you to make sense of why
- 44:47is Chicago coming after this when they're making
- 44:49the good guys good and the bad guys bad. Feels
- 44:51like we need to be putting a little bit more
- 44:53focus and importance on other things at that
- 44:56time. Totally. That's just me. Do you know, have
- 44:59you seen the second, I mean, let's take a second
- 45:02to talk about the poster here. We talked about
- 45:05the poster. I've actually, if you follow our
- 45:07Instagram, I did put the poster of Alibi on there
- 45:12for the announcement of our, you know, schedule
- 45:15to come. And I'm sure on this episode we'll include
- 45:18the, probably this poster as well, if not a better
- 45:21one. Right. It looks like a mellow mushroom order.
- 45:24Wow. That's so accurate. Like it just, the colors
- 45:28are just like. The colors are very vibrant. They're
- 45:31very neon. The font is extremely large and inflated,
- 45:35and it just feels like you're ordering a Maui
- 45:38Waui instead of watching a crime film. That's
- 45:41so good. So that's one poster. There's a second
- 45:44poster that I wanted to talk to you about, though.
- 45:45Okay. And there's a poster that almost looks
- 45:48like maybe it was used for a consideration of
- 45:52the Academy Award. right okay it has a cast photo
- 45:55at the top and then the bottom has text and the
- 45:57text says get prepared for the greatest alibi
- 46:01in quotation marks in the world and I want to
- 46:04I just want to get your reaction real quick in
- 46:07real time as I say the second part the perfect
- 46:09100 % talking dancing thrilling gripping melodrama
- 46:16Okay. And there's two words there that don't
- 46:18really stand out to me. And I'm interested if
- 46:21you caught on. I think you did, because I saw
- 46:23your face on one of them. Right. I'm assuming
- 46:25dancing. Dancing is another one. There is technically
- 46:29dancing. Sure. But it is not a musical. It's
- 46:32not that kind of dancing. It's very much like
- 46:34The Godfather. To be like, oh, I love the dancing
- 46:36in The Godfather. And it's just like the wedding
- 46:38scene at the beginning. They danced at a wedding.
- 46:40What are you talking about? Yeah. And very similar
- 46:42to that. Perfect might be another word that I'm,
- 46:44you know, oh, interesting. Yeah. But 100 % talking,
- 46:47that is true. Thrilling, gripping, melodrama,
- 46:49I give it that. For sure. But dancing, I just
- 46:52read that and was like... Yeah, they're really
- 46:54pulling everything out of this movie. I think
- 46:55you're trying to get everyone in here, yeah.
- 46:56Instead of saying romance, you kind of got all
- 46:59the parties. Yeah. So, interesting way that it's
- 47:03being advertised. Whether now, much after its
- 47:06release, or at the time. Interesting posters.
- 47:10Look up the poster if you can. It's a fun watch.
- 47:12Yeah. I think we're highlighting the poster specifically
- 47:15because obviously this will be way in the past
- 47:17at this point. But as we're recording this, Drew
- 47:20Struzan has passed away, who famously has provided
- 47:25the world with countless incredible film posters.
- 47:28Probably the best in the world. Yes. This movie's
- 47:32poster is not one of those. It really is kind
- 47:36of like an abomination, if we're being honest.
- 47:38It is. You mentioned it. Sorry. Chester Morris's
- 47:42face in the poster is rough. It literally looks
- 47:46like maybe someone was choking him at the time
- 47:49and they kept their hand in. Yeah. And it's just
- 47:51like his face is not that big. It's very strange.
- 47:54And it's almost indicative of like what Hitchcock
- 47:58tried to do with his posters later on. Sure.
- 48:00But this is pre -Hitchcock. So it's like not
- 48:02really like I don't know what it's going for.
- 48:05And to your point, I think posters like this.
- 48:09are exactly why there's artists like Drew Struzan
- 48:12that can come in and really look at a movie and
- 48:14say, okay, how can I capture this while also
- 48:16doing my own style? I personally have two Struzans
- 48:20in my basement, and we're going to keep the Muppet
- 48:24talk going. I have Muppets Christmas Carol and
- 48:26Muppets... Treasure Island. Okay, nice. I have
- 48:30those two in my basement. And I'd love to get
- 48:32more of his. I think his Blade Runner is phenomenal.
- 48:36Indiana Jones. Star Wars. I mean, obviously,
- 48:39he's a big one. But he did do Star Wars, correct?
- 48:42I believe so. I think he did. It definitely looks
- 48:44like he did. Let me know if we got that wrong,
- 48:46folks. But the other ones I'm 100 % sure of.
- 48:49And it's just art style that hasn't been replicated.
- 48:53Yeah. They've tried and they can't get close
- 48:55just because it is so uniquely him. So very cool
- 48:58and very appropriate that we take some time to
- 49:01dedicate some space to him. Because he was a
- 49:05very, very big part, still is a very big part
- 49:08of movies. And Back to the Future is another
- 49:11one he's done. So just incredible work. And he's
- 49:14going to be missed for the work that he did.
- 49:16And all the more reason that we go out there
- 49:17and continue to try doing art, everyone. Oh,
- 49:19yes. We need more Strusens in the world. Yes,
- 49:23we need excellent. excellent movie posters to
- 49:25bring people to the theaters alibi actually kind
- 49:28of has like an ai look to it if i'm being honest
- 49:30which is weird because it's all over like the
- 49:33promotion of this like from what i've looked
- 49:34up so if they are using that ai format behind
- 49:38it that's just weird it feels like whoever made
- 49:41that poster definitely did not watch the movie
- 49:43yeah it's definitely not or know when it was
- 49:45set it doesn't Right. Doesn't even look like
- 49:48it was set at the right time. They're like, yeah,
- 49:51this is like a 70s romp, right? Sure, I got you.
- 49:53And we're like, it came out in 1929. Surprise.
- 49:56A couple things. We're approaching the end of
- 49:59this episode, I think. Roland West, the director,
- 50:01there's a little bit of controversy I wanted
- 50:03to bring up with him. Oh, yeah. So he has long
- 50:07been considered a suspect in this murder conspiracy
- 50:11of Thelma Todd. He was having an affair with
- 50:15Thelma Todd. And she was found dead in her car.
- 50:20Man, I want to say it was in his garage. Let
- 50:25me double check that. It was inside the garage
- 50:28of Jewel Carmen, Roland West's wife at the time.
- 50:31Yes. Okay. That's what it is. So I think that's
- 50:35the first big controversy of anybody that we've
- 50:37experienced through the show yet. He also had
- 50:40a yacht. And after he passed away, this yacht,
- 50:43like mysteriously, everybody on it. and the yacht
- 50:47was just discovered floating out in the ocean.
- 50:49Like a Bermuda Triangle type situation? Sort
- 50:51of. Apparently there's a documentary on it that
- 50:54I really want to check out, because it's called
- 50:56the Joyita, and it sounds spooky. This has nothing
- 51:00to do with the movie at all, but... Well, it's
- 51:03interesting, because it looks like it was something
- 51:06that there was just, you know... accusations,
- 51:09maybe allegations, like assumptions, but no proof
- 51:12that came out that tied Roland specifically to
- 51:15this murder. And that wasn't enough to incarcerate
- 51:20him or, you know, get him found guilty of it.
- 51:22But it was enough within Hollywood, obviously
- 51:25being in the public eye, to stop him from being
- 51:27more involved in projects in the future. Yes.
- 51:30So still very interesting, scary thing to be
- 51:33involved in. Yeah, totally. And, you know, obviously...
- 51:36don't know if he was guilty or what kind of person
- 51:38he was, so take out the morality of the situation.
- 51:41It is a shame that it affected the career of
- 51:46someone that provided movies like this, really.
- 51:49A phrase we didn't throw out yet is film noir.
- 51:52Definitely. It's very much an early example of
- 51:56film noir. A lot of trench coats. Yes, and just
- 51:59the shadows and everything. You don't have that
- 52:01narration element of noir, but... Just the visuals
- 52:06are so striking. I think some movies would sometimes
- 52:10have the audience be in on it, but then have
- 52:12the characters not be in on it. It's kind of
- 52:16interesting to see how much of Alibi keeps the
- 52:19audience at bay and wants you to believe what
- 52:22the characters are believing right now. So there's
- 52:24an element of noir in the narration or lack thereof
- 52:27as well. That's true. That's true. Beyond that,
- 52:30I mean, do you have anything else to say about
- 52:33Alibi? Check out the poster. Have a good laugh.
- 52:38Make sure you check out the YouTube playlist
- 52:40that Kyle is going to shout out here in a minute.
- 52:42So you can watch the YouTube clip, or clip, the
- 52:45YouTube posting of this movie, Alibi. And watch
- 52:50for the cinematography. If anything, watch for
- 52:53the cinematography of this for the performances
- 52:55of Tomi and Morris. Thank you so much. They're
- 52:59doing great work on it. I wish the movie was
- 53:01a bit more cohesive. incoherent. I think there's
- 53:06some technical difficulties that kept me from
- 53:08really enjoying it, but no, I would recommend.
- 53:11You think a restoration where the sound was updated
- 53:14would help aid your enjoyment in this movie?
- 53:17Yeah, you know, we talked about this with the
- 53:19AI element. How much do we want to see these
- 53:21movies touched up? I don't think I would want
- 53:23an audio accompaniment of like, hey, we actually
- 53:27had actors come in and say the lines they're
- 53:29supposed to say here. I think a closed captioning.
- 53:33would be beneficial sure so you keep the historical
- 53:36artifact of like this is how much this is very
- 53:39much how it played back then but also in order
- 53:41for you to like understand the movie here's the
- 53:44closed captioning using the script yeah i think
- 53:46that would be beneficial to me yeah i wouldn't
- 53:49want like a remaker like an ai or you know even
- 53:51not ai like an audio dub of it No, nothing like
- 53:55that. I was more thinking of cleaning up the
- 53:57audio itself. Oh, sure. So that you could hear
- 53:59it clearly. Totally. But really, all this movie
- 54:01needs is, like you said, closed captions. That's
- 54:05it. And you'd be fine. Otherwise, everything
- 54:06looks great. Yeah. Man, I have a lot of praise
- 54:09for this movie, more than I expected. Yeah. You're
- 54:13going to love my rating. You want to do ratings,
- 54:15or do you want to do the double feature? Let's
- 54:17do ratings and then double feature. Sure. What
- 54:19did you rate this the first time and rate it
- 54:23the second time? Oh, man. Let me pull up my rating
- 54:26from the first time I watched it. I feel like
- 54:28it was low. I gave it two stars the first time
- 54:31I saw it. I'm going to go crazy with this. I'm
- 54:34going to give it three and a half stars. You
- 54:35jumped up three. I did. Well, the halves, but
- 54:38yeah. Yeah. It's so beautiful. Yeah. What was
- 54:43I thinking? It's the best looking movie I think
- 54:45we've watched, at least from a creative standpoint.
- 54:49Best looking movie we've watched so far for the
- 54:51show. There's stuff going on here that outside
- 54:55of your Metropolis and your Nosferatu and things
- 55:00like that, that you weren't seeing really in
- 55:02the Academy showcase, but really in the States.
- 55:07You know, it's called German Expressionism for
- 55:09a reason. You're seeing that here and it is pulling
- 55:12its weight and then some. So I really enjoy just
- 55:16watching this movie, even if the plot is like,
- 55:18yeah. It's fine. I mean, you're right. You said
- 55:21this about the Broadway melody, about how we
- 55:23gave the two -sentence introduction. You're like,
- 55:25that's the movie. Right. This is kind of the
- 55:27movie, too. There's not too much going on beyond
- 55:29what we've already discussed. Look, I agree with
- 55:31everything that you said. It is the best -looking
- 55:33one that we've covered so far. The acting in
- 55:36those two performances specifically are great.
- 55:39I did give it a two. Oh? And in our discussion,
- 55:42I feel like I'd want to take it up more to like
- 55:44a two and a half. Yeah. But to be honest, I feel
- 55:46like I'd probably want to swap Broadway melody.
- 55:48And just give that a two and give that half star
- 55:52to Alibi. Sure. So maybe closer to a five, but
- 55:56I think I feel confident in giving it a little
- 55:59bit more credit than I did before, but still
- 56:01not loving it overall. Yeah. And I can rank that
- 56:03a little lower. I mean, I really did enjoy my
- 56:06time in old Arizona. So I feel a little bit better
- 56:09about giving that like a three star, despite
- 56:11its problematic nature. Right. But I think I'd
- 56:15want to give it about two and a half. is how
- 56:17I'd feel comfortable with it right now. Yeah,
- 56:19I think we'll talk more on the ceremony episode
- 56:21of how much we enjoyed each film. Sure. We'll
- 56:24get into that detail. But just from like a technical
- 56:27and like an artistic standpoint, this movie's
- 56:30really doing a lot for me personally. I mean,
- 56:33you put technical in there and it's a five star.
- 56:35So everything else is a, it's everything else
- 56:38in the movie that detracts from that five star.
- 56:40Sure. And I think that's where the nominations
- 56:42kind of nailed it. Yeah. We just need that best
- 56:45supporting actor for Regis Toomey. We're coming
- 56:47for you, buddy. We are. We'll get you that win.
- 56:51Yeah. In the year 2025. Almost 100 years later,
- 56:54we're going to recognize you. So let's talk double
- 56:57feature. Yeah. You had some time to think about
- 56:59this. I did. I had a lot of time. I needed a
- 57:01lot of time. I dropped the ball last episode,
- 57:03but I'm here this time to say that as I had picked
- 57:07my movie, I swapped. Yeah. So I'm going to go
- 57:11with Primal Fear. Great pick. Yes. Wow. Yeah.
- 57:17And I almost don't want to talk about why, because
- 57:20I don't want to spoil that. Sure. But another
- 57:24classic scenario of who's in the right, who's
- 57:27in the wrong. Yes. Yeah. Yeah, that's it. I'm
- 57:30not going to go into any detail. That's great.
- 57:31Watch Primal Fear. That's a great pick. That's
- 57:34probably your most inspired pick so far. Thanks,
- 57:36man. So I'm going to swerve. For my pick of a
- 57:41double feature with the... No, yeah, I do want
- 57:44to do that. For my pick for the double feature
- 57:47of Alibi, I'm choosing a movie that matches the
- 57:51dark tone of this movie when it decides to be
- 57:54dark. Not just in its cinematography, but in
- 57:57its tones, in its theming, features really great
- 58:00performances. And it features an idea of, is
- 58:03this person really the person that I think I'm
- 58:05talking to? Can I fully trust this person? And
- 58:08do they want my best interests at heart? I'm
- 58:10going with David Fincher's Gone Girl. Oh, yeah,
- 58:13yeah. Quite a different experience than this,
- 58:18but the idea of cinematography is always very
- 58:20heavy on David Fincher's mind. Yes. The use of
- 58:24light, the use of shadows, the use of dark tones,
- 58:27the idea of whether or not Rosamund Pike's character
- 58:32really has the best interest of Ben Affleck or
- 58:35anyone other than herself at heart. And what
- 58:38has Ben Affleck done to register any kind of
- 58:41betrayal that she may or may not have done is
- 58:44an interesting thing that pairs well with this.
- 58:46Yes. I think it also shows the true element of
- 58:49who people are versus what they try to show us,
- 58:51which is something that obviously Chick's character
- 58:54does a lot in this. So interesting themes that
- 58:57match each other pretty well. Yeah. And I think
- 58:59Gone Girl is a good example of like. diving into
- 59:02those those themes and characters in a way that
- 59:05i think we both wish this movie did a little
- 59:08bit more absolutely yeah it's pretty face value
- 59:10in alibi yeah whereas gone girl really does deep
- 59:13dive into that so great call out awesome i love
- 59:16both of those we should have some kind of like
- 59:18tally on letterbox of like these movies and they're
- 59:22like double feature counterparts yeah we should
- 59:25uh to keep track of the ones that we double feature
- 59:29them with yeah We'll talk off mic on what would
- 59:32look best for that. Interesting. I think it'll
- 59:34be good. But yeah, that's all I've got for Alibi.
- 59:37That's all I have for Alibi. If you would like
- 59:40to write in and let us know your thoughts about
- 59:41Alibi or any of the other films that we cover
- 59:44on the podcast, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 59:48at gmail .com and we'll read all of those on
- 59:52ceremony episodes. That's coming up here shortly.
- 59:55We've got one more film to talk about next episode.
- 59:58That's going to be the Hollywood Review of 1929.
- 1:00:01If you want to give us a follow on Patreon and
- 1:00:03you want to show support monetarily, financially,
- 1:00:06patreon .com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. That
- 1:00:10is correct. And, editor's note, if anyone knows
- 1:00:14me very well and is listening to this podcast
- 1:00:17episode, in about an hour ago... with some change,
- 1:00:20maybe 45 minutes, you may have heard us talking
- 1:00:23about a character named Chick, and you may have
- 1:00:25heard Kyle then refer to the term wide open spaces.
- 1:00:29And if you're thinking, I'm really surprised
- 1:00:30that Ryan didn't make a joke about the chicks
- 1:00:32and wide open spaces, know that it's been sitting
- 1:00:35in the chamber. And I've been waiting on that
- 1:00:37for 45 minutes, and I did think about it, so
- 1:00:40you did not beat me to it. Perfect. There is
- 1:00:42that one person listening right now that's like,
- 1:00:45yes! Justification. Finally. And her name is
- 1:00:52Taylor, and I will see you at home. Perfect.
- 1:00:54Okay, that's going to do it for this episode.
- 1:00:57As always, I'm your host, Kyle. And I'm Ryan.
- 1:01:00And we'll see you at the movies.