Latest / Shades of Murder / 61: Devil Monster of France - The Story of Lola Daviet

Transcript

61: Devil Monster of France - The Story of Lola Daviet · Shades of Murder

0:03
On October 14th, 2022, in a building courtyard in Paris,
0:07
France, a homeless man stumbled upon a large black trunk.
0:11
The horrific sight that lay inside would haunt him and the
0:15
most experienced of officers. Investigation into this
0:20
mysterious, grisly death would lead to an unusual suspect whose
0:24
actions shocked and enraged an entire country.
0:28
Who was this victim? And who was the monster who had
0:32
murdered them and stuffed their body inside a plastic box?
1:14
Hello and welcome to Shades of Murder.
1:17
I am your host Alita Caldwell. In this podcast, I discuss cases
1:22
of murder from around the world and throughout history,
1:26
attempting to unravel the layers of darkness that help make
1:30
humans and monsters. Please be forewarned that each
1:36
episode contains specific and at times very graphic and
1:40
disturbing details of the case. This show is not intended for
1:43
all audiences and listener discretion is strongly advised.
1:48
Some stories make us believe in the existence of evil.
1:53
When there is no diagnosis of a severe mental illness or a
1:57
nightmarish childhood background to grasp the barbaric actions of
2:03
an offender, what else is left besides viewing them solely as a
2:09
monster? The depths of depravity in the
2:12
void of emotion portrayed by the perpetrator can only be
2:16
explained by the unexplainable darkness of another soul.
2:22
This is the story of the devil monster of France, Dabia
2:27
Binquered. Paris is an absolutely
2:30
mesmerizing city. The capital of France is known
2:33
by many, particularly by its residents as the New York City
2:38
of Europe. Paris is truly a remarkable
2:40
place full of centuries old buildings, astonishing museums
2:44
and breathtaking landmarks. The Arandas men's or districts
2:49
are lined with unique shops and picture perfect St. cafes.
2:54
Paris has long been on my bucket list and the year before this
2:58
horrible tragedy occurred, I took myself there to celebrate
3:01
earning a degree. Even though it was still in the
3:04
midst of the great pandemic, I made the most of my journey and
3:09
loved the experience. I have never been to New York
3:12
City, but I can only imagine it holds the same kind of feverish
3:17
global energy that Paris does. It was in December, mind you,
3:21
but the streets were still crowded and flourishing with
3:24
people everywhere. The roads were riddled with
3:27
traffic jams and pedestrians ignoring the lights running
3:31
around the taxis to reach the next block.
3:34
There's an undeniable magnetic International Energy there with
3:39
every imaginable kind of culture represented.
3:42
My lifelong association with Paris being the height of
3:45
fashion did not let me down. Everyone was very fashionable
3:48
and classy in an effortless way. The people are also much warmer
3:53
and friendlier than other cultures, often to pick them as
3:57
the French simply have more manners and are quiet and they
4:01
expect the same in return. I barely spoke any French and my
4:06
phone would not work outside the country.
4:09
I walked everywhere with a local map and just my visual sense of
4:13
direction, which thanks to hiking in the woods with my
4:16
boyfriend over the years, had significantly improved.
4:20
I would just leisurely stop and eat and explore whenever I felt
4:24
like it. Something about the people and
4:26
the places I've visited made me feel very welcome and relaxed,
4:31
as if it could be my second home.
4:33
I've been waiting more than three years to discuss this case
4:38
for most of my long time listeners.
4:40
You probably have noticed that I don't cover cases that have not
4:44
been handled within the criminal justice system unless they are
4:48
murders which remain unsolved or there has been injustice for the
4:52
victim and their family. I prefer not to cover cases that
4:56
I feel are incomplete. That is, no one has been held
4:59
accountable for the crime. Many podcasts have covered this
5:03
case, but not in its entirety because it was only in October
5:08
of this year that the story came to some kind of closure.
5:13
Harris is a sprawling, massive metropolitan city divided into
5:17
20 diverse and unique air endorsements or districts.
5:21
Like any large urban city, sections and districts are known
5:24
for being more appealing and safer than others.
5:27
The 19th Erdosmund, where this story takes place, is known for
5:31
being somewhat sketchy, although it does have its lovely quiet
5:35
parts, especially for families. It has also been associated with
5:39
a lot of petty crimes and drug trafficking.
5:42
That is more of a cautionary tale for tourists rather than
5:44
its residents, though, and most never encounter any problems.
5:49
This is one of those stories that serves as a reminder that
5:53
although stranger danger is extremely rare, when it does
5:57
occur it often unfolds into a parent's worst nightmare.
6:01
On the afternoon of October 14th, 2020, two 12 year old
6:04
schoolgirl Lola Devier disappeared.
6:08
Her parents expected her home after middle school, which was
6:10
only a short walk away. When she never returned, they
6:14
immediately sensed something was wrong.
6:16
Lola was a darling and very responsible young girl.
6:20
She was respectful and considerate to her parents and
6:23
would never have just run off without telling them.
6:26
Lola's parents were concierge or caretakers of the residential
6:29
building where the family lived. They immediately contacted the
6:32
police and reported their daughter missing.
6:34
Officers began searching around the communal areas of the
6:37
apartment complex. Since her father was the
6:39
caretaker of the building. He immediately began reviewing
6:42
the CCTV footage. At 3:15 PM, he watched as his
6:46
daughter Lola entered the building with an unknown woman.
6:49
Lola appeared to be helping the woman inside with some heavy
6:52
luggage. Then he watched in horror when
6:55
less than two hours later, at 4:59 PM, this same woman, now
7:00
wearing different clothing, was carrying two pink suitcases, one
7:03
which she used to prop open the door.
7:06
The woman left and within a few minutes she was seen awkwardly
7:09
dragging a heavy black trunk covered in a blanket down the
7:13
hallway towards the lobby. What if the neighbors even
7:16
helped hold the door open for her?
7:19
Only a few hours later, a homeless man walking in the
7:22
courtyard of the building stumbled upon what appeared to
7:25
be a plastic trunk. He opened it to see what lay
7:28
inside. The man was horrified at what he
7:31
saw. Underneath some layers of
7:32
clothes appeared to be a child. The man immediately contacted
7:39
the authorities. When investigators arrived at
7:42
the scene, they were not prepared for the disturbing and
7:44
brutal sight of 12 year old Lola Davia's corpse.
7:50
She was nude and had multiple deep gashes and cuts on her
7:53
body. The young girl's face was
7:56
covered in duct tape. The once vanished child had now
8:00
become a victim of an atrocious murder.
8:03
A forensic pathologist would determine that the official
8:06
cause of death was cardio respiratory failure due to
8:09
asphyxiation and cervical compression.
8:12
Many large cuts have been made to the girl's face and back.
8:16
Her neck had been sliced so deeply by a bladed weapon that
8:20
her head was partially severed. The girl had also been a victim
8:24
of brutal sexual assault. Witnesses at the scene told the
8:28
police that they saw the woman leave the building around 5:00
8:30
PM carrying a large trunk which she stuffed inside a friend's
8:34
car. Another witness said the suspect
8:36
had offered him money to assist her in moving the trunk.
8:39
CCTV footage collected from a nearby bar on Rouman in minutes
8:44
after she left the building showed the same woman with two
8:47
very heavy suitcases casually sitting at a table.
8:50
In a bizarre and brazen moment, a man whom she was talking to on
8:54
the street sits down at the table with her.
8:57
He asks her what's inside the trunk to what She tells him she
9:01
is selling kidneys and encourages him to look inside.
9:05
At one point the woman does open the trunk and pairs inside.
9:08
It was later realized that she was looking at Lula Davi's body.
9:13
The man didn't think too much about the weird transaction he
9:16
had with the stranger at the time, but then hours later he
9:19
heard about the grisly news about a 12 year old girl being
9:23
found deceased inside an eerily similar looking trunk.
9:26
He immediately contacted the police and reported the odd
9:29
encounter he had with a woman at the cafe.
9:32
Investigators soon learned that the sister of the suspect lived
9:35
at the same building complex. When they entered the apartment,
9:39
they discovered what they believed to be the weapons used
9:42
in the crime. There were a pair of scissors
9:45
and oyster knife, which is what it sounds it should be used for
9:48
to shock open an oyster and what was described as an IKEA knife.
9:52
They were all spatter with blood.
9:54
The CCTV footage in the area along with witness statements
9:58
and phone records LED investigators to locate the
10:01
suspect slightly before 8:00 AM the morning after the heinous
10:05
murder of this young girl. The suspect was handed at a
10:08
friend's house in Wah Colombs, a suburb of Paris. 3 suspects, in
10:14
addition to the murder suspect, were arrested and held in
10:17
custody. One man and one woman,
10:20
identified as the main suspect's older sister, was later released
10:24
without charges. An older man who was suspected
10:27
of sheltering the suspect remained in custody.
10:31
It was later learned that the man was a friend of the suspect.
10:34
She had persuaded him to drive her, the two suitcases and the
10:37
trunk back to his home. According to this man, Dabia
10:41
Binka Red, the suspect took a chauffeur driven car, which the
10:46
man had arranged for her, back to the residential building,
10:49
where he had picked her up with the trunk.
10:51
When officers brought her older sister Frija in for an
10:54
interview, she told police that her sister was unemployed and
10:57
homeless. She lived with a friend outside
11:00
of Paris, but sometimes she let her younger sister stay at her
11:03
apartment with her. Debbie's sister told
11:05
investigators that her younger sister always had trouble
11:08
fitting in, and during the last month she had started
11:11
sleepwalking. She said that she would wake up
11:14
and say strange, incoherent things.
11:17
Frija described her sister as being bipolar, even calling her
11:21
a bad seed. She claimed not to know anything
11:24
about the crime and was later released without facing any
11:28
charges. On several occasions, a witness
11:30
referred to as Mr. K noticed the suspect hanging out.
11:34
She was known around the 19th Eridasmund for begging.
11:38
W would call it to passerby, sometimes asking them for a
11:41
cigarette, other times trying to scrounge up a few coins.
11:44
He did not know the woman personally, but he saw her from
11:47
time to time and wondered whether she might be a little
11:50
unstable, even a little unhinged.
11:54
The suspect in the murder of 12 year old Lola Davie was
11:57
identified as 24 year old Dabia Binqueret.
12:01
The main suspect was held in custody for 48 hours before
12:05
being brought before the Parisian Judicial Court.
12:08
During this period, she was interviewed 6 times by the
12:12
police. The first three interviews
12:14
yielded nothing for investigators.
12:17
The suspected killer swore that she was not involved in any way
12:21
with the assault and murder of the young French girl.
12:24
When investigators first brought Dabia Binkirit into the
12:28
interrogation room, they showed her grotesque, disturbing
12:32
pictures of the young girl's corpse.
12:35
The only thing she said was again after each photo, when the
12:40
gendarmerie or Parisian police shot the suspect.
12:43
Pictures of Lola's mutilated dead body, she said.
12:47
And I quote, I too was raped and I saw my parents die in front of
12:51
me. It is unknown whether her claims
12:54
were ever true. Dabia Binky Red initially flat
12:58
out denied being involved and kept repeating to investigators.
13:01
I don't want to answer you. Then she began telling them
13:05
events that were contradictory with one another.
13:07
And we're not at all convincing. The suspect offered far fetched,
13:12
bizarre versions of what happened that day.
13:15
However, something in the interrogation room shifted, and
13:19
during the fourth interview, Dabia Binka Red broke her
13:23
silence before confessing. She looked at the investigators
13:26
and smiled, telling them I've always wanted to be a police
13:29
officer. According to the suspect's
13:33
confession, the following sequence of events occurred on
13:36
the afternoon of October 14th, 2022.
13:40
She had woken up that morning around 10 or 11, had breakfast
13:43
with her older sister at her apartment, and then she went for
13:47
a walk. She just walked aimlessly and
13:49
ended up on the metro towards Champs Elise.
13:52
She ended up going to her former boyfriend's residence, where the
13:55
two got into a terrible argument alone.
13:58
Now along with her two suitcases, she returned to her
14:02
sister's apartment building. Debia Binka Red was standing
14:05
near the entrance with two overly sized pieces of luggage.
14:09
She didn't have her own pass since it was her sister's
14:12
apartment, not hers, and the caretaker had refused to give
14:16
her one. Then she appeared, a young girl
14:20
just returning home from school. Debia asked the girl for help
14:24
with her suitcases. The young girl was happy to
14:27
assist in opening the door, but when the woman said she could
14:30
really use her help getting them upstairs and inside her citrus
14:33
apartment, the girl told the lady that she wasn't supposed to
14:37
go inside a stranger's place. But the friendly and pretty
14:41
older woman reassured the young girl that everything's fine,
14:45
everything would be OK, She just really needed her help to get
14:48
the suitcases up the stairs and inside her citrus apartment.
14:52
The kind and trusting young girl decided to go with her.
14:57
Before she entered the apartment, she begged the older
15:01
woman not to hurt her. Once inside the apartment, the
15:05
woman turned on her. She threatened to kill her if
15:09
she didn't do what she was told. Dabia forced the terrified young
15:13
girl to wash herself in the shower.
15:16
She slammed the girl's head against the wall of the shower
15:20
and sexually violated her vaginally and anally.
15:25
She also forced her to perform sexual acts upon her.
15:29
Tabia described how Lola had turned into a ghost.
15:33
She didn't say a word. She slapped the girl, afraid
15:37
that she would tell her family about the assault.
15:41
It is not known of the exact moment over the more than hour
15:45
and a half horrific assault on this young girl, but the attack
15:51
turned deadly. Tabia grabbed a pair of scissors
15:55
and began to stab the girl over and over again.
15:59
She slashed at her face and multiple times across her back.
16:03
Then she pulled out a box cutter and slit the girl's throat and
16:07
stabbed her numerous times with the scissors.
16:13
Tabia grabbed duct tape sealing the girl's mouth shut and
16:17
wrapped the tape around her face.
16:20
It is believed that Lola Daviay was still alive when she taped
16:25
up the young girl, leaving her to suffocate to death.
16:29
Debiah Binky Red admitted to investigators that she had lured
16:33
Lola to her sister's apartment where she quote UN quote,
16:37
committed harm of a sexual nature and other violent acts
16:40
against Lola that caused her death and hid her body in the
16:44
trunk. On Monday, October 17th, 2022,
16:47
Dabia Binkirid spoke not a word as she faced the three judges
16:52
who were investigating this atrocious crime.
16:56
The 24 year old woman was charged with the murder of a
16:59
minor under 15 years old. Under French law Article 2:20
17:04
1/4 of the French Penal Code, killing a person under the age
17:09
of 15 is considered an aggravating circumstance which
17:12
brings with it the possibility of a life sentence.
17:17
Dabia Banker Ed was also charged with rape with acts of torture
17:21
and barbarism as defined by the French Penal Code.
17:25
When rapists proceeded accompanied by are followed by
17:28
torture and acts of barbarity, the crime is punishable by life
17:33
imprisonment. During another court hearing,
17:35
she withdrew the confession, claiming that it had all been a
17:38
dream, none of it was real. Then she told the police that
17:42
she was battling a ghost and had to defend herself from being
17:46
stabbed. Dabia Binkered also made the
17:50
statement that it would be impossible for me to kill a
17:53
child. The Attorney General reported
17:56
there were minimum of 38 wounds inflicted on 12 year old Lola
18:01
Davia's body. Her rib cage had been perforated
18:05
by at least two stabbings made from a pair of scissors and her
18:09
skull had been partially split. The young girl entered
18:13
unimaginable terror, suffering and pain before she died.
18:19
Strangely, it was also revealed that there were post it notes
18:23
that have been written in red ink placed on the soles of the
18:26
girl's feet. On them were the numbers 0 and
18:29
one. The investigation had taken an
18:32
even darker and more mysterious turn.
18:36
There is no known reason as to why Debia Benki Red wrote these
18:41
numbers. In numerology, 0 means nothing
18:45
and everything. The great void 1 symbolizes
18:49
unity, the beginning, the source of all existence.
18:53
Together they symbolize infinite potential.
18:58
It could also hypothetically represent binary code where one
19:02
means something is receiving electricity, or it is on and 0
19:06
means that it is not, it is off. The investigation failed to ever
19:12
unearth, nor did the suspect ever tell why she wrote these
19:16
numbers on her victim's feet, but I doubt it was for no
19:20
purpose. At least at the time of the
19:22
murder, these numbers held significance.
19:26
Investigators quickly learned that Diabiya Binky Red was an
19:30
illegal foreign national. She initially came to France in
19:34
2016 legally on a student resident permit, but something
19:40
went off in her life along the way.
19:43
In 2018, she was the victim of a domestic violence incident in
19:47
which the details are unknown. Dabia Binky Red never finished
19:52
school. She was unemployed and found
19:54
herself living on the streets, often prostituting her body.
19:58
In August 2022, only two months before this tragedy occurred,
20:02
the woman was stopped at an airport in Paris with expired
20:05
student papers. Since the woman did not have a
20:08
criminal record, she was not detained.
20:10
Instead, Yeah Being Curated was given a 30 day notice to leave
20:15
France, but she ignored the request.
20:17
Unfortunately, the OQTF order, also known as an Obligation to
20:22
Leave French Territory order, failed to meet its purpose.
20:26
It is a voluntary order to leave the country within 30 days.
20:30
However, they are notorious for not being followed up on, with
20:34
only one in 10 being observed. What made the circumstances even
20:39
more alarming is that Dabiya Binkered was an Algerian
20:43
national and they are at the top of the foreigners known for
20:47
abusing the system in France. When news of this child
20:50
murderer's immigration status was released to the public, the
20:55
community was outraged by the failure of the system.
20:59
Many members of the Republican Party and other ultra
21:02
conservative groups looked to blame the liberal LAX
21:06
immigration policies for causing Lola Davies death.
21:11
It was the fuel the far right could only have dreamed of that
21:16
proved that illegal immigrants were dangerous to the citizens
21:20
of France and must be handled more harshly.
21:23
The response to Dabia binquered nationality, lit a fire of
21:27
ethnic centered bias and invoked A hatred towards Algerians.
21:32
Eric Zumor, a far right party minister, bought up online
21:36
domain names with the victim Lolas name to control the
21:40
narrative. Others attempted to connect her
21:43
murder to various actions on the part of President Macron,
21:47
including tributes made to that year's Bayonne Dior winner,
21:51
which is an annual football award.
21:53
Kareem Benzema, who happened to be of Algerian descent.
21:56
Some extreme far right groups even tried to make correlation
22:00
between the young girl's death and Algerian protesters who were
22:04
killed by French police during the same week Lola was killed in
22:08
1961. They raided social media,
22:12
placing full blame upon the chaotic and loose illegal
22:16
immigration policies and procedures established under
22:19
President Macron that led to the girl's murder on ex.
22:23
Jordan Bardella, president of France's far right National
22:26
Rally party, wrote that the suspect had no business being of
22:30
France for a right proponent. Eric Zumor wrote how Lola's
22:33
murder should never have crossed her path.
22:37
The Resemblament Nationale and other far right organizations
22:41
used social media to arouse anger and spark demonstrations
22:45
for all victims of crime in Lola's name across the country,
22:49
using the hashtags Manuf por Lola and Justice por Lola.
22:53
During protest, crowds of hundreds sing a rendition of the
22:57
national anthem of France, shouting remigration, death,
23:01
pedophiles and this is our Home. The people demanded change and
23:05
justice, not just for Lola, but for everyone impacted by
23:09
violence in the National Assembly.
23:11
Prime Minister Elizabeth Borne called upon the ministers who
23:14
wanted to address the murder to have a little decency and
23:17
respect for the pain of the family.
23:19
One minister in particular declared that the suspect of
23:23
this barbaric act should not have been in French territory.
23:28
It is difficult to argue that this was true.
23:30
Justice Minister Eric DuPont Moretti accused the right of
23:34
using the coffin of a 12 year old girl to further their
23:38
political agenda. Interior Minister Gerald Armani
23:42
also condemned the indecent behavior of these politicians
23:45
who were using this tragic story of a girl's murder for their
23:50
electoral campaigns. What both sides agreed upon was
23:54
to allow a moment of silence for the slain young girl.
23:58
While these parents were grieving and dealing with the
24:01
most unimaginable pain and sorrow over the tragic loss of
24:05
their daughter, they also had to deal with the onset of questions
24:09
surrounding foreign nationals. Lola's parents were revolted by
24:14
how politicians were trying to exploit their daughter's death
24:18
to prove their stance on tougher immigration policies.
24:22
They wanted nothing to do with the issue.
24:26
Lowe's parents begged for the end of the politicization of
24:29
their daughter's death. They asked that politicians stop
24:33
any use of the name and image of our child for political ends.
24:37
President Emmanuel Macron described the crime as atrocious
24:41
and invited the family to the Alessi Palace.
24:44
There he offered his deepest condolences and told them he
24:47
would do everything in his power to unite the opposing sides and
24:52
support their family in this time of pain and grief.
24:56
President Macron, who was at the center of the right and far
25:00
rights blaming of illegal immigration policies for Lola
25:04
Davia's death, told the press that her parents have asked that
25:07
all sides show their support. Instead of increasing the pain
25:11
they are experiencing, the media lash back at politicians shaming
25:16
them for exploiting a child's death to reignite their anti
25:20
immigration beliefs. Although President Macron
25:23
strongly discouraged the use of Lola's death within political
25:26
arenas in late 20/22, he came forward with concerns of his own
25:31
based on crime data. He stated that, and I quote, if
25:35
we look at crime in Paris today, we cannot fail to see that at
25:38
least half of the crime comes from people who are foreigners,
25:42
either illegal immigrants or those waiting for a president's
25:46
permit. In any case, they're in a very
25:48
delicate situation, often coming in through these illegal
25:52
immigration channels. The officer of the Interior
25:55
Minister further supported this claim.
25:57
According to their crime statistics in Paris, foreigners,
26:01
both those who were residents and those of illegal immigration
26:05
status, comprised 48% of arrests and those held in custody within
26:10
the first six months of that year.
26:13
Their purpose was to illustrate their over representation in all
26:17
areas of crime. However, what was not addressed
26:20
was the nationality of the majority of the victims.
26:24
Although many illegal immigrants have indeed committed crimes in
26:27
France, most of them have been committed against their own
26:30
people and not against French nationals.
26:34
According to crime statistics on homicide in France, specifically
26:38
in Paris, the majority of murders that occur are intra
26:42
racial, meaning they're within the same race, similar to crime
26:46
data in many other nations, in particular United States.
26:49
Most of violent crimes, including homicide, are
26:52
committed against others of the same race or ethnic background
26:57
as the perpetrator. France had experienced this kind
27:00
of dangerous rhetoric and political jargon before.
27:04
In 1973, in Marseille, a bus driver was murdered by a
27:08
mentally ill man who was of Algerian origin.
27:11
The hatred which rose from several articles triggered the
27:15
murder of 20 innocent Algerians in the United States.
27:20
We have also seen this kind of hate speech and profiling of
27:23
racist and ethnic groups result in similar acts of hate crimes
27:28
and violence. The fact remains that the
27:31
murderer was under an expulsion order from France that was never
27:36
enforced. If they had to aborted Dabia
27:39
Binkyred, Lola Davia would not have been held captive, raped,
27:44
tortured and brutally murdered. These are facts that can't be
27:49
denied. However, there is no connection
27:52
between her being Algerian and the vileness of her actions.
27:56
The crimes of Dabiya bin Kirid have nothing to do with Lola's
28:00
nationality or her own. According to Lola Dabiya's
28:04
family, if their daughter's murder is to bring to light any
28:07
social or political issue, then it is one of criminal
28:11
responsibility, including harsher punishment.
28:14
The impact Lola Dabiya's death how on the people of France far
28:19
surpassed being shocked and horrified by what had been done
28:23
to this innocent, beautiful child.
28:25
It enraged the community. Discussions regarding the
28:29
protection of children, violence against minors and the justice
28:32
system's response to the most vile of crimes resurfaced, and
28:37
many were justifiably angry and fed up with the lack of severe
28:42
punishment. At the entrance of the multi
28:45
story apartment complex where the little girl lived and died
28:50
lay rows and rows of hundreds of bouquets, candles, letters and
28:55
notes for the innocent victim. A book of grievances was set up
29:00
in the town hall of the 19th Erdosumund for members of the
29:04
community to share the condolences.
29:08
On October 24th, 2022, Lola Daviere's funeral service was
29:12
held in the Collegiate Church of Le Lers Pas de Calais, her
29:17
mother's hometown. The funeral service was open to
29:21
all, but the family requested that it stay peaceful and not
29:25
have any sign of political conflict or mediate disruption.
29:30
During the memorial, her brother spoke the following, choking on
29:33
his tears. Loha, my adorable little sister.
29:38
I hope you can hear me in heaven.
29:40
Sadly, you left us too soon. I never had a chance to say how
29:44
much I loved you. I hope I was there for you when
29:47
you needed help. We're going to miss you, Lola.
29:50
Davie's family was shattered by her horrific murder.
29:55
They had lived a simple, modest life, but they were a very happy
30:00
and loving family. After they lost little Lola,
30:04
they decided to move away from Paris.
30:06
The tragedy of losing their young daughter, especially in
30:09
such a violent and deplorable manner, destroyed her family,
30:14
but they hung into hope that one day justice would prevail.
30:20
Tragically, Lola's father Johan couldn't hold on any longer.
30:27
When he lost his little girl, he drowned in his demons.
30:31
He would drink from the moment he woke up to when he went to
30:33
bed each night. Within a few years, Lola's
30:37
father had killed himself with alcohol.
30:40
He died in February of 2024 at the age of 49 years old.
30:46
Before his death, Johan Davie left a heartbreaking note on the
30:50
door of the apartment where his daughter was brutally tortured
30:54
and killed. And said, and I quote, my
30:58
darling, I still don't understand why there was so much
31:01
cruelty and barbarity towards you, you who were so kind.
31:06
I can't wait to see you again. That note was signed.
31:09
You're dead. Who loves you for life?
31:13
Not only was Lola's mother, Delphine haunted by the tragic,
31:16
horrible loss of her only daughter, but now she had lost
31:20
her husband too. The senseless attack on Lola
31:25
Daviay have ripped away too innocent, beautiful souls.
31:31
Meanwhile, the focus of the investigation now centered
31:34
around whether the woman who had committed these heinous, brutal
31:37
acts of rape, torture and murder have been suffering from a
31:41
psychiatric disorder at the time of the offence.
31:44
Only time an expert psychiatric evaluations could determine
31:48
whether or not she was criminally responsible under
31:51
French law. Since the early 19th century,
31:54
criminal responsibility has been the foundation of criminal law
31:57
in France. There are three categories of
32:00
criminal responsibility. The first category is a lack of
32:04
criminal responsibility. This stems from a person who was
32:07
suffering from a psychic or neuropsychic disorder at the
32:11
time of the offense which abolish their ability to control
32:14
their actions. The second is diminished
32:17
criminal responsibility. This category is designated for
32:21
individuals who psychiatric or neuropsychiatric disorder
32:25
impaired their ability to control their actions. 1/3 is a
32:29
full criminal responsibility, which indicates full awareness
32:33
and the ability to control their actions.
32:36
To determine the appropriate level of criminal
32:38
responsibility, a judge or the court may recommend one or more
32:43
expert psychiatrist. If an expert's assessment
32:46
concludes that the individual lacked criminal responsibility
32:49
as defined under the statute, a judge can declare the person as
32:53
not being criminally responsible and therefore is not subject to
32:58
incarceration. However, the judge can impose
33:00
certain measures or precautions. These can include prohibiting
33:04
access to the victim or their family or placing restrictions
33:08
on where they live and where they can travel.
33:10
In the majority of cases, a judge will impose an order of
33:13
involuntary hospitalization in a psychiatric hospital.
33:17
However, if the individual is considered to be a threat to
33:21
other safety maximum security psychiatric unit, they may be
33:24
placed in ten such units in France are monitored and
33:28
operated by the Public Health division.
33:31
Although it was determined that Debia Binkirid suffered from
33:35
personality disorders, the accused was evaluated by three
33:39
different psychiatrists. They all concluded that her
33:42
judgement was not impaired due to a mental illness at the time
33:46
of the offense and that she didn't have a treatable
33:49
condition. The psychiatrist and
33:51
psychologist all believed Diabea being carried had psychopathic
33:55
tendencies that were incurable. She was described as not being
34:00
schizophrenic, but a person who exhibited A schizotypal
34:04
personality without being entirely delusional.
34:08
Psychiatrists and psychologists both said that she showed cold
34:12
or flat effect, abnormal thoughts and statements that
34:15
were detached from reality. Debia being cared also conveyed
34:19
no remorse or regret over her actions for three long years.
34:24
Lola Davies killer was examined by multiple psychiatrists and
34:28
psychologists while she was held in prison.
34:31
It was believed by many during this lapse in time that she
34:34
would be declared mentally unfit to stand trial and never face
34:38
any real form of punishment. Dabia being carried would likely
34:42
be diagnosed with a severe mental illness and be sent to a
34:45
psychiatric facility for the criminally insane instead of
34:49
being incarcerated. Then in 2025, almost three years
34:53
to the date in which she had viciously tortured and murdered
34:58
this beautiful little girl, Dabia Ben Cured would face what
35:03
she had done. The psychiatrist did not believe
35:05
her to be mentally ill, although she exhibited many signs of
35:09
psychopathy. Dabia Ben Cured finally admitted
35:12
to everything she had done to Lola Davier and was declared
35:16
competent to stand trial. Once Debia Bing Heard was deemed
35:22
competent to stand trial, the prosecutor's office asked for
35:25
the case, to which the judge agreed.
35:27
Even when a defendant pleads guilty to the charges, under
35:30
French law, a full trial is still required to be held in
35:34
front of the court. To Assis, the court that hears
35:37
the most extreme of crimes, it is not merely a matter of guilt,
35:41
which is determined during the trial, but both sides present
35:45
evidence and aggravating and mitigating circumstances to
35:49
convey both motive and intent. Meanwhile, the death of Lola
35:53
Davier continued to create major controversy in conflict between
35:58
the political parties and division amongst women.
36:01
Alice Cordier, founder of the group Nemesis, stood in front of
36:04
the Parisian Criminal Courthouse when the trial began to, in a
36:08
quote denounced the dangerous impact of mass immigration on
36:12
Western women so that this subject becomes a public debate.
36:16
She attacked feminists, claiming that since most are associated
36:20
with left wing politics, they are more concerned about the
36:23
welfare of the accused who had allegedly been a victim of
36:27
trauma and rape, then they are there to support Lola and her
36:30
family. There is no evidence to support
36:33
this allegation she made against individual feminists or
36:36
feminists based organizations in France.
36:39
Rather, all it did was create more conflict and division
36:42
amongst the people. On Friday October 17th, 2025,
36:47
almost three years to the day that 12 year old Lola Devier had
36:52
been viciously raped, tortured and murdered, her sadistic
36:56
perpetrator would finally face the scales of justice.
37:00
Lola's family and their supporters arrived to the
37:02
courthouse, adorned and matching white T-shirts.
37:05
Then now infamous portrait of the young girl smiling on them
37:09
were written the words You'll be the son of our lives and the
37:13
star of our nights. Before the trial began, Lola's
37:17
brother Timo was granted a moment to directly address his
37:21
sister's killer. The young man bravely looked at
37:25
Debia, binquered and said to her.
37:28
We would like you to tell the truth, the whole truth, and
37:31
nothing but the truth to all of France and to us.
37:36
The reasons why Debbie had been killed, decided to rape, torture
37:40
and mercilessly kill this innocent young girl were never
37:44
revealed. Her story kept changing during
37:48
the police's interrogation of her and throughout her trial.
37:52
First she claimed that she wanted vengeance upon Lola's
37:55
mother, who refused to give her a building pass since she wasn't
37:59
a resident. Then she said she had gotten
38:01
into a huge argument with her ex-boyfriend that day.
38:04
When she saw Lola so vulnerable, she saw what was the perfect
38:11
target to release. Her rage toward Debbie had been
38:14
Keratol de Court that it wasn't little Lola she wanted to hurt
38:18
that day, it was him. She loved him so much, but he
38:23
had insulted her and told her he would never be the father of her
38:27
child. She felt full of revenge and
38:31
hatred. When she crossed the path of
38:34
Lola, Debia Binkered said that he had a gun and she had planned
38:39
to shoot him with it, but wasn't planning on killing him.
38:43
It was only 15 minutes after she had this heated altercation with
38:47
her former lover that Debia spotted Lola returning from
38:51
school. She claimed that she didn't
38:53
initially plan on harming Lola Davya, but once she had
38:58
convinced the young girl to help carry the suitcases upstairs to
39:02
her sister's apartment, she decided she was going to hurt
39:06
her. Then on the second day of the
39:08
trial, Debya being carried story as to why she tortured and
39:12
killed the girl changed now she blamed it on a combination of
39:16
drugs she was on. Debia being carried have been
39:19
taking medication for anxiety, another for epilepsy and Lyrica
39:24
which is used to treat neuropathic pain.
39:27
Debia being carried alleged that she was using the drugs to deal
39:31
with the psychological pain she was suffering from selling her
39:34
body in the streets of Paris. She said that she had taken 3 of
39:38
the tablets the day before she attacked Lola and she fell into
39:42
a dark violent state. When the judge inquired as to
39:47
why she had never shared this information before now, the
39:50
accused stated I know I killed a baby, an Angel, she must be in
39:55
heaven by now. When Debia being cured was asked
39:58
if the drugs is what drove her to rape and murder Lola, she
40:02
said yes, it was the drugs, she just wasn't herself that day.
40:07
Then on the third day, the deranged young woman once again
40:11
changed her story. Now the sequence of evil events
40:14
that unfolded was because she was bewitched by her former
40:18
boyfriend. Debya Binkaran alleged that a
40:21
man in his 30s known as Fatah A, who was currently in prison and
40:26
was on screen from his cell during the trial, had placed a
40:30
spell of witchcraft on her. It was the evil spell that had
40:35
LED her to rape, torture and murder the 12 year old girl.
40:39
The courtroom will listen to the dark and dramatic and totally
40:43
unbelievable tale the sick woman spun.
40:47
She told the judges that it was Fatah that had led me to do it
40:50
and that she had no idea what she was doing.
40:53
Dabia Benkara claimed that when she was with him, he made her
40:57
drink something that caused her to have hallucinations.
41:00
Ever since then, she had viewed the world as upside down.
41:04
She even described how he had taken her to a cemetery where he
41:08
had buried children he had killed.
41:11
And yet the accused provided no other information regarding this
41:14
bizarre and shocking story. When her former boyfriend Fatah
41:19
was asked about these allegations, he said.
41:22
I am baffled by what I just heard.
41:24
I'm a stranger to all this, he testified to the court.
41:28
I had the impression that she was a little possessed.
41:32
I had the impression that she was talking to people, that she
41:35
saw me as someone else. Fatah clarified that he was in
41:40
prison for divorce related offenses, but that he didn't
41:44
want Debia around his young son because of her immoral and
41:49
unpredictable behavior he described to the courtroom.
41:52
Hell, on a trip to the mall one day she stole some candy and
41:55
this infuriated him because he wanted his son to be taught not
41:59
to steal. Dabiya Binkered was void of any
42:04
emotion and she matter of factly explained to the court how she
42:07
took all of her hatred and rage out on the poor girl.
42:11
She didn't want to kill her, but she wanted to hurt someone and
42:15
knew that either way, Lola was going to die that day.
42:18
Dabiya Binkered told the courtroom.
42:20
I took revenge on the little girl.
42:23
She was a weaker person than me. I didn't choose her.
42:25
It came suddenly. Since I had raped her, I might
42:28
as well kill her. In shock and disgust, Loa
42:32
Devier's family in the courtroom had to listen to this woman
42:35
speak about how while Lola was suffocating on her own blood,
42:39
she turned up the music loud and smoked a cigarette while the
42:44
young girl's body shook and jolted, fighting for its last
42:50
breath. During the trial, the courtroom
42:52
filled with Lola Davie's loved ones was further traumatized by
42:56
the graphic horrible images shown of her multiple injuries,
43:01
including those inflicted upon her genitals.
43:03
Several family members could not take any more and walked out of
43:08
the courtroom, but her mother Delphine and brother Tebow
43:14
remained there watching and listening to every horrific
43:19
moment their daughter and sister suffered at the hands of what
43:23
they called the Devil Monster Woman.
43:27
They refused to turn their heads away or cover their ears.
43:31
They were determined to receive justice for their Lola.
43:36
When the horrific and disturbing images of Lola Devier's injuries
43:41
were displayed on screen in court, her murderer stared at
43:46
the screen without any sign of emotion.
43:50
At the trial, Delphine described her late daughter as her mini
43:53
me. She was a very social, loving,
43:56
happy go lucky young girl, naive, always ready to help
44:00
others. Her propensity for being a
44:04
sweet, friendly, trusting little girl became her death sentence.
44:09
Pictures of Lola Davier as a vibrant, lovely little girl
44:14
enjoying her life were projected on the courtroom wall.
44:18
Delphine testified in the courtroom how she had always
44:21
taught her children about being wary of strangers.
44:26
Delphine stated how she used to tell them and I quote, if you're
44:29
attacked, don't hesitate to scream, there will always be
44:32
someone who will hear you. Then her daughter encounter what
44:36
she described as this devil monster.
44:40
I couldn't save my Lola. My heart is forever broken, she
44:45
told the courtroom. Delphine stressed to the judges
44:48
how she not only lost Lola because of Debia being carried.
44:53
She lost her husband, her job, her home, everything was gone
44:59
except for her son, which is the only reason she's still
45:05
breathing. She looked at the devil monster
45:08
Debia been carried and said this thing won't take away the love
45:13
and our family. Lola's grief stricken mother
45:16
pleaded with the court to not spare the accused any
45:19
punishment. She deserves to be locked away
45:22
forever. In a heart wrenching moment
45:24
during the trial, Lola's mother asked her forensic pathologist
45:28
whether her daughter had suffered at the end, stating how
45:32
she had been plagued haunted by the question over the last three
45:35
years. The expert told the mother the
45:38
truth about asphyxiation and how it has three aspects.
45:42
There are the physical, psychological and emotional
45:46
effects. Because the ACT induces extreme
45:48
anxiety in the victim, Being unable to get oxygen to breathe
45:53
is an intense and serious source of anxiety.
45:57
The pathologist could not lie about the degree of how much her
46:01
young daughter had suffered. Mitigating circumstances
46:04
surrounding the accused backgrounds were presented by
46:06
the defense of trial. Debia being carried had a
46:09
volatile, unhappy childhood. She had spent her years in both
46:12
Algeria and France with cold, unaffectionate aunts and an
46:16
abusive father. There had been a documented
46:18
report of a domestic violent incident with a past boyfriend,
46:22
a history of mental illness and the claim she had made
46:25
previously to the police about being a victim of rape.
46:30
But three psychiatric experts said they had noted psychopathic
46:34
tendencies in the accused and they did not believe she
46:37
suffered from any mental health condition that could be cured.
46:41
A court psychiatrist who evaluated the accused testified
46:44
as to how unsettled and frustrated she felt and not
46:48
being able to find a diagnosis or reason for the horrific acts
46:53
W being cured had committed. The psychiatrist, Corrine Jean,
46:57
told the court in a quote. In 15 years of expertise, this
47:01
is the first time I felt this way.
47:05
I found myself faced with a paralysis of my thoughts, a
47:09
feeling of unease that catches in the throat.
47:12
The doctor also shared with the courtroom how the accused was
47:15
very interested in the media coverage surrounding the murder.
47:20
This invested interest by the accused further supported the
47:24
belief that Debia being carried had strong psychopathic
47:29
tendencies. When she was asked to respond to
47:31
the psychiatrist evaluation of her, she stated UN quote.
47:35
I realized that I was talking nonsense to them.
47:38
Her voice was strangely high pitched and barely audible when
47:45
she replied. According to the Attorney
47:47
General, Debia being carried was not simply out for revenge and
47:52
targeted the young girl in a moment of rage.
47:55
She was a predator who lured and trapped the girl to satisfy her
48:00
own sexual pleasures. The prosecutor argued that the
48:03
sentence must represent the depravity of the crime.
48:07
The cruelty, the barbarity and the severe suffering inflicted
48:12
on both the victim and her family must be reflected in the
48:16
defendants punishment. Before she pled guilty to all
48:20
charges and the judges sentenced her, she expressed remorse and
48:23
apologized to Lola's family for her horrible actions.
48:27
Debbie have been carried stated I asked for forgiveness and what
48:32
I did is horrible. That is all I have to say.
48:35
Her words felt choreographed, shallow and meaningless.
48:39
Outside the courtroom, hundreds of residents called for the
48:42
death of Debbie Have been carried.
48:44
But for the citizens of France, justice would prevail even if
48:48
death was not an option under the current law.
48:51
While the verdict was being read, the presenting judge
48:54
addressed the extreme cruelty of the criminal acts, which he
48:57
called true torture and total dehumanization.
49:02
In a moment that stunned all of France and much of the world,
49:06
the judges handed down a life sentence.
49:09
The sentence is what is referred to as an irreducible life
49:13
sentence. This means that there is no
49:15
possibility of parole or reduction in sentence.
49:20
In France, a life sentence without parole specifically
49:24
means that there is no chance of parole before serving a minimum
49:28
of 30 years. After 30 years, a convicted
49:31
offender may ask a judge to review the ban on their
49:35
possibility of parole. Since Debbie had been carried
49:38
had been incarcerated for three years before her trial, this
49:41
means she will have to serve 27 years before being able to
49:45
request a review. This penalty may not sound
49:49
severe enough to listeners in the United States and other
49:52
countries who currently work under a crime control model of
49:55
justice. However, in France, this is the
49:58
longest sentence permitted under the law.
50:01
It is extremely uncommon and is usually only granted to mass
50:06
murder, such as terrorists and serial killers.
50:10
Capital punishment has been abolished in France since 1981.
50:15
The maximum sentence of life imprisonment without parole,
50:18
also known as perpetuate incompressible, was established
50:22
in 1994 in response to some of the most brutal and shocking
50:26
murders France had experienced in decades.
50:28
It was designed to make prison a truly only about a dozen men,
50:34
mainly serial killers and terrorists, had received the
50:36
punishment. Michelle Fournier, also known as
50:39
the Ogre of the Ardens, was convicted of killing twelve
50:42
women. And Jahidas Salah Abdesalem, one
50:46
of the terrorists behind the 2015 attack in Paris, which took
50:50
the lives of 130 people, are two examples of the individuals who
50:54
have received this sentence. 27 year old Debia bin Cured was the
51:00
first woman in France to have been given a life sentence.
51:05
This verdict was unprecedented and made a loud, bold statement
51:10
to the people of France and the world that anyone who commenced
51:14
A sadistic, brutal murder, especially against a child, will
51:19
face the most serious of consequences, no matter the
51:23
gender of the offender. After she was sentenced to the
51:27
most severe punishment under French law, Lola Davi's brother
51:31
Tebow expressed great gratitude to the justice system, stating
51:37
his family is happy with the outcome and how the system has
51:41
restored the memory of his sister.
51:44
It has restored the truth. Lola's mother told the media
51:48
that this was the case. Even if it won't give us back
51:51
our Lola, we believed in justice.
51:54
And justice was received. Lola's mother, Delphine and her
51:57
brother Tebow were seen embracing and crying together
52:01
after the historical verdict was read.
52:04
They could finally breathe a little.
52:07
Justice had come at last for their little Lola, and it was a
52:12
step toward healing. The lure for the family, called
52:15
Tilt Lupetit, spoke of how it fixed a wrong, a wrong that had
52:20
been waiting over three years to be reversed.
52:24
Alexander Volla, the lawyer for the now convicted Dabia
52:28
Binkered, stated that he was not at all surprised by the sentence
52:31
and that his client had not decided whether or not she would
52:34
appeal. It was difficult for anyone to
52:36
deny that justice was not met once this historical verdict was
52:41
delivered. However, for the National Rally
52:43
Party, being given a life sentence for such a barbaric
52:47
crime, but still not enough. The subsequent deportation of
52:51
violent foreign criminals must come after incarceration.
52:55
I would presume that if or when Debia been carried is granted
52:59
parole, which would be shocking if she ever were, she will be
53:05
deported back to her native country of Algeria.
53:09
The country had waited for three years for justice to finally be
53:13
given to Lola Davia. She had become the stolen child
53:19
of all of France, despite her parents ongoing request to not
53:25
have their daughter's murder become political.
53:27
Her death had ignited a debate around the due diligence of
53:32
deportations and the threat of foreign nationals.
53:35
Lola Devier had become a symbol of justice reform, particularly
53:39
in the area of protecting children, and also brought out
53:42
more of an emphasis being placed on mental health support as well
53:46
as the reform of migration laws. I would like to 1st discuss this
53:51
case through the framework of the French legal system.
53:53
It is vastly different from the United States and Britain and
53:57
understanding these differences is critical to the way the case
54:00
was handled, from the investigation to the sentencing.
54:05
The justice system in France is a civil law system. the United
54:09
States and Britain are both based on a system of common law
54:12
which relies heavily on and builds upon its prior case
54:16
decisions. In contrast, France places a
54:19
heavier reliance upon its statutes and applies relevant
54:23
codes and regulations to the Act and its parties.
54:27
Each case is decided as an individual separate case from
54:31
the next, with little to no reference to past court
54:35
decisions. French law is divided into two
54:39
areas of legislation, draw public or public law, which
54:43
governs state and public bodies, and draw privet or private law
54:48
which governs private individuals and entities.
54:50
The private law is further broken down into two sections.
54:53
The first is draw civil and the second is draw Pannell, which
54:58
governs criminal law. Similar to the United States,
55:00
The highest importance is placed upon the rules set forth by the
55:04
Constitution of France. The courts in France are split
55:07
into administrative courts and judicial courts, with the letter
55:10
handling all matters of civil and criminal law.
55:14
The highest judicial court is the Supreme Court of Appeals,
55:17
also known as Court de Sicion. A unique aspect of French law is
55:22
the Constitutional Council, also known as the Concierge
55:25
Constitutional. This is the third branch that
55:28
overseas statutes before they become law national elections
55:32
and address questions posed by citizens surrounding the
55:35
legality of laws. This court includes 9 appointed
55:38
members who are nominated by the President and confirmed by
55:42
Presidents of the two Houses of Parliament, the National
55:45
Assembly and the Senate. The first version of the French
55:48
Constitution was the Declaration of the Rights of Man and its
55:51
Citizens, established on August 26th, 1789.
55:55
Charles de Gaulle founded the Council on October 4th.
55:58
T58 man who is most famously associated with a massive
56:02
International Airport outside Paris.
56:05
There are three criminal courts established in France that
56:08
handle varying levels of seriousness.
56:11
The Tribunal of Police is composed of a single judge who
56:14
determines cases of a minor nature, with potential fines not
56:18
exceeding more than €3000 and with no time in prison.
56:22
The second level of crimes is determined by the Correctional
56:25
Tribunal, which is made-up of three judges.
56:28
These judges handle more serious offenses, which are classified
56:31
as dilits under the Penal Code of France.
56:34
Such crimes face penalties of up to 10 years in prison.
56:38
The accusations within the 1st 2 criminal courts are presented by
56:42
a prosecutor. The most serious of crimes are
56:44
judged by the court the asses, which is composed of three
56:48
professional judges and 9 jurors in which they all deliberate
56:51
together. It is not required that all
56:53
jurors and judges come to a unanimous decision.
56:56
Rather the decision must be made based on a minimum of eight
56:59
votes. If a decision of a high crime is
57:02
appealed, the jury in the Appellate Assis Court increases
57:05
to 15, including three judges and 12 citizen jurors, with a
57:10
majority of 10 needed to convict.
57:12
I find it interesting how a jury is involved in appellate cases
57:16
when only judges hear appellate cases in the United States.
57:19
Also interestingly, there is no official transcript of the
57:24
trial. The court clerk writes notes,
57:26
but they are often done by hand during the proceeding which
57:30
becomes part of the records, but there is no complete word for
57:34
Word documentation of the event. This is strange to me, but I
57:39
think because their case decisions are not based upon
57:42
past court cases, maybe they don't see the purpose in keeping
57:46
an official transcript of each case.
57:49
Still, it seems as if there would be significance in having
57:52
more official records when an individual is held in custody.
57:56
This is called guarde avoux. Under French law, anyone
58:00
arrested is read and given notice of rights that are very
58:03
similar to Miranda rights in the United States.
58:06
However, a defendant who invokes the right to remain silent is
58:09
very rare in France, since remaining silent when the person
58:13
is capable of explaining their circumstances is a strong
58:18
indication of guilt. A person can be held for an
58:21
initial 24 hours for investigative purposes.
58:25
If it is deemed necessary for the investigation to go longer,
58:29
the person can be held for an additional 24 hours under
58:32
written authorization of the district prosecutor.
58:35
For incidents of a more serious nature, such as drug trafficking
58:39
or organized crime, this period can be further extended, with
58:43
suspects of terrorist activity being held up to 6 stays.
58:48
However, only under written authorization by the Judge of
58:51
liberties and detention is this permitted.
58:54
Criminal investigations in France are split into two
58:57
general categories. Then, minor and simpler crimes
59:00
are handled by the police and the public prosecutor.
59:02
For more complex and serious offenses, these crimes are
59:06
handed over to an investigating magistrate.
59:09
It is recorded that more than 90% of criminal cases proceed
59:13
with the police working along with the Public prosecutor to
59:16
investigate and are never handed over to the magistrate.
59:20
Investigating magistrates are located throughout the country
59:23
and under certain circumstances may collaborate as a team.
59:26
Once a preliminary investigation has been performed by the Public
59:30
prosecutor, the investigation magistrate is then given
59:33
authority to commence the investigation.
59:36
There are some circumstances where a third party with a
59:39
vested interest in the case may also file a complaint with the
59:42
magistrate. This tends to be the victim or
59:45
the victim's family, but it can also be a non governmental
59:48
organization. If their claim is approved, the
59:52
status of the third party. This person or the group then
59:55
has access to the information and evidence which is gathered
59:58
throughout the investigation. Once they have become a formal
1:00:02
party to the investigation then they are parties to the trial
1:00:05
and any subsequent appeal. The scope of the investigation
1:00:08
under the magistrate is restricted to the facts and the
1:00:11
individuals who are listed in the order.
1:00:14
Given by the public prosecutor, they ultimately determine
1:00:17
whether a violation of the law has occurred and who the
1:00:20
offender is. If the organization is shown to
1:00:22
have evidence which is significant and corroborated
1:00:25
that the individual or organization is criminally
1:00:28
responsible for the act, they are brought to appear before the
1:00:32
Magistrate. They are then informed that they
1:00:34
have been placed under a formal investigation, also known as
1:00:38
Me's in examine. The investigation Magistrate has
1:00:41
a plethora of tools to use with or without the assistance of the
1:00:45
police, including what are known as dawn raids on the suspects,
1:00:48
premises, wiretaps and of course interrogation.
1:00:52
Once an investigation has been finished, the investigation
1:00:55
Magistrate formally acknowledges its completion and the files are
1:00:58
then handed over to the Public Prosecutor.
1:01:01
Her reviews and submits observations in a formal
1:01:04
document. It includes their opinion as to
1:01:06
who, if anyone, should be charged and prosecuted in a
1:01:09
trial. This document is copied and
1:01:12
given to all parties of the investigation.
1:01:14
However, in stark contrast to the United States, the
1:01:17
investigation magistrate has more authority over the
1:01:20
prosecutor since they can bind a party over to trial whether the
1:01:24
prosecutor has recommended them to be or not.
1:01:28
All parties are allowed to submit their own observations
1:01:31
prior to a final decision being made.
1:01:33
Unique to the French legal system, neither prosecutors nor
1:01:37
judges are considered lawyers in France in the sense that they
1:01:40
are not members of the local bar and they generally have not
1:01:44
received professional training which is applicable to lawyers.
1:01:48
Most of the time. The outcome is one of two
1:01:50
decisions. The investigation magistrate
1:01:53
decides to dismiss the person in any associated charges or the
1:01:57
individual or organization is bound to trial.
1:02:00
There is 1/3 rare outcome and that is when the magistrate
1:02:04
declares that they are without jurisdiction to determine the
1:02:07
direction of the case. The dismissal of a case can be
1:02:10
appealed by the public prosecutor.
1:02:12
Although the other parties can't typically appeal a decision,
1:02:15
they are able to be active in the process and intervene to
1:02:20
influence the investigation. This can include a formal
1:02:23
request for an expert or to search for evidence that could
1:02:26
be exculpatory. Before an individual is given
1:02:29
the status of being under formal investigation, very little can
1:02:33
be done to influence the investigation or prepare a
1:02:36
defense. This is because it is very
1:02:38
difficult for the defense counsel to obtain any
1:02:41
information surrounding the investigation as they are not
1:02:44
allowed direct contact with any potential witness or counsel.
1:02:49
Since this would be perceived as an attempt to influence their
1:02:52
testimony, this act would be considered a serious violation
1:02:56
and defense lawyers avoid making contact with witnesses in any
1:03:00
matter, so it is not considered an issue.
1:03:03
The investigating magistrate is unique to a legal system since
1:03:07
they don't investigate for one side.
1:03:09
Rather, their role is to investigate and gather evidence
1:03:13
that could both be incriminating and exculpatory, meaning that it
1:03:17
could lead to potential doubt regarding the guilt of the
1:03:20
suspect. Unlike a homicide investigating
1:03:22
in the United States, who searches for evidence to support
1:03:25
the prosecution of an offender, the investigating magistrate is
1:03:29
expected to uncover the truth behind what occurred.
1:03:33
France does not have a legal term for homicide.
1:03:35
Instead it is divided into unintentional injuries versus
1:03:39
intentional attacks on another person.
1:03:42
Within the latter of the Criminal Code defines 2 types.
1:03:45
The 1st is the intentional cause of a persons death without
1:03:48
premeditation, which is defined as murder.
1:03:51
The second is premeditated murder or murder line and wait,
1:03:55
which is defined as an assassination.
1:03:58
The intentional rate of death in France in 2023 was 1.3 per
1:04:03
100,000 residents, which is 1 if not the lowest in the European
1:04:07
Union. Female offenders are
1:04:10
exceptionally rare, with an estimation of their committing
1:04:13
murder being as low as 6 per 1,000,000 residents, Similar to
1:04:18
studies performed in the United States and many other nations,
1:04:22
most homicides are committed by youth crime.
1:04:24
Data from 2016 to 2017 indicated that 320 women committed
1:04:30
homicide in Paris. 57% of the offenders were under 36 years
1:04:36
old. The majority of the incidents
1:04:38
occurred in highly populated areas, with 30% in the urban
1:04:42
areas of Paris. Of these female offenders, 44%
1:04:46
were unemployed and 9% were identified as foreign.
1:04:50
There are 6 maximum security prisons and seven maximum
1:04:53
security sections within prisons in France.
1:04:57
Many long sentences are carried out in detention centers or
1:05:00
sections designed for such. Since female prisoners are rare,
1:05:05
most of their facilities are within a separate section of the
1:05:08
male prisons. In fact, only two out of the 59
1:05:12
criminal facilities are specifically designated to
1:05:15
females. In France, there are currently
1:05:17
480 individuals, which is .7% of criminals having a life sentence
1:05:22
in France. There are 75,897 people who are
1:05:27
currently incarcerated in France.
1:05:29
Females comprise 3.3% of the prison population.
1:05:33
Between January 2023 and 2024, country did see an increase of
1:05:37
9.6% in its female prisoners. Of these female prisoners, 23.2%
1:05:43
were identified as foreign nationals.
1:05:45
What is it in? Arguably the most important and
1:05:48
disturbing element of this case to discuss is the gender of the
1:05:52
offender and the prevalence of female sex based violence.
1:05:56
As mentioned while discussing the trial, the Attorney General
1:05:59
and prosecutor pointed out that the crimes committed by Dabiya
1:06:03
Benkurid we're not simply out of revenge or rage.
1:06:07
They were crimes committed by someone seeking to fulfill their
1:06:11
own sick, perverse sexual fantasies or desires.
1:06:15
Dabiya Benkurid was a child predator, a vicious pedophile.
1:06:20
Our society, even with more and more cases every year that
1:06:24
involve women, has trouble grasping the concept of female
1:06:27
predators. The typical image of the
1:06:30
pedophile in people's minds still draws up a white older man
1:06:35
who often works in the vicinity of children, such as a teacher
1:06:39
or sports coach. A violent predator of children
1:06:42
is the weird man who drives around in a windowless van.
1:06:46
A woman in her early 20s who by most standards of beauty would
1:06:51
have been deemed to be attractive and physically fit,
1:06:54
does not fit within the mold of a pedophile, nor a predator, and
1:06:59
society's mind, Dabiya Ben Carried, was the opposite of a
1:07:04
criminal profile for either of these types of sexual offenders.
1:07:10
It's only been in recent years that the media and the legal
1:07:13
system have begun treating females who have inappropriate
1:07:17
and illegal sexual contact with their underage students as the
1:07:22
criminals they are. What?
1:07:24
A man under the same circumstances would be labeled
1:07:27
as a rapist and a pedophile. Women have been painted as being
1:07:31
misunderstood, desperately lonely, and mentally ill.
1:07:35
The media has gone so far as to encourage the narrative of this
1:07:39
being a young boy's ultimate fantasy getting with the hot
1:07:43
older teacher. This is not a new portrayal by
1:07:46
any means as it has been commonly depicted in all forms
1:07:50
of media. Fortunately, today female
1:07:53
educators who prey on young vulnerable males or females are
1:07:57
being cast in a different and more dangerous light than in
1:08:01
previous decades. The research done on female
1:08:04
sexual predators yields very conflicting results depending on
1:08:08
what sources the data has come from.
1:08:10
Hence lies a big reason as to why they are not part of the
1:08:15
stranger danger equation or conversation most parents have.
1:08:20
But studies show their prevalence is much higher than
1:08:24
expected. One research study based on 232
1:08:28
sexual offense arrests of women from 2001 in 21 U.S. states
1:08:33
discovered that of the women arrested for sexual offenses,
1:08:36
45% were Co offenders. Research on female Co offending
1:08:41
has revealed that some of them also engage in abuse on their
1:08:44
own before or after Co offending with a partner, typically male.
1:08:50
A more recent study done in 2015 that analyzed all sexual crime
1:08:54
incidents between 1992 and 2011 across 37 states showed that out
1:09:01
of the 800 and 2150 sex crimes that were reported, if .4% were
1:09:08
committed by females. Of the 43,018 incidents
1:09:12
involving females, 38.1% were committed with a Co offender
1:09:17
with 85% of them being male. What was shocking to learn from
1:09:20
the study is that 61.9% of the cases that were committed by
1:09:26
women were committed by women alone, indicating that 2/3 of
1:09:31
all sexual offenses committed by females are done on their own
1:09:34
without any force, coercion or abuse by a Co offender.
1:09:38
The belief that a female who commits sexual offenses is
1:09:42
almost always accompanied or forced by a male partner is a
1:09:46
lie. It is a myth that perpetuates
1:09:49
the idea that females are victims and they are innocent or
1:09:53
at least less culpable of the crime.
1:09:56
A meta analysis based on 17 samples from 12 different
1:09:59
countries showed that sexual offenses committed by females
1:10:03
reported to police were approximately 2.2% of all
1:10:07
incidents. However, in shocking contrast,
1:10:11
victimization surveys revealed the prevalence of such offenses
1:10:16
to be as high as 11.6%, which is almost 6 times higher than the
1:10:21
official crime data. Males were much more likely to
1:10:24
self report that their offender was a female. 40% of males
1:10:29
reported they were molested or abused by a female versus only
1:10:32
4% of females who reported their offender was a woman.
1:10:36
Another unofficial source supported the disturbing truth
1:10:40
about female sexual offenders. Data from the National Society
1:10:44
for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children revealed that 5% of
1:10:48
girls and 44% of boys who reported abuse through the child
1:10:52
helpline claimed to have been abused by a female.
1:10:57
A meta analysis of female sexual offenders in 12 countries
1:11:01
unearthed a similar alarming pattern.
1:11:04
Officially, reported crimes indicate that they account for
1:11:06
around 2% of sexual offenders. However, when victimization data
1:11:11
was exclusively evaluated, 12% of all sexual offenders were
1:11:16
female. Much of this conflicting data
1:11:18
stems from the fact that many health professionals, as well as
1:11:22
law enforcement, don't perceive females as being sexual abusers
1:11:27
or predators. Too often, their victims are not
1:11:30
believed. Other adults explain away the
1:11:33
actions of the female offenders, behavior that was misunderstood
1:11:37
or misread by the victim in some way.
1:11:39
This is particularly true when the offender is the victim's
1:11:43
relative, especially when it is their mothers.
1:11:46
Instead of being supported and given compassion, victims are
1:11:49
told they must have misinterpreted how their mother
1:11:52
touched them. It was a figment of their
1:11:54
imagination or even a fantasy. When a female does sexually
1:12:00
offend, they are frequently portrayed as the Co offender of
1:12:03
a man who forced them to participate.
1:12:06
Or at least that is how they depict their role in the
1:12:08
offence. Or the woman must have been
1:12:10
severely mentally ill to have committed such a sick act
1:12:13
against a child. Or even more dangerous is the
1:12:17
notion that when a female sexually offends, little to no
1:12:21
harm is done. All of these beliefs align with
1:12:25
the long held traditional view of female criminals.
1:12:28
Females who commit sexual homicide constitute
1:12:31
approximately 5% of all known offenders.
1:12:35
Due to this very low rate of female sexual offenders being
1:12:38
arrested, much less charged and convicted of such offenses, it
1:12:42
remains a low prioritized area of study.
1:12:46
There is very little research that has been conducted on
1:12:49
female sexual offenders, much less female sexual murderers.
1:12:54
Homicide arrests between 1976 and 2022 showed that females
1:12:58
accounted for 11.6% of offenders.
1:13:03
Of these homicide offenders, 6201 cases were defined as
1:13:08
sexual murders. An analysis of 158 single victim
1:13:12
cases revealed some interesting characteristics and patterns of
1:13:16
female sexual murderers. The average age was 27.9, with
1:13:21
75.3% being between the ages of 18 and 39 years old.
1:13:26
Female sexual murderers targeted acquaintances in 42% of the
1:13:31
incidents and 33 point .9% were strangers. 76.6% of these
1:13:37
homicides were committed in areas with higher populations.
1:13:40
Firearms were used in 63.9% of the murders.
1:13:46
For society to believe that girls and women are capable of
1:13:49
purposely and knowingly sexually harming children, including
1:13:53
committing violent acts that lead to their deaths, we must
1:13:58
let go of ingrained perceptions and preconceptions surrounding
1:14:04
females. Not all females are kind,
1:14:07
nurturing, nor are they protective of children.
1:14:10
Not all females are trustworthy. Many females are just as
1:14:15
dangerous and predatory as males can be.
1:14:19
Females can target, manipulate, and harm children.
1:14:23
Females can be sexual offenders. Girls and women can be sick,
1:14:27
twisted, and depraved for the sheer reason of wanting to
1:14:32
inflict harm, control, and seek to fulfill their own vile sexual
1:14:36
pleasures just as boys and men can.
1:14:39
The sooner societies acknowledge and accept this fact, the less
1:14:44
likely an innocent child will fall prey to a sadistic female
1:14:49
predator like Debia Binkered. Thank you so much for listening
1:14:58
to the tragic, heartbreaking story of Francis Lola Davier.
1:15:07
For those of you who aren't already aware, I alone am Shades
1:15:10
of Murder and it's a true labor of love.
1:15:15
I know there are countless true crime podcasts out there and
1:15:19
your support listening and following the show means the
1:15:23
world to me. But I need your help to grow the
1:15:27
podcast and the best way you can do this is make sure you're
1:15:32
following or subscribed of course, and rate it.
1:15:36
Leave a review and share the show with a friend.
1:15:40
It's easy, free, and will only take a moment of your time.
1:15:45
Each one of your voices and your support truly makes a
1:15:50
difference. If you are on Spotify,
1:15:53
underneath the title and cover art, there is a gear or three
1:15:56
dots. You just click on that and you
1:15:58
can rate from there. If you prefer to leave a rating
1:16:01
and a review on Apple, you can simply Scroll down the page of
1:16:04
the show, select a rating, and then tap on Write a Review.
1:16:08
Alternatively, you can leave reviews on the platforms Cast
1:16:11
Box, Pod, Chaser, Audible, and through Amazon Music.
1:16:15
Reviews don't have to be long or complicated.
1:16:18
You can simply tell me what your favorite episode has been so far
1:16:21
or what kind of cases you would like to hear more about.
1:16:24
Sharing your thoughts and comments about the show with
1:16:28
other potential listeners is the best way to support the show and
1:16:34
help it grow. Your support means the world to
1:16:36
me, and if you let me know you left a review, I would be
1:16:39
thrilled to read it on the next episode.
1:16:43
Again, thank you so much for listening.
1:16:46
Until next time, stay safe and watch out for Shades of Murder
1:16:55
happening in the streets next door, actually inside your own
1:17:02
home. Shades of Murder is created,
1:17:07
researched, written and edited by Elito Caldwell.
1:17:13
Original music stranger composed by Stereo Code.