Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP153: When You Need A Specialist CMS Instead of Native Platform Page Builders & How to Evaluate CMS Systems
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for tuning into the re-platform podcast.
- 0:04Sponsored by a synclavier. Oh, you're listening to myself,
- 0:07James GERD and my co-host for Rogers.
- 0:09Good morning may get. How are ya?
- 0:11How you doing? Yeah, well you're on much colder
- 0:14than you because you're over in Dubai.
- 0:15You being there, the Grand Prix. How's it been?
- 0:17Yeah, really good. Although I'm quite cold at the
- 0:20moment. Yeah.
- 0:20Comes pretty cold in the hotel room.
- 0:22I'm doing this from but I won't be in about 45 minutes.
- 0:27Yeah, well I'm not gonna weep for you too much makers.
- 0:30It's freezing in the UK at the moment as you, well know.
- 0:32So enjoy the sunshine while it lasts.
- 0:35Yeah, I've only got another day, so I'll be back in a couple of
- 0:38days, straight back to after the cool.
- 0:40Well, let's let's record. An exciting episode from the
- 0:44freezing cold, AC rooms of Dubai.
- 0:48Welcome back to our regular since thanks for tuning in.
- 0:51And if this is the first time to do the podcast, we hope you
- 0:53enjoy it. If you subscribe, you get new
- 0:56episode alerts, you can subscribe on our website and
- 0:58we'd love a like on YouTube. Spotify or apple because that
- 1:01massively helps us with our visibility and ratings.
- 1:04Thank you. So, our topic today is when do
- 1:07you need a CMS instead of a native e-commerce platform page,
- 1:10build. And how do you, how do you
- 1:11evaluate these systems? So content features, highly most
- 1:15e-commerce platform rfps, especially with Brands who are
- 1:19kind of experience and content-driven, looking to focus
- 1:22on the overall customer experience, not just Commerce
- 1:24capability vendors. Talk about page, builders that
- 1:28businesses are thinking about, Content management.
- 1:31So, the language isn't always tied up and sometimes what
- 1:33people think of when a vendor says page builder is very
- 1:37different to what the modern page Builders can actually do.
- 1:40And sometimes people can Overlook, actually what they can
- 1:42get out of an existing system. So, we want to look at use cases
- 1:44when a specialist content management, system or digital
- 1:47experience platform might be required because the native page
- 1:50builder comedy, satisfied business need.
- 1:52So, we're going to talk about when does a page builder
- 1:54suffice. So, when he get way of not
- 1:56having to spend extra on licensing and integration costs,
- 1:59what car On page, Builders do that specialist content
- 2:01management and and exps digital experience platforms do and how
- 2:05do you mean and really evaluate their party cms's so pulled?
- 2:09You want to put a bit of a context on this or on where
- 2:12we've come from an e-commerce with CMS and where we're at now.
- 2:17Yeah, it's a yes I think as you said still like a really broad
- 2:22kind of space, and I think there's like, there's kind of
- 2:24like different ends of the spectrum as well.
- 2:26So you've got, you know, the likes of Bigcommerce,
- 2:28Salesforce, Magento Shopify. They've all got kind of page,
- 2:31Building Solutions of differing kind of native capability.
- 2:37So, you know, some of just got relatively basic, kind of
- 2:41ability to drop a banner and overlay, text, etc, etc.
- 2:44And then, you know, shop five is now built Our perceptions
- 2:47everywhere, which is quite broad across the shop by platform you
- 2:51then and, you know, yourself, thoughts Magento have the same.
- 2:54I think magenta is historically. I've customized it quite a bit
- 2:58on build, says, quite a lot. You can do with a so dependent
- 3:01on the platform. You've got different kind of.
- 3:03Yeah, flexibility native features, Etc.
- 3:09And then you've got some other platforms.
- 3:10Like, I know you've worked quite a bit with optimizely, or a p
- 3:13server, as it's called before. And I know there are a lot
- 3:15broader And then there's plenty of other platforms on the market
- 3:19that have invested in this area. But then you have, you know, the
- 3:23kind of add-on page builder solutions, that may be like
- 3:27still a step away from a Content management system like maybe,
- 3:30you know, as Ed mags for actually, kind of building out
- 3:33content or Shogun which integrates with, I think all
- 3:37four of those platforms and kind of, yeah, just gives you a
- 3:41little bit more kind of flexibility around content and
- 3:44allows you to maybe use things like Version Control.
- 3:47Cetera. So it's kind of like step
- 3:48towards the content management platform and then at the other
- 3:52end as you have, then you have the likes of kind of Bloom reach
- 3:55and a dance, which are kind of more headless EMS Solutions, but
- 3:59you see them a lot nowadays. And I would say that's probably
- 4:03like, they're probably the two that I see that kind of the, to,
- 4:07with the type of brand that I'm working with where someone might
- 4:10really push, the native capabilities of the platform,
- 4:12then they start looking at that, and then you have the likes of,
- 4:15you know, am and some of the Kind of really enterprise-d XP
- 4:20Solutions, which were a bit broader again.
- 4:23So, yes, that would be my kind of summary of it.
- 4:25And then, I think the majority of our clients would use the
- 4:28native page product, but it is the platforms.
- 4:31I think, particularly big Commerce in Shopify.
- 4:34Pretty strong overall, you know, shop, I've come a long way since
- 4:39they released sections everywhere and, you know, that
- 4:42was always one of the biggest limitations of the platform.
- 4:45Yeah. Magenta is Page.
- 4:47Builder is Pretty good overall like yeah, we've had clients,
- 4:50build out, some pretty good, landing pages and kind of use it
- 4:53pretty well to build out, things like curated prps and all of
- 4:56that kind of stuff again, pretty flexible.
- 4:58But I guess the big one is when you do start to need things like
- 5:03Version Control, things like yeah you know, approval layers,
- 5:07things like shit, but proper scheduling of content.
- 5:10That's probably the biggest one actually that I see people
- 5:13complain about with Shopper buyers, like a proper.
- 5:17You know, content scheduling solution allows for, you know,
- 5:21multiple versions allows for like multi-store, publishing
- 5:26Etc. All of that kind of stuff.
- 5:27But yeah there's various other things I think people would
- 5:29probably want beyond the native capabilities.
- 5:32Yeah and it's interesting because in the Magento space you
- 5:34write a little business love, what we paid Builders suffice
- 5:37because they don't have complex content with clients and just
- 5:39need to be able to publish content and do it without
- 5:42additional development resource. But there are some agencies,
- 5:45like, Tom and Cove built their own CMS on top of Magento and
- 5:49they've got a headless setup and that CMS has a bit of extra
- 5:54capability in it than the standard page Builders such as
- 5:57the version in and the the publishing piece, but it doesn't
- 6:01go as far as an Enterprise CMS and exp quickly before we start
- 6:04into the questions actually, because there might be some
- 6:06people who are newer to this area than others and the
- 6:09terminology like dxp is what the hell does this mean?
- 6:13Can you just very succinctly for them differentiate?
- 6:15What is the Difference between a digital experience platform and
- 6:19a CMS. What does it do?
- 6:20That CMS on its own, doesn't skid questions here?
- 6:23DX P stands for digital experience platform.
- 6:26I think, typically, I personally would expect a dxp to have
- 6:30broader capabilities and just content management.
- 6:33So the majority of them offer some level of personalization or
- 6:37like multiple levels of personalization.
- 6:39So, content, personalization things like the majority of them
- 6:43seemed to offer A/B test testing and if it or maybe Current
- 6:47levels of testing and then kind of all of the features.
- 6:49You'd expect from a Content management platform as well
- 6:52around. Yeah, things like versioning
- 6:53things like yeah, content previewing.
- 6:57Yeah, scheduling. All of that kind of stuff.
- 7:00Yeah, I think that's that nice distinction.
- 7:02And also they tend to have better data analytics and
- 7:05Reporting capabilities so you can get a bit small to our
- 7:08insights out of what's happening on the company's image.
- 7:12Cool. So with that in mind let's
- 7:14start. Let's start answer some of those
- 7:16questions, right? So Here's a page builder, good
- 7:18enough. So I'll just kick off and then
- 7:20you can you can add your user. So to me, a lot of page builder
- 7:25is good enough, is is basically the starting point for me is, do
- 7:29you need to spend on licensing for a third-party CMS on knock?
- 7:33Because if you get a special, CMS you'll add in that on top of
- 7:36your Ecommerce platform licensing.
- 7:38You've got to be sure you can monetize that investment.
- 7:41So you got to start with. Let's go on the premise that
- 7:43page builder is good enough for Phase 1 and potentially we need
- 7:45to evolve into special CMS or dxp later on because especially
- 7:49CMS is can cost 20 K, plus per annum for big sites where you
- 7:56have multiple storefront, you a lot of content Pages, it's
- 7:58hundred K. Plus a lot of teams, just want a
- 8:03strong visual drag and drop editor interface where they
- 8:06don't have to go to a developer to change the page layout they
- 8:09can go in move content. Layouts about from predefined
- 8:11components, be in a predefined template.
- 8:15They can remove a component. Replace it with another one,
- 8:18they can get the view to tell the story.
- 8:20They wanted that page. They can create a new landing
- 8:22page from an existing Templar and dragon all of the relevant
- 8:26components they've got from their component Library.
- 8:28They can then put they can edit into that, they can edit the
- 8:30text, the imagery, the call to action, the hyperlinked, and
- 8:34then publish that for a lot of businesses that suffice has.
- 8:38And then the next step is on top of that, from a Content page,
- 8:40like your home page or a campaign landing page.
- 8:43It's inserting those existing content layouts and Opponents
- 8:47into Commerce pages. So to pull the loot.
- 8:49So early on your PLP, you might want a carousel above the
- 8:53product grid. You might want to add a review
- 8:57layout below product. Great.
- 8:59You might want to insert hero content within the product grid.
- 9:02Yeah. On a PDP, you might want to on
- 9:04top of your product recommendations at set
- 9:05underneath your core product data.
- 9:07You might want to add some ugc for example, so a lot of the
- 9:11modern page builder, you can do this within them.
- 9:14You just need to set them up correctly from the start.
- 9:16So, Some point is, hey, yo, look at what you can get.
- 9:20Can you satisfy your core content objectives without
- 9:22spending that extra money? What's your taken about?
- 9:26Yeah, I think one of the things that you touched on there, I
- 9:29think is a way to really important is that compatible a
- 9:33or that ability to use all of the Native functionality than a
- 9:36platform? Because I think one of the
- 9:37things that I've seen when people take content management
- 9:41out of the platform and introduce another solution is
- 9:45that, although you end up with more functionality, Ality, you
- 9:48do lose the ability to make use of new features or kind of, you
- 9:54know, for platforms got native product recommendations, and you
- 9:56want to be able to use that or, yeah, kind of any other content
- 10:00that you've got within the platform and the other thing is,
- 10:03you know, soon as you start wanting to do anything outside
- 10:07of the norm, you need a developer.
- 10:09And I guess I'm thinking of this in the context of Shopify, but
- 10:12it will apply. And you know, magento's, another
- 10:14good example actually cuz I think page builder, Magento And
- 10:17actually be good, you probably need to do quite a bit of
- 10:19development work up front to get it to where you want it to be,
- 10:22but I do think it can be. And it's also typically used in
- 10:25a more kind of like when what you described their around
- 10:29content and using it within a PLP or any other kind of like,
- 10:33ecomp template, but page Builders, yeah, I guess does
- 10:37that natively, but I think that, that's probably my biggest thing
- 10:43is, I think you just lose a lot of functionality, even little
- 10:45things like, you know, if you want to take enough do block and
- 10:49build that into a shop with, I recommend it or Shopify section,
- 10:55things like that, it's always just a lot trickier when you've
- 10:57got a third party CMS or a headless EMS or something like
- 11:01that. Maybe that's not the best
- 11:02example actually. But yeah, that I that's one of
- 11:05the things that I think is a con for separating the two out that
- 11:09you just lose a certain, major functionality and Reporting
- 11:12might be another one. Yeah, I think it's a really good
- 11:14point because in to go to the CMS bring Complexity and there's
- 11:18Performance challenges and yes, the modern CMS is have built up
- 11:21to be super Speedy that, you know, that the cloud service,
- 11:24they provide the scalability is amazing.
- 11:26But if the, if the integration piece into the Commerce, and the
- 11:29Commerce engine, and the way that that, then brings up that
- 11:33information through and renders, it causes a performance issue.
- 11:36You've got to unpack that and make sure that's working.
- 11:38So I think that's something that sometimes businesses don't
- 11:40appreciate, and it ends up costing a little bit more in the
- 11:43implementation phase. The other the other thing, Is it
- 11:47is? Yeah, as you said the native
- 11:48page Builders. So the likes of Bigcommerce has
- 11:51Shopify and shop where as well, I think is really nice with its
- 11:53customer experiences drop. There's always been historically
- 11:56ahead of the other comparable SAS platforms with its content
- 12:00management, native capability, but they can do a lot of stuff
- 12:03in there. So we talked about custom
- 12:05templates and components. I've worked on a Magento
- 12:08implementation for the question brand.
- 12:10Where we had some really cool layouts with some Dynamic
- 12:13content, with hot spotting enabling LinkedIn.
- 12:16Later functions like quick by really neat.
- 12:19Lovely layouts visually beautiful as well.
- 12:21So you can achieve quite a lot. If you spec out what you want
- 12:24your components to do and you get the logic built correctly
- 12:27from the start, you can also make, you know, deliver mobile
- 12:30responsive design. So you build your components to
- 12:32work across your breakpoints, you can build the component
- 12:36logic to function as it required.
- 12:38You might have a Content block, which is a head in a paragraphs
- 12:43and a call to action with an image to the right on desktop
- 12:46but You can then change the logic to flip it.
- 12:48So the image goes on the left because you want to have
- 12:50different. So there are you can get a lot
- 12:52of flexibility out of even where you can remove the heading or
- 12:54you can remove call to action button but still you're not
- 12:57you're not adding code you're just changing the configurable
- 13:00properties about you can restrict access file user
- 13:03permissions so you can control who has access to the CMS.
- 13:06I have all of the users on the platform.
- 13:08They don't have to have access to the entire e-commerce
- 13:10platform. Some of them do schedule
- 13:13publishing on a basic level. You can't.
- 13:15I've not seen them where you can.
- 13:16A jewel, effectively International across multiple
- 13:21storefronts that him to go set set up.
- 13:23Each publish schedule, separate a storefront level unless you're
- 13:26using a third-party, you can do live preview of content
- 13:29browsers. You can insert HTML into page
- 13:32templates as content blocks. You can add content to Commerce
- 13:35Pages seen this done well on things, like basket Pages where
- 13:39people put USPS or reassurance messaging.
- 13:42We talked about hero content in product grids jewelry and
- 13:45fashion brands. Did this really nicely Eon
- 13:47platform side, Bigcommerce, Shopify, Magento, you can set
- 13:51core SEO, properties. If example, control image image
- 13:56titles and tags when you upload are, what else can you do?
- 14:00You can look at the edit history on some of them.
- 14:01You can make content visible or not visible on specific stores.
- 14:05If you have a banner that you only want visible on you know,
- 14:07UK store, not on us, you can control that.
- 14:10So I think there's a lot you can do in a page builder.
- 14:13So the question is a business is okay, let's be very clear.
- 14:17Have we been seduced by the marketing of what an amazing
- 14:19Enterprise CMS does? But have we have, we actually
- 14:22compared that back to what do we really need in order to operate
- 14:26and what we need over the next 12 to 18 months, is a really an
- 14:29exception where we can't function as a business and
- 14:31Achieve our content goals for e-commerce.
- 14:34Without that edit third-party, the end, the only thing I'd add
- 14:37fact quite interesting is some Magento on paper is actually
- 14:42very good natively. So I think, you know, page
- 14:45builders Good flexible. Like you gave some good
- 14:48examples, there is actually quite a bit more flexible than
- 14:52something like a shop by around. Like, you know, things like
- 14:55mobile, and how you adapt content, Etc.
- 14:58You can use it with some of the other native functionality.
- 15:01So, you know, customer segmentation customer groups
- 15:04Etc. So you can do a lot of it, but
- 15:06one of the things that I think is quite interesting when you're
- 15:08like accessing capabilities is yeah, I like the intuitiveness
- 15:13and how easy it is to do some of this stuff.
- 15:15And and I guess that you say how Development work.
- 15:18You might need to actually get the most out of, even the native
- 15:21stuff because yeah, I still think although magento's
- 15:25actually pretty strong. If you run an RFP and you had a
- 15:28list of requirements actually think, you know, the native
- 15:30capabilities actually pretty good but yeah, they don't always
- 15:33yeah, work as well as they might look like they work if that
- 15:37makes sense. Yeah, it doesn't.
- 15:38It's a really good point and it leads really nice answer the
- 15:41next question, which is what can an Enterprise CMS do the page
- 15:43builder? Cotton and actually one of the
- 15:45benefits is often that the The these Specialists cm x CM s is
- 15:50whether it's just a standalone, CMS or CMS.
- 15:52As part of a dxv provider is that they tend to have a richer
- 15:55library's reference components, Logics things, that you that
- 16:01already exists, that they developed very quickly.
- 16:03Spin up, the content layouts that you need in the templates
- 16:07that you need rather than having to do like fresh coating from
- 16:09scratch. So, you're right, the, although
- 16:11you're paying a license for you, you, you are often saving in
- 16:15development upfront, To get things set up to deliver against
- 16:18the business content needs. So that's really, really
- 16:20important distinction for people to think about, you've got to
- 16:23always assess within your build phase, how much cotton effort
- 16:28for the developers to deliver against your content needs and
- 16:31the other thing link to that, and then I'll hand over to you
- 16:33is automated publishing you touched on this earlier.
- 16:36So a lot most of the page Builders you can you can set
- 16:39schedule publishing say, Okay, I want to publish this new home
- 16:42page layout to my home, to my UK homepage on Thursday at 12 p.m.
- 16:46IM but what you can't do is automate a publishing from like
- 16:50staging environments to production.
- 16:52You're basically live editing and for a lot of businesses live
- 16:56editing in production with preview and then publish or
- 16:58saving drafts is fine. But for others they work on Sony
- 17:02campaigns concurrently but they don't want to do that in a live
- 17:05production environment that brings with it risk and it also
- 17:08is much harder for the business to control the workflow.
- 17:11So they want the true State and of art they want to have at all.
- 17:13That's capable of automatically publishing that up into
- 17:15production. The required time.
- 17:18So they don't have to then manually, recreate everything in
- 17:20the production environment. So that's my, I guess that's a
- 17:23good intro for me. What I do to you.
- 17:25What, what, what have you seen? What can Enterprise CMS is?
- 17:27Do that page. Builders can't, What is amply?
- 17:31INS in a worked, its freedom, the freedom to build a digital
- 17:36experience as Limitless as your vision create preview schedule,
- 17:40and manage. All your content in one easy
- 17:43place. Find out more at a lie and
- 17:46started. Cam a lian's experience freedom.
- 17:52Yeah, absolutely. One thing I was going to add to
- 17:54your thing. That's quite interesting is
- 17:57that's probably one of the biggest kind of pushback areas.
- 18:04I see from people. So we've had a couple of clients
- 18:07that move themselves forced to Shopify and internal teams, just
- 18:11cannot get their head around, not having a proper stage and
- 18:14environment not being able to truly stage content.
- 18:18Yeah, not being able to truly kind of schedule, everything
- 18:21they're doing, except Yeah, that's an interest one.
- 18:24Maybe that could be another episode like kind of battling
- 18:27some of those conversations or like yeah kind of Storytelling a
- 18:30little bit so that makes sense. I think the biggest if I think
- 18:34about the biggest reason why I've seen client moved to these
- 18:38Solutions, I guess one is like overall flexibility.
- 18:42Maybe people are looking to invest in you know editorial or
- 18:46just like really unique content as a brand and they don't feel
- 18:49like the platform as page builder kind.
- 18:52Of allows them to do that. Or so, the biggest one usually,
- 18:56for me is, like, someone's been kind of, maybe sold the dream of
- 19:00doing true personalization and being able to, you know,
- 19:04essentially serve completely different.
- 19:06Customer Journeys to different groups of customers may be based
- 19:10on, you know, their affinities with different product
- 19:12categories, or their behavior, as a customer over, you know,
- 19:17their lifetime and it feels like for me, particularly when you
- 19:21get the Kind of CMS or D SD XP is also connected to the CRM.
- 19:26That's usually that the Holy Grail that people are trying to
- 19:30achieve. And I haven't seen too many
- 19:31people actually achieve it but I think that's usually what people
- 19:35want. But yeah, I mean on paper I
- 19:37think a lot of these platforms have some level of capability
- 19:40where they can provide different experiences for different types
- 19:43of customers. And like I said, I think a lot
- 19:46of our clients have ended up doing that in a relatively basic
- 19:48form that. Yeah, that's something that
- 19:51these Platforms would be stronger than the kind of native
- 19:55capabilities, but platform, even where, you know, some platforms,
- 19:57do have that natively. I think on top of that, one of
- 20:01the other reasons we've seen people take this out of the
- 20:03platform. So again, going back to more
- 20:06like a Shopify example, but is basically trying to bypass and
- 20:12limitations of the platform. So we've got one client, they've
- 20:15got to shop by instances. And then they've essentially got
- 20:1815 sites that are all managed by Story block so essentially it
- 20:24just looks like they've got 15 sites, they've kind of fully
- 20:27localized but then they've got like a much better way of kind
- 20:31of managing content across those sites and then you go into the
- 20:34same check out. So they're using Shopify markets
- 20:36but the content on the front and they have a lot more flexibility
- 20:39around and they don't then have to have all of those different
- 20:43Shopify stores and I think that's probably quite a common
- 20:46use case and I've also seen it where people are almost using
- 20:51like a contempt for Or or yeah, a sanity or whatever else is
- 20:57like, almost like a Pim to be perfectly honest and I can see
- 21:00just trying to make the multi-store piece of Shopify a
- 21:03lot easier. So, yeah, that's another really
- 21:06big one and then a lot of the other ones we've talked about.
- 21:09So proper scheduling proper Version Control, but they are
- 21:13probably the biggest ones that I would expect to lead people to
- 21:17an Enterprise or like a more specialist Cinemas.
- 21:21Yeah, I think that's Great Point actually because we all know
- 21:25that no platforms under present perfect.
- 21:26And there are limitations of every single one and advantage
- 21:29of Iran. And one of the challenges around
- 21:31the, the international multi storefront is whether or not you
- 21:34are using true multi storefront set up in the Commerce or
- 21:37whether you've had to separate the storefronts because of the
- 21:40operational side that how you need to make them work and
- 21:43therefore you can only do it in separate instances and therefore
- 21:46the content management is separate in the page builders
- 21:49for each store from and therefore a A CMS like a pimp,
- 21:54does the product catalog, enabling you to manage all your
- 21:57content in one place and schedule the publishing?
- 21:59And then you're using like the apis to push the continents.
- 22:01Number of install from can save a huge amount of time and effort
- 22:05and wish when we come onto like how do you justify the
- 22:07investment? That's really important
- 22:09discussion to have. So business is really need to
- 22:11scrutinize not just the page builder capability.
- 22:15But how is the, what's the storefront architecture?
- 22:17You're going to have in your new solution that the the
- 22:21development T, the technical I signed off on and what impact
- 22:24does that have on your content production processes?
- 22:27The other, the other things I've seen on a know, the paid
- 22:29Builders are catching up on an example, you know, Shopify or
- 22:31sections everywhere's made a massive change.
- 22:33This is ability to create a single asset and publish it to
- 22:36multiple content locations in one go rather than having to
- 22:39recreate it on every page, you need it to appear on so this
- 22:42could be. I want to draw.
- 22:43I've got a product category of like saddle pads, for like my
- 22:48question brand. I want to now and every PDP in
- 22:51saddle, I pad drop content, block a in at the same place on
- 22:56that page, and I wanted to just publish it once and that is it
- 22:59and it automatically does it because I can set the logic with
- 23:03some some of the page. Builders you've got a bit better
- 23:05control about being able to publish a Content asset to
- 23:08different pages, but you don't have the same granularity.
- 23:10You get in a true CMS at being able to add logic of where and
- 23:14when something appears, and when it doesn't and how to create
- 23:16exceptions to the rules. And that, when you're getting to
- 23:20a more sophisticated level of content targeting, And
- 23:22personalization and customization of the user
- 23:25Journey, that becomes more and more important.
- 23:27And when you're a massive catalog company that
- 23:30differentiation a category subcategory and even specific,
- 23:34skew range, pdp's and not even on the peopie level, which can
- 23:38be really important. And then the other one for me
- 23:42would be distributed content, workflows, which, I know you
- 23:45touched on. Your can get this into
- 23:47International where you might have a centralized content team,
- 23:50but localized Content creators who are wanting to create
- 23:55campaign Pages, or create new car, new content assets, but it
- 23:59has to go through your approval somewhere else.
- 24:01And you need to have a proper workflow, but somebody had to
- 24:04edit create, send it for approval, that be approved.
- 24:07And then either that trigger automatic publish or enables the
- 24:10content creators, and then go and schedule that into the
- 24:12production environment you've talked about personalization, so
- 24:17I won't go back on that. And the other bit actually
- 24:19forgive me if you did, not just wasn't listening.
- 24:22As digital Asset Management. So what can you do with images?
- 24:26When you upload? Is it just a, some, some page
- 24:29Builders. It's very basic.
- 24:30You upload an image and you don't have a really effective
- 24:33library for managing, and storing and categorizing.
- 24:36The, the CMS is into the Dax peas, have much stronger,
- 24:39digital Asset Management. So you can have better structure
- 24:42and of the folders of the images, you have better search
- 24:44to find those images. So, it's easier to find an asset
- 24:47that you want to include. Now, in a new content layout or
- 24:49Templar, you know, they are very good at setting image, Reset.
- 24:52So, for example, you know, if you've got one main Banner, you
- 24:55uploaded it needs for different formats.
- 24:57It also Mo creates those in the relevant format.
- 25:01They're all be minimized optimized so that they don't
- 25:04have performance issues and some of the top-end cms's even enable
- 25:09auto cropping. So they'll crop to the right
- 25:11part of an image, that becomes a much bigger challenge in certain
- 25:14verticals like jewelry. But yeah, if you've got good
- 25:18image image shooting skills and you can actually create images
- 25:22that can Cropped, Auto crop pretty smartly anything else.
- 25:26Anything else we think we miss? In terms of where the those Ends
- 25:28by CMS has added value one. And one thing that we've touched
- 25:32on that, I think is another reason why I've seen people
- 25:35move, content out of the platform is the editorial side.
- 25:39So where you get? I've worked up a few Brands
- 25:43where, you know, 90% of their traffic is going to their blog
- 25:47and then they've got a Commerce aspect or it's just, you know, a
- 25:51particularly Content that brand or someone wants to go to
- 25:54market. So, I could content LED bran.
- 25:56I think the native blogs within the platform's haven't been
- 26:01strong enough so they've ended up, you know, going down the
- 26:05Headless route or introducing. Something to just improve that
- 26:09side of things. So I think that's still pretty
- 26:11common even though. Yeah, some of the platforms have
- 26:14been proved that side. None of them are like I guess,
- 26:16you know, true kind of blogging platform.
- 26:18I have true blogging capabilities and not that most
- 26:21of these cms's do A bit more flexibility and a bit more
- 26:24flexible in kind of getting to that point.
- 26:27Yeah, that's a very good addition.
- 26:29The because if you just have a simple need to publish articles
- 26:32page bugs, work brilliantly, you can publish as many articles,
- 26:35have a template Creator. Each logical can flow slightly
- 26:38differently. Using the existing layouts like
- 26:40a heading or subheading text book image.
- 26:42You name it but if you want a Blog where you have like indexes
- 26:46archives, smart categorization, I also populating like latest
- 26:52Post most rated all that additional functionality.
- 26:55Yeah, you're right. That's a good distinction.
- 26:58Let's move on to the next question.
- 26:59Then how do you evaluate CMS providers?
- 27:03So what what's your advice to people when you're looking at a
- 27:06specialist where you might have to incur additional license
- 27:08fees, how do you evaluate a know whether it's fit for purpose and
- 27:12the right tooling? Yeah, I think this is an
- 27:15interesting because there's so many variables because you've
- 27:17got different solutions with different feature sets and you
- 27:22know, Sometimes you'd be getting like a, you know, really just be
- 27:26buying, a headless EMS. Sometimes you'd be buying like a
- 27:29set of tools that essentially power the whole front end like a
- 27:32Shogun front end but I guess for me, I always look at.
- 27:37So I'm quite lucky. Ecosystem focused I guess
- 27:39usually. And like compatibility is like
- 27:41the number one thing that I would be trying to retain or
- 27:44like essentially not losing too much of the core platform and
- 27:48unless you're kind of starting off with, you know, something
- 27:51that is Ali, just like a Commerce and engine or, you
- 27:55know, a set of apis and it would probably be completely
- 27:57different. But thinking of the types of
- 27:59brands that I would typically work with, I guess I would want
- 28:02some of this well-integrated. There's potentially integrated
- 28:04of other court, like key, third parties, part of your Tech
- 28:08stack. So something like a sanity or,
- 28:11you know, a contempt for some of the ones that might exist, given
- 28:14the platform ecosystem, might be the first one to look at that.
- 28:18That being said, I think you One of the biggest like starting
- 28:23points would be like, how maybe technical your team are and
- 28:28like, you know, somewhat like a contempt for is super flexible
- 28:32and that you need to be semi-technical, I think still to
- 28:34work with that platform as an admin user, or based on my
- 28:38experience of anyway. So I guess that would be one of
- 28:41the biggest things to start with from an evaluation perspective,
- 28:44like cost would be another one flexibility might be another
- 28:48one. Yeah, like lack of varieties of
- 28:50Youth Without development resource might Another one.
- 28:53But yeah they're probably along with like the obvious ones like
- 28:56native functionality around things like yeah, staging shed,
- 29:02feeling all of that kind of stuff but they're probably my
- 29:04biggest Yeah, all sensible. I think for me the might the
- 29:11process only takes to look at it is, is that integration piece
- 29:16first is this CMS other existing live clients using it alongside
- 29:20that e-commerce platform. So if you're a big Commerce and
- 29:24you want to work with with a well we know that they are
- 29:27Integrations. There are live site Soma Bloom
- 29:29reaches but then also it's you've got to then take a step
- 29:34back and say okay, are we using this?
- 29:37Which platform in a different architecture, way than this site
- 29:43is currently being used in. Do our, we create any additional
- 29:45complexities for the integration piece.
- 29:48Just make sure you have in the technical conversations with the
- 29:50with the CMS provider with the platform technically.
- 29:53And with your developers to understand what the impact in
- 29:57build phases, then you've got a grill, the grill on the template
- 30:02and content creation. How much does a Dev work will be
- 30:05required on going if you want to create?
- 30:07Eight new components. What what resources will you
- 30:11need? Can you do it all yourself and
- 30:12house? Are you relying on the third
- 30:13party? Is there any like technical
- 30:16support ongoing involved including the license fee?
- 30:19So, you know, if you wanted to add a few more components that
- 30:21will be done for you as part of service.
- 30:23How extensive is the current Library, you know, our is that
- 30:28is 80% of your content needs already solved from an existing
- 30:31libraries and therefore your the risk in it.
- 30:35And then it's yeah, then it's falling down to things like
- 30:37Staging and production links, how automated a Content,
- 30:40publishing flows versus how much ongoing manual effort digital
- 30:43team need. If you want to use it properly,
- 30:46do you need extra resource? You can have to factor that cost
- 30:49in and then the performance bit. So how will you measure
- 30:52performance? How will, you know that it's not
- 30:55having a detrimental impact to page load times or to the user
- 30:58experiencing? Is it a seamless to have
- 31:01content? Loading?
- 31:02Are there any issues when you're adding like large video files?
- 31:05I know this. This should be a thing of the
- 31:07the past, but how something is integrated and implemented has a
- 31:10big impact, not just what the backend stack and capability of
- 31:14the of the platform is. So that's that.
- 31:17I guess those are the way those are questions that I always have
- 31:19in my mind. So that leads me on to the final
- 31:23question for today, mate. What's the ROI for investing in
- 31:26a special CMS? So how do you build a business
- 31:29case and where have you seen businesses?
- 31:30Get a justifiable return on investment.
- 31:33Yeah. So I think too that have been
- 31:36most relevant for Client. So one is the customer
- 31:41experience or the front and, or the ability to achieve a
- 31:45business goal, around those split customer Journeys, or
- 31:49yeah, that whole piece. So the capability for improving
- 31:54brand and customer experience. And then the other one is saving
- 31:58of time for the like, the business users, essentially.
- 32:02I think they've been the two, and then, I think, yeah, in
- 32:05terms of like, justifying, that, That's probably just be a
- 32:08essentially, quantifying the hours saved or quantifying the
- 32:14Improvement to the experience of the customer like new and
- 32:18existing customers. Yeah, I I tend to focus on the
- 32:22cost saving and efficiency piece as well because it can be very
- 32:25hard to model out. What the, what the revenue
- 32:27impact would be because you don't know whether richer
- 32:32content, which is quite a nebulous term has any
- 32:35fundamental impact on conversion.
- 32:36Maybe it doesn't It's just, you present your brand better and
- 32:39therefore from a creative and brand point of view, the
- 32:41company's happy with how it's visually represented itself
- 32:44online. So until you've done the
- 32:47assessment, you can't really run recent prove, you can do some
- 32:51indicative tests on existing page Builders like create a
- 32:55couple of new pages, spend a little bit of money on getting
- 32:58it, you know, some some richer layouts Diamond test, what
- 33:00impact that might have. But not many people go down that
- 33:03route. They just change the CMS and
- 33:04then then see what happens afterwards.
- 33:06So I think it's you Yeah, it's removing inefficient processes
- 33:09calculate the time say I did it. One climb where we looked at.
- 33:12I think it was about two peoples effort, two days worth of effort
- 33:19to take 23 days per month, would be saved by cutting out the
- 33:23manual effort. Working across the different
- 33:25stores with content, creation, upload, and Etc.
- 33:29And then you monetize that at the existing day rate at those,
- 33:32people are all across the year. And look at whether that
- 33:35nullifies the additional license fee.
- 33:37Because if It cost neutral, there's but you'll get a better
- 33:39tool in. You have a happier team, you've
- 33:41got more intuitive tools, then any Revenue benefit in the
- 33:45future is just a boost, you're not lose anything.
- 33:47So why wouldn't you give the team a stronger set of tools to
- 33:49execute the plans against? And then also about the ongoing
- 33:54like development and maintenance if you're using page builder but
- 33:57you know that every time they're not your Magento, every time
- 34:01there's a major platform upgrade you've got to go through the
- 34:03upgrade process. You've got to look at you know,
- 34:06any backwards incompatible Leti, there might be with custom
- 34:09layouts or components you've built.
- 34:10You might need to tweak some of the code on that to make it
- 34:12compatible with new versions, you never know.
- 34:15So you've got to have that factor in mind of there is
- 34:18additional ongoing maintenance cost because if we're using a
- 34:21CMS then all of that and the logic the components and their
- 34:24performance is maintained out of their platform.
- 34:28Yeah, the back end. So we've got to make sure that
- 34:31we've factored into that, you know, it's not it's not talking
- 34:34about tens of thousand year but maybe it's a few thousand extra
- 34:37year you It's going to cost you that can offset part of the
- 34:39license fee and then the other is the SEO benefit is.
- 34:43If you believe a CMS enables you to create deeper editorial, like
- 34:47you said content like the better content, hubs better traffic and
- 34:50you can execute a quicker and that helps you indexation and
- 34:53driving organic traffic, you can link a potential Revenue, uplift
- 34:56to that. One thing I was going to say as
- 34:59well as I think there's two other things, I just thought of
- 35:03one back in the day, the dev hours piece, I think probably
- 35:07less. So now, but historically, we
- 35:09like probably 50% of our clients would use like Zed mags or
- 35:12equivalent. To basically build richer.
- 35:15Landing pages richer kind of brand Pages without having to
- 35:20pay a development agency to build a bespoke landing page
- 35:23every time and that was you know huge justification of those
- 35:26tools which are typically be between you know one and four
- 35:29grand a month depending on the size of the brand.
- 35:32But one thing with almost all of those is up until recently.
- 35:35They're all javascript-based. So I think They have, you know,
- 35:39a lot less benefit from an SEO perspective than they would, if
- 35:43you're building that content within a kind of inline
- 35:45template. So that was one thing.
- 35:48And then the other thing that I was thinking about with some
- 35:50your wherever points with, I think, typically, most of our
- 35:53clients have signed up to the CMS as part of to let's say
- 35:56they're moving away from Salesforce and then moving to
- 35:59Bigcommerce, they wouldn't be looking at it as like the cost
- 36:01of the CMS, it would be Bigcommerce.
- 36:03Plus an ambulance or a bloom reach, let's say, and then
- 36:07you're Will you know saving quite a lot of money on from a
- 36:10knock backs perspective over a Salesforce potentially but it's
- 36:13the combination of those two that allow them to like cheve
- 36:16their functional requirement. Yeah that's a nice addition.
- 36:19Look at it is a lot of this happens when people re-platform
- 36:23and therefore it's the old toe overall cost of ownership rather
- 36:26than the in the individual line cost of a CMS.
- 36:30Yeah, nice additions. Cool.
- 36:32So that brings us to the end of our whistle-stop tour around.
- 36:36When do you need And she just five estimate in a Content
- 36:39management system versus when can you get way of using
- 36:41platform page? Builders, we'd love to know what
- 36:43everyone else thinks. Yeah.
- 36:44What's your experience whenever you found use cases for a
- 36:48third-party specialist CMS or the XP.
- 36:51What do you write about Native page?
- 36:52Builders let us know. Jump jump online, give us a
- 36:56message and Twitter LinkedIn would love to hear and thanks
- 36:59for listening. Keep an ear out for next
- 37:01episode. We drop one every Tuesday, do
- 37:03subscribe. If you haven't already.
- 37:04And please do give us a rating on Apple Spotify or YouTube.
- 37:07You take care of Buddy. More information on this topic,
- 37:17head over to re-platform dot. F, m, for our audio podcasts to
- 37:20discuss a project, or if you like to chat about any of the
- 37:23topics covered in this episode in more detail.
- 37:25Please reach out to myself, James guard and my co-host, pull
- 37:27Rogers, via LinkedIn, and Twitter.
- 37:29Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 37:31next episode.